The Ashes of Waco: An Investigation

Last updated
The Ashes of Waco: An Investigation
The Ashes of Waco An Investigation.jpg
AuthorDick J. Reavis
LanguageEnglish
Genre non-fiction
Publisher Simon & Schuster, Syracuse University Press
Publication date
July 1995
Pages320
ISBN 9780684811321
OCLC 246907421

The Ashes of Waco: An Investigation is a 1995 non-fiction book by journalist Dick J. Reavis about the Waco siege. Reavis is a professor of English at North Carolina State University and former reporter for the San Antonio Light and San Antonio Express . [1] The book was first published by Simon & Schuster in 1995, and it was later re-published by Syracuse University Press in 1998. According to Catherine Wessinger, Reavis argues that "the story of the Davidian tragedy was not reported fully, in part because the FBI controlled information, but also because reporters did not investigate". [2] Reavis reportedly left his job from an "alternative" newspaper in Texas to research for the book. [3] [4]

Reception

Catherine Wessinger, a religious studies scholar, in Nova Religio argued that although Reavis's research seemed extensive and he seemed to be reliable, it was up to the reader to trust his assertions, especially because he did not provide citations. She believes that Reavis provides a "humanized" version of the Branch Davidians, David Koresh, and the federal agents. Overall, she thinks the book is a "good introduction" to the Waco siege for the general reader. [2]

Dean M. Kelley, a legal scholar, believes that The Ashes of Waco is the "single best source" for a "vivid, engaging, reliable narrative of events at Waco". [4]

Jacob Sullum for Reason calls Reavis's book "thorough and lively" and compliments Reavis on being "meticulous and fairminded" and remaining "agnostic" on the issue of how the 19 April 1993 fire started. [5]

Nancy T. Ammerman for The Review of Politics points out that many of the sources in his work, like the complete transcripts of FBI negotiations with the Branch Davidians, are not publicly available, and he did not divulge how he obtained them. Ammerman complimented Reavis's dedication to studying the Bible and Branch Davidian theology for his book. [6] Murray Seeger for Niemann Reports also complimented his work to study Branch Davidian theology. [7]

Caroline Hartse was disappointed by the book's lack of "in-depth examination of broader issues and themes" despite arguing more specific points very well. Hartse also criticized the book's lack of citations; the book occasionally left quotations unattributed. Some of the descriptions of important people in the conflict like Sheila J. Martin and Marc Breault were distracting and played no role in the narrative of the Waco siege, according to Hartse. [8]

Carol Moore, Libertarian activist and author of The Davidian Massacre: Disturbing Questions About Waco That Must Be Answered , believes that although the book is insightful as an introduction to the siege, only a team of independent investigators could reveal the truth of the conflict. [3]

Timothy K. McMorrow for Trial believes that the book contains "strange claims, questionable conclusions, and a description of [Koresh] that purports to be evenhanded but is just short of sycophantic". [9]

LeAnne Burch in the Military Law Review believes that Reavis failed in respect to providing alternatives to what the federal government did at Waco to prevent further deaths; Burch also notes that Reavis did not provide a clear answer to "what happened at Waco" and accuses him of "antigovernment sentiment". [10]

Ashley Fantz for CNN called the book "exhaustive". [11] A reviewer in the American Journal of Criminal Law called the book an "in-depth look at the standoff in Waco". [12] B. Seth Bailey, also in the American Journal of Criminal Law, believes that the book is not only a "thought-provoking book" but a "useful reference" text for anyone interested in the Waco siege. However, Bailey concludes that the book is a "better guide to which questions should be asked, than it is to which answers are correct". [13]

Gregg Easterbrook in Washington Monthly calls the book "excellent" yet criticizes it for its "average" prose. Easterbrook disagrees with Reavis's depiction of Koresh as, at least at points, as a "misunderstood kid". [14]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Branch Davidians</span> Religious association known for the Waco siege of 1993

The Branch Davidians were an apocalyptic new religious movement founded in 1955 by Benjamin Roden. They regard themselves as a continuation of the General Association of Davidian Seventh-Day Adventists, established by Victor Houteff in 1935.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Waco siege</span> 1993 US law enforcement siege in Texas

The Waco siege, also known as the Waco massacre, was the law enforcement siege of the compound that belonged to the religious sect Branch Davidians. It was carried out by the U.S. federal government, Texas state law enforcement, and the U.S. military, between February 28 and April 19, 1993. The Branch Davidians were led by David Koresh and were headquartered at Mount Carmel Center ranch in the community of Axtell, Texas, 13 miles northeast of Waco. Suspecting the group, who had licenses to manufacture and sell weapons, of stockpiling illegal weapons, the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms (ATF) obtained a search warrant for the compound and arrest warrants for Koresh as well as a select few of the group's members.

Nancy Tatom Ammerman is an American professor of sociology of religion at Boston University School of Theology.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">David Koresh</span> American religious cult leader (1959–1993)

David Koresh was an American cult leader who played a central role in the Waco siege of 1993. As the head of the Branch Davidians, a religious sect and offshoot of the Davidian Seventh-day Adventists, Koresh claimed to be its final prophet. His apocalyptic Biblical teachings, including interpretations of the Book of Revelation and the Seven Seals, attracted various followers.

Catherine Wessinger is an American religion scholar. She is the Rev. H. James Yamauchi, S.J. Professor of the History of Religions at Loyola University New Orleans where she teaches religious studies with a main research focus on millennialism, new religions, women and religion, and religions of India. Wessinger is co-general editor of Nova Religio: The Journal of Alternative and Emergent Religions. She served as a consultant to federal law enforcement during the Montana Freemen standoff and has been cited for her expertise concerning the Branch Davidians and other apocalyptic groups. She is the editor of the Women in Religions series at New York University Press and she is co-editor of the Women in the World's Religions and Spirituality Project, part of the World Religions and Spirituality Project.

Steven Emil Schneider, or Steve Schneider, was an American Branch Davidian commonly called a "lieutenant" to David Koresh, the leader of the new religious movement. He was formally married to Judy Schneider, but in the community Koresh impregnated Judy and she bore a child with him. Steve Schneider was raised in a Seventh-day Adventist household in Wisconsin. Schneider studied at Newbold College in the United Kingdom, and eventually worked to receive a Ph.D. in comparative religion at the University of Hawaii. In approximately 1986, Schneider encountered Marc Breault, an indigenous Hawaiian Branch Davidian, and converted to Branch Davidianism. Schneider was supposedly very successful at gaining converts to Branch Davidianism. David Thibodeau, a survivor of the Waco siege and memoirist, converted after meeting Schneider in California. Scholars James Tabor and Eugene Gallagher note that he claimed to have converted twenty people on a trip to England in 1988. Schneider was in the Mount Carmel compound at the beginning of the Waco siege on 28 February 1993. He stayed in or near the compound for the entire siege and died there. Various police agencies believe that Schneider shot Koresh before shooting himself on 19 April 1993. He was a major character in the 2018 miniseries Waco, played by Paul Sparks.

Douglas Wayne Martin, commonly known as Wayne Martin, was an African-American Branch Davidian and Harvard-trained attorney. He worked as an attorney in multiple fields, including contract, child custody, and real estate law, and provided the proceeds to the Branch Davidians. He was nominally married to Sheila Judith Martin, another Branch Davidian, but she was "carnally" married to David Koresh, the Branch Davidian leader. Wayne and Sheila had six children, three of whom died in the 1993 fire. Sheila had two more children with Koresh. In total, four children died in the 19 April fire: Wayne Joseph, 20; Anita, 18; Sheila Renee, 15; and Lisa Martin, 13. Sheila Martin, who left Mount Carmel Center on 21 March in the middle of the siege, eventually won custody over the three surviving children: James, Daniel, and Kimberly Martin. Wayne Martin was present at Mount Carmel Center when the 28 February 1993 raid occurred. He was the first person in the compound to call 9-1-1 to local authorities and asked to call off the raid for risk of harming women and children. He was considered the second- or third-in-command at Mt. Carmel, behind or equal to Steve Schneider. He died in the 19 April 1993 fire with three of his children. Wayne Martin was a character in the 2018 miniseries Waco, played by Demore Barnes.

David or Dave Thibodeau was a Branch Davidian, a survivor of the Waco siege, and a musician. He was born in Bangor, Maine. In early adulthood, Thibodeau sought to become a musician in Los Angeles, California, where he converted to Branch Davidianism after meeting David Koresh in a Guitar Center in 1990. In the late 1980s, he attended the Musicians Institute of Technology. At the Mount Carmel Center near Waco, Texas, Thibodeau married Michele Jones upon Koresh's request. Thibodeau was present at the Mt. Carmel compound on 28 February 1993, when the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms (ATF) conducted a botched raid. He stayed for the 51-day siege until escaping the fire that consumed the compound with eight other survivors. In 1999, he co-authored a memoir called A Place Called Waco: A Survivor's Story with Leon Whiteson, a Zimbabwe-born novelist, critic, and architect. Thibodeau runs a website called "Waco Survivors," in which he archives media related to the Waco siege. He (re-)married in 1997 and has at least one daughter. In 2018, the miniseries Waco aired featuring Rory Culkin playing David Thibodeau and Thibodeau himself in a cameo role as an unnamed character. Thibodeau is a drummer for the band The Blast Addicts, and he resided in Texas as of 2020. He played drums for other bands after the Waco siege as well like Grooviest Maximus.

Clive Joseph Doyle was a leader in the Branch Davidian movement after the Waco siege in 1993. He was a Branch Davidian and a Davidian Seventh-day Adventist before the Waco siege. Doyle was one of nine survivors of the April 19, 1993 fire that destroyed the Mount Carmel Center at the end of the siege. He along with other survivors built a new chapel on the site of the siege in 1999.

Sheila Judith Martin is a Branch Davidian and a survivor of the Waco siege. She was the wife of Douglas Wayne Martin, a Harvard-educated lawyer, who died in the 19 April 1993 fire that destroyed Mount Carmel Center. Four out of her seven children died in the fire: Wayne Joseph, 20; Anita, 18; Sheila Renee, 15; and Lisa Martin, 13. In September 1993, she received custody of James Martin (1982–1998) who has cerebral palsy and is blind because of a meningitis infection at 4 months old. By 1994, she obtained custody in Texas state court of her two other children – Daniel and Kimberly.

Livingstone Fagan – sometimes misspelled as Livingston Fagan – is a Black British Branch Davidian who survived the Waco siege in 1993. He was born in Jamaica but moved to Nottingham in 1964 with his parents as part of the Windrush generation. He joined the Branch Davidians in 1989 while studying to join the Seventh-day Adventist ministry in the United Kingdom. He moved to Mount Carmel Center with his wife, Evette, and mother, Doris Adina, both of whom would die in the 19 April 1993 fire. He left the Mount Carmel Center before the 19 April fire. He was tried and convicted in the United States of voluntary manslaughter and using a firearm during a crime. He was given a 30-year prison sentence and spent about half of it in various holding facilities in the United States. He was released in July 2007 and deported to the United Kingdom where he currently lives.

<i>The Davidian Massacre: Disturbing Questions About Waco That Must Be Answered</i> Nonfiction book on Waco siege

The Davidian Massacre: Disturbing Questions About Waco That Must Be Answered is a 1995 non-fiction book about the Waco siege written by Carol Moore. It was co-published by the Gun Owners of America Foundation and Legacy Communications.

<i>Armageddon in Waco: Critical Perspectives on the Branch Davidian Conflict</i> Anthology on the Waco siege

Armageddon in Waco: Critical Perspectives on the Branch Davidian Conflict is a 1995 non-fiction anthology book on the Waco siege edited by Stuart A. Wright. It was published by the University of Chicago Press.

<i>From the Ashes: Making Sense of Waco</i> Non-fiction anthology on the Waco siege

From the Ashes: Making Sense of Waco is a 1994 non-fiction anthology book edited by James R. Lewis about the Waco siege. It was published Rowman & Littlefield. The book contains 46 essays from people like Franklin Littell, Stuart A. Wright, David G. Bromley, Thomas Robbins, Dick Anthony, James A. Beckford, James T. Richardson, Dean M. Kelley, and Eldridge Cleaver. Some of the essays are scholarly articles, while others are opinion pieces. Other contents include press releases, personal correspondences, and a poem from a surviving Branch Davidian. Catherine Wessinger notes in her review of the book that it was a chance for new religious movement scholars to respond to the siege.

Why Waco?: Cults and the Battle for Religious Freedom in America is a 1995 non-fiction book written by James D. Tabor and Eugene V. Gallagher on the Waco siege and the anti-cult movement in America. It was published by the University of California Press. The same press reprinted it in 1997 in paperback. The appendix of the book contains an unfinished manuscript written by David Koresh, the leader of the Branch Davidians, on the Seven seals in the Book of Revelation. The appendix has a preface written by Tabor and J. Phillip Arnold. The manuscript was obtained from a survivor of the fire, Ruth Riddle. The final pages of the book provide a list of Branch Davidians who died in the 28 February 1993 raid, the 19 April 1993 fire, and who survived.

Ruth Ottman Riddle is a Canadian Branch Davidian and survivor of the Waco siege. She was born as Ruth Ellen Ottman. Riddle was one of nine survivors of the 19 April 1993 fire that destroyed the Mount Carmel Center and most of its occupants. She carried with her after leaving the compound a copy of David Koresh's final incomplete manuscript which after creating he agreed to leave. It was reprinted in James D. Tabor and Eugene V. Gallagher's book Why Waco?: Cults and the Battle for Religious Freedom in America. She was married to another Branch Davidian, James Loyle Riddle, who died in the 19 April 1993 fire. Her niece, Misty Dawn Ferguson, survived the fire as well. She was formerly of Tweed, Ontario. However, other sources indicate she is from Oshawa, Ontario.

Dana Okimoto is an American former Branch Davidian. She moved to Waco, Texas, from Los Angeles, California, in approximately 1988 with Robyn Bunds, a former Branch Davidian turned critic. She is originally from Hawaii and is a registered psychiatric nurse at Kaneohe State Hospital, and remarried to Roy Kiyabu, a chef, as of 2003. She gave birth to Sky or Skye Borne Okimoto and Scooter Okimoto, who are both children of David Koresh, the leader of the Branch Davidians.

<i>The Branch Davidians of Waco: The History and Beliefs of an Apocalyptic Sect</i> Nonfiction book on the Branch Davidians

The Branch Davidians of Waco: The History and Beliefs of an Apocalyptic Sect is a 2006 nonfiction book by Kenneth G. C. Newport about the Branch Davidians before, during, and after the Waco siege. It was published by Oxford University Press. The book primarily addresses the beliefs, practices, and crucial events in Branch Davidian history through Victor Houteff to David Koresh and Clive Doyle.

Charles J. Pace is the current leader of The Branch, The Lord Our Righteousness, the supposed successor group the Branch Davidians after 1993. According to the Toronto Star, he is from Collingwood, Canada. He joined the Branch Davidians in the 1980s, but he left just before the Waco siege that destroyed the Mt. Carmel center. He claims to be the successor to David Koresh as the prophet of the Branch Davidians, though he does not use the word "prophet". He returned to Waco, Texas in 1994 after having left the Mount Carmel Center in the mid-1980s in order to start his own religious movement. He is trained as a reflexologist, nutritionist, and colon therapist, according to the Toronto Star. A tractor reportedly amputated his foot sometime before April 2013. National Public Radio and other news sources note that he is an herbalist and gardener. He is married to Alex Pace and has two children, Michael and Angela Pace.

Brad Eugene Branch is a former American Branch Davidian who was charged and convicted of aiding and abetting voluntary manslaughter of federal agents during the 1993 Waco siege and weapons charges. He was sentenced to ten years in prison for the voluntary manslaughter charge and thirty years for the weapons charges. Originally, the charge of carrying a firearm during a violent crime was based on a conspiracy to murder charge that was acquitted for Branch and other Davidians, but federal prosecutors asked U.S. District Judge Walter Smith to reinstate the weapons charges, which he did. The Branch Davidians, including Brad Branch, attempted to appeal the charges, but the appeals were turned down in 1997. The United States Supreme Court agreed to hear appellate arguments from the Branch Davidians including Branch in 2000. In response to the Supreme Court's ruling that Smith overstepped his power in his sentencing, he reduced his and other Davidians' sentences to five years for the weapons charges.

References

  1. "Dick Reavis". NC State University: College of Humanities and Social Sciences. Retrieved 2022-08-17.
  2. 1 2 Wessinger, Catherine (October 1997). "Review Essay: Understanding the Branch Davidian Tragedy". Nova Religio . 1 (1): 122–38 via JSTOR.
  3. 1 2 Moore, Carol (1995). "Davidians vs. Goliath". American Enterprise . 6 (6): 90.
  4. 1 2 Kelley, Dean M. (December 1995). "BOOK REVIEWS". Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion . 34 (4): 523–4 via JSTOR.
  5. Sullum, Jacob (March 1996). "Burning Questions". Reason . 27 (10).
  6. Ammerman, Nancy T. (1999). "Moloch's Revenge". The Review of Politics . 61 (4): 755–8 via JSTOR.
  7. Seeger, Murray (Winter 1995). "The Ashes of Waco: An Investigation". Niemann Reports. 49 (4): 87.
  8. Hartse, Caroline (1999). "The Ashes of Waco: An Investigation by Dick J. Reavis". Review of Religious Research . 41 (1): 131–2 via JSTOR.
  9. McMorrow, Timothy K. (June 1996). "The Ashes of Waco: An Investigation". Trial. 32 (6): 71.
  10. Burch, LeAnne (1995). "The Ashes of Waco: An Investigation". Military Law Review. 150: 459–64.
  11. Fantz, Ashley (2011-04-14). "Who was David Koresh?". CNN . Retrieved 2022-08-17.
  12. "BOOKS REVIEWED: THE ASHES OF WACO: AN INVESTIGATION By Dick J. Reavis". American Journal of Criminal Law. 22: 861. Spring 1995.
  13. Bailey, B. Seth (Winter 1996). "BOOK NOTE: Fire on the Mount". American Journal of Criminal Law. 23: 505–8.
  14. Easterbrook, Gregg (September 1995). "POLITICAL BOOKNOTES". Washington Monthly . 27 (9).