Margaret Barclay

Last updated

Margaret Barclay
Died2 June 1618
Known foraccused witch

Margaret Barclay (died 1618), was an accused witch put on trial in 1618, 'gently' tortured, confessed and was strangled and burned at the stake in Irvine, Scotland. [1] Her case was written about with horror ( Letters on Demonology and Witchcraft , 1830) by the romantic novelist Sir Walter Scott, [1] and in the 21st century, a campaign for a memorial in the town and for a pardon for Barclay and other accused witches was raised in the Scottish Parliament. [2] [3]

Contents

Family life

Margaret Barclay was married to Alexander Dein, a burgess and merchant in the town or Irvine, Ayrshire. [4] She was known to have a 'fiery temper' and poor relationships with her husband's family. [5] She had a daughter, Isobel Insch, [6] and said to have had a servant. [2]

Trial for witchcraft

Witch burning etching Witch Burning.jpg
Witch burning etching

Margaret Barclay was accused of being the leader of a witches' coven [7] by her sister-in-law and others, involved in cursing the Irvine ship The Gift of God [4] and causing it to sink near Cornwall, killing all on board, including the owner and skipper, her brother-in-law John Dein and the town Provost Andrew Tran. [1]

Others accused in this trial on 2 June 1618, [4] Isobel Inch her daughter, and John Stewart were tortured and they accused Barclay of cursing the ship and devil worship. [6] However, before the trial they had both died, possibly at their own hand, e.g. Isobel Inch fell from the prison belfry and John Stewart committed suicide by hanging, but another co-accused, Isobel Crawford, received the same treatment and execution as Barclay. [1] John Stewart was an intinerant juggler and had stated under torture that he had heard Barclay curse the ship and make clay effigies of Tran and others and place them in the sea, and Isobel Insch concurred after torture and referred to a 'black dog' as the devil. [1] [6] One piece of evidence of witchcraft against Barclay was that she 'carried a piece of rowan tree and coloured thread' to make her cow produce milk. [1]

Barclay was subjected to what was called a 'gentle' or 'tender' torture to elicit confessions, namely increasing weights placed on her outstretched legs held in iron stocks. Once the pain became unbearable, she confessed: the weights had reached thirty stone (190 kg, or 420 lbs). She was taken to trial, where she then proceeded to deny her guilt, saying “All I have confessed was in agony of torture , and before God, all I have spoken is false and untrue.” [1] She was strangled and burned at the stake as her punishment. [1]

Reaction over centuries

Letters on Demonology and Witchcraft Demonology Walter Scott.jpg
Letters on Demonology and Witchcraft
Display of Margaret Barclay in Witches in Word, Not Deed by Carolyn Sutton at Edinburgh Central Library 2023 Witches in Word, Not Deed by Carolyn Sutton at Edinburgh Central Library. November 2023. Margaret Barclay.jpg
Display of Margaret Barclay in Witches in Word, Not Deed by Carolyn Sutton at Edinburgh Central Library 2023

Barclay's case highlighted cruelty and unreliability of evidence under torture, and her case was still referred to centuries later. After describing the trial and so-called evidence in detail in 1830, Sir Walter Scott wrote

"It is scarce possible that, after reading such a story, a man of sense can listen for an instant to the evidence founded on confessions thus obtained, which has been almost the sole reason by which a few individuals, even in modern times, have endeavoured to justify a belief in the existence of witchcraft.” [1]

Barclay's case was described in modern times as 'merciless justice' in an article about persecuted Scots emigrating to Northern Ireland in the 17th century, as Barclay could not escape her accusers. [8] A local historian started a campaign, four centuries later, for a memorial to her to be placed in the town. [2] The Ayrshire MSP, Ruth Maguire raised a 2018 motion in the Scottish Parliament for memorials to be raised to Barclay and to the thousands of others who were tortured and killed in the Scottish Witch Trials. [2]

In 2021, a wider petition was raised up to right a 'miscarriage of justice' and pardon the accused witches, like Barclay, in Scotland, [3] and their case is being pursued by Claire Mitchell, QC. [9]


In 2023, Barclay was one of thirteen accused witches included in a display Witches in Word, Not Deed by Carolyn Sutton, exhibited in the Edinburgh Central Library. [10]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Isobel Gowdie</span> Scottish woman who confessed to witchcraft at Auldearn near Nairn during 1662

Isobel Gowdie was a Scottish woman who confessed to witchcraft at Auldearn near Nairn during 1662. Scant information is available about her age or life and, although she was probably executed in line with the usual practice, it is uncertain whether this was the case or if she was allowed to return to the obscurity of her former life as a cottar’s wife. Her detailed testimony, apparently achieved without the use of violent torture, provides one of the most comprehensive insights into European witchcraft folklore at the end of the era of witch-hunts.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">North Berwick witch trials</span> Scottish witch trials in 1590

The North Berwick witch trials were the trials in 1590 of a number of people from East Lothian, Scotland, accused of witchcraft in the St Andrew's Auld Kirk in North Berwick on Halloween night. They ran for two years, and implicated over 70 people. These included Francis Stewart, 5th Earl of Bothwell, on charges of high treason.

The witch trials of Vardø were held in Vardø in Finnmark in Northern Norway in the winter of 1662–1663 and were one of the biggest in Scandinavia. Thirty women were put on trial, accused of sorcery and making pacts with the Devil. One was sentenced to a work house, two tortured to death, and eighteen were burned alive at the stake.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pendle witches</span> English witch hunt and trial in 1612

The trials of the Pendle witches in 1612 are among the most famous witch trials in English history, and some of the best recorded of the 17th century. The twelve accused lived in the area surrounding Pendle Hill in Lancashire, and were charged with the murders of ten people by the use of witchcraft. All but two were tried at Lancaster Assizes on 18–19 August 1612, along with the Samlesbury witches and others, in a series of trials that have become known as the Lancashire witch trials. One was tried at York Assizes on 27 July 1612, and another died in prison. Of the eleven who went to trial – nine women and two men – ten were found guilty and executed by hanging; one was found not guilty.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paisley witches</span> 1697 witch trial

The Paisley witches, also known as the Bargarran witches or the Renfrewshire witches, were tried in Paisley, Renfrewshire, central Scotland, in 1697. Eleven-year-old Christian Shaw, daughter of the Laird of Bargarran, complained of being tormented by some local witches; they included one of her family's servants, Catherine Campbell, whom she had reported to her mother after witnessing her steal a drink of milk.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Witch trials in early modern Scotland</span>

In early modern Scotland, in between the early 16th century and the mid-18th century, judicial proceedings concerned with the crimes of witchcraft took place as part of a series of witch trials in Early Modern Europe. In the late middle age there were a handful of prosecutions for harm done through witchcraft, but the passing of the Witchcraft Act 1563 made witchcraft, or consulting with witches, capital crimes. The first major issue of trials under the new act were the North Berwick witch trials, beginning in 1590, in which King James VI played a major part as "victim" and investigator. He became interested in witchcraft and published a defence of witch-hunting in the Daemonologie in 1597, but he appears to have become increasingly sceptical and eventually took steps to limit prosecutions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Allison Balfour</span> Scottish witch

The 1594 trial of alleged witch Allison Balfour or Margaret Balfour is one of the most frequently cited Scottish witchcraft cases. Balfour lived in the Orkney Islands of Scotland in the area of Stenness. At that time in Scotland, the Scottish Witchcraft Act 1563 had made a conviction for witchcraft punishable by death.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Witchcraft in Orkney</span> Overview of witch persecution in Orkney, Scotland

Witchcraft in Orkney possibly has its roots in the settlement of Norsemen on the archipelago from the eighth century onwards. Until the early modern period magical powers were accepted as part of the general lifestyle, but witch-hunts began on the mainland of Scotland in about 1550, and the Scottish Witchcraft Act of 1563 made witchcraft or consultation with witches a crime punishable by death. One of the first Orcadians tried and executed for witchcraft was Allison Balfour, in 1594. Balfour, her elderly husband and two young children, were subjected to severe torture for two days to elicit a confession from her.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pittenweem witches</span>

The Pittenweem witches were five Scottish women accused of witchcraft in the small fishing village of Pittenweem in Fife on the east coast of Scotland in 1704. Another two women and a man were named as accomplices. Accusations made by a teenage boy, Patrick Morton, against a local woman, Beatrix Layng, led to the death in prison of Thomas Brown, and, in January 1705, the murder of Janet Cornfoot by a lynch mob in the village.

The Terrassa witch trials took place in Terrassa, then in the Principality of Catalonia, Spain between 1615 and 1619. Six women of the city of Terrassa were accused of witchcraft and sentenced to death on 27 October 1619.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Margaret Aitken (witch)</span>

Margaret Aitken, known as the Great Witch of Balwearie, was an important figure in the great Scottish witchcraft panic of 1597 as her actions effectively led to an end of that series of witch trials. After being accused of witchcraft Aitken confessed but then identified hundreds of women as other witches to save her own life. She was exposed as a fraud a few months later and was burnt at the stake.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bute witches</span>

The Bute witches were six Scottish women accused of witchcraft and interrogated in the parish of Rothesay on Bute during the Great Scottish Witch Hunt of 1661–62. The Privy Council granted a Commission of Justiciary for a local trial to be held and four of the women – believed by historians to be Margaret McLevin, Margaret McWilliam, Janet Morrison and Isobell McNicoll – were executed in 1662; a fifth may have died while incarcerated. One woman, Jonet NcNicoll, escaped from prison before she could be executed but when she returned to the island in 1673 the sentence was implemented.

Marie Lamont, also referred to as Mary Lawmont (1646–1662), was executed for witchcraft during the reign of Charles II just after Witchmania had peaked in the United Kingdom. Her youth at the time of her execution made her case unusual.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Beatrix Leslie</span> Scottish midwife executed for witchcraft

Beatrix Leslie was a Scottish midwife executed for witchcraft. In 1661 she was accused of causing the collapse of a coal pit through witchcraft. Little is known about her life before that, although there are reported disputes with neighbours that allude to a quarrelsome attitude.

The witch trials in Connecticut, also sometimes referred to as the Hartford witch trials, occurred from 1647 to 1663. They were the first large-scale witch trials in the American colonies, predating the Salem Witch Trials by nearly thirty years. John M. Taylor lists a total of 37 cases, 11 of which resulted in executions. The execution of Alse Young of Windsor in the spring of 1647 was the beginning of the witch panic in the area, which would not come to an end until 1670 with the release of Katherine Harrison.

Unlike neighboring England and Scotland, there were few witchcraft accusations and trials in Wales throughout the 1500s to mid-1700s, and most of the accused were acquitted. Only five people were executed in Wales for witchcraft during this period.

The Witches of Bo'ness were a group of women accused of witchcraft in Bo'ness, Scotland in the late 17th century and ultimately executed for this crime. Among the more famous cases noted by historians, in 1679, Margaret Pringle, Bessie Vickar, Annaple Thomsone, and two women both called Margaret Hamilton were all accused of being witches, alongside "warlock" William Craw. The case of these six was "one of the last multiple trials to take place for witchcraft" in Scotland.

The Fife Witches Trail is a series of plaques located along the Fife Coastal Path, commemorating the women executed as witches there in the 16th to 18th centuries. The plaques are located in the villages of Culross, Valleyfield and Torryburn.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Windsor Witches</span>

The Windsor Witches was the common name for a witch trial in Windsor and Abingdon in England in 1579. The name referred to the four women tried and executed for sorcery: the cunning woman Mother Elizabeth Stile, Mother Devell, Mother Dutten and Mother Margaret.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Margaret Duchill</span> Scottish woman executed for witchcraft in 1658

Margaret Duchill was a Scottish woman who confessed to witchcraft at Alloa during the year 1658. She was implicated by others and she named other women. She was executed on 1 June 1658.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 "The Irvine Witch Trial of 1618". Irvine Scotland. 13 September 2016. Retrieved 29 October 2021.
  2. 1 2 3 4 Hodge, Lisa (9 February 2018). "Memorial plea for Irvine 'witch' Margaret Barclay". Irvine Times. Retrieved 29 October 2021.
  3. 1 2 "Scottish Parliament asked to right 'terrible miscarriage of justice' by pardoning thousands of witches". www.scotsman.com. Retrieved 29 October 2021.
  4. 1 2 3 Goodare, Julian; Yeoman, Louise; Martin, Lauren; Miller, Joyce (2010). "Survey Database, Survey of Scottish Witchcraft - Margaret Barclay (2-6-1618)". witches.shca.ed.ac.uk. doi:10.7488/ds/100 . Retrieved 29 October 2021.
  5. McKim, Clair (5 October 2015). "Five of Scotland's infamous witchcraft trials". www.scotsman.com. Retrieved 29 October 2021.
  6. 1 2 3 "Scottish Witchcraft". TheFreeDictionary.com. Retrieved 29 October 2021.
  7. Marini, Gianni (31 October 2020). "Torture of Ayrshire's 'witches' revealed". Ayr Advertiser. Retrieved 29 October 2021.
  8. "BBC - Legacies - Immigration and Emigration - Northern Ireland - Plantation - Planters, chiefs and hollowed out cheese - Article Page 1". www.bbc.co.uk. Retrieved 29 October 2021.
  9. "Claire Mitchell QC seeks posthumous justice for Scotland's 'witches'". Scottish Legal News. 9 March 2020. Retrieved 29 October 2021.
  10. edinburghcitylibraries (20 September 2023). "Witches in Word, not Deed – an exhibition at Central Library until 30 November 2023". Tales of One City. Retrieved 24 November 2023.