1978 Yegoryevsk Tu-144 crash

Last updated
1978 Yegoryevsk Tu-144 crash
Tupolev TU-144 (6060104119).jpg
СССР-77110, sister aircraft to the Tu-144 involved in the crash
Accident
Date23 May 1978
SummaryFuel leak and in-flight fire leading to crash landing in a field
SiteNear Yegoryevsk, Moscow Oblast, Russian SFSR, Soviet Union (now in Russia)
55°23′41″N38°51′38″E / 55.39472°N 38.86056°E / 55.39472; 38.86056
Aircraft
Aircraft type Tupolev Tu-144D
Operator Aeroflot
Registration СССР-77111
Flight origin Ramenskoye Airport
DestinationRamenskoye Airport
Occupants8
Passengers0
Crew8
Fatalities2
Survivors6

The 1978 Yegoryevsk Tu-144 crash occurred during a test flight of a Tupolev Tu-144 on 23 May 1978. The aircraft suffered a fuel leak, which led to an in-flight fire in the right wing, forcing the shutdown of two of the aircraft's four engines. One of the two remaining engines subsequently failed, forcing the crew to make a belly landing in a field near Yegoryevsk, Moscow Oblast. Two flight engineers were killed in the ensuing crash, but the remaining six crew members survived. The accident prompted a ban on passenger flights of the Tu-144, which had already been beset by numerous problems, leading to a lack of interest that ultimately resulted in the Tu-144 program's cancellation.

Contents

Aircraft and crew

The aircraft was a supersonic Tupolev Tu-144D, registered СССР-77111, built at the Voronezh Aircraft Production Association facility and destined for Soviet flag carrier Aeroflot. It had first flown on 27 April 1978 and completed test flights on 12 May, 16 May, and 18 May, as well as another test flight earlier on the day of the accident. The accident flight was to have been the aircraft's sixth test flight. Eight crewmembers were on board. [1] [ self-published source ]

Accident

The aircraft took off from Ramenskoye Airport near Moscow at 17:30 local time on 23 May 1978. The crew intended to perform a series of tests on the aircraft's generators, engines, cabin airtightness, and controllability at 12,000 metres (39,000 ft). Following the completion of the initial series of tests, the crew descended to 3,000 metres (9,800 ft) to test the aircraft's auxiliary power unit (APU). At 18:44:44 local time, the crew started the APU. Shortly thereafter, at 18:49:15, the crew shut off the APU. Nine seconds later, a fire alarm was triggered; the number 3 engine was shut down at 18:49:31. The crew decided to attempt a return to Ramenskoye Airport. At 18:51:14, the number 4 engine shut down. The crew subsequently noticed a burning smell and thick smoke in the cabin. The number one engine then shut down at 18:53:27; with three of the aircraft's four engines shut down, it was impossible to return to the airport. At 18:55:18, the aircraft belly landed in a field in Yegoryevsky District, roughly 46 kilometres (29 mi; 25 nmi) from Ramenskoye Airport. The aircraft touched down with the landing gear retracted, at a speed of approximately 380 km/h (210 kn; 240 mph). The nose cone collapsed on impact, penetrating a compartment in which two flight engineers were seated and killing them both, while the remaining six crewmembers survived the crash. It was not until about an hour after the crash that the fire was extinguished by firefighters. [2]

Investigation

The aircraft crash investigation mainly focused on a fuel leak caused by fatigue failure in the wing's fuel pipeline, particularly in the power plant zone, due to the breakdown of an experimental temperature sensor pipe. The official report concluded the fuel leak likely started at 18:18 hours at a rate of 220 kg/min, totaling an estimated 8000 kg fuel loss. This was due to a loss of seal integrity in connection elements or fuel pipelines. The ignited APU sparked fuel vapor, leading to a fire and engine failure [3]

After the accident, extensive tests found vibrations from internal fuel flow caused unexpected fatigue damage to the fuel pipelines. These unfamiliar vibrations, up to 1500 Hz compared to the expected 100 Hz, combined with certain pipeline cleaning methods, resulted in the premature wear of the pipeline. Other factors included hydraulic shocks from unusually high pressure. New features in the fuel system for the RD-36-51A APU were critical in causing the disaster. [3]

During the acceptance test flight, the crew, aware of an uncalibrated fuel system, ignored the fuel gauges and relied on fuel flowmeters. A fatal error was made when they dismissed instrument readings, despite acknowledging significant fuel reserve discrepancies. The real fuel leak led to fuel accumulation in multiple compartments, including the ones above the APU. The crew ignored evident leak signs and did not delay testing schedules. [3]

An attempt of APU startup, which likely failed due to excess fuel and compressor stall, led to the immediate ignition of fuel across the aircraft. Recorded fire alarm signals from different locations of the aircraft suggest the entire plane was ablaze. Despite challenging emergency conditions, the aircraft managed to land but impacted an unexpected obstacle, causing fatal injuries to flight engineers. [3]

Aftermath

Measures were implemented to prevent similar accidents. All recognized causes were mitigated, with new methods adopted to improve fuel pipeline durability. Remedies were also found to prevent the hydraulic shocks. These issues were specific to the new elements in the RD-36-51A engine fuel system; the fuel system of the previous variant was found to be unaffected, and passed the tests unmodified. [3]

The crash resulted in a ban on passenger flights of the Tu-144. Combined with other issues involving the Tu-144, including an earlier crash at the 1973 Paris Air Show and complaints about reliability and passenger comfort, this caused a lack of interest in the Tu-144, which ultimately led to the demise of the Tu-144 program. [4]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tupolev Tu-144</span> Soviet supersonic passenger airliner

The Tupolev Tu-144 is a Soviet supersonic passenger airliner designed by Tupolev in operation from 1968 to 1999.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tupolev Tu-104</span> Former Soviet airliner

The Tupolev Tu-104 is a retired medium-range, narrow-body, twin turbojet-powered Soviet airliner. It was the second to enter regular service, behind the British de Havilland Comet and was the only jetliner operating in the world from 1956 to 1958, when the British jetliner was grounded due to safety concerns.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tupolev Tu-204</span> Airliner by Tupolev

The Tupolev Tu-204 is a twin-engined medium-range narrow-body jet airliner capable of carrying 210 passengers, designed by Tupolev and produced by Aviastar-SP and Kazan Aircraft Production Association. First introduced in 1989, it was intended to be broadly equivalent to the Boeing 757, with slightly lower range and payload, and had competitive performance and fuel efficiency in its class. It was developed for Aeroflot as a replacement for the medium-range Tupolev Tu-154 trijet. The latest version, with significant upgrades and improvements, is the Tu-204SM, which made its maiden flight on 29 December 2010. In April 2022, United Aircraft Corporation (UAC) announced plans to assemble 70 Tu-214s by 2030.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeroflot Flight 3352</span> 1984 plane crash in Omsk, Russia

Aeroflot Flight 3352 was a regularly scheduled Aeroflot flight from Krasnodar to Novosibirsk, with an intermediate landing in Omsk. While landing at Omsk Airport on Thursday, 11 October 1984, the aircraft crashed into maintenance vehicles on the runway, killing 174 people on board and four on the ground. While a chain of mistakes in airport operations contributed to the accident, its major cause was an air traffic controller falling asleep on duty. As of 2022, this remains the deadliest aviation accident on Russian territory. It was also the deadliest aviation accident involving a Tupolev Tu-154 at the time until the crash of Aeroflot Flight 5143 nine months later; as of 2023, it still ranks as the second-deadliest accident involving a Tupolev Tu-154. The tragedy was kept secret for twenty years, until Komsomolskaya Pravda published an article in 2004.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Baikal Airlines Flight 130</span> 1994 aviation accident

Baikal Airlines Flight 130 was a scheduled domestic passenger flight from Irkutsk to Moscow that crashed on 3 January 1994. The plane involved in the crash was a Tupolev Tu-154 operated by Russian airline Baikal Airlines. The plane was carrying 115 passengers and 9 crew members and was en route to Moscow when one of the engines suddenly burst into flames. The crew then tried to return to Irkutsk, but lost control of the plane and crashed into a dairy farm near the town of Mamony. All 124 people on board and one person on the ground were killed in the crash. The accident was judged to have been caused by a foreign object entering the engine and slicing several crucial lines to the airplane's hydraulic and fuel systems.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Caspian Airlines Flight 7908</span> 2009 plane crash near Qazvin, Iran

Caspian Airlines Flight 7908 was a scheduled commercial flight from Tehran, Iran, to Yerevan, Armenia, that crashed near the village of Jannatabad, outside the city of Qazvin in north-western Iran, on 15 July 2009. All 153 passengers and 15 crew on board died.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kolavia Flight 348</span> 2011 aviation incident

On 1 January 2011, Kolavia Flight 348, a Tupolev Tu-154 on a domestic scheduled passenger flight from Surgut to Moscow, Russia, caught fire while taxiing out for take-off. Passengers were evacuated, but three were killed and 43 injured. A subsequent investigation concluded that the fire had started in an electric panel for which maintenance was never prescribed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeroflot Flight 964</span> October 1973 Tupolev Tu-104 crash in Moscow

Aeroflot Flight 964 was a flight operated by Aeroflot from Kutaisi Airport, Georgia to Domodedovo Airport, Moscow, Russian SFSR. On 13 October 1973, the Tupolev Tu-104 operating on the route crashed during its approach to Moscow, killing all 122 passengers and crew on board. It remains the deadliest accident involving a Tupolev Tu-104.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeroflot Flight 3932</span> 1973 plane crash in the Soviet Union

Aeroflot Flight 3932 was a flight operated by Aeroflot from Koltsovo Airport to Omsk Tsentralny Airport. On 30 September 1973, the Tupolev Tu-104 operating the route crashed shortly after takeoff from Sverdlovsk, killing all 108 passengers and crew on board.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeroflot Flight 7841</span> Soviet passenger flight involved in a 1985 aviation accident

Aeroflot Flight 7841 was a scheduled Soviet domestic passenger flight from Minsk to Leningrad, which crashed on 1 February 1985 killing fifty eight people on board. Twenty-two people survived the accident. The crash was caused by engine failure brought on by ice ingestion. On 8 May 1985 the Tupolev Tu-134A was officially written off.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeroflot Flight 3519</span> 1984 Russian aviation accident

Aeroflot Flight 3519 was a Tupolev Tu-154B-2 airline flight on a domestic route from Krasnoyarsk to Irkutsk on 23 December 1984. Shortly after takeoff, the No. 3 engine caught fire, and the airplane crashed during an emergency landing. This killed 110 people; there was only one survivor, and the aircraft was destroyed. The engine fire was caused by a manufacturing defect in the compressor disk.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeroflot Flight 2306</span> 1986 aviation accident

Aeroflot Flight 2306 was a scheduled domestic passenger flight from Vorkuta to Moscow in the Soviet Union, with a stopover in Syktyvkar. The Tupolev Tu-134 operated by Aeroflot crashed on 2 July 1986 during an emergency landing after it departed Syktyvkar, killing 54 of 92 passengers and crew on board.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeroflot Flight 2415</span> 1976 Soviet aircraft accident

Aeroflot Flight 2415 was a regularly scheduled passenger flight from Moscow to Leningrad that crashed shortly after takeoff on 28 November 1976. The cause of the accident was attributed to crew disorientation as a result of artificial horizon failure in low visibility conditions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeroflot Flight 3739 (1976)</span> 1976 plane crash during takeoff in Irkutsk, Russia

Aeroflot Flight 3739 was a regularly scheduled Russian domestic flight from Irkutsk to Pulkovo Airport in Saint Petersburg that crashed during takeoff from Irkutsk International Airport on 9 February 1976. Twenty-four of the 114 people on board died in the accident.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeroflot Flight 1912</span> 1971 aviation accident in the Soviet Union

Aeroflot Flight 1912 was a scheduled domestic Aeroflot passenger flight on the Odessa-Kiev (Kyiv)-Chelyabinsk-Novosibirsk-Irkutsk-Khabarovsk-Vladivostok route that crashed on 25 July 1971, making a hard landing at Irkutsk Airport. It touched down 150 metres (490 ft) short of the runway, breaking the left wing and catching fire. Of the 126 people on board the aircraft, 29 survived.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeroflot Flight 513</span> 1965 aviation accident

Aeroflot Flight 513 was a domestic scheduled passenger flight operated by Aeroflot that crashed during takeoff from Kuybyshev Airport in the Soviet Union on 8 March 1965, resulting in the deaths of 30 passengers and crew. It was the first fatal accident involving a Tupolev Tu-124.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeroflot Flight 04</span> 1958 aviation accident in the Soviet Union

Aeroflot Flight 04 was a scheduled domestic passenger flight from Khabarovsk to Moscow with a stopover in Irkutsk that crashed on 15 August 1958, killing all 64 passengers and crew aboard the aircraft. It was the first fatal accident involving a Tupolev Tu-104.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeroflot Flight 5484</span> 1979 aviation accident

Aeroflot Flight 5484 was a scheduled domestic passenger flight from Odesa to Kazan with a stopover in Kyiv that experienced loss of control followed by breaking up in the air on 29 August 1979 over the Tambov Oblast, killing all 63 people on board. It remains the deadliest Tu-124 crash and regular passenger services with the Tu-124 were permanently suspended after the accident, but the Tu-124 was still used by the Soviet military after the accident.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeroflot Flight 2022</span> Tupolev Tu-124 crash in 1973

Aeroflot Flight 2022 was a scheduled Soviet domestic passenger flight between Vilnius Airport in Lithuanian SSR and Vnukovo International Airport in Moscow, Russian SFSR, Soviet Union that crashed on 16 December 1973, killing all 51 people on board. The five hundred mile flight suffered a loss of control as a result of a malfunction of its elevator, causing it to crash as it made its final descent into Moscow. At the time of the crash it was the worst accident in aviation history involving a Tupolev Tu-124, since it entered service with Aeroflot in 1962.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aeroflot Flight 6709</span> 1978 Russian aviation accident

Aeroflot Flight 6709 was a Tupolev Tu-154B on a domestic route from Baku to Leningrad on 19 May 1978. While cruising, fuel starvation affected the flow of fuel to the aircraft's three Kuznetsov NK-8 engines, causing the engines to stop. This issue was possibly as a result of poor aircraft design.

References

  1. "Crash of a Tupolev TU-144D in Kladkovo: 2 killed". Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives. Retrieved 14 Nov 2021.
  2. "Катастрофа Ту-144Д Воронежского авиазавода в Егорьевском районе Московской области" [Accident of the Tu-144D of Voronezh Aircraft Plant in Yegoryevsky District of Moscow Oblast] (in Russian). airdisaster.ru. Retrieved 3 Dec 2021.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 Bliznyuk, Valentin; et al. (2000). "Катастрофа самолета Ту-144Д № 77111(06-2) 23.05.78". Правда о сверхзвуковых пассажирских самолетах [Reality of supersonic passenger airplanes]. Moscow: Moskovsky Rabochiy. ISBN   5-239-02044-2.
  4. Prisco, Jacopo (10 Jul 2019). "Concordski: What ever happened to Soviets' spectacular rival to Concorde?". CNN Style. Retrieved 14 Nov 2021.