| Year | Award Type | Designer | Production |
|---|
2010
64th Tony Awards |
Best Lighting Design
for a Play | Neil Austin | Red |
| Neil Austin | Hamlet |
| Mark Henderson | ENRON |
| Brian MacDevitt | Fences |
Best Lighting Design
for a Musical | Kevin Adams | American Idiot |
| Donald Holder | Ragtime |
| Nick Richings | La Cage aux Folles |
| Robert Wierzel | Fela! |
2011
65th Tony Awards |
Best Lighting Design
for a Play | Paule Constable | War Horse |
| David Lander | Bengal Tiger at the Baghdad Zoo |
| Kenneth Posner | The Merchant of Venice |
| Mimi Jordan Sherin | Jerusalem |
Lighting Design
for a Musical | Brian MacDevitt | The Book of Mormon |
| Ken Billington | The Scottsboro Boys |
| Howell Binkley | How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying |
| Peter Kaczorowski | Anything Goes |
2012
66th Tony Awards |
Lighting Design
for a Play | Jeff Croiter | Peter and the Starcatcher |
| Peter Kaczorowski | The Road to Mecca |
| Brian MacDevitt | Death of a Salesman |
| Kenneth Posner | Other Desert Cities |
Lighting Design
for a Musical | Natasha Katz | Once |
| Christopher Akerlind | Porgy and Bess |
| Natasha Katz | Follies |
| Hugh Vanstone | Ghost the Musical |
2013
67th Tony Awards |
Lighting Design
for a Play | Peggy Eisenhauer and Jules Fisher | Lucky Guy |
| Donald Holder | Golden Boy |
| Jennifer Tipton | The Testament of Mary |
| Japhy Weideman | The Nance |
Lighting Design
for a Musical | Hugh Vanstone | Matilda the Musical |
| Kenneth Posner | Kinky Boots |
| Pippin |
| Rodgers + Hammerstein's Cinderella |
2014
68th Tony Awards |
Lighting Design
for a Play | Natasha Katz | The Glass Menagerie |
| Paule Constable | The Cripple of Inishmaan |
| Jane Cox | Machinal |
| Japhy Weideman | Of Mice and Men |
Lighting Design
for a Musical | Kevin Adams | Hedwig and the Angry Inch |
| Christopher Akerlind | Rocky the Musical |
| Howell Binkley | After Midnight |
| Donald Holder | The Bridges of Madison County |
2015
69th Tony Awards |
Lighting Design
for a Play | Paule Constable | The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time |
| Paule Constable and David Plater | Wolf Hall Parts One & Two |
| Natasha Katz | Skylight |
| Japhy Weideman | Airline Highway |
Lighting Design
for a Musical | Natasha Katz | An American in Paris |
| Donald Holder | The King and I |
| Ben Stanton | Fun Home |
| Japhy Weideman | The Visit |
2016
70th Tony Awards |
Lighting Design
for a Play | Natasha Katz | Long Day's Journey into Night |
| Justin Townsend | The Humans |
| Jan Versweyveld | A View from the Bridge |
| The Crucible |
Lighting Design
for a Musical | Howell Binkley | Hamilton |
| Peggy Eisenhauer and Jules Fisher | Shuffle Along |
| Ben Stanton | Spring Awakening |
| Justin Townsend | American Psycho |
2017
71st Tony Awards |
Lighting Design
for a Play | Christopher Akerlind | Indecent |
| Jane Cox | Jitney |
| Donald Holder | Oslo |
| Jennifer Tipton | A Doll's House, Part 2 |
Lighting Design
for a Musical | Bradley King | Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812 |
| Howell Binkley | Come from Away |
| Natasha Katz | Hello, Dolly! |
| Japhy Weideman | Dear Evan Hansen |
2018
72nd Tony Awards |
Lighting Design
for a Play | Neil Austin | Harry Potter and the Cursed Child |
| Paule Constable | Angels in America |
| Peggy Eisenhauer and Jules Fisher | The Iceman Cometh |
| Paul Russell | Farinelli and the King |
| Ben Stanton | Junk |
Lighting Design
for a Musical | Tyler Micoleau | The Band's Visit |
| Kevin Adams | SpongeBob SquarePants |
| Peggy Eisenhauer and Jules Fisher | Once on This Island |
| Donald Holder | My Fair Lady |
| Brian MacDevitt | Carousel |
2019
73rd Tony Awards |
Lighting Design
for a Play | Neil Austin | Ink |
| Jules Fisher and Peggy Eisenhauer | Gary: A Sequel to Titus Andronicus |
| Peter Mumford | The Ferryman |
| Jennifer Tipton | To Kill a Mockingbird |
| Jan Versweyveld and Tal Yarden | Network |
Lighting Design
for a Musical | Bradley King | Hadestown |
| Kevin Adams | The Cher Show |
| Howell Binkley | Ain’t Too Proud |
| Peter Mumford | King Kong |
| Kenneth Posner and Peter Nigrini | Beetlejuice |