Subtractive synthesis

Last updated

Subtractive synthesis is a method of sound synthesis in which overtones of an audio signal are attenuated by a filter to alter the timbre of the sound.

Contents

Overview

Subtractive synthesis relies on source sounds that have overtones, such as non-sinusoidal waveforms like square and triangle waves, or white and pink noise. These overtones are then modulated to alter the source sound. This modulation can happen in a wide variety of ways, such as voltage-controlled or low-pass filters. [1]

The technology developed in experimental electronic studios which were primarily focused on telecommunications and military applications. [2] Early examples include Bell Labs' Voder (1937–8). [3] Composers began applying the concept of subtractive synthesis beyond the recording studio in concert music. Henri Pousseur's Scambi (1957) subjects white noise to filters and uses the resulting sounds to create montages. Mikrophonie I (1964) by Karlheinz Stockhausen uses a tam-tam and a microphone as the primary sound source which is then filtered extensively by two sound projectionists. [4]

Until the advent of digital synthesizers, subtractive synthesis was the nearly universal electronic method of sound production. [5] Its popularity was due largely to its relative simplicity. [6] Subtractive synthesis was so prevalent in analog synthesizers that it is sometimes called "analog synthesis". [7] It was the method of sound production in instruments like the Trautonium (1930), Novachord (1939), Buchla 100 (1960s), EMS VCS 3 (1969), Minimoog (1970), ARP 2600 (1971), Oberheim OB-1 (1978), and Korg MS-20 (1978). [1] :71–4 Programmable sound generators (PSG) relied heavily on subtractive synthesis. PSGs were used in many personal computers, arcade games, and home consoles such as the Atari ST, Mattel's Intellivision, Sega'sMaster System, and the ZX Spectrum. [7]

Nomenclature

Subtractive synthesis has become a catchall for a method where source sounds are modulated, and it is sometimes applied inappropriately. [8] [9]

Method

The following is an example of subtractive synthesis as it might occur in an electronic instrument to emulate the sound of a plucked string. It was created with a personal computer program designed to emulate an analogue subtractive synthesizer.

Source Sound

First, an electronic oscillator produces a relatively complex waveform with audible overtones. Only one oscillator is necessary, and the number can vary widely. In this case, two oscillators are used:

Closeup oscilloscope of Waveform #1. Waveform 1.jpg
Closeup oscilloscope of Waveform #1.
Closeup oscilloscope of Waveform #2. Closeup oscilloscope of Waveform 2.jpg
Closeup oscilloscope of Waveform #2.

Pulse-width modulation is applied to both waveforms to create a more complex tone with vibrato:

Closeup of pulse-width modulated Waveform 1. Closeup of pulse-width modulated Waveform 1.jpg
Closeup of pulse-width modulated Waveform 1.
Closeup of pulse-width modulated Waveform 2. Closeup of pulse-width modulated Waveform 2.jpg
Closeup of pulse-width modulated Waveform 2.

The pulse-width modulated sounds are now combined at equal volume. Combining them at different volumes would create different timbres. The result is a 2-second source sound, which is ready for subtractive synthesis.

Combined waveforms and pulse-width modulation. Combined waveforms and pulse-width modulation.jpg
Combined waveforms and pulse-width modulation.

Subtractive Synthesis

The combined wave is passed through a voltage-controlled amplifier connected to an envelope generator. The parameters of the sound's envelope (attack, decay, sustain and release) are manipulated to change its sound. In this case, the decay is vastly increased, sustain is reduced, and the release shortened. The resulting sound is audible for half as long as the source sound:

Enveloped waveform. Enveloped waveform.jpg
Enveloped waveform.

With its new envelope, the sound is run through a low-pass filter, which reduces the volume of higher overtones:

Closeup of low-pass filtered waveform. Low-pass filtered waveform.jpg
Closeup of low-pass filtered waveform.

To better emulate the sound of a plucked string, the filter's cutoff frequency is lowered.

Closeup of final waveform Final waveform.jpg
Closeup of final waveform

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Analog synthesizer</span> Synthesizer that uses analog circuits

An analog synthesizer is a synthesizer that uses analog circuits and analog signals to generate sound electronically.

Wavetable synthesis is a sound synthesis technique used to create quasi-periodic waveforms often used in the production of musical tones or notes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Roland D-50</span> Synthesizer

The Roland D-50 is a synthesizer produced by Roland and released in April of 1987. Its features include digital sample-based subtractive synthesis, on-board effects, a joystick for data manipulation, and an analog synthesis-styled layout design. The external Roland PG-1000 (1987) programmer could also be attached to the D-50 for more complex manipulation of its sounds. It was also produced in a rack-mount variant design, the D-550, with almost 450 user-adjustable parameters.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ensoniq ESQ-1</span> Synthesizer

Ensoniq ESQ-1 is a 61-key, velocity sensitive, eight-note polyphonic and multitimbral synthesizer released by Ensoniq in 1985. It was marketed as a "digital wave synthesizer" but was an early Music Workstation. Although its voice generation is typically subtractive in much the same fashion as most analog synthesizers that preceded it, its oscillators are neither voltage nor "digitally controlled", but true digital oscillators, provided by a custom Ensoniq wavetable chip. The signal path includes analog resonant low-pass filters and an analog amplifier.

The Yamaha AN1x is a DSP-based analog modeling synthesizer, produced by Yamaha Corporation from 1997 to 1998, and was marketed as an "analog physical modelling control synthesizer".

Phase distortion (PD) synthesis is a synthesis method introduced in 1984 by Casio in its CZ range of synthesizers. In outline, it is similar to phase modulation synthesis as championed by Yamaha Corporation, in the sense that both methods dynamically change the harmonic content of a carrier waveform by influence of another waveform (modulator) in the time domain. However, the application and results of the two methods are quite distinct.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Korg OASYS</span> Workstation synthesizer

The Korg OASYS is a workstation synthesizer released in early 2005, 1 year after the successful Korg Triton Extreme. Unlike the Triton series, the OASYS uses a custom Linux operating system that was designed to be arbitrarily expandable via software updates, with its functionality limited only by the PC-like hardware.

microKORG Synthesizer released in 2002

The microKORG is a MIDI-capable digital synthesizer/vocoder from Korg featuring DSP-based analog modelling. The synthesizer is built in such a way that it is essentially a Korg MS-2000 with a programmable step arpeggiator, a less advanced vocoder, lack of motion sequencing, lack of an XLR microphone input, and in a smaller case with fewer real-time control knobs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Korg MS-20</span> Patchable semi-modular monophonic analog synthesizer

The Korg MS-20 is a patchable semi-modular monophonic analog synthesizer which Korg released in 1978 and which was in production until 1983. It was part of Korg's MS series of instruments, which also included the single oscillator MS-10, the keyboardless MS-50 module, the SQ-10 sequencer, and the VC-10 Vocoder. Additional devices included the MS-01 Foot Controller, MS-02 Interface, MS-03 Signal Processor, and MS-04 Modulation Pedal.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Korg Prophecy</span> Synthesizer released in 1995

The Korg Prophecy is a monophonic synthesizer released by Korg in 1995. one of the earliest commercial DSP physical/acoustic and analog "virtual" modeling sound synthesizers and Korg's first monophonic synthesizer since the Mono/Poly. The Prophecy employs Korg's Multi Oscillator Synthesis System (MOSS), which features digital oscillators capable of emulating synthesis techniques such as analog synthesis, FM and physical modelling. Emphasized for its portability, expressiveness, and engaging playability, a distinctive feature of the Prophecy is its multifunctional Wheel 3, nicknamed the 'log'.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Palm Products GmbH</span> German electronic musical instrument manufacturer

Palm Products GmbH was a manufacturer of audio synthesizers. Founded and owned by Wolfgang Palm, PPG was located in Hamburg, Germany and, for 12 years from around 1975 to 1987, manufactured an acclaimed and eclectic range of electronic musical instruments, all designed by Palm.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Korg MS2000</span> Synthesizer released in 2000

The Korg MS2000 is a virtual analog synthesizer produced by the Japanese electronic musical instrument manufacturer Korg.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Korg Wavestation</span> Synthesizer

The Korg Wavestation is a vector synthesis synthesizer first produced in the early 1990s and later re-released as a software synthesizer in 2004. Its primary innovation was Wave Sequencing, a method of multi-timbral sound generation in which different PCM waveform data are played successively, resulting in continuously evolving sounds. The Wavestation's "Advanced Vector Synthesis" sound architecture resembled early vector synths such as the Sequential Circuits Prophet VS.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Korg DSS-1</span> Polyphonic synthesizer

The Korg DSS-1 is a polyphonic sampling synthesizer released by Korg in 1986. As Korg's initial entry into the sampling market, the DSS-1 combines sampling, additive synthesis, and waveform drawing with an analog signal path. The DSS-1 was released a time when major synthesizer manufacturers like Yamaha and Casio were beginning to explore sampling, an area of sound design dominated by companies like Fairlight, E-mu, and Ensoniq. Korg did not stay long in the sampling arena; the DSS-1 was the company's only sampler until 1998 when Korg introduced sampling options on their Triton and Trinity series of workstations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Synthesizer</span> Electronic musical instrument

A synthesizer is an electronic musical instrument that generates audio signals. Synthesizers typically create sounds by generating waveforms through methods including subtractive synthesis, additive synthesis and frequency modulation synthesis. These sounds may be altered by components such as filters, which cut or boost frequencies; envelopes, which control articulation, or how notes begin and end; and low-frequency oscillators, which modulate parameters such as pitch, volume, or filter characteristics affecting timbre. Synthesizers are typically played with keyboards or controlled by sequencers, software or other instruments and may be synchronized to other equipment via MIDI.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Korg RADIAS</span> Synthesizer introduced in 2006

The Korg RADIAS is a virtual analog synthesizer and Vocoder, released by Korg in 2006. The RADIAS' MMT engine was based on the Korg OASYS synthesizer module, providing for several different synthesis methods, two of which may be combined in a single voice e.g. phase distortion synthesis can be combined with subtractive synthesis. The different synthesis methods employed by MMT represent the majority of methods used historically in other Korg synthesizers: digital waveguide synthesis Korg first used in the Korg Z1 and phase distortion synthesis was first used in the Korg DS-8. This flexibility allows for very realistic emulations of past Korg synthesizers, though stays away from trying to emulate the Korg M1 and the Korg Wavestation,. As well as using the in-built waveforms for the basis of sound creation, the RADIAS allows for the input of an external signal which may be routed through the various sound shaping devices. The RADIAS has a comprehensive matrix modulation specification and to further enhance a sound the 'Wave Shaper' module allows for various sound distortion effects.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Korg Mono/Poly</span> Analog synthesizer, manufactured by Korg from 1981 to 1984

The Korg Mono/Poly (MP-4) is a paraphonic analog synthesizer released by Korg in 1981, bridging the gap between monophonic and polyphonic synthesis. Released in the same year as the Korg Polysix, as a complementary synth, The Mono/Poly is equipped with four VCOs and can operate as a four-voice paraphonic synth with limited capabilities, or as a monophonic synth using all four oscillators. Upon its release, it was the only monophonic synthesizer with an integrated quad-VCO design available on the market.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Korg Z1</span> Synthesizer released in 1997

The Korg Z1 is a digital synthesizer released by Korg in 1997. The Z1 built upon the foundation set by the monophonic Prophecy released two years prior by offering 12-note polyphony and featuring expanded oscillator options, a polyphonic arpeggiator and an XY touchpad for enhanced performance interaction. It was the world's first multitimbral physical modelling synthesizer.

The history of home keyboards lies in mechanical musical instrument keyboards, electrified keyboards and 1960s and 1970s synthesizer technologies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Korg miniKORG 700</span> Monophonic analogue synthesizer

The miniKORG 700 is a monophonic analog synthesizer released by Korg in 1973, marking their entry into mass-produced synthesizers and their first monophonic synthesizer. It was initially designed to be placed on top of an organ, so its controls are located below the keyboard facing towards the performer. An updated model, the miniKORG 700S, was launched in 1974, introducing a second oscillator that could be detuned, along with additional sustain and vibrato controls.

References

  1. 1 2 Réveillac, Jean-Michel. Synthesizers and Subtractive Synthesis 1. John Wiley & Sons, 2024.
  2. Iverson, Jennifer. “Fraught Adjacencies: The Politics of German Electronic Music.” Acta Musicologica, vol. 92, no. 1, 2020. 94f.
  3. Dudley, Homer, Richard R. Riesz, and Stanley S. A. Watkins. “A Synthetic Speaker.” Journal of the Franklin Institute 227, no. 6 (1939): 739–64.
  4. Manning, Peter. Electronic and Computer Music, Oxford University Press, Incorporated, 2004. 70, 158.
  5. Bates, Jon. "The History of the World: Part One, Subtractive Synthesis". Amiga Format , no. 4, 1989 Nov 01, 1989/11/01/, pp. 98.
  6. Lane, John, et al. “Modeling Analog Synthesis with DSPs.” Computer Music Journal, vol. 21, no. 4, 1997. 23.
  7. 1 2 Collins, Karen. Game Sound: An Introduction to the History, Theory, and Practice of Video Game Music and Sound Design. MIT Press. p. 10. ISBN   9780262033787.
  8. de Poli, Giovanni. “A Tutorial on Digital Sound Synthesis Techniques.” Computer Music Journal , vol. 7, no. 4, 1983. 14.
  9. Stefanakis, Nikolaos, et al. “Sound Synthesis Based on Ordinary Differential Equations.” Computer Music Journal, vol. 39, no. 3, 2015. 48.