Private member's bill

Last updated

A private member's bill is a bill (proposed law) introduced into a legislature by a legislator who is not acting on behalf of the executive branch. The designation "private member's bill" is used in most Westminster system jurisdictions, in which a "private member" is any member of parliament (MP) who is not a member of the cabinet (executive). Other labels may be used for the concept in other parliamentary systems; for example, the label member's bill is used in the Scottish Parliament and the New Zealand Parliament, [1] [2] the term private senator's bill is used in the Australian Senate, [3] and the term public bill is used in the Senate of Canada. [4] In legislatures where the executive does not have the right of initiative, such as the United States Congress, the concept does not arise since bills are always introduced by legislators (or sometimes by popular initiative).

Contents

In the Westminster system, most bills are "government bills" introduced by the executive, with private members' bills the exception; however, some time is set aside in the schedule for reading such bills. They may be introduced by non-ministerial MPs from government-supporting parties (backbenchers), by members of opposition parties (frontbencher or backbencher), or by independents or crossbenchers. The Israeli Knesset has a long history of enacting private members' bills: a slight majority of ther laws passed by it originated as private members' bills, and thousands more are introduced without being passed. [5] In contrast, the Oireachtas (parliament) of the Republic of Ireland rarely passes private members' bills, with the overwhelming number of bills being passed being introduced by members of the cabinet. [6]

A private member's bill is not to be confused with a private bill, which is a bill that only affects an individual citizen or group.

Private member's bill by country

Australia

In Australia, a draft bill is prepared by Parliamentary Counsel, acting under instructions from the private member. After community consultation, the member introduces the bill into the Parliament.

Only 30 private members' bills or private senators' bills introduced into the Australian Parliament since 1901 have been passed into law. [6] Of these, thirteen have been initiated by senators, ten by members and seven by the Speaker and Senate President. A larger number have passed one house but not the other. An even larger number did not pass the house in which they were introduced and thus lapsed.

Among the most notable of the successful bills was the Commonwealth Electoral Bill 1924, which introduced compulsory voting for federal elections. This was introduced by Senator for Tasmania Herbert Payne of the Nationalist Party [7] on 16 July 1924, passed by the Senate on 23 July, passed by the House of Representatives on 24 July – both times with little debate – and given Royal Assent on 31 July. Despite much public debate ever since on the issue of compulsory voting, the legislation has never been repealed.

Another very notable private member's bill was the Euthanasia Laws Bill 1996, which deprived the Northern Territory, Australian Capital Territory and Norfolk Island legislatures of the power to make laws permitting euthanasia. This was introduced by Kevin Andrews, Member for Menzies, after the Northern Territory Legislative Assembly had passed such a law, the Rights of the Terminally Ill Act 1995. Although Andrews was a member of the Liberal Party, members and senators were allowed a conscience vote on the issue, and each side of the debate was supported by members and senators from all political parties.

A private member's bill, the Marriage Amendment (Definition and Religious Freedoms) Act 2017, legalised same-sex marriage throughout Australia on 9 December 2017. It was introduced by Dean Smith, Senator for Western Australia.

Notable also was the private member's bill introduced by Alan Corbett in the New South Wales Legislative Council to amend the Crimes Act of 1900. The first successfully enacted (or indeed introduced) bill in over 100 years to address the protection of children from abuse and excessive physical chastisement. It received very wide support from New South Wales organisations related to child health and welfare and was backed by several prominent members of the medical profession, particularly in the paediatric field, notably Dr. John Yu, CEO of Royal Alexandra Hospital for Children, Sydney (who had been honoured by the Australian Government with the prestigious Australian of the Year award in 1996). Its initial aims were to limit physical chastisement by banning the use of implements (belts, sticks, hairbrushes, etc.), ban the use of force above the shoulders (thus preventing neck, head, brain and facial injuries), and require that any physical force applied leave only trivial and short-lived signs such as redness (that is, no bruising, swelling, welts, cuts, grazes, internal injuries, emotional trauma, etc.); with the exception of the clause banning the use of implements (which was dropped to gain essential support from the state Labor Government for the bill), it was passed intact and became law in 2001.

Canada

In Canada, a private member's bill (French : projet de loi émanant d'un député) is a bill introduced in the House of Commons by a member of parliament who is neither a cabinet minister nor a parliamentary secretary. A private member's bill follows the same legislative process as a government bill, but the time allocated for its consideration is restricted. Private members' bills may be considered only during one of the daily Private Members' Hours. Under rules established in 1986, 20 items of private members' business are selected at random to receive priority in debate. Six of these items are chosen by a committee to be votable and must come to a vote in the House. Prior to the 1986 rules, private members' bills and motions could be "talked out", meaning that all the time allocated to private members' bills could be used up introducing or debating bills without them ever being voted on, as each bill must be voted on after the second hour of debate. (The ramifications of the 1986 rules were discussed in the Canadian Parliamentary Review , 1988, Vol 11, No. 3. [8] ) Even under the new rules, very few private members' bills become law. But passage is more likely in minority government situations. [9] The vast majority of private members' bills that actually do become law are for the purpose of changing the name of the riding represented by the MP introducing the bill.

When an election is called, all bills that have not been passed die on the order paper (that is, they are removed from the agenda of Parliament, and must be re-introduced in the new session of Parliament after an election). In the House of Commons (but not in the Senate), private members' bills remain on the order paper when Parliament is prorogued.

Notable private members bills have been the following:

Passed

In the 98 years from 4 May 1910 to 7 September 2008, 229 private members' bills passed. [10]

Before the 1986 rules
  • One of the bills passed under the old (pre-1986) rules was a 1964 private member's bill to rename "Trans-Canada Airlines" to "Air Canada", introduced by then-rookie MP Jean Chrétien. [11] Chrétien got his bill voted on by convincing the other MPs scheduled to speak during Private Member's Hour to skip their speech and instead request an immediate vote on the bill. [12]
After the 1986 rules

The new rules took effect in 1986. In the 24 years between 5 November 1984 and 7 September 2008, 81 private members' bills passed. [10] Passage was (and is) more likely during the periods of minority governments in Canada. [9] The ramifications of the 1986 rules and new probability of success of private members bills were discussed in the Canadian Parliamentary Review , 1988, Vol 11, No. 3. [8]

  • NDP MP Lynn McDonald succeeded in getting her private member's bill, the "Non-smokers' Health Act" (aka Bill C-204), passed in 1986, (given Royal Assent on 28 June 1988) restricting smoking in federally regulated workplaces and on airplanes, trains and ships. [13] The bill was passed in a free vote of the House of Commons despite being voted against by all members of the federal cabinet, including the Minister of Health. [8]

India

Of the 300 or so private members' bills introduced in the 14th Lok Sabha, barely 4% were discussed; 96% lapsed without even a single debate in the House. To date,[ needs update? ] Parliament has passed a total of 14 private members' bills.

Following are the 14 Private Members' Bills which were passed:-

  1. The Muslim Wakfs Bill introduced by Syed Md. Ahmed Kasmi in Lok Sabha
  2. The Code of Criminal Procedure (Amendment) Bill introduced by Raghunath Singh in Lok Sabha
  3. The Indian Registration (Amendment) Bill introduced by SC Samanta in Lok Sabha
  4. The Proceedings of Legislature (Protection of Publication) Bill introduced by Feroze Gandhi in Lok Sabha
  5. The Women's and Children's Institutions (Licensing) Bill introduced by Rajmata Kamlendu in Lok Sabha
  6. Historical Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains (Declaration of National Importance) Bill introduced by Raghubir Sinh in Rajya Sabha
  7. The Hindu Marriage (Amendment) Bill introduced by Seeta Parmanand in Rajya Sabha
  8. The Code of Criminal Procedure (Amendment) Bill introduced by Subhadra Joshi in Lok Sabha
  9. The Orphanages and other Charitable Homes (Supervision and Control) Bill introduced by Kailash Bihari Lal in Rajya Sabha
  10. The Marine Insurance Bill introduced by MP Bhargava in Rajya Sabha
  11. The Hindu Marriage (Amendment) Bill introduced by Diwan Chand Sharma in Lok Sabha
  12. The Salaries and Allowances of MP (Amendment) Bill introduced by Raghunath Singh in Lok Sabha
  13. Indian Penal Code (Amendment) Bill introduced by Diwan Chand Lal in Rajya Sabha
  14. The SC (enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Bill introduced by Anand Narain in Lok Sabha

Five of these were passed in 1956 alone and after 47 years of passing the last bill, the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Bill, 1968 that became an Act on 9 August 1970; Rajya Sabha has passed the Rights of Transgender Persons Bill, 2014 on April 24, 2015, which was introduced in the lower house, Lok Sabha on 26 February 2016. [14]

Israel

In Israel, a private member's bill (Hebrew : הצעת חוק פרטית) is a bill introduced in the Knesset by an MK who is neither a cabinet minister nor a deputy minister. The number of private members' bills an individual MK can submit is restricted, and their introduction requires approval by the Knesset Presidium (composed of the Speaker of the Knesset and their deputies), who are allowed to reject bills which are racist in their essence or reject the Jewish character of the state.

Unlike government bills, which can be withdrawn at any point before their third reading, a private member's bill cannot be withdrawn after its committee stage, which occurs between first and second readings. In addition, private membes' bills must undergo a preliminary reading, while government bills go to first reading directly when they are introduced.

Compared to other Westminster system parliaments, the number of private members' bills introduced in the Knesset is very large: Between 2000 and 2016, the number of private members' bills introduced before the Knesset was 22,949, a world record. [15]

However, this is a relatively recent phenomenon – while only 6% of laws passed by the Third Knesset where introduced as private members' bills, the equivalent share for the Fifteenth Knesset is 53%, a slight majority.

Malaysia

As of September 2021, there hasn't been a single record where a private member's bill was passed in the Malaysian parliament. [16]

New Zealand

The biscuit tin and numbered counters used to select new member's bill in New Zealand. Members bill biscuit tin, NZ Parliament.jpg
The biscuit tin and numbered counters used to select new member's bill in New Zealand.

In New Zealand, a member's bill (often misattributed as private member's bill) is one that is introduced by a member of Parliament who is not a minister. There can be a maximum of eight members' bills on the Order Paper awaiting their first reading at any one time. When a slot opens up, a ballot is held to select a new members' bill for introduction; each MP can submit only one member's bill at a time to the ballot. Every second Wednesday is reserved for debating members' bills, although this rule is overridden when certain government business is before the House, such as the Budget. Even when a Wednesday is devoted to members' bills, any private or local bills on the Order Paper are considered first. [17]

The ballot to select new members' bills is conducted by drawing numbered counters out of a biscuit tin, purchased in the 1980s from now-defunct department store chain DEKA. As a result, the member's bill process is nicknamed "biscuit tin democracy". [18] [19]

Starting with the 53rd Parliament (2020–23), a member's bill can be introduced directly if it has the support of at least 61 non-executive members of Parliament. This allows members' bills with broad support to avoid the ballot process, while excluding executive members prevents the member's bill process being an alternative way of progressing Government business. [20]

Notable legislation passed as a result of a member's bill includes:

Norway

In the Parliament of Norway, any member may submit a private member's bill, called a representative's bill (Norwegian : representantforslag lovvedtak). [21] [22] The other method of initiating legislation is by a "Proposition to the Storting" from the Government. [21] [23]

United Kingdom

In the United Kingdom House of Commons, there are several routes to introducing private members' bills. In each session, twenty backbench MPs are selected by ballot to introduce a bill. These bills are given priority for debate and generally offer the best chance of success. Additional bills may be introduced via the Ten Minute Rule, although this is usually used just to raise an issue rather than legislate on it, or through presentation without debate under Standing Order 57. Neither Ten Minute Rule or presentation bills are likely to get time to be debated, so only non-controversial bills have any chance of success. Private members' bills from the Lords may also be adopted by an MP to complete their journey through Parliament.

Private members' bills can sometimes become the cause for much anxiety and shenanigans, as outside individuals or organisations seek to influence members who have been selected in the ballot.

There are two principal routes for influencing UK law:

Only a small proportion of private members' bills are enacted. This is generally because of lack of time – a controversial private member's bill can be "talked out". In some cases, measures that a government does not want to take responsibility for may be introduced by backbenchers, with the government secretly or openly backing the measure and ensuring its passage. They are sometimes known as "handouts" or "whips' bills". The Abortion Act 1967 was enacted in the United Kingdom through this means: with the Bill itself being introduced by a Liberal Party Member of Parliament, David Steel; through the support from Labour Home Secretary Roy Jenkins the Bill was given enough government time to allow a full debate.

Other private members' bills to have been enacted include the Adoption Act 1964, the Murder (Abolition of Death Penalty) Act 1965, the Charter Trustees Act 1985, the Law Reform (Year and a Day Rule) Act 1996, the Knives Act 1997, the British Nationality (Hong Kong) Act 1997, the Mental Health (Discrimination) Act 2003 the Female Genital Mutilation Act 2003, the Gangmasters (Licensing) Act 2004, the Sustainable Communities Act 2007.

House of Commons procedure

In principle, private members' bills follow much the same parliamentary stages as any other bill. In practice, the procedural barriers to passage are much greater.

Time is allocated for private members' bills on 13 Fridays a year in the House of Commons. Five hours of time are available each day, and several private members' bills are scheduled for each session.

Unlike Government bills, debates are not timetabled and there is no guarantee that the debate will finish within the time available. MPs opposed to a private member's bill, including Government ministers and whips, will routinely attempt to talk out the bill, stopping further progress by preventing a vote. The bill's proponent can force a vote only with the support of at least a hundred members (and a majority of those voting). [24] As many MPs return to their constituencies on Thursday night, this has the practical effect of blocking all private members' bills without solid support.

It is quite possible for the first bill to take up all five hours, preventing any other bill on the agenda from being debated. Any bill not debated may receive second reading without debate at the end of the session, but a single shout of "object!" will delay consideration to a future date; Government and opposition whips routinely block contentious private members' bills in this way. Another date for second reading will also be set for bills which have been talked out. This is a formality; the bill will be put to the bottom of the order paper, will likely be objected to on each future occasion and has no practical chance of success.

Even if second reading is passed, a bill is likely to need the support of the government to become law. The bill will be referred to public bill committee, which may make amendments. The amended version of the bill will then return to the Commons. To become law, it must also successfully negotiate report stage and third reading, as well as the House of Lords. Contentious bills are likely to run out of parliamentary time unless the government allocates some; any pending private members' bills lapse at the end of each parliamentary session.

Private members' bills may also originate in the House of Lords. To become law, these bills must be adopted by an MP and passed in the same way as a bill originated in the Commons.

See also

Related Research Articles

Acts of parliament, sometimes referred to as primary legislation, are texts of law passed by the legislative body of a jurisdiction. In most countries with a parliamentary system of government, acts of parliament begin as a bill, which the legislature votes on. Depending on the structure of government, this text may then be subject to assent or approval from the executive branch.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rajya Sabha</span> Upper house of the Parliament of India

The Rajya Sabha, constitutionally the Council of States, is the upper house of the bicameral Parliament of India. As of 2021 it has a maximum membership of 245, of which 233 are elected by the legislatures of the states and union territories using single transferable votes through open ballots, while the president can appoint 12 members for their contributions to art, literature, science, and social services. The potential seating capacity of the Rajya Sabha is 245, according to article 80 of the Indian Constitution. Members sit for staggered terms lasting six years, with about a third of the 238 designates up for election every two years, in even-numbered years. The Rajya Sabha meets in continuous sessions, and unlike the Lok Sabha, being the lower house of the Parliament, the Rajya Sabha is not subjected to dissolution. However, the Rajya Sabha, like the Lok Sabha, can be prorogued by the president.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lok Sabha</span> Lower house of the Parliament of India

The Lok Sabha, constitutionally the House of the People, is the lower house of India's bicameral Parliament, with the upper house being the Rajya Sabha. Members of the Lok Sabha are elected by an adult universal suffrage and a first-past-the-post system to represent their respective constituencies, and they hold their seats for five years or until the body is dissolved by the President on the advice of the council of ministers. The house meets in the Lok Sabha Chambers of the Sansad Bhavan, New Delhi.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Parliament of India</span> Bicameral national legislature of India

The Parliament of India is the supreme legislative body of the Republic of India. It is a bicameral legislature composed of the president of India and two houses: the Rajya Sabha and the Lok Sabha. The president in his role as head of the legislature has full powers to summon and prorogue either house of Parliament or to dissolve the Lok Sabha. The president can exercise these powers only upon the advice of the prime minister and his Union Council of Ministers.

India has a parliamentary system as defined by its constitution, with power distributed between the central government and the states.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Speaker of the Lok Sabha</span> Presiding member of the lower house of the Parliament of India

The speaker of the Lok Sabha is the presiding officer and the highest authority of the Lok Sabha, the lower house of the Parliament of India. The speaker is elected generally in the first meeting of the Lok Sabha following general elections. Serving for a term of five years, the speaker chosen from sitting members of the Lok Sabha.

In the Westminster system, a money bill or supply bill is a bill that solely concerns taxation or government spending, as opposed to changes in public law.

This is a brief description of the lawmaking procedure in India.

A reading of a bill is a stage of debate on the bill held by a general body of a legislature.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Act of Parliament (UK)</span> Primary legislation in the United Kingdom

In the United Kingdom an act of Parliament is primary legislation passed by the Parliament of the United Kingdom.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">N. K. Premachandran</span> Indian politician

N. K. Premachandran is an Indian politician. He is presently the Member of Parliament from Kollam Lok Sabha constituency. He was the former minister for Water Resources in the government of Kerala and was responsible for irrigation, ground water development, water supply and sanitation. He was a Member of both houses of the Parliament of India. He is known for his public speeches. Premachandran has written a book "Oh Iraq" based on his travel experience to Iraq. He was instrumental in taking up the issue of the safety of Mullaperiyar Dam.

Rajeev Shankarrao Satav was an Indian politician from the Indian National Congress. At the time of his death, he was the member of the Rajya Sabha the upper house of Indian Parliament from Maharashtra.

Tiruchi Siva is a member of the Parliament of India representing Tamil Nadu in the Rajya Sabha, the upper house of parliament. He is from the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam party, and was elected in 1996, 2002, 2007, 2014 and 2020. He is a speaker and a writer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">The Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013</span>

The Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013, commonly known as The Lokpal Act, is an anti-corruption Act of Indian Parliament in India which "seeks to provide for the establishment of the institution of Lokpal to inquire into allegations of corruption against certain important public functionaries including the Prime Minister, cabinet ministers, members of parliament, Group A officials of the Central Government and for matters connecting them".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rights of Transgender Persons Bill, 2014</span>

The Rights of Transgender Persons Bill, 2014 is a proposed Act of the Parliament of India which seeks to end the discrimination faced by transgender people in India. The Bill was passed by the upper house Rajya Sabha on 24 April 2015. It was introduced in the lower house Lok Sabha on 26 February 2016.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aadhaar Act, 2016</span>

The Aadhaar Act, 2016 is a money bill of the Parliament of India. It aims to provide legal backing to the Aadhaar unique identification number project. It was passed on 11 March 2016 by the Lok Sabha. Certain provisions of the Act came into force from 12 July 2016 and 12 September 2016.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">One Hundred and Third Amendment of the Constitution of India</span>

The One Hundred and Third Amendment of the Constitution of India, officially known as the Constitution Act, 2019, introduces 10% reservation for Economically Weaker Sections (EWS) of society for admission to Central Government-run educational institutions and private educational institutions, and for employment in Central Government jobs. The Amendment does not make such reservations mandatory in State Government-run educational institutions or State Government jobs. However, some states have chosen to implement the 10% reservation for economically weaker sections.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">One Hundred and Second Amendment of the Constitution of India</span>

The One Hundred and Second Amendment of the Constitution of India, officially known as the Constitution Act, 2018, granted constitutional status to the National Commission for Backward Classes (NCBC).

The Repealing and Amending Act, 2019 is an Act of the Parliament of India that repealed 58 Acts. It also made minor amendments to the Income Tax Act, 1961 and The Indian Institutes of Management Act, 2017. The Act was the sixth such repealing act aimed at repealing obsolete laws tabled by the Narendra Modi administration, and the first tabled during its second term. The government had repealed 1,428 Acts during its first term between 2014 and 2019.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">One Hundred and Fifth Amendment of the Constitution of India</span>

The One Hundred and Fifth Amendment to the Constitution of India- officially known as The Constitution Act, 2021- restored the power of State governments to recognise socially and educationally backward classes (SEBCs). SEBCs, which includes the groups commonly known as Other Backward Classes (OBCs), are communities for which the State can provide 'special provisions' or affirmative action in India.

References

  1. Part 3 Members' Bills Archived 2006-09-12 at the Wayback Machine www.scottish.parliament.uk, accessed 1 August 2009
  2. "How laws are made – Types of bill". New Zealand Parliament. Retrieved 27 December 2012.[ permanent dead link ]
  3. Muller, Damon (6 December 2017). "The passage of private members' and senators' bills through the Parliament". Parliament of Australia. Retrieved 22 September 2020.
  4. "Senate Procedure in Practice" (PDF). sencanada.ca. Senate of Canada. June 2015. Retrieved 30 June 2022. Senate public bills are legislative proposals not introduced on behalf of the government.
  5. Klein, Eran (2002). Private Member's Bills - Comparative Analysis and Recommendations (Report). The Israel Democracy Institute. Policy Paper No. 32.
  6. 1 2 "Private Members' business". Parliament of Australia. Retrieved 17 June 2022.
  7. "Parliamentary Handbook". www.aph.gov.au. Archived from the original on 7 September 2007.
  8. 1 2 3 Lever, Nora (14 September 2020). "Private Members' Business: What's Happened Under the New Rules?". Canadian Parliamentary Review . Canadian Parliamentary Review. 11 (3). Retrieved 21 September 2009.
  9. 1 2 "Liberal MP introduces war resisters bill". The Toronto Star. 17 September 2009. Retrieved 19 September 2009.
  10. 1 2 "Private Members' Public Bills Passed by Parliament: 1910 to Date". Parliament of Canada. 30 January 2009. Retrieved 23 September 2009.
  11. "Legacy of Former Prime Minister Jean Chrétien | Mapleleafweb.com". www.mapleleafweb.com. June 2006.
  12. See Jean Chrétien, Straight From the Heart (1990).
  13. Sweanor and K. Kyle, Legislation and Applied Economics in the Pursuit of Public Health: Canada, p. 79.
  14. "Lok Sabha Takes Up Bill To End Transgender Discrimination". NDTV . 27 February 2016. Retrieved 8 March 2016.
  15. https://hashiloach.org.il/%D7%A2%D7%95%D7%A6%D7%A8%D7%99%D7%9D-%D7%90%D7%AA-%D7%98%D7%99%D7%A8%D7%95%D7%A3-%D7%94%D7%97%D7%A7%D7%A7%D7%AA/
  16. Jason Thomas (7 September 2021). "Encourage Private Member's Bills, says constitutional expert". Free Malaysia Today. Archived from the original on 7 September 2021. Retrieved 8 September 2021.
  17. "Lucky dip leads to ground-breaking law changes". New Zealand Parliament. 7 June 2017. Retrieved 8 June 2017.
  18. Graham-McLay, Charlotte (17 December 2019). "Biscuit tin democracy: the humble start of New Zealand's most progressive laws". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 23 July 2020.
  19. "The House: Biscuit tin gamble". RNZ. 5 September 2018. Retrieved 23 July 2020.
  20. "Review of Standing Orders 2020 – New Zealand Parliament". www.parliament.nz. July 2020. pp. 34–35. Retrieved 14 October 2020.
  21. 1 2 "PQR". Dictionary. Stortinget. Retrieved 13 March 2012.
  22. "Representantforslag" (in Norwegian). Stortinget. Retrieved 13 March 2012.
  23. "Lovarbeidet". Stortinget og demokratiet (in Norwegian). Stortinget. Retrieved 13 March 2012.
  24. "House of Commons - Standing Orders of the House of Commons - Public Business 2005". publications.parliament.uk.