Heisman curse

Last updated

The Heisman curse is a two-part assertion of a negative future for the winner of the Heisman Trophy in American football. The "curse" supposes that any college football player who wins the Heisman plays on a team that will likely lose its subsequent bowl game. The trend of post-award failure has garnered the attention of the mainstream media. [1]

Contents

History

Talk of a Heisman curse in relation to bowl results was particularly prevalent from 2003 to 2008, when six Heisman Trophy winners compiled a cumulative 1–5 bowl game record, and five of those six led number one ranked teams into the Bowl Championship Series (BCS) National Championship Game as favorites (Heisman Trophy winners, including Reggie Bush, who gave back his Heisman Trophy, are 4–8 overall in the BCS National Championship Game and College Football Playoff National Championship, although prior to 2009 they were 1–6). Additionally, the Heisman curse asserts that most Heisman winners will either have a poor career in the National Football League (NFL), or not even see such a football career at all. Although many Heisman winners have not enjoyed success at the professional level, including Matt Leinart, Andre Ware, Jason White, Rashaan Salaam, Eric Crouch, Ty Detmer, Troy Smith and Gino Torretta, proponents of the "curse" rarely cite highly successful players such as Barry Sanders, Charles Woodson, Eddie George, Tim Brown, Bo Jackson, Marcus Allen, Earl Campbell, O. J. Simpson, and Tony Dorsett among the notables.

Insofar as there is a "curse" of underperforming Heisman winners, it seems to affect quarterbacks disproportionately. Although certain Heisman winners have gone on to win Super Bowl championships (such as Roger Staubach and Jim Plunkett), comparatively few have had successful NFL careers. Conversely, running backs seem generally to have fared better in the professional ranks, and wide receivers have had mixed results. The only primarily defensive Heisman winner, Charles Woodson, had a successful NFL career and final collegiate bowl game appearance. Seven Heisman winners have also been named Associated Press NFL MVP: Paul Hornung, Simpson, Campbell, Allen, Sanders, Cam Newton, and Lamar Jackson. Meanwhile, four have won the Super Bowl Most Valuable Player Award: Staubach, Plunkett, Allen, and Desmond Howard.

The "curse" does not imply that only Heisman winners have failed careers, only the irony behind college football's best underperforming after the award is given. [2] However, while there are numerous counts of players who underperformed after winning the award, an equal number of players have gone on to see great success, [3] evidence that the "curse" is more of an amusement than a reality.

While there is no statistical or empirical evidence that suggests Heisman winners underperform compared to other high-profile collegiate players, some [ who? ] try to explain the perception of the curse by reference to trends regarding voter selections. Some see the trend going back decades to other players, but it has most famously been observed since the 1990s. The accepted logical explanation for the discrepancy between success and failure of Heisman winners is that the people who pick the Heisman are sportswriters and former Heisman winners. This might mean that they vote for a winner based on reputation, without seeing him or really studying him, basically a qualitative approach. On the other hand, the people who pick players for the NFL are talent evaluators. They study footage, interview players and put them through workouts where their strengths and weaknesses can be quantified. [4]

Heisman Trophy winner's bowl game results

YearPlayerTeamBowl GameOpponentBowl Game Result
1935 Jay Berwanger Chicago Maroons No Bowl——
1936 Larry Kelley No. 12 Yale Bulldogs No Bowl——
1937 Clint Frank No. 12 Yale Bulldogs No Bowl——
1938 Davey O'Brien No. 1 TCU Horned Frogs 1939 Sugar Bowl No. 6 Carnegie Tech W, 15–7
1939 Nile Kinnick No. 9 Iowa Hawkeyes No Bowl——
1940 Tom Harmon No. 3 Michigan Wolverines No Bowl——
1941 Bruce Smith No. 1 Minnesota Golden Gophers No Bowl——
1942 Frank Sinkwich No. 2 Georgia Bulldogs 1943 Rose Bowl No. 13 UCLA Bruins W, 9–0
1943 Angelo Bertelli No. 1 Notre Dame Fighting Irish No Bowl——
1944 Les Horvath No. 2 Ohio State Buckeyes No Bowl——
1945 Doc Blanchard No. 1 Army Cadets No Bowl——
1946 Glenn Davis No. 2 Army Cadets No Bowl——
1947 Johnny Lujack No. 1 Notre Dame Fighting Irish No Bowl——
1948 Doak Walker No. 10 SMU Mustangs 1949 Cotton Bowl Classic No. 9 Oregon Ducks W, 21–13
1949 Leon Hart No. 1 Notre Dame Fighting Irish No Bowl——
1950 Vic Janowicz No. 14 Ohio State Buckeyes No Bowl——
1951 Dick Kazmaier No. 6 Princeton Tigers No Bowl——
1952 Billy Vessels No. 4 Oklahoma Sooners No Bowl——
1953 Johnny Lattner No. 2 Notre Dame Fighting Irish No Bowl——
1954 Alan Ameche No. 9 Wisconsin Badgers No Bowl——
1955 Howard Cassady No. 5 Ohio State Buckeyes No Bowl——
1956 Paul Hornung Notre Dame Fighting Irish No Bowl——
1957 John David Crow No. 9 Texas A&M Aggies 1957 Gator Bowl No. 13 Tennessee Volunteers L, 0–3
1958 Pete Dawkins No. 3 Army Cadets No Bowl——
1959 Billy Cannon No. 3 LSU Tigers 1960 Sugar Bowl No. 2 Ole Miss Rebels L, 0–21
1960 Joe Bellino No. 4 Navy Midshipmen 1961 Orange Bowl No. 5 Missouri Tigers L, 14–21
1961 Ernie Davis No. 14 Syracuse Orangemen 1961 Liberty Bowl Miami Hurricanes W, 15–14
1962 Terry Baker Oregon State 1962 Liberty Bowl Villanova Wildcats W, 6–0
1963 Roger Staubach No. 2 Navy Midshipmen 1964 Cotton Bowl Classic No. 1 Texas Longhorns L, 6–28
1964 John Huarte No. 3 Notre Dame Fighting Irish No Bowl——
1965 Mike Garrett No. 10 USC Trojans No Bowl——
1966 Steve Spurrier No. 11 Florida Gators 1967 Orange Bowl No. 8 Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets W, 27–12
1967 Gary Beban UCLA Bruins No Bowl——
1968 O. J. Simpson No. 2 USC Trojans 1969 Rose Bowl No. 1 Ohio State Buckeyes L, 16–27
1969 Steve Owens Oklahoma Sooners No Bowl——
1970 Jim Plunkett No. 12 Stanford Indians 1971 Rose Bowl No. 2 Ohio State Buckeyes W, 27–17
1971 Pat Sullivan No. 5 Auburn Tigers 1972 Sugar Bowl No. 3 Oklahoma Sooners L, 22–40
1972 Johnny Rodgers No. 9 Nebraska Cornhuskers 1973 Orange Bowl No. 12 Notre Dame Fighting Irish W, 40–6
1973 John Cappelletti No. 6 Penn State Nittany Lions 1974 Orange Bowl No. 13 LSU Tigers W, 16–9
1974 Archie Griffin No. 3 Ohio State Buckeyes 1975 Rose Bowl No. 5 USC Trojans L, 17–18
1975Archie Griffin No. 1 Ohio State Buckeyes 1976 Rose Bowl No. 11 UCLA Bruins L, 10–23
1976 Tony Dorsett No. 1 Pittsburgh Panthers 1977 Sugar Bowl No. 5 Georgia Bulldogs W, 27–3
1977 Earl Campbell No. 1 Texas Longhorns 1978 Cotton Bowl Classic No. 5 Notre Dame Fighting Irish L, 10–38
1978 Billy Sims No. 4 Oklahoma Sooners 1979 Orange Bowl No. 6 Nebraska Cornhuskers W, 31–24
1979 Charles White No. 3 USC Trojans 1980 Rose Bowl No. 1 Ohio State Buckeyes W, 17–16
1980 George Rogers No. 18 South Carolina Gamecocks 1980 Gator Bowl No. 3 Pittsburgh Panthers L, 9–37
1981 Marcus Allen No. 8 USC Trojans 1982 Fiesta Bowl No. 7 Penn State Nittany Lions L, 10–26
1982 Herschel Walker No. 1 Georgia Bulldogs 1983 Sugar Bowl No. 2 Penn State Nittany Lions L, 23–27
1983 Mike Rozier No. 1 Nebraska Cornhuskers 1984 Orange Bowl No. 5 Miami Hurricanes L, 30–31
1984 Doug Flutie No. 8 Boston College Eagles 1985 Cotton Bowl Classic Houston Cougars W, 45–28
1985 Bo Jackson No. 16 Auburn Tigers 1986 Cotton Bowl Classic No. 11 Texas A&M Aggies L, 16–36
1986 Vinny Testaverde No. 1 Miami Hurricanes 1987 Fiesta Bowl No. 2 Penn State Nittany Lions L, 10–14
1987 Tim Brown No. 12 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 1988 Cotton Bowl Classic No. 13 Texas A&M Aggies L, 10–35
1988 Barry Sanders No. 12 Oklahoma State 1988 Holiday Bowl No. 15 Wyoming Cowboys W, 62–14
1989 Andre Ware No. 13 Houston Cougars No Bowl - NCAA Probation——
1990 Ty Detmer No. 13 BYU Cougars 1990 Holiday Bowl Texas A&M Aggies L, 14–65
1991 Desmond Howard No. 4 Michigan Wolverines 1992 Rose Bowl No. 2 Washington Huskies L, 14–34
1992 Gino Torretta No. 1 Miami Hurricanes 1993 Sugar Bowl (National Championship Game) No. 2 Alabama Crimson Tide L, 13–34
1993 Charlie Ward No. 1 Florida State Seminoles 1994 Orange Bowl (National Championship Game) No. 2 Nebraska Cornhuskers W, 18–16
1994 Rashaan Salaam No. 4 Colorado Buffaloes 1995 Fiesta Bowl Notre Dame Fighting Irish W, 41–24
1995 Eddie George No. 4 Ohio State Buckeyes 1996 Florida Citrus Bowl No. 5 Tennessee Volunteers L, 14–20
1996 Danny Wuerffel No. 3 Florida Gators 1997 Sugar Bowl (National Championship Game) No. 1 Florida State Seminoles W, 52–20
1997 Charles Woodson No. 1 Michigan Wolverines 1998 Rose Bowl No. 8 Washington State Cougars W, 21–16
1998 Ricky Williams No. 20 Texas Longhorns 1999 Cotton Bowl Classic No. 25 Mississippi State Bulldogs W, 38–11
1999 Ron Dayne No. 4 Wisconsin Badgers 2000 Rose Bowl No. 22 Stanford Cardinal W, 17–9
2000 Chris Weinke No. 2 Florida State Seminoles 2001 Orange Bowl (National Championship Game) No. 1 Oklahoma Sooners L, 2–13
2001 Eric Crouch No. 2 Nebraska Cornhuskers 2002 Rose Bowl (National Championship Game) No. 1 Miami Hurricanes L, 14–37
2002 Carson Palmer No. 5 USC Trojans 2003 Orange Bowl No. 3 Iowa Hawkeyes W, 38–17
2003 Jason White No. 1 Oklahoma Sooners 2004 Sugar Bowl (National Championship Game) No. 2 LSU Tigers L, 14–21
2004 Matt Leinart No. 1 USC Trojans 2005 Orange Bowl (National Championship Game) No. 2 Oklahoma Sooners W‡, 55–19
2005 Reggie Bush No. 1 USC Trojans 2006 Rose Bowl (National Championship Game) No. 2 Texas Longhorns L, 38–41
2006 Troy Smith No. 1 Ohio State Buckeyes 2007 BCS National Championship Game No. 2 Florida Gators L, 14–41
2007 Tim Tebow No. 9 Florida Gators 2008 Capital One Bowl Michigan Wolverines L, 35–41
2008 Sam Bradford No. 1 Oklahoma Sooners 2009 BCS National Championship Game No. 2 Florida Gators L, 14–24
2009 Mark Ingram II No. 1 Alabama Crimson Tide 2010 BCS National Championship Game No. 2 Texas Longhorns W, 37–21
2010 Cam Newton No. 1 Auburn Tigers 2011 BCS National Championship Game No. 2 Oregon Ducks W, 22–19
2011 Robert Griffin III No. 12 Baylor Bears 2011 Alamo Bowl Washington Huskies W, 67–56
2012 Johnny Manziel No. 10 Texas A&M Aggies 2013 Cotton Bowl Classic No. 12 Oklahoma Sooners W, 41–13
2013 Jameis Winston No. 1 Florida State Seminoles 2014 BCS National Championship Game No. 2 Auburn Tigers W, 34–31
2014 Marcus Mariota No. 3 Oregon Ducks 2015 Rose Bowl
2015 College Football Playoff National Championship 		No. 2 Florida State Seminoles
No. 4 Ohio State Buckeyes 		W, 59–20
L, 20–42
2015 Derrick Henry No. 2 Alabama Crimson Tide 2015 Cotton Bowl Classic (December)
2016 College Football Playoff National Championship 		No. 3 Michigan State Spartans
No. 1 Clemson Tigers 		W, 38–0
W, 45–40
2016 Lamar Jackson No. 8 Louisville Cardinals 2016 Citrus Bowl (December) No. 13 LSU Tigers L, 9–29
2017 Baker Mayfield No. 2 Oklahoma Sooners 2018 Rose Bowl No. 3 Georgia Bulldogs L, 48–54
2018 Kyler Murray No. 4 Oklahoma Sooners 2018 Orange Bowl No. 1 Alabama Crimson Tide L, 34–45
2019 Joe Burrow No. 1 LSU Tigers 2019 Peach Bowl
2020 College Football Playoff National Championship 		No. 4 Oklahoma Sooners
No. 3 Clemson Tigers 		W, 63–28
W, 42–25
2020 DeVonta Smith No. 1 Alabama Crimson Tide 2021 Rose Bowl

2021 College Football Playoff National Championship

No. 4 Notre Dame Fighting Irish

No. 3 Ohio State Buckeyes

W, 31–14
W, 52–24
2021 Bryce Young No. 1 Alabama Crimson Tide 2021 Cotton Bowl Classic
2022 College Football Playoff National Championship 		No. 4 Cincinnati Bearcats
No. 3 Georgia Bulldogs 		W, 27–6
L, 18–33
2022 Caleb Williams No. 10 USC Trojans 2023 Cotton Bowl Classic (January) No. 16 Tulane Green Wave L, 45–46
2023 Jayden Daniels No. 13 LSU Tigers 2024 ReliaQuest Bowl (January) Wisconsin Badgers W, 35–31

Rankings are from the AP Poll upon entering bowl games
‡ USC's 2005 Orange Bowl win was later vacated. [5]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Heisman Trophy</span> Annual award for the outstanding college football player

The Heisman Memorial Trophy is awarded annually to the most outstanding player in college football. Winners epitomize great ability combined with diligence, perseverance, and hard work. It is presented by the Heisman Trophy Trust in early December before the postseason bowl games.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paul Hornung</span> American football player (1935–2020)

Paul Vernon Hornung, nicknamed "the Golden Boy", was an American football halfback and kicker who played for the Green Bay Packers of the National Football League (NFL) from 1957 to 1966. He played on teams that won four NFL titles and the first Super Bowl. He is the first Heisman Trophy winner to win the NFL Most Valuable Player award, and be inducted into both the Pro Football Hall of Fame and College Football Hall of Fame. Packers coach Vince Lombardi stated that Hornung was "the greatest player I ever coached".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Roger Staubach</span> American football player and Navy officer (born 1942)

Roger Thomas Staubach, nicknamed "Roger the Dodger", "Captain America", and "Captain Comeback", is an American former football quarterback who played in the National Football League (NFL) for 11 seasons with the Dallas Cowboys. He attended the U.S. Naval Academy, where he won the 1963 Heisman Trophy playing for the Midshipmen. After graduation, he served in the U.S. Navy, including a tour of duty in Vietnam.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jim Plunkett</span> American football player (born 1947)

James William Plunkett is an American former football quarterback who played in the National Football League (NFL) for 16 seasons. He achieved his greatest success during his final eight seasons with the Raiders franchise, whom he led to two Super Bowl wins.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marcus Allen</span> American football player (born 1960)

Marcus LeMarr Allen is an American former football running back who played in the National Football League (NFL) for 16 seasons, primarily with the Los Angeles Raiders. Considered one of the greatest goal line and short-yard runners in NFL history, he was selected 10th overall by the Raiders in the 1982 NFL draft, following a successful college football career with the USC Trojans. He was a member of the Raiders for 11 seasons and spent his last five seasons with the Kansas City Chiefs.

Eric Eugene Crouch is an American former college football player who was a quarterback for the Nebraska Cornhuskers. He won the Heisman Trophy, Walter Camp Award, and Davey O'Brien Award in 2001. Running Nebraska's option offense that year, he completed 105 of 189 passes for 1,510 yards and seven touchdowns, while also rushing for 1,115 yards and 18 touchdowns. He had brief stints playing professionally in the Canadian Football League (CFL) and United Football League (UFL).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mike Garrett</span> American football player and athletic director (born 1944)

Michael Lockett Garrett is an American former football running back who played in the National Football League (NFL) and the American Football League (AFL) for eight seasons with the Kansas City Chiefs and the San Diego Chargers. He played college football for the USC Trojans, where he won the Heisman Trophy in 1965.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Matt Leinart</span> American football player (born 1983)

Matthew Stephen Leinart is an American former football quarterback who played in the National Football League (NFL) for seven seasons. He played college football for the USC Trojans, where he won the Heisman Trophy and led his team to an undefeated season as a junior. Selected tenth overall by the Arizona Cardinals in the 2006 NFL Draft, Leinart primarily served as Kurt Warner's backup for four seasons. He spent his final three seasons in a backup role for the Houston Texans and the Oakland Raiders. Leinart was inducted to the College Football Hall of Fame in 2017.

Gary Joseph Beban is an American former football quarterback who played in the National Football League (NFL) for two seasons with the Washington Redskins. He played college football for the UCLA Bruins, where he won both the Maxwell Award and the Heisman Trophy in 1967. He was inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame in 1988.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">USC Trojans football</span> American college football team at University of Southern California

The USC Trojans football program represents University of Southern California in the sport of American football. The Trojans compete in the Football Bowl Subdivision (FBS) of the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) and the Big Ten Conference.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tommy Prothro</span> American football player and coach (1920–1995)

James Thompson Prothro Jr. was an American football coach and player. He was the head coach at Oregon State University from 1955 to 1964 and the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) from 1965 to 1970, compiling a career college football record of 104–55–5 (.649).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2005 NCAA Division I-A football season</span> American college football season

The 2005 NCAA Division I-A football season was the highest level of college football competition in the United States organized by the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). The regular season began on September 1, 2005 and ended on December 3, 2005. The postseason concluded on January 4, 2006 with the Rose Bowl, which served as the season's BCS National Championship Game.

The 2005 USC Trojans football team represented the University of Southern California in the 2005 NCAA Division I-A football season, winning the Pacific-10 Conference (Pac-10), and playing for the NCAA Division I-A national championship. The team was coached by Pete Carroll, led on offense by quarterback and 2004 Heisman Trophy winner Matt Leinart, and played their home games in the Los Angeles Coliseum.

The 2006 USC Trojans football team represented the University of Southern California during the 2006 NCAA Division I FBS football season, winning the Pacific-10 Conference (Pac-10) and playing in the Rose Bowl. The team was coached by Pete Carroll, led on offense by quarterback John David Booty, and played their home games in the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stanford Cardinal football</span> American college football organization

The Stanford Cardinal football program represents Stanford University in college football at the NCAA Division I FBS level and is a member of the Atlantic Coast Conference. The team is known as the Cardinal, adopted prior to the 1982 season. Stanford was known as the "Cardinal" for its first two decades of athletic competition, then more commonly as the "Cardinals" until 1930. The name was changed to the "Indians" from 1930 to January 1972, and back to the "Cardinals" from 1972 through 1981. A student vote in December 1975 to change the nickname to "Robber Barons" was not approved by administrators.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jason White (American football)</span> American college football player (born 1980)

Jason White is an American former college football quarterback who played for the Oklahoma Sooners. He was named a unanimous All-American and won the Heisman Trophy in 2003.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2005 Orange Bowl</span> College football game

The 2005 Orange Bowl was the BCS National Championship Game of the 2004 NCAA Division I-A football season and was played on January 4, 2005, at Pro Player Stadium in Miami Gardens, Florida. The game matched the USC Trojans against the Oklahoma Sooners. Both teams entered with undefeated, 12–0 records. Despite only being a 1-point favorite, USC defeated Oklahoma by a score of 55–19, led by quarterback Matt Leinart. ESPN named Leinart's performance as one of the top-10 performances in the first ten years of the BCS system.

The 2004 USC Trojans football team represented the University of Southern California in the 2004 NCAA Division I-A football season. The 2004 Trojans football team won the 2004 BCS National Championship by winning the 2005 Orange Bowl, that year's BCS National Championship Game. The team also won the AP title for the second year in a row. It was the Trojans' first unanimous national championship since 1972, and the second time a team had gone wire-to-wire, with the Trojans holding the number 1 spot in the polls all season. The team was coached by Pete Carroll in his fourth year with the Trojans, and played their home games in the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum. The team is widely considered one of the greatest college football teams of all time.

The 1969 Rose Bowl was the 55th edition of the college football bowl game, played at the Rose Bowl in Pasadena, California, on Wednesday, January 1. The top-ranked Ohio State Buckeyes of the Big Ten Conference defeated the defending national champions - #2 USC Trojans of the Pacific-8 Conference, 27–16. Sophomore quarterback Rex Kern of Ohio State was the Player of the Game.

<i>The Perfect 10</i> (NFL film) American TV series or program

The Perfect 10 is a sports documentary about the 10 Heisman Trophy winners who also got enshrined into the Pro Football Hall of Fame produced by Fox Sports Films, Tim Brown, Hall of Fame Village Media, H2H Productions, and NFL Films. The Perfect 10 premiered on February 11, 2023, at 8 P.M. on Fox, the night before Super Bowl LVII.

References

  1. ↑ "TideSports.com - Heisman curse? Hardly". Alabama.rivals.com. Retrieved 13 January 2015.
  2. ↑ "ESPN.com - Page2 - The List: Biggest Heisman flops". Espn.go.com. Retrieved 13 January 2015.
  3. ↑ "Heisman Trophy Studs & Duds, best Heisman winners, Heisman flops". Bullz-eye.com. Retrieved 13 January 2015.
  4. ↑ "Heisman's Career Curse". Forbes.com. 11 December 2009. Archived from the original on 23 January 2013. Retrieved 1 October 2011.
  5. ↑ "Markazi: USC doesn't need trophy to be champs". 7 June 2011.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.