Minotaur-class cruiser (1947)

Last updated

Class overview
NameDesign Z (Minotaur)
OperatorsNaval Ensign of the United Kingdom.svg  Royal Navy
Preceded by Neptune class (planned)
Succeeded by Tiger class (actual)
Planned6
Cancelled6
General characteristics Design Z, Version D [1]
Type Light cruiser
Displacement15,280 long tons (15,525 t) standard 18,415 long tons (18,711 t) deep load
Length645 ft (197 m) pp
Beam75 ft (23 m)
Draught24 ft 0 in (7.32 m)
Installed power100,000  shp (75 MW)
Propulsion
Speed33.5 kn (62.0 km/h; 38.6 mph) (light) 31.5 kn (58.3 km/h; 36.2 mph) (deep load)
Range6,000 nmi (11,000 km; 6,900 mi) at 20 knots (37 km/h)
Complement1,090
Armament
  • 5 × dual 6 in QF Mk V guns
  • 8 × twin 3 in QF Mk VI AA guns
  • 4× quadruple 21 in (533 mm) torpedo tubes
Armour
  • Belt 3.5 in (89 mm)
  • Bulkheads 3.5–2 in (89–51 mm)
  • Turrets 4–1.5 in (102–38 mm)
  • Decks 1.5 in (38 mm)
General characteristics Design ZA alternative [2]
Class and typeLight cruiser
Displacement13,870 long tons (14,093 t) standard 16,760 long tons (17,029 t) deep load
Length616 ft (188 m) pp
Beam73 ft (22 m)
Draught23 ft 6 in (7.16 m)
Installed power110,000 shp (82 MW)
Propulsion
Speed33.5 kn (62.0 km/h; 38.6 mph) (light) 31.5 kn (58.3 km/h; 36.2 mph) (deep load)
Range6,000 nmi (11,000 km; 6,900 mi) at 20 knots (37 km/h)
Complement1,090
Armament
  • 5 × dual 6 in QF Mk V guns
  • 8 × twin 3 in QF Mk VI AA guns
  • 4× quadruple 21 in (533 mm) torpedo tubes
Armour
  • Belt 3.5 in (89 mm)
  • Bulkheads 3.5–2 in (89–51 mm)
  • Turrets 4–1.5 in (102–38 mm)
  • Decks 1.5 in (38 mm)
NotesSmaller alternative of main Minotaur design

The Minotaur class, or Design Z, was a proposed class of light cruisers planned for the British Royal Navy shortly after the Second World War. Design Z had several proposed configurations with differing armament and propulsion arrangements. [3] The designs were large ships that were planned to be armed with ten 6 in (152 mm) dual purpose guns and an extensive array of 3 in (76 mm) secondary guns. Six ships of the class were planned in 1947 but they were ultimately cancelled before construction could begin, owing to the post-war economic difficulties of the United Kingdom and shifting naval priorities. [3]

Contents

Development

The Design Z proposals for light cruisers were evolutions of the Design Y ( Neptune class) that were planned during the final years of the Second World War. It was intended to take advantage of improved hull subdivision, maximise commonality with the United States Navy and more advanced AA/DP automatic 3-inch and 6-inch twin gun designs of 1945 than the more incremental guns and turrets and design for the Neptunes. Like the 1944 N2, the Minotaur, Design Z was borne from increased crew size and the serious habitability problems with the modern but cramped Fiji (Crown Colony)-class cruiser the derived 1943 Minotaur-class and the Dido-class cruiser (and improved Dido) anti-aircraft classes post war, [4] This demanded either much smaller gun turrets and smaller higher performance guns as in N2 or much larger cruiser designs - Neptune or Minotaur and its 1947 Z derivative. The Director Gunnery and Anti-Air Division (DGD) further proposed that future cruisers should be armed with dual-purpose 6 in (150 mm) and 3 in (76 mm) guns as on the American Worcester class then under construction. In 1946, following orders from the Deputy First Sea Lord [ clarification needed ] to rework existing cruiser designs for improved habitability, the Director of Naval Construction (DNC) developed a series of designs that would mount the new twin 6-inch Mk 26 mounts; these designs were designated as different versions of Design Z. [3]

In a June 1946 meeting that compared the Neptune design with the various Design Z versions, the First Sea Lord deemed version D with five twin 6-inch Mk 26 mounts and eight twin 3-inch mounts to be acceptable; the design had three superfiring Mk 26 mounts forward and two aft. This design was given the name Minotaur (the previous HMS Minotaur, lead ship of the 1943 9,000 ton class, had been transferred before completion to Canada and renamed HMCS Ontario and the class were named after HMS Swiftsure instead), to distinguish it from the Neptune designs and replaced the latter in the building programme. The Minotaur design would displace 15,280 long tons (15,530 t) standard and 18,415 long tons (18,711 t) deep load.

In 1947, the DNC compared the Minotaur design with USS Worcester; the comparison file also included several Design Z alternatives and refinements to Minotaur. Design Z4C combined engine and boiler rooms, while designs ZA and ZB were two smaller alternatives with the same general characteristics of armament, protection, and speed, but with reduced space. Design ZA also had the front two turrets mounted at the same level and reduced the overall length, which then required an increase in propulsive power from 100,000  shp (75 MW) to 110,000 shp (82 MW) to make the required 31.5 knots (58.3 km/h; 36.2 mph). [3]

Suspension

The cruiser programme, which consisted of the new Minotaur class and completion of the Tiger-class (third group of the previous Minotaur class), was suspended in 1947 due to lack of immediate threat, the austerity budget imposed by the Labour government as a consequence of Britain's war debts and to allow reconsideration of cruiser design. The comparable Worcester design was really being completed as design prototypes; much USN opinion being it was of little value as it had been ordered for a supposed threat of bombers operating 6–9 mi (9,700–14,500 m) high, and to counter the wartime threat of the first German anti-ship missiles. [lower-alpha 1] [5] But in the 1940s high level bombing had remained far too inaccurate to hit large warships, [5] and the actual high level threat was reconnaissance planes and shadowers and potential launches (of Fritz X type missiles) from outside any possible gun range. US opinion therefore generally supposed further development of large AA cruisers and guns of larger than 5 inches and the Worcesters - built on a similar hull to Salem class with autoloading 8-inch guns - were nearly converted to mount the same 8-inch turrets. [6] The Royal Navy thought that a RN 'cruiser/destroyer', similar to and derived from the US Mitscher-class Destroyer Leaders of about 3,750 tons [lower-alpha 2] might be sufficient to meet the limited interim threat perceived from Soviet gun cruisers. A substantial legacy aircraft carrier programme of Eagle, Ark Royal and the four intermediate Centaur-class carriers was under construction and the immediate cruiser need was provided by the structural reconstruction of two Town-class cruisers (HMS Newcastle and Birmingham) and two Fiji-class ( Kenya and Newfoundland ) [7] with new Type 274, 275 and 262 fire control. Design work, however, continued on the Minotaur class in the meantime.

The Korean War, along with the arrival of the 20,000 ton Soviet Sverdlov design, saw the Naval staff once again put cruiser options before the British Cabinet in 1951. The options were; (1) A fully designed Minotaur (1951) cruiser with five twin Mk 26 6 inch turrets but only four twin 3-inch/70 AA armament; [8] (2) Mk 3 broad beam Dido cruiser with four twin Mk 6 4.5 turrets and; (3) Immediate restarted Tiger class with Mk 24 turrets in A & B and Mk 6 4.5 twins in X and Y positions - probably similar to the final offer to complete the class for the RAN in mid 1945. The decision was, however, to complete the Tiger to a 1948-9 design, with Mk 26 twin 6-inch and 3-inch/70 armament.

The options for a new cruiser alternative to the Tiger in November 1954 were; the C17, a small cruiser of 10,000 ton light with three twin Mk 26 6 inch and four Mk 11 L/70 [9] or; a new Tiger sized cruiser with a 'cruiser/destroyer' armament of two twin 5/56 (in large turrets sized for the cruiser) two twin L70,and a sextriple 'Vanguard' Bofors in Y position (in the turret design dev into the twin 3/70) with cruiser armour and AD/AW processing. [10] The evident difficulty of developing rapid fire 5-inch guns of acceptable weight and reliability meant however that in 1955 it was decided to limit gun options for missile cruisers to the new twin 6 inch and 3-inch/70. This resulted in the several missile cruiser designs that received staff approval in 1956/7 being similar in dimensions to the proposals of 1947 and 1951 for the Minotaur, with two twin 6-inch gun turrets in A and B position, two-four twin 3-inch turrets and 40 mm light anti-aircraft guns.

A Minotaur size hull and armour was seen by naval staff as necessary for major Pacific and Indian Ocean carrier escorts with long range endurance, stores and workshops, as well as modern guns and missiles combining surface and AA guns, 3D Type 984 radar and a viable large armoured magazine for 48 Seaslug missiles with 16 of these as nuclear missiles [lower-alpha 3] [11] However, Mountbatten, following the Suez crisis in 1956, saw "no use" for cruisers [12] and closed the RN cruiser design department in April 1957 [13] Mountbatten had always favoured smaller guided missile destroyers to carry Seaslug and vetoed nuclear weapons as impractical for anti-aircraft duties on political and escalation grounds. The cruiser department became the new nuclear submarine design unit.

Design

Armament

The main gun armament was to be ten Quick-Firing (QF) 6 in (152 mm) Mark V dual-purpose guns in Mk 26 dual mounts. The new Mk 26 mounts had full remote power control (RPC) and featured automatic loading that gave each gun a designed rate of fire of 15-20 rounds per minute, considerably faster than the 6-8 rounds per minute of the older Mk 24 mounts. The guns were individually sleeved and fired a 129.75 lb (58.9 kg) shell out to 25,000 yd (23 km). While the Minotaur-class cruisers were cancelled, the guns and mountings were eventually fitted onto the Tiger class, whose hulls were laid down during the Second World War and was later redesigned to accommodate these mounts. [14]

The secondary armament consisted of rapid fire 3 in (76 mm) guns in eight twin mountings that would replace the QF 4.5-inch secondary guns as well as the Bofors 40 mm gun and 20 mm Oerlikon anti-aircraft guns of previous cruiser designs. [15] The DNC considered the 3-inch shell to be the smallest that could accommodate a proximity fuse which made it more ideal for high angle anti-aircraft fire. The Director Naval Ordnance (DNO) also adopted this calibre in order to achieve commonality with the United States Navy which developing the 3"/70 gun with UK but on a different mount. [3]

Planned construction

Six Minotaur-class cruisers were planned over a ten-year period by the Royal Navy, with the same names as planned for the Neptune-class cruiser design: Minotaur, Neptune, Centurion, Edgar, Mars, and Bellerophon. The plan involved laying down two cruisers in 1951, 1952, and 1953 with completion in 1954, 1955, and 1956 respectively. Due to cost and the emphasis on aircraft carriers and anti-submarine warfare after the Second World War this plan ultimately never materialized. [3]

Notes

  1. The German remotely controlled Fritz X glide bomb first came to Allies notice when used against ships at Salerno in 1943
  2. a concept which, in 1949–51, the RN envisaged as potentially armed with three US Mk 54 single 5-inch and two twin 3-inch 50-cals
  3. RAF Bristol Bloodhound and USN Terrier AA missiles had special variants

Citations

  1. Friedman 2010, p. 373
  2. Friedman 2010, p. 267
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Friedman 2010 , pp. 267, 268
  4. A. Raven & J. Roberts. British Cruisers of World War Two. Arms & Armour. (London) 1980, p364
  5. 1 2 Freidman 2010, p349
  6. N. Friedman. US Cruisers. Arms & Armour.London (1985) London p349 & 355-6
  7. Raven & Roberts. British Cruisers. Arms & Armour.(1980) London, pp 365,392 & D. Murfin. "AA to AA. The Fiji's" in Warship 2009. Conway. London (2009)
  8. Preston, A. (1983). "Pt 1. Western Powers". In Gardiner, R. (ed.). Conway's All the World's Fighting Ships 1947-1982. London: Conway Maritime. p. 149.
  9. A Preston. British and Commonwealth Warships in Conway's All the World's Fighting Ships 1947-1982, Pt 1. Western Powers' (1983)London, p150.
  10. A. Preston. Conway's All the World's Fighting Ships 1947-1982 (1983) and G. Moore. "Post War Cruiser Design" in Warship 2006, p 53
  11. G. Moore. "Post War Cruiser Design for the RN 1946-56", in Warship 2006. Conway Maritime. London (2006), p56.
  12. Moore. "Post War Cruiser Design" in Warship 2006, p 56
  13. Moore. Cruiser Design in Warship 2006, p 57.
  14. 6"/50 (15.2 cm) QF Mark N5
  15. Friedman 2010 , p. 407

Sources

Related Research Articles

<i>Fiji</i>-class cruiser Class of British light cruisers

The Fiji-class cruisers were a class of eleven light cruisers of the Royal Navy that saw extensive service throughout the Second World War. Each ship of the class was named after a Crown colony or other constituent territory of the British Commonwealth and Empire. The class was also known as the Colony class, or Crown Colony class. Developed as more compact versions of the preceding Town-class cruisers, the last three were built to a slightly modified design and were sometimes also called the Ceylon class.

<i>Tiger</i>-class cruiser Class of British light cruisers

The Tiger class were a class of three British warships of the 20th century and the last all-gun cruisers of the Royal Navy. Construction of three Minotaur-class cruisers began during World War II but, due to post-war austerity, the Korean War and focus on the Royal Air Force over the surface fleet, the hulls remained unfinished. Against a background of changing priorities and financial constraints, approval to complete them to a modified design was given in November 1954 and the three ships – Tiger, Lion and Blake – entered service from March 1959.

HMS <i>Tiger</i> (C20) Lead ship of her class Tiger-class cruiser of the Royal Navy

HMS Tiger was a conventional cruiser of the British Royal Navy, one of a three-ship class known as the Tiger class. Ordered during World War II, she was completed after its end.

Town-class cruiser (1936) Class of British light cruisers

The Town class consisted of 10 light cruisers built for the Royal Navy during the 1930s. The Towns were designed within the constraints of the London Naval Treaty of 1930. The ships were built in the sub-classes, Southampton, Gloucester and Edinburgh, each sub-class adding more weaponry.

County-class cruiser Class of heavy cruisers built for the Royal Navy of the United Kingdom

The County class was a class of heavy cruisers built for the Royal Navy in the years between the First and Second World Wars. They were the first post-war cruisers constructed for the Royal Navy and were designed within the limits of the Washington Naval Treaty of 1922. Such ships, with a limit of 10,000 tons standard displacement and 8-inch calibre main guns may be referred to as "treaty cruisers".

<i>Dido</i>-class cruiser Class of light cruisers built for the Royal Navy

The Dido class consisted of sixteen light cruisers built for the Royal Navy during World War II. The first group of three ships were commissioned in 1940; the second group of six ships and third group of two were commissioned between 1941 and 1942. A fourth group, also described as the Improved Dido or Bellona class were commissioned between 1943 and 1944. Most members of the class were given names drawn from classical history and legend. The groups differed in armament, and for the Bellonas, in function. The Dido class were designed as small trade protection cruisers with a secondary role in the battlefleet as large flotilla leaders. As designed, they mounted five twin 5.25-inch high-angle gun turrets on the centreline providing dual-purpose anti-air and anti-surface capacity; the complex new turrets were unreliable when introduced, and somewhat unsatisfactory at a time when the UK faced a fight for survival. During the war, the original 1939-42 ships required extensive refit work to increase electrical generating capacity for additional wartime systems and in the final Bellona,HMS Diadem, fully-electric turrets. While some damage was experienced initially in extreme North Atlantic weather, changes to gun handling and drill partially mitigated the problems. The fitting of the three forward turrets in the double-superfiring A-B-C arrangement relied upon the heavy use of aluminium in the ships' superstructure, and the lack of aluminium after the evacuation of the British Army from France was one of the primary reasons for the first group only receiving four turrets, while the third group received four twin 4.5-inch mounts and no 5.25-inch guns at all. The Bellonas were designed from the start with four radar-directed 5.25-inch gun turrets with full Remote Power Control and an expanded light anti-aircraft battery, substantially increasing their efficiency as AA platforms.

<i>Atlanta</i>-class cruiser Class of light cruisers of the United States Navy

The Atlanta-class cruisers were eight United States Navy light cruisers which were designed as fast scout cruisers or flotilla leaders but which proved to be effective anti-aircraft cruisers during World War II. They were also known as the Atlanta-Oakland class. The Atlanta class originally had 16 x 5-inch (127 mm)/38 caliber guns in eight two-gun turrets, arranged with three superfiring turrets forward, three more superfiring aft and two waist mounts, one port and one starboard, giving the first four Atlanta-class cruisers the heaviest anti-aircraft armament of any cruiser of World War II. The last four ships of the class, starting with Oakland, had a slightly revised armament with a reduced main gun battery - the waist turrets being deleted - as they were further optimized for anti-aircraft fire in light of war experience.

<i>Minotaur</i>-class cruiser (1943) Class of British light cruisers

The Minotaur class, also known as the Swiftsure class after the lead ship was sold to Canada and renamed, were a group of light cruisers of the British Royal Navy built during the Second World War. They were designed as a modified version of the Fiji class incorporating war modifications and authorised in 1941. However, in spite of the heavy toll of cruisers in that year and the following one, the building of this new class had a relatively low priority and only three of the planned twelve were completed by end of World War II. They played no significant part in the Second World War, though Swiftsure, as flagship of the British Pacific Cruiser Squadron, was selected by Admiral Cecil Harcourt to hoist his flag for the Japanese surrender at Hong Kong.

<i>Hawkins</i>-class cruiser Class of five heavy cruisers of the Royal Navy, designed in 1915

The Hawkins class consisted of five heavy cruisers built for the Royal Navy during the First World War, although none of them saw service during the war. The first ship to be completed, HMS Vindictive, was renamed from HMS Cavendish and converted into an aircraft carrier while under construction. All ships were named after Elizabethan sea captains. The three ships remaining as cruisers in 1939 served in the Second World War, with Effingham being an early war loss through wreck; Raleigh had been lost in a similar shipwreck on uncharted rocks in 1922. Vindictive, though no longer a cruiser, also served throughout the War. This class formed the basis for the definition of the maximum cruiser type under the Washington Naval Treaty of 1922.

<i>Devonshire</i>-class cruiser (1903)

The Devonshire-class cruiser was a group of six armoured cruisers built for the Royal Navy in the first decade of the 20th century. All ships of the class served in World War I. Argyll was wrecked, and Hampshire was sunk by a naval mine. The four survivors were disposed of soon after the war.

<i>Minotaur</i>-class cruiser (1906) British class of armoured cruisers

The Minotaur class was a three-ship class of armoured cruisers built in the first decade of the twentieth century for the Royal Navy. These were the last class of armoured cruisers built for the Royal Navy, with that role being substantially replaced by the first battlecruisers. These initially served with the Home Fleet, generally as the flagships of cruiser squadrons. Minotaur became flagship of the China Station in 1910 and Defence served as flagship of the 1st Cruiser Squadron in the Mediterranean from 1912; Shannon remained at home as flagship of several different squadrons.

<i>Duke of Edinburgh</i>-class cruiser British class of armoured cruisers

The Duke of Edinburgh-class cruiser was a class of two armoured cruisers built for the Royal Navy in the first decade of the 20th century. They were the first British armoured cruisers designed to work with the battlefleet rather than protect merchant shipping. After commissioning, they were assigned to the Atlantic, Channel and Home Fleets until 1913 when they were transferred to the Mediterranean Fleet. After the start of World War I in August 1914, the sister ships participated in the pursuit of the German battlecruiser SMS Goeben and light cruiser SMS Breslau. After the German ships reached their refuge in Ottoman Turkey, the ships were ordered to the Red Sea for convoy escort duties. They captured three German merchant ships before they returned to home at the end of the year.

HMS <i>Swiftsure</i> (08) Minotaur-class cruiser

HMS Swiftsure was one of three Minotaur-class light cruisers built for the Royal Navy during the Second World War. She was laid down by Vickers Armstrong at Newcastle upon Tyne on 22 September 1941, launched on 4 February 1943 by Lady Wake-Walker and commissioned on 22 June 1944. The first of a new Minotaur class, a development of the later Colony class with extra beam and a fifth twin 4 inch turret. Swiftsure was the last Royal Navy cruiser completed during World War II and was the first British cruiser designed around the concept of an operations room and modern radar, with sensor screens and communications positioned for efficient operation. During her service in the Pacific in 1945, she proved the most efficient anti-aircraft cruiser in the fleet and was the first Royal Navy cruiser with the Type 274 lock-and-follow radar targeting system for her main armament.

HMS <i>Minotaur</i> (1906) British lead ship of the Minotaur-class

HMS Minotaur was the lead ship of the Minotaur-class armoured cruisers built for the Royal Navy. Launched in 1906, she served as the flagship of the China Station before the First World War. Shortly after the war began, the ship searched unsuccessfully for the German East Asia Squadron and was transferred to the Grand Fleet at the end of 1914. During the rest of the war Minotaur served as the flagship of the 7th and 2nd Cruiser Squadrons and spent most of her time assigned to the Northern Patrol. In mid-1916 she participated in the Battle of Jutland but did not fire her weapons during the battle. The ship was paid off in 1919 and sold for scrap the following year.

HMS <i>Shannon</i> (1906) British Minotaur-class armoured cruiser

HMS Shannon was a Minotaur-class armoured cruiser built for the Royal Navy in the mid-1900s. Before the First World War, she served with the Home Fleet, generally as the flagship of a cruiser squadron. The ship remained with the Grand Fleet, as the Home Fleet was renamed when the war began, for the entire war, but only participated in a single battle, the Battle of Jutland in May 1916. Shannon spent most of the war unsuccessfully patrolling the North Sea for German warships and commerce raiders. She was paid off in 1919 and sold for scrap in 1922.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Flight deck cruiser</span> Proposed American aircraft cruiser

The flight-deck cruiser was a proposed type of aircraft cruiser,, designed by the United States Navy during the Interwar period. Several designs were proposed for the type, but none was approved for construction. The final design was developed just before World War II, and the entry of the United States into the war saw the project come to an end.

<i>Admiral Nakhimov</i>-class cruiser Soviet class of light cruisers

The Admiral Nakhimov-class cruisers were a group of four light cruisers built for the Imperial Russian Navy just before World War I began in 1914. Construction was interrupted by the Russian Revolution and only two of the ships were eventually completed well after the end of the Russian Civil War by the Soviets. Chervona Ukraina was the first ship completed and was built to essentially the original design. Krasnyi Kavkaz was much modified and completed five years after Chervona Ukraina. Both ships participated in the Sieges of Odessa and Sevastopol after the Germans invaded Russia in June 1941. They ferried troops into the cities, evacuated wounded and bombarded the besieging German troops. Chervona Ukraina was bombed and sunk by dive bombers in November during one of these missions and Krasny Kavkaz was badly damaged by the same type of aircraft in January 1942. After her lengthy repairs were completed, the ship transported reinforcements to cities on the Black Sea coast during the Battle of the Caucasus. She was reclassified as a training ship in 1947 before she was sunk as a target in 1956. Chervona Ukraina was salvaged in 1947 and then became a hulked. She became a target ship in 1950.

<i>Warrior</i>-class cruiser Royal Navys Warrior-class of four armoured cruisers

The Warrior class consisted of four armoured cruisers built for the Royal Navy in the first decade of the 20th century. After commissioning, all four sister ships were assigned to the Channel and Home Fleets until 1913 when Warrior was transferred to the Mediterranean Fleet. After the start of World War I in August 1914, Warrior participated in the pursuit of the German battlecruiser SMS Goeben and light cruiser SMS Breslau and her three sisters were assigned to the 2nd Cruiser Squadron of the Grand Fleet. Warrior joined the 1st Cruiser Squadron of the Grand Fleet in late 1914. Neither squadron participated in any of the naval battles in the North Sea in 1915. Natal was destroyed by a magazine explosion in late 1915 and only two of the ships participated in the Battle of Jutland in 1916. Cochrane was not engaged during the battle, but Warrior was heavily damaged and sank the following morning.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">QF 6-inch Mark N5 gun</span> Naval gun

The QF 6-inch Gun Mark N5 was a British naval gun, which was developed in the post-war period. It was the last large gun to be operational with the Royal Navy.

The Neptune class was a proposed class of cruisers planned for the British Royal Navy in the latter years of the Second World War. They were large ships which were to be armed with twelve 6-inch (152 mm) dual-purpose guns and with a heavy secondary armament. Although five ships of the class were planned in 1944, they were cancelled following the end of the war and before construction could begin.