1994 South Pacific Airmotive DC-3 crash

Last updated

1994 South Pacific Airmotive DC-3 crash
Douglas DC-3, SE-CFP.jpg
DC-3 similar to accident aircraft
Accident
Date24 April 1994 (1994-04-24)
Summary Engine failure, pilot error
Site Sydney Airport, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia
33°56′46″S151°10′38″E / 33.94611°S 151.17722°E / -33.94611; 151.17722
Aircraft
Aircraft type Douglas DC-3
OperatorSouth Pacific Airmotive
Call signECHO DELTA CHARLIE
Registration VH-EDC
Flight originSydney Airport, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia
Stopover Lord Howe Island
Destination Norfolk Island
Occupants25
Passengers21
Crew4
Fatalities0
Injuries1 [1]
Survivors25

The 1994 South Pacific Airmotive DC-3 crash took place on 24 April 1994, when a Douglas DC-3 airliner operated by South Pacific Airmotive, tail number VH-EDC, ditched into Botany Bay shortly after takeoff from Sydney Airport in Sydney, New South Wales, Australia. The cause of the crash was determined by the Bureau of Air Safety Investigation (BASI; now the Australian Transport Safety Bureau, or ATSB) to have been a power loss in the aircraft's left engine caused by an inlet valve being stuck in the open position, compounded by inadequate action on the part of the pilots; Rod Lovell, the pilot in command of the flight, has disputed BASI's conclusions.

Contents

Background

Sydney Airport, pictured in 2016; the DC-3 took off from runway 16R (left) and ditched abeam runway 16L (right). In 1994, runway 16L was still under construction and not suitable for landing. Sydney Airport (Kingsford Smith) - aerial (cropped).jpg
Sydney Airport, pictured in 2016; the DC-3 took off from runway 16R (left) and ditched abeam runway 16L (right). In 1994, runway 16L was still under construction and not suitable for landing.

The accident aircraft was a 50-year-old Douglas DC-3 which was owned and operated by South Pacific Airmotive, a charter airline based in Camden, New South Wales, and was flying under an Air Operators Certificate held by Groupair, which was based at Moorabbin, Victoria. The aircraft had been chartered to transport Scots College band students to Norfolk Island to perform in Anzac Day celebrations; there were twenty-one passengers including a team of journalists from the newspaper The Australian .

A flight plan, submitted by Captain Rod Lovell, indicated that the aircraft was to proceed from Sydney Airport to Norfolk Island, with an intermediate landing at Lord Howe Island to refuel. The flight was to be conducted in accordance with IFR procedures, and would depart from Sydney at 9am. [1]

Accident

Preparations for departure were completed shortly before 9am, and the aircraft was cleared to taxi for runway 16. Captain Lovell occupied the left control position, while his first officer was the handling pilot for the departure. The aircraft was cleared for takeoff at 9.07am. The crew subsequently reported to crash investigators that all engine indications were normal during the take-off roll and that the aircraft was flown off the runway at 81 knots.

During the initial climb, at approximately 200 feet, the crew heard a series of popping sounds above the engine noise. Almost immediately the aircraft began to yaw left, and at 9.04am Lovell advised Sydney air traffic control (ATC) that the aircraft had a problem. The co-pilot determined that the left engine was malfunctioning. The crew subsequently recalled that the aircraft speed at this time had increased to at least 100 knots. Lovell, having verified that the left engine was malfunctioning, closed the left throttle and initiated propeller feathering action. During this period, full power was maintained on the right engine. However, the airspeed began to decay.

The co-pilot reported that he had attempted to maintain 81 KIAS but was unable to do so. The aircraft diverged to the left of the runway centreline. The co-pilot and the supernumerary pilot subsequently reported that almost full right aileron had been used to control the aircraft, but could not recall the skid-ball indication. The co-pilot reported that he had full right rudder or near full right rudder applied. When he first became aware of the engine malfunction, Lovell assessed that, although a landing back on the runway may have been possible, the aircraft was capable of climbing safely on one engine. However, when he determined that the aircraft was not climbing, and that the airspeed had reduced below 81 knots, Lovell took control and at 9.09am advised ATC that he was ditching the aircraft into Botany Bay.

Lovell manoeuvred the aircraft as close as possible to the southern end of the partially constructed runway 16L. The aircraft was ditched approximately forty-six seconds after the captain first advised ATC of the problem. The four crew and twenty-one passengers successfully evacuated through the aircraft's rear door before it sank, and were rescued by nearby fishermen. [2] A photographer from The Australian, having just evacuated the aircraft, took photos of the ditched DC-3 as it sank. The passengers and crew were taken on board pleasure craft and transferred to shore. After initial assessment, they were transported to various hospitals. All were discharged by 2.30pm that afternoon with the exception of the sole flight attendant, who had suffered serious injuries. [1]

Investigation

The crash investigation, conducted by the Bureau of Air Safety Investigation (BASI; now the Australian Transport Safety Bureau, or ATSB), found that the circumstances of the accident were consistent with the left engine having suffered a substantial power loss when an inlet valve became stuck in the open position. The final report singled out the handling pilot's inability to obtain optimum asymmetric performance from the aircraft as the culminating factor in a combination of local and organisational factors that led to this accident. Contributing factors included the overloaded condition of the aircraft, an engine overhaul or maintenance error, non-adherence to operating procedures and lack of skill of the handling pilot.

Organisational factors relating to the plane's operators identified in the BASI report included inadequate communications between South Pacific Airmotive and Groupair, inadequate maintenance management, poor operational procedures and inadequate training. Organisational factors relating to the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) identified in the report included inadequate communications between CAA offices, inadequate communications between the CAA and the plane's operators, poor operational and airworthiness control procedures, inadequate control and monitoring of South Pacific Airmotive, inadequate regulation; and poor training of staff. [3]

Rod Lovell has claimed since the accident that the right engine was not producing rated power. BASI and the CAA refused to acknowledge this and in the final BASI report stated that the Right Engine “had no pre-existing abnormalities”.

However in documents provided by BASI to Rod Lovell a couple of years later found that in the right engine, after strip down, 11 out of the 28 spark plugs, after cleaning, re-gapping and then testing were UNSERVICEABLE.

In 2018, a flight in a DC-3 flight simulator in the Netherlands, confirmed that the right engine was only producing about 65-70% of rated power.

Rod Lovell

Despite being praised by the passengers for his handling of the crisis, Captain Lovell was partly blamed in the BASI report for contributing to the crash and his piloting licence was suspended as a result. Lovell spent the next twenty-five years trying to clear his name and prove that the aircraft was solely at fault for the crash. In 2018, Lovell was invited to the Netherlands to handle the only certified DC-3 flight simulator in the world, and claimed that its outcome demonstrated that "my DC-3 was not producing the power and it had nothing to do with the allegation of above maximum take-off weight." [2] The following year, Lovell released a book, From Hero to Zero, arguing he had been unfairly scapegoated by Australian aviation authorities. [4]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Moorabbin Airport</span> Municipal airport serving Melbourne, Victoria, Australia

Moorabbin Airport is a mostly general aviation airport for light aircraft located in between the southern Melbourne suburbs of Heatherton, Cheltenham, Dingley Village and Mentone. It also receives commercial airline service. The airport grounds are treated as their own suburb, and share the postcode 3194 with the neighbouring suburb of Mentone. With a total of 274,082 aircraft movements, Moorabbin Airport was the second busiest airport in Australia for the calendar year 2011.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Water landing</span> An aircraft landing intentionally on a body of water

In aviation, a water landing is, in the broadest sense, an aircraft landing on a body of water. Seaplanes, such as floatplanes and flying boats, land on water as a normal operation. Ditching is a controlled emergency landing on the water surface in an aircraft not designed for the purpose, a very rare occurrence. Controlled flight into the surface and uncontrolled flight ending in a body of water are generally not considered water landings or ditching.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">S7 Airlines Flight 778</span> 2006 aviation accident

S7 Airlines Flight 778(S7778/SBI778) was a scheduled domestic passenger flight from Moscow to Irkutsk, Russia. On 9 July 2006, at 06:44 local time, the Airbus A310-324 aircraft operating the route overran the runway during its landing in Irkutsk. The aircraft failed to stop and crashed through the airport's concrete perimeter fence, struck rows of private garages and burst into flames, killing 125 people.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pakistan International Airlines Flight 688</span> Aircraft crash in Pakistan, 10 July 2006

Pakistan International Airlines Flight 688 was a domestic passenger flight from Multan to Islamabad with a stopover in Lahore, operated by Pakistan's flag carrier Pakistan International Airlines. On 10 July 2006, the aircraft operating the route, a Fokker F27, crashed into a mango garden after one of its two engines failed shortly after takeoff from Multan International Airport. All 41 passengers and four crewmembers on board were killed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Australian Transport Safety Bureau</span> National transport safety investigator in Australia

The Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) is Australia's national transport safety investigator. The ATSB is the federal government body responsible for investigating transport-related accidents and incidents within Australia. It covers air, sea and rail travel. The ATSB is an independent Commonwealth Government statutory agency, governed by a Commission and is separate from transport regulators, policy makers and service providers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">ALM Flight 980</span> Aviation accident in the Caribbean Sea on 2 May 1970

ALM Antillean Airlines Flight 980 was a flight scheduled to fly from John F. Kennedy International Airport in New York City to Princess Juliana International Airport in St. Maarten, Netherlands Antilles, on 2 May 1970. After several unsuccessful landing attempts, the aircraft's fuel was exhausted, and it made a forced water landing in the Caribbean Sea 48 km off St. Croix, with 23 fatalities and 40 survivors. The accident is one of a small number of intentional water ditchings of jet airliners.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Garuda Indonesia Flight 200</span> 2007 passenger plane crash in Yogyakarta, Indonesia

Garuda Indonesia Flight 200(GA200/GIA 200) was a scheduled domestic passenger flight of a Boeing 737-400 operated by Garuda Indonesia between Jakarta and Yogyakarta, Indonesia. The aircraft overran the runway, crashed into a rice field and burst into flames while landing at Adisucipto International Airport on 7 March 2007. Twenty passengers and one flight attendant were killed. Both pilots survived, and were fired shortly after the accident occurred. It was the fifth hull-loss of a Boeing 737 in Indonesia within less than six months and was the most recent accident with fatalities involving the airline.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alliance Air Flight 7412</span> 2000 aviation accident in Patna, Bihar, India

Alliance Air Flight 7412 was a scheduled Indian domestic passenger flight from Calcutta to Delhi, operated by Indian regional airliner Alliance Air. On 17 July 2000, while on approach to its first stopover in Patna, the Boeing 737-2A8 operating the route nose-dived and crashed into a residential area in Patna, killing 60 people including 5 on the ground.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Advance Airlines Flight 4210</span> 1980 aviation accident in Sydney

Advance Airlines Flight 4210 was a scheduled passenger flight which crashed at Sydney Airport on 21 February 1980, killing all 13 people on board the Advance Airlines Beech Beechcraft King Air 200. After taking off on runway 25 for a scheduled flight the aircraft's left (port) engine failed and the pilot requested an emergency landing on runway 34. The plane crashed into the sea wall while attempting the emergency landing. The accident caused the greatest number of fatalities in a civil aircraft crash in Australia since MacRobertson Miller Airlines Flight 1750, a Vickers Viscount that crashed near Port Hedland in Western Australia on 31 December 1968 killing all 26 on board.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2000 Australia Beechcraft King Air crash</span> Aviation accident in Australia

On 4 September 2000, a chartered Beechcraft 200 Super King Air departed Perth for a flight to the mining town of Leonora, Western Australia. The aircraft crashed near Burketown, Queensland, Australia, resulting in the deaths of all eight occupants. During the flight, the aircraft climbed above its assigned altitude. When air traffic control (ATC) contacted the pilot, the pilot's speech had become significantly impaired, and he was unable to respond to instructions. Three aircraft intercepted the Beechcraft, but were unable to make radio contact. The aircraft continued flying on a straight north-easterly heading for five hours, before exhausting its fuel and crashing 40 mi (65 km) south-east of Burketown. The crash became known in the media as the "ghost flight".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Emirates Flight 407</span> 2009 aviation accident in Melbourne, Australia

Emirates Flight 407 was a scheduled international passenger flight operated by Emirates from Auckland to Dubai with a stopover in Melbourne, operated by an Airbus A340-500 aircraft. On 20 March 2009, the flight failed to take off properly at Melbourne Airport, hitting several structures at the end of the runway before climbing and then returning to the airport for a safe landing. Although no fatalities or injuries resulted, damage to the aircraft was severe enough for the event to be classified by Australian Transport Safety Bureau as an "accident". It was subsequently determined that a data-entry error resulted in insufficient engine thrust during take off. It has been described "as close as we have ever come to a major aviation catastrophe in Australia" by aviation officials.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Airlines PNG Flight 4684</span> 2009 aviation accident

Airlines PNG Flight 4684 (CG4682/TOK4684) was a scheduled domestic passenger flight operated by Papua New Guinean airliner Airlines PNG, flying from Jacksons International Airport in Papua New Guinea's capital Port Moresby to Kokoda Airport in Oro Province, Papua New Guinea. On 11 August 2009, the aircraft operating the flight, a de Havilland Canada Twin Otter, crashed into a forest in Kokoda Valley, a popular trekking site in Papua New Guinea, while carrying 13 people in bad weather. A search and rescue operation was conducted by authorities and found the wreckage of the crashed plane on the next day, 12 August 2009. The aircraft was severely damaged, and searchers found no signs of life. Papua New Guinean Search and Rescue Agency then announced that everyone on board was killed instantly in the crash.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">South African Airlink Flight 8911</span> 2009 aviation accident

South African Airlink Flight 8911 was a positioning flight from Durban International Airport to Pietermaritzburg Airport, South Africa, that crashed into the grounds of Merebank Secondary School, Durban shortly after take-off on 24 September 2009, injuring the three occupants of the aircraft and one on the ground. The captain of the flight subsequently died of his injuries on 7 October 2009.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2009 Pel-Air Westwind ditching</span>

The 2009 Pel-Air Westwind ditching or Norfolk Island ditching was an aircraft accident on 18 November 2009 near Norfolk Island, Australia. A Westwind II jet operated by Pel-Air was conducting an air ambulance flight for CareFlight International when it was forced to ditch after being unable to land in bad weather and not having sufficient fuel to divert to an alternate destination.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Qantas Flight 32</span> Non-fatal 2010 Airbus A380 engine incident

Qantas Flight 32 was a regularly scheduled passenger flight from London to Sydney via Singapore. On 4 November 2010, the aircraft operating the route, an Airbus A380, suffered an uncontained failure in one of its four Rolls-Royce Trent 900 engines. The failure occurred over the Riau Islands, Indonesia, four minutes after takeoff from Singapore Changi Airport. After holding for almost two hours to assess the situation, the aircraft made a successful emergency landing at Changi. No injuries occurred to the passengers, crew, or people on the ground, despite debris from the aircraft falling onto houses in Batam.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">JS Air Flight 201</span> 2010 aviation accident

On 5 November 2010, JS Air Flight 201, a Beechcraft 1900 passenger aircraft on a charter service from Karachi to the Bhit Shah gas field in Sindh, Pakistan, crashed near Karachi's Jinnah International Airport, after suffering an engine malfunction at take-off. All 21 people on board were killed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Georgian Airways Flight 834</span> 2011 aviation accident in Democratic Republic of the Congo

On 4 April 2011, Georgian Airways Flight 834, a Bombardier CRJ100 passenger jet of Georgian Airways operating a domestic flight from Kisangani to Kinshasa in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) crashed while attempting to land at Kinshasa Airport. The aircraft, which was chartered by the United Nations, was trying to land during a thunderstorm. Of the 33 people on board, only one person survived. The incident remains as the United Nations' deadliest aviation disaster. It is also the third-deadliest air disaster involving the CRJ100/200, behind Comair Flight 5191 and China Eastern Airlines Flight 5210.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2012 Queensland DH.84 Dragon crash</span> Air accident in Australia

On 1 October 2012, Riama, a 1934 vintage de Havilland DH.84 Dragon passenger aircraft, crashed in Queensland, Australia, while flying from Monto to Caboolture. Radio contact was lost about an hour after the pilot reported to be in cloud with zero visibility. The wreckage was found in heavily wooded, hilly terrain two days later. The pilot and five passengers were killed in the accident.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Whyalla Airlines Flight 904</span> 2000 aviation accident

Whyalla Airlines Flight 904 was a scheduled commuter flight, operated by a Piper PA-31 Navajo which crashed while attempting to ditch in the Spencer Gulf, South Australia after suffering failures of both engines on the evening of 31 May 2000. All 8 people on board the aircraft were killed as a result of the accident. The findings of a subsequent investigation by the Australian Transport Safety Bureau highlighting the airline's operating procedures as a key factor leading to the accident were later overturned after they were contradicted by evidence presented at a coronial inquiry into the deaths of those on board the flight. The safety implications arising from the accident led to a recall by engine manufacturer Textron Lycoming which saw close to 1000 aircraft grounded worldwide while defects were rectified at an estimated cost of $A66 million. Australia's aviation regulator, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority also mandated lifejackets be carried on all aircraft operating over water after the crash.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2017 Sydney Seaplanes DHC-2 crash</span> Australian plane crash

On 31 December 2017 at about 3:15 pm AEDT (UTC+11:00), a de Havilland Canada DHC-2 Beaver configured as a floatplane crashed into Jerusalem Bay off Cowan Creek, on the northern outskirts of Sydney, Australia. The aircraft, operated by Sydney Seaplanes, was carrying five passengers and a pilot, all of whom were killed in the crash. It was returning diners from Cottage Point Inn restaurant to Rose Bay Water Airport. The ATSB believes it probable that the pilot's performance was adversely affected by carbon monoxide poisoning. Post mortem tests on the bodies of the victims showed raised levels of CO in the blood, and a crack in the exhaust system was seen as the likely source of the gas.

References

  1. 1 2 3 "Crash of a Douglas C-47A-20-DK off Sydney". www.baaa-acro.com. Bureau of Aircraft Accidents Archives. Retrieved 9 January 2022.
  2. 1 2 Trembath, Murray (28 October 2019). "Our own Sully | Pilot 'a scapegoat' in Botany Bay crash". St George & Sutherland Shire Leader. Retrieved 9 January 2022.
  3. Investigation Report 9401043 Archived 12 March 2022 at the Wayback Machine . Bureau of Air Safety Investigation. March 1996. Retrieved 9 January 2022. CC-BY icon.svg Text was copied from this source, which is available under a Attribution 3.0 Australia (CC BY 3.0 AU) license.
  4. Hero pilot tells his extraordinary story of infamous Botany Bay plane crash Archived 9 January 2022 at the Wayback Machine . Manning, Jack. Victor Harbor Times. 5 March 2020. Retrieved 9 January 2022.