Hillsborough Wikipedia posts

Last updated

On 24 April 2014, Oliver Duggan, in the Liverpool Echo , reported that users of computers that used IP addresses registered to the Government Secure Intranet (which is used by many of the United Kingdom's government departments) had added derogatory and offensive material to Wikipedia articles, particularly the article about the Hillsborough disaster. [1] The vandalism was quickly re-reported by other media, and subsequent reports have highlighted other acts of vandalism, on various articles, originated by computers using those IP addresses. After an investigation by The Daily Telegraph and Wikipediocracy the person behind the edits was identified as a "junior civil servant" within the UK government and was dismissed.

Contents

Hillsborough disaster

The issue first emerged when it was reported that the entry about the Hillsborough disaster, in which 96 people died at a football match at the Hillsborough Stadium in 1989, had been altered, briefly, in 2009, [2] with a similar alteration to the Anfield article in 2012. [3] The report suggested that the edits could have been made from the Department for Culture, Media and Sport, Her Majesty's Treasury or the Office of the Solicitor General [1] since those departments use the Government Secure Intranet. However, the Cabinet Office has stated that "At this time, we have no reason to suspect that the Hillsborough edits involve any particular department, nor more than one or two individuals in 2009 and 2012." [4]

The details of the two IP addresses (62.25.106.209  (talk · contribs · count) and 195.92.40.49  (talk · contribs · count) [5] [6] ) used by computers on the Government Secure Intranet came from then-Treasury minister Angela Eagle in a reply to a parliamentary question in 2008. [1] [5] The edits, which were made in 2009 (on the disaster's 20th anniversary) and 2012, included the addition of "Blame Liverpool Fans" to the Hillsborough disaster page and adding the phrases "You'll Never Walk Again" and "yet nothing for the victims of the Heysel Stadium disaster" to mentions of the Hillsborough memorial in the Anfield article. [7]

The Cabinet Office responded to the news by saying that they were making "urgent inquiries" into these reports, and that the claims made in them were being treated with "the utmost seriousness". [8] The office also warned, however, that it might not be possible to determine exactly who used the government's computers to make the edits, saying, "As the first incident happened five years ago and there are hundreds of thousands of people on the government's network, it may prove challenging to identify who was involved, but we are exhausting every option." [4] [9] The inquiry was scheduled to be overseen, but not led, by Andy Burnham. [10] On 20 May, Burnham said the investigation had identified "strong leads" into determining who made the edits. [11]

In 2016, after the second verdict of the Hillsborough inquiry proved unlawful killing of the 96 dead due to gross negligence, the Liverpool Echo reported that edits from an IP associated with Warwickshire County Council (WCC) added the phrase "You'll never walk again" eight times in the lead of the Hillsborough disaster page. [12] A WCC spokesperson told the newspaper: "WCC IP addresses also include our publicly used machines in libraries that can be used by members of the public. The information has been passed onto the head of our IT team and we are going to be investigating." [13]

On 26 April, the Belfast Telegraph reported that one of the edits made via a government IP address (to the Wikipedia entry for Howick Falls) had mentioned "killing or enslaving" black people and suggested that they believe "hearsay and myth". [14]

The Daily Telegraph reported on 27 April that government computers had been used to maliciously alter articles about prominent people, including falsifying the death of television sports presenter Des Lynam. Other public figures targeted include Michael Grade and Chris Evans. [15] On the same day, The Herald in Glasgow reported that the articles for Clydebank and Barlanark, had been vandalized by government computers. [16] Also that day, the National Post reported that a government computer had also targeted the page about Canadian author David Gilmour, which was vandalized to describe him as a "misogynist, homophobe [and] racist". [17]

On 29 April, the BBC reported the results of its investigation into the edits carried out by computers using the two IP addresses. It found more than one hundred edits that it categorised as "inappropriate editing, vandalism and deletion". The BBC gave no time scale for these edits but did reveal that edits were made in 2005 and 2006 and that "several of the offensive messages were made prior to the government IP addresses being disclosed in 2008".

The most serious edit was a change to the veil article, in October 2006, which included the phrase "all Muslims are terrorists". [18] This change was removed six minutes later. Also highlighted was the removal of details, in October 2005, of the controversy regarding flat purchases by Cherie Blair. Other edits mentioned by the BBC were the editing of the 7 July 2005 London bombings article to add conspiracy theories; and the vandalism, usually with insults and sometimes with page blanking, of the Tony Blair, Richard Littlejohn, Jamie Oliver, Libertines, Wayne Rooney, Christopher Byrne, Peter Levy and Arsène Wenger articles.

Regarding the edits, while stating that the vandalism was appalling, a spokesman for Wikimedia UK pointed out that, "Edits of this nature are removed very quickly by the volunteers who write and edit Wikipedia, often in a matter of minutes." He also expanded on the nature of the editing process, saying "Wikipedia is the encyclopaedia that anyone can edit. This openness has led to an enormous reference work of great value. While vandalism does occasionally happen we are grateful to the many thousands of volunteers who write, edit and organise the content." [6]

Reactions

Jon Davies, chief executive of Wikimedia UK, said it was "appalled by such vandalism" but added that, "In this case, none of the offensive comments were up for more than a couple of hours, and most were removed in a few minutes." [8]

The Cabinet Office described the edits in question as "sickening". "The behaviour is in complete contravention of the Civil Service Code. It is entirely unacceptable," they added. [6]

Sheila Coleman of the Hillsborough Justice Campaign called the edits "absolutely disgusting" and said the relatives of the Hillsborough disaster victims would demand a formal inquiry. [1]

A critic of Wikipedia, Nigel Scott, writing in Spiked , sought to place the incident in the context of what he sees as Wikipedia's structural flaws, saying, "Wikipedia is not blameless in this. It allows misinformation to flourish and provides it with a cloak of respectability. It is under-resourced and is unable to police itself adequately." However, the main focus of his argument was other Wikipedia controversies, including the creation of the Bicholim conflict article, accusations of editing on behalf of Chuka Umunna and the Wiki-PR editing of Wikipedia. [19]

Result of the investigation

From May to June 2014, Wikipediocracy, a website critical of Wikipedia, as well as The Daily Telegraph identified the culprit behind the offending edits to Wikipedia. Using the results of the investigation published in the Telegraph, the UK government identified and took action against the suspect. [20] In June 2014, an unnamed 24-year-old civil servant, who was born in London but lived in Liverpool, was sacked for posting offensive comments about the disaster on Wikipedia. [21] After the sacking, the United Kingdom government issued new rules for its civil servants with regard to editing Wikipedia. The guidelines include the statement that anyone making inappropriate edits will be disciplined. [22]

Related Research Articles

Liverpool F.C. Association football club in England

Liverpool Football Club is a professional football club in Liverpool, England, that competes in the Premier League, the top tier of English football. Domestically, the club has won nineteen League titles, seven FA Cups, a record eight League Cups and fifteen FA Community Shields. In international competitions, the club has won six European Cups, more than any other English club, three UEFA Cups, four UEFA Super Cups and one FIFA Club World Cup.

Hillsborough disaster Human crush during the 1989 FA Cup semi-final

The Hillsborough disaster was a fatal human crush during a football match at Hillsborough Stadium in Sheffield, South Yorkshire, England, on 15 April 1989. It occurred during an FA Cup semi-final between Liverpool and Nottingham Forest in the two standing-only central pens in the Leppings Lane stand allocated to Liverpool supporters. Shortly before kick-off, in an attempt to ease overcrowding outside the entrance turnstiles, the police match commander David Duckenfield ordered exit gate C opened, leading to an influx of even more supporters to the pens. This led to a crowding in the pens and the crush.

Open-source journalism, a close cousin to citizen journalism or participatory journalism, is a term coined in the title of a 1999 article by Andrew Leonard of Salon.com. Although the term was not actually used in the body text of Leonard's article, the headline encapsulated a collaboration between users of the internet technology blog Slashdot and a writer for Jane's Intelligence Review. The writer, Johan J. Ingles-le Nobel, had solicited feedback on a story about cyberterrorism from Slashdot readers, and then re-wrote his story based on that feedback and compensated the Slashdot writers whose information and words he used.

<i>Liverpool Echo</i> English daily tabloid newspaper

The Liverpool Echo is a newspaper published by Trinity Mirror North West & North Wales – a subsidiary company of Reach plc and is based in St Paul's Square, Liverpool, Merseyside, England. It is published Monday to Sunday, and is Liverpool's daily newspaper. Until 13 January 2012 it had a sister morning paper, the Liverpool Daily Post. It has an average daily circulation of 26,600.

Sir Bernard Ingham is a British journalist and former civil servant. He was Margaret Thatcher's chief press secretary throughout her time as Prime Minister of the United Kingdom from 1979 to 1990. He was knighted in Thatcher's 1990 resignation honours list.

Some edits to the online encyclopedia Wikipedia by staff of the United States Congress have created controversy, notably in early to mid-2006. Several such instances, such as those involving Marty Meehan, Norm Coleman, Conrad Burns, and Joe Biden, received significant media attention. Others, such as those involving Gil Gutknecht, were reported but received less widespread coverage.

Wikipedia Open-source online encyclopedia

Wikipedia is a free, multilingual open-collaborative online encyclopedia created and maintained by a community of volunteer editors using a wiki-based editing system. It is one of the 15 most popular websites as ranked by Alexa, as of January 2021 and The Economist newspaper placed it as the "13th-most-visited place on the web". Featuring no advertisements, it is hosted by the Wikimedia Foundation, an American non-profit organization funded primarily through donations.

WikiScanner Defunct database linking Wikipedia edits to institutions

WikiScanner was a publicly searchable database operating between 2002 and 2007 that linked millions of anonymous edits on Wikipedia to the organizations where those edits apparently originated, by cross-referencing the edits with data on the owners of the associated block of IP addresses though it did not investigate edits made under a username. It was created by Virgil Griffith and released on August 14, 2007.

Sir Norman George Bettison, QPM is a British former police officer and the former Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police. He resigned in October 2012 amidst controversy about his role in the Hillsborough disaster, in which he was involved in the implementation of a cover-up of police errors. He remained the subject of an Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) investigation, and was charged on the 28 June 2017 with four counts of misconduct in public office. The case was dropped on 21 August 2018. Bettison's own book Hillsborough Untold (2016) contains his version of events.

Internet Watch Foundation and Wikipedia Blacklist of Wikipedia in the UK

On 5 December 2008, the Internet Watch Foundation (IWF), a British watchdog group, blacklisted content on the English Wikipedia related to Scorpions' 1976 studio album Virgin Killer, due to the presence of its controversial cover artwork, depicting a young girl posing nude, with a faux shattered-glass effect obscuring her genitalia. The image was deemed to be "potentially illegal content" under English law which forbids the possession or creation of indecent photographs of children. The IWF's blacklist are used in web filtering systems such as Cleanfeed.

A series of incidents in 2009 led to Church of Scientology-owned networks being blocked from making edits to Wikipedia articles relating to Scientology. The Church of Scientology has long had a controversial history on the Internet and had initiated campaigns to manipulate material and remove information critical of itself from the web. From early in Wikipedia's history, conflict arose within the topic of Scientology on the website. Disputes began in earnest in 2005, with users disagreeing about whether or not to describe Scientology as an abusive cult or religion. By 2006, disagreements concerning the topic of Scientology on Wikipedia had grown more specific. Wikipedia user and Scientology critic David Gerard commented to The Daily Telegraph in 2006 that some articles were neutral due to a requirement to reference stated facts.

Vandalism on Wikipedia Act of editing Wikipedia in a malicious manner

On Wikipedia, vandalism is editing the project in an intentionally disruptive or malicious manner. Vandalism includes any addition, removal, or modification that is humorous, nonsensical, a hoax, or degrading in any way.

Conflict-of-interest (COI) editing on Wikipedia occurs when editors use Wikipedia to advance the interests of their external roles or relationships. The type of COI editing of most concern on Wikipedia is paid editing for public relations (PR) purposes. Several Wikipedia policies and guidelines exist to combat conflict of interest editing, including Wikipedia:Conflict of interest and Wikipedia:Paid-contribution disclosure.

Phil Scraton is a critical criminologist, academic and author. He is a social researcher, known particularly for his investigative work into the context, circumstances and aftermath of the 1989 Hillsborough disaster. More recently, he was a member of the Hillsborough Independent Panel and headed its research. Currently he is Professor Emeritus, School of Law at Queen's University Belfast, and Director of the Childhood, Transition and Social Justice Initiative.

Wikipediocracy Website for discussion and criticism of Wikipedia

Wikipediocracy is a website for discussion and criticism of Wikipedia. Its members have brought information about Wikipedia's controversies to the attention of the media. The site was founded in March 2012 by users of Wikipedia Review, another site critical of Wikipedia.

CongressEdits (@congressedits) was an automated Twitter bot account created in May 2014 that tweeted changes to Wikipedia articles that originated from IP addresses within the ranges assigned to the United States Congress. The changes could have been made by anyone using a computer on the U.S. Capitol complex's computer network, including both staff of U.S. elected representatives and senators as well as visitors such as journalists, constituents, tourists, and lobbyists. Previous to this, the best information about what congressional staff were editing was found in the articles "United States Congressional staff edits to Wikipedia" and "Wikipedia:Congressional staffer edits", which are manually updated. CongressEdits has been called a watchdog by NBC News.

Sir Murray Stuart-Smith, KCMG, PC is a former English barrister and Appeal Court judge. His 1997 re-examination of Lord Taylor's report into the Hillsborough disaster is seen today as a "debacle".

Wikipedia bots are Internet bots that perform tasks in Wikipedia. One prominent example of such is Lsjbot, which had generated millions of articles across various language editions of Wikipedia.

Coverage of American politics in Wikipedia is a subject that has received substantial attention from the media. Since its founding in 2001, Wikipedia has provided coverage of five United States presidential elections, and an equal number of mid-term elections at the federal level, as well as numerous "off-year" state elections and special elections.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Duggan, Oliver (24 April 2014). "Exclusive: Shocking Hillsborough insults added on Wikipedia from Government computers". Liverpool Echo . Retrieved 27 April 2014.
  2. ↑ "Wikipedia diff 283956539". Wikimedia Foundation. 15 April 2009. Retrieved 27 September 2015.
  3. ↑ "Wikipedia diff 493826709". Wikimedia Foundation. 22 May 2012. Retrieved 27 September 2015.
  4. 1 2 "Hillsborough Wikipedia posts were 'sickening', Cabinet Office says". BBC News . 25 April 2014. Retrieved 8 May 2014.
  5. 1 2 "Departmental Internet: 11 Dec 2008: Hansard Written Answers - TheyWorkForYou". TheyWorkForYou . 11 December 2008. Retrieved 8 May 2014.
  6. 1 2 3 Lee, Dave (29 April 2014). "Wikipedia edit from government computer added Muslim insult". BBC. Retrieved 3 May 2014.
  7. ↑ Johnston, Ian (25 April 2014). "Hillsborough Wikipedia posts: Government launches inquiry after insults aimed at Liverpool fans traced to Government computers in Whitehall". The Independent . Retrieved 27 April 2014.
  8. 1 2 Johnson, Dan (25 April 2014). "Hillsborough Wikipedia posts: Government pledges 'urgent inquiries'". BBC News . Retrieved 27 April 2014.
  9. ↑ Press Association (26 April 2014). "Finding Hillsborough 'trolls' could be tough". Independent.ie . Retrieved 27 April 2014.
  10. ↑ Duggan, Oliver (25 April 2014). "Full parliamentary probe into shocking Hillsborough insults added to Wikipedia from Government computers". Liverpool Echo. Retrieved 27 April 2014.
  11. ↑ Johnson, Mark (20 May 2014). "Hillsborough Wikipedia scandal: 'Strong leads' in hunt for trolls who used Government computer". Liverpool Echo. Retrieved 20 May 2014.
  12. ↑ "Wikipedia diff 717548799". Wikimedia Foundation. 28 April 2016. Retrieved 30 April 2016.
  13. ↑ Fitzsimmons, Francesca (28 April 2016). "Offensive Hillsborough comments added to Wikipedia using council IP address". Liverpool Echo. Retrieved 30 April 2016.
  14. ↑ "Wikipedia edits linked to Whitehall". Belfast Telegraph . 26 April 2014. Retrieved 27 April 2014.
  15. ↑ Oliver Duggan "Des Lynam 'killed by a giant snowball' and other embarrassing Wikipedia edits from Whitehall computers", Daily Telegraph, 27 April 2014
  16. ↑ Duffy, Judith (27 April 2014). "Offensive Wikipedia edits made in Whitehall". Herald Scotland. Retrieved 27 April 2014.
  17. ↑ Edmiston, Jake (27 April 2014). "U.K. government computer used to edit Canadian author David Gilmour's Wikipedia page, call him a 'homophobe'". National Post . Retrieved 8 May 2014.
  18. ↑
  19. ↑ Scott, Nigel (29 April 2014). "Wikipedia: where truth dies online". Spiked . Retrieved 29 April 2014.
  20. ↑ Duggan, Oliver, "Civil servant fired after Telegraph investigation into Hillsborough Wikipedia slurs", The Daily Telegraph , 17 June 2014
  21. ↑ "Civil servant sacked for offensive Wikipedia edits on Hillsborough". The Guardian. 17 June 2014. Retrieved 17 June 2014.
  22. ↑ Docking, Neil (20 October 2014). "Government issues new Wikipedia rules for Whitehall staff after civil servant posted Hillsborough slurs". Liverpool Echo. Retrieved 20 October 2014.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.