Controversies
During the debate on same-sex marriage in Scotland,Mason was widely condemned for raising a motion stating that “while some in society approve of same-sex sexual relationships,others do not agree with them”and that no person or organisation should be forced to be involved or to approve of same-sex marriage. [23] In February 2013,he wrote that he did not believe same-sex couples should have sex,on the grounds that,"the Bible is the word of God and its teachings are God’s direction as to how I should live my life. The Bible’s teaching is that a follower of Jesus should not have a sexual relationship with someone of the same sex.” [24] [25] In 2020 Mason returned to the question of gay sex,informing the Scottish Parliament whilst debating the Hate Crime Bill that the legislation would mean,"[Green party co-leader] Patrick Harvie and I can continue to debate who should or should not have sex with whom... That is a sign of a healthy society and a healthy democracy." [25] The remark was criticised as "utterly bizarre". [25]
In January 2015 he spoke in parliament in favour of teaching school children young Earth creationism,claiming that it cannot be "disproved by science". [26] [27]
In February 2016,he publicly asked "How is national debt different from national deficit?" on Twitter,prompting The Spectator to say that he "appears to lack a basic understanding of finance". [28] [29]
In January 2017,he tweeted in the context of a second independence referendum that "Girls don't always say yes first time",leading to criticism that his comments were sexist and trivialised "rape culture" by Scottish Labour leader Kezia Dugdale,the Scottish Conservatives and the President of NUS Scotland,Vonnie Sandlan. Mason defended his comment as innocent and reflected the fact that "asking a girl for a relationship or to dinner,they don't always say yes the first time." [30] [31]
In February 2017,The First Minister of Scotland,Nicola Sturgeon apologised to the families of three Scottish IRA murder victims after Mason had claimed members of the terrorist organisation could be considered freedom fighters. Mason apologised for his comments after a meeting with the SNP's Scottish Parliament chief whip Bill Kidd. [32] [33]
In June 2017 Mason tweeted that,“learning times tables and spelling [were] stronger in my day but we have moved on”. [34] He also wrote that,“Of course,reading and writing are very important. But if someone is a good surgeon and cannot spell,is that a problem?”and “What level of literacy is needed to have an IT career?” [22] During a session of First Minister's Questions,Scottish Conservative leader Ruth Davidson asked Nicola Sturgeon whether she agreed with Mason;the First Minister declined to endorse his comments. [35] [22]
In May 2018,Mason was criticised for comparing the child sexual abuse by former Celtic Boys Club employees to tax avoidance schemes. Mason defended his comments. [36]
Also in May 2018,Mason was contacted by a wheelchair user with concerns about the lack of accessibility to Celtic football club's stadium. [37] Mason suggested that the fan support another team,a comment described as "outrageous" by Labour MSP James Kelly. [38]
In June 2018 Mason responded to an email from a constituent that he did not agree with retrospective pardons for gay men convicted of having consensual sex before decriminalisation. He wrote,"I do not see that we can go round pardoning and apologising for everything that other people did that does not conform to modern customs. Will the Italians be apologising for the Roman occupation?" [39] Mason was criticised for his "flippant tone". [39]
In November 2018 he wrote a letter to The Herald newspaper to complain that transgender people "override science". [24]
In September 2019,he tabled a motion called "Both Lives Matter",which called for abortion to be restricted. [40]
In March 2020,he came under criticism for refusing to follow Scottish Government advice and keeping his parliamentary office open to the public during the COVID-19 pandemic. [41] Fergus Mutch,a former SNP press officer,said of the controversy,"When I ran the SNP press office,I often felt I was defending the indefensible with John Mason. In the past,however,he’s only brought the party into disrepute. This time he’s risking lives. Typically stubborn and deeply arrogant.” [42]
In May 2020,he came under fire for proposing a motion that the Scottish Parliament should "recognise the sacrifices" the armed forces make,the Parliament should "believe that some people use Armed Forces' Day to celebrate military might and power for the promotion of what considers to be an unhealthy British nationalism". Leading to criticism from opposition parties that it was "deeply disrespectful" to the armed forces. Mason defending his proposed motion stating:"I think my motion is clear in that I fully support the armed forces and am happy that we celebrate them." [43]
In 2021,amid reports of a cleansing and vermin crisis in Glasgow,Labour MSP Pam Duncan-Glancy told Holyrood that there were even rats in her flat. [44] Mason heckled her that,"There are rats in every street." [45]
In October 2021,Mason received cross-party criticism for attending an anti-abortion protest outside the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow,for claiming that abortion services were rarely 'vital' and alleging that some women are 'coerced' into having abortions. [46] In September 2022 it was reported that Mason was disciplined by the SNP for defending the anti-abortion protests and "causing distress and trauma to women in the way he expressed his views on abortion rights" [47]
In January 2022 Mason referred to trans women as "people whose biological sex is male" and suggested that those convicted of crimes should serve their sentences in male prisons. Mason's remark was denounced as a "very shrill anti-trans dog whistle". [48]
In May 2022,Mason tweeted that abortion clinics "push abortions without laying out the pros and cons". [49] In June 2022,Mason told a constituent that he was "pretty positive" about the overruling of Roe v. Wade and the end of US-wide abortion rights. In response Scottish Government Minister for Women's Health,Maree Todd MSP wrote,"For the avoidance of doubt:There is nothing positive about the recent US court ruling. Abortion has been legal in Scotland for over 50 years." And Scottish Labour Women’s Health spokesperson,Carol Mochan,said:“It is sickening to see an SNP MSP gloating as millions of women losing access to vital healthcare." [50] Also,in June 2022,Mason described abortion clinics as "conveyor belts". [51]
In October 2022,Mason was criticised by Labour MSP Paul Sweeney for his "insulting" response to a Glasgow-based homeless charity. Homeless Project Scotland had contacted Mason among several politicians looking for support for a safe indoor space to aid them during the winter months,Mason instead criticised the charity’s finances and asked them to "rent a building" instead of seeking assistance from local government,the charity accused Mason of continuing to "blast our charity" and claimed Mason had never responded to requests to visit them. [52]
In March 2023,Mason was accused of 'hijacking' plans for a Scottish baby loss memorial book to further his anti-abortion agenda. He had tabled a motion in parliament welcoming the proposal but called for "more equality for all unborn babies in the future”and compared miscarriage and premature death to abortion. Labour's Monica Lennon said Mr Mason was trying to "undermine abortion rights." Lennon said “Anti-choice campaigners will take every opportunity to undermine abortion rights,and this parliamentary motion from the SNP’s John Mason is the latest example. [53]
In April 2023,Mason was spotted at an SPUC anti-abortion protest in Edinburgh. Lucy Grieve,co-founder of Back Off Scotland said it was “completely inappropriate”that Mason retains the SNP party whip. [54] Mason was interviewed by SPUC at the protest and appeared to admit to having attended another anti-abortion protest in Glasgow "I would have to say I also visited outside the Queen Elizabeth Hospital,I was at the pro-life vigil during the 40 days,and yet again,very quiet,very peaceful. So the idea that we need legislation to restrict demonstrations like this or vigils like this is just absolute nonsense". [55] The legislation Mason is referring to is Gillian Mackay's private members bill to introduce safe access zones around hospitals and clinics providing abortion services
In August 2024,Mason had the SNP whip suspended after claiming that if Israel wanted to commit genocide in the wake of October 7th,it would have killed ten times as many civilians. A spokesperson for the SNP said,"To flippantly dismiss the death of more than 40,000 Palestinians is completely unacceptable. There can be no room in the SNP for this kind of intolerance." [56]
On 13 October 2024,it was announced that Mason had been expelled from the SNP. [57] He has been given 21 days to appeal.
