AI bubble

Last updated

The AI bubble is a theorised stock market bubble growing amid the current AI boom, a period of rapid increase in investment in artificial intelligence (AI) that is affecting the broader economy. [1] Speculation about a bubble largely originates from concerns that leading AI tech firms are involved in a circular flow of investments that are artificially inflating the value of their stocks.

Contents

History

The number of Google searches for the term "AI" has accelerated. 20250202 "AI" (search term) on Google Trends.svg
The number of Google searches for the term "AI" has accelerated.

In late January 2025, the unexpectedly successful launch of the Chinese-made chatbot DeepSeek resulted in concerns about a possible AI bubble. The stock prices of many AI companies dropped, such as Nvidia's shares dropping 17% in one day. Nvidia's share price recovered 8.8% the following day. [2] In August 2025, a report by Nanda (Networked Agents and Decentralized AI), under Massachusetts Institute of Technology's MIT Media Lab stated "despite $30–40 billion [USD] in enterprise investment into Gen[erative]AI, [...] 95% of organizations are getting zero return". [3] Spending from US mega caps is expected to reach $1.1 trillion between 2026 and 2029, and total AI spending is expected to surpass $1.6 trillion. [4]

Due to the growing demand for computer chips to sustain AI technologies, Nvidia became the highest valued company in the world and the first to ever have reached a market value of $4 trillion in July. The figure had quadrupled since 2023, when it surpassed $1 trillion. The company's value made up roughly 7.3% of the S&P 500, which hit an all-time high. [5] [6] In October 2025, the company's value grew beyond $5 trillion, [7] rising higher than the GDP of every country except for the US and China, according to data from the World Bank. Over the year 2025, AI-related enterprises accounted for roughly 80% of gains in the American stock market. Some sceptics warned that the rapid rise of AI tech firms may be the result of excessive financial engineering. [8]

Microsoft disclosed that it had spent almost $35 billion on AI infrastructure in the three months leading up to the end of September. In October, it became the second most valuable company in the world largely due to its 27% stake in OpenAI. While seeing increases in revenue by 18% and in net income by 12%, share values dropped by 4% in after-hours trading amid investors' concerns about the possible costs of sustaining the AI boom. [9]

In late 2025, 30% of the US S&P 500 and 20% of the MSCI World index was solely held up by the five largest companies, which was the greatest concentration in half a century, and share valuations were reportedly the most stretched since the dot-com bubble. [10] [11] Experts warned that AI companies were extremely overvalued, with the S&P 500 trading at 23 times forward earnings, and the FTSE Index trading at 14 times, showing how expensive the US market had become. The Case–Shiller price-to-earnings ratio for the US market also exceeded 40 for the first time since the dot-com crash. [11]

Speculation

Sam Altman, CEO of OpenAI and creator of ChatGPT, stated in 2025 that he believed that an AI bubble is ongoing. [13] In early 2025, Bridgewater Associates co-chief investment officer Ray Dalio said that the current levels of investment in AI are "very similar" to the dot-com bubble. [13] In September 2025, the Australian Financial Review said that "If we really are in another share-market bubble, it's surely the most anticipated example in history." [14]

In October of that year, Jamie Dimon, head of JP Morgan, the largest bank in the US, said he thinks "AI is real" but said he believes some money invested now will be wasted. He also said there is a higher chance of a meaningful drop in stocks over the following two years than the market was reflecting. [15] Dimon warned that an AI-driven stock crash could result in a lot of invested money being lost, although he acknowledged that AI "[would] pay off […] just like cars in total paid off, and TVs in total paid off, but most people involved in them didn't do well". However, he further stated on AI that "the level of uncertainty should be higher in most people's minds". [16]

Circular investment

Bubble graphics depicting circular investments by AI companies became popular in October 2025. Some market analysts have questioned the investment structure of the AI industry due to profitability and cash flow issues for major AI companies. 2025 AI Bubble Speculation 2.png
Bubble graphics depicting circular investments by AI companies became popular in October 2025. Some market analysts have questioned the investment structure of the AI industry due to profitability and cash flow issues for major AI companies.

Concerns were raised that leading AI tech firms were using circular financing and investment to artificially boost their valuations. In September, Nvidia made a $100 billion investment into OpenAI, expanding the pre-existing stake that it held in the company. This agreement was made on the expectation that OpenAI would power additional data centres using the chips that it had been buying from Nvidia, establishing a circular flow of money. [20] [21]

On 9 September 2025, Nvidia entered into an $6.3 billion agreement with AI cloud-computing provider CoreWeave to purchase the latter's unsold data center capacity through to 13 April 2032. [22] Nvidia held 7% of CoreWeave shares as at 31 March 2025, and is also supplying chips to the company. [22] [23]

In October 2025, OpenAI purchased billions of dollars worth of electronics from AMD, a rival of Nvidia, to supply its development of AI in an agreement that made it one of the largest shareholders in the company. Microsoft also held a large stake in OpenAI, and Oracle Corporation, a computing company, also entered into a $300 billion deal with the company. [20]

Bank of England statement

The Bank of England warned of the growing risks of a global market correction due to a possible overvaluation of leading AI tech firms in the stock market, such as OpenAI, which more than tripled its value from $157 billion in October 2024 to $500 billion the following year. These valuations, they claimed, could be further harmed if the infrastructure requirements for sustaining the technology were too high to be met. They added that investors were not properly cautioned about the risks of a stock market crash were AI to fall short of market expectations. [24]

The International Monetary Fund agreed with and reinforced the bank's claims. Kristalina Georgieva, a Bulgarian economist and the 12th managing director of the IMF, also drew comparisons to the dot-com bubble of 2001, highlighting that a market correction could stunt global growth and weaken the economies of developing countries. [10]

Debt

Debt funding has also raised the risk of the bubble. [25] Analysts at Morgan Stanley estimated that debt used to fund data centers could exceed $1 trillion by 2028. [26]

Opposing views

Strategies from major financial institutions have largely dismissed concerns regarding an artificial "AI bubble," attributing the surge in equity valuations to tangible fundamental strength rather than speculative mania.

Goldman Sachs chief equity strategist argues that the rapid appreciation in stock prices is substantiated by robust and sustained profit growth in earnings and fundamentals among large-cap AI and technology incumbents. The firm notes that valuation multiples for the market leaders of the post-2022 bull run—specifically forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios—remain modest compared to the excesses of the dot-com era. [27]

Similarly, Morgan Stanley analysts argued the fear of a bubble is "misplaced" or "premature." Their research highlights a structural shift in corporate financial health: the median cash flow and capital reserves of the top 500 US firms are approximately triple those observed during historical bubble periods. Furthermore, they distinguish current market leaders by their durable earnings streams and robust margin profiles, contrasting them with the hype-driven, revenue-negative valuations of the late 1990s. [28] [29]

JPMorgan reinforces this stance, stating that the sector does not meet the classic criteria for a financial bubble. In a December 2025 analysis, the bank applied a five-factor diagnostic framework to the AI rally, concluding that the sector exhibits genuine structural utility rather than pure speculation. The report emphasizes that AI represents a transformative economic driver, with capital inflows tied directly to measurable enterprise growth and revenue generation. [30]

Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell has also distinguished the current economic landscape from the dot-com bubble. Powell posits that the AI sector is underpinned by substantial realized revenue and that the massive capital expenditure (CapEx) directed toward AI data centres is functioning as a major engine of broader economic growth, rather than a sink for speculative capital. [31]

See also

References

  1. Multiple sources:
    • Aspan, Maria (30 August 2025). "AI and Nvidia have been bright spots in an uncertain economy, but there are doubts now". NPR . Retrieved 3 November 2025.
    • De Vynck, Gerrit (4 August 2025). "The AI spending boom could have real consequences for the U.S. economy". The Washington Post . Archived from the original on 26 August 2025.
    • Casselman, Ben; Ember, Sydney (22 November 2025). "The A.I. Boom Is Driving the Economy. What Happens if It Falters?". The New York Times . Archived from the original on 24 November 2025.
    • Tobin, Meaghan (3 October 2025). "A.I. Is Driving a Stock Market Rally in China, Too". The New York Times . Archived from the original on 3 October 2025.
    • DePillis, Lydia (27 August 2025). "The A.I. Spending Frenzy Is Propping Up the Real Economy, Too". The New York Times . Archived from the original on 8 September 2025.
    • Munjal, Mayank; Sachdev, Vineet (5 December 2025). "Investment in AI is exploding". Reuters .
  2. Hoskins, Peter; Edwards, Charlotte (28 January 2025). "Nvidia and Microsoft shares steady after DeepSeek AI app shock". BBC . Retrieved 26 August 2025.
  3. "STATE OF AI IN BUSINESS 2025" (PDF). July 2025. Retrieved 3 January 2025.
  4. Aquino, Kristine (10 October 2025). "Companies overpaying for AI add to stock market bubble risks, survey shows". Financial Post . Retrieved 10 October 2025.
  5. Edwards, Charlotte (9 July 2025). "Nvidia becomes world's first $4tn company". BBC. Retrieved 3 November 2025.
  6. Montgomery, Blake (9 July 2025). "Nvidia becomes first company to reach $4tn in market value". The Guardian . Retrieved 3 November 2025.
  7. Nishant, Niket; Singh, Rashika (29 October 2025). "Nvidia hits $5 trillion valuation as AI boom powers meteoric rise". Reuters . Retrieved 3 November 2025.
  8. Kaye, Danielle (29 October 2025). "Nvidia hits new milestone as world's first $5tn company". BBC. Retrieved 3 November 2025.
  9. Sephton, Connor (30 October 2025). "Microsoft, Alphabet and Meta results overshadowed by growing fears of AI bubble". Sky News . Retrieved 3 November 2025.
  10. 1 2 "Bank of England warns of 'sharp correction' for markets if AI bubble bursts - and IMF agrees". Sky News. 8 October 2025. Retrieved 3 November 2025.
  11. 1 2 More, Durva (16 October 2025). "Experts warn AI could trigger next global stock market crash — here's what might happen". The Economic Times . Retrieved 3 November 2025.
  12. @DavidSacks (24 November 2025). "According to today's WSJ, AI-related investment accounts for half of GDP growth. A reversal would risk recession. We can't afford to go backwards" (Tweet). Archived from the original on 25 November 2025 via Twitter.
  13. 1 2 "Wall Street isn't worried about an AI bubble. Sam Altman is". Fortune. 19 August 2025. Retrieved 26 August 2025.
  14. "'Close to full ponzi': What big fundies are doing as markets flash red" . Australian Financial Review . 26 September 2025. Retrieved 29 September 2025.
  15. Towfighi, John (9 October 2025). "Jamie Dimon is worried about a stock market correction | CNN Business". CNN . Retrieved 12 October 2025.
  16. Jack, Simon; McNamee, Michael Sheils (9 October 2025). "America's top banker sounds warning on US stock market fall". BBC. Retrieved 3 November 2025.
  17. Yip, Jaures (21 October 2025). "Are we in an AI bubble? Here's what analysts and experts are saying". CNBC . Retrieved 28 October 2025.
  18. Wile, Rob (6 October 2025). "The AI boom's reliance on circular deals is raising fears of a bubble". NBC News . Retrieved 28 October 2025.
  19. Weil, Jonathan (22 October 2025). "Is the Flurry of Circular AI Deals a Win-Win—or Sign of a Bubble?". The Wall Street Journal . Retrieved 3 November 2025.
  20. 1 2 Jamali, Lily (11 October 2025). "'It's going to be really bad': Fears over AI bubble bursting grow in Silicon Valley". BBC. Retrieved 3 November 2025.
  21. Gu, Jacqueline; Metz, Cade (31 October 2025). "How OpenAI Uses Complex and Circular Deals to Fuel Its Multibillion-Dollar Rise". The New York Times . Archived from the original on 23 November 2025.
  22. 1 2 CoreWeave, Inc. (15 September 2025). "Form 8-K". U.S. Securities and Investment Commission (SEC). Archived from the original on 14 December 2025. Retrieved 14 December 2025.
  23. Maidan, Laila (3 June 2025). "Why investors should care about Nvidia's 'unusual' relationship with CoreWeave". MarketWatch. Retrieved 14 December 2025.
  24. Makortoff, Kalyeena (8 October 2025). "Bank of England warns of growing risk that AI bubble could burst". The Guardian. Retrieved 3 November 2025.
  25. Sen, Anirban; Mackenzie, Nell (4 December 2025). "Focus: Hedge funds double down using near-record leverage in quest to boost returns". Reuters . Hedge funds are using near-record levels of leverage to trade equities and betting on debt-backed strategies in efforts to juice returns, making the most of markets buoyed by a boom in artificial intelligence.
  26. Metz, Cade (10 November 2025). "Why Debt Funding Is Ratcheting Up the Risks of the A.I. Boom" . The New York Times . Archived from the original on 12 November 2025.
  27. Mills, Madison (9 October 2025). "Goldman Sachs says we're not in an AI bubble (yet)". Axios . Archived from the original on 10 October 2025. Retrieved 12 October 2025.
  28. Gottsegen, Gordon (9 October 2025). "Morgan Stanley believes AI bubble fears are 'misplaced' as tech stocks waver today". MarketWatch . Retrieved 12 October 2025.
  29. Klebanov, Sam (9 October 2025). "Is there an AI bubble or not?". Morning Brew. Retrieved 3 November 2025.
  30. Manoukian, Jacob (12 December 2025). "Is AI a bubble? Here are 5 ways to find out". Morning Brew. Retrieved 14 January 2026.
  31. Yip, Jaures (29 October 2025). "Powell says AI is different from dotcom bubble and is major source of economic growth". CNBC. Retrieved 31 October 2025.