Dalma culture

Last updated
Dalma Ceramic Vessel excavated in Iran in 1961 by Robert H. Dyson Jr. Metropolitan Museum Dalma ceramic vessel.jpg
Dalma Ceramic Vessel excavated in Iran in 1961 by Robert H. Dyson Jr. Metropolitan Museum

Dalma culture was a prehistoric archaeological culture of north-western Iran dating to early fifth millennium B.C. Later, it spread into the central Zagros region and elsewhere in adjacent areas. Its widespread ceramic remains were excavated in central and northern valleys of the Zagros Mountains in north-western Iran. [1] Dalma assemblages were initially discovered by the excavations carried out at Dalma Tepe and Hasanlu Tepe in south-western parts of Lake Urmia, in the valley of Solduz. [2] [3]

Contents

Further excavations in Dalma Tepe as part of the Hasanlu Project of the University of Pennsylvania in 1961 uncovered more Dalma assemblages. [2] [4] The excavated materials included architectural, burial, and ceramic remains, clay, bones, artifacts, ground stones, and chipped stones. [5] They indicated that Dalma culture dated back to the fifth millennium B.C. [2] As stated by Akbar Abedi, an Iranian archaeologist, Dalma is one of the famous type sites located in north-western Iran. [6]

Excavated ceramics are the most prominent aspect of this culture that has been uncovered so far, and there is less information available about other aspects. [7] [8] The excavated materials do not provide sufficient details about Dalma people and their lifestyles. [7]

Dalma material tradition was spread across a wide area in the region with analogues technical and stylistic characteristics. [1] Excavated evidence indicates that this culture dispersed across central Zagros Mountains, northern Luristan, Urmia basin in Azerbaijan, and some parts of Mesopotamia such as Kirkuk. [9] [10] Traces of Dalma culture have been discovered in north-western parts of the Iranian Plateau. [9] The widespread dispersal of Dalma tradition in this region argues that nomadic people were involved in the spread of this culture. [11]

Community

With the exception of pottery, other aspects of the culture, such as its origins, chronology, social, and economic structure, are poorly understood. [3] Dalma Tepe is one of the first sedentary settlements in Ushun-Solduz Valley in north-western Iran. [5]

Two types of settlements

As suggested by the three scholars, Akbar Abedi, Behrooz Omrani, and Azam Karimifar, the distribution of Dalma sites indicated two types of settlement pattern by Dalma people: firstly, permanent settlements in the valleys of the Zagros Mountain and secondly, temporary settlement sites in the highlands of north-western Iran including Zagros and Caucasian Mountains. [3] The most likely settlement pattern of Dalma people was a small group of nomads moving between villages with which they maintained their connection through kinship. [3] Dalma ceramics were distributed across a 40,000 km2 (15,000 sq mi) area. [1]

The extensive spread of potteries in large quantities, the number of Dalma sites in the Zagros region, and the distance and travel time between these sites, suggest that Dalma vessels could not have been produced and distributed from local production sites such as local markets. [1] These vessels must have been produced by regional ethnic groups at the household level and dispersed by the movement of nomadic tribes and their interactions with Dalma villages. [7] [12]

Sedentary communities

The burials in the excavated areas propose that Dalma people were part of a sedentary and farming community with common cultural characteristics. [7] The homogeneous stylistic and morphological patterns among Dalma ceramics across a large geographical area may indicate a strong ethnical and socio-political identity among Dalma communities. [12] Settlement patterns do not show signs of social hierarchy and political, economic, or religious structures existent within the Dalma society. [1] [11] The Dalma people's societal practices may have a modern analog in Kurdish tribal displays, such as clothing or carpet patterns, which are intended to publicly display tribal affiliation. [1]

Locations

Dalma Tepe

Dalma tepe is an archaeological site about 2km northeast of the town of Naqadeh (formerly Solduz), in Naqadeh County, Iran, at the southwestern end of Lake Urmia. Nearby, there are two other small tells. An important contemporary site of Ḥasanlū Tepe is also in the area.

Dalma remains were initially excavated at Dalma Tepe, in the Solduz Valley of north-western Zagros. Later, more contemporary sites were found in the Mahidasht and Kangavar valleys in the central Zagros region in Iran. [7] Initial excavations in Dalma Tepe as part of the Hasanlu project yielded limited results due to insufficient excavation durations and a lack of available staff for the project. [5] In 2021, Archaeological survey again began at Dalma Tepe after a six-decade hiatus. [13]

Dalma culture originally began its existence around the Lake Urmia in north-western Iran and was then expanded into the central Zagros region. [1] [14] Several sites related to this culture, such as Dalma Tepe, are located around Lake Urmia. [1]

Geographical distribution

Traces of Dalma ceramics have been found in the Caucasus Mountains, and parts of eastern Iraq such as Kirkuk and Jabal Hamarein. [1] [7] [9]

According to the location of the excavated ceramics, Dalma culture's southern boundaries reached the eastern Kurdish valleys, central Zagros and, valleys of Kangavar and Nehavand in north-eastern Luristan. [1] Dalma pottery tradition was diffused eastwards as far as Zanjan and Ardebil provinces. [11] Traces of Dalma remains have not been excavated in the Iranian Plateau further in the east, or southern parts of Luristan and Khuzistan. [1] The Chaine Magistrale (Persian: کوه سفید, Kuh-i Sefid) acted as a barrier and stopped the expansion of Dalma tradition towards the west. [1] Traces of Dalma Impressed ware in the west have been found as far as the Diyala province. [12] All of the routes for Dalma culture's development from the northwest were originated in the Lake Urmia region and intersected the Silk Road. [14] The location of Dalma sites facilitated trade, access to main routes, exploitation of resources, and interaction of people between lowland and highland areas, which were all critical elements in the distribution of Dalma potteries. [3]

According to Yukiko Tonoike, as of 2012, no further excavations had happened in the previously mentioned Dalma sites in Iran since 1979. [7] A series of excavations done by Mahmoud Heydarian in Songhor and Koliyaei Plains of central Zagros from 2004 to 2009 uncovered Dalma potsherds in 9 archaeological sites, namely Khodaei, Sheikh-Jalil, Ab-Naz, Tepe Varz, Kalaavil, QolQole, and Nad Ali Beig. [9] All of these sites are located in ecologically optimal locations for human settlement and close to riverbanks, springs, or canals. [9] Since some of the sites are situated at higher altitudes and have colder weather conditions during winter and fall, they were probably occupied by semi-nomadic communities practicing animal husbandry. [9]

Excavated Materials

Burials

Initial excavations at Dalma Tepe revealed fourteen Dalma burials, which consisted of single infants placed tightly in ceramic vessels with no evidence of adult or juvenile burials. [5] It appears that adults were buried outside of the settlements, and infants were interred under the architectural structures within the settlements. [5] Sixteen burials which related to the periods after the Dalma tradition were discovered during these initial excavations. [5]

Architecture

Dalma assemblage indicates evidence of walls made from "chineh (layers of packed mud)" which were sometimes separated by thin clay layers. [5] Walls did not show any evidence of paintings on them, and their heights ranged from 15 to 60 centimetres. [5] Evidence found in Dalma Tepe indicates the existence of structures with enclosed and open areas. [5]

Artifacts

Artifacts initially discovered in Dalma Tepe consisted of ground stones, chipped stones, clay wares, bones, and ceramics. [5] The latter formed the larger proportion of the discovered assemblage. [5]

Ceramics

Dalma ceramic sherds excavated in 1961 in Dalma Tepe, Iran, as part of the University of Pennsylvania's Hasanlu project Dalma ceramic sherds.jpg
Dalma ceramic sherds excavated in 1961 in Dalma Tepe, Iran, as part of the University of Pennsylvania's Hasanlu project

Dalma ceramics were introduced in the region in the sixth millennium B.C. (Late Neolithic period), spread throughout north-western Iran during the fifth millennium B.C. (Chalcolithic period), and remained in use until the fourth millennium B.C. [1] [7] [9] Jars, beakers, and bowls are among the excavated Dalma vessels. [6]

Common Characteristics

Constant interactions among different Dalma communities ensured some levels of commonality among the vessels’ characteristics. [7] Ceramics excavated from Dalma sites were created by hand, and they were mostly made of chaff-tempered clay with small amounts of grit included. [7] Since the ceramics were not appropriately baked, Dalma vessels have a dark and grey core with a pink to orange colour on the surface. [7] [9] Based on their surface characteristics, Dalma vessels can be categorised into the following groups: [7]

  1. Dalma Painted: Dalma painted wares have very different decoration patterns on the surface with bold geometric and triangular patterns. [4] [7] They are painted in red with purple and brown shades on light and yellow background. [7] Parts of the excavated vessels in this category have double-coloured paintings on them, and the majority are monochrome. [1]
  2. Dalma Impressed:  Initial excavations at Dalma Tepe indicated signs of change in Dalma ceramics as it appears that the earlier version of Dalma painted vessels were developed into distinctive impressed wares. [5] These vessels have marks of fingertips and textiles stamped on them, and they are painted in red. [4] [7] In 1975, Carol Hamlin proposed that Dalma Impressed wares must have been made with some kind of cooking method as some of them have a dark surface. [7]
  3. Dalma Red Slipped: A large number of the excavated potteries fall into this category. [7] Dalma Red Slipped ceramics have a thick red, cream, purple, or brown slip, which covers both outside and inside of the vessels in most cases. [1] [7] Some of the ceramics in this category have a double coating of a white layer and a second red layer. [7]
  4. Dalma Plain Ware: Dalma plain wares do not include any decorations on the surface.

Local Characteristics

Kangavar Valley: Excavated sites in the Kangavar Valley include Seh Gabi and Godin Tepe. [1] Ceramics found in this site can be categorised into two groups called hard-ware and soft-ware, respectively. [1] Soft-wares consist of vessels that are low-fired and have different decorations on their surface, and high-ware ceramics are uncoated, quite thin, and high-fired. [1] Most of the Dalma potteries excavated in this valley fall into the soft-ware category. [1] Hard-wares’ decorations do not indicate Dalma stylistic elements; rather, they partly remind one of the Mesopotamia's Ubaid period decorative characteristics. [1] The analysis done by Roghayeh Rahimi and Moein Eslami on the structure of the excavated potteries in the eastern Zagros region at Soha Chey Tepe, Iran, indicated that these non-Dalma ceramics have very different stylistics and technical structures compared to those of Dalma ceramics. [10] According to these two experts, this stylistic and technical difference supports the hypothesis that these ceramics were imported into Dalma villages and were not produced locally. [10]

Mahidasht Valley: Evidence of Dalma ceramics were found in 16 sites across this valley, namely Tepe Siahbid and Chogha Maran, and Tepe Koh. [1] The same categorisation into hard-ware and soft-ware applies to the vessels excavated in this site. [1] Soft-ware ceramics in this valley mostly consist of Dalma Red-Slipped and Plain wares. [1] Dalma Impressed wares are excavated in lesser quantities in this valley compared to Kangavar Valley, and high-fired vessels with Ubaid reminiscent characteristics are more commonly found in Mahidasht Valley. [1] [10]

Lake Urmia Region: Dalma wares in this region include Plain, Impressed, and Painted wares. [1]

Chronology

Similar to other cultural traditions in the Near East, Dalma tradition exists from a cultural and chronological point of view. [10] After its initial flourish in north-western Iran in the first half of the fifth millennium B.C, Dalma tradition spread southwards into the central Zagros region during the second half of the fifth millennium B.C. [3]

As of 2015, lack of absolute dating in north-western Iran and the limited number of excavations carried out in Dalma sites had made it impossible to define an accurate chronological table for the Dalma tradition and timeline of the region in the Chalcolithic period. [3] Chronologically, the Dalma period is a continuation of the region's Late Neolithic Hajji Firuz period, proceeded immediately by the Middle Chalcolithic Pisdeli period of north-western Iran, and contemporary to the Ubaid III period in Mesopotamia and the Sialk III tradition in Central Iranian Plateau. [7] [10]

As stated by Akbar Abedi, Behrooz Omrani, and Azam Karimifar, Dalma was the final result of the Hajji Firuz tradition development. [3] With the exception of changes in pottery production, no other aspects of the material culture indicate signs of a discontinuity between Dalma and the preceding Hajji Firuz tradition. [3]

According to James Mellaart, the British archaeologist, the advancement of pottery techniques in the Dalma period compared to the Hajji Firuz period is noticeable. [8] [15] He stated that Dalma wares might have been developed from the vessels created in the Hajji Firuz period as they contain painting elements common to this period as well as some new stylistic innovations. [8]

Radiocarbon dating results have indicated that there must have been a transitional period of 400 years between Hajji Firuz and Dalma traditions in this region at the end of the 6th millennium B.C. [3] [12]

According to Steve Renette (2022), Dalma tradition started during the final centuries of the 6th millennium BCE, and it may have continued until the middle of the 5th millennium. [16]

But according to Johnny Samuele Baldi (2022), the associated Dalma traditions, which he analyses, are all much later than Neolithic and Early Chalcolithic. Instead, they were closer to the Middle Chalcolithic in date, and continued during the Late Chalcolithic (LC1). Which would amount to the range between 4700 and 4250 BCE. [17]

Chaff-Faced Ware

Chalcolithic chaff-faced ware appeared in the South Caucasus and Upper Mesopotamia in the first half of the 5th millennium BCE. According to Catherine Marro (2022), the systematic use of chaff, creating a Chaff-Faced Ware effect, is attested from the beginning of the 5th millennium BCE with the development of the Dalma culture. [18]

This Chaff-Faced Ware oikumenè is also indicated by the "common trends in house building and funerary traditions". The trends in obsidian use are also relevant here.

"The earliest Caucasian chaff-faced repertoires have so far been evidenced in the Middle Araxes valley, as illustrated by the ceramic assemblages from Nakhchivan Tepe and Uçan Ağıl. Nakhchivan Tepe may be considered as a Dalma site ... " [19]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ubaid period</span> Prehistoric period of Mesopotamia

The Ubaid period is a prehistoric period of Mesopotamia. The name derives from Tell al-'Ubaid where the earliest large excavation of Ubaid period material was conducted initially in 1919 by Henry Hall and later by Leonard Woolley.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kura–Araxes culture</span> Archaeological culture from the Caucasus region

The Kura–Araxes culture was an archaeological culture that existed from about 4000 BC until about 2000 BC, which has traditionally been regarded as the date of its end; in some locations it may have disappeared as early as 2600 or 2700 BC. The earliest evidence for this culture is found on the Ararat plain; it spread north in the Caucasus by 3000 BC.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Teppe Hasanlu</span>

Teppe Hasanlu or Hasanlu Tepe is an archeological site of an ancient city located in northwest Iran, a short distance south of Lake Urmia. The nature of its destruction at the end of the 9th century BC essentially froze one layer of the city in time, providing researchers with extremely well preserved buildings, artifacts, and skeletal remains from the victims and enemy combatants of the attack. The site was likely associated with the Mannaeans.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Godin Tepe</span> Place

Godin Tepe is an archaeological site in western Iran, located in the valley of Kangavar in Kermanshah province. The importance of the site may have been due to its role as a trading outpost in the early Mesopotamian trade networks.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Teppe Zagheh</span>

Teppe Zagheh is an early urban settlement located near Qazvin, Iran. In Persian, Tappeh means "tell, mound". It was first excavated by a team from the University of Tehran under the direction of Ezzat Negahban in the early 1970s

Tapeh Yahya is an archaeological site in Kermān Province, Iran, some 220 kilometres (140 mi) south of Kerman city, 90 kilometres (56 mi) south of Baft city and 90 km south-west of Jiroft. The easternmost occupation of the Proto-Elamite culture was found there.

Aratashen is a town in the Armavir Province of Armenia. It is located on the Ararat Plain.

Hajji Firuz Tepe is an archaeological site located in West Azarbaijan Province in north-western Iran and lies in the north-western part of the Zagros Mountains. The site was excavated between 1958 and 1968 by archaeologists from the University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology. The excavations revealed a Neolithic village that was occupied in the second half of the sixth millennium BC where some of the oldest archaeological evidence of grape-based wine was discovered in the form of organic residue in a pottery jar.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kültəpə</span> Village and municipality in Nakhchivan, Azerbaijan

Kültəpə is a settlement dating from the Neolithic, a village and municipality in the Babek District of Nakhchivan, Azerbaijan. It has a population of 1,859.

Ərəbyengicə is a village and municipality in the Sharur District of Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic, Azerbaijan. It is located 12 km in the south from the district center, on the left bank of the Arpachay River. Its population is busy with farming and animal husbandry. There are secondary school, club and a medical center in the village. It has a population of 894.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Leyla-Tepe culture</span>

The Leyla-Tepe culture of the South Caucasus belongs to the Chalcolithic era. It got its name from the site in the Agdam District of modern-day Azerbaijan. Its settlements were distributed on the southern slopes of Central Caucasus, from 4350 until 4000 B.C.

The Halaf-Ubaid Transitional period or HUT is a prehistoric period of Mesopotamia. It lies chronologically between the Halaf period and the Ubaid period. It is still a complex and rather poorly understood period. At the same time, recent efforts were made to study the gradual change from Halaf style pottery to Ubaid style pottery in various parts of North Mesopotamia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alikomektepe</span> Archaeological site in Jalilabad District, Azerbaijan

Alikomektepe is an ancient settlement located in Jalilabad District (Azerbaijan), in the Mughan plain, belonging to the Chalcolithic period, dating to c. 5000 BC. Early levels belonged to the Shulaveri–Shomu culture. It covers an area of over 1 hectare.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Yarim Tepe</span>

Yarim Tepe is an archaeological site of an early farming settlement that goes back to about 6000 BC. It is located in the Sinjar valley some 7km southwest from the town of Tal Afar in northern Iraq. The site consists of several hills reflecting the development of the Hassuna culture, and then of the Halaf and Ubaid cultures.

Kul Tepe Jolfa is an ancient archaeological site in the Jolfa County of Iran, located in the city of Hadishahr, about 10 km south from the Araxes River.

Bülövaqaya settlement is an archeological site located on the left bank of the Sarisu river, west of Göynük village of Babek district.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ovçular Tepesi</span>

Ovçular Tepesi is an ancient settlement located at the northern end of Dizə, Sharur village in Sharur District of Azerbaijan, on the left bank of Arpa (river). It dates back to the fifth millennium BC, and continued to the third millenniums BC.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dalma Tepe</span>

Dalma Tepe is an archaeological site about 2km northeast of Naqadeh, Naqadeh County, in the Iranian province of West Azerbaijan. It is the type site of Dalma culture, a prehistoric culture of north-western Iran from the fifth millennium B.C.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Godedzor</span> Archaeological site in Armenia

Godedzor is a prehistorical archaeological site located about 1,5 kilometres west of the village of Angeghakot in the Syunik Province of Armenia. The settlement of Nerkin Godedzor is in the Vorotan river gorge, at the altitude of 1800 meters. Some petroglyphs are also found close by.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nakhchivan Tepe</span> Chalcolithic settlement in Nakhchivan, Azerbaijan

Nakhchivan Tepe (Naxçıvantəpə) is a Chalcolithic settlement in Nakhchivan, Azerbaijan. It is located in Nakhchivan (city) and is dated to the first half of the 5th millennium BC. It is on the right bank of the Nakhchivançay river at the altitude of 850m.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 HENRICKSON, Elizabeth F.; VITALI, Vanda (1987). "The Dalma Tradition : Prehistoric Inter-Regional Cultural Integration in Highland Western Iran". Paléorient . 13 (2): 37–45. doi:10.3406/paleo.1987.4427. ISSN   0153-9345. JSTOR   41492253.
  2. 1 2 3 Young, T. Cuyler (1963). "DALMA PAINTED WARE". Penn Museum . Retrieved 2020-05-28.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Abedi, Akbar; Omrani, Behrooz; Karimifar, Azam (December 2015). "Fifth and fourth millennium BC in north-western Iran: Dalma and Pisdeli revisited". Documenta Praehistorica. 42. doi: 10.4312/dp.42.23 . ISSN   1854-2492 via ResearchGate.
  4. 1 2 3 Dyson, Robert H. (1993). "DALMĀ TEPE". Encyclopaedia Iranica . Retrieved 2020-05-28.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Hamlin, Carol (1975). "Dalma Tepe". Iran. 13: 111–127. doi:10.2307/4300529. ISSN   0578-6967. JSTOR   4300529.
  6. 1 2 Abedi, Akbar (2017). "Iranian Azerbaijan Pathway From The Zagros To The Caucasus, Anatolia And Northern Mesopotamia: Dava Göz, A New Neolithic And Chalcolithic Site In Nw Iran". Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry. 17: 69–87. doi:10.5281/ZENODO.258086.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Tonoike, Yukiko (2014). "Petrographic Analysis of the 6th Millennium B.C. Dalma Ceramics from Northwestern and Central Zagros". Iranian Journal of Archaeological Studies. 2 (2): 65–82. doi:10.22111/ijas.2014.1526.
  8. 1 2 3 Mellaart, James (1967). The Earliest Settlements in Western Asia: From the Ninth to the End of the Fifth Millennium B.C. Cambridge University Press.
  9. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Zeynivand, Mohsen; Hariryan, Hamid; Heydarian, Mahmoud (2013). "The Dalma Settlements of Songhor and Koliyaei Plains, Central Zagros". Iranian Journal of Archaeological Studies. 3 (1): 39–47. doi:10.22111/ijas.2013.1734.
  10. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Rahimi Sorkhani, Roghayeh; Eslami, Moein (2018-02-01). "Specialized pottery production in Dalma tradition; a statistical approach in pottery analysis from Soha Chay Tepe, Zanjan, Iran". Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports. 17: 220–234. Bibcode:2018JArSR..17..220R. doi:10.1016/j.jasrep.2017.11.007. ISSN   2352-409X via Elsevier Science Direct.
  11. 1 2 3 Binandeh, Ali; Glascock, Michael D.; Oga, April (2020-08-01). "Origin of obsidian tools from Ubaid and Rick Abad in Little Zab basin, Northwestern Iran". Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports. 32: 102395. Bibcode:2020JArSR..32j2395B. doi: 10.1016/j.jasrep.2020.102395 . ISSN   2352-409X. S2CID   219472213.
  12. 1 2 3 4 Barge, Olivier; Azizi Kharanaghi, Hossein; Biglari, Feiredoun; Moradi, Babak; Mashkour, Marjan; Tengberg, Margareta; Chataigner, Christine (February 2018). "Diffusion of Anatolian and Caucasian obsidian in the Zagros Mountains and the highlands of Iran: Elements of explanation in 'least cost path' models". Quaternary International. 467: 297–322. Bibcode:2018QuInt.467..297B. doi:10.1016/j.quaint.2018.01.032.
  13. Archaeological survey begins on Dalma Tepe after six-decade hiatus. Tehran Times, September 29, 2021.
  14. 1 2 Abedi, Akbar; Eskandari, Nasir; Shahidi, Hamid Khatib; Sharahi, Ismail; Shirzadeh, Gholam (2014). "New Evidence from Dalma and Kura-Araxes Culture at Tapeh Qal'e-ye-Sarsakhti". Iran & the Caucasus. 18 (2): 101–114. doi:10.1163/1573384X-20140202. ISSN   1609-8498. JSTOR   43899067.
  15. "James Mellaart". The Telegraph. 2012-08-03. ISSN   0307-1235 . Retrieved 2020-05-28.
  16. Renette, Steve (2022-07-29). "Defining Dalma: an Incipient Mountain Identity?". Paléorient (48–1): 111–130. doi:10.4000/paleorient.1699. ISSN   0153-9345.
  17. Baldi, Johnny Samuele (2022-07-29). "Between an End and a New Beginning: Tracking the post-Ubaid ceramic transition as an indicator of social change". Paléorient. Delineating the End of a World: Reassessing the Ubaid/Post-Ubaid Transition in Greater Mesopotamia (48–1): 41–72. doi:10.4000/paleorient.1539. ISSN   0153-9345.
  18. Catherine Marro 2022, The View from the North: The Emergence and Spread of the Chaff-Faced Ware oikumenè as seen from the Caucasus (ca. 4600-3500 BCE). doi 10.4000/paleorient.1675
  19. Catherine Marro 2022, The View from the North: The Emergence and Spread of the Chaff-Faced Ware oikumenè as seen from the Caucasus (ca. 4600-3500 BCE). doi 10.4000/paleorient.1675