Mantineia Base

Last updated
Three muses (NAMA 215) NAMA 3 Muses.jpg
Three muses (NAMA 215)
From left to rightL Apollo, a servant in Scythian dress, and Marsyas (NAMA 216) Apollon & Marsyas.jpg
From left to rightL Apollo, a servant in Scythian dress, and Marsyas (NAMA 216)
Three muses (NAMA 217) MANA 217 Mantineia base.JPG
Three muses (NAMA 217)

The Mantineia Base is an ensemble of three ancient Greek bas relief plaques, one of which depicts Apollo, Marsyas, and a slave, and the other two of which each show a group of three Muses. They were discovered in 1887 on the site of the ancient Gree city of Mantineia in Arcadia and were probably decoration for a statue base. They have been attributed to the sculptor Praxiteles or another member of his workshop. They are currently kept in the National Archaeological Museum of Athens, where their inventory numbers are NAMA 215–217.

Contents

Description

On 11 August 1887 in the course of excavations at Mantineia by the French School at Athens, the archaeologist Gustave Fougères discovered the three plaques, which had been reused in the floor of a Byzantine church. [1] The upper part had been heavily worn by the passage of the parishioners, but the side facing downwards still bore sculpted decoration in a good state. The plaques were immediately transferred to the National Archaeological Museum of Athens, where they were restored. [1]

They are made of white marble, which was once identified as the marble of Doliana, near Tegea, [1] but is now recognised to be Pentelic marble. [2] The three plaques have very similar dimensions: NAMA 216 is 1.35 m wide and 0.96 m high; NAMA 215 and 217 are 1.36 m by 0.96 m and 0.98 m respectively. [1] Their depth varies from 8 to 12 cm. [1] They are decorated in the same way: on the upper part, an Echinus moulding above a broad flat band, on the lower edge there is a concave moulding and another broad flat band. Each panel has three attachment holes in the same locations. These aspects indicate that they were all made together. [3]

Each plaque depicts three figures on a blank background. They are juxtaposed simply, without any complicated compositional features. [4]

Apollo and Marsyas (NAMA 216)

At left, the god Apollo is represented seated, with long hair, wearing a chiton and himation, and holding a kithara in his left hand which rests on his left knee. With his right hand he grabs a fold in his himation. At right, Marsyas is shown with a beard, his left leg bent, playing the aulos (double flute). In the centre a bearded man is standing, wearing a kind of Phrygian cap, a chiton, and anaxyrides (trousers), holding a knife in one hand. Based on the identifications of the other two figures, he must be the servant who flays Marsyas after he loses his musical contest against Apollo.

Muses (NAMA 215 and 217)

The other two plaques represent the Muses, who, in some versions of the myth of Marsyas, were the judges of the contest. [5] The Muses are differentiated. On NAMA 215, the one on the left holds an aulos, the one in the centre holds the folds of her himation, and the one on the right is seated and plays a little string instrument – perhaps a bandora. [2] On NAMA 217, the left Muse holds some unrolled parchment, the central Muse holds a rolled-up scroll in her left hand, and the right Muse holds up a kithara in her right hand. Canonically, there were nine Muses, so presumably there was a fourth plaque depicting the missing three Muses. [3]

Attribution

When he published the discovery, Fougères suggested that the three plaques decorated the sides of a rectangular pedestal and suggested that they be associated with a passage of Pausanias who mentions in his description of Mantineia, "a sanctuary of Leto and her children; it was Praxiteles who made the statues, two generations after Alcamenes; on their base there are carvings of a Muse and a Marsyas playing the aulos." [6]

This text which has been transmitted mentions only a single Muse and presents a difficulty in that while representations of Marsyas playing the flute with a single Maenad are common, there are no known representations of Marsyas playing the flute with a single Muse. [7] To resolve the problem, it has been suggested that Pausanias, whose descriptions are often very vague, was confused and has mistaken Apollo for a Muse. Fougères proposed to emend Μοῦσα (Muse) to Μοῦσαι (Muses), a correction which has been widely accepted since. [2]

Hypothetical reconstruction of the plaques in order to force them to match Pausanias' description. Mantineia Base.JPG
Hypothetical reconstruction of the plaques in order to force them to match Pausanias' description.

The main objection to this hypothesis concerns the proposed arrangement of the base, with the plaque of Apollo and Marsyas on the front, the plaques of the Muses on the sides. [3] This would create a base measuring 1.36 x 1.36 metres, which would be too small for the three statues that Pausanias mentions. [8] The three plaques could instead be arranged next to one another, with Apollo and Marsyas in the centre and the Muses on either side, but there are no traces of attachments for connecting the plaques on their sides, which argues against this hypothesis. [9] It has been proposed to see the plaques as the decoration for a platform for the competitors of a musical contest which took place every year in Arcadia according to Polybius. [10] Indeed, one of the heads of the Muses of NAMA 217 was recovered from the ruins of the theatre. [11] However, this reconstruction is not supported by any archaeological evidence. [12]

Related Research Articles

<i>Venus de Milo</i> Ancient Greek marble statue of the goddess Aphrodite

The Venus de Milo or Aphrodite of Melos is an ancient Greek marble sculpture that was created during the Hellenistic period. Its exact dating is uncertain, but the modern consensus places it in the 2nd century BC, perhaps between 160 and 110 BC. It was rediscovered in 1820 on the island of Milos, Greece, and has been displayed at the Louvre Museum since 1821. Since the statue's discovery, it had become one of the most famous works of ancient Greek sculpture in the world.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Marsyas</span> Satyr musician in Greek mythology

In Greek mythology, the satyr Marsyas is a central figure in two stories involving music: in one, he picked up the double oboe (aulos) that had been abandoned by Athena and played it; in the other, he challenged Apollo to a contest of music and lost his hide and life. In antiquity, literary sources often emphasize the hubris of Marsyas and the justice of his punishment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Praxiteles</span> 4th-century BC Athenian sculptor

Praxiteles of Athens, the son of Cephisodotus the Elder, was the most renowned of the Attica sculptors of the 4th century BC. He was the first to sculpt the nude female form in a life-size statue. While no indubitably attributable sculpture by Praxiteles is extant, numerous copies of his works have survived; several authors, including Pliny the Elder, wrote of his works; and coins engraved with silhouettes of his various famous statuary types from the period still exist.

Myron of Eleutherae was an Athenian sculptor from the mid-5th century BC. He was born in Eleutherae on the borders of Boeotia and Attica. According to Natural History, a Latin encyclopedia by Pliny the Elder, a scholar in Ancient Rome, Ageladas of Argos was his teacher.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mantineia</span> Municipal unit in Greece; ancient city in Arcadia, Greece

Mantineia was a city in ancient Arcadia, Greece, which was the site of two significant battles in Classical Greek history.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lyceus</span>

The Apollo Lyceus type, also known as Lycean Apollo, originating with Praxiteles and known from many full-size statue and figurine copies as well as from 1st century BCE Athenian coinage, is a statue type of Apollo showing the god resting on a support, his right forearm touching the top of his head and his hair fixed in braids on the top of a head in a haircut typical of childhood. It is called "Lycean" not after Lycia itself, but after its identification with a lost work described, though not attributed to a sculptor, by Lucian as being on show in the Lyceum, one of the gymnasia of Athens. According to Lucian, the god leaning on a support with his bow in his left hand and his right resting on his head is shown "as if resting after long effort." Its main exemplar is the Apollino in Florence or Apollo Medici, in the Uffizi, Florence.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aulos</span> Ancient Greek wind instrument

An aulos or tibia (Latin) was a wind instrument in ancient Greece, often depicted in art and also attested by archaeology.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hermes (Museo Pio-Clementino)</span>

The Hermes of the Museo Pio-Clementino is an ancient Roman sculpture, part of the Vatican collections, Rome. It was long admired as the Belvedere Antinous, named from its prominent placement in the Cortile del Belvedere. It is now inventory number 907 in the Museo Pio-Clementino.

<i>Venus of Arles</i> Sculpture of Venus at Musée du Louvre

The Venus of Arles is a 1.94-metre-high (6.4 ft) sculpture of Venus at the Musée du Louvre. It is in Hymettus marble and dates to the end of the 1st century BC.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Temple of Apollo Patroos</span>

The Temple of Apollo Patroos is a small ruined temple on the west side of the Ancient Agora of Athens. The original temple was an apsidal structure, built in the mid-sixth century BC and destroyed in 480/79 BC. The area probably remained sacred to Apollo. A new hexastyle ionic temple was built ca. 306-300 BC, which has an unusual L-shaped floor plan. Some fragments from the sculptural decoration of this structure survive. The colossal cult statue, by Euphranor, has also been recovered.

Brunilde Sismondo Ridgway is an Italian archaeologist and specialist in ancient Greek sculpture.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kithara</span> Ancient Greek musical instrument

The kithara, or Latinized cithara, was an ancient Greek musical instrument in the yoke lutes family. It was a seven-stringed professional version of the lyre, which was regarded as a rustic, or folk instrument, appropriate for teaching music to beginners. As opposed to the simpler lyre, the cithara was primarily used by professional musicians, called kitharodes. In modern Greek, the word kithara has come to mean "guitar", a word which etymologically stems from kithara.

<i>Hermes and the Infant Dionysus</i> Ancient Greek sculpture

Hermes and the Infant Dionysus, also known as the Hermes of Praxiteles or the Hermes of Olympia is an ancient Greek sculpture of Hermes and the infant Dionysus discovered in 1877 in the ruins of the Temple of Hera, Olympia, in Greece. It is displayed at the Archaeological Museum of Olympia.

<i>Diana of Gabii</i> Statue at the Louvre in Paris

The Diana of Gabii is a statue of a woman in drapery which probably represents the goddess Artemis and is traditionally attributed to the sculptor Praxiteles. It became part of the Borghese collection and is now conserved in the Louvre with the inventory number Ma 529.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Despinis Head</span>

The Despinis Head is part of a colossal ancient Greek sculpture, depicting a female head, which was conserved in the store rooms of the Archaeological Museum of the Ancient Agora in Athens until recently. According to George Despinis, director of the museum, it was originally part of the statue of Artemis Brauronia carved by Praxiteles.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dancers of Delphi</span> Greek sculpture

The Dancers of Delphi, also known as the Acanthus Column, are three figures in high relief on top of an acanthus column found near the sanctuary of Pythian Apollo at Delphi. They are on display in the Delphi Archaeological Museum and were the inspiration for the first of Claude Debussy's Préludes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Head of Arles</span> Roman copy of 4th-century BC sculpture

The Head of Arles, formerly known also as the Head of Livia or the Head with the broken nose is a fragment of a Roman marble statue in two parts, of which only the bust remains, which probably depicts Venus (Aphrodite) and was discovered in the ruins of the Ancient Theatre of Arles in 1823 during the removal of accreted material from the theatre. The Head of Arles represents an iconographic type called Aspremont-Lynden/Arles. It is now part of the permanent exhibition of the Musée de l'Arles et de la Provence antiques with the inventory number FAN.92.00.405.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pediments of the Parthenon</span>

The pediments of the Parthenon are the two sets of statues in Pentelic marble originally located as the pedimental sculpture on the east and west facades of the Parthenon on the Acropolis of Athens. They were probably made by several artists, including Agoracritos. The master builder was probably Phidias. They were probably lifted into place by 432 BC, having been carved on the ground.

<i>Apollo and Daphnis</i> Painting by Pietro Perugino

Apollo and Daphnis is a c.1483 mythological painting by Perugino. It was sold to the Louvre in Paris in 1883, where it still hangs and in whose catalogue it was known as Apollo and Marsyas. By the 1880s it had become misattributed to Raphael.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Athena Marsyas Group</span> Sculpture by Myron

The Athena Marsyas Group was a bronze sculptural group by Myron that stood on the Acropolis of Athens in the high classical period, dated to c 450 BCE. Now lost, it has been reconstructed from copies, coins, other visual sources and literary testimonia. The work depicted the satyr Marsyas picking up an aulos dropped by Athena.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Fougères, p. 105.
  2. 1 2 3 Pasquier, p. 110.
  3. 1 2 3 Fougères, p. 106.
  4. Rolley, p. 254.
  5. e.g HygFab (165.4) and Libanios (14).
  6. PauDes (8.9.1). Marion Muller-Dufeu, La Sculpture grecque. Sources littéraires et épigraphiques, Paris, éditions de l'École nationale supérieure des Beaux-Arts, coll. « Beaux-Arts histoire », 2002 ( ISBN   2-84056-087-9), no 1394, p. 485.
  7. Fougères, p. 107.
  8. Johannes Overbeck, Berichte der Koniglich Sachsischen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften, 1888, p. 184ff.
  9. Ridgway [1997], p. 206.
  10. Polybius 4.20.9.
  11. Johannes N. Svoronos, Das Athener Nationalmuseum, vol. I, Beck und Barth, Athènes, 1908 (German translation of the Greek original of 1903), p. 192.
  12. Ridgway [1997], p. 207 ; Pasquier, p. 111.

Bibliography