Saipan incident

Saipan incident

Date	May 2002
Location	Saipan, Northern Mariana Islands
Type	Industrial relations
Cause	Differential perspectives on FAI policy
Participants	Roy Keane, Mick McCarthy, Bertie Ahern
Outcome	Dismissal of Roy Keane
Inquiries	FAI Genesis Report
Litigation	None

The Saipan incident was a public quarrel in May 2002 between Republic of Ireland national football team's captain Roy Keane and manager Mick McCarthy when the team was preparing in Saipan for its matches in Japan in the 2002 FIFA World Cup. It resulted in Keane, a key player, being sent home from the squad. The incident divided public opinion in Ireland regarding who was to blame.

Background

Roy Keane signing autographs in 2005.

Keane was the captain of the Irish national team; since his senior debut under Jack Charlton and then-captain McCarthy, Keane had perceived problems with the preparations of the Irish side. He regarded the Football Association of Ireland (FAI)'s preparations as unprofessional and challenged both Charlton and McCarthy in a number of notable incidents. ^[1]

Among Keane's issues with Irish management were the conditions of the camp, travel arrangements (which seated the players in business class seats on flights, while FAI officials sat in first class), strategy, expectations, diet, and McCarthy's competence. ^[2] In his autobiography, Keane said that before a World Cup qualifier away versus the Netherlands, the Irish players were eating cheese sandwiches because the more suitable pre-match meal of pasta was not available. ^[3]

The island of Saipan was selected by an FAI delegation as an initial base. From management's perspective the time was considered a period of relative rest and recreation, at the end of a long club season, and a precursor to moving to Japan to prepare for the tournament. Keane, on the other hand, who is reputed to have told Alex Ferguson that he was going to the World Cup "to win it", viewed it as a period of preparation for the World Cup Finals. He therefore became dissatisfied when facilities and general preparation did not match his expectations. On 22 May Keane decided he was going home but subsequently changed his mind and stayed on. ^[4]

Events

Irish broadcaster RTÉ became aware of the developing row, as did several Irish newspapers. Because of its isolated location, there were certain stories circulating about the incidents, which were all critical of Keane. The Daily Star newspaper had been a harsh critic of Keane for months in the run up to the competition. This included making persistent allegations about Keane's commitment to the Irish team.

Keane had originally agreed to give an interview to sports journalist Paul Kimmage of the Sunday Independent . Kimmage then agreed to let Tom Humphries of The Irish Times join the interview, but made him promise not to print the article until after Kimmage's column on Sunday. Humphries reneged on the deal, stealing a major scoop for The Irish Times. ^[2] In the article, Humphries listed the events and concerns which had led Keane to decide to leave the team. This article included details and references to the FAI's preparations for the Irish team. ^[2] This indirectly implied that the event was organized as a junket for FAI officialdom. The article was seen as a direct affront to the authority of the Irish manager and the competence of the FAI.

The Irish Times article increased tensions greatly. McCarthy decided to question Keane about the article. In a team meeting McCarthy held up a copy of the article and asked "What's this all about?", and an argument started. McCarthy then accused Keane of faking injury when Ireland were playing Iran in the second leg of the play off. Keane then unleashed a stinging verbal tirade against McCarthy: "Mick, you're a liar … you're a fucking wanker. I didn't rate you as a player, I don't rate you as a manager, and I don't rate you as a person. You're a fucking wanker and you can stick your World Cup up your arse. The only reason I have any dealings with you is that somehow you are the manager of my country! You can stick it up your bollocks." ^[5] Mick McCarthy then held a press conference announcing that he had sent Keane home. ^{[6] [7]}

Niall Quinn observed in his autobiography that "Roy Keane's 10-minute oration [against Mick McCarthy] ... was clinical, fierce, earth-shattering to the person on the end of it and it ultimately caused a huge controversy in Irish society." But at the same time, he was also critical of Keane's stance, saying that "[Keane] left us in Saipan, not the other way round. And he punished himself more than any of us by not coming back." ^[8]

None of his team-mates voiced support for Keane during the meeting, though some later expressed their support to him privately. Keane mentioned in his autobiography that Gary Breen and David Connolly visited his room. Senior players Steve Staunton and Niall Quinn seemed to take the side of McCarthy, and the FAI, in the argument that followed. Staunton was the most loyal to the FAI line of the argument. He was later given the captaincy in Keane's absence. ^[9]

Aftermath

Despite the efforts of the media and Taoiseach Bertie Ahern, Keane and McCarthy failed to resolve the conflict and Keane missed the World Cup. ^[10] Keane gave an interview concerning the controversy to RTÉ and when asked if it was possible to go back he did not deny that he might. The Irish football team were defeated in a penalty shootout by Spain in the second round.

The FAI commissioned a report from external consultants Genesis, into its World Cup preparations. The "Genesis Report" agreed with many of Keane's criticisms, finding that the FAI structure was not conducive to good planning and making a range of recommendations. ^[11] The complete report was not published for legal reasons.^{[ further explanation needed ]} Brendan Menton resigned as FAI General Secretary at this time, and the media linked the two events, though Menton denied this. ^[12]

Legacy

Roy Keane stated that he would not play again for Ireland under McCarthy, and in his autobiography even said that his former national team coach could 'rot in hell'. McCarthy continued as national team manager and Ireland then played Russia in a qualifying match for the European Championship. Ireland lost to a badly resourced Russian team 4–2, who had played badly in the World Cup. Ireland lost the game 2–1 at Lansdowne Road. In the face of rebellion on the terraces, a decrease in support for the national team, and consequent declining attendance revenues, the FAI decided to ask McCarthy to resign. ^[13]

The appointment of Brian Kerr as team manager in 2003 led to Keane's return to international football on 27 May 2004, in a friendly match against Romania at Lansdowne Road. He played his final international game the following year, having been capped 67 times for the nation since 1991. He retired from playing at club level in 2006. Ireland failed to qualify for any major tournament until 2011, when after beating Estonia they qualified for the 2012 European Championships.

By November 2006, Keane appeared to have reconciled with McCarthy when the two men settled their differences via a phone call ahead of a match between McCarthy's Wolverhampton Wanderers and Keane's Sunderland. The handshake between the two men received considerable media attention. In April 2007, the managers again met in another match, and Keane praised McCarthy for his work in Sunderland previous to Keane's tenure there. In December 2013, Keane, speaking in an ITV4 documentary, admitted his regret at missing out on the 2002 World Cup and said that he should have put his personal issues with McCarthy to one side for the sake of the country, saying "To play in the World Cup. It would have been nice to play, A lot of people were disappointed, particularly my family." ^{[14] [15]}

Popular culture

The incident was so divisive that it was called a "civil war" for Ireland. The Irish Times later wrote that "[m]ost people have ... a story of a split between families, between friends, between work colleagues." ^[16] In 2005, a musical comedy play parodying the incident and its key players, I, Keano , opened in Dublin. The play, written by Arthur Mathews, Michael Nugent, and Paul Woodfull, represented the incident as a mock-epic melodrama about a Roman legion preparing for war. Keane attended a performance of the show, ^[17] which ran in Dublin until May 2008.

In an echo of the incident, three main cast members, including Mario Rosenstock, who portrayed "Keano" (the play's version of Roy Keane), left the show early in its first run, leading to media articles about life imitating art imitating life. ^{[18] [19] [20]}

References

1. Keane, Roy; Dunphy, Eamon (2002). Keane: The Autobiography. Michael Joseph. ISBN   0-7181-4554-2. p. 244
2. Malone, Emmet (9 May 2020). "Sporting Controversies: The whole story of Saipan and how the saga unfolded". Irish Times .
3. Soccer-Ireland.com Saipan Incident Thesis
4. Humphries, Tom (23 May 2002). "'People were not happy but life goes on. Nobody died.'". Irish Times .
5. "10 classic Roy Keane rants". The Guardian . London. 24 August 2006. Retrieved 21 April 2010.
6. "McCarthy sends Keane home from World Cup". RTE News. 23 May 2002.
7. "20 years of drama in Irish football, Chapter 2: Saipan - Paradise Lost". The 42. 11 May 2020. Retrieved 13 May 2020.
8. "The Odd Couple". BBC Sport. 27 August 2006. Retrieved 31 December 2009.
9. "World Cup: 25 stunning moments ... No13: Roy Keane walks out on Ireland". The Guardian. 1 May 2014. Retrieved 2 April 2015.
10. Cummiskey, Gavin (6 May 2022). "Saipan 20 years on: The inside story of the World Cup row that divided a nation". Irish Times.
11. http://foot.ie/inc/pdf/genesis.pdf ^{[ bare URL PDF ]}
12. "Menton quits following damning FAI report". RTÉ. 12 November 2002. Archived from the original on 9 December 2008. Retrieved 19 August 2009.
13. "McCarthy quits Republic". BBC Sport . 6 November 2002. Retrieved 19 August 2009.
14. McDonnell, Daniel (11 December 2013). "Keane: Missing 2002 World Cup is biggest regret of my career". Irish Independent. Retrieved 11 December 2013.
15. "13 things we learned from the Roy Keane-Patrick Vieira documentary". The Score. 11 December 2013. Archived from the original on 13 December 2013. Retrieved 11 December 2013.
16. Clerkin, Malachy (12 May 2012). "How war in the Pacific brought madness to these shores". Irish Times. Retrieved 12 May 2012.
17. Niamh Hennessy, Hundreds Queue for Tickets on Roy's Home Turf. Archived 29 September 2007 at the Wayback Machine . Irish Examiner, 26 July 2005
18. Art Imitates Life as Hit I, Keano Camp Splits. Evening Herald , 25 February 2005
19. New Scandal For Roy Keane Musical. Brian Logan, The Guardian , 3 March 2005
20. Lasting Impression Archived 17 August 2009 at the Wayback Machine Interview with Mario Rosenstock, Irish Examiner, 24 December 2005

External links

• Article and Analysis of the incident