Eleutherornis

Last updated

Eleutherornis
Temporal range: Lutetian
Eleutherornis.png
E. cotei material from Switzerland
Scientific classification OOjs UI icon edit-ltr.svg
Domain: Eukaryota
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Class: Aves
Order: Cariamiformes
Family: Eleutherornithidae
Genus: Eleutherornis
Schaub, 1940
Species:
E. cotei
Binomial name
Eleutherornis cotei
(Gaillard, 1936)
Synonyms
  • Diatryma coteiGaillard 1936
  • Eleutherornis helveticusSchaub 1940

Eleutherornis cotei is an extinct flightless predatory cariamiform bird which lived during the Middle Eocene of France and Switzerland. Since the early 20th century, researchers have initially described the fossils of Eleutherornis as separate taxa, some remains as a species of Gastornis and others as an ancient ratite related to modern ostriches. However, subsequent analyses have questioned the original interpretations, and a thorough reexamination in 2013 indicated that all of these described remains represent the same species.

Contents

It is estimated that Eleutherornis is a relatively tall bird that could grow up to 1.5 metres (4.9 ft) in total height. Paleontologists now agree that Eleutherornis certainly belongs to the order Cariamiformes, which includes the modern seriemas and the extinct Phorusrhacidae, a group of flightless predatory birds mainly known from the Americas. This makes Eleutherornis a relative of the phorusrhacids, with some researchers even suggesting that Eleutherornis is a European member of this group, though this claim has been disputed by others and additional material may be required for confirmation.

History of discovery

Location of E. cotei finds Eleutherornis find locations.png
Location of E. cotei finds

The phalanges of Eleutherornis was first reported from Switzerland in Egerkingen by Schaub back in 1929, but he only classified them as Aves incertae sedis. [1] [2] From 1936 to 1937, Gaillard described the current type specimen of this taxon from France near Listeu, a municipality of the metropolis of Lyon, under the binomial name Diatryma cotei as a possible species of Gastornis (formerly Diatryma), and suggested that the phalanges reported by Schaub in 1929 resembles this species. [3] [4] [2] In 1940, Schaub named Eleutherornis helveticus based on bird fossils from Switzerland which he considered as a ratite. [5] In 1951, Wetmore placed Eleutherornis within its own family Eleutherornithidae under the order Struthioniformes, [6] and the other putative ratite Proceriavis martini was also tentatively placed as a member of this family in 1979. [7]

Subsequent analyses questioned the original interpretations, with D.? cotei considered as Aves incertae sedis outside the genus Gastornis, and with E. helveticus considered as a non-struthiform and a possible phorusrhacid instead. [8] [9] In 2009, the German paleontologist Gerald Mayr suggested that both D? cotei and E. helveticus are neognaths and they possibly belong the same clade, while considering the putative ratite affinities of Proceriavis to be uncertain. [10] This was confirmed through the reexaminations and comparisons of the specimens by Angst and colleagues in 2013, who considered both D? cotei and E. helveticus to represent the same species based on virtually identical material and recombined the name of the taxon as Eleutherornis cotei. [2]

Description

E. cotei material from France Eleutherornis cotei.png
E. cotei material from France

Eleutherornis is the last known giant bird of Europe during the Paleogene, [11] which stood up to 1.5 metres (4.9 ft) tall, roughly around the size of Patagornis . [2] Its specimens show a combination of basal and derivative characters. Tarchlea of tarsometatarsus II is enlarged in its middle part as in psilopterines, while the pre-acetabulary of the ilium is more compressed laterally and more ventilated with neural spines of the synsacral vertebrae than in psilopterines, and thus recalls the more evolved phorusrchacids. Ungual phalanges are less compressed laterally and have a more developed flexor tubercle than those of the other cariamiform bird, Strigogyps. [2]

Classification

Angst and colleagues suggested that Eleutherornis is potentially the only known phorusrhacid in Europe and one of the few possible members of this family outside the Americas along with Lavocatavis . [2] [12] Gerald Mayr suggested that Eleutherornis more closely resembles other cariamiforms Strigogyps and ?Dynamopterus anthracinus , while Lavocatavis is likely more related to a possible paleognath Eremopezus , questioning the taxonomic placement of both taxa as phorusrhacids. [13] [14] Buffetaut and Angst, who previously assigned this taxon to phorusrhacids, criticized Mayr's classification in 2021 for his claim not being based on substantial morphological evidence, and that Eleutherornis is likely Phorusrhacidae incertae sedis. [15]

Because the known fossils are fragmentary, definitive phylogenetic classification cannot be conducted, and Mayr still suggested that it is likely closer to Strigogyps in 2022, based on a biogeographical viewpoint and a morphological similarity of the tarsometatarsus and curved ungual phalanges from both taxa. [16] While tentatively classified as a phorusrhacid in their 2024 study, LaBarge, Garderner and Organ excluded both Eleutherornis and Lavocatavis from phylogenetic analysis and considered their identity as phorusrhacids highly questionable. [17]

Related Research Articles

<i>Gastornis</i> Extinct genus of birds

Gastornis is an extinct genus of large, flightless birds that lived during the mid-Paleocene to mid-Eocene epochs of the Paleogene period. Fossils have been found in Europe, Asia and North America, with the North American specimens formerly assigned to the genus Diatryma.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Phorusrhacidae</span> Extinct family of flightless birds

Phorusrhacids, colloquially known as terror birds, are an extinct family of large carnivorous, mostly flightless birds that were among the largest apex predators in South America during the Cenozoic era. Their definitive fossil records range from the Middle Eocene to the Late Pleistocene around 43 to 0.1 million years ago, though some specimens suggest that they were present since the Early Eocene.

<i>Andalgalornis</i> Extinct genus of birds

Andalgalornis is a genus of flightless predatory birds of the extinct family Phorusrhacidae that lived in Argentina. The type and only species is A. steulleti.

<i>Brontornis</i> Extinct genus of birds

Brontornis is an extinct genus of giant bird that inhabited Argentina during the Early to Middle Miocene. Its taxonomic position is highly controversial, with authors alternatively considering it to be a cariamiform, typically a phorusrhacid or an anserimorph.

<i>Strigogyps</i> Extinct genus of birds in the familie Ameghinornithidae

Strigogyps is an extinct genus of prehistoric bird from the Middle Eocene to Early Oligocene of France and Germany. It was probably around the size of a large chicken or a guan, weighing not quite 1 kilogram (2.2 lb). Apparently, as indicated by the ratio of lengths of wing to leg bones, S. sapea was flightless. Its legs were not adapted to running, so it seems to have had a walking lifestyle similar to trumpeters. Unlike other Cariamiformes which appear to have been mostly carnivorous, the specimens of one species, Strigogyps sapea, suggest a facultatively herbivorous or omnivorous diet.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sophiornithidae</span> Extinct family of birds

The Sophiornithidae are an extinct family of chicken-sized predatory birds that lived from the Paleocene to the Eocene periods of the Cenozoic, and were found primarily in Europe, and are thought to be primitive owls.

<i>Palaeotis</i> Extinct genus of birds

Palaeotis is a genus of paleognath birds from the middle Eocene epoch of central Europe. One species is known, Palaeotis weigelti. The holotype specimen is a fossil tarsometatarsus and phalanx. Lambrect (1928) described it as an extinct bustard, and gave it its consequent name. After a suggestion by Storrs L. Olson, a review of the type specimen and the referral of several other fossils by Houde and Haubold (1987) concluded that Palaeotis is a palaeognath and assigned it to the same order as ostriches; the Struthioniformes. In 2021, it was considered a member of the family Paleotididae alongside Galligeranoides from the Early Eocene of France, which were found to be basal members of the Struthioniformes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bird ichnology</span>

Bird ichnology is the study of avian life traces in ornithology and paleontology. Such life traces can include footprints, nests, feces and coproliths. Scientists gain insight about the behavior and diversity of birds by studying such evidence.

<i>Patagornis</i> Extinct genus of birds

Patagornis is a genus of extinct flightless predatory birds of the family Phorusrhacidae. Known as "terror birds", these lived in what is now Argentina during the Early and Middle Miocene; the Santa Cruz Formation in Patagonia contains numerous specimens. Patagornis was an agile, medium sized Patagornithine and was likely a pursuit predator.

<i>Procariama</i> Extinct genus of birds

Procariama is an extinct monotypic genus of phorusrhacid, which lived from the Late Miocene to the Late Pliocene of Argentina. Fossils of the animal have been found in six places, in the Cerro Azul and Andalhuala Formations. More specifically in the Andagalá department and in the north of the Belén department of the Catamarca province, with a single location in the La Pampa province. The type and only species, Procariama simplex, is the largest member of the subfamily Psilopterinae.

Macrodontopteryx is a genus of the prehistoric pseudotooth birds of somewhat doubtful validity. These animals were probably rather close relatives of either pelicans and storks, or of waterfowl, and are here placed in the order Odontopterygiformes to account for this uncertainty.

Lavocatavis is an extinct genus of prehistoric bird from the Eocene of Algeria. A fossilized femur was described from the Glib Zegdou Formation in 2011 and is the only known specimen of Lavocatavis. The species was designated L. africana.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cariamiformes</span> Order of birds

Cariamiformes is an order of primarily flightless birds that has existed for over 50 million years. The group includes the family Cariamidae (seriemas) and the extinct families such as Phorusrhacidae, Bathornithidae, Idiornithidae and Ameghinornithidae. Extant members (seriemas) are only known from South America, but fossils of many extinct taxa are also found in other continents including Europe and North America. Though traditionally considered a suborder within Gruiformes, both morphological and genetic studies show that it belongs to a separate group of birds, Australaves, whose other living members are Falconidae, Psittaciformes and Passeriformes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Australaves</span> Clade of birds

Australaves is a recently defined clade of birds, consisting of the Eufalconimorphae as well as the Cariamiformes. They appear to be the sister group of Afroaves.

Remiornis heberti is an extinct species of paleognath bird from the Paleocene of France. It is a species comparable in size to modern rheas, and possibly related to another European Paleogene ratite, Palaeotis. In spite of being one of the oldest ratites in the world, it is often ignored for Gondwana vicariance narratives.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bathornithidae</span> Extinct family of birds

Bathornithidae is an extinct family of birds from the Eocene to Miocene of North America. Part of Cariamiformes, they are related to the still extant seriemas and the extinct Phorusrhacidae. They were likely similar in habits, being terrestrial, long-legged predators, some of which attained massive sizes.

Paracrax is a genus of extinct North American flightless birds, possibly related to modern seriemas and the extinct terror birds. Part of Bathornithidae, it is a specialised member of this group, being cursorial carnivores much like their South American cousins, some species attaining massive sizes.

<i>Bathornis</i> Extinct genus of birds

Bathornis is an extinct lineage of birds related to modern day seriemas, that lived in North America about 37–20 million years ago. Like the closely related and also extinct phorusrhacids, it was a flightless predator, occupying predatory niches in environments classically considered to be dominated by mammals. It was a highly diverse and successful genus, spanning a large number of species that occurred from the Priabonian Eocene to the Burdigalian Miocene epochs.

Elaphrocnemus is a genus of extinct bird from the Eocene and Oligocene periods of Europe. Part of Cariamiformes, its closest living relatives are seriemas, though it differs significantly from them, being a better flyer.

Geranoididae is a clade of extinct birds from the early to late Eocene and possibly early Oligocene of North America and Europe. These were mid-sized, long-legged flightless birds. Recent research shows that these birds may actually be palaeognaths related to ostriches.

References

  1. Schaub S (1929). "Über eocäne Ratitenrste in der osteologischen Sammlung des Basler Museums". Verhandlungen Naturforschenden Gesllschaft Basel. 40: 588–598.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Angst, D.; Buffetaut, E.; Lécuyer, C.; Amiot, R. (2013). ""Terror Birds" (Phorusrhacidae) from the Eocene of Europe Imply Trans-Tethys Dispersal". PLOS ONE. 8 (11): e80357. Bibcode:2013PLoSO...880357A. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0080357 . PMC   3842325 . PMID   24312212.
  3. Gaillard, C. (1936). "Un oiseau géant dans les dépôts éocènes du Mont-d'Or lyonnais". Comptes Rendus de l'Académie des Sciences. 202: 965–967.
  4. Gaillard, C. (1937). "Un oiseau géant dans les dépôts éocènes du Mont-d'Or lyonnais". Annales de la Société Linnéenne de Lyon. 80: 111–126.
  5. Schaub, S. (1940). "Ein Ratitenbecken aus dem Bohnerz von Egerkingen". Eclogae Geologicae Helvetiae. 33: 274–284.
  6. Wetmore, A. (1951). "A revised classification for the birds of the world" (PDF). Smithsonian Miscellaneous Collections. 117 (4): 1–22.
  7. Harrison, C.J.O.; Walker. C.A. (1979). "Birds of the British Lower Oligocene". Studies in Tertiary avian paleontology. Vol. 5. Tertiary Research Special Paper. pp. 29–43.
  8. Olson, Storrs L. (1985). "The Fossil Record of Birds" (PDF). Avian Biology. Academic Press. pp. 79–238.
  9. Mlikovsky, J. (2002). Cenozoic Birds of the World Part 1: Europe (PDF). Praha: NINOX Press.
  10. Mayr, G. (2009). "Palaeognathous Birds". Paleogene Fossil Birds (PDF). Springer Cham. pp. 25–33. ISBN   978-3540896272.
  11. Pérez-Pueyo M, Cruzado-Caballero P, Moreno-Azanza M, Vila B, Castanera D, Gasca JM, Puértolas-Pascual E, Bádenas B, Canudo JI (2021). "First record of a giant bird (Ornithuromorpha) from the uppermost Maastrichtian of the Southern Pyrenees, northeast Spain". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 41 (1): e1900210. Bibcode:2021JVPal..41E0210P. doi:10.1080/02724634.2021.1900210. S2CID   235506488.
  12. Mourer-Chauviré, Cécile; Tabuce, Rodolphe; Mahboubi, M’hammed; Adaci, Mohammed; Bensalah, Mustapha (2011-08-28). "A Phororhacoid bird from the Eocene of Africa". Naturwissenschaften. 98 (10): 815–823. Bibcode:2011NW.....98..815M. doi:10.1007/s00114-011-0829-5. ISSN   1432-1904. PMID   21874523. S2CID   19805809.
  13. Mayr, G. (2017). "Cariamiforms and Diurnal Birds of Prey". Avian Evolution: The Fossil Record of Birds and its Paleobiological Significance. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell. pp. 189–204. ISBN   978-1119020769.
  14. Mayr, G. (2020). "An updated review of the middle Eocene avifauna from the Geiseltal (Germany), with comments on the unusual taphonomy of some bird remains". Geobios. 62: 45–59. doi:10.1016/j.geobios.2020.06.011.
  15. Buffetaut, Eric; Angst, Delphine (June 2021). "Macrornis tanaupus Seeley, 1866: an enigmatic giant bird from the upper Eocene of England". Geological Magazine. 158 (6): 1129–1134. doi:10.1017/S0016756820001466. ISSN   0016-7568.
  16. Mayr, G. (2022). "Accipitriformes (New World Vultures, Hawks, and Allies), Falconiformes (Falcons), and Cariamiformes (Seriemas and Allies)". Paleogene Fossil Birds (2nd ed.). Springer Cham. pp. 153–176. doi:10.1007/978-3-030-87645-6_8.
  17. LaBarge, T. W.; Gardner, J. D.; Organ, C. L. (2024). "The evolution and ecology of gigantism in terror birds (Aves, Phorusrhacidae)". Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 291 (2021). 20240235. doi:10.1098/rspb.2024.0235. PMID   38654650. Supplementary Information