Critical reception
The song received generally mixed reviews from music critics. Jason Lipshutz of Billboard ranked it as the sixth best song from Man's Best Friend, praising Carpenter for "sell[ing] the one-liners and inject[ing] personality the corners of the track" as well as the song's suitable placement on the album. [3] Adam White of The Independent described the song as "a painfully literal celebration of the masculine glow-up", and remarked that it "rides a squelchy bassline hook reminiscent of Ginuwine's 'Pony', but feels too much like Thank U, Next -era Ariana Grande cosplay to properly hit." [5] Brittany Spanos of Rolling Stone stated that the line "You were an ugly kid, but you're a sexy man" "can only work with her winking delivery." [4] Mikael Wood of Los Angeles Times commented the song "feels like something Ariana Grande abandoned after workshopping for a minute." [6] Reviewing the album for The New York Times , Jon Caramanica wrote "Carpenter is best when playful, but not winking. Accordingly, the most effective songs here are the most literal." He cited the song as an instance, stating it "literally descends into lip-biting panting." [7] Mary Chiney of Beats Per Minute wrote "'When Did You Get Hot' anchors the middle stretch with lyrics that could only have been written in 2025: self-aware, plugged into the language of online culture, yet grounded in the timeless confusion of attraction. It's also where you start to see why so many of her song titles read like text messages; they're snapshots of conversations, fragments of thought, punchlines before the joke lands." [10] Nick Levine of NME commented the song was an example in which "she's so gleefully horny that she comes off like a Gen Z version of Blanche from The Golden Girls ." [11]
This page is based on this
Wikipedia article Text is available under the
CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.