Internet in Africa

Last updated

Percentage of population using the Internet in 2022. Note that Africa has significantly less internet usage. Share-of-individuals-using-the-internet.png
Percentage of population using the Internet in 2022. Note that Africa has significantly less internet usage.

The Internet in Africa is limited by a lower penetration rate when compared to the rest of the world. Measurable parameters such as the number of ISP subscriptions, overall number of hosts, IXP-traffic, and overall available bandwidth are indicators that Africa is far behind the "digital divide". Moreover, Africa itself exhibits an inner digital divide, with most Internet activity and infrastructure concentrated in South Africa, Morocco, and Egypt, as well as smaller economies like Mauritius and the Seychelles. In general, only 43% of the African population has access to the Internet as of 2021. [2] [3] Only 0.4% of the African population has a fixed-broadband subscription. The majority of internet users use it through mobile broadband. [4] [5] [6] [7]

Contents

During the COVID-19 pandemic, many people who were not connected to the internet lost access to health care and education. Production in all industries was seriously harmed. [4] [8] [9] [10]

While the telecommunications market in Africa is still in its early stages of development, it is also one of the fastest-growing in the world. In the 2000s, mobile telephone service in Africa has been rising, and mobile telephone use is now substantially more widespread than fixed-line telephony. Telecommunication companies in Africa are looking at Broadband Wireless Access technologies as the key to make Internet available to the population at large. Projects are being completed that aim at the realization of Internet backbones that might help cut the cost of bandwidth in African countries.

The International Telecommunication Union held the first Connect the World meeting in Kigali, Rwanda (in October 2007) as a demonstration that the development of telecommunications in Africa is considered a key intermediate objective for the fulfillment of the Millennium Development Goals. [11]

Internet penetration in Africa, by country

Previous situation

A map of the percentage of the population of African countries using the Internet in 2015 (see table for 2000 and 2015 data by individual country). African internet 2015.svg
A map of the percentage of the population of African countries using the Internet in 2015 (see table for 2000 and 2015 data by individual country).

The information available about the ability of people in Africa to use the internet (for instance ISP subscriptions, host number, network traffic, available bandwidth and bandwidth cost) give an essentially homogeneous picture. South Africa is the only African country that has figures similar to those of Europe and North America: it is followed by some smaller, tourist-dependent economies, such as Seychelles and Mauritius, and a few North African countries, notably Morocco and Egypt. The leading Subsaharan countries in telecommunication sand internet development are South Africa and Kenya. [12]

Nation
Population
in thousands
Individuals
using the internet
in 2000
(%)
Individuals
using the internet
in 2015
(%)
Individuals
using the internet
in 2022
(%) [1]
Algeria 396700.4938.2071.2
Angola 253260.1112.4039.3
Benin 107820.236.7933.8
Botswana 21762.9027.5077.3
Burkina Faso 184502.9027.5019.9
Burundi 98240.084.8711.3
Cameroon 219180.2520.6843.9
Cape Verde 5251.8243.0272.1
Central African
Republic
49000.054.5610.6
Chad 136750.042.7012.2
Congo 39030.037.6236.2
DR Congo 772670.013.8027.2
Ivory Coast 231260.2321.0038.4
Djibouti 9610.1911.9265
Egypt 891250.6437.8272.2
Equatorial Guinea 19960.1321.3266.8
Eritrea 68950.141.0826.6
Eswatini 11190.9330.3858.3
Ethiopia 993910.0211.6019.4
Gabon 18731.2223.5073.7
Gambia 20220.9217.1254.2
Ghana 274140.1523.4869.8
Guinea 109350.104.7033.9
Guinea Bissau 17880.233.5431.6
Kenya 455330.3245.6240.8
Lesotho 19080.2116.0747
Liberia 40460.025.9030.1
Libya 62780.1919.0288.4
Madagascar 230430.204.1720.6
Malawi 163070.139.3018
Mali 177960.1410.3033.1
Mauritania 36320.1915.2044.4
Mauritius 12637.2850.1475.5
Morocco 343800.6957.0889.9
Mozambique 280130.119.0021.2
Namibia 22811.6422.3162.2
Niger 188800.042.2216.9
Nigeria 1815630.0647.4435.5
Rwanda 113240.0618.0034.4
São Tomé and
Príncipe
2064.6425.8257
Senegal 141500.4021.6960
Sierra Leone 65130.125.3630.4
Somalia 109720.0255.7627.6
South Africa 549575.3551.9274.7
Sudan 40235 / 125190.0326.6128.6
Tanzania 510460.125.3631.9
Togo 70650.807.1237.6
Tunisia 111182.7548.5273.8
Uganda 371020.1619.2210
Zambia 154740.1921.0031.2
Zimbabwe 135030.4016.3632.6

Current trend

As of December 2020, Kenya had an internet penetration of approximately 85.2. This high rate is mainly because Kenya is home to M-Pesa, which is a mobile wallet provider and the offered secure payment system encourages internet access. As of October 2020, the majority of web traffic in leading digital markets in Africa originated from mobile devices in Nigeria, one of the countries with the biggest number of internet users worldwide. Across the nation, 74 percent of web traffic was generated via smartphones and only 24 percent via PC devices. This is connected to the fact that mobile connections are much cheaper and do not require the infrastructure that is needed for traditional desktop PCs with fixed-line internet connections. [13]

Context

Internet access point in Kigali, Rwanda Cybercafe in kigali.jpg
Internet access point in Kigali, Rwanda

Obstacles to the accessibility of Internet services in Africa include generally low levels of computer literacy in the population, poor infrastructures, and high costs of Internet services. Power availability is also scarce, with vast rural areas that are not connected to power grids as well as frequent black-outs in major urban areas such as Dar es Salaam. [14]

In 2000, Subsaharan Africa as a whole had fewer fixed telephone lines than Manhattan, and in 2006, Africa contributed to only 2% of the world's overall telephone lines in the world. [14] As a consequence of this general lack of connectivity, most Africa-generated network traffic (something between 70% [15] and 85% [14] ) is routed through servers that are located elsewhere (mainly Europe).

Overall bandwidth in Africa is scarce, and its irregular distribution clearly reflects the African "inner digital divide". In 2007, 16 countries in Africa had just one international Internet connection with a capacity of 10 Mbit/s or lower, while South Africa alone had over 800 Mbit/s. The main backbones connecting Africa to the rest of the world via submarine cables, i.e., SAT-2 and SAT-3, provide for a limited bandwidth. In 2007, all these international connections from Africa amounted to roughly 28,000 Mbit/s, while Asia had 800,000 Mbit/s and Europe had over 3,000,000 Mbit/s. The total bandwidth available to Africa was less than that available to Norway alone (49,000 Mbit/s). [14]

As a consequence of the scarce overall bandwidth provided by cable connections, a large section of Internet traffic in Africa goes through expensive satellite links. [15] In general, thus, the cost of Internet access (and even more so broadband access) is unaffordable for most of the population. [14] According to the Kenyan ISPs association, high costs are also a consequence of the subjection of African ISPs to European ISPs and the lack of a clear international regulation of inter-ISP cost partition. For example, while ITU has long ratified that the cost of inter-provider telephonic connections must be charged to all involved providers in equal parts, in 2002, the Kenyan ISP association has denounced that all costs of Internet traffic between Europe and Africa are charged to African providers. [16]

Internet access

Internet users by region [17]
Region2005201020172023
Africa2%10%21.8%37%
Americas36%49%65.9%87%
Arab States8%26%43.7%69%
Asia and Pacific9%23%43.9%66%
Commonwealth of
Independent States
10%34%67.7%89%
Europe46%67%79.6%91%

According to 2011 estimates, about 13.5% of the African population has Internet access. [18] While Africa accounts for 15.0% of the world's population, only 6.2% of the World's Internet subscribers are Africans. [19] Africans who have access to broadband connections are estimated to be in percentage of 1% or lower. [15] [20] In September 2007, African broadband subscribers were 1,097,200, with a major part of these subscriptions from large companies or institutions. [20]

Internet access is also irregularly distributed, with 2/3 of overall online activity in Africa being generated in South Africa (which only accounts for 5% of the continent's population). [19] Most of the remaining 1/3 is in Morocco and Egypt. [14] The largest percentage of Internet subscribers are found in small economies such as Seychelles, where as much as 37% of the population has Internet access (while in South Africa this value is 11% and in Egypt it is 8%). [14]

It has been noted, anyway, that data on Internet subscribers only partially reflect the actual number of Internet users in Africa, and the impact of the network on African daily life and culture. [21] [22] For example, cybercafes and Internet kiosks are common in the urban areas of many African countries. There are also other informal means to "access" the Internet; for example, couriers that print e-mail messages and deliver them by hand to recipients in remote locations, or radio stations that broadcast information taken from the Internet. [21]

Number of hosts

The picture provided by the figures for the number of network hosts is coherent with those above. At the end of 2007:

The table below lists the number of hosts for African countries with more than 1000 hosts in 2007 and 2013. These countries collectively account for 99% of Africa's overall hosts. The last column for each year provides the "host density" measured as the number of hosts per 1000 inhabitants; for comparison, consider that the average host density in the world was 43 hosts per 1000 inhabitants in 2007 and 72 hosts per 1000 inhabitants in 2013. [24] [25]

 June 2013 [25] December 2007 [24]
NationHosts
(×1000)
Percentage
(of Africa's
total)
Hosts
(per 1000
 inhabitants)
Hosts
(×1000)
Percentage
(of Africa's
total)
Hosts
(per 1000
 inhabitants)
South Africa 4835809611976525
Morocco 27959273159
Egypt 20434175102
Mozambique 92242311
Libya 79112
Namibia 78137703
Kenya 73122411
Ghana 60122411
Mauritius 511421018
Zimbabwe 47141812
Madagascar 431211111
Angola 3712600
Uganda 3311100
Réunion 33139
Tanzania 27012111
Côte d'Ivoire 2501600
Zambia 1701801
Lesotho 1105
Cameroon 1001
Botswana 804604
Rwanda 400200
Malawi 300
Congo, DR 300200
Swaziland 302302
Congo, RO 301
Nigeria 200200
Burkina Faso 200
Gambia 201
São Tomé and
Príncipe
2010108
Eritrea 100100
Sierra Leone 100
Benin 100
Togo 100
Africa (total)6027100618301002

IXP traffic

An indirect measure that is sometimes used to assess the penetration of Internet technology in a given area is the overall amount of data traffic at Internet exchange points (IXPs). On African IXPs, traffic can be measured in kbit/s (kilobits per second) or Mbit/s (megabits per second), while in the rest of the world it is typically in the order of magnitude of Gbit/s (gigabits per second). The main IXP of Johannesburg, JINX (which is also the largest IXP in Africa) has about 6.5 Gbit/s traffic (in Sep 2012). [26]

IXP traffic, anyway, is only a measure of local network traffic (mainly e-mail), while most of African generated traffic is routed through other continents, and most Web content created in Africa is hosted on Web servers located elsewhere. [20] Additionally, measurable data do not consider private peering, i.e., inter-ISP traffic that does not go through IXPs. For example, the main academic network in South Africa, TENET, has 10 Gbit/s private peering with ISP Internet Solutions both in Johannesburg and Cape Town. [20]

Regulation

The privatization of the telecommunication market, as well as the regulation of the competition in this market, are in an early stage of development in many Africa countries. Kenya and Botswana have started a privatization process for Telkom Kenya and Botswana Telecommunications Corporation (BTC), respectively. [14] The mobile telephony market is generally more open and dynamic, and even more so is the Internet market. [14]

The table below depicts the percentage of African countries where telecommunications markets (fixed line telephony, mobile telephony, Internet) are monopolistic, partially competitive, or fully competitive, either de iure or de facto (data refer to 2007). [14]


Internet
Mobile
telephones
Fixed
telephones
Monopolistic10%9%55%
Partially competitive12%41%23%
Fully competitive69%43%25%

The regulation of network businesses and the establishment of authorities to control them is widely recognised as a relevant objective by most African governments. A model for such regulation is provided by Morocco; after an authority was established in 1998, and Meditel entered the market in 1999 to compete with the main incumbent Maroc Telecom, the situation has been quickly developing. [14] Based on such experiences and on the directions provided by ITU, most African countries now have local Internet authorities and are defining local regulation of the Internet market. In 2007, 83% of African countries had their own authority for Internet services and data traffic. [14]

Benefits of Internet Access in Africa

It is widely recognized that increased availability of Internet technology in Africa would provide several key benefits. Specifically, some of the major issues of the continent might be tackled by applications of this technology, as demonstrated by some initiatives that have already been started and that proved successful. For example, organizations such as RANET (RAdio and interNET for The communication of Hydro-Meteorological and Climate-Related Information) and the ACMAD (African Centre of Meteorological Application for Development) use Internet to develop reliable weather models for Sahel and other areas in Africa, with dramatic benefits for local agricultures. [21]

Internet-based telemedicine and distance education could improve quality of life in the most remote rural areas of Africa. [27] The availability of information on the network could benefit education in general, counterbalancing the general lack of local libraries. [21] It has also been suggested that e-Government applications could indirectly alleviate widespread political issues such as they would definitely help bridge the gap between the institutions and remote rural areas. Most Web 2.0 applications developed in Africa insofar have actually been created by governments. [14]

African economy might also benefit from broadband availability, for example as a consequence of the applicability of e-commerce and outsourcing business models that have long proved effective in Europe and North America. [14] Currently there are many small businesses (Cybercafes, local ISPs or Wireless ISPs) that benefit from broadband availability via satellite to provide Internet connectivity solutions to local customers.

One technology that has been utilized in many African countries for the provision of Internet broadband connectivity is VSAT, which allows businesses to access the European or US Internet backbone via satellite in regions that lack terrestrial Internet access. Fiber in Africa has been restricted to big coastal cities facing North Atlantic, South Atlantic, and Indian Oceans. According to World Bank data only 37% of Africa's 1.2 billion people actually live in those regions. Therefore, satellite remains to be the most effective and viable way to reach rural areas, and thus a major portion of Africa's population. Satellite access in Africa is popular on KU band and C band, [28] with C band being the preferred access method in countries that have heavy rainfall.

Evolution and perspectives

Internet availability

The African telecommunication market is growing at a faster rate than in the rest of the world. [24] In the 2000s this has especially been true for the mobile telephony market, that between 2004 and 2007 grew three times as fast as the world's average. [29] In 2005, over 5 billion USD have been invested in Africa in telecommunication infrastructures. [15]

Internet in Africa is now growing even faster than mobile telephony. Between 2000 and 2008, Internet subscriptions have grown by 1030.2%, versus the world's average of 290.6%. [19]

The table below summarizes figures for the number of Internet subscription in Africa from 2000 to 2008, based on estimates made in 2008. [19]

Nation
Population
(×1000)
Subscriptions
in 2000
(×1000)
Subscriptions
in 2008
(×1000)
Growth
2000–2008
(%)
Internet
users
(%)
Algeria 337705035006910
Angola 12531301002331
Benin 8295151509002
Botswana 184215804334
Burkina Faso 1526510807001
Burundi 869136019001
Camerun 184682037017502
Cape Verde 4278373629
Central African
Republic
44351137671
Chad 1011116059001
Comoros 73212113003
Congo 3903170139002
DR Congo 665141230459801
Côte d'Ivoire 18373403006502
Djibouti 5061116852
Egypt 817134508620181510
Equatorial Guinea 6161815001
Eritrea 5028512023002
Ethiopia 782541029128101
Gabon 148615814405
Gambia 1735410024056
Ghana 233833065020663
Guinea 102118505251
Guinea Bissau 150313723662
Kenya 37954200300014008
Lesotho 212847016503
Liberia 3335111001
Libya 61741026025004
Madagascar 20043301102661
Malawi 13932151398301
Mali 12324181004311
Mauritania 33655305001
Mauritius 12748734029127
Morocco 343431007300720021
Mozambique 21285302005661
Namibia 2089301002335
Niger 132735407031
Nigeria 1688032001000049007
Rwanda 10186515029001
São Tomé and
Príncipe
20662325311
Senegal 128534082019506
Seychelles 8263243339
Sierra Leone 62955131601
Somalia 9559198489001
South Africa 437862400510011222
Sudan 4021830150049004
Swaziland 112810423204
Tanzania 402131154002481
Togo 58591003202205
Tunisia 103831001722162217
Uganda 3136840200049006
Zambia 116692050024004
Zimbabwe 12382501351260211
Africa (total)98572645145102210305

Infrastructure development

African undersea cables African Undersea Cables in 2023 (version 54).png
African undersea cables

A number of projects have been started that aim at bringing more bandwidth to Africa, in order to cut down costs for both operators and end users. At least three projects for an underseas backbone in the Indian Ocean have been started. EASSy (East African Submarine cable System), sponsored by the World Bank and the Development Bank of Southern Africa, is a cable system that will connect Mtunzini (South Africa) and Port Sudan (Sudan), with branches to several countries on the eastern coast of Africa. The Kenyan government has started a similar project named TEAMS (The East Africa Marine System), with the collaboration of Etisalat. [30] A third project, SEACOM, is completely African-owned. [31] SEACOM bandwidth has already been sold to several customers, including the South African network TENET. [32] On the eastern coast of the continent of Africa, the Africa Coast to Europe cable connects Gibraltar to South Africa and lands in Gulf of Guinea nations, and allows for more access to connectivity. The Eastern African Submarine System, a 10,000 km cable network, is another example. [4] [33]

In South Africa, the SANReN network, with a 500 Gbit/s core, has been designed to become the fastest academic network in the world; the universities of Witwatersrand and Johannesburg are already using a bandwidth of 10 Gbit/s provided by this network.

According to the European Commission, a 10% rise in digital coverage could result in a more than 1% increase in African GDP. The European Investment Bank makes funding emerging developments on the continent a priority, in line with the EU's plan for African digital transformation. [34] [35] The European Investment Bank is providing a €25 million for a 600 km undersea cable in Mauritania, to provide digital access to more people. [4] [36]

Access

Efforts to connect previously disconnected parts of the world have been compared to previous rounds of infrastructure in Africa. The recent linking of East Africa to the global fibre-optic network generated similar visions and hopes to those that emerged in the Victorian era when railways were used to connect the previously disconnected. [37]

With bandwidth becoming more available and less costly, the first to benefit will be institutions and companies that already have Internet access. In order for the network to reach a larger part of the population, solutions are needed for the last mile problem, i.e., to make bandwidth available to the final user. To be feasible for Africa, last mile solutions must be found that take into account the limited penetration of fixed telephony lines, especially in rural areas. Of about 400.000 rural communities that are estimated to exist in Africa, less than 3% have PSTN access. Note that providing network access to rural communities is one of Millennium Goals defined by the World Summit on the Information Society.

Most studies on this subject identify Broadband Wireless Access (BWA) technologies such as WiMAX as the most promising solution for the end user's Internet access in Africa. [14] These technologies can also benefit from the wide availability of the mobile telephony network. Even in smaller countries like Seychelles, most Internet users already access the network via the GSM network. [14] Providers that have 3G licenses will be able to provide WiMAX services. [14]

Some experimentation is already being conducted in a few countries. In Kenya, the Digital Village Scheme project aims at providing government services in rural areas via wireless access. In Nigeria, Horizon Wireless is running a broadband (3.5 GHz) wireless network. Since 2007, MTN Rwanda has been working to provide broadband wireless access in Kigali. [14] In Algeria, the Icosnet ISP and Aperto Networks have been collaborating for a business WiMAX solution. The South African authority ICASA has already assigned WiMAX licences to several providers, and Neotel is implementing WiMAX-based last mile solutions in Johannesburg, Pretoria, Cape Town and Durban. [38]

Mobile technology is the primary infrastructure for telecom services in Africa, with operators focusing their efforts on it. In certain markets, mobile networks handle up to 99% of voice and data traffic. Fixed-line infrastructure is slower, more expensive, has a larger reach, and has fewer difficulties. [4] [39] The number of mobile customers in Africa is expanding faster than everywhere else. By rapidly linking entrepreneurs, startups, and enterprises with existing and future clientele, digital platforms are creating possibilities for them. Mobile financial services allow for immediate payment of products and services. [40] [41] [42]

According to a survey conducted in 2022, the percentage of banks offering digital products or services ranges from at least 80% in Central Africa to more than 95% in West Africa (mostly driven by Nigeria). The top three most often requested services are domestic money transfers (87%), receiving payments from clients (85%), and paying bills or suppliers (79.6%). [43] [44] [45]

In the 2020s, in an effort to bridge the digital divide, several African countries granted licenses to companies who offer satellite internet or other electronic communications offerings. [46]

See also

References

  1. 1 2 “Data Page: Share of the population using the Internet”, part of the following publication: Hannah Ritchie, Edouard Mathieu, Max Roser, and Esteban Ortiz-Ospina (2023) - “Internet”. Data adapted from International Telecommunication Union (via World Bank). Retrieved from https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/share-of-individuals-using-the-internet [online resource]
  2. Black, Jeremy (April 2022). A History of the World: From Prehistory to the 21st Century. Arcturus. p. 221. ISBN   9781838570514.
  3. Galal, Saifaddin (Jan 10, 2024). "Internet usage in Africa - statistics & facts". STATISTA.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 "Digital infrastructure help Africa build resilient societies". European Investment Bank. Retrieved 2022-09-01.
  5. "African e-Connectivity Index 2021: the final frontier and a huge opportunity". Investment Monitor. 2021-11-10. Retrieved 2022-09-01.
  6. "Africa Connectivity Outlook: 2022 and Beyond". SES. 27 June 2022. Retrieved 2022-09-01.
  7. "Why aren't more people using mobile internet in West Africa?". blogs.worldbank.org. 8 December 2021. Retrieved 2022-09-01.
  8. "COVID-19 and Africa: Socio-economic implications and policy responses". OECD. Retrieved 2022-09-01.
  9. "Africa and Europe: In the face of common opportunities and challenges, let's build common responses | EEAS Website". www.eeas.europa.eu. Retrieved 2022-09-01.
  10. "COVID-19". World Bank. Retrieved 2022-09-01.
  11. ITU (2010)
  12. "Percentage of Individuals using the Internet". ITU Statistics. ITU. 2017. Retrieved 27 February 2017.
  13. "Africa: internet penetration, by country 2020". Statista. Retrieved 2021-05-22.
  14. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 ITU (2007)
  15. 1 2 3 4 Waters (2007)
  16. BBC News (2002)
  17. "Measuring digital development: Facts and figures 2023". Telecommunication Development Bureau, International Telecommunication Union (ITU). Retrieved 2024-06-14.
  18. Internet World Statistics Archived 2018-04-13 at the Wayback Machine (2011)
  19. 1 2 3 4 Internet World Stats (2011)
  20. 1 2 3 4 Pingdom (2008)
  21. 1 2 3 4 Cornu (2005)
  22. Oyelaran-Oyeyinka and Nyaki Adeya (2002)
  23. "Nigeria | History, Population, Flag, Map, Languages, Capital, & Facts". Encyclopedia Britannica. Retrieved 2021-05-22.
  24. 1 2 3 4 Livraghi (2008)
  25. 1 2 Livraghi (2014)
  26. INX portal
  27. Albert Butare (Rwanda Minister of Telecommunications), quoted in Waters (2007)
  28. ""C Band Ku Band Comparison". Technical. Link Communications Systems". 30 July 2004.
  29. Hamadoun Touré, International Telecommunication Union, quoted in Waters (2007)
  30. Balancing Act (2008b)
  31. MyBroadband (2007)
  32. Andrew Alston, quoted in Pingdom (2008)
  33. "Eurasia Terrestrial - Submarine Networks". www.submarinenetworks.com. Retrieved 2022-09-06.
  34. "Press corner". European Commission - European Commission. Retrieved 2021-04-16.
  35. "How digitalisation fights COVID-19 and climate change in Africa". European Investment Bank. Retrieved 2021-04-16.
  36. "MAURITANIA COVID-19 RESILIENCE SUBMARINE CABLE". www.eib.org. Retrieved 2022-09-01.
  37. Graham, Mark; Andersen, Casper; Mann, Laura (2014-12-15). "Geographical imagination and technological connectivity in East Africa". Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers. 40 (3): 334–349. doi: 10.1111/tran.12076 . ISSN   0020-2754.
  38. Balancing (2008b)
  39. "Sub-Saharan Africa". The Mobile Economy. Retrieved 2022-09-01.
  40. "Solutions". www.wearetech.africa (in French). Retrieved 2022-09-01.
  41. "How Africa's growing mobile money market is evolving". www.ey.com. Retrieved 2022-09-01.
  42. Bayuo, Blaise; Bamford, Roxanne; Baah, Belinda; Mwaya, Judith; Gakuo, Chizi; Tholstrup, Sophie (February 2022). "Supercharging Africa's Startups: The Continent's Path to Tech Excellence".
  43. Bank, European Investment (2022-10-19). Finance in Africa - Navigating the financial landscape in turbulent times. European Investment Bank. ISBN   978-92-861-5382-2.
  44. Hiebert, Tapfuma Musewe, Kyle. "The Future of Fintech Is Unfolding in Africa". Centre for International Governance Innovation. Retrieved 2022-10-28.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  45. "Fintech in Nigeria | McKinsey". www.mckinsey.com. Retrieved 2022-10-28.
  46. "Zambia becomes sixth African country to get SpaceX's Starlink satellite internet service". 5 October 2023.

African online communities