| Name | Institution | Year |
|---|
| Anurag Agrawal | Cornell University | 2021 |
| Richard D. Alexander (d. 2018) | University of Michigan | 1974 |
| Robert W. Allard (d. 2003) | University of California, Davis | 1973 |
| Wyatt Anderson (d. 2023) | University of Georgia | 1987 |
| Douglas Futuyma | State University of New York at Stony Brook | 2005 |
| John Avise | University of California, Irvine | 1991 |
| George A. Bartholomew | University of California, Los Angeles | 1985 |
| May Berenbaum | University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign | 1994 |
| John Tyler Bonner | Princeton University | 1973 |
| Adriana Briscoe | University of California, Irvine | 2024 |
| Roy John Britten (d. 2012) | California Institute of Technology | 1972 |
| James J. Bull | University of Idaho | 2016 |
| Hampton L. Carson (d. 2004) | University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa | 1978 |
| Andrew G. Clark | Cornell University | 2012 |
| Michael T. Clegg | University of California, Irvine | 1990 |
| Edwin H. Colbert (d. 2001) | Museum of Northern Arizona | 1957 |
| Rita Colwell | University of Maryland, College Park | 2000 |
| Peter Crane | Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew | 2001 |
| Edward Smith Deevey Jr. (d. 1988) | University of Florida | 1981 |
| Jody Deming | University of Washington | 2003 |
| Michael Donoghue | Yale University | 2005 |
| W. Ford Doolittle | Dalhousie University | 2002 |
| Scott V. Edwards | Harvard University | 2015 |
| Thomas Eisner (d. 2011) | Cornell University | 1969 |
| Marcus Feldman | Stanford University | 2013 |
| Joseph Felsenstein | University of Washington | 1999 |
| Walter Fitch (d. 2011) | University of California, Irvine | 1989 |
| Douglas J. Futuyma | Stony Brook University | 2006 |
| Madhav Gadgil | Indian Institute of Science | 1991 |
| Stephen Jay Gould (d. 2002) | Harvard University | 1989 |
| John Harper | University of Wales, Aberystwyth | 1984 |
| Daniel Hartl | Harvard University | 2005 |
| Arthur D. Hasler (d. 2001) | University of Wisconsin–Madison | 1969 |
| David Hillis | University of Texas | 2008 |
| Hopi Hoekstra | Harvard University | 2016 |
| Bert Hölldobler | University of Würzburg | 1998 |
| Raymond B. Huey | University of Washington | 2024 |
| G. Evelyn Hutchinson (d. 1991) | Yale University | 1950 |
| David Jablonski | University of Chicago | 2010 |
| Warwick Estevam Kerr | Federal University of Uberlândia | 1990 |
| Margaret Kidwell | University of Arizona | 1996 |
| Nicole King | University of California, Berkeley | 2022 |
| Mark Kirkpatrick | University of Texas at Austin | 2020 |
| Richard Klein | Stanford University | 2003 |
| Russell Lande | University of California, San Diego | 2015 |
| Richard Lenski | Michigan State University | 2006 |
| Bruce R. Levin | Emory University | 2012 |
| Wen-Hsiung Li | University of Chicago | 2003 |
| Jonathan Losos | Washington University in St. Louis | 2018 |
| Michael Lynch | Indiana University | 2009 |
| Trudy Mackay | Clemson University | 2010 |
| Lynn Margulis (d. 2011) | University of Massachusetts Amherst | 1983 |
| Ernst Mayr (d. 2005) | Harvard University | 1954 |
| Charles Michener (d. 2015) | University of Kansas | 1965 |
| John A. Moore (d. 2002) | University of California, Riverside | 1963 |
| Nancy Moran | University of Arizona | 2004 |
| G. Balakrish Nair | | 2002 |
| Masatoshi Nei | Temple University | 1997 |
| Eviatar Nevo | University of Haifa | 2000 |
| Rasmus Nielsen | University of California, Berkeley | 2022 |
| Tomoko Ohta | National Institute of Genetics | 2002 |
| Everett C. Olson (d. 1993) | University of California, Los Angeles | 1980 |
| Gordon Orians | University of Washington | 1989 |
| Sarah Otto | University of British Columbia | 2013 |
| Svante Pääbo | Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology | 2004 |
| Catherine Peichel | University of Bern | 2023 |
| Naomi Pierce | Harvard University | 2023 |
| David Pilbeam | Harvard University | 1992 |
| Colin Pittendrigh (d. 1996) | Stanford University | 1963 |
| Molly Przeworski | Columbia University | 2020 |
| David C. Queller | Washington University in St. Louis | 2024 |
| Sidney Dillon Ripley (d. 2001) | Smithsonian Institution | 1968 |
| Gene E. Robinson | University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign | 2005 |
| Jose Sarukhan | National Autonomous University of Mexico | 1993 |
| Barbara Schaal | Washington University in St. Louis | 1999 |
| Douglas Schemske | Michigan State University | 2017 |
| Johanna Schmitt | University of California, Davis | 2008 |
| J. William Schopf | University of California, Los Angeles | 1998 |
| Robert Selander | Pennsylvania State University | 1982 |
| Ruth G. Shaw | University of Minnesota | 2021 |
| Neil Shubin | University of Chicago | 2011 |
| Charles Sibley (d. 1998) | Yale University | 1986 |
| Montgomery Slatkin | University of California, Berkeley | 2014 |
| Robert Sokal (d. 2012) | State University of New York at Stony Brook | 1987 |
| Joan E. Strassman | Washington University in St. Louis | 2013 |
| Sharon Y. Strauss | University of California, Davis | 2022 |
| Michael Turelli | University of California, Davis | 2021 |
| Paul Turner | Yale University | 2019 |
| James Valentine (d. 2023) | University of California, Berkeley | 1984 |
| Geerat J. Vermeij | University of California, Davis | 2022 |
| Günter P. Wagner | Yale University | 2018 |
| Warren H. Wagner (d. 2000) | University of Michigan | 1985 |
| David B. Wake (d. 2021) | University of California, Berkeley | 1998 |
| Bruce Wallace | Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University | 1970 |
| Mary Jane West-Eberhard | Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute | 1988 |
| Anne D. Yoder | Duke University | 2023 |
| Marlene Zuk | University of Minnesota | 2019 |