Reasons of the Supreme Court of Canada by Justice Karakatsanis

Last updated

This is a list of the reasons written by Justice Karakatsanis during her tenure as puisne justice of the Supreme Court of Canada.

Contents

By year

2012

Statistics
4
Majority or Plurality
0
Concurrence
0
Other
0
Dissent
0
Concurrence/dissentTotal = 4
Written opinions = 4Oral opinions = 0 Unanimous decisions = 3
Case nameIssueCo-authored byJoined by
R v Tse
2012 SCC 16
Whether s. 184.4 of the Criminal Code infringes the right to be free from unreasonable search and seizure under s. 8 of the Charter Moldaver JUnanimous
R v Maybin
2012 SCC 24
Criminal law – Causation and intervening actsUnanimous
Southcott Estates Inc v Toronto Catholic District School Board
2012 SCC 51
Contracts – Whether plaintiff seeking specific performance has obligation to mitigate losses LeBel, Deschamps, Abella, Rothstein and Cromwell JJ
R v Davey
2012 SCC 75
Whether it was appropriate for the Crown to seek personal opinions of local police officers as to the "suitability" of prospective jurors for use in exercise of peremptory challenges; Whether there should have been disclosure of same to the defence; Whether there is a reasonable possibility that such conduct affected trial fairness or gave rise to an appearance of unfairness, such that a miscarriage of justice occurredUnanimous

2013

Statistics
9
Majority or Plurality
1
Concurrence
0
Other
3
Dissent
0
Concurrence/dissentTotal = 13
Written opinions = 13Oral opinions = 0 Unanimous decisions = 4
Case nameIssueCo-authored byJoined by
R v Sanichar
2013 SCC 4
Whether appellate court erred in setting aside convictions and ordering a new trial McLachlin CJ and Abella, Rothstein, Moldaver and Wagner JJ
Manitoba Metis Federation Inc v Canada (AG)
2013 SCC 14
Aboriginal law and the honour of the Crown McLachlin CJ LeBel, Fish, Abella and Cromwell JJ
Penner v Niagara (Regional Police Services Board)
2013 SCC 19
Issue estoppel: administrative tribunal proceedings and civil proceedings Cromwell J McLachlin CJ and Fish J
R v Vuradin
2013 SCC 38
Whether trial judge's reasons for judgment were sufficient and whether trial judge properly applied the burden of proof in a criminal caseUnanimous
R v Youvarajah
2013 SCC 41
Admissibility of hearsay evidence: prior inconsistent statementsMcLachlin CJ and Fish, Abella and Cromwell JJ
Conseil scolaire francophone de la Colombie-Britannique v British Columbia
2013 SCC 42
Civil procedure – Admissibility of affidavits in languages other than English under 1731 English Act received into British Columbia law providing English as language of court "proceedings" LeBel and Abella JJ
Ontario v Criminal Lawyers' Association of Ontario
2013 SCC 43
Jurisdiction of courts – Whether superior and statutory courts have inherent jurisdiction to determine the rate of remuneration of amici curiae McLachlin CJ and Rothstein, Moldaver and Wagner JJ
Marine Services International Ltd v Ryan Estate
2013 SCC 44
Division of powers – Whether negligence action brought by dependents under federal maritime legislation is prohibited by provincial workers' compensation legislation LeBel JUnanimous
R v Chehil
2013 SCC 49
Unreasonable search and seizure under s. 8 of the Charter and whether police had reasonable grounds to suspect the accused was involved in a drug-related offenceUnanimous
Cuthbertson v Rasouli
2013 SCC 53
Health law – Consent to withdrawal of treatment; whether withdrawal constitutes "treatment" under Ontario Health Care Consent Act Abella J
Sun-Rype Products Ltd v Archer Daniels Midland Co
2013 SCC 58
Civil procedure – Certification of class actions Cromwell J
McLean v British Columbia (Securities Commission)
2013 SCC 67
Judicial review and standard of review of securities commission decision
R v McRae
2013 SCC 68
Offence of uttering threats Cromwell JUnanimous

2014

2014 statistics
9
Majority or Plurality
2
Concurrence
0
Other
2
Dissent
0
Concurrence/dissentTotal = 13
Written opinions = 11Oral opinions = 2 Unanimous decisions = 8
Case nameIssueCo-authored byJoined by
Hryniak v Mauldin
2014 SCC 7
Summary judgmentsUnanimous
Bruno Appliance and Furniture, Inc v Hryniak
2014 SCC 8
Summary judgmentsUnanimous
Reference Re Supreme Court Act, ss 5 and 6
2014 SCC 21
Eligibility requirements to the Supreme Court of Canada McLachlin CJ and LeBel, Abella, Cromwell and Wagner JJ
Martin v Alberta (Workers' Compensation Board)
2014 SCC 25
Judicial review of workers' compensation decisionUnanimous
R v Summers
2014 SCC 26
Sentencing and credit for pre-sentence detention under the Criminal CodeUnanimous
R v Carvery
2014 SCC 27
Sentencing and credit for pre-sentence detention under the Criminal CodeUnanimous
R v Quesnelle
2014 SCC 46
Whether police occurrence reports prepared in the investigation of unrelated incidents involving a complainant or witness are "records" within the meaning of s. 278.1 of the Criminal CodeUnanimous
R v Hart
2014 SCC 52
Admissibility of "Mr. Big" confessions
R v Conception
2014 SCC 60
Mental disorders and dispositions by a court or review board McLachlin CJ and Moldaver and Wagner JJ
British Columbia Teachers' Federation v British Columbia School Employers' Association
2014 SCC 70
Judicial review of labour arbitration Unanimous (oral)
Wakeling v United States of America
2014 SCC 72
Unreasonable search and seizure under s. 8 of the Charter and the disclosure of intercepted private communications without consent Abella and Cromwell JJ
R v Wilcox
2014 SCC 75
Offence of aggravated sexual assault and credibility of complainantUnanimous (oral)
R v Fearon
2014 SCC 77
Unreasonable search and seizure and search incident to arrest under s. 8 of the Charter LeBel and Abella JJ

2015

Statistics
7
Majority or Plurality
1
Concurrence
0
Other
2
Dissent
1
Concurrence/dissentTotal11
Written opinions = XXXOral opinions = XXX Unanimous decisions = 3
Case nameIssueCo-authored byJoined by
Tervita Corp v Canada (Commissioner of Competition
2015 SCC 3
Legal test for when a merger gives rise to a substantial prevention of competition under the Competition Act; Defence of statutory efficiencies
R v Grant
2015 SCC 9
Appropriate framework for determining the admissibility of defence-led evidence concerning an unknown third-party suspectUnanimous
Quebec (AG) v Canada (AG)
2015 SCC 14
Whether federal legislation abolishing the long-gun registry also containing provision requiring the destruction of long-gun registration data is ultra vires the criminal law power of Parliament under s. 91(27) of the Constitution Act, 1867 Cromwell J McLachlin CJ and Rothstein and Moldaver JJ
Association des parents de l'école Rose-des-vents v British Columbia (Education)
2015 SCC 21
Minority language education rights and the manner in which courts should assess whether children of rights holders are provided with an educational experience equivalent to that provided in schools of the linguistic majority of the province or territory; Whether a finding of a lack of equivalence amounts to a breach of s. 23 of the CharterUnanimous
Henry v British Columbia (AG)
2015 SCC 24
Wrongful conviction of claimant; Civil action alleging breach of Charter rights resulting from Crown counsel's wrongful non-disclose of relevant information; Whether s. 24(1) authorizes courts to award damages against Crown for wrongful non-disclosure, and the level of fault claimant must establish to meet liability threshold for awarding s. 24(1) damages McLachlin CJ
R v Kokopenace
2015 SCC 28
Appropriate legal test for representativeness on jury roll; Jury representativeness under ss. 11(d) and (f) and 15 of the Charter
R v Barabash
2015 SCC 29
Offence of child pornography and whether the "private use" exception under s 163.1 of the Criminal Code requires a separate and additional inquiry into the minors' exploitation, or whether an exploitation inquiry is included under the lawfulness inquiryUnanimous
Goodwin v British Columbia (Superintendent of Motor Vehicles)
2015 SCC 46
Whether an automatic roadside prohibition scheme enacted under s. 92(13) of the Constitution Act, 1867 is ultra vires provincial authority as being exclusively within federal government's criminal law power under s. 91(27) of the Constitution Act, 1867; Whether same automatic roadside prohibition regime creates an offence within the meaning of s. 11 of the Charter and infringes the presumption of innocence under s. 11(d) of same; Whether same automatic roadside prohibition scheme infringes the right to be secure against unreasonable search and seizure under s. 8 of the Charter Cromwell, Moldaver, Wagner, Gascon and Côté JJ
Caron v Alberta
2015 SCC 56
Whether provincial Languages Act is ultra vires or inoperative insofar that by requiring provincial laws and regulates to be enacted, printed and published in English only, it abrogates the constitutional duty owed by Alberta to enact, print and publish its laws and regulations in both English and French in Rupert's Land and North-Western Territory Order (1870) Cromwell J McLachlin CJ and Rothstein, Moldaver and Gascon JJ
Canadian Broadcasting Corp v SODRAC 2003 Inc
2015 SCC 57
Intellectual property and copyright
Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Green
2015 SCC 60
Limitation period of class actions Moldaver and Gascon JJ
  • Tervita Corp v Canada (Commissioner of Competition), 2015 SCC 3 (dissent)
  • R v Grant, 2015 SCC 9 (unanimous)
  • Quebec (AG) v Canada (AG) , 2015 SCC 14 (majority)
  • Association des parents de l'école Rose-des-vents v British Columbia, 2015 SCC 21 (unanimous)
  • Henry v British Columbia (AG), 2015 SCC 24 (concurrence)
  • R v Kokopenace, 2015 SCC 28 (concurrence)
  • R v Barabash, 2015 SCC 29 (unanimous)
  • Goodwin v British Columbia (Superintendent of Motor Vehicles), 2015 SCC 46 (majority)
  • Caron v Alberta, 2015 SCC 56 (majority)
  • Canadian Broadcasting Corp v SODRAC 2003 Inc, 2015 SCC 57 (dissent)
  • Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Green, 2015 SCC 60 (majority in CIBC and IMAX; dissent in part in Celestica)

2016

2016 statistics
8
Majority or Plurality
1
Concurrence
0
Other
0
Dissent
1
Concurrence/dissentTotal = 10
Written opinions = 10Oral opinions = 0 Unanimous decisions = 1
Case nameIssueCo-authored byJoined by
Carter v Canada (AG)
2016 SCC 4
Motion seeking an order extending the suspension of the declaration of constitutional invalidity issued in Carter v Canada (AG) , 2015 SCC 5 Abella, Wagner, Gascon and Côté JJ
R v Saeed
2016 SCC 24
Unreasonable search and seizure under s. 8 of the Charter
R v Williamson
2016 SCC 28
Right to be tried within a reasonable time under s. 11 of the Charter Moldaver and Brown JJ Abella and Côté JJ
R v Jordan
2016 SCC 27
Right to be tried within a reasonable time under s. 11 of the Charter Moldaver and Brown JJ Abella and Côté JJ
Wilson v Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd
2016 SCC 29
Unjust dismissal of non-unionized employees under the Canada Labour Code McLachlin CJ and Wagner and Gascon JJ
R v KRJ
2016 SCC 31
Sentencing and s. 11 of the Charter McLachlin CJ and Cromwell, Moldaver, Wagner, Gascon and Côté JJ
Conférence des juges de paix magistrats du Québec v Quebec (AG)
2016 SCC 39
Provincial legislation amending status of justices of the peace; judicial independence Wagner and Côté JJUnanimous
R v Diamond
2016 SCC 46
[DESCRIPTION] Wagner and Brown JJ
Edmonton (City of) v Edmonton East (Capilano) Shopping Centres Ltd
2016 SCC 47
Municipal property assessment for taxation purposes Abella, Cromwell, Wagner and Gascon JJ
Windsor (City of) v Canadian Transit Co
2016 SCC 54
Jurisdiction of courts McLachlin CJ and Cromwell, Wagner and Gascon JJ

2017

2017 statistics
9
Majority or Plurality
0
Concurrence
0
Other
1
Dissent
1
Concurrence/dissentTotal = 11
Written opinions = 9Oral opinions = 2 Unanimous decisions = 6
Case nameIssueCo-authored byJoined by
Sabean v Portage La Prairie Mutual Insurance Co
2017 SCC 7
Automobile insuranceUnanimous
R v Olotu
2017 SCC 11
Criminal law – Misapprehension of evidenceUnanimous (oral)
R v Bingley
2017 SCC 12
Expert opinion evidence Gascon J
Pintea v Johns
2017 SCC 23
Contempt of court Unanimous (oral)
Douez v Facebook, Inc
2017 SCC 33
Private intentional law – Jurisdiction Wagner and Gascon JJ
R v Bradshaw
2017 SCC 35
Admissibility of hearsay evidence McLachlin CJ and Abella, Wagner and Brown JJ
Clyde River (Hamlet of) v Petroleum Geo-Services Inc
2017 SCC 40
Aboriginal treaty rights and the Crown's duty to consult Brown JUnanimous
Chippewas of the Thames First Nation v Enbridge Pipelines Inc
2017 SCC 41
Aboriginal treaty rights and the Crown's duty to consult Brown JUnanimous
Association of Justice Counsel v Canada (AG)
2017 SCC 55
Judicial review of a labour arbitrator's interpretation of a collective agreement and management rights clause McLachlin CJ and Abella, Wagner, Gascon, Brown and Rowe JJ
First Nation of Nacho Nyak Dun v Yukon
2017 SCC 58
Aboriginal treaty rights and honour of the CrownUnanimous
R v Boutilier
2017 SCC 64
Constitutional law – Fundamental justice and sentencing

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States</span> United States federal judge position

An associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States is a justice of the Supreme Court of the United States, other than the chief justice of the United States. The number of associate justices is eight, as set by the Judiciary Act of 1869.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Supreme Court of the United States</span> Highest court of jurisdiction in the US

The Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) is the highest court in the federal judiciary of the United States. It has ultimate appellate jurisdiction over all U.S. federal court cases, and over state court cases that turn on questions of U.S. constitutional or federal law. It also has original jurisdiction over a narrow range of cases, specifically "all Cases affecting Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls, and those in which a State shall be Party." In 1803, the Court asserted itself the power of judicial review, the ability to invalidate a statute for violating a provision of the Constitution via the landmark case Marbury v Madison. It is also able to strike down presidential directives for violating either the Constitution or statutory law.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chief Justice of the United States</span> Chief judicial officer of the United States

The chief justice of the United States is the chief judge of the Supreme Court of the United States and is the highest-ranking officer of the U.S. federal judiciary. Article II, Section 2, Clause 2 of the U.S. Constitution grants plenary power to the president of the United States to nominate, and, with the advice and consent of the United States Senate, appoint "Judges of the supreme Court", who serve until they die, resign, retire, or are impeached and convicted. The existence of a chief justice is only explicit in Article I, Section 3, Clause 6 which states that the chief justice shall preside over the impeachment trial of the president; this has occurred three times, for Andrew Johnson, Bill Clinton, and for Donald Trump’s first impeachment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">United States Attorney General</span> Head of the US Department of Justice

The United States attorney general (AG) is the head of the United States Department of Justice (DOJ) and is the chief law enforcement officer of the federal government of the United States. The attorney general serves as the principal advisor to the president of the United States on all legal matters. The attorney general is a statutory member of the Cabinet of the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">United States Department of Justice</span> U.S. federal executive department

The United States Department of Justice (DOJ), also known as the Justice Department, is a federal executive department of the United States government tasked with the enforcement of federal law and administration of justice in the United States. It is equivalent to the justice or interior ministries of other countries. The department is headed by the U.S. attorney general, who reports directly to the president of the United States and is a member of the president's Cabinet. The current attorney general is Merrick Garland, who has served since March 2021.

In most common law jurisdictions, the attorney general or attorney-general is the main legal advisor to the government. In some jurisdictions, attorneys general also have executive responsibility for law enforcement, prosecutions or even responsibility for legal affairs generally. In practice, the extent to which the attorney general personally provides legal advice to the government varies between jurisdictions, and even between individual office-holders within the same jurisdiction, often depending on the level and nature of the office-holder's prior legal experience.

Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113 (1973), was a landmark decision of the U.S. Supreme Court in which the Court ruled that the Constitution of the United States protected a right to have an abortion. The decision struck down many abortion laws, and it sparked an ongoing abortion debate in the United States about whether, or to what extent, abortion should be legal, who should decide the legality of abortion, and what the role of moral and religious views in the political sphere should be. The decision also shaped debate concerning which methods the Supreme Court should use in constitutional adjudication.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Antonin Scalia</span> US Supreme Court justice from 1986 to 2016

Antonin Gregory Scalia was an American jurist who served as an associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States from 1986 until his death in 2016. He was described as the intellectual anchor for the originalist and textualist position in the U.S. Supreme Court's conservative wing. For catalyzing an originalist and textualist movement in American law, he has been described as one of the most influential jurists of the twentieth century, and one of the most important justices in the history of the Supreme Court. Scalia was posthumously awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom in 2018, and the Antonin Scalia Law School at George Mason University was named in his honor.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ruth Bader Ginsburg</span> US Supreme Court justice from 1993 to 2020

Joan Ruth Bader Ginsburg was an American lawyer and jurist who served as an associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States from 1993 until her death in 2020. She was nominated by President Bill Clinton to replace retiring justice Byron White, and at the time was viewed as a moderate consensus-builder. Ginsburg was the first Jewish woman and the second woman to serve on the Court, after Sandra Day O'Connor. During her tenure, Ginsburg authored the majority opinions in cases such as United States v. Virginia (1996), Olmstead v. L.C. (1999), Friends of the Earth, Inc. v. Laidlaw Environmental Services, Inc. (2000), and City of Sherrill v. Oneida Indian Nation of New York (2005). Later in her tenure, Ginsburg received attention for passionate dissents that reflected liberal views of the law. She was popularly dubbed "the Notorious R.B.G.", a moniker she later embraced.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Justice of the peace</span> Judicial officer elected or appointed to keep the peace and perform minor civic jobs

A justice of the peace (JP) is a judicial officer of a lower court, elected or appointed by means of a commission to keep the peace. In past centuries the term commissioner of the peace was often used with the same meaning. Depending on the jurisdiction, such justices dispense summary justice or merely deal with local administrative applications in common law jurisdictions. Justices of the peace are appointed or elected from the citizens of the jurisdiction in which they serve, and are usually not required to have any formal legal education in order to qualify for the office. Some jurisdictions have varying forms of training for JPs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chief Justice of India</span> Presiding judge of the Supreme Court of India

The Chief Justice of India (CJI) (ISO: Bhārat kē Mukhya Nyāyādhīśa) is the chief judge of the Supreme Court of India and the highest-ranking officer of the Indian judiciary. The Constitution of India grants power to the President of India to appoint, as recommended by the outgoing chief justice in consultation with other judges, (as envisaged in Article 124 (2) of the Constitution) the next Chief Justice, who will serve until they reach the age of 65 or are removed by the constitutional process of impeachment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Merrick Garland</span> American lawyer and jurist (born 1952)

Merrick Brian Garland is an American lawyer and jurist who has served as the 86th United States attorney general since 2021. He previously served as a circuit judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit from 1997 to 2021. In 2016, President Barack Obama nominated Garland to the U.S. Supreme Court, but the Republican-led U.S. Senate did not hold a vote to confirm him.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Samuel Alito</span> US Supreme Court justice since 2006

Samuel Anthony Alito Jr. is an American jurist who serves as an associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States. He was nominated to the high court by President George W. Bush on October 31, 2005, and has served on it since January 31, 2006. After Antonin Scalia, Alito is the second Italian American justice to serve on the U.S. Supreme Court.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Roberts</span> Chief Justice of the United States since 2005

John Glover Roberts Jr. is an American jurist who has served since 2005 as the 17th chief justice of the United States. He has been described as having a moderate conservative judicial philosophy, though he is primarily an institutionalist. Regarded as a swing vote in some cases, Roberts has presided over an ideological shift toward conservative jurisprudence on the high court, in which he has authored key opinions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sonia Sotomayor</span> US Supreme Court justice since 2009

Sonia Maria Sotomayor is an American lawyer and jurist who serves as an associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States. She was nominated by President Barack Obama on May 26, 2009, and has served since August 8, 2009. She is the third woman, the first woman of color, the first Hispanic, and the first Latina to serve on the Supreme Court.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">William Rehnquist</span> Chief Justice of the United States from 1986 to 2005

William Hubbs Rehnquist was an American attorney and jurist who served as the 16th chief justice of the United States from 1986 until his death in 2005, having previously been an associate justice from 1972 to 1986. Considered a staunch conservative, Rehnquist favored a conception of federalism that emphasized the Tenth Amendment's reservation of powers to the states. Under this view of federalism, the Court, for the first time since the 1930s, struck down an act of Congress as exceeding its power under the Commerce Clause.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lady Justice</span> Personification of justice

Lady Justice is an allegorical personification of the moral force in judicial systems. Her attributes are scales, a sword and sometimes a blindfold. She often appears as a pair with Prudentia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Clarence Thomas</span> US Supreme Court justice since 1991

Clarence Thomas is an American lawyer and jurist who serves as an associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States. He was nominated by President George H. W. Bush to succeed Thurgood Marshall and has served since 1991. After Marshall, Thomas is the second African American to serve on the Supreme Court and has been its longest-serving member since Anthony Kennedy's retirement in 2018. Since Stephen Breyer's retirement in 2022, he is also the Court's oldest member.

<i>Justice League</i> (film) 2017 film produced by DC Films

Justice League is a 2017 American superhero film based on the DC Comics superhero team of the same name. Produced by Warner Bros. Pictures, DC Films, RatPac-Dune Entertainment, Atlas Entertainment, and Cruel and Unusual Films, and distributed by Warner Bros. Pictures, it is the fifth installment in the DC Extended Universe (DCEU). Directed by Zack Snyder who was replaced by Joss Whedon after Snyder left the project and written by Chris Terrio and Joss Whedon, the film features an ensemble cast including Ben Affleck, Henry Cavill, Gal Gadot, Ezra Miller, Jason Momoa, Ray Fisher, Amy Adams, Jeremy Irons, Diane Lane, Connie Nielsen, and J. K. Simmons. In the film, following the events of Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016) Batman and Wonder Woman recruit The Flash, Aquaman, and Cyborg after the death of Superman to save the world from the catastrophic threat of Steppenwolf and his army of Parademons.