Sacred Suicide

Last updated

Sacred Suicide
Sacred Suicide cover.png
Author
LanguageEnglish
SeriesAshgate New Religions
Subject Suicide in religion
Publisher Ashgate Publishing
Publication date
2014
Pages299
ISBN 978-1-4094-5086-3
OCLC 884298298
202’.3
LC Class BL504 .S225 2014

Sacred Suicide is a 2014 edited volume about suicide and religion, particularly as it relates to cults or new religious movements. It was published by Ashgate and edited by James R. Lewis and Carole M. Cusack, part of the Ashgate New Religions series. Other contributors to the book include Nachman Ben-Yehuda, Mattias Gardell, and Thomas Robbins. It is divided into five sections.

Contents

The book covers various aspects of suicide as they relate to religion, including high profile "suicide cults" like Heaven's Gate, the Solar Temple, and the Peoples Temple, as well as historical mass suicides like that of the siege of Masada and the Old Believers. It also covers groups that have faced more dubious allegations of being suicide cults, such as the Branch Davidians and the Falun Gong. Further topics discussed include religious terrorism, and the depiction of suicide and religion in the media.

It received a largely positive reception, with praise for the content of many of its essays; the chapter on the Peoples Temple and its coverage of the contemporary movements was singled out for praise. It was highly recommended by several reviewers, though others criticized it for not providing a proper analytical structure in the volume as a whole. The appropriateness of the cover, which depicts a person self-immolating, was also criticized by one reviewer.

Background

James R. Lewis (of the University of Tromsø) was an academic focusing on new religious movements; he had previously edited several other anthologies on the topic of violence and NRMs. Carole M. Cusack was a professor of Religious Studies at the University of Sydney, and the author of several books on religion. [1] [2] The book includes contributors from several continents and countries. [2]

Contents

The contributors to the book are, alongside the two editors, Nachman Ben-Yehuda, Thomas Robbins, Henrik Bogdan, Rebecca Moore, John Walliss, Jan A. Ali, Mattias Gardell, Katarina Plank, Lorenz Graitl, Helen Farley, Lynn S. Neal, and Christopher Hartney. In the book's introduction, Lewis and Cusack discuss the view of religiously or politically motivated suicide by society, contrasting the perception of Muslim suicide bombers, self-sacrifice in wartime, and the mass suicides of several NRMs. They argue that the factors driving many groups to suicide are too disparate to have a unifying cause, noting that though the mass suicide NRMs had some similarities they lacked this with suicide bombers and other religious suicides; the editors instead argue a commonality between all these cases is the stereotypical idea of religion as an "irrational force" that drives its adherents to commit suicide, an idea they criticize. A summary of each of the chapters follows this.

"Historical Suicide Cults" discusses two historic cases of mass suicide: the siege of Masada and the Old Believers. In 73 AD, 967 Jewish Sicarii, besieged by the Romans, committed mass suicide upon their realization they could not escape. Ben-Yahuda discusses the siege and its historicity, arguing that by the 1960s it had become a founding myth of Israel. Robbins covers the Old Believers, a group of Russian schismatic Christians, tens of thousands whom committed suicide through self-immolation over a decades long period from the late 1700s on. He compares it to Jonestown, though argues that unlike Jonestown only a minority of Old Believers partook in mass suicide and that unlike the Old Believers, much of the persecution the Peoples Temple supposedly faced was fantasy.

The second section, "Contemporary Suicide Cults", discusses more modern "suicide cults": the Order of the Solar Temple, Peoples Temple, Heaven's Gate, and the Movement for the Restoration of the Ten Commandments of God, four NRMs that made headlines for high-profile mass suicides. Henrik Bogdan first discusses the Solar Temple, a cult notorious for several group suicides and murders in the 1990s; Bogdan analyzes the various hypotheses for why the group turned violent, among them the ideas of internal stressors, perceived outside threats, and "catastrophic millennialism". Moore – related to two people who died in the massacre [3] – then covers the deaths of 918 individuals on the Peoples Temple Jonestown commune in 1978, noting the revolutionary beliefs of many of its members, and how this ideology lead to self-inflicted violence. Cusack's chapter is on Heaven's Gate, giving a background to UFO religions historically and the social circumstances under which they emerged, and how these earlier movements are related to Heaven's Gate theology. The comparatively more obscure MRTCG is covered by Walliss; nearly a thousand members of the group died in what was initially believed to be a mass suicide, but what later investigations described as mass murder as well as mass suicide. Wallis notes the confused evidence of many aspects of the case, and how basic details are to this day uncertain, though of the many competing theories largely concurs with Richard Vokes's analysis of the group.

The third part discusses "Social-Political Suicides" of various groups, including Muslim suicide terrorists, suicide attacks as a political strategy, self-immolation in Tibetan Buddhism, and the usage of it as a media weapon by those who commit it. Ali explores Islamist terrorism as a sociological phenomenon, noting Muslim terrorist's connections to their broader social groups and their status as a form of resistance. Gardell follows this with an analysis of martyrdom and suicide attacks, and how attitudes to the concept vary between societies. He argues that it has been used by many societies, particularly focusing on Palestinian attackers. The self-immolation of Tibetan Buddhists – related to the annexation of Tibet by China – is then discussed by Katarina Plank, who traces the history of Buddhist thought that lead to the practice. She argues that a divide between Abrahamic and Indic religions leads to self-immolation being more common in Indic religions, and that method of suicide carries an additional religious aspect as a sacrifice to a larger cause. Graitl discusses the orchestrated media aspect of many of these suicides, and how it is used to communicate their ideas. He argues that to understand suicide attacks the social sciences must pay attention to the actual messages.

"Faux Suicide Cults", the fourth section, covers Falun Gong and the Branch Davidians, two groups that were accused of committing group suicide, but the truth of this is contested in both cases. Five members of Falun Gong self-immolated in Tiananmen Square in 2001, of which two died; in the aftermath, group spokespeople defended the organization, saying they were against suicide, but Chinese media organizations criticized the group's teachings as responsible for these and over a thousand other deaths. Farley argues that though the organization explicitly condemns suicide, the group's rhetoric lead to such acts, and that their teachings on medicine lead to what was effectively suicide of many members due to a refusal to consent to medical treatment. This is followed by Lewis's account of the Waco siege and the Branch Davidians. He argues that the Branch Davidians were not ideologically inclined towards suicide, and that instead the ATF's actions and the perception that they were a "suicide cult" resulted in the botched siege and deaths. The fifth section, "Screen Suicide Cults", discusses the perception of religious suicide in the media. Lynn S. Neal discusses America television's portrayal of cults and suicide; analyzing episodes of several TV shows, she argues that the episodes, by blending elements of many groups, create a cultural memory of cults, and that they present an idealized history where both the government and supposedly real religious groups acted ideally. In the final chapter, Hartney writes of Hollywood's portrayal of Muslims in film, arguing that the portrayals are orientalist in nature and that they are racist depictions.

Publication and reception

The book was published in 2014 by Ashgate as part of its Ashgate New Religions series. [1] [2] Some of the chapters had been previously published elsewhere before being collected in this volume. [4] Sacred Suicide was received generally positively by reviewers. A review in Choice recommended it, describing it as of particular interest to sociologists and psychologists studying religion. They said its essays "enhance understanding" of the connection between religion and violence, and praised the bibliography sections included in each chapter. [2] Sarah K. Pinnock highly recommended it, praising its format as convenient for research purposes as the chapters stand alone, and for its accessibility. [5] Benjamin E. Zeller, an academic studying Heaven's Gate, called the book "very refreshing" in his review in the Journal of Religious History , as well as a "major contribution to the field". [6]

In a review in the Journal of Religion and Violence , John Soboslai gave a more mixed opinion. He said overall the book contained "much of interest" to scholars studying the specific cases covered in the book, but that it varied in quality and contained missed opportunities; he said it was not worth the high price it was sold for by its publisher, but that it would be useful to those who borrowed it. [3] Nova Religio 's Ian Reader criticized the book, saying that while some chapters provided interesting analysis, the volume as a whole did not provide a "coherent framework or analysis" to analyze the topic, and that the book as a whole was "highly problematic" and disappointing. [4] Zeller described the chapters as disconnected from each other, but argued this was inherent in an anthology volume. [6] While praising the individual essays, Soboslai criticized the lack of a "systematic examination" of the broader concepts utilized in the book, and said that readers looking for a synthesis of the individual conclusions in the chapters in the book would be disappointed. [3]

Reader said the book's introduction sidestepped this issue by merely saying that the incidents studied in the book were too disparate to discuss under one analytical scheme, and that the authors had taken an easier route in simply bringing together the essays but that the book's coherence suffered as a result. He also said the categories the book's contents were divided into and its key concepts were not clearly defined; he particularly described the contents of the fourth section as "dubious" in light of this. He did praise the contents of some specific chapters, complimenting Moore, Hartney, and Walliss's chapters, though he criticized Lewis's discussion of Waco for, in his view, using selective evidence and being written in a "tabloid media" style. [4] Soboslai praised Cusack's analysis of Heaven's Gate as fascinating. [3] Zeller praised the book's inclusion of other cases than the typical cult mass suicide affairs like Heaven's Gate or the Peoples Temple, saying its discussion of jihadism and Buddhist self-immolation provided a reminder that religious suicide was not limited to new religions. [6]

Pinnock argued the volume was strongest in its dealing with contemporary movements, and complimented its structure in opening with historical cases and ending with discussions of modern media portrayals. [5] Bernard Doherty criticized the choice of cover (depicting a person who had set themself on fire), arguing that there was likely art relating to suicide that would be more appropriate and "far less visceral" than a picture of self-immolation, but praised the work overall. He said it offered a "smorgasbord of perspectives on a complex and controversial topic" and that any future works on the topic should refer to it. He singled out Moore's chapter in particular for praise, describing it as a "fascinating look" at the rhetoric of the Peoples Temple, and described the content of the other summaries in the second section generally as "excellent". [7]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Discordianism</span> Belief system based around the Greek goddess Eris

Discordianism is a belief system based around Eris, the Greek goddess of strife and discord, and variously defined as a religion, new religious movement, virtual religion, or act of social commentary; though prior to 2005, some sources categorized it as a parody religion. It was founded after the 1963 publication of its holy book, Principia Discordia, written by Greg Hill with Kerry Wendell Thornley, the two working under the pseudonyms Malaclypse the Younger and Omar Khayyam Ravenhurst.

A new religious movement (NRM), also known as a new religion, is a religious or spiritual group that has modern origins and is peripheral to its society's dominant religious culture. NRMs can be novel in origin, or they can be part of a wider religion, in which case they are distinct from pre-existing denominations. Some NRMs deal with the challenges that the modernizing world poses to them by embracing individualism, while other NRMs deal with them by embracing tightly knit collective means. Scholars have estimated that NRMs number in the tens of thousands worldwide. Most NRMs only have a few members, some of them have thousands of members, and a few of them have more than a million members.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mass suicide</span> Groups of people killing themselves together

Mass suicide is a form of suicide, occurring when a group of people simultaneously kill themselves. Mass suicide sometimes occurs in religious settings. In war, defeated groups may resort to mass suicide rather than being captured. Suicide pacts are a form of mass suicide that are sometimes planned or carried out by small groups of depressed or hopeless people. Mass suicides have been used as a form of political protest.

The Movement for the Restoration of the Ten Commandments of God was a religious movement founded by Credonia Mwerinde and Joseph Kibweteere in southwestern Uganda, notorious for the mass death of several hundred members of the group in a mass suicide in the year 2000. It was formed in 1989 after Mwerinde and Kibweteere claimed that they had seen visions of the Virgin Mary.

A doomsday cult is a cult that believes in apocalypticism and millenarianism, including both those that predict disaster and those that attempt to destroy the entire universe. Sociologist John Lofland coined the term doomsday cult in his 1966 study of a group of members belonging to the Unification Church of the United States: Doomsday Cult: A Study of Conversion, Proselytization, and Maintenance of Faith. In 1958, Leon Festinger published a study of a group with cataclysmic predictions: When Prophecy Fails: A Social and Psychological Study of a Modern Group that Predicted the Destruction of the World.

<i>Misunderstanding Cults</i> Book by Benjamin Zablocki and Thomas Robbins

Misunderstanding Cults: Searching for Objectivity in a Controversial Field is an edited volume discussing various topics related to cults, including the scholarly field itself, the concept of brainwashing, and the public perception of the groups. The book was edited by Benjamin Zablocki and Thomas Robbins, and was published by University of Toronto Press on December 1, 2001. It includes contributions from 12 religious, sociological, and psychological scholars, in 14 essays.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">James R. Lewis (scholar)</span> Author and academic (1949–2022)

James Roger Lewis was an American philosophy professor at Wuhan University. He was a religious studies scholar, sociologist of religion, and writer, who specialized in the academic study of new religious movements, astrology, and New Age.

<i>Deadly Cults</i> 2003 book by Robert L. Snow

Deadly Cults: The Crimes of True Believers is a book about cults by Robert L. Snow. It was published November 30, 2003 by Praeger Publishers in hardcover format. Snow, a retired police captain and former commander of the homicide branch of the Indianapolis Police Department, has authored several other books on crime including SWAT Teams and Technology and Law Enforcement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Heaven's Gate (religious group)</span> American UFO religion (1974–1997)

Heaven's Gate was an American new religious movement known primarily for the mass suicides committed by its members in 1997. Commonly designated a cult, it was founded in 1974 and led by Marshall Applewhite (1931–1997) and Bonnie Nettles (1927–1985), known within the movement as Do and Ti. Nettles and Applewhite first met in 1972 and went on a journey of spiritual discovery, identifying themselves as the two witnesses of the Book of Revelation, attracting a following of several hundred people in the mid-1970s. In 1976, a core group of a few dozen members stopped recruiting and instituted a monastic lifestyle.

<i>Scientology</i> (Lewis book) 2009 book by James R. Lewis

Scientology is an edited volume about Scientology, and the Church of Scientology organization, published in 2009 by Oxford University Press. It was edited by the sociologist James R. Lewis. Chapters in the work give an overview and introduction to the organization, and present analysis of the movement from the perspective of sociology. The book compares the organization to religious movements, and goes over its history of controversy. It delves into the practices of the organization and the activities undertaken at its facilities.

Jean-François Mayer is a Swiss religious historian, author, and translator. He is also Director of the Religioscope Institute, which he founded. He received his masters degree, and then his doctorate, from the Jean Moulin University Lyon 3 in 1979 and 1984. His writing focuses on religion, with a particular focus on new religious movements and cults, including the Unification Church, the Church of Scientology and the Pilgrims of Arès.

<i>Ghosts of Kanungu</i> 2009 book by Richard Vokes

Ghosts of Kanungu: Fertility, Secrecy and Exchange in the Great Lakes of East Africa is a book by Richard Vokes about the cult the Movement for the Restoration of the Ten Commandments of God (MRTC), notorious for the deaths of hundreds of its members in what was alternatively described as mass suicide or mass murder in 2000. The book was co-published by the Ugandan publisher Fountain Publishers and James Currey in 2009. An ethnography of the group, the book analyzes the MRTC in the context of the wider religious background of Uganda, and attempts to show what led to the deaths.

<i>The Order of the Solar Temple: The Temple of Death</i> 2006 book by James R. Lewis

The Order of the Solar Temple: The Temple of Death is an edited volume about the Order of the Solar Temple (OTS), a religious group notorious for the mass deaths of its members in several mass murders and suicides throughout the 1990s. It was edited by James R. Lewis, and published in 2006 by Ashgate Publishing as part of its Controversial New Religions series. Contributors to the book include Jean-François Mayer, Massimo Introvigne, Susan J. Palmer, and George D. Chryssides.

<i>Millennium, Messiahs, and Mayhem</i> 1997 book by Susan J. Palmer and Thomas Robbins

Millennium, Messiahs, and Mayhem: Contemporary Apocalyptic Movements is an edited volume about apocalypticism and millenarianism, largely but not entirely within a North American context. It was edited by sociologists Susan J. Palmer and Thomas Robbins, and was published in 1997 by Routledge. Contributors to the book include David G. Bromley, Catherine Wessinger, Robert W. Balch, Anson Shupe, Massimo Introvigne, Michael Barkun, and Dick Anthony, of 21 authors total. The book has 16 chapters in 4 sections divided by theme.

<i>The New Heretics of France</i> 2011 book by Susan J. Palmer

The New Heretics of France: Minority Religions, la République, and the Government-Sponsored "War on Sects" is a book by Susan J. Palmer. It was published in 2011 by Oxford University Press. Palmer is a sociologist of religion who has authored several other books on new religious movements (NRMs), and is a professor in religious studies. The book focuses on what Palmer calls the "French sect wars" – the anti-cult efforts of the French government and anti-cult groups – placing it into historical context and analyzing it along with the French conception of secularism, laïcité.

<i>Apocalypse Observed</i> 2000 book by John R. Hall

Apocalypse Observed: Religious Movements and Violence in North America, Europe and Japan is a book about millennialism, apocalypticism and religious violence, written by sociologist John R. Hall. Philip D. Schuyler and Sylvaine Trinh, also sociologists, co-authored two of the chapters. It was published in December 2000 by Routledge. The book analyzes five new religious movements known for high profile acts of violence from a sociological perspective: the Peoples Temple, the Branch Davidians, Aum Shinrikyo, the Order of the Solar Temple, and Heaven's Gate.

<i>How the Millennium Comes Violently</i> 2000 book by Catherine Wessinger

How the Millennium Comes Violently: From Jonestown to Heaven's Gate is a book about millennialist violence by Catherine Wessinger, published in 2000 by Seven Bridges Press. The book covers various millennialist new religious movements (NRMs) and their relation to violence, including the Peoples Temple, the Branch Davidians, Aum Shinrikyo, the Order of the Solar Temple, and Heaven's Gate, and attempts to set out a typology for dealing with millennial NRMs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bibliography of the Order of the Solar Temple</span>

Following the Order of the Solar Temple affair – a case that gained international notoriety when members of the group, a then-obscure neo-Templar group, orchestrated several mass suicides and mass murders in the 1990s – there have been several books and studies published about the events and organization. The case became a media sensation, with many conspiracy theories promoted by the media. As described by Susan J. Palmer, "false or unverifiable trails have been laid: secondhand testimonies are traded by journalists, ghost-written apostate memoirs are in progress and conspiracy theories abound."

<i>Violence and New Religious Movements</i> 2011 book by James R. Lewis

Violence and New Religious Movements is a 2011 edited volume. It was edited by sociologist James R. Lewis and published by Oxford University Press. Lewis' previous work had focused on new religious movements, and he had edited several books on the topic. Containing 19 articles by 22 academics, mostly sociologists or scholars in religious studies, it discusses the intersection between new religious movements and violence, both perpetrated by and against the groups. It is divided into five sections.

<i>Controversial New Religions</i> 2004 book by James R. Lewis and Jesper Aagaard Petersen

Controversial New Religions is an edited volume discussing new religious movements, or cults, that have resulted in controversy. It was co-edited by James R. Lewis and Jesper Aagaard Petersen, and was first published in 2004 by Oxford University Press. A second edition containing mostly new content was published with the same two editors in 2014. The first edition contains 19 essays, while the second contains 22. Both editions are divided into four sections by topic, and cover numerous groups.

References

  1. 1 2 "Sacred Suicide". Routledge . Retrieved 4 August 2024.
  2. 1 2 3 4 Lippy, C. H. (2015). "Sacred suicide". CHOICE: Current Reviews for Academic Libraries . 52 (12): 2035. doi:10.5860/CHOICE.189373 (inactive 1 February 2025). ISSN   0009-4978.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: DOI inactive as of February 2025 (link)
  3. 1 2 3 4 Soboslai, John (2016). "Review of Sacred Suicide by Carole M. Cusack, James Lewis and George Chryssides". Journal of Religion and Violence . 4 (1): 113–116. ISSN   2159-6808. JSTOR   26671492.
  4. 1 2 3 Reader, Ian (November 2016). "Review: Sacred Suicide edited by James R. Lewis and Carole M. Cusack". Nova Religio . 20 (2): 125–128. doi:10.1525/nr.2016.20.2.125. ISSN   1092-6690. JSTOR   26417839.
  5. 1 2 Pinnock, Sarah K. (January 2018). "Sacred Suicide, James R.Lewis and Carole M.Cusack (eds.), Ashgate, 2014 (ISBN 978-1-4094-5086-3), x + 299 pp., hb £70". Reviews in Religion & Theology. 25 (1): 97–99. doi:10.1111/rirt.13159. ISSN   1350-7303.
  6. 1 2 3 Zeller, Benjamin E. (September 2015). "James R.Lewis and Carole M.Cusack, eds: Sacred Suicide. Farnham: Ashgate, 2014; pp. 310". Journal of Religious History . 39 (3): 458–459. doi:10.1111/1467-9809.12290. ISSN   0022-4227.
  7. ↑ Doherty, Bernard (2017). "Sacred Suicide. Edited by James R. Lewis and Carole M. Cusack". Alternative Spirituality and Religion Review. 8 (1): 155–158. doi:10.5840/asrr2017812. ISSN   1946-0538.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.