Rankings of universities in Canada are typically published annually by a variety of nationally, and internationally based publications. Rankings of post-secondary institutions have most often been conducted by magazines, newspapers, websites, governments, or academia. Ranking are established to help inform potential applicants about universities in Canada based on a range of criteria, including student body characteristics, classes, faculty, finances, library, and reputation. Various rankings consider combinations of factors, including funding and endowment, research excellence and/or influence, specialization expertise, admissions, student options, award numbers, internationalization, graduate employment, industrial linkage, historical reputation and other criteria. Various rankings also evaluate universities based on research output.
Several Canadian-based publication have produced rankings of universities in Canada, the most prominent being the news magazine Maclean's under the name Guide to Canadian Universities which began in 1991. [1] Canadian-based publications have generally limited their rankings to only universities in Canada. Several universities in Canada have also placed in rankings which includes other universities from around the world; such as Academic Ranking of World Universities , QS World University Rankings , the Times Higher Education World University Rankings , and the U.S. News & World Report Best Global University Ranking .
Several international publications assess the quality of a university by using the weighted average of opinions gathered in surveys, alongside other quantitative measures. Those surveyed typically include members of academia and the business community. These types of rankings include Quacquarelli Symonds's World University Ranking , The Times Higher Education World University Ranking , and the U.S. News & World Report's Best Global University Ranking. [2] [3] [4]
The following table includes Canadian universities, and their most recent global rank in the aforementioned publications (with national ranks in parentheses):
University | 2023 QS World University Ranking [note 1] [5] | 2023 Times Higher Education World University Ranking [note 2] [6] | 2023 U.S. News & World Report Best Global University Ranking [note 2] [7] |
---|---|---|---|
University of Alberta | 110 (4) | 118 (6) | 136 (4) |
University of British Columbia | 47 (3) | 40 (2) | 35 (2) |
Brock University | 1001–1200 (28–30) | — | 1394 (32) |
University of Calgary | 242 (10) | 201–250 (8–10) | 175 (7) |
Carleton University | 601–650 (21) | 601–800 (20–27) | 526 (20) |
Concordia University | 551–560 (18) | 601–800 (20–27) | 653 (21) |
Dalhousie University | 308 (12) | 301–350 (14–15) | 314 (11) |
University of Guelph | 591–600 (20) | 501–600 (18–19) | 497 (19) |
Université Laval | 433 (15) | 251–300 (11–13) | 397 (15) |
Lakehead University | — | 801–1000 (28–30) | 1291 (30) |
Laurentian University | — | — | 1405 (33) |
University of Lethbridge | — | 1201–1500 (31) | 1741 (37) |
University of Manitoba | 651–700 (22) | 351–400 (16) | 372 (14) |
McGill University | 31 (1) | 46 (3) | 54 (3) |
McMaster University | 152 (6) | 85 (4) | 138 (5) |
Memorial University of Newfoundland | 751–800 (24–26) | 601–800 (20–27) | 698 (22) |
Université de Montréal | 116 (5) | 111 (5) | 156 (6) |
University of New Brunswick | 700–751 (23) | 601–800 (20–27) | 948 (26) |
University of Northern British Columbia | — | 801–1000 (28–30) | — |
Ontario Tech University | — | 601–800 (20–27) | 1121 (T-27) |
University of Ottawa | 237 (9) | 137 (7) | 215 (9) |
Université du Québec | 571–580 (19) | 601–800 (20–27) | [note 3] |
Queen's University at Kingston | 246 (11) | 251–300 (11–13) | 429 (17) |
University of Regina | 1001–1200 (28–30) | 601–800 (20–27) | 935 (25) |
University of Saskatchewan | 473 (17) | 501–600 (18–19) | 441 (18) |
Université de Sherbrooke | 751–800 (24–26) | — | 789 (24) |
Simon Fraser University | 328 (13) | 251–300 (11–13) | 317 (12) |
University of Toronto | 34 (2) | 18 (1) | 18 (1) |
Toronto Metropolitan University | 801–1000 (27) | 801–1000 (28–30) | 1452 (34) |
Trent University | — | — | 1570 (35) |
University of Victoria | 359 (14) | 301–350 (14–15) | 327 (13) |
University of Waterloo | 154 (7) | 201–250 (8–10) | 191 (8) |
Western University | 172 (8) | 201–250 (8–10) | 300 (10) |
Wilfrid Laurier University | — | — | 1271 (29) |
University of Windsor | 751–800 (24–26) | 601–800 (20–27) | 1121 (T-27) |
Vancouver Island University | 1001–1200 (28–30) | — | — |
York University | 456 (16) | 401–500 (17) | 426 (16) |
Several institutions and publications have created university rankings whose methodologies rely only on quantitative measures. These rankings use quantitative measures to assess the quality of an institution, such as bibliometrics, or through the number of awards and distinctions accrued by a university's faculty and/or alumni. Quantitative international rankings include the Academic Ranking of World Universities , published by the Shanghai Ranking Consultancy; and the Center for World University Rankings.
Several institutions publish rankings that are primarily bibliometric, based on citation analysis. Biblometric rankings specifically evaluate the impact a university has on specialized journals and other academic publications. Bibliometrics is a field of statistics used to provide quantitative analysis of academic literature. Primarily bibliometric rankings include those; the Performance Ranking of Scientific Papers for World Universities, published by the National Taiwan University; and University Ranking by Academic Performance, published by the Middle East Technical University.
The following table includes Canadian universities, and their most recent global rank in the aforementioned publications (with national ranks in parentheses):
University | 2022 Academic Ranking of World Universities [8] | 2020 Performance Ranking of Scientific Papers for World Universities [9] | 2020–21 University Ranking by Academic Performance [10] | 2023 Center for World University Rankings [11] |
---|---|---|---|---|
University of Alberta | 92 (5) | 92 (4) | 77 (4) | 76 (4) |
University of British Columbia | 44 (2) | 33 (2) | 29 (2) | 51 (3) |
Brock University | — | — | — | 1255 (31) |
University of Calgary | 151–200 (7–8) | 147 (7) | 125 (6) | 195 (8) |
Carleton University | 501–600 (20–22) | 501–550 (19–20) | 563 (20) | 539 (20) |
Concordia University | 501–600 (20–22) | 701–750 (23–24) | 589 (23) | 620 (22) |
Dalhousie University | 301–400 (13–17) | 311 (13) | 297 (13) | 348 (14) |
École de technologie supérieure | — | — | — | 1443 (33) |
Institut national de la recherche scientifique | — | — | — | 969 (26) |
University of Guelph | 401–500 (18–19) | 501–550 (19–20) | 420 (17) | 486 (19) |
Lakehead University | — | — | — | 1321 (32) |
Laurentian University | — | — | — | 1716 (38) |
Université Laval | 301–400 (13–17) | 268 (11) | 238 (11) | 299 (12) |
University of Lethbridge | — | — | — | 1596 (36) |
University of Manitoba | 201–300 (9–12) | 308 (12) | 289 (12) | 282 (11) |
McGill University | 73 (3) | 49 (3) | 47 (3) | 26 (2) |
McMaster University | 90 (4) | 120 (6) | 133 (7) | 174 (6) |
Memorial University of Newfoundland | 701–800 (23–24) | 601–650 (22) | 573 (21) | 648 (24) |
Polytechnique Montréal [note 4] | — | — | 790 (26) | — |
Université de Montréal | 101–150 (6) | 115 (5) | 104 (5) | 122 (5) |
University of New Brunswick | — | — | 950 (27) | 1092 (29) |
Ontario Tech University | 901–1000 (25–26) | — | — | 1545 (35) |
University of Ottawa | 201–300 (9–12) | 156 (8) | 144 (8) | 212 (10) |
Université du Québec à Montréal | 701–800 (23–24) | 701–750 (23–24) | 629 (24) | 641 (23) |
Université du Québec à Trois-Rivières | — | — | — | 1696 (37) |
Queen's University at Kingston | 201–300 (9–12) | 381 (15) | 364 (14) | 325 (13) |
University of Regina | — | — | — | 998 (28) |
Saint Mary's University | — | — | — | 1887 (39) |
University of Saskatchewan | 301–400 (13–17) | 467 (17) | 370 (15) | 394 (16) |
University of Winnipeg | — | — | — | 1975 (40) |
Université de Sherbrooke | 501–600 (20–22) | 551–600 (21) | 580 (22) | 601 (21) |
Simon Fraser University | 301–400 (13–17) | 400 (16) | 405 (16) | 371 (15) |
University of Toronto | 22 (1) | 3 (1) | 2 (1) | 23 (1) |
Toronto Metropolitan University | 901–1000 (25–26) | — | 737 (25) | 835 (25) |
Trent University | — | — | — | 1507 (34) |
University of Victoria | 301–400 (13–17) | 377 (14) | 424 (18) | 404 (17) |
University of Waterloo | 151–200 (7–8) | 238 (10) | 192 (10) | 204 (9) |
University of Windsor | — | — | 981 (28) | 990 (27) |
Western University | 201–300 (9–12) | 214 (9) | 186 (9) | 188 (7) |
Wilfrid Laurier University | — | — | — | 1226 (30) |
York University | 401–500 (18–19) | 478 (18) | 546 (19) | 451 (18) |
Webometrics Ranking of World Universities is biannual university ranking produced by Cybermetrics Lab. The webometrics rankings use link analysis in an effort to evaluate the institution's overall web presence, and accessibility. [12]
A number of Canadian-based publications have ranked universities in Canada. The most prominent of which is Maclean's , a Toronto-based news magazine that has published an annual rankings of Canadian universities since 1991. [1] In addition to the Maclean's ranking, there are other Canadian-based publications that also rank Canadian universities. In 2012, the Toronto-based Higher Education Strategy Associates published a study ranking Canadian Universities based on research strength. The study ranks Canadian Universities in two broad fields: Science and Engineering, and Social Sciences and Humanities. [13]
A number of nationally based organizations have also crafted ranking using input from students and alumni. In 2014, the Toronto-based CampusRanking.ca began publication of its annual Canadian University and College Rankings, focusing on undergraduate education. The student-generated rankings asked over 40,000 undergraduate students and alumni to rate their schools. The survey was done across 135 schools in Canada. [14] This data was used to develop a school matching quiz, MatchU, where students are matched to schools based on their personality type and school preferences. [15] In February 2017, University Magazine, based in Windsor and Edmonton, started publishing its list of Top 10 universities in Canada. [16] University Magazine surveyed undergraduate and graduate students at 96 Canadian universities, using this information to rank the universities
Maclean's publishes an annual ranking of Canadian universities, intended to measure a university's overall "undergraduate experience". [17] Universities are split into three categories: medical/doctoral, comprehensive, and undergraduate. Maclean's evaluates post-secondary institutions on a number of performance factors, such as awards collected, resources, reputation, as well as student satisfaction surveys. [18]
University of Windsor professor and co-author of The Marketing of Canadian University Rankings: A Misadventure Now 24 Years Old [19] Stewart Page, had observed, in 2012, that numerous Canadian schools had withdrawn active cooperation from Maclean’s annual surveys. [20]
In addition to the medical/doctoral, comprehensive, and undergraduate university categories, the magazine also produces rankings for that focus on individual academic fields.[ citation needed ] The Maclean's ranking of "medical/doctoral universities" includes universities that are heavily research-based, and have a broad range of graduate-level programs. [21] Universities placed within Maclean's comprehensive rankings includes universities with a significant degree of research activity and a wide range of programs at the undergraduate, graduate, and professional levels. [22] Universities placed in their primarily undergraduate rankings features universities that are smaller in size and offer fewer graduate programs than universities found in other categories. [23]
Maclean's medical/doctoral, comprehensive, and undergraduate annual rankings uses a number of performance factors to evaluate universities, including a reputational survey that accounts for 15 per cent of an institution's final score in the magazine's medical/doctoral, comprehensive, and undergraduate rankings. [18] Respondents to the magazine's reputation survey includes university administrators and faculty, secondary school guidance counsellors, and members of the business community. [18] [24] In addition to using the information obtained from the reputational survey for its medical/comprehensive/undergraduate university rankings, Maclean's also publishes the results of the survey in the form of a reputational ranking. Maclean's reputational rankings rankgs institutions in several categories, including quality, innovation, and "leaders of tomorrow". [18] [24] The following are Maclean's overall reputational rankings:
2023 Maclean's overall reputation rankings [note 2] [24] | |
---|---|
University | Rank |
University of Toronto | 1 |
University of Waterloo | 2 |
University of British Columbia | 3 |
McGill University | 4 |
McMaster University | 5 |
Queen's University at Kingston | 6 |
University of Alberta | 7 |
Université de Montréal | 8 |
Simon Fraser University | 9 |
University of Victoria | 10 |
University of Calgary | 11 |
University of Guelph | 12 |
Western University | 13 |
University of Ottawa | 14 |
Dalhousie University | 15 |
Université Laval | 16 |
York University | 17 |
Concordia University | 18 |
Toronto Metropolitan University | 19 |
Université de Sherbrooke | 20 |
Carleton University | 21 |
University of Saskatchewan | 22 |
Wilfrid Laurier University | 23 |
Memorial University of Newfoundland | 24 |
University of Manitoba | 25 |
Université du Québec à Montréal | 26 |
Brock University | 27 |
Mount Allison University | 28 |
University of New Brunswick | 29 |
Trent University | 30 |
Ontario Tech University | 31 |
University of Northern British Columbia | 32 |
Acadia University | 33 |
St. Francis Xavier University | 34 |
University of Winnipeg | 35 |
Saint Mary's University | 36 |
University of Prince Edward Island | 37 |
University of Lethbridge | 38 |
University of Regina | 39 |
Université de Moncton | 40 |
University of Windsor | 41 |
Bishop's University | 42 |
Lakehead University | 43 |
Brandon University | 44 |
Mount Saint Vincent University | 45 |
Cape Breton University | 46 |
St. Thomas University | 47 |
Nipissing University | 48 |
Laurentian University | 49 |
Several Canadian institutions have been critical of Maclean's rankings, either frustrated with its process or its results. [19] After Maclean's released the methodology it used in 1992, Memorial University of Newfoundland and Carleton University opted to not participate in Maclean's 1993 ranking in protest of it. In 1994, the vice-chancellor of McGill University, Bernard Shapiro, wrote a letter to Maclean's coordinating editor concerning the rankings. [25]
Wide-scale withdrawals from participation in Maclean's rankings began in 1995, when 15 universities, primarily made up of francophone institutions from Quebec, as well as the University of Manitoba, Memorial University of Newfoundland, and Université de Moncton. opted to not participate in Maclean's survey. However, these universities continued to provide similar data to the ones requested by Maclean's to the Association of Universities and Colleges of Canada for comparison purposes. [25]
Further opt-outs from several research universities began in 2005, after the University of Toronto opted to not participate in the survey that year. [19] [25] The University of Toronto's withdrawal from Maclean's rankings resulted in Maclean's utilizing freedom-of-information laws to obtain the data it needed to compile its rankings. [19] In August 2006, the University of Alberta, University of British Columbia, University of Calgary, Dalhousie University, University of Lethbridge, University of Manitoba, McMaster University, Université de Montréal, University of Ottawa, Simon Fraser University, and the University of Toronto issued a joint letter stating they would not participate in Maclean's ranking survey or provide them with any data. [26] [27] The joint statement described the rankings as "over-simplified and arbitrary," and were critical of the low response rates for its reputation surveys. [28] By the end of 2006, a total of 26 universities opted to not complete Maclean's questionnaire. [28]
University of Alberta president Indira Samarasekera wrote that Maclean's initially filed a "Freedom of Information" request but that it was "too late" for the universities to respond. Samarasekera further stated, "Most of [the universities] had already posted the data online, and we directed Maclean's staff to our website. In instances where the magazine staff couldn't find data on our website, they chose to use the previous year's data." [29] Beginning with its 2007 rankings, the magazine gathered information previously obtained from the questionnaires from third-party, or other official sources and reports. [28]
In 2016, a team at University of Windsor published its analyses of Maclean’s Canadian universities ranking data of the previous 24 years, as The Marketing of Canadian University Rankings: A Misadventure Now 24 Years Old. The report offers a statistical findings summary, along with discussions regarding status quo as well as effects of the surveys on student welfare. [19]
The Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology (KAIST) is a national research university located in Daedeok Innopolis, Daejeon, South Korea. KAIST was established by the Korean government in 1971 as the nation's first public, research-oriented science and engineering institution. KAIST is considered to be one of the most prestigious universities in the nation. KAIST has been internationally accredited in business education, and hosts the Secretariat of the Association of Asia-Pacific Business Schools (AAPBS). KAIST has 10,504 full-time students and 1,342 faculty researchers and had a total budget of US$765 million in 2013, of which US$459 million was from research contracts.
Sorbonne University is a public research university located in Paris, France. The institution's legacy reaches back to the Middle Ages in 1257 when Sorbonne College was established by Robert de Sorbon as one of the first universities in Europe.
The University of Northern British Columbia (UNBC) is a university serving the northern region of the Canadian province of British Columbia. It is not affiliated with UBC. The main campus is located in Prince George, with additional campuses located in Prince Rupert, Terrace, Quesnel, and Fort St. John. Because of its northern latitude, UNBC is a member of the University of the Arctic. In the 2020–21 academic year, 4,253 students were enrolled at UNBC.
Maclean's, founded in 1905, is a Canadian news magazine reporting on Canadian issues such as politics, pop culture, and current events. Its founder, publisher John Bayne Maclean, established the magazine to provide a uniquely Canadian perspective on current affairs and to "entertain but also inspire its readers". Rogers Media, the magazine's publisher since 1994, announced in September 2016 that Maclean's would become a monthly beginning January 2017, while continuing to produce a weekly issue on the Texture app. In 2019, the magazine was bought by its current publisher, St. Joseph Communications.
Université Laval is a public research university in Quebec City, Quebec, Canada. The university was founded by François de Montmorency-Laval as Séminaire de Québec in 1663, making it the oldest institution of higher education in Canada and the first North American institution to offer higher education in French. The university, which was founded in Old Québec, moved to a new campus in the 1950s in the suburban borough of Sainte-Foy–Sillery–Cap-Rouge. It is ranked among the top 10 Canadian universities in research funding and holds four Canada Excellence Research Chairs.
The Université de Sherbrooke is a French-language public research university in Sherbrooke, Quebec, Canada, with a second campus in Longueuil, a suburb on the South Shore of Montreal. It is one of two universities in the Estrie region of Quebec, and the only French-language university for the region.
College and university rankings order institutions in higher education based on factors that vary depending on the ranking. Some rankings evaluate institutions within a single country, while others assess institutions worldwide. Rankings are typically conducted by magazines, newspapers, websites, governments, or academics. In addition to ranking entire institutions, specific programs, departments, and schools can be ranked. Some rankings consider measures of wealth, excellence in research, selective admissions, and alumni success. Rankings may also consider various combinations of measures of specialization expertise, student options, award numbers, internationalization, graduate employment, industrial linkage, historical reputation and other criteria.
Three national rankings of universities in the United Kingdom are published annually, by The Complete University Guide, The Guardian and jointly by The Times and The Sunday Times. Rankings have also been produced in the past by The Daily Telegraph and Financial Times. UK Universities also rank highly in global university rankings with 8 UK Universities ranking in the top 100 of the three major global rankings: QS World University Rankings, Times Higher Education World University Rankings and Academic Ranking of World Universities.
Xi'an Jiaotong University is a public university in Xi'an, Shaanxi, China. It is affiliated with and funded by the Ministry of Education of China. The university is part of Project 211, Project 985, and the Double First-Class Construction.
The Academic Ranking of World Universities (ARWU), also known as the Shanghai Ranking, is one of the annual publications of world university rankings. The league table was originally compiled and issued by Shanghai Jiao Tong University in 2003, making it the first global university ranking with multifarious indicators.
The Université de Montréal is a French-language public research university in Montreal, Quebec, Canada. The university's main campus is located in the Côte-des-Neiges neighborhood of Côte-des-Neiges–Notre-Dame-de-Grâce on Mount Royal near the Outremont Summit, in the borough of Outremont. The institution comprises thirteen faculties, more than sixty departments and two affiliated schools: the Polytechnique Montréal and HEC Montréal. It offers more than 650 undergraduate programmes and graduate programmes, including 71 doctoral programmes.
Quacquarelli Symonds (QS) is a higher education analyst and services provider headquartered in London with offices in Europe, Asia, and the Americas.
Criticism of college and university rankings refers to critiques of various rankings publications among faculty and administrators in institutions of higher education in both the United States and Canada, as well as in media reports.
The Times Higher Education World University Rankings, often referred to as the THE Rankings or just THE, is the annual publication of university rankings by the Times Higher Education magazine. The publisher had collaborated with Quacquarelli Symonds (QS) to publish the joint THE-QS World University Rankings from 2004 to 2009 before it turned to Thomson Reuters for a new ranking system from 2010 to 2013. In 2014, the magazine signed an agreement with Elsevier to provide it with the data used in compiling its annual rankings.
QS World University Rankings is a portfolio of comparative college and university rankings compiled by Quacquarelli Symonds, a higher education analytics firm. Its first and earliest edition was published in collaboration with Times Higher Education (THE) magazine as Times Higher Education–QS World University Rankings, inaugurated in 2004 to provide an independent source of comparative data about university performance. In 2009, the two organizations parted ways to produce independent university rankings, the QS World University Rankings and THE World University Rankings.
College and university rankings in the United States order the best U.S. colleges and universities based on factors that vary depending on the ranking. Rankings are typically conducted by magazines, newspapers, websites, governments, or academics. In addition to ranking entire institutions, specific programs, departments, and schools can be ranked. Some rankings consider measures of wealth, excellence in research, selective admissions, and alumni success. There is also much debate about rankings' interpretation, accuracy, and usefulness.
The Best Global Universities ranking by U.S. News & World Report is an annual ranking of world universities. On October 28, 2014, U.S. News, which began ranking American universities in 1983, published its inaugural global ranking, assessing 500 universities in 49 countries. That first installment of the Best Global Universities Ranking was published without prior announcement, with U.S. News later clarifying that the rankings of that year were a trial balloon for the publication's entrance into the global university rankings field. After pre-announcing the rankings of next year, in 2016, the periodical formalized the global university rankings as part of its regular annual programming. Having made official the ranking methodology, it disclosed that it is based on 10 different indicators that measure universities' academic performance and reputations. The ranking has since been revised and expanded to cover 1,500 institutions in 81 countries and now includes five regional and 28 subject rankings. Employing 13 indicators and based largely on data provided by Clarivate, the U.S. News global ranking is methodologically different from its ranking of American institutions; global universities are rated using factors such as research reputation, academic publications, and the number of highly cited papers.
Academic rankings of universities in Mexico are listings of universities and institutions of higher education in the country that has been sorted according to different criteria of evaluation. The ratings may be based on the "subjective quality perceived", in a certain combination of empirical statistics, bibliometric statistics or examinations by teachers, students or others. These classifications are often consulted by applicants to obtain a place at a university and choose one according to personal criteria.
The CHE University Ranking is an annual ranking of German universities and colleges. It is a subject‐specific, multidimensional system aimed at providing information for students, with its main emphasis on teaching, rather than research. Introduced in 1998 and published by the Centre for Higher Education in cooperation with Die Zeit, it is the most comprehensive ranking of its kind in Germany.
Notes
Works cited