Comparative hearing

Last updated

The comparative hearing process was used by the United States Federal Radio Commission from 1927 to 1934 and its successor, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), from 1934 to 1994 for the evaluation of mutually exclusive applications for broadcast stations and other licenses. After designating such applications for hearing, commission examiners evaluated criteria to make an initial decision, which could then be appealed to a review board and then the full commission.

Contents

A confluence of factors in the 1990s, including a court case invalidating the commission's comparative criteria as arbitrary and capricious; an increased workload that had already led to the implementation of lotteries in certain fields in telecommunications and low-power television; and a desire to reduce the federal budget deficit, led to the FCC ultimately being required by Congress in the Balanced Budget Act of 1997 to auction off broadcast and other licenses to the highest bidder. The FCC had previously been authorized in 1993 to auction non-broadcast licenses.

History

Introduction

The establishment of the Federal Radio Commission in 1927 introduced evaluation of public interest criteria to determining the allocation of radio frequencies in the United States, a process once governed by first-user considerations in the early days of radio. [1] : 532  This continued into the FRC's successor, the Federal Communications Commission. In 1945, in Ashbacker Radio Corporation v. FCC, the Supreme Court of the United States required the FCC to hold comparative hearings for mutually exclusive station applications. [2] The commission standardized comparative criteria in 1965, issuing a policy statement with a consistent list. [2] : 496 

Reforms and use of alternate processes

In September 1983, two years after being authorized, [1] : 532  the first low-power TV license lottery was held to select 23 station licensees, with minority-owned applicants given greater weight. At the first lottery, numbers were loaded into one of the four drums that the Selective Service System had once employed for draft lotteries in the Vietnam War. [3] [4] Lotteries were also used to assign cellular telephone licenses from 1984 to 1989, as there were more than 1,400 such licenses to be awarded; however, the use of lotteries encouraged speculators and "application mills", as well as resale of granted licenses. [1] [2] : 511 

The FCC reformed the process in 1990 to cut down on "sham applications" that hoped to profit from settlement payments among applicants and make hearings less time-consuming, reducing the number of cases for which the review board held arguments. [5] In a 1998 journal article, economist Thomas Hazlett called the process "socially wasteful and politically charged". [1] : 530 

Discontinuation

On December 20, 1993, a federal appeals court ruled in Bechtel v. FCC that a longstanding comparative criterion, which favored the integration of ownership and management, was arbitrary and capricious. The case had been filed by the losing applicant for a radio station in Selbyville, Delaware, Susan Bechtel. The appeals court found that the FCC could not prove the superior benefits of "integrated" management, which usually materialized as a promise by the owner to move to the community in question to manage the station. [2] : 501  As a result, the commission froze all pending comparative cases on February 28, 1994, and began appointing settlement judges to allow applicants to withdraw pending cases. [6] [7] The freeze had an impact on new television networks, such as The WB, that were counting on the commission to approve new stations in varying areas of the United States. [2] : 507 

The Balanced Budget Act of 1997 extended the FCC's authority to auction spectrum, first granted by Congress in 1993 to allow the commission to auction non-broadcasting services, to allow radio and television auctions; [8] this came in the context of reducing the federal budget deficit, and the timing of its passage ensured it would have little impact on the transition to digital television in the U.S. [1] : 568  The commission urged settlements in frozen comparative cases until September 28, 1999, when parties were ordered to bid on the frequencies they had sought. Most notably affected by Bechtel and its aftermath was 96.5 FM at Biltmore Forest, North Carolina, near Asheville. When no settlement was held in the 11-year battle, for which an initial winning applicant had already started a station under temporary authority, had it rescinded and then restored, it was sent to auction among five remaining parties. [9] The initial station, WZLS, then definitively left the air in February 2002. [10]

Criteria

At the time the FCC abandoned the use of comparative criteria due to the ruling in Bechtel, these were the criteria: [11]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Federal Communications Commission</span> Independent U.S. government agency

The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is an independent agency of the United States federal government that regulates communications by radio, television, wire, satellite, and cable across the United States. The FCC maintains jurisdiction over the areas of broadband access, fair competition, radio frequency use, media responsibility, public safety, and homeland security.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">KALW</span> Public radio station in San Francisco

KALW (91.7 MHz) is an educational FM public radio station, licensed to the San Francisco Unified School District (SFUSD), which serves the San Francisco Bay Area. Its studios are located at Phillip and Sala Burton Academic High School off Mansell Avenue in San Francisco, and its transmitter tower is on Twin Peaks.

A broadcast license is a type of spectrum license granting the licensee permission to use a portion of the radio frequency spectrum in a given geographical area for broadcasting purposes. The licenses generally include restrictions, which vary from band to band.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">AM expanded band</span> Broadcast stations between 1600 and 1700 kHz

The extended mediumwave broadcast band, commonly known as the AM expanded band, refers to the broadcast station frequency assignments immediately above the earlier upper limits of 1600 kHz in International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Region 2, and 1602 kHz in ITU Regions 1 and 3.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Spectrum auction</span> Government auction of radio spectrum

A spectrum auction is a process whereby a government uses an auction system to sell the rights to transmit signals over specific bands of the electromagnetic spectrum and to assign scarce spectrum resources. Depending on the specific auction format used, a spectrum auction can last from a single day to several months from the opening bid to the final winning bid. With a well-designed auction, resources are allocated efficiently to the parties that value them the most, the government securing revenue in the process. Spectrum auctions are a step toward market-based spectrum management and privatization of public airwaves, and are a way for governments to allocate scarce resources.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">WCAV</span> CBS/Fox affiliate in Charlottesville, Virginia

WCAV is a television station in Charlottesville, Virginia, United States, affiliated with CBS and Fox. It is owned by Lockwood Broadcast Group alongside low-power ABC affiliate WVAW-LD. Both stations share studios on Rio East Court in Charlottesville, while WCAV's transmitter is located on Carters Mountain south of the city.

KAFM is a radio station located in Grand Junction, Colorado, United States.

Bandwidth allocation is the process of assigning radio frequencies to different applications. The radio spectrum is a finite resource, which means there is great need for an effective allocation process. In the United States, the Federal Communications Commission or FCC has the responsibility of allocating discrete portions of the spectrum, or bands, to various industries. The FCC did this recently, when it shifted the location of television broadcasting on the spectrum in order to open up more space for mobile data. Different bands of spectrum are able to transmit more data than others, and some bands of the spectrum transmit a clearer signal than others. Bands that are particularly fast or that have long range are of critical importance for companies that intend to operate a business involving wireless communications.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">WOXL-FM</span> Radio station in Biltmore Forest, North Carolina

WOXL-FM is a radio station licensed to Biltmore Forest, North Carolina, United States, the station serves the Asheville area and broadcasts a hot adult contemporary music format. The station is currently owned by the Asheville Radio Group subsidiary of Saga Communications.

KFTK was a commercial radio station that was licensed to East St. Louis, Illinois at 1490 AM, and broadcast from 1972 to 2020. KFTK's transmitter was located in East St. Louis. From 2016 to 2020, KFTK and low-power translator K254CR were operated by both Emmis Communications and Entercom as a full-time simulcast of KFTK-FM (97.1).

WXKD is a radio station licensed to serve Brantley, Alabama, United States. The station is owned by Roscoe Miller, through licensee Autaugaville Radio, Inc. It normally airs an Urban Contemporary format.

WGTW-TV is a religious television station licensed to Millville, New Jersey, United States, owned and operated by the Trinity Broadcasting Network (TBN). It previously served the Philadelphia, Pennsylvania television market, but can now only be received in Southern New Jersey. The station's studios are located on Columbia Avenue in suburban Folcroft, Pennsylvania; its transmitter was previously located in the Roxborough section of Philadelphia, but is now shared with True Crime Network affiliate WMGM-TV along Avalon Boulevard in the Swainton section of Middle Township, east of the Garden State Parkway off Exit 13.

<i>Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod v. FCC</i> In 1998

Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod v. FCC was a 1998 D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals case involving the Federal Communications Commission's (FCC) enforcement of the Equal Employment Opportunity Act and the Fifth Amendment. The FCC claimed that the Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod had violated the FCC's Equal Employment Opportunity requirements by not hiring enough minorities/women and by requiring a knowledge of Lutheran doctrine in order to be hired to work at its two FM and AM radio stations located in Clayton, Missouri.

KKXA is a commercial radio station licensed to Snohomish, Washington and serving the Seattle metropolitan area. The station's broadcast license is held by CAAM Partnership, LLC., an entity controlled by the Skotdal family, which also publishes the Everett Post newspaper. The KKXA studios are shared with sister station AM 1380 KRKO at the Key Tower building in downtown Everett, Washington. The transmitter is off Short School Road in Snohomish. KKXA airs a classic country radio format.

WTCF is a Contemporary Christian formatted broadcast radio station licensed to Wardensville, West Virginia, serving the Northern Shenandoah Valley in Virginia and the Eastern Panhandle and Potomac Highlands of West Virginia. WTCF is owned and operated by Educational Media Foundation.

WQQW was a commercial daytime-only radio station that was licensed to serve Highland, Illinois, at 1510 AM, and broadcast from 1998 to 2019. The station's transmitter site was located in the town of Pierron, Illinois.

The 1978 Broadcast Policy Statement on minority ownership is a publicly issued statement by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) regarding the state of minority and gender based ownership, the implications of previous ownership policies, and by taking affirmative action set into place two new additional policy measures aimed at progressing and encouraging continued diversity in media ownership. In this statement the FCC officially set forward two new programs favoring minority ownership of broadcasting facilities.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Planning permission</span> Government permission required for construction or expansion

Planning permission or developmental approval refers to the approval needed for construction or expansion, and sometimes for demolition, in some jurisdictions. It is usually given in the form of a building permit.

WHZN was a radio station that operated on 1300 kHz in Hazleton, Pennsylvania, United States. It operated as WTHT from 1961 to 1964 and WHZN from 1964 to 1965. The station was owned by Lou Adelman and closed due to a strike by union workers amid mounting financial and regulatory troubles.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">KZIS</span> Radio station in California, United States

KZIS is a radio station in Sacramento, California, United States. It is owned and operated by iHeartMedia, broadcasting from the iHeartMedia studio center in North Sacramento and a tower north of the city near Elverta, also used by KXPR and KQEI-FM. The station is broadcasting a Hot adult contemporary format as "Kiss 107.9".

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Hazlett, Thomas W. (October 1998). "Assigning Property Rights to Radio Spectrum Users: Why Did FCC License Auctions Take 67 Years?". The Journal of Law and Economics. 41 (S2): 529–576. doi:10.1086/467402. ISSN   0022-2186. S2CID   154325132.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 Halm, K.C. (1998). "Bechtel v. FCC: the beginning of the end of the FCC's comparative hearing process". Administrative Law Review. 50 (2): 491–514. ISSN   0001-8368. JSTOR   40709912.
  3. ↑ Isikoff, Michael (September 30, 1983). "FCC Holds Lottery for TV Licenses". The Washington Post . pp. C1, C3. ProQuest   147522526.
  4. ↑ Black, Norman (August 10, 1983). "TV License Lottery: FCC Rolls Out The Barrel". The State. Associated Press. p. 2-A. Retrieved February 11, 2023– via Newspapers.com.
  5. ↑ "FCC limits new station application payments" (PDF). Broadcasting. December 17, 1990. p. 39.
  6. ↑ Holland, Bill (March 12, 1994). "FCC Freezes Comparative Hearing Cases After Ruling". Billboard. p. 87. ProQuest   1506053797.
  7. ↑ Spangler, Matt (August 27, 1999). "Frozen Applicants Chilly To FCC Refund" (PDF). Radio & Records . pp. 4, 10.
  8. ↑ "Budgetary Implications of the Balanced Budget Act of 1997" (PDF). Congressional Budget Office . December 1997. p. 11. Archived (PDF) from the original on May 18, 2022. Retrieved August 1, 2022.
  9. ↑ Barrett, Mark (August 11, 1998). "Highest bid to settle radio fight: Dispute over radio frequency ownership may be resolved". Asheville Citizen-Times. Asheville, North Carolina. p. A1, A4 . Retrieved February 7, 2023– via Newspapers.com.
  10. ↑ Barrett, Mark (February 22, 2002). "WZLS loses 96.5 frequency; WOXL set to take over". Asheville Citizen-Times. p. A1, A7 . Retrieved February 7, 2023– via Newspapers.com.
  11. ↑ "Legal Guide to Broadcast Law and Regulation" (PDF). National Association of Broadcasters. 1996. pp. 19–23.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.