Ghosts of Kanungu

Last updated

Ghosts of Kanungu
Ghosts of Kanungu cover.png
AuthorRichard Vokes
LanguageEnglish
SeriesAfrican Anthropology
Subject Movement for the Restoration of the Ten Commandments of God
Publisher Fountain Publishers/James Currey
Publication date
2009
Pages240
ISBN 978-9970-02-732-3
OCLC 837174529
276.7’61082
LC Class BX9998 .V64 2009

Ghosts of Kanungu: Fertility, Secrecy and Exchange in the Great Lakes of East Africa is a book by Richard Vokes about the cult the Movement for the Restoration of the Ten Commandments of God (MRTC), notorious for the deaths of hundreds of its members in what was alternatively described as mass suicide or mass murder in 2000. The book was co-published by the Ugandan publisher Fountain Publishers and James Currey in 2009. An ethnography of the group, the book analyzes the MRTC in the context of the wider religious background of Uganda, and attempts to show what led to the deaths.

Contents

It places the MRTC within the context of Ugandan religion and history at the time, with a particular focus on the influence of Nyabingi, a set of local religious practices utilized to redress misfortune, which Vokes argues was later replaced by and conflated with the Virgin Mary. He also focuses on how its growth was influenced by the struggles of AIDs and its background of Catholic religious influence. It argues against the commonly accepted theory about the MRTC, that there was mass murder by the groups leaders; instead, he argues that it had actually been mass suicide, and that the dead believed to have been mass murder victims were actually malaria victims from years prior.

Ghosts of Kanungu received a highly positive reception. Reviewers praised it for its writing quality and style; several reviews compared it to a detective story. The conclusions of the book were mostly praised, with reviewers calling them plausible and well evidenced, though some commentators disagreed with the classification Vokes made of the organization or its aspects. Some minor criticisms were levied at the book's clarity and open-ended nature.

Background

After the 1980s, there was an increase in charismatic religious leaders and movements in Uganda. [1] The Movement for the Restoration of the Ten Commandments of God was one of these, a millennialist religious movement, an African-initiated church (AIC) created by native Africans instead of missionaries. [2] [1] The group was led by Joseph Kibwetere and Ceredonia Mwerinde. [3]

In March 2000, several hundred corpses were found in a burnt building on one of the group's compounds. [2] Initially, it was believed that they had died in a mass suicide, but the discovery of several hundred more bodies in mass graves at the group's other locations made later investigators believe it was possibly mass murder. [2] [4] The leaders of the group were never found. [5] This incident made worldwide news, but many events surrounding it remained confused, and the Commission of Inquiry to investigate the case never released a report; one reviewer argued this was due in part to how complicated the issue was, while another called it part of the "global forgetting" the government of Uganda had encouraged to avoid embarrassment. [3] [5]

Richard Vokes is an associate professor in anthropology at the University of Western Australia. [6] He began doctoral fieldwork in Uganda in 2001; the MRTC suicides occurred just a week after he arrived in Kampala. [5] He has conducted fieldwork in the Great Lakes region of East Africa as well as in the Western Indian Ocean Rim area. He received his PhD in social anthropology from the University of Oxford in 2004, and is the author of several books and collections. [6]

Publication

The book was based on an eight year long ethnographic study Vokes undertook. [3] In investigating the MRTC, Vokes traveled contacting former members, relatives, and others who would have knowledge of the group, while based in a village home. He learned the Runyankole and Rukiga languages and developed many relationships with the people he met while investigating. In writing the book, he analyzed a variety of primary source documents, including newspapers, archives, and photos. [2] As many of the members were dead, he relied mostly on accounts of defectors and relatives, as well as the group's published works. [4] The book was co-published by James Currey and the Ugandan Fountain Publishers. [2] Following its publication, it was shortlisted for the Herskovits Award. [1]

Contents

Ghosts of Kanungu opens with a prologue describing the discovery of the deaths, as well as the immediate investigation and media coverage on what had occurred. Vokes tells of how he had only recently arrived in the country and was attempting to kill time when, sitting in a hotel, he saw it break on the news; he later traveled near the crime scene by coincidence but was denied entry by a policeman. The media initially portrayed the group as a suicidal millennial cult that had committed mass suicide, comparing it to several past notorious cult suicides, but only a few days later the story changed to the group committing mass murder following the discovery of the other bodies. Vokes argues this conclusion was made by the Ugandan police due to pressure from foreign journalists.

He describes the "only plausible explanation" that emerged from this period was the idea that the group's members had wanted their money returned following a failed prophecy, leading to the group's leadership deciding to kill the dissenting members – but due to increasing levels of dissent it escalated into a mass murder. Vokes calls this theory "plausible" but also "far-fetched"; in his view this led to the dropping of the case by the international media due to their inability to give a conventional narrative to the case. In the introduction that follows Vokes sets out the book's goals and what he describes as its main argument. The introduction largely summarizes the rest of the book. He notes the group's secrecy compared to other AICs, which he views as one of the stranger aspects of the case, and says this shows that the group is most easily understood as having been, for at least most of its history, a network of secret groups. The introduction summarizes the book's arguments, including its relation to Nyabingi, an organization mostly viewed a colonial resistance group active in the early 20th century, but that which actually had the primary purpose of acquiring redress for misfortunes.

With the influence of the Catholic Church by colonial missionaries, it began to fulfill the social role Nyabingi had once provided, particularly through the sacrament of confession. Attempting to convert the local peoples, they had utilized their beliefs; adoration of the Virgin Mary was used by missionaries to replace Nyabingi worship. While the missionaries viewed Mary as an alternative to Nyabingi, the converts viewed her instead as a transformation of her. Vokes views this model of Christian thought as heavily influenced by indigenous Kiga cosmology, and many old Nyabingi practices and terms were transformed into Catholic ones. Many of these Marian networks expanded across the region with an increase in popular Christianity in Uganda more broadly, leading to an increase in reports of Marian visions. Vokes presents the MRTC as an AIC starting as a branch of the Legion of Mary (a largely female Catholic organization).

Its leader Joseph Kibweteere had experienced in 1984 a Marian vision, in which he was told by the vision of Mary that humanity had become corrupted and that the only way to save humanity was to return to the Ten Commandments. Following this vision, he left Kabale, and joined the Legion of Mary and traveled to visit other seers and communicate their visions. In 1989, he met another seer, Ceredonia Mwerinde, who told him that she had received a vision telling her she would soon meet a man named Joseph, with whom she would change the world. Vokes calls the key event in the creation of the MRTC. According to Vokes, membership was influenced by a desire to resolve infertility issues, polygamy, and illness, but was also affected by Uganda's AIDS epidemic; the area they operated in was heavily affected by the disease, and its membership rapidly grew during a period of severity.

Vokes then argues against the typical interpretation of events that there was mass murder by the groups leaders. He raises several issues with this idea, noting that though a key point of evidence was that the dead had sold all their belongings, they had done so out of desperation and had nowhere else to turn. He describes what happened as the product of both the member's influences and also the product of forces beyond them. He notes his "last revelation" as when he had interviewed a former member of the MRTC, who alongside disagreeing with a major aspect of the murder hypothesis told him that there was actually a major malaria epidemic several years prior and that this was what the bodies in the pits came from. Vokes argues that this matches up with an epidemic that occurred there in 1998, and that due to few signs of violence on the pit bodies and their advanced stage of decomposition, it was likely that his story was accurate; while he says this evidence is circumstantial, he says that it is not contradicted by any police evidence. Vokes argues that the main set of deaths were unrelated and were, in fact, a mass suicide, with little signs of resistance by the dead.

In an epilogue, Vokes discusses the aftereffects of the MRTC's actions. He says that the MRTC deaths led to many shifts in the political landscape of Uganda; local authorities emerged highly embarrassed by the affair (especially following revelations several local officials had made dealings with the organization) and the fires were used as a tool to push for district status for Kanungu as a region, which succeeded. It resulted in criticism of the government, and the religious authorities in the region began to take steps to prevent similar acts from occurring once more. He concludes by discussing some "imaginaries"; several people he interviewed described being haunted by the Kanungu dead, and notes that he has begun to imagine that "the ghosts of Kanungu have at least acknowledged my own humble endeavours, to record the details of their lives, and to make some little sense of how and why they met their final, tragic ends".

Reception

The book received critical acclaim from reviewers. Richard Fardon of the University of London called it "compelling", complimenting it as "amongst the outstanding Africanist ethnographies of recent years" and "riveting from first to last". [7] A review in American Ethnologist called the book an "excellent" example of anthropology on easily misunderstood groups and a "vital contribution to the study of the MRTC". They praised its research and said it provided an important counter to the typical "mysteries" that were discussed around the MRTC and similar groups. [8] Shane Doyle of the journal Africa described the book as "remarkable" and "impressively researched". [5]

The writing and style were praised. [9] [2] [3] [10] Katrien Pype praised the writing as fluent, noting its appeal to various audiences and saying it "extends the Africanist library". [9] Susan Reynolds Whyte said it showed "what Africanist scholarship can be at its best", calling it a "tour de force in historical ethnography and anthropological detective work". She said it would appeal to many audiences, including scholars of Africa, Ugandans, and that all readers would appreciate the style and "detective" elements. [2] Many reviewers compared the book to a detective story. [2] [9] [11] T.O. Beidelman described it as resembling an "an investigative journalistic account of a major murder mystery" and said it seemed as if much information had been withheld by involved authorities. [11] Beidelman further complained that the book was unclear in several respects about what had happened and what had led to it, arguing that "if an author writes a murder mystery, he or she should expect the reader to want more answers than this provocative book provides." [11]

The conclusions reached by Vokes were largely praised. Naomi Haynes, writing for the journal Social Analysis , said Ghosts of Kanungu was "cogently argued and compelling", calling its conclusions plausible. [4] John Walliss, in the 2014 book Sacred Suicide , in his survey of accounts on what could have happened, says he found Vokes' theory the "most convincing" of all proposed theories, due to the quality of his fieldwork and the fact he answers the question of why there was no evidence of a 1999/2000 prophecy (instead Vokes theorizes it was 2000/2001). He describes Vokes' theory of the deaths themselves, that the bodies found after the fire were unrelated, as "without doubt the most radical aspect" of the book, noting its rejection of the usual interpretation of the events. He does note that, as Vokes himself says, this theory could be challenged by new evidence. [12] In an analysis on violence and religion in Uganda, Kizito Kiyimba of the Journal for the Study of Religion called it the "most authoritative analysis" of what had led to the deaths, saying he largely agreed with Vokes's interpretation and that he had done a valuable job. He however argued that Vokes's interpretation may have been "overly materialistic" as well as reductionist, and that it failed to explain some aspects. [13]

Other reviewers disagreed with some aspects of his conclusion, or viewed them as unconvincing. The journal History and Anthropology described Vokes's work as "especially compelling" in how it showed how the MRTC was subject to international influences, but criticized its conclusion as the "least convincing" aspect of the book. They concluded positively, describing it as "admirably mix[ing] history, ethnography and a sense of fundamental continuities". [14] Grace Akello described the book as "well-written and accessible" and said its main findings were "methodologically well-grounded". [3] She did however question Vokes' conclusions deeming the MRTC Nyabingi worshipers given that the evidence he presented and the group's own goals seemed to tie them more to the Catholic church, as well as the usage of several informants in New Zealand (who only had access to photographs) to verify some data instead of people who were at the scene. [3] American Ethnologist argued the book raised questions about the nature of evidence in ethnography, and raised the question of whether his distance in time from the events "facilitates or impedes ethnographic analysis". [8] Haynes wished the book had included more engagement with literature on African Independent Christianity, or other types of Christianity; she viewed the book's treatment of these as cursory, and wished for a stronger emphasis on comparative religion. [4] Scholar J. Kwabena Asamoah-Gyadu however questioned the assessment of the MRTC as an AIC, and viewed the descriptor as "forced" on the movement by the book. [10] Kiyimba also disagreed with the portrayal of the group as an AIC. [13]

Following the 2023 Shakahola Forest incident in Uganda, in which many cult members died, its leader was compared to Kibweteere and there were discussions on what could lead to both such incidents. The Ugandan Daily Monitor reviewed Ghosts of Kanungu in the aftermath, praising it as a "highly readable" work and noting its focus on the context of the movement's origins. [1]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anthropology</span> Scientific study of humans, human behavior, and societies

Anthropology is the scientific study of humanity, concerned with human behavior, human biology, cultures, societies, and linguistics, in both the present and past, including archaic humans. Social anthropology studies patterns of behavior, while cultural anthropology studies cultural meaning, including norms and values. The term sociocultural anthropology is commonly used today. Linguistic anthropology studies how language influences social life. Biological or physical anthropology studies the biological development of humans.

<i>The Golden Bough</i> 1890 book by James Frazer

The Golden Bough: A Study in Comparative Religion is a wide-ranging, comparative study of mythology and religion, written by the Scottish anthropologist Sir James George Frazer. The Golden Bough was first published in two volumes in 1890; in three volumes in 1900; and in twelve volumes in the third edition, published 1906–1915. It has also been published in several different one-volume abridgments. The work was for a wide literate audience raised on tales as told in such publications as Thomas Bulfinch's The Age of Fable, or Stories of Gods and Heroes (1855). The influence of The Golden Bough on contemporary European literature and thought has been substantial.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ritual</span> Activities performed according to a set sequence

A ritual is a sequence of activities involving gestures, words, actions, or revered objects. Rituals may be prescribed by the traditions of a community, including a religious community. Rituals are characterized, but not defined, by formalism, traditionalism, invariance, rule-governance, sacral symbolism, and performance.

Anthropology of religion is the study of religion in relation to other social institutions, and the comparison of religious beliefs and practices across cultures. The anthropology of religion, as a field, overlaps with but is distinct from the field of Religious Studies. The history of anthropology of religion is a history of striving to understand how other people view and navigate the world. This history involves deciding what religion is, what it does, and how it functions. Today, one of the main concerns of anthropologists of religion is defining religion, which is a theoretical undertaking in and of itself. Scholars such as Edward Tylor, Emile Durkheim, E.E. Evans Pritchard, Mary Douglas, Victor Turner, Clifford Geertz, and Talal Asad have all grappled with defining and characterizing religion anthropologically.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bronisław Malinowski</span> Polish anthropologist and ethnographer (1884–1942)

Bronisław Kasper Malinowski was a Polish-British anthropologist and ethnologist whose writings on ethnography, social theory, and field research have exerted a lasting influence on the discipline of anthropology.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mary Douglas</span> British anthropologist (1921–2007)

Dame Mary Douglas, was a British anthropologist, known for her writings on human culture, symbolism and risk, whose area of speciality was social anthropology. Douglas was considered a follower of Émile Durkheim and a proponent of structuralist analysis, with a strong interest in comparative religion.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mass suicide</span> Groups of people killing themselves together

Mass suicide is a form of suicide, occurring when a group of people simultaneously kill themselves. Mass suicide sometimes occurs in religious settings. In war, defeated groups may resort to mass suicide rather than being captured. Suicide pacts are a form of mass suicide that are sometimes planned or carried out by small groups of depressed or hopeless people. Mass suicides have been used as a form of political protest.

The Movement for the Restoration of the Ten Commandments of God was a religious movement founded by Credonia Mwerinde and Joseph Kibweteere in southwestern Uganda, notorious for the mass death of several hundred members of the group in a mass suicide in the year 2000. It was formed in 1989 after Mwerinde and Kibweteere claimed that they had seen visions of the Virgin Mary.

Joseph Kibweteere was one of the leaders of the Movement for the Restoration of the Ten Commandments of God, a group that splintered from the Catholic Church in Uganda and became infamous after 778 of its members were found dead. Although Kibweteere was assumed to have died in the incident, the Ugandan police shortly afterwards issued a warrant for arrest against the other leaders of the group. In 2014 it was announced by the Uganda National Police that there were reports that Kibweteere was hiding in Malawi.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">African-initiated church</span> Independent Christian church

An African-initiated church (AIC) is a Christian church independently started in Africa by Africans rather than chiefly by missionaries from another continent.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kigezi District</span> Former district in Uganda

Kigezi District once covered what are now Kabale District, Kanungu District, Kisoro District and Rukungiri District, in southwest Uganda. Its terraced fields are what gives this part of Uganda its distinctive character. Kigezi was popularly known as the Switzerland of Africa. The coordinates for the region are: Latitude:01 13 20S, 29 53 20E.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Audrey Richards</span> British anthropologist (1899–1984)

Audrey Isabel Richards, CBE, FRAI, FBA, was a pioneering British social anthropologist. She produced notable ethnographic studies. The most famous of which is Chisungu: A Girl's initiation ceremony among the Bemba of Zambia.

Credonia Mwerinde was the high priestess and co-founder of the Movement for the Restoration of the Ten Commandments of God (MRTC), a sect that splintered from the Roman Catholic Church in Uganda. Before founding the movement she was a shopkeeper, brewer, and a prostitute. She and two other group members approached Joseph Kibweteere in 1989, and said that the Virgin Mary had instructed him to take them in; together Mwerinde and Kibweteere would found the MRTC in 1989.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hamites</span> Outdated grouping of human beings

Hamites is the name formerly used for some Northern and Horn of Africa peoples in the context of a now-outdated model of dividing humanity into different races; this was developed originally by Europeans in support of colonialism and slavery. The term was originally borrowed from the Book of Genesis, in which it refers to the descendants of Ham, son of Noah.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Great Lakes Twa</span> Pygmy ethnic group of the African Great Lakes region

The Great Lakes Twa, also known as Batwa, Abatwa or Ge-Sera, are a Bantu speaking group native to the African Great Lakes region on the border of Central and East Africa. As an indigenous pygmy people, the Twa are generally assumed to be the oldest surviving population of the Great Lakes region. Current populations of Great Lakes Twa people live in the states of Rwanda, Burundi, Uganda and the eastern portion of the Democratic Republic of Congo. In 2000 they numbered approximately 80,000 people, making them a significant minority group in these countries. The largest population of Twa is located in Burundi estimated in 2008 at 78,071 people.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Archie Mafeje</span> South African anthropologist and activist (1936–2007)

Archibald Boyce Monwabisi Mafeje, commonly known as Archie Mafeje, was a South African anthropologist and activist. Born in what is now the Eastern Cape, he received degrees from the University of Cape Town (UCT) and the University of Cambridge. He became a professor at various universities in Europe, North America, and Africa. He spent most of his career away from apartheid South Africa after he was blocked from teaching at UCT in 1968.

<i>Sacred Suicide</i> 2014 book by James R. Lewis and Carole M. Cusack

Sacred Suicide is a 2014 edited volume about suicide and religion, particularly as it relates to cults or new religious movements. It was published by Ashgate and edited by James R. Lewis and Carole M. Cusack, part of the Ashgate New Religions series. Other contributors to the book include Nachman Ben-Yehuda, Mattias Gardell, and Thomas Robbins. It is divided into five sections.

<i>Apocalypse Observed</i> 2000 book by John R. Hall

Apocalypse Observed: Religious Movements and Violence in North America, Europe and Japan is a book about millennialism, apocalypticism and religious violence, written by sociologist John R. Hall. Philip D. Schuyler and Sylvaine Trinh, also sociologists, co-authored two of the chapters. It was published in December 2000 by Routledge. The book analyzes five new religious movements known for high profile acts of violence from a sociological perspective: the Peoples Temple, the Branch Davidians, Aum Shinrikyo, the Order of the Solar Temple, and Heaven's Gate.

<i>Violence and New Religious Movements</i> 2011 book by James R. Lewis

Violence and New Religious Movements is a 2011 edited volume. It was edited by sociologist James R. Lewis and published by Oxford University Press. Lewis' previous work had focused on new religious movements, and he had edited several books on the topic. Containing 19 articles by 22 academics, mostly sociologists or scholars in religious studies, it discusses the intersection between new religious movements and violence, both perpetrated by and against the groups. It is divided into five sections.

Heike Behrend is a German social anthropologist, specialized in African and Media studies. From 1994 until 2012, she was professor of Ethnology at the Institute of African Studies and Egyptology at the University of Cologne. Her scientific career is based on her fieldwork in African countries, particularly Kenya and Uganda. Her research is focused on ritual practices, religion, and memory, exploring the intersections between local African beliefs and global influences. Further, she has contributed several studies and curated exhibitions on photography in Africa.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Matogo, Phillip (30 April 2023). "Kanungu to Malindi, cult religion persists" . Daily Monitor . Kampala. Retrieved 4 August 2024.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Whyte, Susan Reynolds (December 2011). "Ghosts of Kanungu: Fertility, Secrecy and Exchange in the Great Lakes of East Africa". Ethnos: Journal of Anthropology. 76 (4): 562–564. doi:10.1080/00141844.2011.565127. ISSN   0014-1844.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Akello, Grace (November 2010). "Ghosts of Kanungu: fertility, secrecy and exchange in the Great Lakes of East Africa by Vokes Richard". Social Anthropology . 18 (4): 503–505. doi:10.1111/j.1469-8676.2010.00133_24.x. ISSN   0964-0282.
  4. 1 2 3 4 Haynes, Naomi (2016). "Review of Ghosts of Kanungu: Fertility, Secrecy and Exchange in the Great Lakes of East Africa". Social Analysis: The International Journal of Social and Cultural Practice . 60 (3): 134–136. ISSN   0155-977X. JSTOR   26404945.
  5. 1 2 3 4 Doyle, Shane (2015). "Review of Ghosts of Kanungu: fertility, secrecy and exchange in the Great Lakes of East Africa". Africa: Journal of the International African Institute . 85 (2): 366–367. ISSN   0001-9720. JSTOR   24525745.
  6. 1 2 "Dr Richard Vokes". School of Anthropology & Museum Ethnography. University of Oxford . Retrieved 4 August 2024.
  7. ↑ Fardon, Richard (2012). "Review of Ghosts of Kanungu: Fertility, secrecy and exchange in the Great Lakes of East Africa, (Series in African Anthropology)". African Affairs . 111 (445): 673–675. ISSN   0001-9909. JSTOR   23357177.
  8. 1 2 Murchison, Julian M. (2015). "Review of Ghosts of Kanungu: Fertility, Secrecy and Exchange in the Great Lakes of East Africa". American Ethnologist . 42 (2): 377–378. ISSN   0094-0496. JSTOR   43867920.
  9. 1 2 3 Pype, Katrien (2014). "Review of Ghosts of Kanungu Fertility, Secrecy & Exchange in the Great Lakes of East Africa". Journal of Religion in Africa . 44 (3/4): 428–429. ISSN   0022-4200. JSTOR   43303328.
  10. 1 2 Asamoah-Gyadu, J. Kwabena (January 2011). "Ghosts of Kanungu. Fertility, secrecy and exchange in the great lakes of East Africa. By Richard Vokes. (African Anthropology.) Pp. xiv+240 incl. 3 maps and 24 ills. Kampala: Fountain Publishers/Woodbridge: James Currey, 2009. £55. 978 9970 02 732 3; 978 1 84701 009 4". The Journal of Ecclesiastical History . 62 (1): 203–204. doi:10.1017/S0022046910002952. ISSN   1469-7637.
  11. 1 2 3 Beidelman, T.O. (2015). "Review of Ghosts of Kanungu: fertility, secrecy and exchange in the Great Lakes of East Africa". Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute . 21 (1): 242–243. ISSN   1359-0987. JSTOR   43907854.
  12. ↑ Walliss, John (2014). "Apocalypse in Uganda: The Movement for the Restoration of the Ten Commandments of God One Decade On". In Lewis, James R.; Cusack, Carole M. (eds.). Sacred Suicide. Ashgate Publishing. pp. 123–125. ISBN   978-1-4094-5086-3.
  13. 1 2 Kiyimba, Kizito (2017). "An Analysis of the Epistemic Link between the Catholic Religion and Violence in Uganda's History". Journal for the Study of Religion . 30 (1): 26–51. doi:10.17159/2413-3027/2017/v30n1a2. ISSN   1011-7601.
  14. ↑ Ranger, Terence (December 2012). "Ghosts of Kanungu: Fertility, Secrecy and Exchange in the Great Lakes of East Africa". History and Anthropology . 23 (4): 507–510. doi:10.1080/02757206.2012.726718. ISSN   0275-7206.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.