Einstein Telescope

Last updated
Einstein Telescope
Website www.et-gw.eu OOjs UI icon edit-ltr-progressive.svg

Einstein Telescope (ET), is a proposed third-generation ground-based gravitational wave (GW) detector, currently under study by some institutions in the European Union. It will be able to test Einstein's general theory of relativity in strong field conditions, realize precision gravitational wave astronomy and enable multi-messenger astronomy.

Contents

The initial design study project was supported by the European Commission under the Framework Programme 7 (FP7). It concerned the study and the conceptual design for a new research infrastructure in the emergent field of gravitational-wave astronomy. The ET Project was accepted onto the roadmap of the European Strategy Forum on Research Infrastructures in 2021. [1] In 2022, the ET Collaboration was founded as the organization of scientists working on the realization and future operation of the ET. [2] In 2025, support for ET was expressed on the national levels: the governments of Netherlands [3] and Belgium [4] set ET as one of the national priorities; the German government placed ET on a shortlist for large scientific infrastructures [5] and highlighted as a top European scientific project in a coalition agreement; [6] the regional Italian governement set ET as one of the top priorities, [7] following previously expressed commitment by the national government. [8] It is expected that in 2026 the site location will be announced, with construction starting in 2028 and the detector launch in 2035. [9]

Motivation

Second generation gravitational-wave detectors, Advanced Virgo, Advanced LIGO and KAGRA, are approaching their design sensitivity, with the final set of updates completed by the fifth observational run in 2028. [10] Future possible upgrades would reach the facility limits, imposed by the external factors, such as the achievable arm length and local seismology. Many science cases require significant sensitivity increase towards low frequencies, where current detectors are fundamentally limited by seismic noise.

The strategy for the third generation gravitational-wave detectors, which includes Einstein Telescope and proposed Cosmic Explorer in the US, is to significantly increase the arm length and laser power in the arms. Einstein Telescope further aims to increase the sensitivity towards signals at a few Hz by going deep underground and suppressing thermal noise of its mirrors and suspensions with cryogenic operation.

The main science case for the Einstein Telescope includes, among others: [11]

Detector design

The goal of the detector design is to achieve high sensitivity (~ factor of 10 compared to the existing detectors) in a frequency band from a few Hz to >2 kHz. The main limitations to the sensitivity of the detector are: [12] [13]

Increasing the light power circulating in the arms increases the sensitivity of a detector. However, due to the light absorption in the material, high laser power is not compatible with cryogenic operation. Therefore, ET features a so-called xylophone configuration, [23] where two co-located interferometers target two different frequency bands: low frequency (LF) between ~2 Hz and 30 Hz and high frequency (HF) between 30 Hz and 2kHz:

Generally, using long arms allows to increase the detector sensitivity. There are two alternative designs that feature 10km (triangle configuration) and 15km (2-L configuration).

Both configurations come with their own advantages and challenges. [24]

Prototypes

A number of prototyping activities, dedicated to various aspects of ET technology, are operating or under development.

ETpathfinder

A prototype, or testing facility, called the ETpathfinder was built at Maastricht University's Randwyck Campus in the Netherlands. [25] The facility was opened in November 2021 by Dutch Minister of Education, Culture and Science, Ingrid van Engelshoven. Project leader is Professor Stefan Hild. A focus of the facility is the development of technologies for cryogenic gravitational wave detectors. [26] ETpathfinder will be a useful research centre in its own right after the ET has been built. [27] [28] [29]

E-TEST

A prototype of a large suspended mirror at a cryogenic temperature under construciton in Liège, Belgium. [30]

CAOS

A center in Perguia, Italy, dedicated to testing mechanical and optical systems for ET. [31]

WAVE

An initiative in Hamburg, Germany, dedicated to testing environmental monitoring and Newtonian noise mitigation for ET, among other goals. [32]

AEI-10m

A 10m interferometer prototype in Hanover, Germany, targeted at ultra-low noise performance for testing prototype technologies. [33]

Site location

Several geographic locations are considered as possible sites hosting Einstein Telescope.

The Meuse-Rhine Euroregion proposal

Source: [34]

In 2015, the Meuse-Rhine Euroregion, specifically the rural area between Maastricht, Liège and Aachen, was mentioned as one of the ET's possible sites. The Meuse-Rhine Euroregion has stable ground with little disturbance to the environment. But it also has a network of knowledge partners to cooperate with, companies that can supply the high-tech, and pleasant, accessible living and working environments.

The Einstein Telescope in the Meuse-Rhine Euroregion involves a triangular-shaped tunnel with arms of 10 kilometres long. The telescope will be located 250 to 300 metres underground. At the three vertices there will be large underground chambers. Laser beams run through the 10-kilometre arms, the tunnel tubes. A laser beam is split into two beams and these are reflected by mirrors at the ends of the arms in the underground chambers. From the three vertices, a lift will reach ground level. Maintenance will be carried out inside the tunnel via these shafts.

From 2021, Nikhef will carry out exploratory drilling in Terziet, Banholt, Cottessen and various locations in the German-Belgian border area. In April 2022, the Dutch gouvernment made €42 million available from the National Growth Fund for preparatory work of the ET and also reserved €870 million for construction. As the Einstein Telescope is an international project, the Netherlands, Belgium and Germany are cooperating in feasibility studies for the telescope in the Meuse-Rhine Euroregion. For example, studies are under way into the differences in planning laws and regulations and their significance for the project. Ultimately, these feasibility studies should lead to a bid book, which will be ready in 2025 at the earliest.

The Italian proposal

Source: [35]

The Italian government is ready to support the candidacy of Sos Enattos (Sardinia) as a place for the construction of the telescope together with the Nobel prizewinner Giorgio Parisi. [36] [37] [38]

Sos Enattos was chosen for the functional characteristics of the project [39] of the site on the island:

In January 2021 seismological surveys were carried out to validate the site, installing 15 seismometric stations near the Sos Enattos mine. [44]

In September 2022, the Draghi government mandated the president of INFN Antonio Zoccoli to proceed with the creation of Italy's candidacy dossier, [45] [46] confirming the 350 million euro of economic commitment already allocated by the Sardinia Region. [47]

Saxony proposal

In 2024, the government of Saxony (Germany) has proposed [48] [49] the third candidate site in the Lusatia region of Saxony as a part of the German Center for Astrophysics (Deutsches Zentrum für Astrophysik, DZA). [50] Geological characteristics of the region feature a large granite massif that provides exceptional seismic stability. [51]

Technical groups of ET-FP7

Through its four technical working groups, the ET-FP7 project is addressing the basic questions in the realization of this proposed observatory: site location and characteristics (WP1), suspension design and technologies (WP2), detector topology and geometry (WP3), detection capabilities requirements and astrophysics potentialities (WP4).

Participants

ET is a design study project in the European Framework Programme (FP7). It has been proposed by 8 European leading gravitational wave experimental research institutes, coordinated by the European Gravitational Observatory: [52]

See also

References

  1. 'ET | ESFRI Roadmap 2021', roadmap2021.esfri.eu.
  2. 'The birth of the ET collaboration', www.et-gw.eu, 14 June 2022.
  3. Vijgen, Nicole (2025-02-11). "Government of the Netherlands: Einstein Telescope is national priority". Einstein Telescope. Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  4. Vijgen, Nicole (2025-02-04). "New government of Belgium embraces Einstein Telescope". Einstein Telescope. Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  5. Vijgen, Nicole (2025-07-08). "Einstein Telescope on German shortlist for scientific projects". Einstein Telescope. Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  6. Vijgen, Nicole (2025-04-23). "'German coalition agreement is a major success for the EMR-region'". Einstein Telescope. Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  7. Nobile, Gloria (2025-06-20). "ET, THE REGIONAL GOVERNMENT ESTABLISHES THE STEERING COMMITTEE TO STRENGTHEN SOS ENATTOS' CANDIDACY". Einstein Telescope Italia. Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  8. matteo.serra (2023-12-13). "THE ITALIAN GOVERNMENT STRENGTHENS THE EINSTEIN TELESCOPE CANDIDACY". Einstein Telescope Italia. Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  9. "Organisation and timeline". Einstein Telescope. Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  10. "IGWN | Observing Plans". observing.docs.ligo.org. Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  11. Abac, Adrian; Abramo, Raul; Albanesi, Simone; Albertini, Angelica; Agapito, Alessandro; Agathos, Michalis; Albertus, Conrado; Andersson, Nils; Andrade, Tomás (2025-03-15), The Science of the Einstein Telescope, arXiv: 2503.12263 , retrieved 2025-07-13
  12. Hild, S; Abernathy, M; Acernese, F; Amaro-Seoane, P; Andersson, N; Arun, K; Barone, F; Barr, B; Barsuglia, M; Beker, M; Beveridge, N; Birindelli, S; Bose, S; Bosi, L; Braccini, S (2011-04-19). "Sensitivity studies for third-generation gravitational wave observatories". Classical and Quantum Gravity. 28 (9): 094013. arXiv: 1012.0908 . Bibcode:2011CQGra..28i4013H. doi:10.1088/0264-9381/28/9/094013. ISSN   0264-9381.
  13. Punturo, M; Abernathy, M; Acernese, F; Allen, B; Andersson, N; Arun, K; Barone, F; Barr, B; Barsuglia, M; Beker, M; Beveridge, N; Birindelli, S; Bose, S; Bosi, L; Braccini, S (2010-09-21). "The Einstein Telescope: a third-generation gravitational wave observatory". Classical and Quantum Gravity. 27 (19): 194002. doi:10.1088/0264-9381/27/19/194002. hdl: 11858/00-001M-0000-0011-2EC1-3 . ISSN   0264-9381.
  14. Harms, Jan (2019-10-14). "Terrestrial gravity fluctuations". Living Reviews in Relativity. 22 (1) 6. arXiv: 1507.05850 . doi:10.1007/s41114-019-0022-2. ISSN   1433-8351.
  15. Harms, Jan; Venkateswara, Krishna (2016-10-28). "Newtonian-noise cancellation in large-scale interferometric GW detectors using seismic tiltmeters" . Classical and Quantum Gravity. 33 (23): 234001. Bibcode:2016CQGra..33w4001H. doi:10.1088/0264-9381/33/23/234001. ISSN   0264-9381.
  16. Lucia, Trozzo; Francesca, Badaracco (2022-02-22). "Seismic and Newtonian Noise in the GW Detectors". Galaxies. 10 (1): 20. Bibcode:2022Galax..10...20T. doi: 10.3390/galaxies10010020 . ISSN   2075-4434.
  17. Bertocco, A; Bruno, M; De Rosa, R; Di Fiore, L; D’Urso, D; Frasconi, F; Gennai, A; Lucchesi, L; Refat, M; Pilo, F; Rozza, D; Ruggi, P; Sipala, V; Tosta e Melo, I; Trozzo, L (2024-05-08). "New Generation of Superattenuator for Einstein Telescope: preliminary studies". Classical and Quantum Gravity. 41 (11): 117004. Bibcode:2024CQGra..41k7004B. doi: 10.1088/1361-6382/ad407e . ISSN   0264-9381.
  18. Matichard, F; Lantz, B; Mittleman, R; Mason, K; Kissel, J; Abbott, B; Biscans, S; McIver, J; Abbott, R; Abbott, S; Allwine, E; Barnum, S; Birch, J; Celerier, C; Clark, D (2015-08-24). "Seismic isolation of Advanced LIGO: Review of strategy, instrumentation and performance". Classical and Quantum Gravity. 32 (18): 185003. arXiv: 1502.06300 . Bibcode:2015CQGra..32r5003M. doi:10.1088/0264-9381/32/18/185003. ISSN   0264-9381.
  19. Rowan, S.; Hough, J.; Crooks, D. R. M. (2005-11-14). "Thermal noise and material issues for gravitational wave detectors" . Physics Letters A. Einstein Special Issue. 347 (1): 25–32. doi:10.1016/j.physleta.2005.06.055. ISSN   0375-9601.
  20. Koroveshi, Xhesika; Busch, Lennard; Majorana, Ettore; Puppo, Paola; Rapagnani, Piero; Ricci, Fulvio; Ruggi, Paolo; Grohmann, Steffen (2023-12-07). "Cryogenic payloads for the Einstein Telescope: Baseline design with heat extraction, suspension thermal noise modeling, and sensitivity analyses". Physical Review D. 108 (12): 123009. arXiv: 2305.01419 . doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.108.123009.
  21. Danilishin, Stefan L.; Khalili, Farid Ya. (2012-04-26). "Quantum Measurement Theory in Gravitational-Wave Detectors". Living Reviews in Relativity. 15 (1): 5. arXiv: 1203.1706 . Bibcode:2012LRR....15....5D. doi: 10.12942/lrr-2012-5 . ISSN   1433-8351. PMC   5256003 . PMID   28179836.
  22. Mikhail, Korobko (2025-02-05). "Quantum Technologies for the Einstein Telescope". Galaxies. 13 (1): 11. doi: 10.3390/galaxies13010011 . ISSN   2075-4434.
  23. Hild, S; Abernathy, M; Acernese, F; Amaro-Seoane, P; Andersson, N; Arun, K; Barone, F; Barr, B; Barsuglia, M; Beker, M; Beveridge, N; Birindelli, S; Bose, S; Bosi, L; Braccini, S (2011-04-19). "Sensitivity studies for third-generation gravitational wave observatories". Classical and Quantum Gravity. 28 (9): 094013. arXiv: 1012.0908 . Bibcode:2011CQGra..28i4013H. doi:10.1088/0264-9381/28/9/094013. ISSN   0264-9381.
  24. Branchesi, Marica; Maggiore, Michele; Alonso, David; Badger, Charles; Banerjee, Biswajit; Beirnaert, Freija; Belgacem, Enis; Bhagwat, Swetha; Boileau, Guillaume; Borhanian, Ssohrab; Brown, Daniel David; Leong Chan, Man; Cusin, Giulia; Danilishin, Stefan L.; Degallaix, Jerome (2023-07-01). "Science with the Einstein Telescope: a comparison of different designs". Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics. 2023 (7): 068. arXiv: 2303.15923 . Bibcode:2023JCAP...07..068B. doi:10.1088/1475-7516/2023/07/068. ISSN   1475-7516.
  25. Prototype Einstein Telescope komt in pand 'zwarte doos' in Maastricht, 6 August 2019
  26. Utina, A.; et al. (10 Jun 2022). "ETpathfinder: A cryogenic testbed for interferometric gravitational-wave detectors". Classical and Quantum Gravity. 39 (21). arXiv: 2206.04905 . Bibcode:2022CQGra..39u5008U. doi:10.1088/1361-6382/ac8fdb.
  27. 'Looking back on ETpathfinder's opening', maastrichtuniversity.nl, 9 November 2021.
  28. 'ET - Site Studies and Characterization', agenda.infn.it, 20 August 2022.
  29. 'ET SPB and WP4 of ET-PP', 'indico.ego-gw.it', 20 August 2022.
  30. "E-TEST – Einstein Telescope EMR Site & Technology" . Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  31. matteo.serra (2024-04-22). "ET: A NEW STEP TOWARDS THE REALIZATION OF THE CAOS LABORATORY". Einstein Telescope Italia. Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  32. WAVE (2024-10-25). "WAVE and the Einstein Telescope". WAVE. Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  33. "AEI 10 m Prototype". 2023-09-15. Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  34. "Home". Einstein Telescope (in Dutch). Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  35. "Home". Einstein Telescope Italia (in Italian). Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  36. "Einstein Telescope, presto l'annuncio della candidatura italiana - Scienza & Tecnica". ANSA.it (in Italian). 2023-03-07. Retrieved 2023-03-18.
  37. "It's official! Italy on the race for the Einstein Telescope | GARR". www.garr.it. Retrieved 2023-03-18.
  38. "Home". ET (in Italian). Retrieved 2023-05-12.
  39. 1 2 "Einstein Telescope, la sfida sarda per il futuro". L'Unione Sarda.it (in Italian). 2020-11-25. Retrieved 2023-03-18.
  40. Di Giovanni, Matteo; Giunchi, Carlo; Saccorotti, Gilberto; Berbellini, Andrea; Boschi, Lapo; Olivieri, Marco; De Rosa, Rosario; Naticchioni, Luca; Oggiano, Giacomo; Carpinelli, Massimo; d'Urso, Domenico; Cuccuru, Stefano; Sipala, Valeria; Calloni, Enrico; Di Fiore, Luciano; Grado, Aniello; Migoni, Carlo; Cardini, Alessandro; Paoletti, Federico; Fiori, Irene; Harms, Jan; Majorana, Ettore; Rapagnani, Piero; Ricci, Fulvio; Punturo, Michele; et al. (Matteo Di Giovanni, Carlo Giunchi, Gilberto Saccorotti, Andrea Berbellini, Lapo Boschi, Marco Olivieri, Rosario De Rosa, Luca Naticchioni, Giacomo Oggiano, Massimo Carpinelli, Domenico D’Urso, Stefano Cuccuru, Valeria Sipala, Enrico Calloni, Luciano Di Fiore, Aniello Grado, Carlo Migoni, Alessandro Cardini, Federico Paoletti, Irene Fiori, Jan Harms, Ettore Majorana, Piero Rapagnani, Fulvio Ricci, Michele Punturo) (2020). "A Seismological Study of the Sos Enattos Area—the Sardinia Candidate Site for the Einstein Telescope" . Seismological Research Letters. 92: 352–364. doi:10.1785/0220200186. S2CID   228918534.
  41. "Un'ex miniera in Sardegna è fra i siti più 'silenziosi' del mondo". Agi (in Italian). 17 November 2020. Retrieved 2023-03-18.
  42. 1 2 "Einstein Telescope – INFN – Sezione di Cagliari" (in Italian). Retrieved 2023-03-18.
  43. "Einstein Telescope, progetto da 4,5 mld e 36 mila occupati - Sardegna". Agenzia ANSA (in Italian). 2022-03-16. Retrieved 2023-03-18.
  44. Inaf, Redazione Media (2021-01-20). "Einstein Telescope, iniziano le misure geofisiche". MEDIA INAF (in Italian). Retrieved 2023-03-18.
  45. "Dal Governo sostegno alla proposta di ospitare l'Einstein Telescope in Italia | www.governo.it". 2022-09-27. Archived from the original on 2022-09-27. Retrieved 2023-03-18.
  46. "Draghi backs hosting Einstein Telescope in Sardinia - English". ANSA.it. 2022-09-27. Retrieved 2023-03-18.
  47. Stampa, Ufficio (2022-03-16). "Progetto Einstein Telescope in IV Commissione. "Occasione unica per la Sardegna". La Regione pronta a investire 350 milioni di euro". Consiglio regionale della Sardegna (in Italian). Retrieved 2023-03-18.
  48. "Lusatia Proposed Candidacy as Site for ET – Einstein Teleskop Deutschland" (in German). Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  49. Vries, Gieljan de (2024-12-06). "Saxony also wants to build the Einstein Telescope". Einstein Telescope. Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  50. "Start | DZA | Deutsches Zentrum für Astrophysik". www.deutscheszentrumastrophysik.de. Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  51. "Research | DZA | Deutsches Zentrum für Astrophysik". www.deutscheszentrumastrophysik.de. Retrieved 2025-07-13.
  52. ET Design Study Participants Archived 2016-08-15 at the Wayback Machine 10 October 2008.

Further reading