An object with the spectral type T (also called T dwarf or methane brown dwarf) [1] is either a brown dwarf [2] or young free-floating planetary-mass object. [3] An directly imaged exoplanet with a young age can also be a T-dwarf. [4] T dwarfs are colder than L dwarfs, [1] but warmer than Y dwarfs. [5]
The first T-dwarf discovered was Gliese 229B, which was discovered in 1995. [6] This object had a temperature below 1000 K and showed methane (CH4), water vapor (H2O) and carbon monoxide (CO) in its spectrum. In the upper atmosphere CO is converted into CH4 and H2O, while the opposite is true for the hotter lower atmosphere. [7] [8] [9] It also showed absorption due to caesium (Cs), but absorption features commonly found in M-dwarfs (CaH, FeH, TiO, and VO) were missing. [10] Ammonia (NH3) was included in the analysis of the spectrum. [11] Sodium (Na) and potassium (K) are also detected in this T-dwarf. [12] Later work found a dynamical mass of 70 ± 5 MJ for Gliese 229B, which is much higher than the cooling models would suggest. [2] The spectral type is somewhat ambiguous. This is because it shows strong CH4 absorption at 1.3 and 1.6 μm, indicative of a T7 type, but weaker CH4 and H2O features at 1.1, 1.4, 1.9, and 2.2 μm, indicative of a T5-T6 type. [13] It is also suspected that Gliese 229B is a binary, which could explain its high mass and its unusual spectrum. [14] The binarity was confirmed in 2024 with instruments on the Very Large Telescope, which resolved the pair and constrained their orbit to be a tight semi-major axis of about 16 Earth-Moon distances and an orbital period of about 12.1 days. Gliese 229Ba has a mass of about 38 MJ and Gliese 229Bb has a mass of about 34 MJ. [15]
The spectral type "T" was first proposed in 1999 with Gliese 229B as its only representative at the time. [1] Next came the discovery of Gliese 570D, [16] SDSS 1624+00 (first field T-dwarf) [17] and SDSS 1346-00 (second field T-dwarf). [18] These were however mid- to late T-dwarfs and the first early T-dwarfs (SDSS 0837, SDSS 1254, and SDSS 1021) were discovered in data of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey in 2000. These objects show weaker CH4 absorption than previously discovered T-dwarfs. [19] CH4 appears first in the K-band in L8 dwarfs and L- and T-dwarfs are distinguished by the appearance of CH4 in the H-band for T-dwarfs. T-dwarfs show an increasing absorption of H2O and CH4 from T0 to T8. Neutral Na and K features broaden in L- and T-dwarfs and the Na feature increases in depth for L/T-dwarfs with increasing spectral type. [20] One of the coldest T-dwarfs was discovered with UKIDSS, called UGPS 0722-05. [21] [22] Researchers used WISE to discover additional late T-dwarfs and the objects of the newly discovered Y-dwarfs. The transition between T- and Y-dwarfs is defined with the help of UGPS 0722-05 as the T9 standard and WISE 1738+2732 as the Y0 standard. Late T and early Y-dwarfs show deep H2O and CH4 absorption features and the transition between T- and Y-dwarfs occurs near 500 K. [5] [23] Another important T-dwarf is Luhman 16B, which is the closest T-dwarf. It has a spectral type of T0.5, near the L/T transition. It shows a hint of FeH in the spectrum, which weakens in late L dwarfs, but strengthens in early to mid T-dwarfs due to cloud disruption. [24] [25] Observations of T-dwarfs in the near- and mid-infrared with JWST clearly show additional absorption features due to NH3, CH4, H2O, CO and carbon dioxide (CO2). [26] Observations with Gemini showed the first detection of hydrogen sulfide (H2S) and molecular hydrogen (H2) in the T6 dwarf DENIS J081730.0−615520. [27]
Subdwarfs with a T spectral type are known, with 2MASSI J0937347+293142 being the first T-type subdwarf. It shows blue near-infrared colors due to suppression of the 2.1 μm peak, likely caused by enhanced collision induced absorption (CIA) of hydrogen (H2). [28] [29] Subdwarfs have a low metallicity and at first only a small sample with moderate low metallicity was known. In 2020 the backyard worlds citizen science project discovered the first extreme subdwarfs of spectral type T, called WISEA 0414−5854 and WISEA 1810−1010. These objects have unusual blue colors, indicative of a lower absorption from CH4. [30] Follow-up observations of WISEA 1810−1010 show that it only shows absorption due to H2O and H2 in the optical and infrared spectra. CH4 is missing completely, which stays in contrast to the definition of T-dwarfs as "methane dwarfs" and WISEA 1810−1010 was instead called a "water vapor dwarf". [31] In 2024 Burgasser et al. introduced a classification system for T subdwarfs, which allows the classification into mild subdwarfs (d/sdT), subdwarfs (sdT) and extreme subdwarfs (esdT). The signature of a low metallicity are a strong collision induce absorption (CIA) of hydrogen molecules, obscured methane and water features, and weak potassium K I absorption. This work also identified three brown dwarfs that are candidate members of stellar streams. Future works with JWST, Euclid, Rubin and Roman will increase the sample of T subdwarfs to thousands. [32] JWST has already discovered the first distant T subdwarfs such as UNCOVER-BD-1. [33]
Most T-dwarfs are brown dwarfs. Brown dwarfs have a mass lower than the hydrogen burning minimum mass (0.075 M☉ or 78.5 MJ). [34] There are currently 920 objects in the UltracoolSheet with an infrared spectral type of T. [35] The table of ultracool fundamental parameters lists objects with an infrared spectral type of T that have masses between 2 and 58 MJ. [36] [37] Additional T-type brown dwarfs that orbit stars or white dwarfs are known and the age of the primary can help to determine the mass of the T-dwarfs. [38] [39] [40] One of the oldest known T-dwarfs is Wolf 1130C, which is around 10 billion years old. [41]
One of the first objects that was conclusively determined to be a young isolated planetary-mass object with spectral type T was SDSS J1110+0116 (T5.5), which is a member of the 120 Myr old AB Doradus moving group. [42] Another significant discovery is one of the closest planetary-mass objects, called SIMP J013656.5+093347 (T2.5, 12.7 ±1.0 MJ), which is part of the 200 Myr old Carina-Near moving group. [3] This object is also variable with a period of 2.4 hours, likely due to clouds. [43] It also shows radio emission due to aurorae. [44] Additional young T-dwarf candidates are known from other young stellar associations and these objects show red colors compared to field T-dwarfs. [45] Young directly imaged exoplanets and planetary-mass companions sometimes show a T spectral type, such as 51 Eridani b (T4.5-T6). [4]
Two of the most variable brown dwarfs are the T-dwarfs Luhman 16B, showing a variation up to 20% [46] and 2MASS J2139+02, which varies with an amplitude as high as 26%. [47] T-dwarfs, especially young early-type T-dwarfs are often variable. The variability has been connected to the presence of clouds, but other explanations were proposed, such as hot spots and aurorae. [48] These early T-dwarfs are thought to have an iron cloud deck and a patchy silicate cloud layer on top of it. The silicate clouds are thought to dissipate near the L/T transition, resulting into the patchy silicate cloud layer and high amplitude variability for late L and early T dwarfs. [49] The disruption of clouds make deeper layers accessible for observations. These deeper layers are warmer and contain FeH. This explains the reappearance and strengthening of FeH and the blue near-infrared color for early to mid T-dwarfs. [25] Late T-dwarfs should also have cloud layers made of chromium, potassium chloride and different sulfides. These cloud layers are thin and exist above the silicate clouds. [49] One late T-dwarf that is variable is WISE 0458+6434 (T8.5), which varied with 13% in one epoch. [50]
The first T-dwarf detected in radio emission was 2MASS J1047+21 (T6.5), which was discovered with the Arecibo radio telescope. [51] Since then several other T-dwarfs with radio emission were discovered, including the planetary-mass object SIMP J013656.5+093347 (T2.5) [44] and the discovery of the T-dwarf BDR J1750+3809 with the help of radio emission. [52] The coldest T-dwarf with a radio emission is WISEPA J062309.94-045624.6 (T8). [53] Radio emission in T-dwarfs is thought to be generated by an aurora, similar to late L-dwarfs. Additionally H-alpha emission is often connected to radio emission in L4-T8 dwarfs and is thought to come from aurorae. [54] 2MASS 1237+6526 (T6.5) is an unusual strong H-alpha emitting T-dwarf that was discovered in 2000. [55] It was theorized that the H-alpha emission, UV emission and radio emission come either from a cold companion (1-2.8 R🜨; <500 K) or from an aurora. [56]
Late T dwarf binaries are less common than L-type binaries. Only 8±6% systems with a T5–Y0 primary are binaries and these systems usually have a separation of a few astronomical units (AU). [57] One well-known T dwarf binary is Epsilon Indi B. [58] This binary consists of a T1 and a T6 dwarf that orbit each other with a separation of 2.65 AU. [59] T dwarf triple systems also exist, with 2M0838+15 being the first fully resolved triple T dwarf that was discovered. [60]
Brown dwarfs are substellar objects that have more mass than the biggest gas giant planets, but less than the least massive main-sequence stars. Their mass is approximately 13 to 80 times that of Jupiter (MJ)—not big enough to sustain nuclear fusion of ordinary hydrogen (1H) into helium in their cores, but massive enough to emit some light and heat from the fusion of deuterium (2H). The most massive ones can fuse lithium (7Li).
A subdwarf, sometimes denoted by "sd", is a star with luminosity class VI under the Yerkes spectral classification system. They are defined as stars with luminosity 1.5 to 2 magnitudes lower than that of main-sequence stars of the same spectral type. On a Hertzsprung–Russell diagram subdwarfs appear to lie below the main sequence.
Gliese 229 is a multiple system composed of a red dwarf and two brown dwarfs, located 18.8 light years away in the constellation Lepus. The primary component has 58% of the mass of the Sun, 55% of the Sun's radius, and a very low projected rotation velocity of 1 km/s at the stellar equator.
2MASS J05325346+8246465 is possibly the first brown dwarf observed in the galactic halo of the Milky Way, and the first known substellar subdwarf star. It was discovered from Two Micron All-Sky Survey data, and verified by observations at Palomar Observatory and W. M. Keck Observatory. It has a low metallicity, which indicates it is an old star.
An object with the spectral type L can be either a low-mass star, a brown dwarf or a young free-floating planetary-mass object. If a young exoplanet or planetary-mass companion is detected via direct imaging, it can also have an L spectral type, such as Kappa Andromedae b.
An object with a spectral type Y is either a brown dwarf or a free-floating planetary-mass object. They have temperatures below around 500 Kelvin and are colder than T-dwarfs. Y-dwarfs have a similar spectrum when compared to the giant planet Jupiter.
SIMP J013656.5+093347 is a brown dwarf or planetary mass object at 19.9 light-years from Earth in the constellation Pisces. It belongs to the spectral class T2.5 and its position shifts due to its proper motion annually by about 1.24 arcsec in the right ascension.
WISEPA J173835.53+273258.9 is a brown dwarf of spectral class Y0, located in the constellation Hercules at 24.9 light-years from Earth.
2MASS J21392676+0220226 is a brown dwarf located 34 light-years from Earth in the constellation Aquarius. Its surface is thought to be host to a massive storm, resulting in large variability of its color. It is a member of the Carina-Near moving group. This brown dwarf was discovered in the Two Micron All-Sky Survey (2MASS).
Backyard Worlds: Planet 9 is a NASA-funded citizen science project which is part of the Zooniverse web portal. It aims to discover new brown dwarfs, faint objects that are less massive than stars, some of which might be among the nearest neighbors of the Solar System, and might conceivably detect the hypothesized Planet Nine. The project's principal investigator is Marc Kuchner, an astrophysicist at NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center.
2MASS J11263991−5003550(2MASS J1126−5003) is a brown dwarf about 53 light-years distant from earth. The brown dwarf is notable for an unusual blue near-infrared color. This brown dwarf does not show subdwarf features and the blue color cannot be explained by an unresolved binary. Instead the blue color is explained by patchy clouds. The patchy cloud model allows thick clouds and a cloud coverage of 50% to explain the spectra of 2MASS J1126−5003. Other blue L-dwarfs exist, but are quite rare.
Wolf 1130 is a nearby pre-cataclysmic triple star system consisting of a cold subdwarf of spectral type sdM3 (A), an ultramassive white dwarf (B) and a cold brown dwarf of spectral type sdT8 (C). Wolf 1130 is 54.1 light-years distant from earth.
BD+29 5007 is a K-type star, located 77 light-years in the constellation Pegasus. It has a large-separation companion that was identified in 2016. The pair was identified to be a possible member of the 45+15
−5 million years old Argus association, though this is disputed.
UNCOVER-BD-1 is a distant brown dwarf. It is the most distant T dwarf discovered to date.
SDSS 1624+00 is the first T dwarf discovered in the field, meaning it does free-float in space and does not belong to a group of stars.
{{cite journal}}
: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link){{cite arXiv}}
: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)