Bonisicyon

Last updated

Bonisicyon
Temporal range: Messinian, 6.5–5.3  Ma
Ꞓ
O
S
D
C
P
T
J
K
Pg
N
↓
Scientific classification OOjs UI icon edit-ltr.svg
Domain: Eukaryota
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Class: Mammalia
Order: Carnivora
Family:† Amphicyonidae
Subfamily:† Amphicyoninae
Genus:† Bonisicyon
Werdelin and Simpson, 2009
Type species
†Bonisicyon illacabo
Werdelin and Simpson, 2009

Bonisicyon is an extinct genus of carnivoran mammals, belonging to the family Amphicyonidae ("bear dogs"). It is the last-surviving member of its family, living in East Africa during the end of the Miocene epoch. Known only from a damaged mandible and isolated teeth from the Nawata Formation, and possibly also the Lukeino Formation, its closer taxonomic affinities are unclear. It is notable for both its small size, and its unique dentition. [1]

Contents

History and naming

The first published material belonging to this genus includes a broken mandibular ramus with a damaged m1 and alveoli for m2 and m3, as well as roots for p4, from the Upper Nawata Formation in Lothagam, Kenya. [2] Bonisicyon was described on basis of material found at Gona, Ethiopia, with a right m1 (HMD1/P11) serving as holotype. Other described material includes an isolated left m2 and a damaged right M2. A M1 from Lemudong’o, Kenya, originally referred to the ailurid Simocyon , has also been tentatively attributed to the genus. [1] A P4 discovered at the Kenyan Lukeino Formation has also been proposed to belong to an amphicyonid, as both its age and dimensions are similar to Bonisicyon. [3]

The genus is named in honour of Dr Louis de Bonis, whereas illacabo is the Afar word for (as in "the end of the story"). [1]

Description

Bonisicyon is a rather small amphicyonid. Its body mass has been estimated at 33 kg based on tooth size, though this is likely an overestimation. The relatively slender mandible, and similarities in tooth size to a coyote, suggest that its mass was closer to 20 kg than 30 kg. [4]

The robust m1 is relatively wide at the base of its crown, and possesses an entirely mesiodistal carnassial shear. The tall hypoconid is formed into an elongated crest, and is effectively part of the carnassial shear, only separated from the trigonid by a narrow postvallid notch, which is morphologically similar to the carnassial notch. The trigonid consists of a well-developed paraconid and protoconid, and a reduced metaconid, which is only evidenced as a bulge on the lingual side of the protoconid. The almost entirely mesiodistal carnassial shear only has a very slight angle between paraconid and protoconid. All these features suggest that Bonisicyon was a hypercarnivore. However, it lacks several features usually associated with such a diet, such as taller trigonid cuspids and a shortened talonid. Indeed, the trigonid is relatively short and its cuspids blunt. Therefore, its dentition possesses a peculiar mix of hypercarnivorous and mesocarnivorous features, although the narrowness of the tooth means it lacks a proper crushing basin, therefore pointing towards hypercarnivory. [1] [4]

Other notable features include the paraconid, which is much lower and mesodistally shorter than the tall protoconid, and possesses a very short cristid. The well-developed preprotocristid is expanded slightly dorsally roughly midway between the tooth's apex and the carnassial notch. The postprotocristid is much more vertically oriented in comparison, meeting the talonid at the posterior carnassial notch. The talonid is about half as long as the trigonid, and is dominated by the hypocinid, which is about ⅔ the height of the protoconid and almost reaches the length of the directly distally located protoconid. Elongated into a cristid, it runs the entire length of the talonid and ends in a nearly vertical face dropping to the distal end of the tooth. The talonids lingual part consists of a lingual cristid, which is separated from the hypoconid by a narrow, shallow groove. The two roots are about equally long mesiodistally, although the posterior is perhaps slightly longer. It lacks a basal cingulum, possessing only a modest out-bulging of the enamel. Both the m2 and M1 are very similar to other small and medium-sized amphicyonids. [1]

The m1 of Bonisicyon shares several features with that of Afrocyon , such as the relatively short talonid and reduced metaconid. However, Afrocyon differs in its very tall and relatively transversely thin mandibular ramus and elongated m2. Bonisicyon lacks the peculiar m1 of Myacyon dojambir, and numerous features differentiate it from the similarly sized ?M. peignei. Among these are its taller, more bulbous, but less trenchant paraconid, lower and blunter protoconid and reduced metaconid. In both size and shape, it is most similar to Cynelos/Hecubides euryodon. Their M1 is almost indistinguishable, and their m2 are very similar, although C. euryodon has a less developed metaconid and a more cusp-like hypoconid. Their m1 too shares many similarities, although most of these are shared, primitive characteristics. In comparison, Bonisicyon possesses a much more developed hypoconid and paraconid, a reduced metaconid and a distinct, sharp notch between protoconid and hypoconid.

Classification

By the Late Miocene, the diversity of the Amphicyonidae was decreasing, likely as a result of the Vallesian Crisis, which resulted in the spread of open habitats at the cost of woodlands, and therefore a decline of forest-dwelling species. [1] [5] The last North American amphicyonids disappeared around 9 Ma [6] while poorly known species such as Amphicyon pannonicus survived in Europe until MN11-MN12. Two further obscure taxons (Amphicyon lydekkeri and Amphicyon palaeindicus) from the Indian Subcontinent have been reported to be of Messinian age. [7] If so, they are of similar age to Bonisicyon. However, it has been pointed out that these remains are not securely dated. [8] A recent overview of Siwalik faunas does not include A.palaeindicus in faunal lists that are younger than Vallesian age, [9] whereas A. lydekkeri is reported from the locality Hasnot, which is dated to ca. 7–5.3 Ma. [10] [11] Besides Bonisicyon, a further amphicyonid is known from Lothagam, although from the stratigraphically older Lower Nawata Formation (dating to 7.4 ± 0.1 – 6.5 ± 0.1 Ma). [12] Like most amphicyonids known from the Late Miocene of Africa, these remains have been tentatively assigned to the genus Myacyon . [3] However, despite the geographical and temporal proximity, it shares no close relationship to Bonisicyon. Indeed, all these Late Miocene taxa are very large, in stark contrast to the comparatively small Bonisicyon, suggesting that they're only distantly related. [1] In Europe, the last amphicyonids of similar size disappeared following MN5 (although the much smaller, omnivorous Pseudarctos survived until MN7/8). [13] Some dental features, as well as the lack of any similar forms outside of Africa, suggest that Bonisicyon may be derived from African species of Cynelos (sometimes included in their own, separate genus Hecubides). However, there is a gap of nine million years between these forms, which means the usefulness of this argument is limited until intermediate forms are found. Therefore, Bonisicyon currently stands as a genus of unclear taxonomic affinities, unlike any other amphicyonid of the late Miocene. [1] However, like other African amphicyonids it is included in the tribe Amphicyonini. [14]

Palaeoecology

The Upper Nawata, where the first fossils of Bonisicyon were found, was likely covered by a mixed, although rather open, environment. [1] During this time period, a dry interval led to floodplain vegetation changing from tree savanna to dry or thornbush savanna. [12] As all localities where remains of Bonisicyon were discovered were covered by such habitat, it has been suggested that may have successfully adapted to these new environments, unlike its larger relatives. If that was the case, competition with Eucyon (a medium-sized canid arriving in Africa around this time in Africa), which was better adapted to these environments, may have resulted in the extinction of this amphicyonid. However, more evidence, and especially postcranial remains, are needed to confirm this speculation. [1]

At Lothagam, Bonisicyon shared its habitat with several other carnivorans, such as the machairodontines Lokotunjailurus and Dinofelis , the mustelid Erokomellivora and the hyaena Ictitherium , with which it may have competed for food. [4] Among the small to medium-sized mammals on which it may have preyed are primates, like Parapapio , the aardvark Leptorycteropus, the tiny suid Cainochoerus as well as various rodents. Larger herbivores are represented by various proboscidean, among them Stegotetrabelodon , Anancus and Deinotherium , the hippopotamus Hexaprotodon , rhinos such as Brachypotherium and Ceratotherium , the equid Eurygnathohippus , the giraffe Palaeotragus , the suid Nyanzochoerus and a variety of bovids, including Aepyceros , Tragoportax , Kobus and Hippotragus . [12]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Amphicyonidae</span> Extinct family of carnivores

Amphicyonidae is an extinct family of terrestrial carnivorans belonging to the suborder Caniformia. They first appeared in North America in the middle Eocene, spread to Europe by the late Eocene, and further spread to Asia and Africa by the early Miocene. They had largely disappeared worldwide by the late Miocene, with the latest recorded species at the end of the Miocene in Africa. They were among the first carnivorans to evolve large body size. Amphicyonids are colloquially referred to as "bear-dogs".

<i>Amphicyon</i> Extinct genus of carnivores

Amphicyon is an extinct genus of large carnivorans belonging to the family Amphicyonidae, subfamily Amphicyoninae, from the Miocene epoch. Members of this family received their vernacular name for possessing bear-like and dog-like features. They ranged over North America, Europe, Asia, and Africa.

<i>Ambondro mahabo</i> Species of small mammal from the middle Jurassic of Madagascar

Ambondro mahabo is a mammal from the Middle Jurassic (Bathonian) Isalo III Formation of Madagascar. The only described species of the genus Ambondro, it is known from a fragmentary lower jaw with three teeth, interpreted as the last premolar and the first two molars. The premolar consists of a central cusp with one or two smaller cusps and a cingulum (shelf) on the inner, or lingual, side of the tooth. The molars also have such a lingual cingulum. They consist of two groups of cusps: a trigonid of three cusps at the front and a talonid with a main cusp, a smaller cusp, and a crest at the back. Features of the talonid suggest that Ambondro had tribosphenic molars, the basic arrangement of molar features also present in marsupial and placental mammals. It is the oldest known mammal with putatively tribosphenic teeth; at the time of its discovery it antedated the second oldest example by about 25 million years.

<i>Agnotherium</i> Extinct genus of carnivores

Agnotherium is a genus of large sized carnivoran mammals, belonging to the Amphicyonidae, which has been found in Western Europe, and possibly China and Northern Africa, and lived during the Late Miocene epoch. Despite only being known from fragmentary remains, the genus notable for hypercarnivorous adaptions, which have been said to represent the "apex" among its family.

Gobicyon is an extinct genus of large-sized carnivoran mammals, belonging to the Amphicyonidae, that was discovered in China, Mongolia, and Serbia, and lived during the Middle Miocene epoch. Despite only being known from rather fragmentary remains, recent discoveries showcase that it was an aberrant member of the subfamily Haplocyoninae, with adaptions towards bone-crushing similar to those of a hyaena.

<i>Triaenops goodmani</i> Species of mammal

Triaenops goodmani is an extinct bat from Madagascar in the genus Triaenops. It is known from three lower jaws collected in a cave at Anjohibe in 1996, and described as a new species in 2007. The material is at most 10,000 years old. A bat humerus from the same site could not be identified as either T. goodmani or the living T. menamena. T. goodmani is identifiable as a member of Triaenops or the related genus Paratriaenops by a number of features of the teeth, such as the single-cusped, canine-like fourth premolar and the presence of a gap between the entoconid and hypoconulid cusps on the first two molars. T. goodmani is larger than the living species of Triaenops and Paratriaenops on Madagascar, and on the first molar the protoconid cusp is only slightly higher than the hypoconid, not much higher as in the other species.

Donodontidae is an extinct family of cladotherian mammals known from the Late Jurassic and Early Cretaceous of North Africa. When originally named in 1991, Donodontidae was a monotypic family containing a single species: Donodon perscriptoris. In 2022, four more species were designated and placed within the family: Donodon minor, Stylodens amerrukensis, Anoualestes incidens, and Amazighodon orbis. All five species are endemic to the Ksar Metlili Formation of Morocco, which is dated to the Tithonian and Berriasian. Donodontid fossils are restricted to postcanine teeth and associated jaw fragments.

Dermotherium is a genus of fossil mammals closely related to the living colugos, a small group of gliding mammals from Southeast Asia. Two species are recognized: D. major from the Late Eocene of Thailand, based on a single fragment of the lower jaw, and D. chimaera from the Late Oligocene of Thailand, known from three fragments of the lower jaw and two isolated upper molars. In addition, a single isolated upper molar from the Early Oligocene of Pakistan has been tentatively assigned to D. chimaera. All sites where fossils of Dermotherium have been found were probably forested environments and the fossil species were probably forest dwellers like living colugos, but whether they had the gliding adaptations of the living species is unknown.

<i>Afrasia djijidae</i> Eocene fossil primate from Myanmar

Afrasia djijidae is a fossil primate that lived in Myanmar approximately 37 million years ago, during the late middle Eocene. The only species in the genus Afrasia, it was a small primate, estimated to weigh around 100 grams (3.5 oz). Despite the significant geographic distance between them, Afrasia is thought to be closely related to Afrotarsius, an enigmatic fossil found in Libya and Egypt that dates to 38–39 million years ago. If this relationship is correct, it suggests that early simians dispersed from Asia to Africa during the middle Eocene and would add further support to the hypothesis that the first simians evolved in Asia, not Africa. Neither Afrasia nor Afrotarsius, which together form the family Afrotarsiidae, is considered ancestral to living simians, but they are part of a side branch or stem group known as eosimiiforms. Because they did not give rise to the stem simians that are known from the same deposits in Africa, early Asian simians are thought to have dispersed from Asia to Africa more than once prior to the late middle Eocene. Such dispersals from Asia to Africa also were seen around the same time in other mammalian groups, including hystricognathous rodents and anthracotheres.

Indraloris is a fossil primate from the Miocene of India and Pakistan in the family Sivaladapidae. Two species are now recognized: I. himalayensis from Haritalyangar, India and I. kamlialensis from the Pothohar Plateau, Pakistan. Other material from the Potwar Plateau may represent an additional, unnamed species. Body mass estimates range from about 2 kg (4.4 lb) for the smaller I. kamlialensis to over 4 kg (8.8 lb) for the larger I. himalayensis.

Exiguodon is an extinct genus of hyainailourid hyaenodont mammal of the subfamily Hyainailourinae. Remains are known from early Miocene deposits in Kenya and Uganda, in East Africa.

Ammitocyon is a genus of large sized carnivoran mammals, belonging to the Amphicyonidae, that lived during the Late Miocene in what is now Spain. It is notable for its extreme adaptations towards hypercarnivory, its extremely robust skeleton, and was one of the last surviving members of its family.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thaumastocyoninae</span> Extinct subfamily of amphicyonids

Thaumastocyoninae is an extinct subfamily of amphicyonids, large terrestrial carnivores, which inhabited what is now Europe during the Miocene epoch. The subfamily was erected by Hürzeler (1940), and is defined by the complete suppression of m1 metaconid, reduction of the premolars, except the p4, which is reinforced, and the oblique abrasion of the teeth, and the possession of hypercarnivorous tendencies. Thaumastocyonines are poorly known, with only about 65 dental specimens, most of those isolated teeth, being known as of 2020, although more complete remains have recently been discovered.

Katifelis is an extinct genus of felids that lived in what is now Kenya during the Early Miocene and is notable for its dental features, which are intermediate between basal and modern cats. It contains a single species, Katifelis nightingalei.

Diamantofelis is an extinct genus of felids that lived in what is now Namibia during the Early Miocene. It contains a single species, Diamantofelis ferox.

Namafelis is an extinct genus of felids that lived in what is now Namibia during the Early Miocene. It contains a single species, Namafelis minor. Closely related to Diamantofelis, it is of “Pseudaelurus-grade”, and therefore a rather basal member of the cat family.

Myacyon is an extinct genus of large sized carnivoran mammals, belonging to the family Amphicyonidae, that lived in Africa during the Miocene epoch. Due to the limited scope and fragmentary nature of the severely damaged holotype, as well as the illustrations in its descriptions, which have been called inadequate, usage of this genus poses serious issues. However, it is notable for being one of the last surviving members of its family and its adaptions to hypercarnivory. Its relationships to other amphicyonids are obscure, and it is not closely related to Bonisicyon, the other late surviving African genus, although it has been proposed that it descends from a species of Cynelos or Namibiocyon.

Namibiocyon is an extinct genus of carnivoran mammals, belonging to the family Amphicyonidae, that lived in Namibia during the Early Miocene epoch. Before the erection of this taxon in 2022, the type and only species, N. ginsburgi, had been assigned to a variety of other genera. It is notable for its adaptions toward hypercarnivory.

<i>Lonchocyon</i> Extinct genus of mammals

Lonchocyon is an extinct genus of arctoid carnivorans, with possible affinities to amphicyonids or hemicyonine bears. It contains a single species, Lonchocyon qiui, known from a single left mandible discovered at the fossil-bearing locality Haerhada at the base of the Baron Sog Formation, which is located in Inner Mongolia, China, and dates to the late Eocene. This taxon is notable for its large size in comparison to other arctoid carnivorans of the Eocene epoch, and for its hypercarnivorous adaptions, most notably its large canine and strongly reduced premolars. The genus name is a combination of Greek lonch, meaning spear and referencing the spear-like paraconid on its lower carnassial, and cyon, meaning dog. The specific name honours Professor Zhan-Xiang Qiu.

Alagtsavbaatar is an extinct species of carnivorous cat-like carnivoran belonging to the superfamily Aeluroidea. It was endemic to Asia, with all known specimens being found in Mongolia, and lived during the late Eocene epoch. It is a monotypic genus, with the type and only known species being A. indigenus, and is named after the Alag Tsav locality where its remains were first discovered.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Werdelin, Lars; Simpson, Scott W. (2009). "The last amphicyonid (Mammalia, Carnivora) in Africa". Geodiversitas. 31 (4): 775–787. doi:10.5252/g2009n4a775. ISSN   1280-9659. S2CID   73677723.
  2. ↑ Werdelin, Lars (2003-01-23), "Mio-Pliocene Carnivora from Lothagam, Kenya", Lothagam (in German), Columbia University Press, pp. 261–328, doi:10.7312/leak11870-013, ISBN   978-0-231-50760-8 , retrieved 2023-02-27
  3. 1 2 Morales, Jorge; Pickford, M.; Valenciano, Alberto (2016). "Systematics of African Amphicyonidae, with descriptions of new material from Napak (Uganda) and Grillental (Namibia)". Journal of Iberian Geology. 42 (2): 131–150. doi:10.13039/501100003329. hdl:10261/137042. ISSN   1698-6180.
  4. 1 2 3 Otto, Oksanen (2017). Feeding ecology of Lothagam and Koobi Fora fossil carnivorans (Thesis). University of Helsinki.
  5. ↑ Agustí, Jordi; Cabrera, Lluís; Garcés, Miguel (2013-01-01). "The Vallesian Mammal Turnover: A Late Miocene record of decoupled land-ocean evolution". Geobios. 46 (1): 151–157. Bibcode:2013Geobi..46..151A. doi:10.1016/j.geobios.2012.10.005. ISSN   0016-6995.
  6. ↑ Hunt, Robert (1998-01-01). "Amphicyonidae". Mammalogy Papers: University of Nebraska State Museum.
  7. ↑ Barry, J. C.; Lindsay, E. H.; Jacobs, L. L. (1982-02-01). "A biostratigraphic zonation of the middle and upper siwaliks of the potwar plateau of Northern Pakistan". Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. The geochronology and biochronology of the Siwalik Group, Pakistan. 37 (1): 95–130. Bibcode:1982PPP....37...95B. doi:10.1016/0031-0182(82)90059-1. ISSN   0031-0182.
  8. ↑ Morales, J.; Brewer, P.; Pickford, M. (March 2010). "Carnivores (Creodonta and Carnivora) from the basal middle Miocene of Gebel Zelten, Libya, with a note on a large amphicyonid from the middle Miocene of Ngorora, Kenya". Bulletin of the Tethys Geological Society. 5: 43–54 – via ResearchGate.
  9. ↑ Nanda, A. C.; Sehgal, R. K.; Chauhan, P. R. (2018-08-15). "Siwalik-age faunas from the Himalayan Foreland Basin of South Asia". Journal of Asian Earth Sciences. Emergence and Evolution of Himalayan Foreland Basin. 162: 54–68. Bibcode:2018JAESc.162...54N. doi:10.1016/j.jseaes.2017.10.035. ISSN   1367-9120. S2CID   134929306.
  10. ↑ Jasinski, Steven E.; Abbas, Sayyed Ghyour; Mahmood, Khalid; Babar, Muhammad Adeeb; Khan, Muhammad Akbar (2022-11-03). "New Carnivoran (Mammalia: Carnivora) specimens from the Siwaliks of Pakistan and India and their faunal and evolutionary implications". Historical Biology. 35 (11): 2217–2252. doi:10.1080/08912963.2022.2138376. ISSN   0891-2963. S2CID   253346978.
  11. ↑ Khan, Muhammad Akbar; Akhtar, Muhammad; Iliopoulos, George (2014-09-01). "Cervid remains from the middle Siwaliks of Hasnot (Late Miocene), Pakistan". Journal of the Geological Society of India. 84 (3): 352–360. doi:10.1007/s12594-014-0139-6. ISSN   0974-6889. S2CID   128757418.
  12. 1 2 3 Leakey, Meave G.; Harris, John Michael (2003). Lothagam: The Dawn of Humanity in Eastern Africa. Columbia University Press. ISBN   978-0-231-11870-5.
  13. ↑ Solé, Floréal; Lesport, Jean-François; Heitz, Antoine; Mennecart, Bastien (2022-06-15). "A new gigantic carnivore (Carnivora, Amphicyonidae) from the late middle Miocene of France". PeerJ. 10: e13457. doi: 10.7717/peerj.13457 . ISSN   2167-8359. PMC   9206431 . PMID   35726261.
  14. ↑ Morales, Jorge; Pickford, Martin (2022). "The taxonomic status of "Ysengrinia" ginsburgi Morales et al. 1998 (Amphicyonidae, Carnivora) from the basal middle Miocene of Arrisdrift, Namibia" (PDF). Communications of the Geological Survey of Namibia. 24: 1–16 – via Google Scholar.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.