Early Church of Jerusalem

Last updated

The Early Church of Jerusalem is considered to be the first community of early Christianity. It was formed in Jerusalem after the crucifixion of Jesus. It proclaimed to Jews and non-Jews the resurrection of Jesus Christ, the forgiveness of sins and Jesus' commandments to prepare for his return (parousia ) and the associated end of the world.

Contents

Sources

There is little concrete evidence for the beginnings of the early Church of Jerusalem. Sources include the statements in Paul's letter to the Galatians, inferences from the synoptic gospels and, above all, statements from Luke's Acts of the Apostles. [1] These writings were written between 62 and around 100 AD. We can go further back in time with doctrinal traditions quoted by Paul of Tarsus in his letters. [2] The oldest Passion account integrated into the Gospel of Mark (Mk 14–15) was probably also written by early Christians in Jerusalem. [3]

Chronology

The chronological key dates provide an overview of the first events and evolution of the early church. [4]

ADEventsSources
30Death of JesusMk 15
~ 30–32Constitution of the church of Jerusalem

/first conflicts

Acts 1–5
As from 30Activity of the Jesus movement in Galilee; initially oral transmission of the Jesus tradition.Mk 16; Mt 28; Jn 21
31–43Peter leads the church of JerusalemActs 1–5
31/32Formation of a church in DamascusActs 9
~ 32Hebrews and Hellenists in JerusalemActs 6
32/33StephenActs 7
32/33Paul's callingActs 9; 22; 26
As from 33Philip's missionActs 8
~ 33–34Paul ArabiaGal 1,17–18
~ 34Foundation of the church in AntiochActs 11,19ff
351st Paul's visit to JerusalemGal 1,18
~ 35Barnabas is active in AntiochActs 11,22–26
~ 35–40Oral/written record of the Passion narrative, first specific collections of Jesus traditions.-
~ 36–42Paul in Syria and Cilicia (Tarsus)Acts 9,28–30
~ 40Founding of the church in Rome, 'Christians' as a separate group in AntiochActs11,26
~ 40–50Emergence of pre-Pauline traditions-
~ 42Paul joins AntiochActs 11,25–26
43/44Persecution under Agrippa I, Peter leaves Jerusalem and James becomes leader of the churchActs 12,1–4.17
~ 45–471st missionary journeyActs 13–14
48Apostles' Convention (spring); Antiochian incident (summer/autumn)Acts 15,1–34;

Gal 2,1–10.11–14

49Edict of ClaudiusActs 18,2
48–51/522nd missionary journeyActs 15–18
50/51Paul in CorinthActs 18,1–17
51/52Gallio in CorinthActs 18,12–17
52–55/563rd missionary journeyActs 18–21
52–54/55Paul in EphesusActs 19
55Paul's journey to MacedoniaActs 20:1-2; 2Cor 2:13
56(Beginning of the year:) Paul's last stay in Corinth(Acts 20,2–3)
56(Early summer:) Paul's arrival in JerusalemActs 21
56–58Paul's imprisonment in CaesareaActs 23–24
58Change of office Felix/FestusActs 24,27
59Paul's arrival in RomeActs 28,11ff
64Death of Peter and Paul-

Origins

Jesus' followers from Galilee, who had followed him to Jerusalem, probably dispersed after his arrest (Mk 14:50). Most of the disciples returned to their home villages after his burial at the latest, as his execution on the cross also seemed to have refuted his preaching of the imminent kingdom of God (Lk 24:21).

After they had come to believe in the resurrection of Jesus in Galilee, a group of disciples led by Peter returned to Jerusalem, which happened without attracting attention due to the constant arrival of pilgrims in the city. [5] Small house churches without a comprehensive organization probably emerged at around the same time, scattered all over Palestine. [6] They proclaimed Jesus as the Messiah of Israel and all nations. What motivated the followers of Jesus to do this is historically obscure, but is connected to their resurrection experiences.

According to Luke's account in Acts 2, the early church came into being through a miracle, the outpouring of the Holy Spirit on Pentecost. For the early Christians, this fulfilled the promise of the Spirit that the Jewish prophet Joel 3 had promised for the end times. For with Jesus' resurrection, the end times promised by Israel's prophets began for them. They therefore proclaimed the miracle of Pentecost as an anticipation of the coming of the kingdom of God, which overcomes all language barriers and allows all nationalities to join in the praise of God due to the forgiveness of sins obtained through Jesus (Dan 7:14). Accordingly, the author of Acts understood the early church as an eschatological community of salvation, in which the understanding between nations is already a reality and points to the promised peace between nations (Isa 2:2ff and Mic 4:1-5).

Members and organization

The early church essentially consisted of "disciples" - men and women - whom Jesus of Nazareth had already called to be his followers in Galilee and who had accompanied him on his way to Jerusalem. After the disciples proclaimed Jesus' resurrection, they were initially joined by Jews from very different backgrounds, many of them probably " devout" with a strong expectation of the end times. They were also joined by Pharisees, who brought with them their intensive study of the Hebrew Bible and their focus on God in everyday life. Zealots, who joined the early church, conveyed their commitment to the poor and disadvantaged. When (Acts 6:7) mentions that Jewish priests also "became obedient to the faith", they may have been Essenes living in Jerusalem. Ludger Schenke believes that parallels in self-image and practice between Qumran and the early church can be traced back to converted Essenes. [7]

Theodotos inscription, donor inscription of a Jerusalem synagogue of the 1st century AD (Israel Museum). 8V2A3067 (47715698331).jpg
Theodotos inscription, donor inscription of a Jerusalem synagogue of the 1st century AD (Israel Museum).

There were also many Greek-speaking Jews living in Jerusalem who had come from the Diaspora and for whom a more conservative orientation and a very positive attitude toward the temple can be assumed. If some were disappointed with the temple cult as they experienced it there, they may have joined the early church and introduced the temple criticism that later characterized the Jerusalem "Hellenists". [8]

Twelve of the male followers called by Jesus are highlighted by name in the Gospels as the first called and a reflection of the Twelve Tribes of Israel. Judas Iscariot, who belonged to this circle, is said to have taken his own life after betraying Jesus to the high council; according to Acts 1:21f, Matthias took his place. Schenke assumes that the Twelve (under Peter's leadership) led the Jerusalem church as a college. However, this college only existed for a short time, as Paul did not meet it again when he visited Jerusalem. The restoration of the Twelve Tribes of Israel had programmatic significance in Jerusalem in particular. [9] The early dogmatization of the Twelve in all the Gospels also shows that the early church saw itself as the end-time forerunner of the entire people of God, chosen by the Messiah Jesus Christ, who was glorified by God. [10] Their mission to Israel therefore had priority for them.

According to the New Testament, Jesus showed himself to his disciples as the Risen One and called them to mission: this established their authority as apostles. As Simon Peter experienced the first appearance of the Risen Lord, he was confirmed in his leadership position, which he had already held in the circle of disciples during Jesus' lifetime. Schenke refers to the tradition passage Lk 22:31-32 and assumes that the group of disciples was in a serious crisis (apparently after Jesus' death on the cross), and Peter called the discouraged together and strengthened them. [11] Anyone who had an apparition of the Risen One after Jesus' death and had been commissioned by him for mission was considered an apostle. This circle went beyond the Twelve: only Luke identified it with the leaders and founders of the early church. It is uncertain until when the circle of twelve was in charge. In his letter to the Galatians (written 50–57), Paul only mentions the "three pillars" James, Simon Peter and John (Gal 2:9). [12]

Icon representation of St. James Saint James the Just.jpg
Icon representation of St. James

According to the list of witnesses of the early church (1 Cor 15:3-8 ), James, a brother of Jesus, had received his own vision of the risen Christ. He had not been a follower of Jesus during his lifetime, but became the leader of the early church after Easter. [13] He represented the group of "Judaizers", who demanded that all newly baptized Gentile Christians observe important Torah commandments, possibly also circumcision, i.e. conversion to Judaism. This is why Paul named him over Peter, who usually comes first in all lists of apostles, as the main partner in his negotiations on the Gentile mission. His companion Barnabas, a Levite from Cyprus, played an important role in this. Due to his diaspora background, he was able to mediate between Greek-speaking and Aramaic-speaking early Christians. [14]

The Acts of the Apostles reports the election of seven deacons to care for the poor (Acts 6). Schenke assumes that these were charismatic missionaries who addressed the Greek-speaking Jews in Jerusalem. As the Greek speaking part of the early church of Jerusalem became organizationally independent, they became its governing body; however, the Twelve continued to lead the church as a whole, so that according to Schenke there was no competition. [15] The Jewish priests who had joined the early church continued to perform their duties at the temple, and Jewish scribes who joined the early church worked there as teachers (rabbis). The early church had no need for its own ministerial structure because it was convinced that the end of the world was imminent. For this reason, no successors were envisaged for the seven or the twelve. [16]

Prophets were probably also an essential element of the early church, and like their colleagues in Corinth, they received direct revelations from God, spoke in "tongues" and had various "charisms" (gifts of grace) to share (1 Cor 12:12ff). [17]

The number of members can only be estimated. According to Acts 1:13-15, there were initially only around 120 "brothers", whereas Acts 2:41 already mentions 3,000 first baptized after Peter's first sermon, 4:4 soon after 5,000: however, these figures appear to be far inflated in view of the meetings in the Jerusalem temple tolerated by the Sanhedrin. The Roman authorities would not have simply allowed a large messianic group in Jerusalem. [18]

Theology and worship

The ideal image of the early church is primarily determined by the description in Acts 2:37-47: The early Christian missionary preaching, which is entirely focused on the proclamation of Jesus' resurrection and his exaltation as "Kyrios", is followed here by the conversion and baptism of new disciples. This meant forgiveness of sin and thus acceptance into the end-time community of salvation. This meant salvation from the expected final judgment and reception of the Holy Spirit, who enabled them to keep Jesus' commandments and spread his "teaching".

According to Luke (Acts 2, 42–26), the following criteria united the early Christians into a community:

Fixed liturgical structures or uniformity were not yet to be expected at the gatherings in the houses. It can be assumed that someone presided over the meal and opened it by breaking and sharing the bread. This is also indicated by the fixed term "breaking of bread" for the meal celebration. A reminder that some early Christians abstained from wine may have been preserved in Mk 14:25. The gatherings anticipated the imminent end times, which explains the great joy of the participants (Acts 2:46). It can be assumed that the scriptures were read out at the meetings and interpreted with a view to their own everyday lives and the significance of Jesus Christ (Christology). In this respect, the gatherings were places where early Christian traditions could develop. [20] The communal prayer of supplication was considered to be particularly effective (cf. Mt 18:19-20) and is likely to have played an important role in the gatherings. The Lord's Prayer is the only early Christian prayer form that has been passed down. [21] The early Christian call to prayer Maranatha ("Our Lord, come!") is attested by Paul, the Didache and (in Greek translation) Rev 22:20-21. [22] Based on the Didache, it can be assumed that this call to Maranatha concluded the early Christian celebration of the Eucharist. [23] The feeding miracles in the Gospels can be interpreted in terms of the early Christian celebration of the meal. They show that they were filling main meals that were celebrated as a foreshadowing of the end-time banquet of joy. [24]

Baptism by immersion in water (preferably running water) was the initiation rite of the early church. A very old baptismal formula is recorded in Acts 2:38. According to this, the person being baptized pronounced the name of Jesus and thereby became the property of the Messiah, whose end-time return was expected. He was thus protected in a special way in the threats of the end times. His sins were forgiven and he received the Holy Spirit. It can be assumed from the ancient gloss Acts 8:37 that the baptized person also made a profession of faith. [25]

The first sermons of Peter, which Luke edited, reflect the basic ideas of the early Christian mission: for them, Jesus was the bringer of salvation for God's people announced throughout Israel's entire biblical history, whose death on the cross as the final judgment fulfilled the promises of blessing to the patriarchs, whose resurrection brought about God's reconciliation with Israel, opened salvation to the nations and called the listeners of the sermon to comprehensive repentance.

The creedal formulas taken up by Paul also place Jesus' self-giving and his resurrection by God at the center of the early Christian doctrine of faith.

Community of goods

Whether the members of the Jerusalem church actually lived without property and shared all their possessions is disputed. Some exegetes point out that Luke presents the early church as the realization of "social utopias of an ideal community often found in ancient philosophy." An analogous tradition is, for example, Pythagoras' community of goods. [26]

However, very early passages in the Q source already define the lack of possessions as a condition of following Jesus (Mt 10:9f). This is because the disciples belonged to the beggarly poor (Greek: ptochoi), who made up the majority of the Galilean and Judean population (ochlos) at the time. Based on the beatitudes of Jesus' Sermon on the Mount, they were regarded as the true chosen people of God (Mt 4:1-11). The rich were also invited to give up their possessions in order to become Jesus' disciples (Mk 10:21). For formerly wealthy followers of Jesus, this was not just general charity, but an obligatory part of neighbourly love towards the poor (cf. Lk 6:27-35).

The sharing of possessions and food, community of goods and feeding the poor was also practised in other Jewish end-time communities, such as the presumed Qumran group, who, however, did not turn to the majority of the people, but withdrew into the desert as a "holy remnant". [27] In Jesus' case, on the other hand, the giving up of possessions was not aimed at ascetic perfection, but at the real earthly anticipation of the heavenly justice that God had promised the poor with the coming of the Messiah (Lk 4:16-21). For example, the possessions of tax collectors ("tax collectors") were regarded as plunder, acquired at the expense of their impoverished and indebted compatriots. The followers of Jesus were to go through all areas of Israel to proclaim the imminent kingdom of God and thus the imminent end of these exploitative conditions (Mt 10:5-15), without worrying about accumulating possessions and making a living like rich people (Mt 6:24-33).

It was not until Luke's time, when the early Christian mission had reached the wealthy coastal towns of Asia Minor, that Jesus' disciples' natural task of giving up their possessions became a moral appeal, which was apparently only followed in exceptional cases and was therefore emphasized (Acts 4:36f). Luke therefore highlighted examples in his Gospel where Jesus persuaded relatively rich people like Zacchaeus to return their possessions to those who had been robbed (Luke 19:1-11). Some sold all their possessions and brought the money to the apostles, who used it to provide for the entire community (Acts 4:32-37 [1]). This care for the poor was no longer a sign of solidarity within the Jewish people, but served to equalize the wealth of poorer and richer Christians within the community. However, this remained unusual within the ancient society and attractive to the poorer classes. There are only certain parallels to support in Hellenistic associations. [28]

According to Acts 5:1-11, a married couple (Ananias and Sapphira) died after transferring only part of the proceeds of the land they had sold to the early church. According to one interpretation, keeping property that belonged to everyone for oneself was a taboo here: [29] Anyone who kept back any of their property was "betraying" the Holy Spirit himself and thus losing their right to live. According to another interpretation, the radical renunciation of possessions was voluntary (cf. Acts 5:4) and was particularly praised by Barnabas (Acts 4:36-37). However, Hananias and Sapphira took this step half-heartedly, which was interpreted as an attempt to deceive God and the Holy Spirit. Schenke suspects that some Jerusalem Christians "owned houses, land and capital. They were not 'expropriated'." [30] Thus, giving up property was not legally institutionalized, but rather made available to all fellow Christians, for example their own house as a meeting place. According to Schenke, the money collected through sales went into a "common fund", which was used for social emergencies, perhaps also for the purchase of burial sites. [30]

Luke's depiction of the early Christian community of goods has sometimes been interpreted as an early form of communism. However, this term also includes the upheaval of production relations, which is not mentioned in the book of Acts. Since the early church saw itself as an anticipation of the end-time people of God, its expectations of salvation, like those of Judaism, also indirectly included the future radical change in property and power relations (cf. Lk 1:46-55 ). [31] The ideal of the community of goods, which anticipated this expectation, has continued to have an impact in many ways in the history of Christianity, for example in some monastic orders, monastic communities and basic ecclesial communities.

Groups and conflicts

According to the Acts of the Apostles, the members of the early church initially lived together in harmony. But the growth of the church soon brought problems. According to Acts 6:1-6, the widows from the Greek-speaking [32] part of the church were overlooked in the daily care of the poor. This indicates that this sub-group was organizationally independent; perhaps the Aramaic-speaking early Christians also had reservations about them. [33] As a result, the general assembly of the early church selected seven "deacons" (helpers, servants) to ensure that everyone was cared for fairly. Stephen, Philip, Prochorus, Nicanor, Timon, Parmenas and Nicholas were named.

Their task is unclear: they are not reported to have performed diaconal services, but Stephen (Acts 6:8) and Philip (Acts 8:4-13; Acts 8:26-40) acted as missionaries. Their election is therefore not only seen as a solution to an administrative problem, but also as an indication of conflicts between Jewish Christians and Hellenistic Jewish Christians in Jerusalem. [34] Apparently, the leadership role of the apostles there was disputed early on. This may also have been related to material problems: The early church received donations for the poor from the other new Christian communities (Gal 2:10; Acts 11:29). With their election, the Hellenists in the early church evidently received the right to distribute it and thus a certain degree of autonomy.

This internal conflict was accompanied by the distrust of the highest Jewish authority in Jerusalem, the Sanhedrin. According to Acts 4, it interrogated Peter and John and tried to stop their missionary preaching. However, the sympathy of the people had preserved the leaders of the early church (Acts 4:21). After their re-arrest, it was the advice of the Pharisee Gamaliel that secured their release (Acts 5:34-40). Hans Conzelmann points out that the Pharisees are portrayed several times in Luke as being relatively well-disposed towards the Christians because both groups shared a belief in the resurrection. [35]

The beginnings of the Gentile mission probably came from the Hellenists, as their leader Stephen criticized the Mosaic Law and the temple cult (Acts 6:13f). [36] He publicly accused the Sanhedrin of breaking the law and of murdering Jesus. This was followed by a religious trial that ended with his stoning (Acts 7:56). [37] As a result, part of the early church was expelled from Jerusalem and dispersed into the neighboring regions. The circle of twelve remained in Jerusalem as the nucleus of a rebuilding of the early church (Acts 8:1). From then on, however, Luke reports nothing more about them.

Hellenistic missionaries such as Philip founded new churches (Acts 8:40), so that Christianity expanded into Samaria, Syria and Asia Minor. The first large mixed congregation of Jews and Gentiles besides Jerusalem was founded in the Asia Minor metropolis of Antioch. Apparently, it was made easier or waived for these new Christians to observe the Jewish commandments: This is why they were fiercely persecuted by Jews loyal to the Torah, such as the Pharisee Paul, on behalf of the Sanhedrin (Acts 8:1). However, after his unexpected conversion, he advocated a Torah-free mission to the nations and initially carried out missionary work in the Mediterranean region independently of the apostles of the early church (Acts 8–10).

The Apostolic Council

After the expulsion and flight of the Hellenists, Peter and the Twelve gave up their sedentary lifestyle in Jerusalem and went about as itinerant missionaries, as they had already done during Jesus' lifetime. The model of the end-time pilgrimage of the nations to Zion faded; instead, Jerusalem became the starting point of a "centrifugal" early Christian mission of unprecedented intensity that encompassed the entire Mediterranean region. Peter, John and James were only occasionally to be found in Jerusalem, and no trace of the other apostles remains. In place of the college of twelve, James, the brother of the Lord, became the leader of the early church of Jerusalem, and other members of Jesus' family probably also took on leadership roles. For the first time, elders (presbyters) are now also mentioned in Jerusalem; this is probably the leadership college of the Aramaic-speaking early Christians, corresponding to the seven who led the Greek-speaking part of the church until the expulsion of the Hellenists. [38] Schenke assumes that the Jewish Christian community led by James and the presbyteral college developed forms of organization in which a kind of "church discipline" was practised and sinners were excluded if rebuke was unsuccessful. [39]

The early Christian Hellenists also turned to Greeks who had no Jewish background. As a result, the proportion of so-called Gentile Christians - newly baptized people of non-Jewish descent - in early Christianity grew. Jewish regulations were imposed on them in many communities. Initially, the "Judaizers" among the apostles of the early church probably also tolerated this; Paul reports no restrictions after his first visit to Jerusalem, where he met Jesus' brother James (Gal 1:18f). However, tensions later arose between him and Peter, whom Luke portrays as the first missionary to the Gentiles (Acts 10), over the issue of purity laws (Acts 11). Apparently, the leaders of the early church disagreed as to whether the Gentile Christians should be subject to certain conditions and if so, which ones.

The different approaches of the missionaries called into question the leadership role and identity of the early church and threatened the unity of early Christianity as a whole. The issue of circumcision, in particular, led to a crucial test: should Gentiles also be circumcised at baptism and thus obliged to observe the entire Jewish Torah? If they did not observe their eating and purity laws, the common meal between Christians of Jewish and Gentile origin in the congregations would also become a problem. This raised the fundamental theological question of whether being a Christian was only possible as part of Judaism or whether this boundary was no longer valid.

This fundamentally affected the self-image of the early church: it saw itself primarily as the "vanguard" of God's people Israel, who had yet to be saved, saved by the Messiah from sin and divine wrath. According to this, Gentile Christians were " called ones" who owed their salvation entirely to the "excess of grace" of the mediator of salvation, Jesus Christ. The lack of clarity as to what this meant in relation to the "covenant of God with Israel (Brit)" and the instructions given to Israel by God (Torah) pushed for a binding solution.

The insistence of some Jerusalem apostles that the Jewish commandments were also binding for Gentile Christians caused a lack of understanding among the Hellenistic apostles. There was a threat of a division into congregations of Jewish Christians and Gentile Christians. To prevent this, both sides asserted all their authority. The Jerusalem apostles summoned a meeting of the missionaries to settle the dispute; on the way there, Barnabas and Paul became spokesmen for the Gentile Christian churches (Acts 15:1-3). [40]

The so-called Apostles' Council (also known as the Apostles' Convention) was a decisive turning point in the history of early Christianity. Paul and Luke describe its course and results differently. According to Acts 15, there was a plenary meeting of the early church at which the Judaizers initially argued that the circumcision of the Gentile Christians was necessary. This was followed by an internal debate between Peter, Barnabas, Paul, James and probably others. The essence of the law-free Gentile mission according to Gal 2:1-14 was confirmed. This prevented the division of early Christianity. However, the validity of the Jewish ritual laws remained a controversial issue afterwards. [41]

Further events

The early church had survived the persecution after the execution of Stephen (around 36) (Acts 7:59) as well as the execution of James the Great under Herod Agrippa I (44) (Acts 12:2) and was therefore still tolerated by the leading groups of Judaism. It was therefore able to send out its missionaries to the Jews and Gentiles from Jerusalem to the surrounding regions.

Notes in the Gospels reveal the regions in which new Christian communities were founded: Mk 3:7, for example, lists Idumea (in southern Judea), Perea (in the east) and Phoenicia (coastal region in the west) in addition to Galilee, Judea and Jerusalem. Instead, Mt 4:24 mentions the Decapolis, a Hellenistic confederation of cities on the East Bank, and Syria, while Lk 6:17 mentions Samaria as well as Phoenicia. After his conversion, Paul not only visited Damascus, but also "Arabia" (Gal 1:17): This meant the kingdom of the Nabataeans east of Judea at the time. If the information is added together, one gets a rough picture of the dispersion of the Christian communities in and around Palestine up to around 100. [42]

After the Apostles' Council, the Acts of the Apostles almost exclusively depicts Paul's missionary journeys and offers hardly any news about the early church. The Jerusalem group of twelve had probably already been replaced by a committee of three under the leadership of Jesus' eldest brother (Mk 6:3), James (Gal 2:9); the other apostles no longer appear. Peter had left Jerusalem after the council and traveled around Asia Minor as a missionary (Gal 2:11-14; 1 Cor 9). [43]

Only James and the "elders" are later mentioned again as recipients of the collection for the poor that Paul had been instructed to make at the council (Acts 21:15ff). It is therefore assumed that he had now become the sole leader of the early church. According to Gal 2:12, he apparently enforced the resolutions of the Apostles' Council outside Jerusalem and, according to Acts 21:21-25, supported the separation of the Jewish Christians from the Gentile Christians even after Paul's missionary successes. Until his death, the early church retained its pre-eminent position in early Christianity.

Although Paul had to fight against groups in his churches who rejected or distorted his law-free mission to the Gentiles, he did not identify their missionaries as his enemies (including the "super-apostles" in 2 Cor 11:5;12:11), but always recognized the primacy of the early church: This is confirmed by his collection for them in his letter to the Romans around 60 (Rom 15:25-28).

As a peripheral group of Palestinian Judaism, the early church of Jerusalem was severely affected by the intensifying conflicts between parts of the Jewish population and the Roman occupation. When Paul delivered his collection in Jerusalem, he found a large Jewish-Christian community that kept its distance from him. According to the Acts of the Apostles, Sicarii planned his murder. The First Epistle to the Thessalonians (written around 50), in which Paul vehemently polemicizes against the Jewish authorities persecuting his mission (1 Thess 2:14-16), seems to reflect a politically tense situation in which there was "harassment and hostility against Christians and Christian communities in Palestine". [44]

According to Flavius Josephus, the Sadducees under the high priest Ananias II (Annas) took advantage of the power vacuum after the death of the governor Festus until the arrival of his successor to execute James with other Jewish Christians in Jerusalem. [45] His death is dated to the year 62.

Eusebius of Caesarea wrote in the 4th century that most members of the Jerusalem early church had fled to the East Bank, to Pella, before the start of the Jewish War in 68. [46] Ludger Schenke summarizes: "Palestinian Jewish Christianity was fighting for its existence in a hopeless situation. It was caught between all camps ... The Jerusalem early church left the city at the beginning of the Jewish War. Their trace ... is lost in the darkness of history." [47]

Several authors of the early church claim to have information about the fate of the early church of Jerusalem after the destruction of the temple in the year 70: A remnant church had been re-established in the ruins of Jerusalem; sons of James and other relatives of Jesus had led it and ensured the continuity of its traditions. [48] In the course of the Bar Kochba Revolt (132–135), this remnant church had fled Jerusalem for good. [49]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Acts of the Apostles</span> Book of the New Testament

The Acts of the Apostles is the fifth book of the New Testament; it tells of the founding of the Christian Church and the spread of its message to the Roman Empire.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Barnabas</span> Early Christian disciple and bishop

Barnabas, born Joseph (Ἰωσήφ) or Joses (Ἰωσής), was according to tradition an early Christian, one of the prominent Christian disciples in Jerusalem. According to Acts 4:36, Barnabas was a Cypriot Levite. Named an apostle in Acts 14:14, he and Paul the Apostle undertook missionary journeys together and defended Gentile converts against the Judaizers. They traveled together making more converts, and participated in the Council of Jerusalem. Barnabas and Paul successfully evangelized among the "God-fearing" Gentiles who attended synagogues in various Hellenized cities of Anatolia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paul the Apostle</span> Christian apostle and missionary

Paul also named Saul of Tarsus, commonly known as Paul the Apostle and Saint Paul, was a Christian apostle who spread the teachings of Jesus in the first-century world. For his contributions towards the New Testament, he is generally regarded as one of the most important figures of the Apostolic Age, and he also founded several Christian communities in Asia Minor and Europe from the mid-40s to the mid-50s AD.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pauline Christianity</span> Form of Christianity developed from the doctrines of the Apostle Paul

Pauline Christianity or Pauline theology, otherwise referred to as Gentile Christianity, is the theology and form of Christianity which developed from the beliefs and doctrines espoused by the Hellenistic-Jewish Apostle Paul through his writings and those New Testament writings traditionally attributed to him. Paul's beliefs were rooted in the earliest Jewish Christianity, but they deviated from this Jewish Christianity in their emphasis on inclusion of the Gentiles into God's New Covenant and in his rejection of circumcision as an unnecessary token of upholding the Mosaic Law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Council of Jerusalem</span> First Christian synod (c. 48–50 AD)

The Council of Jerusalem or Apostolic Council is a council described in chapter 15 of the Acts of the Apostles, held in Jerusalem c. 48–50 AD.

Günther Bornkamm was a German New Testament scholar belonging to the school of Rudolf Bultmann and a Professor of New Testament at the University of Heidelberg. Under Adolf Hitler, he opposed the nazification of the Protestant churches and their unification into the movement of the 'German Christians'. His post-war fame as a scholar rested on his effort to separate fiction from facts in his reconstruction of Jesus' life and in his subsequent treatment of the gospel of Matthew. His brother was the ecclesiastical historian and Luther scholar Heinrich Bornkamm.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Friedrich Spitta</span> German Protestant theologian (1852–1924)

Friedrich Spitta was a German Protestant theologian.

The persecution of Christians in the New Testament is an important part of the Early Christian narrative which depicts the early church as being persecuted for their heterodox beliefs by a Jewish establishment in the Roman province of Judea. The New Testament, especially the Gospel of John, has traditionally been interpreted as relating Christian accounts of the Pharisee rejection of Jesus and accusations of the Pharisee responsibility for his crucifixion. The Acts of the Apostles depicts instances of early Christian persecution by the Sanhedrin, the Jewish religious court.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">God-fearer</span> Greco-Roman sympathizers to Hellenistic Judaism

God-fearers or God-worshippers were a numerous class of Gentile sympathizers to Hellenistic Judaism that existed in the Greco-Roman world, which observed certain Jewish religious rites and traditions without becoming full converts to Judaism. The concept has precedents in the proselytes of the Hebrew Bible.

Christianity began as a Second Temple Judaic sect in the 1st century in the Roman province of Judea, from where it spread throughout and beyond the Roman Empire.

Cullmann, Oscar (1953). Peter, Disciple, Apostle, Martyr: A Historical and Theological Study. Philadelphia: Westminster Press. p. 18. The incident at Antioch was an Apostolic Age dispute between the apostles Paul and Peter which occurred in the city of Antioch around the middle of the first century. The primary source for the incident is Paul's Epistle to the Galatians 2:11–14. Since the 19th century figure Ferdinand Christian Baur, biblical scholars have found evidence of conflict among the leaders of early Christianity; for example, James D. G. Dunn proposes that Peter was a "bridge-man" between the opposing views of Paul and James, brother of Jesus. The final outcome of the incident remains uncertain, resulting in several Christian views on the Old Covenant.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paul the Apostle and Jewish Christianity</span>

Since the 1970s, scholars have sought to place Paul the Apostle within his historical context in Second Temple Judaism. Paul's relationship to Judaism involves topics including the status of Israel's covenant with God and the role of works as a means to either gain or keep the covenant.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Christianity in the 1st century</span> Christianity-related events during the 1st century

Christianity in the 1st century covers the formative history of Christianity from the start of the ministry of Jesus to the death of the last of the Twelve Apostles and is thus also known as the Apostolic Age. Early Christianity developed out of the eschatological ministry of Jesus. Subsequent to Jesus' death, his earliest followers formed an apocalyptic messianic Jewish sect during the late Second Temple period of the 1st century. Initially believing that Jesus' resurrection was the start of the end time, their beliefs soon changed in the expected Second Coming of Jesus and the start of God's Kingdom at a later point in time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Historical reliability of the Acts of the Apostles</span>

The historical reliability of the Acts of the Apostles, the principal historical source for the Apostolic Age, is of interest for biblical scholars and historians of Early Christianity as part of the debate over the historicity of the Bible. Historical reliability is not dependent on a source being inerrant or void of agendas since there are sources that are considered generally reliable despite having such traits.

Early Christianity, otherwise called the Early Church or Paleo-Christianity, describes the historical era of the Christian religion up to the First Council of Nicaea in 325. Christianity spread from the Levant, across the Roman Empire, and beyond. Originally, this progression was closely connected to already established Jewish centers in the Holy Land and the Jewish diaspora throughout the Eastern Mediterranean. The first followers of Christianity were Jews who had converted to the faith, i.e. Jewish Christians, as well as Phoenicians, i.e. Lebanese Christians. Early Christianity contains the Apostolic Age and is followed by, and substantially overlaps with, the Patristic era.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Apostles in the New Testament</span> Primary disciples of Jesus

In Christian theology and ecclesiology, the apostles, particularly the Twelve Apostles, were the primary disciples of Jesus according to the New Testament. During the life and ministry of Jesus in the 1st century AD, the apostles were his closest followers and became the primary teachers of the gospel message of Jesus. There is also an Eastern Christian tradition derived from the Gospel of Luke that there were seventy apostles during the time of Jesus' ministry.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Acts 10</span> Chapter of the New Testament

Acts 10 is the tenth chapter of the Acts of the Apostles in the New Testament of the Christian Bible. The book containing this chapter is anonymous but early Christian tradition uniformly affirmed that Luke composed this book as well as the Gospel of Luke. This chapter records the vision of Saint Peter and his meeting with Cornelius in Caesarea.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Acts 11</span> Chapter of the New Testament

Acts 11 is the eleventh chapter of the Acts of the Apostles in the New Testament of the Christian Bible. It records that Saint Peter defends his visit to Cornelius in Caesarea and retells his vision prior to the meeting as well as the pouring of Holy Spirit during the meeting. The book containing this chapter is anonymous but early Christian tradition uniformly affirmed that Luke composed this book as well as the Gospel of Luke.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Flight to Pella</span>

The fourth-century Church Fathers Eusebius of Caesarea and Epiphanius of Salamis cite a tradition that before the destruction of Jerusalem in AD 70 the early Christians had been warned to flee to Pella in the region of the Decapolis across the Jordan River. The flight to Pella probably did not include the Ebionites.

The community of goods of the early church of Jerusalem refers to the transfer of all property and sharing the proceeds with those in need, which Luke's Acts of the Apostles in the New Testament highlights as a characteristic of this first community of early Christianity in Jerusalem. To emulate this New Testament account, several later Christian groups attempted to share their property and administer it jointly in whole or in part.

References

  1. Pock, Johann (2006). Gemeinden zwischen Idealisierung und Planungszwang (in German). Vienna: LIT Verlag. p. 86.
  2. Cf. Leonhard Goppelt (1978): Theologie des Neuen Testaments (In German). Göttingen, p. 325.
  3. On this thesis see Rudolf Pesch: Das Evangelium in Jerusalem: Mk 14,12-26 als ältestes Überlieferungsgut der Urgemeinde. In: Peter Stuhlmacher (ed.): Das Evangelium und die Evangelien: Vorträge vom Tübinger Symposium 1982 (= Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament. Vol. 28). Mohr Siebeck, Tübingen 1983, pp. 113-155.
  4. Schnelle, Udo (2019): Die ersten 100 Jahre des Christentums 30-130 A.D.Die Entstehung einer Weltreligion. Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 3rd revised edition. Göttingen p. 238 (plate 4: Chronologie des frühen Christentumsbis 50 AD) and p. 327 (plate 5: Chronologie des frühen Christentums bis 70 AD)
  5. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 22.
  6. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 23.
  7. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 67 f.
  8. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 70
  9. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 75-78.
  10. Cf. Leonhard Goppelt: Theologie des Neuen Testaments, Göttingen 1978, p. 259. Behind this formulation is Goppelt's thesis of a gradual development of the church as the new people of God, Israel: "The circle of twelve is its symbolic foreshadowing, the church of Pentecost its fundamental realization, the church under the Pauline gospel its fundamental development." Quoted here from: Horst Simonsen: Leonhard Goppelt (1911-1973). Eine theologische Biographie. Exegese in theologischer und kirchlicher Verantwortung. Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, Göttingen 2004, p. 151.
  11. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 20-22.
  12. Cf. Conzelmann, Hans (1976). Geschichte des Urchristentums, Göttingen, p. 41.
  13. Cf. Conzelmann, Hans (1976). Geschichte des Urchristentums, Göttingen, p. 28.
  14. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 79.
  15. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 78.
  16. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 80.
  17. Cf. Conzelmann, Hans (1976). Geschichte des Urchristentums, Göttingen, p. 36
  18. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 66.
  19. Cf. Leonhard Goppelt: Theologie des Neuen Testaments, Göttingen 1978, p. 336: "They visited the temple not only to do missionary work, but also to take part in the temple service."
  20. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, pp. 94 and 111. Schenke also compares the Encratites of the early church to the renunciation of wine.
  21. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 96.
  22. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 98.
  23. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 109.
  24. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 110.
  25. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 115.
  26. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 91.
  27. Cf. Conzelmann, Hans (1976). Geschichte des Urchristentums, Göttingen, p. 34.
  28. Cf. on this: Markus Öhler (2005). Die Jerusalemer Urgemeinde im Spiegel des antiken Vereinswesens. In: New Testament Studies 51, pp. 393-415.
  29. Cf. Conzelmann, Hans (1976). Geschichte des Urchristentums, Göttingen, p. 22.
  30. 1 2 Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 93.
  31. Cf. Hans Conzelmann (1976). Geschichte des Urchristentums, Göttingen, p. 35: "early Christian communism was never a social reality. And Luke, who sketches this picture of the community of goods in the Acts of the Apostles, does not turn it into a program for shaping the church of his own time."
  32. The early Christians referred to as "Hellenists" in the Acts of the Apostles were not former non-Jews or Jews who had adapted particularly strongly to the Greek way of life, but Jews of Greek mother tongue. Cf. Ludger Schenke: Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart 1990, p. 72.
  33. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 72.
  34. Cf. Hans Conzelmann: Geschichte des Urchristentums, Göttingen 1976, p. 43f. "It is clear that the Seven are not the caretakers of the poor, but the leading body of a special group of the church; they are not below, but next to the Twelve." (S. 44)
  35. Conzelmann Hans (1976) Geschichte des Urchristentums, Göttingen , p. 46:
  36. In contrast, Leonhard Goppelt (1978) Theologie des Neuen Testaments, Göttingen , p. 338: The Jerusalem Hellenists, whom Stephen represents, criticized the temple cult, but freedom from the law was not an issue for them.
  37. Cf. Hans Conzelmann (1976). Geschichte des Urchristentums, Göttingen, p. 47: The account of the Acts of the Apostles shimmers between lynching and orderly trial to show: "The highest authority behaves like a gang and makes a mockery of true justice."
  38. Ludger Schenke (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart , pp. 241-244. According to Schenke, Mark 3:31-35 shows that the claim to leadership of Jesus' relatives met with criticism.
  39. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, pp. 241-244.
  40. On the Council of the Apostles, see Hans Conzelmann (1976). Geschichte des Urchristentums, Göttingen , especially p. 70: According to Conzelmann, the Acts of the Apostles is "one-sidedly focused on Jerusalem's leadership role. But in reality, Paul is a partner, not a recipient of orders." According to Conzelmann, where the Letter to the Galatians gives different information, it always deserves preference as a source.
  41. Cf. Conzelmann, Hans (1976). Geschichte des Urchristentums, Göttingen, p. 72
  42. Cf. Conzelmann, Hans (1976). Geschichte des Urchristentums, Göttingen, p. 49. On Arabia cf. p. 66.
  43. Cf. Conzelmann, Hans (1976). Geschichte des Urchristentums, Göttingen, p. 92
  44. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 249.
  45. Flavius Josephus: Antiquities of the Jews 20,199-203.
  46. Eusebius of Caesarea: Church History 3,5,3. The historicity of the Pella tradition is questioned in particular by Gerd Lüdemann, see Udo Schnelle: Theologie des Neuen Testaments. Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 3rd revised edition Göttingen 2016, p. 358.
  47. Schenke, Ludger (1990). Die Urgemeinde. Geschichtliche und theologische Entwicklung, Stuttgart, p. 260.
  48. Cf. Eusebius of Caesarea: Demonstratio evangelica 3,5 (large Christian community in Jerusalem) and Church History 4,5,3 (list of Jerusalem bishops).
  49. Cf. Justin Martyr: Apology 1,31,6: "During the recent Jewish war, Bar Kochba, the leader of the Jewish revolt, ordered only Christians to be led away to the most severe punishments if they did not deny and blaspheme Christ." However, Bar Kochba did not control Jerusalem, where a Roman legion was stationed: see Hanan Eshel: The Bar Kochba Revolt, 132-135. In: Steven T. Katz (ed.): The Cambridge History of Judaism. Volume 4: The Late Roman - Rabbinic Period. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2006, p. 115; Werner Eck: Rom und Judaea, Tübingen 2007, p. 116, Menahem Mor: The Second Jewish Revolt. The Bar Kokhba War, 132-136 CE. Brill, Leiden 2016, p. 437.

Bibliography