An editor has nominated this article for deletion. You are welcome to participate in the deletion discussion , which will decide whether or not to retain it. |
Victorian bias in the Australian Football League (also known as "VicBias") is an assertion by critics of the Australian Football League (AFL) that there is an intrinsic bias towards its Victorian based clubs and Victorian developed players. Causes attributed to the alleged bias range from
In 1982 the VFL relocated the South Melbourne Football Club to Sydney in New South Wales with the following decade seeing the competition established clubs in all Australian mainland states. By 1997 there were 10 clubs located in Victoria and 6 clubs located outside of that the state. After a further series of expansion clubs being introduced the AFL consists of 8 clubs outside Victoria whilst retaining 10 clubs inside it. This imbalance of clubs inside and outside Victoria is often cited as the main, or even only, cause of any bias. [1]
Assertions of bias towards Victorian based clubs in the AFL are multifaceted.
The location of the AFL Grand Final is often the subject of allegations of Victorian bias in the AFL due to long-term deals for it to be hosted at the Melbourne Cricket Ground. [2] John Longmire in 2024 spoke out about the advantage playing the Grand Final at the MCG gives to Victorian clubs, proposing a best-of-three series to counter it. [3]
During its history, the league has prioritised Victorian clubs in its national expansion in an effort to maintain their history, tradition and fanbase. As such the vast majority, 12 of 18 AFL clubs in 2024, present strong Victorian Football League identities. Two notable cases of this are the Sydney Swans (who began in South Melbourne) and the Brisbane Lions (who merged with the Fitzroy Football Club). In both cases the league subsidised the retention of their Victorian histories and identities in the new national competition. [4] [5] [6] In 1981 the league dismissed new license proposals from Perth, Adelaide, Canberra and Sydney prior to incentivising the relocation of South Melbourne to Sydney. [7] [8] And despite the club not being accepted there, continued for decades to heavily subsidise it and re-tender the license to ensure its survival across the Barassi Line over a wide range of proposals involving non-Victorian licenses. [9] [10] The league pushed to move struggling Fitzroy to Brisbane as early as 1986 initially giving the proposal first priority over a new Brisbane license [11] [12] and ultimately forcing the merger in 1996. [13] [14]
Likewise the league strongly prioritised relocation of the North Melbourne Football Club over plans for new clubs in Canberra, Gold Coast, Greater Western Sydney and Tasmania as new licenses with their own identities. [15] [16] Both Fitzroy and North Melbourne strongly resisted these moves abd the AFL persisted despite the clubs failing to gain any significant following in the new markets.
The league since the 1980s has charged many millions in new license fees which were distributed to its primarily Victorian members to support their financial survival. [17] In 2004 it introduced a Competitive Balance Fund (CBF) which subsidised primarily the continued existence of struggling Victorian clubs. The Melbourne Football Club successfully lobbied the AFL to provide assistance to Victorian clubs arguing that the domination of the competition by non-Victorian clubs was permanent and not cyclical. [18] In 2023 North Melbourne and St Kilda, Melbourne and the Western Bulldogs received similar amounts to Brisbane [19] even though Brisbane's debt levels were much higher. [19] Four Victorian clubs received more than the five out of eight non-Victorian clubs. [19] Emergency funds have been given as grants outside the CBF in 2003 to Victorian clubs North Melbourne, Western Bulldogs, Carlton in 2006 and Melbourne in 2009 and 2013 to prevent insolvency. [20]
In contrast, its has been less forthcoming to non-Victorian clubs. Expansion clubs the West Coast Eagles and Brisbane Bears, whose $4 million 1986 license fees kept Fitzroy and Footscray trading both came to the brink of financial collapse within two seasons. [21] [22] In 1989 as both clubs were about to fold their Victorian counterparts continued to trade. [21] [22] Neither the Eagles or Bears received league assistance, instead it sold the Bears to Reuben Pelerman [22] and the West Australian Football Commission bought up a significant stake in the Eagles to ensure their survival. [21] The Port Adelaide Football Club was required to significantly modify its identity to protect the identity of Victorian club Collingwood prior to being granted entry to the league. [23] In 2009, the league initially denied Port emergency funds when it faced a financial crisis, instead it faced the threat of its license being revoked and was demanded to seek funds from the South Australian National Football League, in place of an emergency grant the league brokered a deal that involved a loan from the SANFL and a buy-back of the club's AFL license. [24] [25]
Despite rebranding as the AFL in 1990, the league retains all Victorian records since becoming a national competition, meaning that it will take many decades for non-Victorian clubs and players to challenge existing records such as Victorian premiership tallies and Victorian player records which have an almost century long head start.
In 2020 Mick Malthouse claimed that the AFL was Victorian-centric in its handling of the fixture, pointing to its decisions during the COVID-19 Pandemic as a prime example. [26] Travis Boak called out the unfair fixture and the advantage it gives to Victorian teams. [27] Adam Simpson claimed that the fixturing makes it harder for interstate sides to win than Victorian sides. [28] In 2023 Tim Gossage claimed that the AFL fixture is biased towards Victorian clubs because Victorian teams play many more away games on their home grounds than the interstate teams do. [29] In 2024 Graham Cornes claimed that the fixture is biased towards Victorian clubs and unfairly penalises South Australian clubs. [30] The league cites commercial factors such as audience maximisation in defence of the fixture. [31]
The West Australian in 2020 reported that non-Victorian based players are required to travel far greater distances during their careers [32] with West Coast Eagles players Darren Glass, Daniel Kerr, Mark LeCras, Quinten Lynch and Chris Masten all travelling over 515,000 km in their first 200 games compared to Collingwood players Ben Johnson, Alan Didak, Dane Swan, Josh Fraser and Travis Cloke all travelling less than 96,000 km for their first 200 appearances in the AFL. [32]
Friday nights are regarded as the premier time slot for AFL fixtures as they are broadcast nationally on free to air, consequently generating the largest TV audiences of the week for the competition. Victorian clubs often dominate the Friday night fixture, and it is asserted that this is the result of broadcasters' preference for those matches to involve Melbourne teams, as that city is the largest market for the competition. [33]
The AFL fixture has a heavy bias towards providing Victorian clubs with stand alone public holiday fixtures.[ citation needed ] The Anzac Day match has since 1995 been perpetually held in Victoria at the Melbourne Cricket Ground between Collingwood and Essendon, and is often cited as an example of a Victorian-centric approach to commemorating the national public holiday. [34] Victoria is the only state to get a dedicated public holiday for the AFL competition; non-Victorian clubs are required to travel early to Melbourne on Grand Final eve to participate in festivities. [35]
As a result of both the AFL administrative headquarters (AFL House) and the majority of the league's teams being located in Victoria the majority of the competitions associated media is based in Victoria. As a result, it is asserted that the media that covers the game has a bias towards Victorian clubs and particularly Victorian based players with critics suggesting that players of Victorian clubs garner a higher profile compared to their non-Victorian counterparts. [36]
Supporters of non-Victorian clubs often complain about the AFL's clash uniform policy which is lenient on Victorian based clubs but strongly upheld for non-Victorian clubs. [37] Richmond, Carlton and Collingwood are often singled out as almost never adhering to the AFL's 'Clash Uniform Policy'. [38] However, in more recent times Richmond have been more accepting of the policy, wearing a full clash uniform for the 2017 AFL Grand Final. [39]
There have been claims that supporters of non-Victorian clubs pay higher ticket prices than those in Melbourne with the former effectively subsiding the latter. [37]
In 1990 the league made selection exceptions to State of Origin rules resulting in three of the four best players representing Victoria who were not even from Victoria, including Hawthorn's Jason Dunstall and Essendon's Terry Daniher from Queensland and New South Wales respectively. [40] Upon taking over State of Origin in 1993, it merged 4 states and territories effectively removing their representation in interstate football. In 1994 it merged further states into a composite team called The Allies representing multiple states. Despite the competition being popular outside of Victoria and the unpopularity of these composite sides, it abolished State of Origin in 1999. After this it would schedule matches (AFL Hall of Fame Tribute Match and State of Origin for Bushfire Relief Match) such that only Victoria would compete as a standalone state effectively preventing all other states from challenging it and all players from outside Victoria from representing their state of origin. [41] In 2017 the AFL removed representative teams from the National Championships in favour of teams based on its clubs to secure talented athletes from other sports, which means that players from other states are not able to achieve state selection on merit from their local competitions.
More than 60% of professional AFL players are recruited from the state in 2017 despite it having just 30% share of registered players worldwide and 40% of Australian players. While this reflects the proportion of Victorian clubs in the competition, it also denies many players from oustide Victoria the opportunity to play the sport professionally. AFL clubs across the country have been accused of focusing their recruitment on Victorian developed players. Critics claim that this is because current pathways favour them. [42] This is exacerbated by a "go home factor" where clubs won't risk recruiting players from outside the state who could return due to homesickness. [43] [44] The AFL run Talent League which is based in Victoria and predominantly consists of Victorian teams is promoted as the best way to recruit players, with the vast majority of players being sourced from its ranks. [45] [46] Victorian AFL clubs have lobbied against the introduction of northern academies aimed at increasing the number of players from developing states like New South Wales and Queensland. [47] [48] This bias is not as evident in the AFL Women's competition where despite a similar demographic distribution, the most successful clubs appear to be more open minded to non-Victorian and local talent. [49] [50]
The AFL draft includes a father–son rule, allowing clubs priority access to recruit the sons of former players. During the first two decades of the non-Victorian clubs' existences, this rule applied unequally to Victorian and non-Victorian clubs: for Victorian clubs, it applied to sons whose fathers who had played 100 games for their club; for Western Australian clubs, it applied to sons whose fathers had played 150 games for one of four WAFL clubs; and for South Australian clubs, it applied to sons whose fathers had played 200 games for one of four or six SANFL clubs. [51] This was supposed to create a roughly equitable outcome, but failed in practice, with very few South Australian or Western Australian sons ever recruited under the state-league eligibility rule. [52] [53]
When the AFL introduced the NGA, vic clubs were given access 12 months before SA and WA, and then SA and WA were limited to indigenous players selected after pick 40 except for two remote regions.[ citation needed ]
The Australian Football Hall of Fame has been criticised by football writers and historians for being heavily biased towards figures from Victoria. [54] The initial selection committee was made up of 11 Victorians, one South Australian and one Western Australian, with the current selection committee being made up of six Victorians, two Western Australians and one South Australian. Of the 136 inaugural inductees into the Hall of Fame, 116 played substantial parts of their careers in Victoria, with eleven of the thirteen "Legends" from Victoria. [55]
It is often argued by Victorian football commentators that the non-Victorian teams have the only real home ground advantages in the competition as they host travelling sides every second week whereas Victorian clubs are often hosting games against other Victorian clubs resulting in neutral fixtures in regards to home ground advantage.[ citation needed ]
It has been argued that the two South Australian clubs receive an unfair advantage during the home-and-away season as a result of the neutral Gather Round event being played there, giving them an extra game in a home-like atmosphere compared with other clubs.[ citation needed ] Gather Round, first staged in 2023, will be played in South Australia every year until at least 2026. [56]
It is sometimes argued by supporters of Geelong that instead of there being a Victorian bias in the AFL it is actually a Melbourne bias with the club often being forced to play home games in the neighbouring city instead of in Geelong.
It is also suggested that the AFL revenue stream is more profitable from large Victorian Clubs succeeding in the regular season and playing finals, almost a desired top 8 of rich Victorian Clubs.
An AFL top 8 featuring high membership Victorian Clubs attracts larger TV viewership and therefore higher audience, which all helps with TV rights negotiations.
The Victorian Football League (VFL) is an Australian rules football competition in Australia operated by the Australian Football League (AFL) as a second-tier, regional, semi-professional competition. It includes teams from clubs based in eastern states of Australia: Victoria, New South Wales and Queensland, including reserves teams for the eastern state AFL clubs. It succeeded and continues the competition of the former Victorian Football Association (VFA) which began in 1877. The name of the competition was changed to the Victorian Football League in 1996. Under its VFL brand, the AFL also operates a women's football competition known as VFL Women's, which was established in 2016.
Representative matches in Australian rules football are matches between representative teams played under the Australian rules, most notably of the colonies and later Australian states and territories. Senior intercolonial representative matches took place from 1879 to the turn of the 20th century. For most of the 20th century, the absence of a national club competition in Australia meant that interstate matches were regarded as important events.
The Australian Football Hall of Fame was established in 1996, the centenary year of the Australian Football League, to help recognise the contributions made to the sport of Australian rules football by players, umpires, media personalities, coaches and administrators. It was initially established with 136 inductees. As of 2024, this figure has grown to more than 300, including 32 "Legends". Jason Dunstall became the most recent inductee to achieve Legend status in 2024. There had previously been 32 official Legends prior to Dunstall's elevation, but disgraced player Barry Cable had his football honours rescinded after being found guilty of historical child sex abuse.
The Talent League is an under-19 Australian rules football representative competition based in Melbourne and run by the Australian Football League (AFL). It is based on geographic regions throughout country Victoria and metropolitan Melbourne with each team representing one of twelve Victorian regions, while a thirteenth team from Tasmania was reintroduced in 2019.
The Australian Football League (AFL) is the pre-eminent professional competition of Australian rules football. It was originally named the Victorian Football League (VFL) and was founded in 1896 as a breakaway competition from the Victorian Football Association (VFA), with its inaugural season in 1897. It changed its name to Australian Football League in 1990 after expanding its competition to other Australian states in the 1980s. The AFL publishes its Laws of Australian football, which are used, with variations, by other Australian rules football organisations.
In New South Wales, Australian rules football dates back to the 1860s colonial era, with organised competitions being continuous since the 1880s. It is traditionally popular in the outback areas of the state near the Victorian and South Australian borders— in the Murray Region, in the Riverina and in Broken Hill. These areas form part of an Australian cultural divide described as the Barassi Line. To the west of the line it is commonly known as "football" or "Australian Football" and to east of the line, it is promoted under the acronym "AFL" by the main development body AFL NSW/ACT. There are more than 15 regional leagues though some are run from other states, the highest profile are AFL Sydney and the Riverina Football Netball League. With 80,572 registered players, it has the third most of any jurisdiction.
In Victoria Australian rules football is the most popular sport overall, being the most watched and second most participated code of football. Australian rules football originated in Melbourne in the late 1850s and quickly came to dominate in the sport, which it continues to. Victoria has more than double the number of players of any other state in Australia accounting for approximately 42% of all Australian players in 2023 and continues to grow strongly. In 2023 there were 76 competitions and 1,242 clubs. According to Ausplay there are 227,213 adult of which about one in three are female and 96,068 children playing, similar numbers to soccer. The sport is governed by AFL Victoria based in Melbourne. The national governing body, the AFL Commission is also based in Melbourne.
The 1991 AFL season was the 95th season of the Australian Football League (AFL), which was known previously as the Victorian Football League until 1989. The season ran from 22 March until 28 September, and comprised a 22-game home-and-away season followed by a finals series featuring the top six clubs, an increase from the top five clubs which had contested the finals since 1972.
The 1987 VFL season was the 91st season of the Victorian Football League (VFL). The season ran from 27 March until 26 September, and comprised a 22-game home-and-away season followed by a finals series featuring the top five clubs.
The Barassi Line is an imaginary line in Australia which approximately divides areas where Australian rules football or rugby league is the most popular football code. The term was first used by historian Ian Turner in his 1978 Ron Barassi Memorial Lecture. Crowd figures, media coverage, and participation rates are heavily skewed in favour of the dominant code on either side. Most other sports are unaffected by the dichotomy; Australian cricket, for example, has maintained consistent national interest throughout its history, though soccer faces more competition for participation in areas where Australian rules is more popular.
The Australian National Football Council (ANFC) was the national governing body for Australian rules football in Australia from 1906 until 1995. The council was a body of delegates representing each of the principal leagues which controlled the sport in their respective regions. The council was the owner of the laws of the game and managed interstate administrative and football matters. Its function was superseded by the AFL Commission.
The Australian Football League, currently an 18 team competition, has a history of expansion since 1908 when its 8 club competition, formed as an 1897 breakaway from the rival Victorian Football Association, grew to 10 teams. Many clubs have been proposed since this time, particularly since the 1980s when the league began to expand nationally. Only 3 teams have left the competition in its history.
The Aspley Football Club, nicknamed the Hornets, is an Australian rules football club based in the northern-Brisbane suburb of Aspley. The club competes in multiple Queensland-based competitions, including in the Queensland Australian Football League, Division 1 of the Queensland Football Association, the Queensland AFL Women's League, and several underage competitions for boys and girls. The senior men's team has in the past competed in second-tier state league competitions, notably the North East Australian Football League from 2011 to 2020 and the Victorian Football League in 2021.
The AFL Australian Football League is the top professional Australian rules football league in the world. The league consists of eighteen teams: nine based in the city of Melbourne, one from regional Victoria, and eight based in other Australian states. The reason for this unbalanced geographic distribution lies in the history of the league, which was based solely within Victoria from the time it was established in 1897, until the time the league expanded through the addition of clubs from interstate to the existing teams starting in the 1980s; until this expansion, the league was known as the VFL (Victorian Football League).
The Australian Football League stages the highest-level senior Australian rules football competition in the country.
The 2000 VFL season was the 119th season of the Victorian Football League (VFL), a second-tier Australian rules football competition played in the state of Victoria. The premiership was won by the Sandringham Football Club, after defeating North Ballarat by 31 points in the Grand Final on 27 August.
VFL Women's (VFLW) is the major state-level women's Australian rules football league in Victoria. The league initially comprised the six premier division clubs and the top four division 1 clubs from the now-defunct Victorian Women's Football League (VWFL), and has since evolved into what is also the second primary competition for AFL Women's (AFLW) clubs in Victoria.
The 2020 AFL season was the 124th season of the Australian Football League (AFL), the highest level senior men's Australian rules football competition in Australia, which was known as the Victorian Football League until 1989. The season featured eighteen clubs.
The AFL Grand Final, which is the final premiership deciding match each season in the Australian Football League (AFL), has been played at the Melbourne Cricket Ground in Melbourne, Victoria, every year since 1902, except on seven occasions when the ground was unavailable or because of the COVID-19 pandemic in the case of the 2020 AFL Grand Final; and it is presently contracted to be played there until 2059. Despite the long-term stability in its location, and its natural fit as the largest capacity stadium in both Melbourne and Australia, the ongoing use of the Melbourne Cricket Ground has been controversial throughout its history.
The 2021 Victorian Football League season was the 139th season of the Victorian Football Association/Victorian Football League Australian rules football competition. The season commenced on 16 April was curtailed without a premiership awarded on 1 September 2021, due to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic.