The Deshaun Watson trade was a significant National Football League trade made on March 18, 2022, centered on sending quarterback Deshaun Watson from the Houston Texans to the Cleveland Browns. The quarterback and a Texans 2024 sixth round selection was exchanged for Cleveland's 2022 first and fourth round selections, 2023 first and third round selections, and 2024 first and fourth round selections. [1]
The trade and ensuing contract, guaranteeing Deshaun Watson $230 million, is currently considered by some sports media outlets and analysts to be one of the worst trades in the history of the NFL. [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] This is in part due to the perceived lopsidedness of the first round picks granted to the Texans that were used to draft several Pro Bowlers and starting players including Defensive Rookie of the Year Will Anderson Jr. paired with Offensive Rookie of the Year quarterback C. J. Stroud. Additionally, Baker Mayfield, the Browns' previous starting quarterback who was traded to the Carolina Panthers in the aftermath of the trade, saw success on the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, leading them to a division title and playoff victory in a Pro Bowl 2023 season, and has continued to be one of the league's more efficient quarterbacks in 2024. Watson's play in the same time frame was marred by a lack of efficiency compared to his time on the Texans, as well as back-to-back season ending injuries in 2023 and 2024.
The trade also received criticism due to it occurring in the midst of a series of sexual assault lawsuits filed against Watson, with multiple outlets describing the trade as bringing significant PR baggage to the Cleveland Browns franchise and damaging fan support. Many found the organization difficult to support on an ethical basis as a result of the trade. [2] [5] [6]
Deshaun Watson began his professional career with the 2017 Houston Texans. After a season-ending injury in his rookie year, his tenure with the Texans was marked by two consecutive AFC South titles in 2018 and 2019. Watson's performance peaked in 2020 when he led the league in passing yards with 4,823 yards in spite of the Texans' abysmal 4-13 record. That same year, Watson had the 3rd best touchdown-to-interception ratio at 33:7, and the 2nd highest passer rating in the NFL at 112.4, trailing only behind Aaron Rodgers who was named the league's Most Valuable Player that season. During his time with the Texans, Watson was known for his proficiency as a dual-threat quarterback (in spite of Watson disliking the term due to its perceived stereotyping of black quarterbacks), as well as his completion percentage of passes with 20 or more air yards; boasting a 43% completion rate on such throws, representing the 6th best in the NFL at the time. [2]
The 2020 season was the Texans' final season with Deshaun Watson as the starting quarterback, as he would sit out the next season amidst sexual misconduct allegations as well as his own request to be traded over conflicts within coaching changes. [7] [8] Watson's final game as a Texan was on January 3, 2021, a 38–41 loss to the Tennessee Titans. [9]
The Cleveland Browns made the decision to move on from their previous quarterback, Baker Mayfield, following the 2021 season due to his poor performance while suffering from an shoulder injury. [2] [10] Insider reports of the Browns indicated that Mayfield was considered too immature to be a team leader, leading to him being traded away to the Carolina Panthers, with insider reports stating that the Browns leadership wanted an "adult" at the quarterback position. [11] [12]
On March 16, 2021, a Houston massage therapist filed a civil lawsuit delivered by attorney Tony Buzbee against then-Texans' quarterback Deshaun Watson, claiming that Watson had touched her with the tip of his erect penis while asking her for sex during a visit to her home for treatment in March 2020. Watson vehemently denied Buzbee's claims, stating that "I have never treated any woman with anything other than the utmost respect." According to the suit, the massage therapist immediately ended the session and cried after the incident. Several weeks later, two additional NFL players contacted the massage therapist on Watson's recommendation. The suit also claims that Watson later reached out to the massage therapist and apologized for his actions. [13]
Over the next few days, several more civil lawsuits were filed against Watson by further massage therapists represented by Buzbee accusing him of being a "serial predator", with allegations including Watson directing victims to massage his anus and penis and forcing them to touch it, [14] forcing a victim to perform oral sex on him, [15] attempting to forcibly kiss a victim, [16] locking doors behind victims to force sexual assault, and telling therapists to keep quiet about what happened. [17]
By April 5, 2021, 22 lawsuits have been filed against Watson, [18] though 18 professional massage therapists have since expressed support of his character, saying that the allegations contradict their experiences with Watson. [19] On April 7, 2021, Nike and Beats By Dre suspended endorsement deals with Watson. Reliant Energy and H-E-B stated that they did not plan on engaging with Watson in the future. [20] These legal challenges led to Watson's absence from the field for the entire 2021 season, during which he remained with the Houston Texans but did not participate in any games. The situation was further complicated by Watson's simultaneous request for a trade from the team. [2]
On March 11, 2022, a grand jury declined to indict Watson on criminal charges related to "harassment and sexual misconduct". On that date he still faced 22 civil lawsuits, many alleging sexual misconduct and assault. [21] After two more accusers joined the lawsuit in June 2022, Watson settled 23 of the 24 lawsuits in July and August. [22]
On August 1, as a result of these allegations, Watson was suspended for six regular season games to start the 2022 season by judge Sue Lewis Robinson. [23] Two days later, the NFL appealed the suspension, seeking to extend the suspension to at least a full season as well as seeking a fine and establishing a requirement for Watson to seek treatment for his conduct. [24] The appeal was reviewed by former New Jersey Attorney General Peter C. Harvey. [25] [26] On August 18, after the NFL and the NFLPA reached a settlement, Watson was suspended for the first 11 games of the season and was fined $5 million. [27]
Despite the ongoing legal issues, the Cleveland Browns acquired Watson in a high-profile trade in March 2022. At the time of signing, Watson's five-year deal included $230 million in guaranteed money, which set a new benchmark for guaranteed contracts in the NFL especially among quarterbacks. Subsequently, several larger contracts were signed for quarterbacks on other teams, leading to several records for the largest contracts in the NFL. [2] [28] [29]
To Houston Texans | To Cleveland Browns [2] [30] |
---|---|
|
|
Pick acquired by Houston | Houston's subsequent transactions [2] [30] |
---|---|
Cleveland's first-round pick in 2022 (13th) |
|
Cleveland's fourth-round pick in 2022 (104th) |
|
Cleveland's first-round pick in 2023 (12th) |
|
Cleveland's third-round pick in 2023 (73rd) |
|
Cleveland's first-round pick in 2024 (23rd) |
|
Cleveland's fourth-round pick in 2024 (123rd) |
|
Based on CBS Sports, all of the received draft picks and subsequent trades resulted in the Texans acquiring: "the 2023 NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year Will Anderson Jr., starting wide receiver Tank Dell, starting left guard Kenyon Green, starting free safety Calen Bullock, starting cornerback Kamari Lassiter, wide receiver John Metchie III, linebacker Christian Harris, running back Dameon Pierce, linebacker Jamal Hill, and tight end Cade Stover. They also acquired an extra 2025 second-round pick via the Vikings, because of the compensation they received from the Browns". [2]
After Watson was traded to the Cleveland Browns, the Browns immediately signed Watson to a groundbreaking five-year contract worth $230 million, fully guaranteed—at the time, the largest guaranteed sum in NFL history. [31] However, Watson's debut with the Browns was delayed due to a league-imposed suspension. He was ultimately suspended for 11 games as a result of the numerous sexual assault allegations against him. [2]
Watson's return to NFL play in Week 13 of the 2022 NFL season marked the beginning of a prominent decline in his on-field performance based on in-game statistics. Over the 2022 and 2023 NFL seasons, Watson's statistics placed him among the bottom tier of NFL quarterbacks, with a completion percentage of 59.8% (41st in the NFL for QBs with a minimum of 300 pass attempts in the 2022–2023 seasons), average passing yards per attempt at 6.5 yards (36th in the NFL), and a passer rating of 81.7 (37th in the NFL). In addition, his deep ball efficiency of 20+ yards fell from 43% while with the Texans to 28% since joining the Browns, ranking him 38th out of 45 qualified quarterbacks since 2022. [2]
During the Browns’ 2024 season opener against the Dallas Cowboys, Watson became the first player in 1,752 recorded instances to fail to complete a single pass on ten or more attempts of 15 yards or more downfield in a game, as reported by CBS Sports analyst Zach Pereles. His performance was also compared to former Browns quarterback Baker Mayfield, who achieved several career high statistics in his 2023 season with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers ranking 9th in passing yards and 7th in passing touchdowns among quarterbacks. His performance with the Buccaneers earned him his first Pro Bowl selection and a three-year, $100 million contract extension with the Buccaneers. Mayfield's performance continued to draw comparisons with Watson's during his 2024 season opener, where Mayfield threw for 289 yards and four touchdowns with no interceptions, achieving a passer rating of 146.4— the highest of Week 1. [2]
In the team's first six games of the 2024 NFL season, the Browns struggled to a poor 1–5 record with Watson as their starting quarterback, and his performances in those games prompted several observers to call for Watson's benching. [32] [33] [34] In the team's next game against the Cincinnati Bengals, Watson ruptured his Achilles tendon on a non-contact play, marking the second consecutive year he suffered a season-ending injury. [35] [36] A small number of Browns fans were heard cheering as the injury happened out of frustration with Watson's poor play, which drew criticism from players. [37]
The Browns traded the 2024 sixth round selection acquired in this trade, along with a fifth round selection, to the Denver Broncos in exchange for WR Jerry Jeudy. [38]
The Deshaun Watson trade and subsequent contract was widely criticized as one of the most detrimental personnel decisions in NFL history on the Browns' side, with far-reaching consequences both on and off the field. [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] The acquisition was referred to by CBS Sports as "the single worst transaction in NFL history", stating that the only NFL trade in history that "comes close" was the Minnesota Vikings' infamous trade to receive Herschel Walker from the Dallas Cowboys. They noted that the Browns surrendered significant draft capital, including three first-round picks and three additional selections, but also committed to a record-breaking contract for Watson despite his legal issues. [2] [3] [6]
This substantial financial commitment has created severe salary cap constraints for the Browns, particularly for the 2025 and 2026 NFL seasons. The structure of Watson's contract, which lacked flexibility or potential exit routes for the team, is expected to significantly limit the Browns' ability to maneuver in free agency or retain other key players during these years. As a result, many NFL analysts argued that the trade and contract has potentially set the franchise back by several years by hindering their ability to build a well-rounded team through future drafts and free agency signings. [2] [5] [6]
Furthermore, many news outlets and NFL journalists stated that the Browns' decision to acquire Watson has also had significant repercussions for the franchise's public image. By effectively making Watson the "face of their organization" despite the numerous civil lawsuits alleging sexual misconduct, the Browns have faced considerable backlash from fans, media, and advocacy groups. These in turn have led to ongoing public relations challenges for the franchise which has impacted fan support, sponsorships, and the team's standing within the NFL, in Cleveland, and in the nation as a whole. [2] [5] [6] [39]
The history of the Houston Texans began in 2002, bringing the National Football League back to Houston, Texas after the city's previous franchise, the Houston Oilers, relocated to Nashville, Tennessee to eventually become the Tennessee Titans. The Texans are the newest franchise in the NFL. Despite some growing pains in the first nine years of their existence, the Texans became a more dominant team in the NFL's AFC South division in the 2010s, though they have yet to appear in a Super Bowl or a conference championship game.
William James O'Brien, nicknamed "the Teapot", is an American football coach who is currently the head coach at Boston College. Previously, he was the head coach of the Houston Texans from 2014 to 2020, and at Penn State from 2012 to 2013. Prior to Boston College, O'Brien was the offensive coordinator at the University of Alabama and for the New England Patriots. After the Patriots parted ways with longtime head coach Bill Belichick at the end of the 2023 season, O'Brien was not retained by the team.
Tyrod Diallo Taylor is an American professional football quarterback for the New York Jets of the National Football League (NFL). He played college football for the Virginia Tech Hokies and was selected by the Baltimore Ravens in the sixth round of the 2011 NFL draft.
Casey Austin Keenum is an American professional football quarterback for the Houston Texans of the National Football League (NFL). He played college football for the Houston Cougars, where he became the NCAA's all-time leader in total passing yards, touchdowns, and completions. In the 2008 college football season, Keenum ranked first nationally in total offense and second in total passing yards.
The National Football League (NFL) is the premier professional American football league in the United States, and is also one of the major North American professional sports leagues. Controversies in the NFL include subjects such as questionable championship rulings, team relocation decisions, and criminal behavior by players. Many of the recent controversies have surrounded NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell, player conduct, and/or the league's role in player safety.
Jeffrey Matthew Driskel is an American professional football quarterback for the Washington Commanders of the National Football League (NFL). He played college football for the Florida Gators and Louisiana Tech Bulldogs and was selected by the San Francisco 49ers in the sixth round of the 2016 NFL draft. Driskel has played for the Cincinnati Bengals, Detroit Lions, Denver Broncos, Houston Texans, Arizona Cardinals, and Cleveland Browns.
Baker Reagan Mayfield is an American professional football quarterback for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers of the National Football League (NFL). After beginning his college football career with the Texas Tech Red Raiders, Mayfield played for the Oklahoma Sooners, where he was the first walk-on player to win the Heisman Trophy in 2017. He was selected first overall by the Cleveland Browns in the 2018 NFL draft.
Jacoby JaJuan Brissett is an American professional football quarterback for the New England Patriots of the National Football League (NFL). Following a stint with the Florida Gators, he played college football for the NC State Wolfpack and was selected by the Patriots in the third round of the 2016 NFL draft. Brissett was traded to the Indianapolis Colts after his rookie season, where he was their primary starter in 2017 and 2019. He spent his next three seasons alternating as the starter and backup with the Miami Dolphins, Cleveland Browns, and Washington Commanders, before rejoining the Patriots in 2024.
Derrick Deshaun Watson is an American professional football quarterback for the Cleveland Browns of the National Football League (NFL). He played college football for the Clemson Tigers, leading the team to a national championship in 2016. Watson was selected in the first round of the 2017 NFL draft by the Houston Texans.
Robert Joshua Dobbs is an American professional football quarterback for the San Francisco 49ers of the National Football League (NFL). He played college football for the Tennessee Volunteers, and was selected by the Pittsburgh Steelers in the fourth round of the 2017 NFL draft. Dobbs has been a member of eight NFL teams during his career, including as the starter for the Tennessee Titans, Arizona Cardinals, and Minnesota Vikings.
Phillip "P. J." Walker Jr. is an American professional football quarterback for the Calgary Stampeders of the Canadian Football League (CFL). He played college football at Temple, and was signed as an undrafted free agent by the Indianapolis Colts in 2017. He also played for the Houston Roughnecks of the XFL in 2020, leading the league in passing yards and touchdowns before it suspended operations due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Kellen Louis Mond is an American professional football quarterback for the San Antonio Brahmas of the United Football League (UFL). He played college football for the Texas A&M Aggies, where he was a four-year starter and became one of three SEC quarterbacks to record over 9,000 career passing yards with 1,500 rushing yards. Mond was selected by the Minnesota Vikings in the third round of the 2021 NFL draft.
The 2020 season was the Houston Texans' 19th season in the National Football League (NFL) and their seventh and final season under head coach Bill O'Brien. Following their week 10 loss to the Cleveland Browns, they failed to match/improve their 10–6 record from last year and failed to win 10 or more games for the first time since the 2017 season. They were eliminated from playoff contention after a Week 14 loss to the Chicago Bears and suffered their first losing season since 2017. This was also the first season since 2012 that DeAndre Hopkins was not on the roster, as he was traded to the Arizona Cardinals in the offseason. This was the Texans' final season with Deshaun Watson as the starting quarterback, as he would sit out the next season amidst sexual misconduct allegations as well as demanding to be traded. Watson's final game as a Texan was on January 2, 2021, a 38–41 loss to the Tennessee Titans, and would be traded to the Cleveland Browns a year later, on March 18, 2022.
Dorian Trevor Thompson-Robinson, also known by his initials DTR, is an American professional football quarterback for the Cleveland Browns of the National Football League (NFL). He played college football for the UCLA Bruins, where he was a two-time second-team all-conference selection in the Pac-12. He was selected by the Browns in the fifth round of the 2023 NFL draft.
Davis Compton Mills is an American professional football quarterback for the Houston Texans of the National Football League (NFL). He played college football for the Stanford Cardinal and was selected by the Texans in the third round of the 2021 NFL draft. Mills was Houston's starter during his first two seasons, before reverting to a backup role after the Texans drafted C. J. Stroud.
The 2021 season was the Houston Texans' 20th season in the National Football League (NFL), and their only under head coach David Culley. For the first time since 2011, defensive end J. J. Watt was not on the roster, as he had signed with the Arizona Cardinals on March 5, 2021, reuniting him with former Texans teammate DeAndre Hopkins, who was traded to the Cardinals the season prior. It also was the first time since 2014 without former head coach Bill O'Brien, as he was fired just four games into the 2020 season when the Texans began 0–4.
Daniel Calhoun "Cal" McNair is an American businessman and sports executive. He is the principal owner, chairman, and chief executive officer for the Houston Texans of the National Football League (NFL).
The 2022 season was the Cleveland Browns' 70th in the National Football League (NFL), their 74th overall, and their third under the head coach/general manager tandem of Kevin Stefanski and Andrew Berry. The Browns failed to improve upon their 8–9 record from the previous season as they finished 7–10. The Browns failed to qualify for the playoffs for the second straight season The Browns introduced a new midfield logo, with Brownie the Elf; this is their first season with a new midfield logo since 2016.
The 2022 season was the Houston Texans' 21st in the National Football League (NFL) and their only season under Lovie Smith, following the firing of David Culley at the end of the 2021 season.
The 2023 season was the Cleveland Browns' 71st season as a member of the National Football League (NFL), their 75th overall, and their fourth under the head coach/general manager tandem of Kevin Stefanski and Andrew Berry. They improved upon their 7–10 record from the previous season, finishing with an 11–6 record and clinching their first winning season and playoff berth since 2020.