The food of The Bear is central to the storytelling and relationship-building on the series The Bear , an episodic television dramedy based the world of U.S. restaurants after the COVID-19 pandemic. The two main characters, Carmy Berzatto (Jeremy Allen White) and Sydney Adamu (Ayo Edebiri), are exquisitely trained, experienced, elite chefs who work together to save Berzatto family restaurant, a failing Italian beef sandwich joint, and launch a new high-end dining destination called The Bear. The show's culinary producer, Courtney "Coco" Storer, is an experienced chef and the sister of series creator Christopher Storer. [2] Executive producer and castmember Matty Matheson is also an experienced chef and cookbook author. [3]
An Italian beef sandwich is a very regional, Chicago-specific sandwich, with significantly less fame with than a Philadelphia cheesesteak or a Cuban sandwich from Florida. [4] The Italian beef experience, according to Chicagoan Lucas Kwan Peterson, writing in the Los Angeles Times , is "a 6–8 in (15–20 cm) long sandwich filled with thin-sliced marinated meat on a French roll drenched in juice and swaddled tightly in waxed paper or insulated foil wrap," and it should feel heavier than it looks as a result of absorbing the liquid jus and the oil from the toppings. [5] As retold by Chicago native Kevin Pang in Esquire magazine: [6]
Italian beefs came from Neapolitan immigrants who moved to Chicago a century ago...Cooks would take a medicine-ball portion of beef bottom round, seasoned aggressively with garlic, basil, and oregano; roast it in a pan of its juices; then slice it so thin one could practically see through it. These meat shavings were piled onto a roll and topped with a spicy bricolage of pickled vegetables known as giardiniera (sometimes boiled sweet peppers), and the whole sandwich got dunked in the pan juices. Suddenly, 15 pounds of cheap beef would feed 50 people." [6]
Another description characterized it as sort of like a roast-beef sandwich, but also sort of like a French dip, because of the importance of beef broth, also known as "gravy or au jus ". [7] The jus is typically a "thin, broth-like gravy reminiscent of oregano and bouillon cubes." [5] The beef is typically seasoned with oregano, basil, red pepper, black pepper, and either fresh garlic or garlic powder and then "roasted slowly, partially submerged in beef stock." [8] The beef should be fully cooked, then cooled, shaved, very thinly, not chopped. [5] [8] According to the Chicago Tribune , if the sandwich is "dipped," it "often comes out looking like a water-logged roll of paper towels." [4] Requests for "wet" get jus spooned over the top. [8] The bread has to be "chewy and firm" to hold up against the dipping. [5] On the show Marcus originally bakes the rolls in-house but in real Chicago, they are often ordered from Turano, Gonnella, or D'amato's bakeries. [4] [8] Typical topping options include either sweet peppers (green bell, red bell, or Melrose peppers), or hot peppers, also known as the aforementioned giardiniera (described as "pickled mix of vegetables and chiles submerged in oil"), and in recent years "shredded cheese and tomato sauce have become increasingly popular." [4] Italian beef sandwiches are commonly accompanied by French fries and/or a "cup of Italian ice served with a plastic straw that has a spoon on one end." [5] Some of this food culture developed around Taylor Street in Chicago's Little Italy. [6] Famous Italian beef spots in Chicago, other than Mr. Beef itself (which inspired the show's Original Beef of Chicagoland sandwich joint), include Al's #1 Italian (originally opened in 1938 as a front for a gambling operation), Tony's Italian Deli & Subs in Edison Park, Johnnie's in Elmwood Park, the Portillo's chain, and the Buona chain. [6] [4] [9] Chris Zucchero's recommended sandwich order is "'hot, sweet, and juicy'—that's the Italian beef sandwich with hot peppers, which is the giardiniera, sweet peppers, which is bell peppers, and dipped. That's the way to get it." [10] Writing in 2022, Peterson said of the Italian beef: [5]
"For whatever reason, Italian beef is one of those hyper-local foods...that has never quite translated outside its home...you can certainly find Italian beef outside of Chicago...but over the years, I've slowed down in my pursuit of a truly great one. Fairly or not, it's tough to compete with memory...But it's just as well, as Chicagoans are fanatically protective of their foods. Chicago-style dogs with nearly every vegetable under the sun piled on top of them? Cheese and caramel popcorn eaten together? Deep-dish pizza derided by none other than Anthony Bourdain himself? We Chicagoans hear what you say about us and our food. We hear every little gibe and good-natured insult. And in true Midwest fashion, we squish all of it into a tight little ball and push it way down inside, to be released later at an inappropriate time." [5]
A set of four index cards are taped to the bookshelf in the Bear office reveal the recipe for " giardiniera by Nonna." [11] Nonna means grandmother. [12] Giardiniera is the typical topping for an Italian beef sandwich. [13]
1⁄2 head cauliflower chopped into small florets
10 ribs celery diced
5 carrots diced
2 large bell peppers
1 cup sliced green pitted olives
4 serrano peppers slicedspices, ingredients for each pint jar:
- 1⁄2 teaspoon dried oregano
- 1⁄2 teaspoon coriander
- 1⁄4 teaspoon mustard seeds
- 1⁄4 tablespoon fennel seeds
- 1⁄4 teaspoon black peppercorns
Carmy made Ecto-Cooler punch for the party. The original Ecto-Cooler was a special flavor of fruit-flavored soft drink Hi-C that was released in association with The Real Ghostbusters TV cartoon that ran from 1986 to 1991. [14] Ecto-Cooler was made with tangerine and orange fruit concentrate. [14] One recipe for homemade Ecto-Cooler calls for tangerine juice, orange juice, crystalized instant lemonade mix, instant orange-drink mix, and sugar. [15] The "you're a child asshole, Richie" discourse and Carmy's hunt for a bottle of ketchup in the kitchen fridge is related to the local standard for a Chicago-style hot dog, which Chef Berzatto is disrupting for the sake of the clientele at this children's birthday party. As per the Chicago Food Encyclopedia, published 2017 by the University of Illinois Press, "Chicago-style hot dogs are defined by an elaborate style of toppings. An all-beef hot dog, preferably natural casing, heated in a hot water bath, placed on a steamed bun (poppy seed or plain), then topped with a smear of yellow mustard, a trail of bright green relish, chopped fresh onions, sliced tomatoes, dill pickle spears, mildly hot pickled 'sport' peppers and, optionally, a sprinkling of celery salt. French fries are an expected accompaniment, and never, ever is ketchup allowed on the hot dog, though it might be available for the fries." [16]
Marcus' chocolate cake was created by the show's pastry consultant Sarah Mispagel-Lustbader, who served a version of it at her Chicago bakery Loaf Lounge. [17] The cake has a chocolate mousse filling and takes about 12 hours to prepare and chill for service. [18] Marcus' cake evolves over the season starting out with a more "rustic frosting job" that he refines into a "mirror glaze" by the season finale episode, "Braciole." [17]
Ebon Moss-Bachrach told an interviewer that his favorite story beat from season one is in this episode: "...when we shot it, I watched this happen and my heart just melted, and when I watch it on TV, I feel the same way...Richie and Carmy come back after the crazy birthday party. There's some cake and ice cream that Marcus serves up, and Richie and Carmy are so beat, and everyone is so exhausted. Carmy takes one bite of cake and says to Marcus, 'Chef, this is delicious,' and Marcus gives him this thumbs up. The thumbs up comes straight out of his heart. Maybe I'm just sentimental or something, but that encapsulated so much of this season for me." [19]When Sydney enters the kitchen she immediately understands what Carmy is already working on and asks "Can I?" Carmy approves, so she begins hammering chicken breasts with a meat tenderizer while he makes conversation about having looked at her COGS, which are reports about "costs of goods sold." [20] Later, using the chicken in question, Carmy shows the cooks how to make lemon chicken piccata for the updated dinner menu. [21] This is "mom's chicken" that Sugar was making for dinner in episode two, "Hands." [21] Carmy uses the term monter (from beurre monté ) and then switches to simpler language. Translated literally from the French monter means "to mount," but it's used in "culinary English" to mean "to thicken," specifically by slowly whisking in butter. [22] Piccata is the Italian word "for a very thin, usually flattened, slice of meat or fish." [23] Veal piccata was the original form, chicken piccata came later. [24]
The stock that Sydney asks Carmy to help her strain is an étouffée stock for use in her forthcoming risotto dish. [25] [20] Per The New Food Lover's Companion , étouffée is a traditional "thick, spicy" Creole-cuisine or Cajun-cuisine stew made from crayfish and vegetables, usually served over rice. [26]The title of the episode, "Braciole," refers to a dish that Carmy tells his studio audience that Mikey usually made with beef. Mikey, with backup by Carmy, prepares braciole in the flashback scene in "Ceres." Per Food & Wine , braciola are "Italian-style roulade, a rolled and stuffed meat...also called involtini, or bruciuluni in Sicilian. The etymology of the word translates to a slice of meat rolled over coals. The meat—typically beef, veal, or pork—is pounded thin and stuffed with prosciutto, breadcrumbs, cheese, and herbs. It can be grilled, pan-fried, or braised in sauce." [27] The Bear's culinary producer, Courtney Storer, created a recipe for Mikey's braciole that calls for 3 pounds flank steak that has been "butterflied and pounded thin," ideally by the butcher or meat counter man at point of purchase. [28] The recipe also calls for "homemade breadcrumbs (toasted in butter, olive oil, herbs, cheese, red pepper flakes, salt and pepper)." [28]
Along with Mikey's braciole, Sydney's cola ribs also used a braising technique, which Carmy described in the pilot "System," when he told Richie, "The only beef I could get was bone-in, which you have to braise, alright? It takes two hours longer." [29]
Mikey also left behind a recipe for spaghetti sauce on the 3" x 5" index card that amounted to his suicide note, [30] which one recipe developer theorized was "inspired by two pretty iconic tomato sauces: Scarpetta's spaghetti with tomato and basil, and Marcella Hazan's tomato sauce with onion and butter." [31] Mikey's recipe calls for San Marzano tomatoes which are a "paste tomato" rather than a slicing tomato, and according to food writer Amanda Blum, "They grow elongated to a pointed tip. Yield is the name of the game with paste tomatoes, to make sauce, salsa, and paste. But even in the realm of paste tomatoes, the San Marzano is prized among gardeners for the taste." [32] Pomodoro San Marzano dell’Agro Sarnese-Nocerino have protected designation of origin status in Italy. [32] Most San Marzano tomato products sold in the United States come from New Jersey. [32] Even though Carmy postponed using the San Marzanos for spaghetti sauce, the canned tomatoes would also have been useful as ingredients in a braised beef or short ribs dish. [32]
I love you dude.
Let it rip
Family Meal Spaghetti
–10 Garlic Cloves
–Basil Steeped in Oil
–San Marzano Tomatoes
2 28 oz cans (the smaller cans
taste better)
Syd's omelette is based on a classic French omelette. [39] [40] A French omelette is prepared differently than omelettes served in the United States, where the show is set. [41]
French omelettes are different from American omelettes in two primary ways. First, they are very thin, and they cook very quickly. American omelettes tend to be thick and fluffy, stuffed with toppings and add-ins, but a French omelette is thin and elegant. The second difference is the toppings. American omelettes include a bevy of options, but the French version traditionally only includes eggs, butter, and perhaps some cheese, but not always. The point of a French omelette is to highlight the creamy, perfectly cooked eggs without any distraction from other ingredients. [41]
According to restaurateur Abe Beame, Syd's omelette technique is "more or less flawless, although, if I may nitpick, the pan doesn't seem hot enough because the butter isn't 'singing' as it should when it first hits the pan, and she pipes a thin tube of Boursin onto the setting eggs, a major no-no (but almost certainly delicious, based on Ludo Lefevbre's omelet recipe). Extra point for rubbing butter onto the rolled omelet on the plate, and the textural chip crumble with chive garnish spoke directly to my Jewish palate. More food-based intimacy in season 3, please." [42] [43] [44]
Boursin is a so-called "Gournay cheese" invented by Norman cheese maker François Boursin in 1957. [45] It's a soft, creamy, spreadable cow's milk cheese—not dissimilar from mascarpone, goat's milk chèvre , or Brie—that was "inspired by the common French party treat called fromage frais ." [46] The original flavor is garlic-and- fines herbes . [45] Chef Lefevbre recommends the cracked black pepper flavor of Boursin for an omelette. [47] Lacking Boursin, scallion-blend cream cheese from a bagel shop is a viable substitute. [48] Sydney used what were likely sour-cream-and-onion-flavor Ruffles-brand potato chips, since she mentioned using chips that have "ridges," but any crumbled-up potato chip would work. [48] One food writer commented that the use of crumbled potato chips recalled the use of potato in tortilla española . [49]
After season two premiered, many recipe developers took up the challenge of recreating Sydney's omelette. [47] [50] [51] [52]Under the supervision of culinary producer Coco Storer, the seven fishes dish was designed by Tim Flores and Genie Kwon of Chicago's Kasama, simplifying the banquet concept down to "one prawn and mussels and this beautiful fumé with saffron." [53] Storer designed the savory cannoli, named in honor of Mikey Berzatto, which was made of a Parmesan shell, stuffed with mostarda and onion jam, coated in pistachios. [53]
Chester complains about the wine, and Richie barks back, "That's a Cru Beaujolais!" [54] Syd's dad, Emmanuel Adamu, does not drink alcohol and gets a special delivery of the "Bear Pop Service." Soft drinks, or soda, are typically called "pop" in the Chicago area and the Midwestern United States generally. [55] [56]
Richie sent a chocolate-covered banana to Jimmy for desert, recalling a conversation they had five years ago at Seven Fishes when Tiff could only eat a banana because of morning sickness and Jimmy recalled getting chocolate-covered bananas with his dad at a roadside stand. [57] Pro tip from The Globe and Mail of Canada: Add a big spoonful of peanut butter or a small spoonful of coconut oil to the melted chocolate for a better dip and a "snappier" chocolate shell. [58]A key detail in "Tomorrow" is that we see Carmy creating and plating the paupiette of hamachi with blood orange sauce that is more than likely "the best meal" Sydney ever had, that she described in passing to both Marcus in season one's "Braciole" and Carmy's mom, Donna Berzatto, in the season four wedding episode "Bears." [59] [60] Paupiette is defined by the Oxford English Dictionary as a "long thin slice of meat or fish (or sometimes other foods which can be rolled) spread with forcemeat or other filling and rolled up," [61] but here more likely describes a classic French fish dish whereby a thin slice of fish (tuna, sole, whiting, or even anchovy) is stuffed, rolled and secured with string before cooking in a stock. [62] Hamachi describes young Japanese amberjack fish (Seriola quinqueradiata), also known as yellowtail, farm-raised and prized for use in sushi and sashimi. The smaller fish are the hamachi, larger ones are called buri but it is unusual for even the bigger fish to get larger than 20 lb (9.1 kg). [63] Blood oranges are a type of citrus fruit with reddish flesh and skins that produce a deep red, almost maroon, sweet-tart juice. They primarily grow in California and around the Mediterranean region. [64]
Carmy's first iteration of the dish used dill, which Fields rejected with edict "never repeat ingredients," which in turn seemed to influence Carmy's season three dictate that they were going to change the menu every day. [65] "No repetitions" is one of the rules of a Thomas Keller kitchen. [66] At the French Laundry, the nine-course menu changes daily and "No ingredient can be featured more than once on each night's menu, with the exception...of truffles, caviar, and foie gras." [66]
The dish that was served to Sydney was a one-off, created on the pretext that the diner had a allergy, fennel soubise being a key element of the plate, but Syd has worked with various forms of fennel multiple times since joining the crew of the Beef, including for the first family meal she prepared on her first day, and she thus almost certainly does not have such a food sensitivity. [67] [a]
Jeremy Allen White told the Daily Beast in June 2024, "There is this connection between these two people that existed before they even met...Then, that gets you thinking about, like, what a beautiful thing it is to prepare food for someone. How you're connected forever, in some way, dining in these restaurants." [69]The main dish prepared during the episode is an elevated but kid-friendly beef bowl made with the Cheeseburger Macaroni variety of Hamburger Helper. [70] [71] [72] According to The Today Show's food reporter Joseph Lamour, "Like previous seasons' standout dishes...this one combines haute cuisine with accessible ingredients." [71] All Hamburger Helper varieties are essentially a meal kit offering a "blend of spices and pasta...meant to be prepared with ground beef." [73] When interviewed by Rolling Stone about the episode, Boyce picked Hamburger Helper as his preferred "instant-comfort nostalgia food," specifically the beef stroganoff and mac and cheese varieties. [74]
Hamburger Helper became popular in American homes in the 1970s when, "strained by inflation and soaring beef prices, [people] looked to turn a pound of ground beef into an entire meal." [70] Ground beef is a comparably economical form of this protein, depending on which part of the cow it came from and the fat percentage: "The least expensive product is sold as regular ground beef or regular hamburger. It's usually made with trimmings of the less expensive cuts such as brisket and shank, and can contain up to 30 percent fat." [75]
According to Edebiri, "Sydney's canonically bad with kids," but she manages to connect with T.J. through the process of constructing this dish. [76] Syd (with help from T.J.) adds double-concentrated tomato paste, diced yellow onion, shredded cheese, toasted panko bread crumbs, and replaced some of the milk with heavy cream "for a richer sauce." [73] [77] Food Republic's Cara J. Suppa said Syd's cheese looked like it was probably white cheddar or mozzarella, but recommended substituting Parmigiano Reggiano for maximum umami, and suggested that ketchup works as a substitute if tomato paste is unavailable, with the sugar in ketchup adding another flavor dimension to the dish. [78] Other versions of Syd's dish used an aged Irish cheddar, [72] and added finely minced fresh parsley, oregano, and basil to season the sauce and to finish the dish. [71] Chantel intended to add hot sauce. [73] [79]
The Kitchn's Perry Santanachote replicated Syd's amendments and determined that the resulting dish "looked like something I'd expect to be served at a restaurant—or proudly offer to guests at my own table. And once I dug in, it was every bit as satisfying: deeply savory and beefy, creamy and comforting. The tomato paste brought a hit of umami and mellowed the artificial yellow from the powdered cheese, making the dish look more natural. The real cheese added a tangy edge, but it was the parsley and panko that were my favorite additions, adding a fresh, green note and satisfying crunch." [77] Today food correspondent Lamour also made a version and reported, "This is the very first time in my 42 years of life that I have eaten Hamburger Helper—and I am officially a convert. Each spoonful was rich, but not not too rich. The herbs gave it a fresh bite and the panko added a buttery crunch...Plus, the dish is attractive. You could make this for a dinner party and get compliments from people who would have no idea that a glove with eyes was involved in its creation." [71] (Hamburger Helper's advertising "mascot," named Lefty, is a puffy white glove with a face on its palm.) [70]
The inclusion of Hamburger Helper in the series was not a paid product placement. [70]
The title of the episode, "Worms," refers to favorite-treat gummy worms that Syd buys at the market. [80]Donna described a dish of roasted red peppers that she was served while vacationing in Italy with Carmy's dad. Carmy identified the accompanying sauce as tonnato. Per Donna, it looked disgusting but was delicious. [81] Tonnato "refers culinarily to dishes that are somehow prepared with or accompanied by tuna. The most well-known preparation is vitello tonnato , which consists of cold, sliced, roasted veal accompanied with a sauce of puréed tuna, anchovy filets, capers, lemon juice, and olive oil." [82] Most common in the Piedmont region, "smooth, creamy, beige" tonnato is served cold and is summer-suitable, often as a topping for cooked vegetables like tomatoes, asparagus, and green beans. [81]
Carmy makes a whole roast chicken for Donna, the way he was trained by Thomas Keller at the French Laundry in Yountville, California. In the Bouchon cookbook, Keller recommends brining the chicken for restaurant prep but not for home cooks. Key steps are patting the chicken completely dry, and trussing the chicken with butcher's twine. The trussing stage is where the pope's nose comes in to play. [83] [84] Per Keller, season the chicken generously with salt and black pepper, face the breast up and the legs to the back of the oven, and finish by adding fresh thyme leaves to the pan, "and baste the birds several times with the juices and thyme leaves." [85] Roast for 10 minutes per 1 pound (0.45 kg) at 475 °F (246 °C). [85] [86]
Donna told Carmy he should wash the chicken first; he replied that washing chicken just splashes salmonella all over the kitchen sink. [87] Under the we-listen-and-we-don't-judge headline "Our Science, Your Choice," the U.S. Department of Agriculture states that "the best practice is not to wash poultry...washing, rinsing, or brining meat and poultry in salt water, vinegar, or lemon juice does not destroy bacteria." [88] Poultry needs to be cooked to an internal temperature, checked by meat thermometer, of 165 °F (74 °C) to destroy pathogenic bacteria. [88]