United States of America v. The Spy Factory, Inc. d/b/a "Spy Factory", Ronald Kimball, Marlin Richardson, a/k/a "Brud", and Tracy Edward Ford
Decided
July 31, 1997, August 1, 1997, August 1, 1997 & August 29, 1997 (judgments) January 7, 1997 as amended February 6, 1997 (regarding motion to dismiss for vagueness and to change venue) March 11, 1997 (regarding motion to reconsider vagueness, to sever defendants, etc.)
18 U.S.C. § 2512, which prohibits the knowing manufacture, assembly, possession, sale, transmission (by mail or interstate commerce) or advertisement of devices "primarily useful for the purpose of the surreptitious interception of wire, oral, or electronic communications", is not unconstitutionally vague.[1][2][Note 1]
United States v. Spy Factory, Inc.[Note 2] was a criminal case dealing with the largest chain of surveillance equipment shops in the United States, the San Antonio, Texas-based Spy Factory.[3] The store and its officers Ronald Kimball, Marlin Richardson and Tracy Edward Ford were indicted on a total of 70 counts related to smuggling of and illegal trade in equipment used for wiretapping and surveillance.[4][5] Despite motions to dismiss the case because of the alleged vagueness of 18U.S.C.§2512 and other issues,[1][2] the company and all three officers pleaded guilty and were convicted.[4]
The Spy Factory, Inc. was the largest chain of surveillance equipment stores (colloquially, spy shops) in the United States, with outlets in Arizona, California, Colorado, Georgia, Illinois, Missouri, Nevada, Texas, Utah and Washington.[3][6][Note 3]
The company was owned by Ronald Kimball, a former federal agent who worked for the United States Department of Justice in Ecuador and Costa Rica, and also a purveyor of bullet-proof vehicles through his other business, Executive Armoring.[12]
According to Kimball, "[c]orporate executives and political figures in Mexico and Latin America" were the Spy Factory's first customers; "[t]hen orders started coming in from the Middle East", and by 1991, the company did about 90% of its business overseas.[12]
Customs raids
On April 5, 1995, agents of the United States Customs Service raided surveillance equipment stores in 24 cities across the country.[8] These raids took place following a 17-month investigation into the smuggling of electronic surveillance equipment, and involved the execution of search warrants at 40 stores.[8]
Indictments
On August 21, 1995, federal indictments were issued for three The Spy Factory, Inc. executives, as well as for the company itself.[4][13] Ronald Kimball, the owner, was arrested that day in San Antonio.[4][13] The next day, the deputy general manager, Tracy Edward Ford, was also arrested in San Antonio.[4][13] Marlin Richardson, the general manager, had already been arrested the previous April.[13]
The initial indictment contained eight counts per defendant, charging that the Spy Factory was involved in the illegal trafficking of more than US$1.5 million of wiretapping devices from Tokyo-based Micro Electronics.[13] The scheme involved the supplier creating duplicate invoices: an accurate one was sent to Spy Factory headquarters, while a falsified invoice (with prices marked down by as much as 90%) was sent with the goods to avoid full payment of customs duties.[13]
Since the government alleged that conspiracy, smuggling, possession and sale of illegal devices had taken place, the defendants were liable to serve five years' imprisonment per charge.[13] Additionally, the government sought forfeiture of at least US$1.5 million in proceeds.[13]
On July 11, 1996, the government entered a superseding indictment that replaced the original allegations with 70 counts.[4] The Spy Factory, Inc. was charged with all but count 69, Kimball and Richardson with all but count 68, and Ford with counts 1, 13–16, 28–31, 43–47, 62–67 and 69–70.[4]
After a change in his counsel, defendant Ford moved for reconsideration of the vagueness argument, and simultaneously asked to be tried separately (severance), requested additional discovery, asked to inspect the grand juryminutes and requested that the government specify the charges in more detail (with a bill of particulars).[2] Sotomayor decided that severance would be wasteful of judicial resources, that further discovery and inspection of grand jury minutes were unnecessary and the government had "more than adequately apprise[d] the defendant of the nature of the charge[s] against him".[2]
Following the failure of both motions, all defendants pleaded guilty to a subset of the charges in July and August 1997, and were variously ordered to pay fines, make restitution, serve home confinement and/or be imprisoned.[4] The Spy Factory itself pleaded guilty to all 69 counts against it, and was sentenced to pay a special assessment of US$13,400 and a fine of US$1, due immediately.[4]
Ronald Kimball pleaded guilty to three counts,[Note 4] telling Sotomayor "I accept full responsibility for my conduct",[14] and was sentenced to 51 months' imprisonment.[4][6] He was ordered to forfeit US$2.3 million, the value of the proceeds from the sale of illegal equipment.[6] As part of his plea agreement, Kimball relinquished all of the company's assets to the government, and agreed to close all of the stores.[14] In response, federal agents entered Spy Factory locations and confiscated the contents and the premises.[5] Marlin Richardson pleaded guilty to the same three counts as Kimball, and was sentenced to 46 months' imprisonment.[4] Kimball and Richardson were ordered to pay special assessments of US$150 each.[4]
Tracy Edward Ford also pleaded guilty[Note 5] and was sentenced to 36 months' probation with 6 months' home confinement.[4][6] Ford was prohibited from selling electronic devices while on probation,[6] and was ordered to pay a special assessment of US$100.[4]
18 U.S.C. § 2512
18U.S.C.§2512 provides criminal penalties for the manufacture, assembly, possession, sale, transmission (by mail or interstate commerce) or advertisement of surveillance equipment, subject to certain exceptions for governments and communication service providers. Anyone intentionally engaging in the foregoing prohibited conduct, with knowledge (or reason to have knowledge) that the devices are "primarily useful for the purpose of the surreptitious interception of wire, oral, or electronic communications", is liable to be fined (pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 3571) and/or be imprisoned for up to five years.
In a Senate Judiciary Committee report describing this law, it was explained that this prohibition was intended to apply to "the martini olive transmitter, the spike mike, the infinity transmitter, and the microphone disguised as a wristwatch, picture frame, cuff link, tie clip, fountain pen, stapler, or cigarette pack."[15]:95 Similarly, it was intended to exclude things like parabolic microphones, which are not considered "primarily useful for surreptitious listening", because of their ordinary use in the broadcast coverage of sporting events.[15]:95
Notes
↑ Several other procedural issues were also resolved in the published opinions: the Southern District of New York is the appropriate venue, severance would be wasteful of judicial resources, additional discovery and inspection of grand juryminutes are unnecessary and the charges are already specified with sufficient particularity.
↑ Two opinions regarding procedural motions were published as 951 F.Supp. 450 (1997) and 960 F.Supp. 684 (1997). The judgments were not published.
↑ Kimball pleaded guilty to the 1st, 16th and 46th counts of the superseding indictment, namely conspiracy to defraud the United States, trafficking in wire interception devices (the 18 U.S.C. § 2512 issue argued earlier) and smuggling, respectively.[4]
↑ Ford pleaded guilty to the 15th and 16th counts of the superseding indictment, both related to trafficking in wire interception devices contrary to 18 U.S.C. § 2512.[4]
Related Research Articles
In legal terms, a plea is simply an answer to a claim made by someone in a criminal case under common law using the adversarial system. Colloquially, a plea has come to mean the assertion by a defendant at arraignment, or otherwise in response to a criminal charge, whether that person pleaded or pled guilty, not guilty, nolo contendere, no case to answer, or Alford plea.
The Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act is a United States federal law that provides for extended criminal penalties and a civil cause of action for acts performed as part of an ongoing criminal organization.
Operation Boptrot, also referred to as Boptrot, was an investigation by the United States Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) into corruption among the Kentucky General Assembly, the Commonwealth's legislature. The operation was highly successful, with the investigation culminating in several indictments in 1992, leading to the conviction of more than a dozen legislators between 1992 and 1995. The investigation also led to reform legislation being passed in 1993.
The Lawrence Franklin espionage scandal involved Lawrence Franklin passing classified documents regarding United States policy towards Iran to Israel. Franklin, a former United States Department of Defense employee, pleaded guilty to several espionage-related charges and was sentenced in January 2006 to nearly 13 years of prison, which was later reduced to ten months' house arrest. Franklin passed information to American Israel Public Affairs Committee policy director Steven Rosen and AIPAC senior Iran analyst Keith Weissman, who later were fired by AIPAC. They were later indicted for illegally conspiring to gather and disclose classified national security information to Israel. However, prosecutors later dropped all charges against them without any plea bargain.
October Martinique Lewis was a member of a terrorist group dubbed the Portland Seven, some members of which attempted to travel to Afghanistan shortly after 9/11 in order to aid the Taliban. Lewis was sentenced to three years in federal prison after cooperating with the government and pleading guilty to six counts of money laundering. Lewis admitted to transferring money abroad to Jeffrey Leon Battle, her ex-husband, in order to assist him in his efforts to aid the Taliban.
Operation Site Down is the umbrella name for a law enforcement initiative conducted by the United States' FBI and law enforcement agents from ten other countries which resulted in a raid on targets on June 29, 2005. Three separate undercover investigations were involved, based in Chicago, Charlotte and San Jose. The raid consisted of approximately 70 searches in the U.S. and approximately 20 others in ten other countries in an effort to disrupt and dismantle many of the leading Warez groups which distribute and trade in copyrighted software, movies, music and games on the Internet.
The Harrisburg Seven were a group of religious anti-war activists, led by Philip Berrigan, charged in 1971 in a failed conspiracy case in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania, located at Harrisburg. The seven were Phillip Berrigan, Elizabeth McAlister, Rev. Neil McLaughlin, Rev. Joseph Wenderoth, Eqbal Ahmad, Anthony Scoblick, and Mary Cain Scoblick.
The Lucchese crime family's New Jersey faction, also known as the Jersey Crew, is a powerful crew within the Lucchese crime family. The members operate throughout the Northern New Jersey area. During the 1970s into the late 1980s, the crew was led by Anthony Accetturo and his protégé Michael Taccetta. In 1987, Victor Amuso took over the family and began demanding a higher percentage of tribute from the crew. Accetturo refused and a war erupted between the New Jersey members and the New York members. This left brothers Michael and Martin Taccetta in charge of the crew as they tried to have Accetturo and his family murdered. In 1993, Accetturo defected and became a government witness. He helped convict Michael and Martin Taccetta. The crew was most recently controlled by Ralph Perna.
Tony Silva is an American aviculturist and ornithologist, and the author of books and articles about parrots. From 1989 to 1992, he was curator of birds at Loro Parque, the largest parrot park in the world. In 1996, he was convicted of conspiring to smuggle rare parrots into the United States and of tax evasion.
Hutaree was a militia movement group adhering to the ideology of the Christian Patriot movement, based near Adrian, Michigan, in the United States. The group formed in early 2006. The name "Hutaree" appears to be a neologism; the group's website says that the name means "Christian warriors", but an investigation by the FBI concluded the word does not have a Christian background. The group became widely known in 2010 after the United States FBI prosecuted them in federal court for an alleged plan for violent revolt. The prosecution said they intended to kill a police officer and to attack the funeral with bombs. The presiding judge dismissed these charges. Three members pleaded guilty to possessing a machine gun and were sentenced to time served.
United States v. Jackson, 390 U.S. 570 (1968), was a United States Supreme Court decision that ruled part of the Federal Kidnapping Act unconstitutional.
In United States v. Riggs, the government of the United States prosecuted Robert Riggs and Craig Neidorf for obtaining unauthorized access to and subsequently disseminating a file held on BellSouth's computers. The file, referred to as the E911 file, gave information regarding BellSouth's products implementing 911 emergency telephone services. Riggs and Neidorf were both indicted in the District Court of the Northern District of Illinois on numerous charges relating to the dissemination of the E911 text file. As Riggs had previously been indicted in the Northern District of Georgia in relation to the same incident, his charges from Illinois were transferred to Georgia. Riggs ultimately pleaded guilty in Georgia and was sentenced to 21 months in prison and two years' supervised release. Neidorf pleaded not guilty in Illinois and the government dropped all charges against Neidorf four days after the trial began.
Mohamad Anas Haitham Soueid is a Syrian-born naturalized United States citizen and a resident of Leesburg, Virginia who was indicted on espionage-related charges by federal prosecutors in October 2011. Soueid, 47 years old, is accused of passing information about Syrian American protesters in the United States to the government of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad, who are thought to have arrested and tortured numerous Syrian political refugees' family members and associates living in Syria.
The Tran Organization was a criminal gang of casino cheats in the 2000s. The group targeted at least 28 casinos across the United States and one in Canada. The casinos lost around $7,000,000 to the organization. As of 2011, 47 people were indicted, of which 42 had already pleaded guilty in relation to the conspiracy.
Conspiracy against the United States, or conspiracy to defraud the United States, is a federal offense in the United States of America under 18 U.S.C. § 371. The crime is that of two or more persons who conspire to commit an offense against the United States, or to defraud the United States.
The Special Counsel investigation was a United States law enforcement and counterintelligence investigation of the Russian government's efforts to interfere in United States politics and any possible involvement by members of the 2016 Trump presidential campaign. It was primarily focused on the 2016 presidential election.
Operation Lost Trust was the name of an FBI investigation into the South Carolina General Assembly from 1989 to 1999. By the end of the investigation, seventeen members of the South Carolina General Assembly were arrested for bribery, extortion, or drug use. Operation Lost Trust is often considered the greatest political scandal in the history of the state of South Carolina. It directly influenced the passing of South Carolina's Ethics Reform Act of 1991 and led to the restructuring of the state government in 1993. In its wake the once dominant South Carolina Democratic Party was weakened as a political party and the Republican Party emerged as a viable political entity in the state.
Paul Petersen is a former public official in Arizona who was accused of smuggling pregnant women from the Marshall Islands to at least three different states, as part of an adoption scheme. He pled guilty to charges of human smuggling, communication fraud, fraud and other charges in June 2020 and was sentenced to six years in prison in an Arkansas federal case in December 2020. His actions violated a compact between the United States and the Marshall Islands, which bans Marshallese people from traveling to the United States for adoptions unless they have a specific visa.
1 2 Appleson, Gail (March 10, 1997), "Spy Factory, owner plead guilty to smuggling.", Reuters News, New York, NY: Reuters, Factiva lba0000020011002dt3a08wn0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, "History", docket 1:95-cr-00737-SS, terminated August 29, 1997
"1060. Scope of 18 U.S.C § 2512 Prohibitions". Criminal Resource Manual. U.S. Department of Justice Archives.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply. Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.
