2024 Ohio State University pro-Palestinian campus protests | |||
---|---|---|---|
Part of pro-Palestinian protests on university campuses and Israel-Hamas war protests in the United States | |||
Top to bottom:
| |||
Date | November 23, 2023 – Present | ||
Location | Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, United States 40°00′07″N83°00′54″W / 40.002°N 83.015°W | ||
Methods | |||
Parties | |||
| |||
Lead figures | |||
Protesters and organizers
| |||
Casualties and losses | |||
|
A series of protests at Ohio State University by pro-Palestinian demonstrators occurred on-campus in response to the Israel-Palestine conflict beginning on October 7, 2023. A solidarity encampment was constructed on OSU's South Oval on April 25, 2024, during which there were at least 36 arrests, [1] making for the largest en masse arrests on campus since the 1969–1970 Vietnam War protests. [2]
The protester demands of OSU include "financial divestment, academic boycott, financial disclosure, acknowledging the genocide, and ending targeted policing". [3]
Pro-Palestinian groups have been critical of the university's responses to the protests, which have included allowing state troopers to aim long-range rifles at students during the dispersal of the Gaza Solidarity Encampment, [4] suspending a pro-Palestinian student organization, [5] and suppressing the Undergraduate Student Government's attempts at passing legislation for financial divestment from Israel after receiving pressure from officials in Zionist organization Hillel International. [6]
The university has insisted their actions are politically neutral, with President Walter E. Carter Jr. stating the "university's long-standing space rules are content neutral and are enforced uniformly". [7]
Pro-Palestinian protests on university campuses started in 2023 and escalated in April 2024, spreading in the United States and other countries, as part of wider Israel–Hamas war protests. The escalation began after mass arrests at the Columbia University campus occupation, led by anti-Zionist groups, in which protesters demanded the university's disinvestment from Israel over its alleged genocide of Palestinians. [8] In the U.S. over 3,100 protesters have been arrested, [9] including faculty members and professors, [10] [11] on over 60 campuses. [12] On May 7, protests spread across Europe with mass arrests in the Netherlands. [13] [14] By May 12, twenty encampments had been established in the United Kingdom, and across universities in Australia and Canada. [15] [16] The protests largely ended as universities closed for the summer. [17]
The different protests' varying demands include severing financial ties with Israel, transparency over financial ties, an end to partnerships with Israeli institutions, [18] and amnesty for protesters. [19] Universities have suspended and expelled student protesters, in some cases evicting them from campus housing. [10] [20] [21] Some universities have relied on police to forcibly disband encampments and end occupations of buildings, [22] others made agreements with protesters for encampments to be dismantled, [23] and a number of universities have cut ties with Israeli institutions, or companies involved with Israel and its occupied territories. [a] The occupations have also resulted in the closure of Columbia University, [30] Cal Poly Humboldt, [31] and the University of Amsterdam; [32] rolling strikes by academic workers on campuses in California; [33] and the cancellation of a few university graduation ceremonies in the U.S., with protests occurring at various ceremonies. [34] [35] [36]Since October 7th, 2023, protesters have been arrested at the following pro-Palestine events:
Date | Incident | Confirmed arrests | Alleged arrests by pro-Palestine groups |
---|---|---|---|
April 23, 2024 | Meiling Hall disruption | 2 [37] [38] | 2 |
April 25, 2024 | Gaza Solidarity Encampment | 36 [39] | 41 [40] |
June 1, 2024 | Ohio Union disruption | 0 | 3 [41] |
Present | Total | 38 | 46 |
On April 23, 2024, in an event organized by Ohio Youth for Climate Justice, around 60 individuals gathered outside Meiling Hall, an administrative building near the Wexner Medical Center, to protest the Israel-Palestine conflict, and to advocate fossil fuel divestment during an OSU Board of Trustees meeting inside the building. [37]
According to the President of Ohio Youth for Climate Justice, students were warned that there would be "no tolerance for amplified noise" because it was Reading Day. In order to comply, the students chanted without using their megaphones after marching to Meiling Hall. OSU police officers told the protesters that even though they did not bring their megaphones, they could be heard from inside the building's lobby. After refusing to leave, police arrested two protesters who were OSU students, charging them with criminal trespassing and misdemeanor. [37] [38]
An encampment was organized for April 25, 2024, by multiple pro-Palestinian student organizations including OSU [42] and Toledo [43] Students for Justice in Palestine, [44] OSU Jews for Justice in Palestine, [42] the Party for Socialism and Liberation in Columbus, [42] Justice, Unity, & Social Transformation, [45] Rising Tide Columbus, [46] and Ohio Youth for Climate Justice. [47]
Protesters initially arrived in the morning. Several were arrested throughout the day for pitching tents on the South Oval, [2] as police observed from a distance. [4] One Faculty & Staff for Justice in Palestine member was reportedly arrested by police, and several others were reportedly harassed, for "reading and sitting in the oval". [48] During the night of the encampment, President Walter E. Carter Jr. requested the state patrol's assistance, although university police had already been coordinating with state police since around 5:00 p.m. [40] Officials cited "rules prohibiting camping, overnight events, and disruption to university business", which was later satirized in a political cartoon. [49]
At 7:32 p.m., authorities issued a warning: "disperse within 15 minutes or face arrest." According to The Lantern , "although warnings came from beyond the crowd, laughter, and smiles abounded within". At around 10 p.m., while Muslim students were praying, [2] riot police marched on the encampment and began arrests. In response, protesters formed a human barrier around the tents by connecting their arms together. [50]
During the arrests, Ohio State Highway Patrol troopers on the Ohio Union switched from observing students through binoculars to aiming "long-range firearms" at students, which university spokesperson Benjamin Johnson claimed was part of their protocol. [4] Johnson originally stated "there are no snipers" on the Ohio Union rooftop, but after photographs of the snipers were later released, [51] [52] he stated that "the team carries standard equipment, including firearms, that would only be used reactively to protect the safety of all present, including demonstrators". [39] Ohio State University was one of the only two universities in the world, the other being Indiana University, with reports of police snipers being present at the 2024 pro-Palestinian campus protests. [51] [52]
By the end of the evening, at least 36 protesters, including 16 Ohio State students and 20 non-Ohio State students, had been arrested according to authorities. [53] This number is disputed by the Council on American–Islamic Relations, who reported 41 were arrested during this event. [40] One woman who was struck in the face showed "her bruise to others watching as she walked away from the chaos". [50] Those arrested were charged with criminal trespassing. A statement OSU later released read: "Arrests are not an action that we take lightly, and we appreciate the support of all of our law enforcement partners to disperse the encampment for the safety of our university community." [2]
Students for Justice in Palestine claim there were "at least 70 officers" on the scene. [54] After being arrested, they also alleged that hijabs were forcefully removed from students during mugshots, Muslims were refused a space to pray, and police refused to provide them with Halal food. [54] [55] [56]
On April 29, 2024, pro-Palestinian demonstrators arrived at a Columbus City Council meeting to support demonstrators who were arrested at the Gaza Solidarity Encampment, demanding the city drop all charges against them for criminal trespassing. The demonstrators filled the gallery and yelled slogans such as "shame" at courthouse representatives during the speeches of three OSU students who been arrested at the Gaza Solidarity Encampment.
One speaker accused police of giving her a severe concussion, [57] and a second speaker accused police of pulling down his pants after being ziptied. [58] He also claimed that after another protester passed out and hit his head on a wall, police ignored them for 15 minutes before seeking paramedics. [59]
On December 13, 2023, the Central Ohio Revolutionary Socialists (CORS), a registered pro-Palestinian OSU student organization, was suspended from OSU, during which "the club [was] prohibited from participating in or holding activities". [5] According to OSU spokesperson Dave Isaacs, this was due to several violations, including "disregarding university directives, being non-responsive to meeting requests from the organization's advisors and university leaders, and dissemination of materials that include a logo associated with a designated terrorist organization". [b] Their poster, titled "Intifada, Revolution, and the Path to a Free Palestine", included a drawing of an armed pro-Palestinian militant, which caused the university to claim CORS posed a "significant risk of substantial harm". [5] [61] [62]
CORS called the statements made by The Lantern defamatory, demanding that the OSU administration retract and apologize for their article. In a public statement, CORS claimed OSU misrepresented the charges in order to suspend them due to their political beliefs, including using ignoring a generic "getting to know you" email sent during finals week as a pretense for claiming they ignored communications from the university, by not making clear that an OSU room reservation they made had expired, and by selectively enforcing OSU signage policy. [61]
On February 2, 2024, CORS was reinstated as a student organization under the condition they attend extra meetings with administration, which CORS claims was largely due to "the hundreds of individuals and organizations who supported us". [63] [62]
On March 25, 2024, OSU's Undergraduate Student Government (USG) proposed an initiative titled "Urging OSU to Divest from Companies Profiting from Human Rights Violations". The initiative received 1247 signatures (with 415 digital signatures from a digital circulator and 832 signatures from other sources), above the 1,000-signature minimum needed to appear on the presidency ballot. USG's Judicial Panel nullified this initiative. [6]
According to Students for Justice in Palestine President Jineen Musa, the signatures were "deemed invalid due to the dissemination of the petition on Instagram". Musa claimed other candidates who had "used the exact same method to a greater extent than what we did" were not penalized, implying their initiative was targeted due to its pro-Palestinian content. [6]
OSU Students for Justice in Palestine leaked screenshots of emails between Senior Vice President for Student Life Javaune Adams-Gaston and Hillel International member Joseph Kohane. [64] In the email, Kohane implores USG's Judicial Panel to veto the initiative, saying, "we urge that USG and especially the Judicial Panel hold itself accountable and make the needed changes, including reversing the signature threshold." Threats of impeachment ensued against the USG justices "due to concerns of an 'abuse of power and position'", which caused three justices to resign shortly after the incident. [65]
The "CAMPUS" Act, also known as House Bill 606 (HB606), was initially introduced by Ohio Representatives (R) Justin Pizzulli and (D) Dontavius Jarrells, was later incorporated into Senate Bill 94 (SB94), and was signed into law on July 26, 2024, with an effective date of October 24, 2024. [66] [67] [68] The policy's stated goal is to "require public and private colleges and universities to adopt and enforce a policy regarding racial, religious, and ethnic harassment and intimidation". [69] [67] The act has garnered attention on social media, with pro-Palestine group Rising Tide Columbus alleging that it marks the end of free speech protections at OSU and that it was passed to oppress pro-Palestinian protests. [70]
One of the provisions of SB94, outlined in Section 3320.08, enables each state institution of higher education to publicize on its website "any time, place, or manner restrictions it places on expressive activities". [71] According to Ohio Revised Code Section 3345.0211, expressive activities includes "any lawful verbal, written, audiovisual, or electronic means by which individuals may communicate ideas, including all forms of peaceful assembly, protests, speeches, distribution of literature, carrying and displaying signs, and circulating petitions". [72] While the bill says it protects First Amendment rights, the bill does not put any constraints on when restrictions on expressive activities are allowed to be implemented. [71]
The bill also mandates that institutions ensure collaboration between their campus security and local law enforcement, the state highway patrol, and student communities to provide security for student organizations facing threats of terror attacks or hate crimes. [73] Additionally, the act establishes three grant programs to ensure student safety at events: the Campus Security Support Program, the Campus Student Safety Grant Program, and the Campus Community Grant Program. [67]
Funding allocations for these programs include $2,000,000 for the Campus Security Support Program, $1,000,000 for the Campus Student Safety Grant Program, and $1,375,000 for Campus Safety and Training. [74]
Date | Incident | Details |
---|---|---|
October 8, 2023 | Spitting incident | A student in the OSU Oval purchasing a "I stand with Israel" bracelet was spat on. [75] |
November 9, 2023 | Hillel flag vandalism | Two protesters with no known connections with the protests vandalized Israeli flags in the OSU Hillel lobby, shouting slogans like "you support genocide". They were charged with misdemeanor, ethnic intimidation, and more. [76] All charges were later dropped except for the trespassing charge. [77] |
March 27, 2024 | Hillel infosession disruption | Black-bloc pro-Palestinian protesters affiliated with Jews for Justice in Palestine (JJP) and an unnamed allied organization disrupted an infosession for Hillel International's annual "Fact Finder Israel Trip" by holding a sign saying "OSU Hillel invites you to visit a genocidal state". JJP accused Hillel of being an "ethnonationalistic" organization and the event was canceled due to the disruption. [78] |
April 20, 2024 | Ohio State Student Union protest clash | A counter-protester wearing a kippah confronted pro-Palestinian protesters at a Student Union protest, repeatedly shouting "show your face" at a masked protester and pushing him. [79] |
September 12, 2024 | Moritz pro-Palestine rally counter-protests | Students for Justice in Palestine hosted a rally outside the Moritz College of Law. A counter-protest began shortly after, with counter-protesters waving Israeli flags. During a pro-Palestine professor's speech, counter-protesters chanted "free the hostages", which was met with "shame" from pro-Palestine protesters. [80] |
October 7, 2024 | Ohio Union pro-Palestine picket counter-protests | Students for Justice in Palestine hosted a picket outside the Ohio Union. A counter-protest of around 40 students and community members began shortly after, with counter-protesters holding Israeli flags. [81] |
On November 10, there was a violent antisemitic hate crime perpetrated by two males against Jewish students on North High Street next to OSU campus. [82] The individuals responsible were not identified and there is no indication they are affiliated with any pro-Palestinian organization.
On April 20, 2024, Ohio State University claimed "deplorable" comments were made at student protests, describing them as hate speech, but they did not describe what specific comments were made. [83] President Walter E. Carter Jr. has referred to pro-Palestinian demonstrations as consisting of "threats of violence" and "hate speech", again without describing any specific comments. [84]
Multiple OSU Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP) members have stated that they have been targets of social media death threats, in-class harassment, public profiling and, in one female student's case, a stalking incident. One member received a death threat through Instagram direct messages, saying: "Death to you and your family. I hope the IDF find [sic] you and you die slowly. It's good to know you go to tosu [sic] terrorist, the dean will know your [sic] beheading babies bitch". [75] A second member said she was stalked by a stranger several times after a class and that she filed a formal complaint and reached out to supervisors "at least 10 times" but that no actions were taken, so she stopped going to the class. A third member reported someone using a fake name and address sent a flyer of an Israeli hostage to her private address. [75] A spokesperson for the university said the administration and an OSUPD detective reviewed the incidents and offered resources and support, but that none of the students responded. [75]
Canary Mission, a public database dedicated to doxxing pro-Palestinian protesters, has targeted and blacklisted multiple students in OSU SJP and a current OSU professor. [85]
After the Gaza Solidarity Encampment, President Carter released a public statement directed toward "students, faculty, and staff" saying, "What occurred on our campus on April 25 was not about limiting free speech. It was an intentional violation of university space rules that exist so that teaching, learning, research, service and patient care can occur on our campuses without interruption". [86] In a later interview with The Lantern, Carter was asked about why an "on-campus Christian baptism ceremony", which outstayed its space reservation, resulted in no arrests, in contrast to the Gaza Solidarity Encampment. Carter stated that the latter protest only ended in arrests due to "a planned attempt and a clear statement to violate campus space rules". [87]
University officials, including Ohio State University spokesperson Benjamin Johnson, have referenced anti-BDS law Ohio Revised Code Section 9.76, a state law passed in 2016 and amended in 2022 which prohibits state agencies, including public universities, from boycotting Israel or divesting from companies that have policies in favor of Israel. [88]
Shortly after the Gaza Solidarity Encampment, the Faculty Council of the Ohio State University Senate released their first public statement in two years (passed with 36 votes yes, 11 votes no, and 8 votes abstaining), [89] stating "we strongly reject the use of force as a response to the peaceful protests of April 2024 on The Ohio State University's campus" and that "we call on the university to take every action possible to see dropped and expunged all criminal charges related to the peaceful protests that occurred during April 2024 on Ohio State's campus". [90]
In an op-ed by former OSU Professor Keith Kilty, Kilty criticized the administration's suppression of using sound systems, stating, "During my 29 years as a professor at OSU, I helped to organize many rallies and demonstrations, where we used sound systems so that we could be heard, and those were at all times of the day. Yet now, under your leadership, we are to be silenced and denied our right to speak?" [91] In the same op-ed, Kilty suggested that Carter resign from his position as OSU's President. [91]
In an op-ed by OSU associate Professor of Elementary Language Arts Michiko Hikida, Hikida stated "it is our job to protect the young people in our care as they learn to stand up for what they believe, as they learn to fight for what they believe is right". Talking to Carter, she said, "How dare you put them in harm’s way. You should be ashamed of yourself". [92]
After the Gaza Solidarity Encampment, Ohio Governor (R) Mike DeWine expressed support for the university's policy in an interview. [40] DeWine said, "I think that Ohio State did well", "what we don't want is any kind of hate", and that he opposes protests "right outside the door of a classroom". [40] The demonstrators at the encampment were on the South Oval, which is not in the vicinity of any classrooms. [93] [53] [94] He said that he supports Ohio and the U.S. "backing the country of Israel". [40] In the same interview, he expressed support for Ohio Revised Code Section 9.76.
After the Gaza Solidarity Encampment, Ohio State Senator (R) Jerry Cirino gave a speech named "New OSU President Passes First Test with Flying Colors", stating that "university administrators across the country could learn a thing or two from the OSU example, rather than sitting on their hands as violent mobs riot, storm buildings, and engage in running street battles with police, as shockingly occurred at colleges including Columbia and UCLA". [95] Cirino also claimed that "outside agitators" were responsible for the encampments. He concluded his speech by saying "perhaps we should consider introducing legislation that would provide for the termination of faculty members, tenured or not, who participate in, or encourage others to commit, violence on campus" and that "freedom from this horrible fear is every student's God-given right" and is his "sacred duty". [95]
The Diag is a large open space in the middle of the University of Michigan's Central Campus. Originally known as the Diagonal Green, the Diag derives its name from the many sidewalks running near or through it in diagonal directions. Many of the University's most frequented buildings are situated around the Diag, including West Hall, Randall Lab, the Shapiro Undergraduate Library, the Hatcher Graduate Library, and Angell, Mason, Haven, and Tisch Halls, among others.
The Ohio State University was founded in 1870 as a land-grant university in accordance with the Morrill Act of 1862 under the name of Ohio Agricultural and Mechanical College. The school was originally situated within a farming community located on the northern edge of Columbus, and was intended to matriculate students of various agricultural and mechanical disciplines. The university opened its doors to 24 students on September 17, 1873. In 1878, the first class of six men graduated. The first woman graduated the following year. In 1900, in light of its expanded focus, the college permanently changed its name to the now-familiar "The Ohio State University". Ohio State began accepting graduate students in the 1880s, with the university awarding its first master's and doctoral degrees in 1886 and 1890 respectively. 1891 saw the founding of Ohio State's law school.
Students for Justice in Palestine is a pro-Palestinian college student activism organization in the United States, Canada and New Zealand. Founded at the University of California in 2001, it has campaigned for boycott and divestment against corporations that deal with Israel and organized events about Israel's human rights violations. In 2011, The New York Times called it "the leading pro-Palestinian voice on campus". As of 2024, National SJP has over 350 chapters in North America.
Protests, including rallies, demonstrations, campaigns, and vigils, relating to the Israel–Hamas war have occurred nationwide across the United States since the conflict's start on October 7, 2023, occurring as part of a broader phenomenon of the Israel–Hamas war protests around the world.
As a result of the Israel–Hamas war, nationwide protests occurred across the UK. These demonstrations occurred as part of a broader movement of war-related protests occurring around the world.
A series of occupation protests by pro-Palestinian students occurred at Columbia University in New York City from April to June 2024, in the context of the broader Israel–Hamas war protests in the United States. The protests began on April 17, 2024, when pro-Palestinian students established an encampment of approximately 50 tents on the university campus, calling it the Gaza Solidarity Encampment, and demanded the university divest from Israel.
Pro-Palestinian protests on university campuses started in 2023 and escalated in April 2024, spreading in the United States and other countries, as part of wider Israel–Hamas war protests. The escalation began after mass arrests at the Columbia University campus occupation, led by anti-Zionist groups, in which protesters demanded the university's disinvestment from Israel over its alleged genocide of Palestinians. In the U.S. over 3,100 protesters have been arrested, including faculty members and professors, on over 60 campuses. On May 7, protests spread across Europe with mass arrests in the Netherlands. By May 12, twenty encampments had been established in the United Kingdom, and across universities in Australia and Canada. The protests largely ended as universities closed for the summer.
On April 25, 2024, a student protest began at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) to protest the administration's investments in Israel. The occupation, self-titled as the 'Palestine Solidarity Encampment', was a part of pro-Palestine protests on university campuses campaigning for divestment from Israel. The encampment was attacked multiple times by counter protestors, leading to clashes. On May 2, the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) raided and dismantled the encampment, arresting the protestors and ending the occupation.
On April 29, 2024, approximately 100 University of Oregon students established a camp on the Eugene campus to support Palestinians in Gaza and demanding action from administrators. As part of the 2024 pro-Palestinian protests on university campuses, demonstrators requested for the university to divest from “the state of Israel, Israeli companies, and any weapons or surveillance manufacturing.”
In May 2024, peaceful pro-Palestinian student protesters at the University of Virginia (UVa) demonstrated on the campus. The protesters organized an anti-war occupation on university grounds in support of Palestinian nationalism in the context of the mass death and displacement of tens of thousands of Palestinian civilians during the Israel–Hamas war.
On April 24, 2024 an occupation protest began at the University of Southern California (USC) in Los Angeles, California. The protest was a part of pro-Palestine protests on university campuses campaigning for divestment from Israel. USC cancelled their main commencement ceremony over safety concerns about protests. The encampment was cleared by the Los Angeles Police Department on the morning of May 5.
The McGill University pro-Palestinian encampment was an occupation protest which took place on the downtown campus of McGill University, in Montreal, from 27 April to 10 July 2024. It was the first notable Canadian demonstration in the 2024 movement of pro-Palestinian protests on university campuses, which call for universities to cut ties with Israel amid the country's assault on Gaza in the Israel–Hamas war. Like many of its predecessors, the protest at McGill took the form of an encampment, a group of tents occupied day and night by protesters.
The pro-Palestinian campus occupations at Radboud University Nijmegen in the Netherlands were a series of occupation protests, as part of the broader protests against the Israel–Hamas war. On 13 May 2024 protesters created an encampment, similar to other campus protests in the Netherlands, the United States and other countries. On 20 May a second encampment was established next to the universities' administrative building. On 5 June after the occupation of another university building, police cleared the encampment. The protesters demanded that the university board divest from Israel over its alleged genocide of Palestinians and invasion of the Gaza Strip, and to support Palestinian students and universities. The protests included walkouts, daily marches, temporary occupations, as well as vandalism.
In 2024, an occupation protest was started by students on the University of Washington campus, in Seattle, Washington.
On April 25th, students at University of Pennsylvania began an encampment to protest the ongoing Israel–Hamas war and to call for divestment from Israel. The occupation, named the "Gaza Solidarity Encampment," was part of a series of 2024 pro-Palestinian protests on university campuses. On May 10th, the encampment was raided and protesters were arrested, ending the occupation.
The pro-Palestinian campus occupations at the University of Oxford are ongoing occupation protests in Oxford, England, organised by Oxford Action for Palestine (OA4P). The occupations started on 6 May 2024 on the Museum of Natural History's lawn, in front of the Pitt Rivers Museum. Escalating the protests, a second encampment was established on 19 May outside the Radcliffe Camera. Protests have taken elsewhere in the city, including on Wellington Square, where 17 students were arrested after occupying the Vice-Chancellor's office on 23 May. Protesters demands include disclosure of investments and divestment from Israeli companies, among others. The university refused to negotiate with protesters until responding to an email to arrange discussion on 5 June. The protests have been supported by over 500 members of staff, and criticised by the university as intimidating.
Pro-Palestinian protests at the University of Texas at Austin began on April 24, 2024, organized by the Palestinian Solidarity Committee in response to the ongoing Israel-Hamas War. The protests have included sit-ins, marches, and encampments on campus, calling for the university to divest from companies linked to Israel's actions in Gaza. The demonstrations escalated when university officials, with support from local and state law enforcement, intervened to disperse protestors, leading to multiple arrests and sparking criticism over the suppression of free speech on campus. Despite arrests and clashes with police, the protests have continued, drawing significant attention and raising debates about civil liberties and the role of university administration in managing campus protests.
Among the lead student groups in the coalition are the Columbia chapters of Jewish Voice for Peace and Students for Justice in Palestine. The two decades-old anti-Zionism advocacy groups that protest Israel's military occupation have chapters across the country that have been key to protests on other campuses.
It's one of several schools around the country where professors are getting arrested at demonstrations, circulating letters in support of arrested protesters and holding no-confidence votes in their administrations.