F.D.R. Jones

"F.D.R. Jones"
Single by Chick Webb and His Orchestra with Ella Fitzgerald
B-side	"I Love Each Move You Make"
Released	1938
Recorded	October 6, 1938 [1]
Genre	Swing music
Label	Decca 2105 [2]
Songwriter(s)	Harold Rome
Chick Webb and His Orchestra with Ella Fitzgerald singles chronology
"MacPherson Is Rehearsin' to Swing" (1938) "F.D.R. Jones" (1938) "Undecided" (1938)

"F.D.R. Jones" (sometimes "Franklin D. Roosevelt Jones"; originally titled "Man of the Year") is a 1938 satirical song written by Harold Rome. It was first recorded and released as a single by Ella Fitzgerald in 1938 and was performed by Judy Garland in blackface in the 1941 musical picture Babes on Broadway . The song satirizes the then contemporaneous practice of African American parents who named their children after Franklin D. Roosevelt, the 32nd President of the United States. ^[3]

The song was written by Rome for his and Charles Friedman's 1938 satirical musical revue Sing out the News, where it was introduced by Rex Ingram and chorus and bandleader Hazel Scott. The song was performed in the musical in the context of a block party in Harlem. ^[4] Rome's biographer, Tighe E. Zimmers, described the song as "Rome at his tuneful, liberal best, celebrating the birth of a black baby while paying homage to Franklin D. Roosevelt." ^[4] It has also been described as "patronizing, if well-meant" by Guido van Rijn in his 1995 book Roosevelt's Blues: African-American Blues and Gospel Artists on President Franklin D. Roosevelt. ^[5]

The song was first recorded by Chick Webb and His Orchestra with vocalist Ella Fitzgerald and released by Decca Records as catalog number 2105, with the flip side "I Love Each Move You Make". ^[6] It was recorded by 16 other American and British vocalists within a year. ^[5] Judy Garland released it as the B side to her 1941 single "How About You?" as Decca 4072. ^[7]

Other satirical songs in the musical included "I Married a Republican" and "My Heart is Unemployed". ^[8] Rome later contributed the song "Little Miss Victory Jones" to Howard Dietz and Vernon Duke's 1942 satirical revue Dancing in the Streets, but it was not perceived as successful as "F.D.R. Jones" being described by writer Louis Kronenberger as "more a puniest sort of stepsister" rather than a cousin to "F.D.R. Jones". ^[9] "F.D.R. Jones" subsequently won an award from the American American Society of Composers, Authors, and Publishers (ASCAP) as one of the best songs of 1938. ^[10]

The song was extremely popular from its debut, and sold 70,000 sheet music copies. It was covered by Cab Calloway, Chick Webb, Flanagan & Allen, Glenn Miller, as well as Fitzgerald and Garland. ^[4] In his 1994 book My Singing Teachers, singer Mel Tormé described Fitzgerald's version as one of his favourites that she recorded with the Chick Webb band and that she sang it with "great humor". ^[11]

The songs popularity endured until World War II, it was subsequently sung by soldiers waiting to be evacuated after the Battle of Dunkirk in 1940 and broadcast with altered lyrics by the Nazi propagandist band Charlie and his Orchestra in January 1942 as part of an anti-Semitic attack on Roosevelt. ^{[4] [5]}

Garland's Babes On Broadway performance

The song was performed as part of a minstrel medley by Judy Garland and Mickey Rooney in blackface in the 1941 musical film Babes on Broadway . ^[12] The medley was subsequently described by Michael Feingold in a 1998 review of recent Garland reissues in the Village Voice as "otherwise unstomachable" apart from Garland's performance of the song which he felt was a "triumphant rendition...innocence joyously cubed and that "...she largely eschews the genre's racist mannerisms. It's just Judy, proud and happy, as a nonwhite male American, a role like other roles". ^[12]

Feingold concluded that "Distressing as the sequence is, Judy's spirit gets past it. She does not seem to be playing to the blackface, as Jolson does in similar numbers; what stays in the memory is her vocal clarity (the crane shot climbs over a single bell-toned long note), not the horrific racist cartoon. It's the ultimate indication of her power to transcend: There's very little uglier than this in American pop culture, yet even here Judy can find a reserve of dignity, and not be brought down. She does not "sell" racism; at her bosses' behest, she merely wears its costumes". ^[13]

References

1. Stuart Nicholson (22 July 2014). Ella Fitzgerald: A Biography of the First Lady of Jazz, Updated Edition. Routledge. ISBN   978-1-136-78814-7.
2. "Chick Webb - F.D.R. Jones/I Love Each Move You Make at Discogs". discogs.com. Retrieved 16 March 2017.
3. Nancy Joan Weiss (1983). Farewell to the Party of Lincoln: Black Politics in the Age of FDR. Princeton University Press. p. 18. ISBN   0-691-10151-5.
4. Tighe E. Zimmers (30 October 2013). Lyrical Satirical Harold Rome: A Biography of the Broadway Composer-Lyricist. McFarland. p. 29. ISBN   978-1-4766-0166-3.
5. Guido van Rijn (1995). Roosevelt's Blues: African-American Blues and Gospel Artists on President Franklin D. Roosevelt. Univ. Press of Mississippi. p. 41. ISBN   978-1-60473-165-1.
6. Decca Records in the 2000 to 2499 series
7. "Judy Garland - How About You/F.D.R. Jones at Discogs". discogs.com. Retrieved 16 March 2017.
8. Diane Holloway (2001). American History in Song: Lyrics from 1900 to 1945. Authors Choice Press. p. 370. ISBN   978-0-595-19331-8.
9. Dan Dietz (2 February 2015). The Complete Book of 1940s Broadway Musicals. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. p. 135. ISBN   978-1-4422-4528-0.
10. John Arthur Garraty; Mark Christopher Carnes (1 January 1999). American National Biography. Oxford University Press. p. 800. ISBN   978-0-19-512797-3.
11. Mel Tormé (January 1994). My Singing Teachers. Oxford University Press. p. 38. ISBN   978-0-19-509095-6.
12. David Shipman (1 June 1994). Judy Garland: The Secret Life of an American Legend. Hyperion. p. 124. ISBN   978-0-7868-8026-3.
13. "Pure Presentation". Village Voice. 3 November 1998. Retrieved 5 May 2017.