Siege of the Manila Hotel

Last updated

Manila Hotel siege
Date6–8 July 1986
Location
Manila Hotel, Ermita, Manila, Philippines
Result

Philippine government victory

  • Coup averted
  • Surrender and dispersal of coup participants
Belligerents
Flag of the Philippines (navy blue).svg  Philippines
War Flag of the Philippines (navy blue).svg Marcos loyalists
Commanders and leaders
Flag of the Philippines (navy blue).svg Corazon Aquino
Flag of the Philippines (navy blue).svg Juan Ponce Enrile
Flag of the Philippines (navy blue).svg Fidel Ramos
Flag of the Philippines (navy blue).svg Ramon Montaño
War Flag of the Philippines (navy blue).svg Ferdinand Marcos
War Flag of the Philippines (navy blue).svg Arturo Tolentino
War Flag of the Philippines (navy blue).svg Jose Maria Zumel
War Flag of the Philippines (navy blue).svg Rolando Abadilla
Military support
Flag of the Armed Forces of the Philippines.svg Armed Forces of the Philippines War Flag of the Philippines (navy blue).svg Marcos loyalists from the AFP
Civilian supporters of Marcos

The siege of the Manila Hotel (Filipino: Pagkubkob sa Manila Hotel) was an occupation of the Manila Hotel, a luxury hotel in the Philippine capital Manila, led by former vice-presidential candidate Arturo Tolentino and other military and civilian supporters of deposed President Ferdinand Marcos as part of a coup attempt to overthrow his successor, Corazon Aquino and restore him to power, on 6–8 July 1986. The coup failed to gain extensive support, and ended on 8 July with the departure of most participants and the surrender of others.

Contents

The coup occurred barely five months [1] after Aquino was installed in office following the People Power Revolution in February, and was the first of nine attempts to topple Aquino's government. It was followed by the God Save the Queen Plot in November later that year.

Background

After Marcos' overthrow and exile to Hawaii in February 1986, his supporters regularly held rallies demanding his restoration as president every Sunday at Manila's Luneta Park, which was next to the Manila Hotel, a luxury hotel that was a prominent gathering place for politicians, expatriates and other leading members of Philippine society. The rallies were often attended by prominent personalities associated with Marcos who had stayed behind in the Philippines, [2] including Arturo Tolentino, Marcos' running mate in the 1986 snap presidential election on 7 February, whose disputed outcome precipitated the People Power Revolution on 22–25 February that ousted Marcos and installed his electoral rival, Corazon Aquino.

The coup was launched whilst the Aquino government was grappling with several issues such as student unrest in Metro Manila, agrarian reform, rising tensions with the Armed Forces of the Philippines regarding negotiations with the CPP-NPA to end the communist insurgency and the supposed presence of left-wing officials in Aquino's cabinet, the drafting of a new constitution, and preparations for Aquino's state visit to the United States. [1]

Preparations for the coup

A few days before the coup, Tolentino reportedly booked four adjoining rooms at the Manila Hotel's 14th floor under a woman's name, while other loyalists booked rooms under false names and used codes to communicate with each other. They also brought ample stocks of food and water for a prolonged stay. [1]

The coup was also known beforehand to several military officers, including those affiliated with the Reform the Armed Forces Movement (RAM), which helped lead the People Power Revolution. [1] It later emerged that Marcos loyalist officer Colonel Rolando Abadilla contacted RAM leader Gringo Honasan a month before the coup, asking for their support. However, RAM adopted a wait-and-see approach, although in an apparent sign of rapprochement, senior RAM official Rodolfo Aguinaldo was also seen inside the hotel during the coup. [3] On the morning of the coup, prominent Marcos loyalists at the InterContinental Manila invited American journalist Jack Anderson to their regular Sunday rally at the Luneta, promising a "scoop". [1]

Events

Occupation of the hotel

Manila Hotel in 2012 Manila hotel luneta (2012).jpg
Manila Hotel in 2012
Arturo Tolentino Arturo Tolentino.jpg
Arturo Tolentino

During the regular Marcos loyalist rally at the Luneta's Quirino Grandstand [3] on 6 July 1986, some 100 armed soldiers and civilians entered the Manila Hotel and set up camp in the lobby, with Brigadier General Jose Maria Zumel, a former superintendent of the Philippine Military Academy and officer in Marcos' Presidential Security Command, informing the hotel's head of catering of their takeover. Likewise, a former assistant manager of the hotel who was related to a Marcos official proclaimed himself the hotel's new general manager, while an officer working for Marcos' exiled AFP Chief of Staff Fabian Ver declared himself the hotel's security chief. The total number of occupiers was later estimated to be about 490 military personnel and 5,000 civilians. [1] Many of the soldiers arrived on military trucks and jeeps from camps in Metro Manila and Central Luzon and were armed with machine guns and wireless radios. [4] Many were also members of the Guardians Brotherhood, a mutual-aid society within the AFP that was seen as close to Honasan. [3]

An hour later, at the hotel's driveway, Tolentino announced that Marcos had authorized him to temporarily take over the government. He then took his oath as Acting President in front of a former Supreme Court justice, and designated a five-person cabinet [4] composed of Rafael Recto as Minister of Justice, Manuel Collantes as Minister of Foreign Affairs, Manuel Alba as Minister of Budget, Isidro Rodriguez Jr. as Minister of Local Government, and Juan Ponce Enrile as Minister of National Defense and concurrent Prime Minister. Tolentino also ordered Nicanor Yñiguez, the speaker of Marcos' dissolved rubber-stamp parliament, the Regular Batasang Pambansa, to convene the body and call for local elections. [1]

In an interview, Tolentino said he did want to have any "real confrontation" with Aquino, but said he hoped she would "listen to the will of the people." He said he could not stay at the hotel for long, citing its expensiveness, but insisted that he would continue to "assert the authority as the legitimate government." [4] Tolentino also claimed to have received a congratulatory telephone call from Marcos in Hawaii. [5]

Other Marcos loyalists made speeches throughout the evening, while supporters camped in and around the hotel overnight. [4] [6] They were supplied with food, drinks and pro-Marcos T-shirts, and barricaded the approaches to the hotel using trucks, buses, concrete flower pots and burning tires. Several teenage supporters were seen manning the roadblocks armed with rocks. [7] A Navy gunboat was also reported to have docked in Manila Bay to support the rebels, [4] while officials in Quezon City reported that there were attempts to recruit residents to support the loyalists. [1]

As time passed however, the momentum of the coup gradually disappeared due to a lack of reinforcements and popular support. An early morning downpour on 7 July [7] reduced the number of participants to a few hundred by daybreak. [5] In the morning, some 200 rebel soldiers surrendered, saying that they were misled into thinking that they were supporting Enrile and AFP Chief of Staff Fidel Ramos, both of whom spearheaded the People Power uprising in February. [4] All 300 guests and employees were also evacuated from the hotel at the same time. [8] [5] Tolentino then held a press conference, claiming that he was forced into taking the oath of office by the "clamor" of the crowd and called on Aquino to hold early elections. [1]

The coup was seen as an attempt to try and replicate a joint civil-military uprising in the hopes of gathering enough support to seize the presidential residence at Malacañang, similar to what happened during the People Power Revolution. [2]

Prominent participants

Several military officers associated with Marcos were also seen during the takeover, [1] including:

Politicians associated with Marcos [1] were also seen at the hotel, including:

Several actors also participated in the coup, including Alona Alegre, Elizabeth Oropesa, Amalia Fuentes, Weng Weng, Carlos Salazar and Rio Diaz. [1]

Marcos' involvement

While the coup was unfolding, a spokesman for Marcos in Honolulu said that he was monitoring the events closely and would return to the Philippines as an "elder statesman" if Aquino was overthrown. He also said Marcos was unaware of Tolentino's plans. [4] After the coup failed, Marcos personally denied involvement in any coups or acts of sedition and destabilization against the government. [8]

However, in August 1987, transcripts containing seven calls by Marcos to supporters at the Manila Hotel were released, appearing to show that Marcos extensively knew about the planned coup and directed events once it came. The conversations were recorded during the first 14 hours of the coup before the evacuation of all employees from the hotel and were transcribed by the hotel's telephone operator at the instruction of hotel officials. Among the details that were released was that Marcos had three men at the hotel directly monitoring the situation for him, and that he dissuaded his supporters from marching on Malacañang pending the arrival of reinforcements led by his close ally, former Lanao del Sur governor Ali Dimaporo. The conversations contributed to the government's view that the coup was a "pre-planned and premeditated conspiracy" to destabilize the Aquino government. [8]

Following the revelations, the Reagan administration opened an inquiry into Marcos' involvement in the coup and said it would review his guest status in the United States if it were shown that he was involved in "partisan political activities" in the Philippines in violation of the Neutrality Act. [8]

Government response

The coup occurred at a time when the leading figures of Aquino's government were away from Manila. [9] Aquino was accompanied by Ramos in Cagayan de Oro when the coup broke out, forcing their return to Manila, while vice president Salvador Laurel was on an official visit to Spain. [4]

Defense Minister Juan Ponce Enrile, who was formerly Marcos' defense minister before switching sides to Aquino during the People Power revolt and was the highest-ranking official of Aquino's government in the capital, rejected his inclusion in Tolentino's cabinet. Aquino insisted on maximum tolerance in dealing with the rebels, but warned of arrests in case violence broke out, and said it was best to ignore Tolentino, calling him a "nobody", while announcing plans to charge him with sedition. [5]

As a precaution, roadblocks were set up on roads leading to Malacañang, about three miles from the hotel. [4] Eight armored personnel carriers were deployed at the Luneta, while additional soldiers were deployed at bridges and other strategic points in Manila, including radio and television transmitters. [5] Four radio stations were temporarily closed down for spreading loyalist propaganda. [1]

At the hotel, water and electricity were cut off, while employees shut down telephone and public address systems. [1]

Negotiations and end of the coup

Negotiations between the government and the rebels began at midnight on 6–7 July between generals Zumel and metropolitan police chief Ramon Montaño, [8] who was acting on instructions from Enrile. [5]

In the meantime, various suggestions were made on how to end the coup, ranging from an attack to a total blockade. [1] One cabinet minister suggested threatening the last coup participant to leave the hotel with paying the full bill for all their companions. [2]

At 2 p.m. on 7 July, Aquino issued a statement insisting that her government was still in control and ordered the rebels to surrender within 24 hours. Shortly afterwards, Tolentino and other key followers left the hotel and resumed negotiations with the government at the nearby Army and Navy Club and later at a police outpost behind Quirino Grandstand that was attended by Honasan and Aquino's son Noynoy. [1]

While negotiations were underway, Honasan, who had regularly briefed his political patron Enrile on the coup's developments, approached the rebels with a promise of amnesty from the latter, who had not consulted the matter with Aquino, and extracted Colonel Abadilla, who had been liaising with them, from the hotel. [3] This enabled the surrender of the rebel soldiers and the non-violent dispersal of civilian participants in the early morning of 8 July. [1]

The rebel soldiers were brought to Philippine Army headquarters in Fort Bonifacio, where Enrile surprised everyone by publicizing his offer of a blanket amnesty, saying that "no punishment" would be given and urging everyone to "forget" what had happened. [3] To help defuse the tension, General Ramos ordered the rebels to do thirty push-ups, which was later erroneously reported to be their only punishment and became a point of criticism for those who advocated a harsher response to the revolt. [10] On 9 July, Aquino offered clemency to the participants in exchange for taking the “oath of loyalty to the Freedom Constitution.” [1]

Aftermath

Damages to the hotel

The three-day takeover of the 500-room Manila Hotel resulted in the hotel sustaining its worst damage since the Battle of Manila in 1945. Its general manager Franz Schutzman estimated the damage at $500,000 and noted that the hotel lost five business days, two during the actual occupation and three to cleanup efforts. [11]

The doors of 26 rooms on the sixth floor were pried open, and all their towels, leather-bound folders and even the brass numbers on the doors were stolen. Other rooms and corridors occupied by the rebels were strewn with trash and leftover food and ransacked, as were the hotel's restaurant, pantry and bar. A dozen improvised explosives were discovered in the lobby. The hotel president, Feliciano Belmonte Jr., said $15,000 went missing from cash registers and four safety-deposit boxes were forced open. [11]

Tolentino and his followers had only paid for the rooms they occupied at the 14th floor and only for one night. Despite the Manila Hotel being government-owned at the time, Aquino insisted that Tolentino reimburse the damages, saying that "their boss (Marcos) had left enough debt". [11]

The Ministry of Tourism said that at least 670 hotel reservations by prospective foreign visitors in Metro Manila were cancelled as a result of the coup. [1]

Prosecution of coup participants

Tolentino and 34 others were sued by the Manila Hotel for damages reaching up to $850,000. Nevertheless, this did not prevent him from subsequently visiting the hotel and attending events hosted by its management. He avoided further prosecution by the government by swearing allegiance to Aquino's government, while insisting that he was still the legitimate vice president of the country. [12]

The involvement of Enrile and RAM in the coup was never properly investigated, which appeared to have encouraged them to launch subsequent plots against Aquino's government. [3]

Political repercussions

Enrile's inclusion in Tolentino's cabinet, despite his disavowals, strained his relations with Aquino and contributed to his dismissal as defense minister following the God Save the Queen Plot later that year in November. [2]

Tolentino was later elected to the Philippine Senate in 1992 and served until 1995. [13]

The public, still reeling from the excesses of the Marcos regime, remained generally unaffected by the coup. [1]

International reaction

The United States reiterated its support for Aquino's government, with State Department officials calling the coup a "tempest in a teapot" [4] and the "last desperate act" of Marcos supporters. [5]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">People Power Revolution</span> Series of popular demonstrations in the Philippines in 1986 that overthrew Ferdinand Marcos

The People Power Revolution, also known as the EDSA Revolution or the February Revolution, was a series of popular demonstrations in the Philippines, mostly in Metro Manila, from February 22 to 25, 1986. There was a sustained campaign of civil resistance against regime violence and electoral fraud. The nonviolent revolution led to the departure of Ferdinand Marcos, the end of his 20-year dictatorship and the restoration of democracy in the Philippines.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Juan Ponce Enrile</span> President of the Senate of the Philippines from 2008 to 2013

Juan Valentin Furagganan Ponce Enrile Sr.,, also referred to by his initials JPE, is a Filipino politician and lawyer who served as 21st President of the Senate of the Philippines from 2008 to 2013 and known for his role in the administration of Philippine president Ferdinand Marcos; his role in the failed coup that helped hasten the 1986 People Power Revolution and the ouster of Marcos; and his tenure in the Philippine legislature in the years after the revolution. Enrile has served four terms in the Senate, in a total of twenty-two years, he holds the third longest-tenure in the history of the upper chamber. In 2022, at the age of 98, he returned to government office as the Chief Presidential Legal Counsel in the administration of President Bongbong Marcos.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gregorio Honasan</span> Filipino politician

Gregorio "Gringo" Ballesteros Honasan II, is a Filipino politician and a cashiered Philippine Army officer who led unsuccessful coups d'état against President Corazon Aquino. He played a key role in the 1986 EDSA Revolution that toppled President Ferdinand Marcos, and participated in the EDSA III rallies in 2001 that preceded the May 1 riots near Malacañang Palace.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of the Philippines (1965–1986)</span>

The history of the Philippines, from 1965 to 1986, covers the presidency of Ferdinand Marcos. The Marcos era includes the final years of the Third Republic (1965–1972), the Philippines under martial law (1972–1981), and the majority of the Fourth Republic (1981–1986). By the end of the Marcos dictatorial era, the country was experiencing a debt crisis, extreme poverty, and severe underemployment.

<i>A Dangerous Life</i> 1988 Australian TV series or program

The Four Day Revolution is a 1988 Australian television film directed by Robert Markowitz and written by David Williamson. The story is about the journey and the love affair of an American foreign correspondent set during the final years of Ferdinand Marcos' dictatorship in the Philippines, from the assassination of Benigno Aquino Jr. in 1983 to the People Power Revolution in 1986, as well as other key events that led to the ouster of Marcos.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Coup attempts against Corazon Aquino</span> 1986–1990 plots to overthrow Philippine President Corazon Aquino

From 1986 to 1987, there were several plots to overthrow Philippine President Corazon Aquino involving various members of the Armed Forces of the Philippines. A significant number of the military participants in these attempts belonged to the Reform the Armed Forces Movement (RAM), while others were identified loyalists of former President Ferdinand Marcos, who had been deposed in the People Power Revolution in late February 1986.

The 1989 Philippine coup attempt was the most serious attempted coup d'état against the government of Philippine President Corazon Aquino and part of a series of coup attempts against her. It was staged beginning December 1, 1989, by members of the Armed Forces of the Philippines belonging to the Reform the Armed Forces Movement (RAM) and soldiers loyal to former President Ferdinand Marcos. Metro Manila was shaken by this Christmas-time coup, which almost seized Malacañang Palace. It was completely defeated by the Philippine government by December 9, 1989.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Presidency of Corazon Aquino</span> Philippine presidential administration from 1986 to 1992

Corazon Aquino became the 11th President of the Philippines following the People Power Revolution or EDSA 1, and spanned a six-year period from February 25, 1986, to June 30, 1992. Aquino's relatively peaceful ascension to the Philippine presidency signaled the end of authoritarian rule of Ferdinand Marcos in the Philippines, and drew her and the Filipino people international acclaim and admiration.

The Reform the Armed Forces Movement, also referred to by the acronym RAM, was a cabal of officers of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) known for several attempts to seize power in the Philippines during the 1980s and 1990s. In 1986, some of these officers launched a failed coup d'état against Ferdinand Marcos, prompting a large number of civilians to attempt to prevent Marcos from wiping the RAM rebels out. This eventually snowballed into the 1986 People Power revolution which ended the dictatorship of Ferdinand Marcos and forced him into exile. RAM later attempted six coups d'état against the administration of Corazon Aquino.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fourth inauguration of Ferdinand Marcos</span>

The fourth inauguration of Ferdinand Marcos as the tenth president of the Philippines took place on Tuesday, February 25, 1986, at Malacañang Palace in Manila. The inauguration marked the commencement of the fourth and final term of Ferdinand Marcos as president. Marcos eventually stepped down as president a few hours later while the 3-day mass demonstrations were taking place.

1986 in the Philippines details events of note that happened in the Philippines in the year 1986.

1987 in the Philippines details events of note that happened in the Philippines in the year 1987.

The People Power Revolution was a series of popular demonstrations in the Philippines that began in 1983 and culminated in 1986. The methods used amounted to a sustained campaign of civil resistance against regime violence and electoral fraud. This case of nonviolent revolution led to the toppling of dictator Ferdinand Marcos and the restoration of the country's democracy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1990 Mindanao revolt</span> Filipino coup

The 1990 Mindanao revolt was an uprising that occurred in parts of the island of Mindanao in the southern Philippines. It began when Alexander Noble, a dissident Philippine Army colonel linked to the 1989 Philippine coup attempt against President Corazon Aquino, and his supporters, which included Mindanaoan separatists, seized two military garrisons in Cagayan de Oro and Butuan without firing a shot and unilaterally proclaimed the independence of the Federal Republic of Mindanao on October 4, 1990, to be led by a civilian-military junta and with an ultimate goal of removing Aquino from office. However, Noble failed to gain support, and surrendered two days later following attacks by government forces. The revolt was the last overt attempt to overthrow Aquino's government until the end of her term in 1992.

The Siege at Hotel Delfino in Tuguegarao, Cagayan in the Philippines, took place on March 4, 1990. A private army estimated at 300 men seized the hotel under the command of suspended Cagayan governor Rodolfo "Agi" Aguinaldo, a fierce critic of the administration of President Corazon Aquino and the Communist insurgency in the Philippines. The incident was an offshoot of the 1989 Philippine coup d'état attempt that Aguinaldo publicly supported, which prompted his suspension and arrest. The standoff ended violently after several hours, leaving 14 people dead, including a general who tried to arrest him.

The February 1986 Reform the Armed Forces Movement coup was set in motion by the Reform the Armed Forces Movement (RAM) under the leadership of Defense Minister Juan Ponce Enrile to depose then-president Ferdinand Marcos, but was discovered and aborted in its earliest stages on February 22, 1986. The coup's intent was to take advantage of the public disruption arising from revelations of cheating during the 1986 Philippine presidential election, and replace Marcos with a military junta which would include Enrile, Philippine Constabulary Chief Fidel V. Ramos, then-Presidential Candidate Corazon Aquino, and Roman Catholic Cardinal Jaime Sin, among others, which Enrile and the RAM Colonels would control from behind the scenes.

On August 28, 1987, a coup d'état against the government of Philippine President Corazon Aquino was staged by members of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) belonging to the Reform the Armed Forces Movement (RAM) led by Colonel Gregorio Honasan, who had been a former top aide of ousted Defense Secretary Juan Ponce Enrile, one of the instigators of the People Power Revolution that brought Aquino to power in 1986. The coup was repelled by military forces loyal to Aquino within the day, although Honasan managed to escape.

On January 27, 1987, a coup d'état against the government of Philippine President Corazon Aquino was staged by civilian and military supporters of Aquino's deposed predecessor, Ferdinand Marcos. The soldiers were members of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) who belonged to the Guardians Brotherhood, Inc (GBI) led by Colonel Oscar Canlas. They launched failed attacks on Philippine Air Force (PAF) installations at Villamor Air Base in Pasay and Sangley Point Air Station in Cavite, and occupied the GMA-7 television station in Quezon City for 61 hours before surrendering on January 29.

The God Save the Queen Plot was a planned coup in November 1986 by Minister of National Defense Juan Ponce Enrile and the Reform the Armed Forces Movement (RAM), a dissident faction within the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) to overthrow President Corazon Aquino, whom it helped install during the People Power Revolution nine months before. However, the staging of the coup was delayed and ultimately stopped by maneuvers within the AFP led by Chief of Staff General Fidel Ramos before a shot was even fired. As a result, Enrile was subsequently fired by Aquino from her cabinet.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rolando Abadilla</span> Filipino politician and military officer (died 1996)

Rolando “Rolly” Abadilla was a Filipino politician and Philippine Constabulary (PC) officer best known for heading the PC Metropolitan Command's Intelligence and Security Group under the dictatorship of Ferdinand Marcos, which became notorious for numerous documented human rights abuses.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 "The Final Report of the Fact-Finding Commission: IV: Military Intervention in the Philippines: 1986 – 1987". Official Gazette of the Republic of the Philippines. October 5, 1990.PD-icon.svg This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain .
  2. 1 2 3 4 Reid, Robert; Guerrero, Eileen. Corazon Aquino and the Brushfire Revolution. Louisiana State University Press.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 McCoy, Alfred. Closer than Brothers: Manhood at the Philippine Military Academy. Anvil Publishing.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Tan, Ab (July 7, 1986). "Philippine Coup Try Fizzling". Washington Post . Retrieved August 26, 2023.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Mydans, Seth (July 9, 1986). "MARCOS BACKERS TAKE OVER HOTEL, BUT FAIL TO WIN MILITARY SUPPORT". New York Times . Retrieved August 26, 2023.
  6. Davide Fact-Finding Commission 1990, p. 135.
  7. 1 2 Friedman, Joel (July 6, 1986). "Manila hotel packed with Marcos supporters". UPI . Retrieved August 26, 2023.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 Mydans, Seth (August 17, 1986). "MARCOS TIE TO HOTEL TAKEOVER IS SEEN". New York Times . Retrieved August 26, 2023.
  9. "Room service at the Manila Hotel". Christian Science Monitor . July 9, 1986. Retrieved August 26, 2023.
  10. Lagustan, Nick (November 5, 2012). "Those push-ups weren't a punishment". Philippine Daily Inquirer . Retrieved August 26, 2023.
  11. 1 2 3 "Manila Hotel Abashed By Bedroom Manners Of Coup-Prone Guests". Washington Post . July 9, 1986. Retrieved August 26, 2023.
  12. Reaves, Joseph (October 14, 1986). "FROM REBELLION TO ROSTRUM IN 84 DAYS". Chicago Tribune . Retrieved August 26, 2023.
  13. "Arturo Tolentino". Senate of the Philippines . Retrieved August 26, 2023.

Bibliography