Friar Tuck

Last updated

Friar Tuck
The friar took Robin on his back by Louis Rhead 1912.png
"The friar took Robin on his back" Illustration by Louis Rhead to Bold Robin Hood and His Outlaw Band: Their Famous Exploits in Sherwood Forest
Born15th-century
Died15th-century
Known forMember of Robin Hood's Merry Men
Figure of Friar Tuck, Scott Monument, Edinburgh, by George Clark Stanton Figure of Friar Tuck, Scott Monument, Edinburgh.jpg
Figure of Friar Tuck, Scott Monument, Edinburgh, by George Clark Stanton

Friar Tuck is one of the Merry Men, the band of heroic outlaws in the folklore of Robin Hood. Although a common character in the modern Robin Hood legend, Tuck does not appear in the earliest surviving Robin Hood ballads. [1]

Contents

History

The figure of the jovial friar was common in the May Games festivals of England and Scotland during the 15th to 17th centuries. Friar figures also appear in morris dances associated with May Day celebrations of the period. [1] The original association of Friar Tuck with Robin Hood remains uncertain and may have emerged through morris tradition, dramatic performance, or both. He appears as a character in the fragment of a Robin Hood play from 1475, sometimes called Robin Hood and the Knight or Robin Hood and the Sheriff, and a play for the May games published in 1560 which tells a story similar to "Robin Hood and the Curtal Friar" (the oldest surviving copy of this ballad is from the 17th century). The character likely entered the tradition through these folk plays, and he was often associated with Maid Marian, who was also a May Games character. [2] By the mid 16th century May Games were becoming increasingly bawdy, and in one play Robin even gives Marian to Friar Tuck as a concubine: "She is a trul of trust, to serue a frier at his lust/a prycker a prauncer a terer of shetes/a wagger of ballockes when other men slepes." [3] His appearance in "Robin Hood and the Sheriff" means that he was already part of the legend around the time when the earliest surviving copies of the Robin Hood ballads were being made.

A friar with Robin's band in the historical period of Richard the Lion-Hearted would have been unlikely as the period predates formal mendicant religious orders in England. Christian religious hermits in England do date as far back as Cuthbert in the late 7th century. [4] In addition, multiple historical references to eremitic hermits unallied with formal orders have been noted, among them Eustace the Monk (a medieval outlaw) and Robert of Knaresborough who was contemporaries with Richard I. However, the association of Robin Hood with Richard I was not made until the 16th century; the early ballad "A Gest of Robin Hood" names his king as "Edward".

What follows is a story which includes different versions of the legend. He was a former monk of Fountains Abbey (or in some cases, St Mary's Abbey in York, which is also the scene of some other Robin Hood tales) who was expelled by his order because of his lack of respect for authority. Because of this, and in spite of his taste for good food and wine, he became the chaplain of Robin's band. In Howard Pyle's The Merry Adventures of Robin Hood , he was specifically sought out as part of the tale of Alan-a-Dale: Robin has need of a priest who will marry Allan to his sweetheart in defiance of the Bishop of Hereford. [5]

In many tales, from Robin Hood and the Curtal Friar to The Merry Adventures of Robin Hood , his first encounter with Robin results in a battle of wits in which first one and then the other gains the upper hand and forces the other to carry him across a river. This ends with the Friar tossing Robin into the river.

In some tales, he is depicted as a physically fit man and a skilled swordsman and archer with a hot-headed temper. However, most commonly, Tuck is depicted as a fat, balding monk with a good sense of humour and a great love of food and ale, often together. Sometimes, the latter depiction of Tuck is the comic relief of the tale.

Two royal writs in 1417 refer to Robert Stafford, a Sussex chaplain who had assumed the alias of Frere Tuk. This "Friar Tuck" was still at large in 1429. These are the earliest surviving references to a character by that name. [6]

Portrayals in other media

Friar Tuck meets the disguised Richard the Lionheart in Sir Walter Scott's Ivanhoe. J. Cooper, Sr. - Sir Walter Scott - Le Noir Faineant in the Hermit's Cell - Ivanhoe.jpg
Friar Tuck meets the disguised Richard the Lionheart in Sir Walter Scott's Ivanhoe .

Friar Tuck has been featured in numerous adaptations across stage, film, television, animation, video games, and literature. These portrayals have varied in characterization and style, but commonly emphasize his loyalty, humor, and defiance in the face of authority. Notably, there are numerous instances where Tuck is referenced not in relation to Robin Hood.


TitleYearPortrayed byMedia Type
Ivanhoe [7] 1891 Avon Saxon Romantic opera
Douglas Fairbanks in Robin Hood 1922 Willard Louis Film
The Adventures of Robin Hood 1938 Eugene Pallette Film
The Bandit of Sherwood Forest 1946 Edgar Buchanan Film
The Prince of Thieves 1948 Alan Mowbray Film
Rogues of Sherwood Forest 1950 Billy House Film
The Adventures of Robin Hood 1955-1959 Alexander Gauge TV series
The Story of Robin Hood and His Merrie Men 1952 James Hayter Film
Robin Hood Daffy 1958 Porky Pig Animated short
A Challenge for Robin Hood 1967 James Hayter Film
Robin Hood 1973 Andy Devine Animated film
When Things Were Rotten 1975 Dick Van Patten TV series
Robin of Sherwood 1980s Phil Rose TV series
Robin Hood no Daibōken 1990-1991 Kenichi Ogata [8] Anime series
Young Robin Hood 1991 Harry Standjofski [9] Animated series}
Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves 1991 Mike McShane Film
Robin Hood 1991 Jeff Nuttall Film
Star Trek: TNG "Qpid"1991 Data TV series [10]
Robin Hood: Men in Tights 1993 Mel Brooks Film
Robin Hood 2009 David Harewood TV series
Robin Hood 2010 Mark Addy Film
Once Upon a Time 2014-2016Michael P. Northey [11] TV series
Doctor Who "Robot of Sherwood"2014 Trevor Cooper TV series
Robin Hood 2018 Tim Minchin Film

Analysis

Anne K. Kaler noted that a common misconception about Friar Tuck is that he was a Franciscan friar; she noted this is not plausible as he could belong to Benedictine, Augustinian or Carmelite orders instead, or perhaps be a renegade monk or a hermit. She notes that he fits into the Robin Hood story as one of the classic archetypes or stereotypes; here, of "a laudatory example of Christian clergyman", remembered for qualities such as "joy and good fellowship", a role for which he became immortalized in popular culture since. She compared him to characters such as Santa Claus, Falstaff or Winnie the Pooh, calling him "our 'belly cheer', our Lord of Misrule, our occasional defiance of authority, our spirit of seasonal joy". [12]

Medical references

A pattern in the dermatologic disease trichotillomania (compulsive pulling out of scalp hair) has been nicknamed the “Friar Tuck sign” because of its resemblance to Friar Tuck’s familiar tonsured hair, which was common in many male religious orders in the mediaeval period. [13]

References

  1. 1 2 Forrest, John (1999). The History of Morris Dancing, 1438–1750. University of Toronto Press. doi:10.3138/9781442681453 . Retrieved 14 December 2025.
  2. Child, Francis James. The English and Scottish Popular Ballads. Vol. 3. Boston and New York, Houghton, Mifflin and Company. p. 122.
  3. Morris, Harry (December 1958). "Ophelia's 'Bonny Sweet Robin'". PMLA. 73 (5, part 1): 603.
  4. "Hermitages (an introduction to Heritage Assets)". Historic England.org.uk. Retrieved 26 January 2022.
  5. Michael Patrick Hearn, "Afterword", Howard Pyle The Merry Adventures of Robin Hood, p 384 ISBN   0-451-52007-6
  6. Holt, J. C. (1982). Robin Hood. New York, N.Y.: Thames and Hudson. ISBN   9780500250815.
  7. Stone, David. "Avon Saxon". Who Was Who in the D'Oyly Carte Opera Company. Retrieved 14 December 2025.
  8. "Kenichi Ogata – Anime News Network Encyclopedia". Anime News Network. Retrieved 14 December 2025.
  9. "Young Robin Hood: The Complete Series". Internet Archive. Retrieved 14 December 2025.
  10. "Qpid (Star Trek: The Next Generation) – IMDb". IMDb. Retrieved 14 December 2025.
  11. "Michael P. Northey – IMDb". IMDb. Retrieved 14 December 2025.
  12. Kaler, Anne K. (March 1997). "Who is that Monk in the Hood?: Friar Tuck, Francis of Assisi, and Robin Hood" . The Journal of Popular Culture. 30 (4): 51–74. doi:10.1111/j.0022-3840.1997.3004_51.x. ISSN   0022-3840.
  13. Peralta, Lígia; Morais, Paulo (30 June 2012). "The Friar Tuck sign in trichotillomania". Journal of Dermatological Case Reports. 6 (2): 63–64. doi:10.3315/jdcr.2012.1103. ISSN   1898-7249. PMC   3399682 . PMID   22826725.