Bertelsmann Transformation Index

Last updated
Global trend report analyzes the results of the Bertelsmann Stiftung's Transformation Index BTI 2022. BTI 2022 DEM.jpg
Global trend report analyzes the results of the Bertelsmann Stiftung’s Transformation Index BTI 2022.

The Bertelsmann Transformation Index (BTI) is a measure of the development status and governance of political and economic transformation processes in developing and transition countries around the world. [2] [3] The BTI has been published biennially by the Bertelsmann Stiftung since 2005, [4] most recently in 2022 on 137 countries. [5] The index measures and compares the quality of government action in a ranking list based on self-recorded data and analyzes successes and setbacks on the path to constitutional democracy and a market economy accompanied by sociopolitical support. [6] For this purpose, the "Status Index" is calculated on the general level of development with regard to democratic and market-economy characteristics and the "Management Index" on the political management of decision-makers. [7] [8]

Contents

Status and Management Index

The Bertelsmann Transformation Index publishes two rankings. [9] [10] The Status Index is composed of the study dimensions Political and Economic Transformation. Political transformation includes essential features of a democratic state order. This includes participation rights, the rule of law, the stability of democratic institutions and the political and social integration of institutions, but also statehood as a basic condition for the functioning of a democracy. Economic transformation takes into account not only the classic market-economy characteristics such as economic performance, market and competition regulation, currency and price stability and the protection of private property, but also social components such as the level of socio-economic development, the social order and ecological and educational sustainability. [11]

The Management Index assesses the extent to which political decision-makers can steer and promote the transformation process. It is composed of the criteria steering capability, resource efficiency, consensus building and international cooperation. In calculating the Management Index, the degree of difficulty is taken into account, such as structural obstacles, civil society traditions and the intensity of conflict. [12]

Bertelsmann Transformation Indices by Country

The following list shows the Bertelsmann Transformation Indices since 2016. [13]

CountryStatus-Index 2022Governance-Index 2022Status-Index 2020Governance-Index 2020Status-Index 2018Governance-Index 2018Status-Index 2016Governance-Index 2016
Flag of the Taliban.svg  Afghanistan 2.924.023.214.362.954.022.953.88
Flag of Egypt.svg  Egypt 4.133.774.203.854.283.964.404.44
Flag of Albania.svg  Albania 6.686.286.845.956.836.026.715.77
Flag of Algeria.svg  Algeria 5.044.675.034.414.984.555.114.50
Flag of Angola.svg  Angola 4.214.464.164.233.943.604.163.61
Flag of Equatorial Guinea.svg  Equatorial Guinea 2.973.333.023.41----
Flag of Argentina.svg  Argentina 6.735.527.296.107.276.006.654.78
Flag of Armenia.svg  Armenia 6.434.936.695.295.584.255.564.31
Flag of Azerbaijan.svg  Azerbaijan 4.473.984.344.004.133.864.443.76
Flag of Ethiopia.svg  Ethiopia 3.574.263.824.963.333.653.553.49
Flag of Bahrain.svg  Bahrain 4.503.734.633.244.623.524.963.86
Flag of Bangladesh.svg  Bangladesh 4.824.575.054.505.114.275.394.38
Flag of Belarus.svg  Belarus 4.612.784.893.714.723.524.273.02
Flag of Benin.svg  Benin 6.085.856.436.066.435.866.285.42
Flag of Bhutan.svg  Bhutan 6.386.696.286.676.256.506.026.58
Bandera de Bolivia (Estado).svg  Bolivia 6.175.546.225.456.465.666.585.63
Flag of Bosnia and Herzegovina.svg  Bosnia and Herzegovina 5.933.786.113.806.284.096.384.10
Flag of Botswana.svg  Botswana 7.596.818.007.257.897.097.847.04
Flag of Brazil.svg  Brasil 6.834.427.155.587.295.957.606.76
Flag of Bulgaria.svg  Bulgaria 7.465.877.766.187.805.987.916.02
Flag of Burkina Faso.svg  Burkina Faso 5.105.245.355.235.455.204.714.92
Flag of Burundi.svg  Burundi 3.383.253.493.233.973.294.364.07
Flag of Chile.svg  Chile 8.747.158.867.338.877.338.777.51
Flag of the People's Republic of China.svg  China 4.945.295.044.715.024.794.954.73
Flag of Costa Rica.svg  Costa Rica 8.377.138.496.928.496.858.496.93
Flag of Cote d'Ivoire.svg  Ivory Coast 4.975.405.495.455.385.545.095.13
Flag of the Dominican Republic.svg  Dominican Republic 6.325.846.365.756.445.576.445.69
Flag of Djibouti.svg  Djibouti 4.125.174.165.10----
Flag of Ecuador.svg  Ecuador 6.234.886.485.225.724.995.554.48
Flag of El Salvador.svg  El Salvador 6.465.636.806.546.886.576.906.79
Flag of Eritrea.svg  Eritrea 1.681.121.701.201.841.131.711.13
Flag of Estonia.svg  Estonia 9.477.029.547.469.527.449.497.40
Flag of Eswatini.svg  Eswatini 3.563.063.513.11----
Flag of Gabon.svg  Gabon 4.834.534.894.86----
Flag of The Gambia.svg  Gambia 5.925.735.845.98----
Flag of Georgia.svg  Georgia 6.005.556.395.836.425.876.315.72
Flag of Ghana.svg  Ghana 6.796.236.716.266.756.186.886.41
Flag of Guatemala.svg  Guatemala 4.503.364.473.585.084.525.134.62
Flag of Guinea.svg  Guinea 4.605.075.335.985.285.825.085.83
Flag of Guinea-Bissau.svg  Guinea-Bissau 5.014.305.324.60----
Flag of Haiti.svg  Haiti 3.342.943.593.333.503.393.463.44
Flag of Honduras.svg  Honduras 4.714.004.944.335.514.985.945.56
Flag of India.svg  India 5.885.156.705.926.966.026.966.16
Flag of Indonesia.svg  Indonesia 6.145.176.285.396.255.456.475.58
Flag of Iraq.svg  Iraq 3.804.954.045.003.754.433.534.26
Flag of Iran.svg  Iran 2.831.702.831.793.152.852.982.73
Flag of Jamaica.svg  Jamaica 7.195.797.295.867.315.867.205.99
Flag of Yemen.svg  Yemen 1.411.511.521.631.721.702.913.82
Flag of Jordan.svg  Jordan 4.984.845.144.845.224.845.094.74
Flag of Cambodia.svg  Cambodia 3.863.054.003.144.003.234.123.42
Flag of Cameroon.svg  Cameroon 4.113.954.083.564.233.464.263.63
Flag of Kazakhstan.svg  Kazakhstan 4.914.564.914.544.704.414.884.27
Flag of Qatar.svg  Qatar 5.866.175.905.465.885.406.015.33
Flag of Kenya.svg  Kenya 5.334.845.164.485.804.925.805.00
Flag of Kyrgyzstan (2023).svg  Kyrgyzstan 5.494.425.874.565.904.735.714.78
Flag of Colombia.svg  Colombia 6.455.246.675.716.596.146.656.13
Flag of the Democratic Republic of the Congo.svg  Democratic Republic of the Congo 3.242.653.172.583.132.473.092.76
Flag of the Republic of the Congo.svg  Republic of the Congo 3.322.933.362.933.383.003.583.43
Flag of Kosovo.svg  Kosovo 6.335.456.205.216.215.176.335.19
Flag of Croatia.svg  Croatia 8.135.987.916.048.076.077.936.39
Flag of Cuba.svg  Cuba 3.704.463.773.954.023.934.154.12
Flag of Kuwait.svg  Kuwait 5.794.865.944.525.614.375.854.29
Flag of Laos.svg  Laos 3.734.233.883.963.853.893.833.68
Flag of Lesotho.svg  Lesotho 5.053.845.033.585.193.595.334.04
Flag of Latvia.svg  Latvia 8.807.118.757.008.687.008.636.97
Flag of Lebanon.svg  Lebanon 4.683.055.363.985.153.605.743.95
Flag of Liberia.svg  Liberia 5.285.015.485.365.565.845.546.16
Flag of Libya.svg  Libya 2.432.452.532.312.602.292.642.47
Flag of Lithuania.svg  Lithuania 9.277.219.307.189.247.189.157.19
Flag of Madagascar.svg  Madagascar 4.504.945.045.385.015.124.974.86
Flag of Malawi.svg  Malawi 5.475.645.414.695.495.615.555.63
Flag of Malaysia.svg  Malaysia 6.245.156.575.716.005.206.215.46
Flag of Mali.svg  Mali 4.364.665.065.195.145.175.185.40
Flag of Morocco.svg  Morocco 4.774.844.704.404.614.284.604.37
Flag of Mauritania.svg  Mauritania 4.304.004.224.004.224.064.354.20
Flag of Mauritius.svg  Mauritius 8.176.768.266.738.256.648.096.74
Flag of Mexico.svg  Mexico 6.014.696.205.026.235.176.405.34
Flag of Moldova.svg  Moldova 5.914.995.784.875.965.156.245.31
Flag of Mongolia.svg  Mongolia 6.455.906.655.876.595.966.615.83
Flag of Montenegro.svg  Montenegro 6.966.237.216.637.356.497.486.46
Flag of Mozambique.svg  Mozambique 4.114.214.244.414.314.255.235.00
Flag of Myanmar.svg  Myanmar 3.203.533.283.593.383.972.984.20
Flag of Namibia.svg  Namibia 6.495.076.465.156.505.497.056.15
Flag of Nepal.svg  Nepal 5.234.465.214.344.523.744.744.05
Flag of Nicaragua.svg  Nicaragua 4.062.454.342.775.144.225.534.92
Flag of Niger.svg  Niger 4.905.105.015.235.135.875.405.94
Flag of Nigeria.svg  Nigeria 3.913.954.694.044.604.594.884.06
Flag of North Korea.svg  North Korea 2.041.222.111.372.161.302.141.22
Flag of North Macedonia.svg  North Macedonia 7.376.307.176.226.765.246.865.74
Flag of Oman.svg  Oman 4.303.784.223.524.433.544.753.67
Flag of Pakistan.svg  Pakistan 3.893.483.963.544.013.513.903.32
Flag of Panama.svg  Panama 6.585.356.945.397.115.727.325.91
Flag of Papua New Guinea.svg  Papua New Guinea 5.124.745.415.705.584.785.364.77
Flag of Paraguay.svg  Paraguay 6.295.776.325.856.246.046.386.14
Flag of Peru.svg  Peru 6.565.776.835.796.855.816.865.40
Flag of the Philippines.svg  Philippines 5.594.316.094.896.474.906.535.22
Flag of Poland.svg  Poland 7.935.308.156.158.586.259.237.22
Flag of Romania.svg  Romania 7.755.584.805.214.805.204.835.10
Flag of Russia.svg  Russia 5.273.487.654.838.065.898.065.84
Flag of Rwanda.svg  Rwanda 4.655.255.303.475.313.525.063.17
Flag of Zambia.svg  Zambia 4.343.915.164.775.455.065.705.19
Flag of Saudi Arabia.svg  Saudi Arabia 4.393.994.333.544.273.804.263.82
Flag of Senegal.svg  Senegal 5.976.716.056.686.186.706.116.65
Flag of Serbia.svg  Serbia 6.484.896.945.787.406.067.436.38
Flag of Sierra Leone.svg  Sierra Leone 5.094.785.294.875.154.935.375.35
Flag of Zimbabwe.svg  Zimbabwe 3.392.723.683.193.332.373.832.71
Flag of Singapore.svg  Singapore 7.056.967.075.957.155.957.175.96
Flag of Slovakia.svg  Slovakia 8.776.538.726.368.596.708.756.96
Flag of Slovenia.svg  Slovenia 8.906.209.276.729.186.789.016.47
Flag of Somalia.svg  Somalia 1.542.411.382.431.342.251.382.08
Flag of Sri Lanka.svg  Sri Lanka 6.044.806.585.456.615.605.584.55
Flag of South Africa.svg  South Africa 6.786.106.806.256.965.967.056.14
Flag of Sudan.svg  Sudan 2.453.052.061.482.281.972.442.02
Flag of South Korea.svg  South Korea 8.516.798.666.658.556.518.576.89
Flag of South Sudan.svg  South Sudan 2.302.152.262.152.272.302.822.99
Flag of Syria.svg  Syria 1.541.211.761.221.571.131.801.20
Flag of Tajikistan.svg  Tajikistan 3.213.203.323.343.313.313.603.27
Flag of the Republic of China.svg  Taiwan 9.487.649.497.379.427.339.537.48
Flag of Tanzania.svg  Tanzania 4.884.435.494.475.515.075.585.14
Flag of Thailand.svg  Thailand 4.984.024.814.024.713.894.793.93
Flag of East Timor.svg  East Timor 6.095.786.155.93----
Flag of Togo.svg  Togo 4.794.934.794.964.895.104.704.84
Flag of Trinidad and Tobago.svg  Trinidad and Tobago 7.436.097.496.02----
Flag of Chad.svg  Chad 3.072.633.152.553.312.843.502.79
Flag of the Czech Republic.svg  Czechia 9.316.649.577.089.527.039.406.85
Flag of Tunisia.svg  Tunisia 6.265.336.385.436.275.336.155.33
Flag of Turkey.svg  Turkey 5.453.985.514.056.174.727.306.06
Flag of Turkmenistan.svg  Turkmenistan 2.672.192.712.323.142.513.392.41
Flag of Uganda.svg  Uganda 5.144.895.425.145.665.316.195.70
Flag of Ukraine.svg  Ukraine 6.765.316.815.526.545.416.055.02
Flag of Hungary.svg  Hungary 6.623.866.994.137.434.447.694.67
Flag of Uruguay.svg  Uruguay 9.127.399.167.339.197.369.267.56
Flag of Uzbekistan.svg  Uzbekistan 4.153.834.083.633.732.553.401.95
Flag of Venezuela.svg  Venezuela 2.651.442.771.293.471.864.041.87
Flag of the United Arab Emirates.svg  United Arab Emirates 6.016.385.955.356.075.556.055.36
Flag of Vietnam.svg  Vietnam 4.855.334.824.734.414.514.724.85
Flag of the Central African Republic.svg  Central African Republic 3.113.813.284.083.284.102.894.28

Method of calculation

The Status and Management Index is composed of a modular system of investigation dimensions (2nd level), criteria (3rd level) and indicators (4th level). [14]

Country selection

All developing and transition countries with more than one million inhabitants are examined. Developing and transition countries are those countries that are not considered to be democratically and market-economically consolidated. In the absence of a concretely applicable definition of the consolidation limit, OECD membership prior to 1989 is used as a consolidation criterion.

In exceptional cases, countries with less than one million inhabitants (Bhutan, Djibouti and Montenegro) are also examined. From 2003 to 2022, the number of countries surveyed has increased from 116 to 137. [15]

Survey procedure

The reports and assessments of each study, involving some 250 country experts, are based on a multi-stage survey and review process. The aim of the procedure is to arrive at results that are as objective and comparable as possible. Two experts per country - usually one international and one local expert - prepare and review qualitative country analyses on the basis of 49 standardized questions and translate the answers independently of each other into quantitative assessments. On this basis, seven regional coordinators standardise the results intra- and interregionally. A scientific advisory board of transformation experts monitors and discusses the results and adopts the final values.

The prototype of the BTI was published in 2003 and subsequently methodologically revised. [16] Since then, no fundamental methodological changes have taken place, so that comparable time series since 2006 can be formed.

Publications

The study results are published in the form of country [17] and regional reports [18] and a book series in English and partly in German. Initiated and financed by foreign think tanks, BTI study content has also been published in other languages: in Arabic by the Gulf Research Center in 2009, in Russian by the Moscow Center for Post-Industrial Studies in 2010 and in Spanish by the Argentinean Centro para la Apertura y el Desarrollo de América Latina in 2014. The BTI Atlas, a graphics application, offers individual visual access to the results and reports of all editions since 2006.

Use

The Bertelsmann Transformation Index is used both by governments around the world to assess partner countries and by international organizations to produce their own analyses. [19] Transparency International's Corruption Perceptions Index and the Ibrahim Index of African Governance are based in part on BTI results.

The sister project Sustainable Governance Indicators, which is methodologically modelled on the BTI, examines the reform capacity and sustainability of advanced democracies and market economies. The study covers all OECD and EU member states, including the OECD core countries not included in the BTI.

Related Research Articles

Governance is the process of making and enforcing decisions within an organization or society. It encompasses decision-making, rule-setting, and enforcement mechanisms to guide the functioning of an organization or society. Effective governance is essential for maintaining order, achieving objectives, and addressing the needs of the community or members within the organization. Furthermore, effective governance promotes transparency, fosters trust among stakeholders, and adapts to changing circumstances, ensuring the organization or society remains responsive and resilient in achieving its goals. It is the process of interactions through the laws, social norms, power or language as structured in communication of an organized society over a social system. It is done by the government of a state, by a market, or by a network. It is the process of choosing the right course among the actors involved in a collective problem that leads to the creation, reinforcement, or reproduction of acceptable conduct and social order". In lay terms, it could be described as the processes that exist in and between formal institutions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gross National Happiness</span> Guiding philosophy of the government of Bhutan

Gross National Happiness, sometimes called Gross Domestic Happiness (GDH), is a philosophy that guides the government of Bhutan. It includes an index which is used to measure the collective happiness and well-being of a population. Gross National Happiness Index is instituted as the goal of the government of Bhutan in the Constitution of Bhutan, enacted on 18 July 2008.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development</span> Ministry of the Federal Republic of Germany

The Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development, abbreviated BMZ, is a cabinet-level ministry of the Federal Republic of Germany. Its main office is at the former German Chancellery in Bonn with a second major office at the Europahaus in Berlin.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aart Jan de Geus</span> Dutch politician and businessman

Aart Jan de Geus is a retired Dutch politician of the Christian Democratic Appeal (CDA) party and businessman. He served as Minister of Labor and Social Affairs from 2002 to 2007. Then he worked as Deputy Secretary-General for the OECD. From 2012 to 2019, De Geus was Chairman and CEO of the Bertelsmann Stiftung. Since January 2020, he has been Chairman of the Goldschmeding Foundation.

The Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH, often simply shortened to GIZ, is the main German development agency. It is headquartered in Bonn and Eschborn and provides services in the field of international development cooperation and international education work. The organization's self-declared goal is to deliver effective solutions that offer people better prospects and sustainably improve their living conditions.

<i>The Economist Democracy Index</i> Measure of the state of democracy

The Democracy Index published by the Economist Group is an index measuring the quality of democracy across the world. This quantitative and comparative assessment is centrally concerned with democratic rights and democratic institutions. The methodology for assessing democracy used in this democracy index is according to Economist Intelligence Unit which is part of the Economist Group, a UK-based private company, which publishes the weekly newspaper The Economist. The index is based on 60 indicators grouped into five categories, measuring pluralism, civil liberties, and political culture. In addition to a numeric score and a ranking, the index categorizes each country into one of four regime types: full democracies, flawed democracies, hybrid regimes, and authoritarian regimes. The first Democracy Index report was published in 2006. Reports were published every two years until 2010 and annually thereafter. The index includes 167 countries and territories, of which 166 are sovereign states and 164 are UN member states. Other democracy indices with similar assessments of the state of democracy include V-Dem Democracy indices or Bertelsmann Transformation Index.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bertelsmann Stiftung</span> German independent foundation

The Bertelsmann Stiftung is an independent foundation under private law, based in Gütersloh, Germany. It was founded in 1977 by Reinhard Mohn as the result of social, corporate and fiscal considerations. As the Bertelsmann Stiftung itself has put it, the foundation promotes "reform processes" and "the principles of entrepreneurial activity" to build a "future-oriented society."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Legatum Prosperity Index</span> Annual ranking of countries by Legatum

The Legatum Prosperity Index is an annual ranking developed by the Legatum Institute, an independent educational charity founded and part-funded by the private investment firm Legatum. The ranking is based on a variety of factors including wealth, economic growth, education, health, personal well-being, and quality of life.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ibrahim Index of African Governance</span> Annual assessment of African countries

The Ibrahim Index of African Governance (IIAG), established in 2007, provides an assessment of the quality of governance in African countries. The IIAG is compiled by 81 indicators and 265 variables from 54 data projects, coming from 47 independent African and international data sources. Published every two years, the IIAG is one of the world’s most comprehensive collections of data on African governance.

The Sustainable Governance Indicators (SGI), first published in spring 2009 and updated in 2011, analyze and compare the need for reform in Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) member countries, as well as each country's ability to respond to current social and political challenges. The project is designed to create a comprehensive data pool on government-related activities in the countries considered the world's most developed free-market democracies. In addition, it uses international comparisons to provide evidence-based input for reform-related public discourse taking place in these countries. The SGI are updated every two or three years.

Canada ranks among the highest in international measurements of government transparency, civil liberties, quality of life, economic freedom, education levels, gender equality, public services, public security and environmental sustainability. It ranks among the lowest of the most developed countries for housing affordability, healthcare services and foreign direct investment.

The development of the European Lifelong Learning Indicators (ELLI) is an initiative of the non-profit Bertelsmann Stiftung to monitor the state of lifelong learning in Europe. The main focus of the ELLI project is the ELLI Index. The ELLI index is an annually updated composite indicator summarizing the state of lifelong learning for European countries. The ELLI IT platform is an online portal that provides access to regional data related to learning and socio-economic outcomes in Europe.

A hybrid regime is a type of political system often created as a result of an incomplete democratic transition from an authoritarian regime to a democratic one. Hybrid regimes are categorized as having a combination of autocratic features with democratic ones and can simultaneously hold political repressions and regular elections. Hybrid regimes are commonly found in developing countries with abundant natural resources such as petro-states. Although these regimes experience civil unrest, they may be relatively stable and tenacious for decades at a time. There has been a rise in hybrid regimes since the end of the Cold War.

The International Non-Profit Credit Rating Agency was a project to reform the assessment of states' creditworthiness. It was intended to serve as a non-profit alternative to the commercially oriented rating agencies. To improve the quality of the ratings, socio-economic indicators were taken into account in addition to macroeconomic factors. INCRA was presented in 2012 by the Bertelsmann Foundation and the Bertelsmann Stiftung.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Julio C. Teehankee</span> Filipino political scientist

Julio Cabral Teehankee is a Filipino political scientist. He is Full Professor of Political Science and International Studies at De La Salle University (DLSU) where he served as Chair of the Political Science Department (1994–2007); Chair of the International Studies Department (2008–2013); and Dean of the College of Liberal Arts (2013–2017).

Government competitiveness is a state capacity concept created by Tobin Im, a scholar of public administration and a professor at the Graduate School of Public Administration at Seoul National University. Since 2011, Center for Government Competitiveness (CGC) at Seoul National University has developed the Government Competitiveness (GC) index which evaluates government achievements in the various fields and furthermore provides policy recommendations to increase competitiveness of government in the future.

North Korea ranks as the third least democratic country in the world in the Economist Intelligence Unit's Democracy Index, while The Heritage Foundation and The Wall Street Journal's Index of Economic Freedom places the country as the one with least economic freedom. According to the Press Freedom Index, North Korea has the least free press in the world.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Agrarian Party of Turkmenistan</span> Political party in Turkmenistan

The Agrarian Party of Turkmenistan is a registered political party in Turkmenistan, founded on September 28, 2014.

Democracy indices are quantitative and comparative assessments of the state of democracy for different countries according to various definitions of democracy.

A social justice index is a set of numbers which have been calculated through weighing several indicators of various entities, usually countries, but also regions or commercial firms. These indicators are considered related to social justice.

References

  1. "Global Dashboard". BTI 2022. Retrieved Apr 17, 2023.
  2. Bogaards, Matthijs (2005). "Dominant Parties and Democratic Defects". Georgetown Journal of International Affairs. 6 (2). Georgetown University Press: 29–35. ISSN   1526-0054. JSTOR   43134090 . Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  3. "The Bertelsmann Stiftung's Transformation Index (BTI)". UNESCO. 2023-04-22. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  4. Møller, Jørgen; Skaaning, Svend-Erik (2010). "Beyond the Radial Delusion: Conceptualizing and Measuring Democracy and Non-democracy". International Political Science Review. 31 (3). Sage Publications: 261–283. doi: 10.1177/0192512110369522 . ISSN   0192-5121. JSTOR   25703866. S2CID   145327844.
  5. "Governance Report". BTI 2022. Retrieved Apr 17, 2023.
  6. "Democracy data: how do researchers measure democracy?". Our World in Data. 2022-06-17. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  7. "Who We Are". BTI Blog. Retrieved 2020-07-10.
  8. Observatory, the Global (2012-09-19). "Catalogue of Indices". IPI Global Observatory. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  9. "Guides: Political Science: Democratization". Guides at Middlebury College. 2014-03-05. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  10. Jeremic, V.; Radojicic, Z.; Dobrota, M. (2016). Emerging Trends in the Development and Application of Composite Indicators. Advances in Data Mining and Database Management (2327-1981). IGI Global. p. 151. ISBN   978-1-5225-0715-4 . Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  11. Kaufmann, D.; Kraay, A.; Mastruzzi, M.; Growth, W.B.D.R.G.M.; Institute, W.B. (2006). Governance Matters V: Aggregate and Individual Governance Indicators for 1996-2005. Policy research working papers. World Bank, Development Research Group, Macroeconomics and Growth Team, and the World Bank Institute. p. 49. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  12. "FAQ". BTI Blog. Retrieved 2020-07-10.
  13. "Bertelsmann Transformation Index Methodology". BTI Website. Retrieved 2023-05-26.
  14. Stiftung, B. (2022). Transformation Index BTI 2022: Governance in International Comparison. Verlag Bertelsmann Stiftung. ISBN   978-3-86793-939-3 . Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  15. "Country selection". BTI Methodology. Retrieved 2022-08-01.
  16. "News and Notes". Journal of Democracy. Retrieved 2023-04-22.
  17. "Länderberichte: Transformationsindex". 2014-08-05. Archived from the original on 2014-08-05. Retrieved 2020-07-10.
  18. Welle (www.dw.com), Deutsche. "Is Bangladesh becoming an autocracy? | DW | 27.03.2018". DW.COM. Retrieved 2020-07-10.
  19. BMZ, Bundesministerium für wirtschaftliche Zusammenarbeit und Entwicklung. "Wie "misst" man Good Governance?". Bundesministerium für wirtschaftliche Zusammenarbeit und Entwicklung (in German). Retrieved 2020-07-10.