Shafia family murders

Last updated

The Shafia family murders took place on June 30, 2009, in Kingston, Ontario, Canada. Shafia sisters Zainab, 19, Sahar, 17, and Geeti, 13, along with their father's wife Rona Muhammad Omar, 52 (all of Afghan origin), were found dead inside a car that was discovered underwater in front of the northernmost Kingston Mills lock of the Rideau Canal. [1] Zainab, Sahar, and Geeti were daughters of Mohammad Shafia, 58, and his wife, Tooba Mohammad Yahya, 41. The couple also had a son, Hamed, 20, and three other children. Rona, who was herself infertile, was the first wife of Mohammad Shafia in their polygamous household.

Contents

On July 23, 2009, Mohammad, Tooba Yahya, and Hamed were arrested on charges of four counts of first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder under the guise of honour killing. [2] [3] The jury found them guilty of all four counts in January 2012. The trial, which took place at the Frontenac County Court House, was believed to be the first in Canada conducted in four languages – English, French, Dari and Spanish. [4]

Background

In 1979 or 1980, Mohammad Shafia married Rona Mohammed. The couple did not have children, and medical tests confirmed that Rona was unable to have children. In keeping with Afghan custom, and at Rona's behest, Mohammad Shafia took Tooba Yahya as his second wife. The second wedding took place in 1989, and Rona features prominently in many wedding photographs, many of which feature Shafia flanked by his two wives. [5] The three of them lived together in one household, as is customary, and Tooba gave birth to seven children. Rona participated fully in raising and caring for the children and bonded strongly with them as though they were her own. Her relationship with her co-wife, however, was less idyllic. [5]

The Shafia family left Afghanistan in 1992. They moved to Australia for a brief time. Later, they relocated to the United Arab Emirates, where they lived for over a decade. Mohammad Shafia made a considerable fortune in Dubai, working in the used car business and later diversifying into real estate. [6] By 2007, he was a multimillionaire. He soon decided to take advantage of an immigration program introduced by the government of Quebec in Canada which offered permanent residence and eventual citizenship to people who invested significant money in the province. Shafia invested $2 million in purchasing a strip-mall on the outskirts of Montreal; he invested a further $200,000 in building a spacious new house for his family. Shafia, his second wife Tooba, and their seven children immigrated to Canada and settled in the Saint-Léonard borough of Montreal in 2007. [7] [8] Five months later, Shafia sponsored Rona's immigration, telling authorities that she was his cousin and that she would work as a cook and housekeeper. [9] [10] [11]

According to a family member's interview, Rona was trapped in an abusive, loveless marriage, trying in vain to convince her husband to grant her a divorce. Rona's siblings claimed that she feared for her life during the days leading up to her death. [12] Tooba allegedly said to Rona, "You are a slave; you are a servant." Reportedly, the Shafias held all of Rona's identity documents, including her passport, so Rona believed she could not flee to another country where she had relatives. [9] The Montreal Gazette reported that Rona emigrated to Canada as a domestic servant on a visitor's visa and that her husband and co-wife "held [the visa's renewal] over her head like an axe ready to fall." [13]

The interviewed family member also stated that the Shafia family's eldest daughter, Zainab, was in a relationship with a Pakistani boy that elicited much anger from her father; the family member claimed to have overheard the father's threats to kill Zainab. [14]

With Mohammad Shafia, Tooba Mohammad Yahya, and their eldest son Hamed Shafia all in custody during the trial, the remaining Shafia children, two girls, and a boy, were being cared for under social services. [6]

Investigation

On June 30, 2009, a worker at the Kingston Mills locks discovered a black Nissan Sentra with a broken left taillight submerged in the water. Divers discovered four female bodies floating inside. [15] Mohammad Shafia was at the Kingston Police station to report that four of his family members – three teenage daughters and a purported aunt – were missing. [8] Police initially believed that it was a tragic, if bizarre, accident; they first categorized it as a "sudden death investigation." [15]

However, authorities soon learned that Hamed had reported an accident with the family Lexus SUV in an empty parking lot earlier that same morning in Montreal. Despite their suspicions, authorities did not have "reasonable and probable grounds" or sufficient evidence to ask a judge for a search warrant. Kingston Police Det. Steve Koopman, the liaison with the Shafia family, managed to gain the Shafia family's consent to view the Lexus. After assessing the damage on both vehicles, police theorized that the Lexus was used to ram the Nissan into the locks. [16]

It had been reported that the Shafia family purchased the used Nissan Sentra for CAD $5,000 on the day prior to the family leaving Montreal for Niagara Falls. [17]

Trial

Jury selection began on October 11, 2011, and the trial officially began on October 20 the same year. [18] Ontario Superior Court Judge Robert Maranger presided over the trial. [19]

Verdict

On January 29, 2012, after 15 hours of deliberation, a jury found each of the three defendants guilty of four counts of first-degree murder. In Canada, first-degree murder verdicts carry an automatic sentence of life without the possibility of parole for 25 years. [20]

Media coverage of the Shafia murder trial

The coverage of the Shafia murder trial was widespread, often being on the front page of newspapers and the top story in TV newscasts. Since the case involved Afghan Canadians, questions arose as to whether or not it was correct, or even appropriate, to call the murders honour killings or simply domestic violence. While the judge who presided over the case referred to the deaths simply as murders, the media chose a different course when it called the murders "honour killings." Across media outlets, the murder was framed as such. A publication ban placed on the case prevented the media from naming the three surviving children in the care of Canadian social services.

CBC

CBC News covered the trials extensively from the first day; they went a step further by publishing its audience's comments to show how Canadians felt about the case and its details. The CBC stated that the published comments were a chosen representative "summary" sampling out of the much higher number of comments the story garnered, and moreover that Canadians generally "agreed with the verdict, applauding the court and the jury for its decision after the three-month trial." [21]

CTV

CTV News published a piece stating that the trial cast a shadow over Canada's Islamic community, further tarnishing an image that had not yet recovered from the events of 9/11. However, like other media outlets, CTV asked the Muslim community to clarify their stance on the issue of honour killing: "Muslims across the country, however, say the revelations in a Kingston, Ont., courtroom have shone a light on problematic aspects of their culture and illuminated new ways to tackle the issues." [22]

CTV also published a timeline spanning the gamut from the Shafia family's days in Afghanistan to the events that took place in Canada. [23]

Ottawa Citizen

Pascale Fournier, writing for The Ottawa Citizen , said that there was a greater tragedy in the failure of the state to intervene before the murders occurred. He also said that while vulnerable groups from immigrant communities need the most protection, they rarely receive it from authorities. [24]

The Globe and Mail

In addition to covering every detail of the trial, The Globe and Mail published a piece with the "ten most shocking quotes" from the Shafia trial. One of the quotes was by Crown attorney Gerard Laarhuis after the verdicts, and it read as follows:

"This jury found that four strong, vivacious and freedom-loving women were murdered by their own family in the most troubling of circumstances. We all think of these four wonderful women now who died needless deaths. This verdict sends a very clear message about our Canadian values and the core principles in a free and democratic society that both Canadians and visitors to Canada enjoy." [22] [25] [ better source needed ]

This was one of the most criticized quotes by Afghan Canadians; they asserted that intolerance towards violence against women is not just a Canadian value, but a universal value. They also asserted that Afghans, like any other peoples, condemn the acts of the perpetrators.[ citation needed ]

Montreal Gazette

The Montreal Gazette published a column in which it said that labelling the murders as honour killing is a mistake as domestic violence against women is ubiquitous and framing it as a particular paradigm would mean distancing oneself from a crime that is all too common. The authors argue that premeditation is put forth as a core component to differentiate honour killings from other types of murders, such as crimes of convenience or passion. However, recent studies indicate that premeditation is as much a component in other cases of domestic violence and murder as it is in "honour killings".

"Calling the murders 'honour killings' accomplishes two goals. First, it makes it seem as if femicide is a highly unusual event. Second, it makes it seem as if femicide is confined to specific populations within Canada and specific national cultures or religions in the world at large. But Canadian statistics prove otherwise. According to StatsCan figures, from 2000 to 2009 an average of 58 women a year were killed in this country as a result of spousal violence. In that same period, 67 children and young people aged 12 to 17 were murdered by family members. In contrast, recent estimates tell us that there have been 12 or 13 so-called honour killings in Canada in the last decade. It does not take a genius to see that comparing 12 or 13 against the hundreds of women and children who were victims of familial violence serves only to frame 'honour killing' as peculiar, when in reality it is part of a larger pattern of violence against women." [26]

Maclean's

Maclean's referred to the four murders as "honouricide." Writer Michael Friscolanti sat throughout the three-month trial and wrote a 22-page comprehensive article detailing the girls' lives and even wrote about how one of the girls' tombstones has the incorrect birthdate.

"In life, and in death, they had no voice," Friscolanti wrote. "No one to save them. No one who even cares enough to fix Geeti's headstone. Nearly three years after she was buried, it is still engraved with Sahar's birth-date, not hers." [27]

Reaction

Muslims in Canada

The murders gave rise to the debate about the relationship between honour killing and Islam. Islamic organizations based in Canada condemned the murders. The Islamic Supreme Council of Canada, along with other Canadian Muslim organizations, have publicly denounced domestic violence and honour killing as un-Islamic. [28] Ali Falih Altaie, the family imam, said that the murders were unforgivable; he also cautioned against associating honour crimes with Islam, calling the actions incompatible with any religion. [29] [30]

In 2012 imams from across Canada and the U.S. issued a moral ruling officially condemning honour killings, domestic violence, and misogyny as un-Islamic. Thirty-four imams belonging to the Islamic Supreme Council of Canada, including a handful of American members, signed the fatwa in an effort to counter misinterpretations of the Qur'an. [31]

Afghan Canadians

In an interview with CTV News, the Afghan Embassy in Ottawa condemned the murders of the four members of the Shafia family. The embassy called the deaths of the three teenage sisters and their father's first wife a heinous crime against humanity. Moreover, they claimed that this kind of crime is not part of Afghan or Islamic culture and is not acceptable in any way. [32]

See also

Honour killing in Canada:

Honour killings of people with Afghan heritage:

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kingston Penitentiary</span> Former Canadian maximum security prison

Kingston Penitentiary is a former maximum security prison located in Kingston, Ontario, Canada, between King Street West and Lake Ontario.

Guy Paul Morin is a Canadian who was wrongly convicted of the October 1984 rape and murder of his nine-year-old next-door neighbour, Christine Jessop of Queensville, north of Toronto, Ontario. DNA testing led to a subsequent overturning of this verdict. On October 15, 2020, the Toronto Police Service announced a DNA match identifying Calvin Hoover as the one whose semen was recovered from Jessop’s underwear. Hoover killed himself in 2015.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Reena Virk</span> 1997 murder of a teenager in Saanich, British Columbia, Canada

Reena Virk was a 14-year-old Canadian girl who was beaten and killed by a group of teenagers in Saanich, British Columbia, Canada. Her status as a victim of bullying prior to her murder attracted substantial media scrutiny in Canada. Six teenagers were tried and convicted for their participation in her death. The Globe and Mail commented at the time that her case was "elevated into a national tragedy." A pair of Canadian sociologists have described the case as a watershed moment for a "moral panic" over girl violence by the Canadian public in the late 1990s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rona Ambrose</span> Canadian politician

Ronalee Ambrose Veitch is a Canadian former politician who was interim leader of the Conservative Party and the leader of the Opposition between 2015 and 2017. She was the Conservative Party member of the House of Commons for Sturgeon River—Parkland between 2015 and 2017, and had previously represented Edmonton—Spruce Grove from 2004 to 2015.

The Boxing Day shooting was a Canadian gang-related shooting which occurred on December 26, 2005, on Toronto's Yonge Street, resulting in the death of 15-year-old student Jane Creba. Six other bystanders—four men and two women—were wounded. The incident took place on one of Toronto's most crowded streets on the very busy shopping day, just a few blocks north of the Toronto Eaton Centre. The story generated national news coverage in Canada and influenced the then-underway 2006 federal election campaign on the issues of gun crime and street violence.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Shafilea Ahmed</span> Suspected honour killing of a 17-year-old British Pakistani girl in 2003

Shafilea Iftikhar Ahmed was a British-Pakistani girl who was murdered by her parents in a suspected honour killing at the age of 17, due to her refusal to accept an arranged marriage.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert Pickton</span> Canadian serial killer

Robert William Pickton, also known as the Pig Farmer Killer or the Butcher, is a Canadian serial killer, serial rapist, former pig farmer and possible cannibal who is suspected of being one of the most prolific serial killers in Canadian history. After dropping out of school, Pickton left a butcher's apprenticeship to begin working full-time at his family's pig farm. He is believed to have begun his murders in the early 1990s after inheriting the farm. Arrested in 2002, he was convicted in 2007 of the second-degree murders of six women and was also the subject of a lengthy investigation that yielded evidence of numerous other murders.

Anooshe Sediq Ghulam (1979–2002) was a 22-year-old Afghan refugee in Norway, who was murdered by her husband, Afghan Nasruddin Shamsi, in an "honour killing".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edward Sapiano</span>

Edward Sapiano was a Canadian defence lawyer, based in Toronto, Ontario, notable for his role in many high-profile criminal cases. He initiated Canada's largest criminal investigation of police, resulting in the arrest and prosecution of several Toronto police officers and was also involved in the so-called Toronto 18 terrorism trial. Edward Sapiano is also noted for demanding immediate DNA testing of his client shortly following the 1996 arrest of the suspected "North York serial rapist", leading to his client Jeremy Foster's full vindication, despite a false confession to the crime. In his quest to get illegal guns off the street, Sapiano also created the only lawyer-operated gun amnesty program available in North America, Piece Options. He is also known for starting a database of rulings and judgements to track alleged misconduct among Toronto-area officers which was then retrievable for cross-examinations in other cases by other lawyers. Edward Sapiano, after putting his practice on hold for two and a half years due to kidney failure, returned to court in 2017 for the Andrea White murder trial. Edward died on March 21, 2020, from complications of kidney disease and was cited to be the first lawyer in Canada to practise while undergoing 10 hours of daily dialysis. He was regularly featured by media outlets, including The Globe and Mail, CBC, and the New York Times commenting on criminal law issues.

Aqsa "Axa" Parvez was the victim of a murder in Mississauga, Ontario, Canada. During the murder trial, Superior Court Justice Bruce Durno acknowledged the slaying as an honour killing, stating, that he found it "profoundly disturbing that a 16-year-old could be murdered by a father and brother for the purpose of saving family pride, for saving them from what they perceived as family embarrassment". Aqsa's brother, Waqas, had strangled her. Aqsa's death was reported internationally and sparked a debate about the status of women in Islam. The Toronto Star stated that the father's perception of himself being unable to influence his daughter's behavior was a major factor in the death, and that "Media in Toronto and around the world immediately reported and continues to report that Aqsa was killed because she refused to wear the hijab. But it was much more complicated than that."

Victoria Elizabeth Marie"Tori"Stafford was a Canadian girl who was abducted, raped, and murdered by Michael Rafferty and Terri-Lynne McClintic. Her body was found three months later in a wooded area in rural Ontario. The subsequent investigation and search were the subject of massive media coverage across Canada.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">David Ridgen</span> Canadian filmmaker

David Ridgen is an independent Canadian filmmaker born in Stratford, Ontario. He has worked for CBC Television, MSNBC, NPR, TVOntario and others. He is currently the writer, producer and host of CBC Radio’s true-crime podcast series, Someone Knows Something and The Next Call.

David Russell Williams is a Canadian serial rapist, murderer and former colonel in the Royal Canadian Air Force. He is currently serving a life sentence with the possibility of parole after 25 years for two murders, committed in November 2009 and January 2010.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Frontenac County Court House</span> Historic site in Ontario, Canada

The Frontenac County Court House in Kingston, Ontario, Canada is the Courthouse for Frontenac County, Ontario. The Neoclassical building was designed by Edward Horsey and constructed by builders Scobell and Tossell. Alternation after 1874 fire by John Power added the dome tower. It overlooks City Park to its south, and Lake Ontario beyond. The front of the structure features the Royal coat of arms of the United Kingdom.

Events from the year 2012 in Canada.

In May 2012, Jun Lin, a university student, was fatally stabbed and dismembered in Montreal, Canada, by Luka Rocco Magnotta, who then mailed Lin's hands and feet to elementary schools and federal political party offices. After a video depicting the murder was posted online, Magnotta fled Canada, becoming the subject of an Interpol Red Notice and prompting an international manhunt. In June 2012, he was arrested in an internet café in Berlin. In December 2014, after eight days of deliberations, a jury convicted him of first-degree murder. Magnotta was given a mandatory life sentence and 19 years for other charges, to be served concurrently. Magnotta was previously sought by animal rights groups for uploading videos of himself killing kittens.

Colten Boushie was a 22-year-old Indigenous man of the Cree Red Pheasant First Nation who was fatally shot on a rural Saskatchewan farm by its owner, Gerald Stanley. Stanley stood trial for second-degree murder and for a lesser charge of manslaughter, but was ultimately acquitted in February 2018.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Marrisa Shen</span> 2017 child murder in Burnaby, British Columbia

Marrisa Shen was a 13-year-old Canadian girl who was raped and murdered in a wooded area in Central Park, in Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada. Shen was reported missing by her parents on the evening of July 18, 2017, after she failed to return home from what was supposed to be a brief trip to a nearby Tim Hortons. Early the next morning, police located her body in the park by tracking the GPS device inside her mobile phone. The RCMP stated the attack appeared to be random. After Shen's murder, the RCMP told parents to talk to their children about safety and warned the public to be vigilant.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Elaine Campione</span> Canadian murderer

Frances Elaine Campione is an Ontario woman who murdered her two children in Barrie, Ontario, on October 2, 2006. Canadian prosecutors argued that she wanted to get revenge on her ex-husband and was afraid he would receive custody.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2021 London, Ontario truck attack</span> 2021 killing in Canada

On June 6, 2021, a 20-year old named Nathaniel Veltman rammed a pickup truck into a family of Muslim Pakistani Canadian pedestrians at an intersection in London, Ontario, Canada. Four people were killed and a fifth was wounded. The attack was the deadliest mass killing in London's history. It was condemned by Canadian leaders, and described as terrorism by Prime Minister of Canada Justin Trudeau, Prime Minister of Pakistan Imran Khan and Premier of Ontario Doug Ford.

References

  1. ↑ "A timeline of the Kingston canal deaths". Windsor Star. July 24, 2009. Archived from the original on July 28, 2009. Retrieved July 25, 2009.
  2. ↑ "Shafia daughter married for revenge, court hears". CBC News. November 10, 2011. Retrieved November 10, 2011.
  3. ↑ Dale, Daniel (July 25, 2009). "Shining a light on honour killings' dark corner". Toronto Star. Retrieved July 25, 2009.
  4. ↑ Jury selection for murder trial begins next week Archived April 4, 2012, at the Wayback Machine from The Kingston Whig-Standard. Retrieved November 24, 2011.
  5. 1 2 Friscolanti, Michael (March 3, 2016). "Inside the Shafia killings that shocked a nation". Macleans.ca. Retrieved July 28, 2021.
  6. 1 2 "shafia trial – Topics". Macleans.ca. Retrieved January 31, 2012.
  7. ↑ "Picture of troubled family emerges". National Post. Canada. July 25, 2009. Retrieved July 25, 2009.[ dead link ]
  8. 1 2 "Chronology of events in the Shafia murders". January 29, 2012. Retrieved January 30, 2012.
  9. 1 2 Tripp, Rob (November 30, 2011). "Shafia trial told of abuse, violence against woman". Montrealgazette.com. Archived from the original on December 1, 2011. Retrieved January 31, 2012.
  10. ↑ "DiManno: Accused mother testifies at Shafia murder trial". thestar.com. January 9, 2012.
  11. ↑ https://montrealgazette.com/news/Accused+says+heart+often+bleeds+cries+only+once+stand/5970215/story.html?id=5970215%5B%5D
  12. ↑ "Oldest canal victim feared for her life: siblings". CBC News. July 24, 2009. Archived from the original on July 27, 2009. Retrieved July 25, 2009.
  13. ↑ Christie Blatchford (January 30, 2012). "Christie Blatchford: There's no honour in 'shameless murders'". The Gazette. Montrealgazette.com. Archived from the original on January 31, 2012. Retrieved January 31, 2012.
  14. ↑ Jones, Allison (November 22, 2011). "Shafia sisters complained about violence at home months before their deaths". The Canadian Press via Yahoo news. Archived from the original on February 4, 2012. Retrieved February 1, 2012.
  15. 1 2 Jones, Allison (January 30, 2012). "How the Shafia Investigation Unfolded". GlobalNews. The Canadian Press. Retrieved September 7, 2020.
  16. ↑ "Blatchford: Meet Mr. Nice Cop – the detective who won the Shafia clan's trust". Vancouver Sun. November 25, 2011. Archived from the original on December 31, 2011. Retrieved January 31, 2012.
  17. ↑ Christie Blatchford (January 29, 2012). "Christie Blatchford: No honour in 'cold-blooded, shameless' murder of Shafia girls". National Post. nationalpost.com. Retrieved April 13, 2017.
  18. ↑ Rocha, Roberto (January 31, 2012). "Road to a guilty verdict". Calgary Herald. Archived from the original on January 28, 2016. Retrieved January 31, 2012.
  19. ↑ "Key players in Shafia trial react to verdict". Canada: CBC. January 29, 2012.
  20. ↑ "Shafia jury finds all guilty". CBC News. January 29, 2012. Retrieved January 29, 2012.
  21. ↑ "Community reaction to the Shafia trial verdict". CBC News. January 30, 2012. Archived from the original on April 4, 2012. Retrieved April 5, 2012.
  22. 1 2 "Shafia murder trial casts shadow over Canada's Islamic community". CTV News. January 30, 2012. Retrieved April 5, 2012.
  23. ↑ "Chronology of events in the Shafia murders". CBC News. January 29, 2012. Archived from the original on April 2, 2012. Retrieved April 5, 2012.
  24. ↑ Fournier, Pascale (January 31, 2012). "Media coverage of Shafia case sometimes fuelled prejudices". Guelph Mercury. Retrieved April 5, 2012.[ dead link ]
  25. ↑ "Shafia jury finds all guilty". CBC News. January 29, 2012. Retrieved April 5, 2012.
  26. ↑ "Should we call it 'honour killing'?". Montreal Gazette. January 31, 2012. Retrieved April 5, 2012.[ permanent dead link ]
  27. ↑ Friscolanti, Michael (March 3, 2016). "Inside the Shafia Killings That Shocked a Nation". Maclean's. Retrieved September 7, 2020.
  28. ↑ "Muslim leaders decry domestic violence". Canada: CBC. December 9, 2011. Retrieved December 10, 2011.
  29. ↑ "Shafia deaths unforgivable, says family imam". The Canadian Press via CTV. January 31, 2012. Archived from the original on February 1, 2012. Retrieved January 31, 2012.
  30. ↑ "The House of Shafia". CBC News. Archived from the original on February 12, 2012.
  31. ↑ "Shafia Murders: Imams Issue Fatwa Against Honour Killings, Domestic Violence". Canada: Huffington Post. February 4, 2012. Retrieved October 6, 2020.
  32. ↑ "Afghan Embassy speaks out against Shafia murders". CTV News. January 31, 2012. Archived from the original on March 4, 2012. Retrieved April 5, 2012.

44°17′35″N76°26′30″W / 44.293014°N 76.441766°W / 44.293014; -76.441766

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.