Vetulocystidae

Last updated

Vetulocystidae
Temporal range: Cambrian Stage 3
Cathaymyrus diacodexis.jpg
Reconstruction of 2 specimens of Vetulocystis catenata (in the lower part), and the chordate Cathaymyrus diadexus .
Scientific classification OOjs UI icon edit-ltr.svg
Domain: Eukaryota
Kingdom: Animalia
Clade: Ambulacraria (?)
Clade: Vetulocystida
Family: Vetulocystidae
Shu, et al., 2004
Genera

Vetulocystidae is the only family of the taxon Vetulocystida, which is a group of extinct deuterostomes of uncertain phylogenetic position. Vetulocystidae is made up of the genera Vetulocystis , Dianchicystis and Thylacocercus . [1] [2]

Contents

Etymology

The latin vetus means "old," while cystis refers to the organisms' bag-like shape. [1]

Description

The body consists of a voluminous thecal-shaped section (similar to the outer shape of the pterobranchs), where there are two cone-shaped structures (anterior and posterior) and a lenticular respiratory organ; and another small section attached to the substrate. [1]

The anterior cone-shaped structure is believed to have constituted the mouth, due to its similarity to primitive echinoderms (such as stylophorans and blastoids); while the posterior structure (similar to that of the cystoids and eocrinoids) fulfilled the functions of anus and gonopore. [3] Furthermore, and unlike many other echinoderms, these animals lacked a calcified skeleton. [4]

Paleoecology

They were probably sessile and fed by filtration, although it is possible that the part attached to the substrate produced a slow displacement, at least for Vetulocystis and Dianchicystis. [1] Thylacocercus shows evidence of a holdfast at the end of its posterior section. [2]

Vetulocystis catenata specimens have been found in close proximity to specimens of the small vetulicolid Beidazoon venustum . [5]

Phylogeny

The affinities of vetulocystida remain unclear, [4] and the only cladistic analysis of the taxon was done as an extension of work focused on stem-chordates. [6]

Internal phylogeny

Thylacocercus may be more derived than Vetulocystis and Dianchicystis, which its higher stratigraphic position would support. [2] The only available phylogenetic analysis of vetulocystids noted that the interpretation of their morphology "remains highly contested," but found weak support for the following arrangement: [7]

Vetulocystidae

External phylogeny

Numerous placements have been proposed for vetulocystids, without any consensus emerging. These include stem-group ambulacrarians, [8] stem-group echinoderms, [9] stem-group deuterostomes, [10] and even a phylogenetic study that found weak support for a placement at the base of the chordate stem. [6] The following cladogram shows each of these placements with respect to well-established clades (other taxa of uncertain placement, including xenacoelomorphs, cambroernids, and Yanjiahella , are omitted for simplicity):

Deuterostomia
? Vetulocystida 

    Vetulocystis catenata cropped.png

Deuterostomia
Ambulacraria
? Vetulocystida 

    Vetulocystis catenata cropped.png

Echinodermata
? Vetulocystida 

    Vetulocystis catenata cropped.png

Echinodermata

    Echinaster serpentarius (USNM E28192) 001.png

Hemichordata

Balanoglossus by Spengel 1893.png

Chordata
? Vetulocystida 

    Vetulocystis catenata cropped.png

Chordata

    Haikouichthys NT.jpg

Possible relationships to vetulicolians and echinoderms

Despite noting certain shared surface characteristics with other taxa (such as Tunicata), the discovers of the first vetulocytids believed them to belong to the Echinodermata stem group, and also to be related to the taxon Vetulicolia. Based on this, Vetulocystida would represent the transition from the body plan of the vetulicolians to one of the echinoderms, as shown by the following cladogram simplified from Shu et al. (2004): [9]

Interpreting the vetulocystids as intermediate between vetulicolians and echinoderms relies on features such as a straight gut, which is seen in the best-preserved specimens as running to the segmented posterior section and a presumed terminal anus, as in vetulicolians. The presence of a single respiratory structure (and possible gill) rather than paired gills could indicate the sort of asymmetry found in echinoderms. [11]

However, a recent review of theories of echinoderm origins disputed such a placement based on the lack of observable echinoderm apomorphies in vetulocystids. [4] Another challenge to the above cladogram is the more recent majority view that vetulicolians are stem chordates, rather than being placed as basal deuterostomes. [12]

Possible relationship to Yanjiahella

If vetulocystids are ancestral to echinoderms, then the tentacles of Thylacocercus could be coleomic structures related to feeding ambulacra. In this scenario, the proposed stem echinoderm Yanjiahella could be interpreted as having characteristics intermediate between Thylacocercus (as a relatively derived vetulocystid) and echinoderms. [2] While a stem-echinoderm affinity for Yanjiahella is a matter of some debate, the proposed alternatives are also within stem- or crown-group Ambulacraria. [13]

Disproven relationship to Saccorhytus

An alternative phylogeny connecting both vetulocystids and vetulicolians with Saccorhytus , which was initially thought to be an early deuterostome, [14] was disproven when Saccorhytus was shown to be an ecdysozoan (a protostome) instead. [15]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chordate</span> Phylum of animals having a dorsal nerve cord

A chordate is a deuterostomal bilaterian animal belonging to the phylum Chordata. All chordates possess, at some point during their larval or adult stages, five distinctive physical characteristics (synapomorphies) that distinguish them from other taxa. These five synapomorphies are a notochord, a hollow dorsal nerve cord, an endostyle or thyroid, pharyngeal slits, and a post-anal tail.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Vetulicolia</span> Extinct Cambrian group of animals

Vetulicolia is a group of bilaterian marine animals encompassing several extinct species from the Cambrian, and possibly Ediacaran, periods. As of 2023, the majority of workers favor placing Vetulicolians in the stem group of the Chordata, but some continue to favor a more crownward placement as a sister group to the Tunicata. It was initially erected as a monophyletic clade with the rank of phylum in 2001, with subsequent work supporting its monophyly. However, more recent research suggests that vetulicolians may be paraphyletic and form a basal evolutionary grade of stem chordates.

<i>Yunnanozoon</i> Cambrian fossil chordate

Yunnanozoon lividum is an extinct species of bilaterian animal from the Lower Cambrian Chengjiang biota of Yunnan province, China. Its affinities have been long the subject of controversy.

<i>Vetulicola</i> Fossil genus of marine animal

Vetulicola is an extinct genus of marine animal discovered from the Cambrian of China. It is the eponymous member of the enigmatic phylum Vetulicolia, which is of uncertain affinities but may belong to the deuterostomes. The name was derived from Vetulicola cuneata, the first species described by Hou Xian-guang in 1987 from the Lower Cambrian Chiungchussu Formation in Chengjiang, China.

<i>Didazoon</i> Cambrian age animal

Didazoon haoae is an extinct species of vetulicolid vetulicolian described by Shu, et al. based on fossils found in the Qiongzhusi (Chiungchussu) Formation, Yu'anshan Member, Lower Cambrian, in the Dabanqiao area (Kunming), about 60 km northwest of Chengjiang, China.

<i>Pomatrum</i> Cambrian age animal

Pomatrum is an extinct vetulicolian, the senior synonym of Xidazoon; the latter taxon was described by Shu, et al. (1999) based on fossils found in the Qiongzhusi (Chiungchussu) Formation, Yu'anshan Member, Lower Cambrian, Haikou, (Kunming), about 50 km west of Chengjiang, China.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Vetulicolidae</span> Extinct Cambrian family of vetulicolian animals

Vetulicolidae is a vetulicolian family from the Cambrian Stage 3 Maotianshan Shale and Sirius Passet Lagerstätte that consists of Vetulicola, Beidazoon, and Ooedigera. It is distinguished from the Didazoonidae by a harder body wall and the lack of an oral disc.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Didazoonidae</span> Extinct Cambrian family of vetulicolid animals

Didazoonidae is a vetulicolian family within the order Vetulicolata. It is charaterized by a relatively thin-walled, non-biomineralized body and a large, round anterior opening surrounded by an oral disc. It may be paraphyletic, even if the phylum Vetulicolia is monophyletic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ambulacraria</span> Clade of deuterostomes containing echinoderms and hemichordates

Ambulacraria, or Coelomopora, is a clade of invertebrate phyla that includes echinoderms and hemichordates; a member of this group is called an ambulacrarian. Phylogenetic analysis suggests the echinoderms and hemichordates separated around 533 million years ago. The Ambulacraria are part of the deuterostomes, a clade that also includes the many Chordata, and the few extinct species belonging to the Vetulicolia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Deuterostome</span> Superphylum of bilateral animals

Deuterostomes are bilaterian animals of the superphylum Deuterostomia, typically characterized by their anus forming before the mouth during embryonic development. Deuterostomia is further divided into four phyla: Chordata, Echinodermata, Hemichordata, and the extinct Vetulicolia known from Cambrian fossils. The extinct clade Cambroernida is thought to be a member of Deuterostomia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Banffozoa</span> Extinct Cambrian group of marine animals

Banffozoa is an extinct class of bilaterians. Most workers place it in the Vetulicolia, but the protostome-like features of some members have motivated ongoing debate. Banffozoa consists of the order Banffiata as well as a dwarf "Form A" that has not been formally described or named. Skeemella has been placed incertae sedis in this class, but has more recently been placed with the Banffiidae. Banffozoa may be paraphyletic even if Vetulicolia is monophyletic.

<i>Cotyledion</i> Extinct genus of filter-feeders

Cotyledion tylodes is an extinct, stalked filter-feeder known from the Chengjiang lagerstatten. The living animal reached a couple of centimetres in height, and bore a loose scleritome of ovoid sclerites. Its interpretation has been controversial, but it is currently thought to be a member of the Entoprocta stem group.

<i>Nesonektris</i> Extinct genus of Cambrian Era Chordate

Nesonektris aldridgei is an extinct vetulicolian from the Late Botomian-aged Emu Bay Shale Lagerstätte in Kangaroo Island, Australia. So far, it is the fourth described vetulicolian that is not restricted to the Maotianshan Shales.

<i>Saccorhytus</i> Extinct genus of Cambrian ecdysozoan

Saccorhytus is an extinct genus of animal possibly belonging to the superphylum Ecdysozoa, and it is represented by a single species, Saccorhytus coronarius. The organism lived approximately 540 million years ago in the beginning of the Cambrian period. Initially proposed as a deuterostome, which would have made it the oldest known species of this superphylum, it has since been determined to belong to a protostome group called the ecdysozoans.

<i>Beidazoon</i> Extinct species of Cambrian organism

Beidazoon venustum is a marine deuterostome from the group Vetulicolia. It originates from the lower Cambrian Chengjiang biota of Yunnan Province, China, and was discovered in 2005. It is known as the smallest described vetulicolian, and for its surface being covered in many small nodes.

<i>Vetulocystis</i> Genus of vetulocystids

Vetulocystis is an extinct genus type genus of the family Vetulocystidae. It was found in the Maotianshan Shales, which date to roughly 518 mya.

Dianchicystis is an extinct genus of vetulocystid deuterostome. It was found in Jianshan, China, near Haikou, in the Cambrian Qiongzhusi Formation.

<i>Shenzianyuloma</i> Species of vetulicolian invertebrate

Shenzianyuloma is an extinct genus of vetulicolian represented by a single species, Shenzianyuloma yunnanense, from the Maotianshan Shale during Stage 3 of the Cambrian period. It is notable for having a compact body shape akin to that of an angelfish. It's exact phylogenetic position is unclear, and it was not included in a 2024 phylogenetic analysis of vetulicolians.

<i>Heteromorphus</i> Extinct genus of Cambrian organisms

Heteromorphus is an extinct genus of banffiid from the lower Cambrian Chengjiang lagerstatte. It contains one broadly accepted species, Heteromorphus confusus, as well as a proposed junior synonym, Heteromorphus longicaudatus that may prove to be a separate species as additional specimens are examined. A much smaller species labeled "Form A" is allied with Heteromorphus at the class level but has not been formally described or assigned to Heteromorphus itself.

Thylacocercus is a genus of vetulocystid from the Wheeler Shale of Utah that is tentatively placed withini the family Vetulocystidae. Its discovery extended the temporal range of vetulocystids from the Lower Cambrian Stage 3 to the Middle Cambrian Stage 5 (Drumian), and the geographic range from South China to Laurentia.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Shu et al. 2004 , pp. 422–423
  2. 1 2 3 4 Conway Morris et al. 2015 , pp. 4–5
  3. Shu et al. 2004 , pp. 425–426
  4. 1 2 3 Rahman & Zamora 2024 , p. 301
  5. Han et al. 2006 , p. 2487–2488
  6. 1 2 Mussini et al. 2024 , supplemental data figure S4
  7. Mussini et al. 2024 , supplemental document "Phylogenetic analyses and character descriptions. Related to the STAR methods and Figures 4 and S2-S4.", page 2
  8. "†unranked clade Vetulocystida Shu et al. 2002". The Paleobiology Database. Retrieved December 20, 2024.
  9. 1 2 Shu et al. 2004 , pp. 426–427
  10. Naimark, Parkhaev & Demidenko 2006
  11. Smith 2004 , p. 412
  12. Onai et al. 2023 , p. 202
  13. Zamora et al. 2020
  14. Han et al. 2017
  15. Liu et al. 2022

Works cited