Muhammad in film

Last updated

The depiction of the Islamic prophet Muhammad (as with other visual depictions) is a controversial topic both within and outside of Islam. Although the Quran does not explicitly forbid images of Muhammad, there are a few hadith (supplemental teachings) which have explicitly prohibited Muslims from creating visual depictions of figures. Because the different branches of Islam use different Hadith collections, there is a split on this issue between the two major denominations of Islam, Sunni and Shia Islam.

Contents

Most Sunni Muslims believe that visual depictions of all the prophets of Islam should be prohibited [1] and are particularly averse to visual representations of Muhammad. [2] In 1926, Egyptian actor Youssef Wahbi was in discussions to play Muhammad in a film financed by the Turkish government under Atatürk. When the Sunni Islamic Al-Azhar University in Cairo heard about it, scholars there released a fatwa stipulating that Islam forbids the depiction of Muhammad on screen and King Fuad then sent a severe warning to the actor, threatening to exile him and strip him of his Egyptian nationality. As a result of the controversy, the film was abandoned. [3]

In Shia Islam, scholars historically were also against such depictions, but have taken a more relaxed view over the years and images of Muhammad are quite common nowadays. [2] A fatwa given by Ali al-Sistani, the Shi'a marja of Iraq, states that it is permissible to depict Muhammad, even in television or movies, if done with respect. [4]

Notable films

L'Inferno

Dante's Inferno, originally released in Italy as L'Inferno, was one of, if not the first depiction of Muhammad in a feature-length film. The depiction of Muhammad in L'Inferno is very brief and very unflattering. It has a brief section in which Muhammad is being tortured in Hell with his chest opened, exposing his entrails. [5]

The Message

Mohammad, Messenger of God, released in the US as The Message, was the first major film about Muhammad. The film was released on January 1, 1976 and on July 29 of the same year it had its premiere in "Plaza", a London cinema. There are two versions of the movie, an English one and an Arab one. The Arab version had also its premiere in a London cinema, Curzon, on August 19, 1976. Both versions were screened till September 29. So the English version was shown for nine weeks, and the Arab version for six weeks.

When director Mustafa Akkad was shooting the film, he made use of an American cast and an Egyptian cast. In the English version Anthony Quinn played Hamza, Michael Ansara Muhammad's principal opponent Abu Sufyan, and Irene Papas Abu Sufyan's wife Hind. In the Arab version these roles were played by Egyptian actors. However, in a number of overall shots, in which a large group is acting, such as the Battle of Badr, it can be heard that the scene is shot only once, as the actors shout " Allahu Akbar ", whereas in other similar scenes the director opted for "God is great".

Although the movie is about Muhammad, the director decided to shoot the film so as to not depict Muhammad. Akkad frequently changed the position of the camera at moments when Muhammad would be brought into vision. When Muhammad was essential to a scene, the camera would show events from his point of view. [6]

The Message became very popular, not the least in the circles of Muslims, for example in Africa, and Asia. Even so, two well-known fatwas from Al-Azhar University and Shiite Council of Lebanon were issued about The Message.

It is certainly probable that this is not the result of the creativity of the filmmakers but of the rules announced by the Islamic scholars of the Azhar and the Shia Council of Lebanon, who prohibited any representation of Muhammad's wives as well as of Muhammad himself. [6]

Muhammad: The Last Prophet

Muhammad: The Last Prophet is an animated film produced by Badr International according to the same principles as "The Message". Its director is Richard Rich. The movie was released in 2004 and it was screened in a limited number of movie-theatres in the United States and the United Kingdom. The film focuses on the early period of Islam.

Muhammad: The Messenger of God

In October 2012, Iranian director Majid Majidi began shooting a film titled Muhammad: The Messenger of God with plans to show Muhammad on screen, though not his face, as per Shia tradition. The film world premier was on 27 August 2015. [7]

The Lady of Heaven

In June 2020, Deadline Hollywood announced that Enlightened Kingdom were producing The Lady of Heaven which would be the first film that shows the face of Muhammad. [8] In order to respect aniconism in Islam, Muhammad was portrayed by light and cinematic effects as opposed to being portrayed by an actor or single individual. [9] The producers of the film also discussed how they tackled the very challenging aspect of depicting a Muslim holy personality. [10] A trailer for the film was released on 23 December 2020 followed by a US theatrical release date a year later on 10 December 2021. [11] [12]

Later projects

There are some new films currently being produced about Muhammad, considered the "second of their kind" (referring to Western films respecting the portrayal of Muhammad). [13] [14]

In October 2008, Producer Oscar Zoghbi, who worked on the original The Message , stated that he would shooting a remake called The Messenger of Peace, to be shot around the holy cities of Mecca and Medina. [14]

Film producer Barrie M. Osborne has been hired as an adviser on a possible series of epics about Muhammad. The films, which are financed by a Qatari media company and will be supervised by the Egyptian cleric Yusuf al-Qaradawi, are unlikely to depict Muhammad at all on screen as per Sunni tradition which sees all renderings of the prophets as blasphemous. [13] [15]

List of films

DateProduction companyTitleCountry of originReferences
Unknown History Channel Muhammad: Biography UK [16]
UnknownUnknown Muhammad: A Mercy to Mankind
March 10, 1911 Milano Films L'Inferno Italy
September 3, 1977 Moustapha Akkad The Message (or Mohammad, Messenger of God)
UK, USA [17] [18]
2000PBS Islam: Empire of Faith USA [19]
[20]
March 12, 2002Mpi Home Video Story of Islam USA
December 17, 2002 PBS Muhammad: Legacy of a Prophet USA [21] [22]
[23] [24]
[25]
May 2, 2004BBC A Muslim In The Family UK [26] [27]
November 14, 2004Fine Media Group Muhammad: The Last Prophet USA [28]
[29] [30]
October 21, 2004 National Geographic Inside Mecca USA
2005 BBC (BBC Four) An Islamic History of Europe UK [31] [32]
[33]
2005BBC The Smell of Paradise UK
March 2, 2006Towers Productions Secrets of the Koran ( Decoding the Past )USA
September 25, 2006Quantum Leaps; EDS Understanding Islam: The Signs of the Last Day Turkey
July 2011 BBC (BBC Two) The Life of Muhammad UK [34]
July 2012 Nakoula Basseley Nakoula Innocence of Muslims US
December 10, 2012Enlightened Kingdom The Lady of Heaven UK
March 2015Nurtaban Film Industry Muhammad Iran

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sunni Islam</span> Largest branch of Islam

Sunni Islam is the largest branch of Islam, followed by 85–90% of the world's Muslims, and simultaneously the largest religious denomination in the world. Its name comes from the word Sunnah, referring to the tradition of Muhammad. The differences between Sunni and Shia Muslims arose from a disagreement over the succession to Muhammad and subsequently acquired broader political significance, as well as theological and juridical dimensions. According to Sunni traditions, Muhammad left no successor and the participants of the Saqifah event appointed Abu Bakr as the next-in-line. This contrasts with the Shia view, which holds that Muhammad appointed his son-in-law and cousin Ali ibn Abi Talib as his successor.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Al-Azhar University</span> Public university in Cairo, Egypt

The Al-Azhar University is a public university in Cairo, Egypt. Associated with Al-Azhar Al-Sharif in Islamic Cairo, it is Egypt's oldest degree-granting university and is known as one of the most prestigious universities for Islamic learning. In addition to higher education, Al-Azhar oversees a national network of schools with approximately two million students. As of 1996, over 4,000 teaching institutes in Egypt were affiliated with the university.

In Shia Islam, the Imamah is a doctrine which asserts that certain individuals from the lineage of the Islamic prophet Muhammad are to be accepted as leaders and guides of the ummah after the death of Muhammad. Imamah further says that Imams possess divine knowledge and authority (Ismah) as well as being part of the Ahl al-Bayt, the family of Muhammad. These Imams have the role of providing commentary and interpretation of the Quran as well as guidance.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mawlid</span> Islamic observation of prophet Muhammads birthday

Mawlid, also known as Eid-e-Milad an-Nabi, is an observance of the day when the Islamic prophet Muhammad is reported to have been born. It is commemorated in Rabi' al-Awwal, the third month in the Islamic calendar. 12th Rabi' al-awwal is the accepted date among most of the Sunni scholars, while some Shi'a scholars regard 17th Rabi' al-awwal as the accepted date.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Al-Azhar Shia Fatwa</span>

The Al-Azhar Shia Fatwa, known in Arabic as The Shaltoot Fatwa, is an Islamic fatwa issued in 1959 on the topic of Shi'a–Sunni relations by Sunni scholar Shaikh Mahmood Shaltoot. Under Shaltut, Sunni-Shia ecumenical activities would reach their zenith.

<i>The Message</i> (1976 film) Islamic drama film by Moustapha Akkad

The Message is a 1976 epic film directed and produced by Moustapha Akkad that chronicles the life and times of Muhammad, who is never directly depicted.

Sunni and Shia are different sects among Muslims and the difference of opinions have resulted in many Fatwas, non-binding but authoritative legal opinion or learned interpretation issues pertaining to the Islamic law. Fatwas are based on the question and answer process found in the Quran, which seeks to enlighten on theological and philosophical issues, hadith, legal theory, duties, and the Sharia law. Sunni fatwas have been used to justify the persecution of Shia throughout their history.

Tawassul is an Arabic word originated from 'wasilat'. The wasilah is a means by which a person, goal or objective is approached, attained or achieved. In another version of the meaning of tawassul in another text: Tawassul is an Arabic word that comes from a verbal noun, wasilah, which according to Ibn Manzur in Lisān al-'Arab means "a station of King, a rank, or act of devotion". In other words, it refers to a position of power due to one's proximity to the king or sovereign. While the tawassul or tawassulan is the use of wasilah for this purpose. In religious contexts, the tawassul is the use of a wasilah to arrive at or obtain favour of Allah.

Ahmed Al-Hasan is an Iraqi Shia Muslim religious leader. He has been called the most prominent of figures claiming to be the messianic al-Yamani, in the chaos following the US invasion of Iraq in 2003. In Twelver Shi'ism Islam, the majority religion of Iraq, al-Yamani is "the deputy of the Mahdi, the Twelfth Imam, and a precursor to his Reappearance" and to End Times.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fatima</span> Daughter of Muhammad (c. 605–632)

Fatima bint Muhammad, commonly known as Fatima al-Zahra', was the daughter of the Islamic prophet Muhammad and his wife Khadija. Fatima's husband was Ali, the fourth of the Rashidun Caliphs and the first Shia Imam. Fatima's sons were Hasan and Husayn, the second and third Shia Imams, respectively. Fatima has been compared to Mary, mother of Jesus, especially in Shia Islam. Muhammad is said to have regarded her as the best of women and the dearest person to him. She is often viewed as an ultimate archetype for Muslim women and an example of compassion, generosity, and enduring suffering. It is through Fatima that Muhammad's family line has survived to this date. Her name and her epithets remain popular choices for Muslim girls.

The permissibility of depictions of Muhammad in Islam has been a contentious issue. Oral and written descriptions of Muhammad are readily accepted by all traditions of Islam, but there is disagreement about visual depictions. The Quran does not explicitly or implicitly forbid images of Muhammad. The ahadith present an ambiguous picture, but there are a few that have explicitly prohibited Muslims from creating visual depictions of human figures. It is agreed on all sides that there is no authentic visual tradition as to the appearance of Muhammad, although there are early legends of portraits of him, and written physical descriptions whose authenticity is often accepted.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ahmed el-Tayeb</span> Egyptian Islamic scholar (born 1946)

Ahmed Mohamed Ahmed El-Tayeb is an Egyptian Islamic scholar and the current Grand Imam of al-Azhar, Al-Azhar Al Sharif and former president of al-Azhar University. He was appointed by the Egyptian President, Hosni Mubarak, following the death of Mohamed Sayed Tantawy in 2010. He is from Kurna, Luxor Governorate in Upper Egypt, and he belongs to a Sunni Muslim family.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Yasser Al-Habib</span> Kuwaiti Shia Cleric (born 1979)

Sheikh Yasser al-Habib is a Kuwaiti Shi'i scholar, and the head of the London-based Mahdi Servants Union, as well as Al-Muhassin mosque in Fulmer, Buckinghamshire, and the writer of The Lady of Heaven. Al-Habib's work focuses on Islamic history, drawing on Shia and Sunni sources.

Criticism of Twelver Shia Islam dates from the initial ideological rift among early Muslims that led to the two primary denominations of Islam, the Sunnis and the Shias. The question of succession to Muhammad in Islam, the nature of the Imamate, the status of the twelfth Shia Imam, and other areas in which Shia Islam differs from Sunni Islam have been criticized by Sunni scholars, even though there is no disagreement between the two sects regarding the centrality of the Quran, Muhammad, and many other doctrinal, theological and ritual matters. Shia commentators such as Musa al-Musawi and Ali Shariati have themselves, in their attempts to reform the faith, criticized practices and beliefs which have become prevalent in the Twelver Shia community.

Shia Islam in Egypt is composed of the highly persecuted low profile Shia Muslim community of Egypt.

<i>Muhammad: The Messenger of God</i> (film) 2015 Islamic epic Iranian film directed by Majid Majidi

Muhammad: The Messenger of God is a 2015 Iranian Islamic epic film directed by Majid Majidi and co-written with Kambuzia Partovi. Set in the sixth century, the plot revolves around the childhood of the Islamic prophet Muhammad.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fatwa of Ali Khamenei against insulting revered Sunni figures</span>

A Fatwa prohibiting the insulting of the most religious figures of Sunni Islam was published by Iran's Supreme Leader, Ali Khamenei, on 30 September 2010. The fatwa was issued following the insulting of Aisha by Yasser Al-Habib. This fatwa received various reactions from Shia and Sunni Muslims, and from Arabic and Western media.

<i>The Lady of Heaven</i> 2021 historical British film

The Lady of Heaven is a 2021 British historical drama film written by the Twelver Shia cleric Yasser Al-Habib, the spiritual leader and founder of The Mahdi Servants Union as well as of Fadak TV. Produced by Enlightened Kingdom, the film is the first movie on the life of the historical figure Fatima, the daughter of the Islamic prophet Muhammad, during the early Muslim period.

References

  1. Larsson, Göran (2011). Muslims and the New Media. Ashgate. p. 51. ISBN   978-1-4094-2750-6.
  2. 1 2 Devotion in pictures: Muslim popular iconography – The prophet Muhammad, University of Bergen
  3. Alessandra. Raengo & Robert Stam (2004). A Companion To Literature And Film . Blackwell Publishing. p.  31. ISBN   0-631-23053-X.
  4. "Istifta" . Retrieved 2015-09-28.
  5. Plate, S. Brent (2006). Blasphemy: Art that Offends. Black Dog. p. 39. ISBN   978-1-9047-7253-8.
  6. 1 2 Bakker, Freek L. (January 2006). "The image of Muhammad in The Message, the first and only feature film about the Prophet of Islam" (PDF). Routledge, "Islam and Christian-Muslim Relations", Vol. 17, No.1. Retrieved 2007-07-06.[ permanent dead link ]
  7. "MUHAMMAD THE FILM EVENT OF 2015 TO HAVE WORLD PREMIERE AT THE MONTREAL WORLD FILM FESTIVAL". ffm-montreal.org. Archived from the original on 22 July 2015. Retrieved 22 July 2015.
  8. D'Alessandro, Anthony (2020-06-29). "Enlightened Kingdom Sets 'Lady Of Heaven'; Feature About Lady Fatima, Daughter Of Muhammad". Deadline. Retrieved 2020-06-29.
  9. Al-Habib, Yasser. "The Lady of Heaven". Alhabib.org. Retrieved 2021-02-15.
  10. Blyth, Antonia (2021-07-14). "How 'The Lady Of Heaven' Producers Tackled The "Very Challenging" Aspect Of Depicting A Muslim Holy Person – Cannes Studio". Deadline. Retrieved 2021-07-16.
  11. "The Lady of Heaven, The Untold Story". KinoCheck. Retrieved 2021-07-16.
  12. "The Lady of Heaven". AMC Theatres. Retrieved 2021-10-28.
  13. 1 2 Child, Ben (March 15, 2013). "Qatar and Iran on rival missions to make films about prophet Muhammad". The Guardian.
  14. 1 2 "Movie planned on life of Mohammad". Reuters. Oct 27, 2008. Retrieved 2009-01-29.
  15. MTV
  16. "The Prophet Muhammad". History Channel Asia.com. Retrieved 2008-12-31.[ permanent dead link ]
  17. Kifner, John (2008). "Mohammad Messenger of God (1976) Alternate Titles: The Message, Mohammad: Messenger of God, Al-Risalah". Movies & TV Dept. The New York Times . Archived from the original on 2008-02-01. Retrieved 2008-12-31.
  18. "Overview for Mohammad Messenger of God (1976)". tcm.com. Retrieved 2008-12-31.
  19. "The Making of Islam: Empire of Faith". PBS.org. Retrieved 2008-12-31.
  20. "Islam: Empire of Faith Homepage". PBS . Retrieved 2008-12-31.
  21. "Muhammad: Legacy of a Prophet PBS Homepage". PBS. Retrieved 2009-01-01.
  22. "Muhammad: Legacy of a Prophet (2002) at IMDb". IMDb . Retrieved 2009-01-01.
  23. "Unity Production Foundations - Details (SYNOPSIS)". Archived from the original on 2008-07-30. Retrieved 2009-01-01.
  24. "Islam Project.org". Archived from the original on 2008-12-12. Retrieved 2009-01-01.
  25. "20,000 Dialogues". 20,000 Dialogues. Archived from the original on 2009-02-07. Retrieved 2009-01-01.
  26. Childs, Roger (1 May 2004). "BBC News article "A Muslim in the family"". BBC. Retrieved 2008-12-31.
  27. Omaar, Rageh. "BBC (Religion & Ethics: Islam) Essay: A Muslim in the family". BBC. Retrieved 2008-12-31.
  28. "Muhammad, the Last Prophet (2004) Profile". Yahoo. Retrieved 2008-12-31.
  29. Stevens, Dana (November 13, 2004). "Animated Retelling of the Birth of Islam (Film Review)". The New York Times. Retrieved 2008-12-31.
  30. Metacritic.com. "Muhammad: The Last Prophet Metacritic.com reviews". Metacritic.com. Archived from the original on 2018-12-26. Retrieved 2008-12-31.
  31. Omaar, Rageh. "An Islamic History of Europe". Rageh Omaar. BBC. Retrieved 2008-12-31.
  32. "An Islamic History of Europe BBC Educational Archive". Archived from the original on 2007-10-23. Retrieved 2008-12-31.
  33. "Bringing to Life the Islamic History of Europe: A Video Documentary Testimony". MuslimHeritage.com, BBC Four, Rageh Omaar. Archived from the original on 2013-01-04. Retrieved 2008-12-31.
  34. "Rageh Omaar to present The Life Of Muhammad for BBC Two". BBC. 2011-06-20. Retrieved 2013-02-01.

Further reading