Gamaliel's principle

Last updated
Rabban Gamaliel Gamliel.jpg
Rabban Gamaliel

Gamaliel's principle, [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] also called Gamaliel's rule, [8] Gamaliel's rule-of-thumb, [9] Gamaliel's counsel, [10] Gamaliel's law, [11] [12] or the Gamaliel attitude, [13] is a principle outlined in the Book of Acts in the New Testament by the Rabban Gamaliel. [lower-alpha 1] Gamaliel cautions the Jewish Sanhedrin against killing Jesus' disciples, saying that if their ideas were of human origin, they would "come to nought" and the Jews did not need to worry about them; but if they were from God, their ideas would be impossible to overthrow anyway, and if the Jews tried to stop them, they would be fighting against God. Therefore, in Gamaliel's view it would be better to do nothing and let God take care of the situation.

Contents

In modern times Gamaliel's principle has been used in support of religious pluralism and reforms within religious groups.

Origin

The Sanhedrin was made up of Jewish rabbis who acted as judges. Sanhedrin1.jpg
The Sanhedrin was made up of Jewish rabbis who acted as judges.

In the Acts 5 in the New Testament, an account is told of the apostles of Jesus being brought before the Sanhedrin in Jerusalem, which acted as a Jewish court system. The high priest accuses them of disobeying an order to stop preaching, to which the apostle Peter responds by beginning to preach to the Sanhedrin. The Sanhedrin then considers killing the apostles in retaliation, at which point Gamaliel gives the following advice: [14]

"And now I say unto you, Refrain from these men, and let them alone: for if this counsel or this work be of men, it will come to nought:
"But if it be of God, ye cannot overthrow it; lest haply ye be found even to fight against God."
- Acts 5:38–39, King James Version

To prove his point, Gamaliel also notes two examples, Theudas and Judas of Galilee, who gained a large following but came "to nought". [14] According to the Bible, the other rabbis in the Sanhedrin agree with Gamaliel and decide to not kill the disciples, instead having them beaten and then released. [14]

Various theories have been put forth regarding Gamaliel's motives, and how much he believed or disbelieved the Christians, and some have even theorized that he secretly was a Christian, although there is no evidence to support that theory. [10] [lower-alpha 2] It is also possible he was happy that the Christians were preaching the resurrection from the dead, a doctrine which he believed in as a Pharisee, but the Sadducees in the Sanhedrin did not. [14] [10] According to the Pulpit Commentary , there is "no doubt" that being Pharisee "would rather dispose him to resist the violent counsels of the Sadducean members, and the more so as the doctrine of the Resurrection was in question." [14] According to Alexander Maclaren, Gamaliel was known to be "prudent, wise, cautious and calm, tolerant, opposed to fanaticism and violence" and so it is unsurprising he would have given advice such as this. [10] It is also possible Gamaliel did not want the Sanhedrin to anger the general population in Jerusalem, because many of them supported the Christians; [15] and according to John F. MacArthur it is likely that he really did believe what he said. [16]

Modern application

Gamaliel's principle has been used to support reforms such as the ordination of women. JeffertsSchori.JPG
Gamaliel's principle has been used to support reforms such as the ordination of women.

Some Christians have argued that Gamaliel's principle should guide Christians when interacting with other religions or denominations, and that following it would avoid religious violence and intolerance. [2] [5] Raymond E. Brown argued that while "it may not be true that every religious movement that is of human origin fails; nevertheless, the church would have been wiser many times in its history if it had used Gamaliel's principle to judge new developments in Christianity rather than reacting in a hostile manner too quickly." [1]

The Gamaliel principle has also sometimes been applied to changes or reforms, especially within the church, [3] such as the ordination of women. [17] Reginald Hoefer writes that "the Gamaliel Principle is a helpful lens through which to view all the things that might disturb us about the state of the world, the country, the Church" because it argues that what is right will win and anything that is wrong will lose. [6]

Gamaliel's principle has also been compared to Jesus's admonition "You will know them by their fruits". [18] Pat Boone used what he called "the Gamaliel attitude" to argue that church bodies should "judge the fruit before [making] any rash or rigid pronouncements". [19]

Criticism

Some have argued that Gamaliel's principle is a fallacy. [20] [7] For instance, John F. MacArthur argued from an evangelical perspective that since evil is allowed to exist, "Gamaliel's principle will come true only when Christ returns to establish His kingdom on earth". [20] MacArthur gives for an example that the Sanhedrin still existed in Israel at the time of Gamaliel even though it was "instrumental in Christ's death", and that therefore the only valid part of Gamaliel's argument is the second part: "If it be of God, ye cannot overthrow it". [20] He concludes that the proper argument that Gamaliel should have used is not to "wait and see" but to study the scriptures. [21]

One writer argued against the Gamaliel principle as applied to the ordination of women, saying that the time it would take to determine whether it was right would produce "profound and lasting damage to the Church". [17] Beatrice Pate responded that this position demonstrates "a surprisingly low view of the Church, and a low view of the sovereignty of God." [17]

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ The "Gamaliel" named in the Bible is almost certainly the famous Gamaliel the Elder, who for some time was president of the Sanhedrin, as opposed to his grandson Gamaliel II or another Gamaliel. According to the Pulpit Commentary , the events and context of the story put his identity "beyond all reasonable doubt". [14]
  2. ↑ The Pulpit Commentary states that there is not "any foundation for the legend... that he was in secret a Christian." [14]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Acts of the Apostles</span> Book of the New Testament

The Acts of the Apostles is the fifth book of the New Testament; it tells of the founding of the Christian Church and the spread of its message to the Roman Empire.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paul the Apostle</span> Christian apostle and missionary

Paul, commonly known as Paul the Apostle and Saint Paul, was a Christian apostle who spread the teachings of Jesus in the first-century world. For his contributions towards the New Testament, he is generally regarded as one of the most important figures of the Apostolic Age, and he also founded several Christian communities in Asia Minor and Europe from the mid-40s to the mid-50s AD.

The Pharisees were a Jewish social movement and a school of thought in the Levant during the time of Second Temple Judaism. After the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 AD, Pharisaic beliefs became the foundational, liturgical, and ritualistic basis for Rabbinic Judaism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sanhedrin</span> Assemblies of twenty-three or seventy-one Jewish elders

The Sanhedrin was a legislative and judicial assembly of either 23 or 71 elders, existing at both a local and central level in the ancient Land of Israel.

The Sadducees were a sect of Jews active in Judea during the Second Temple period, from the second century BCE to the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE. The Sadducees are described in contemporary literary sources in contrast to the two other major sects at the time, the Pharisees and the Essenes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Laying on of hands</span> Ritual that is a part of religious practices found in various cultures

The laying on of hands is a religious practice. In Judaism semikhah accompanies the conferring of a blessing or authority.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nicodemus</span> Pharisee, biblical figure appearing in the Gospel of John

Nicodemus is a New Testament person venerated as a saint in a number of Christian traditions. Depicted as a Pharisee and a member of the Sanhedrin who is drawn to hear Jesus's teachings, he is mentioned in three places in the Gospel of John:

Theudas was a Jewish rebel of the 1st century AD. Scholars attribute to his name a Greek etymology possibly meant as "flowing with water", although with a Hellenist-styled ending. At some point between 44 and 46 AD, Theudas led his followers in a short-lived revolt.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Council of Jerusalem</span> First Christian synod (c. 48–50 AD)

The Council of Jerusalem or Apostolic Council is a council described in chapter 15 of the Acts of the Apostles, allegedly held in Jerusalem around c. 48–50 AD.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gamaliel</span> First century leading authority on Jewish law in the Sanhedrin

Gamaliel the Elder, or Rabban Gamaliel I, was a leading authority in the Sanhedrin in the early first century CE. He was the son of Simeon ben Hillel and grandson of the great Jewish teacher Hillel the Elder. He fathered Simeon ben Gamliel, who was named for Gamaliel's father, and a daughter, who married a priest named Simon ben Nathanael.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Historical background of the New Testament</span>

Most scholars who study the historical Jesus and early Christianity believe that the canonical gospels and the life of Jesus must be viewed within their historical and cultural context, rather than purely in terms of Christian orthodoxy. They look at Second Temple Judaism, the tensions, trends, and changes in the region under the influence of Hellenism and the Roman occupation, and the Jewish factions of the time, seeing Jesus as a Jew in this environment; and the written New Testament as arising from a period of oral gospel traditions after his death.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Matthew 5:17</span> [Truth] The proof of True Grace and Salvation.

Matthew 5:17 is the 17th verse of the fifth chapter of the Gospel of Matthew in the New Testament and is part of the Sermon on the Mount. One of the most debated verses in the gospel, this verse begins a new section on Jesus and the Torah, where Jesus discusses the Law and the Prophets.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John 4</span> Chapter of the New Testament

John 4 is the fourth chapter of the Gospel of John in the New Testament of the Christian Bible. The major part of this chapter recalls Jesus' interaction with the Samaritan woman at the well in Sychar. In verses 43-54, he returns to Galilee, where he heals a royal official's son.

The persecution of Christians in the New Testament is an important part of the Early Christian narrative which depicts the early Church as being persecuted for their heterodox beliefs by a Jewish establishment in what was then the Roman province of Judea.

Ananias son of Nedebeus was a high priest who, according to the Acts of the Apostles, presided during the trials of the apostle Paul at Jerusalem and Caesarea.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Saint Stephen</span> 1st-century early Christian martyr and saint

Stephen is traditionally venerated as the protomartyr or first martyr of Christianity. According to the Acts of the Apostles, he was a deacon in the early church at Jerusalem who angered members of various synagogues by his teachings. Accused of blasphemy at his trial, he made a speech denouncing the Jewish authorities who were sitting in judgment on him and was then stoned to death. Saul of Tarsus, later known as Paul the Apostle, a Pharisee and Roman citizen who would later become an apostle, participated in Stephen's martyrdom.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Acts 4</span> Chapter of the New Testament

Acts 4 is the fourth chapter of the Acts of the Apostles in the New Testament of the Christian Bible. The book containing this chapter is anonymous but early Christian tradition affirmed that Luke composed this book as well as the Gospel of Luke. This chapter records the aftermath of a healing by Simon Peter and his preaching in Solomon's Portico, that Sanhedrin arrested the apostles, but had to let them go.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Acts 5</span> Chapter of the New Testament

Acts 5 is the fifth chapter of the Acts of the Apostles in the New Testament of the Christian Bible. It records the growth of the early church and the obstacles it encountered.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Acts 7</span> Chapter of the New Testament

Acts 7 is the seventh chapter of the Acts of the Apostles in the New Testament of the Christian Bible. It records the address of Stephen before the Sanhedrin and his execution outside Jerusalem, and introduces Saul. The book containing this chapter is anonymous, but early Christian tradition uniformly affirmed that Luke composed this book as well as the Gospel of Luke.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Acts 23</span> Chapter of the New Testament

Acts 23 is the twenty-third chapter of the Acts of the Apostles in the New Testament of the Christian Bible. It records the period of Paul's imprisonment in Jerusalem then in Caesarea. The book containing this chapter is anonymous but early Christian tradition uniformly affirmed that Luke composed this book as well as the Gospel of Luke.

References

  1. 1 2 Brown, Raymond E. (1994). A once-and-coming Spirit at Pentecost: essays on the liturgical readings between Easter and Pentecost, taken from the Acts of the Apostles and from the Gospel according to John . Collegeville, Minn.: Liturgical Press. p. 36.
  2. 1 2 Kealy, Sean P. (1975). The early church and Africa: a school certificate course based on the East African syllabus for Christian religious education . Nairobi: Oxford University Press. p. 77.
  3. 1 2 Valentine, Mary Hester (1970). Prayer and renewal : proceedings and communications of regional meetings of the Sister Formation Conferences, 1969 . New York: Fordham University Press. p. 139.
  4. ↑ Robertson, Constance Noyes (1977). Oneida Community profiles . Syracuse, N.Y.: Syracuse University Press. p. 119.
  5. 1 2 Editors (Jan 12, 1922) "The Jews and Christian Liberties". The Christian Century. Vol 39. Iss 2. Christian Century Foundation.
  6. 1 2 Hoefer, Reginald (February 15, 2017). "The Gamaliel Principle". Dominicana.
  7. 1 2 Span John (Feb 17, 2014). “You Might be Opposing God”: Bring on the “Gamaliel principle”. Biblical Missiology.
  8. ↑ Henry, Matthew (1992). The NIV Matthew Henry commentary in one volume . Grand Rapids, Mich.: Zondervan Pub. House. p. 130.
  9. ↑ Hahn, Scott; Mitch, Curtis; Walters, Dennis (2002). The Acts of the Apostles: with introduction, commentary, and notes . San Francisco, CA : Ignatius Press. p. 67.
  10. 1 2 3 4 MacLaren, Alexander (1900). Expositions of Holy Scripture: the Acts. London: Hodder & Stoughton. p. 196.
  11. ↑ Byrne, Lavinia (1991). The Hidden tradition: women's spiritual writings rediscovered: an anthology . New York: Crossroad. p. 2.
  12. ↑ Moore, Paul (1979). Take a Bishop like me . New York: Harper & Row. p. 183.
  13. ↑ Boone, Pat (1975). My brother's keeper? . New York: Pillar Books. pp. 52-56. (Originally titled Dr. Balaam's talking mule.)
  14. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Exell, Joseph S.; Spence-Jones, Henry Donald Maurice (Editors). On "Acts 5". In: The Pulpit Commentary . 23 volumes. First publication: 1890. Electronic Database. Copyright © 2001, 2003, 2005, 2006, 2010 by Biblesoft, Inc.
  15. ↑ MacArthur, John (1988). Keys to effective evangelism . Chicago: Moody Press. p. 51.
  16. ↑ MacArthur 1988, p. 52.
  17. 1 2 3 Pate, Beatrice; Field, Barbara (ed.) (1989). Fit for this office: women and ordination . Melbourne: Collins Dove. pp. 116-117.
  18. ↑ Ezeogu, Ernest M. (2003) ""Surely we are not blind, are we": An African theological reading of the story of the healing of the man born blind, John 9:1-41". Society of Biblical Literature. p. 13.
  19. ↑ Boone 1975, p. 53.
  20. 1 2 3 MacArthur 1988, p. 54.
  21. ↑ MacArthur 1988, pp. 54-55.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.