The Dorchester Review

Last updated
The Dorchester Review
The Dorchester Review logo.png
Editors
  • C. P. Champion
  • Michael R. Jackson Bonner
  • James W. J. Bowden
  • F. H. Buckley
  • Donal Lowry
  • Philip Marchand
  • Gregory Melleuish
  • John Pepall
  • Phyllis Reeve
  • John Robson
  • Alastair Sweeny [1]
CategoriesHistory and culture
FrequencySemi-annual
Circulation 800
First issueJune 1, 2011;12 years ago (2011-06-01)
Country Canada
Based in Ottawa
Language English
Website www.dorchesterreview.ca
ISSN 1925-7600

The Dorchester Review, founded in 2011, is a semi-annual journal of history and historical commentary that describes itself as a non-partisan but "robustly polemical" outlet for "elements of tradition and culture inherent to Canadian experience that fail to conform to a stridently progressivist narrative." [2]

Contents

Dorchester Review for sale on a newsstand in The Glebe, Ottawa, November 2011: top left Dorchester Review for sale on newsstand.jpg
Dorchester Review for sale on a newsstand in The Glebe, Ottawa, November 2011: top left

Contents

The journal includes articles on history as well as historical commentary. The name Dorchester was chosen to honour the 1st Baron Dorchester, Guy Carleton, who served as Governor of the Province of Quebec from 1768 to 1778, and Governor General of British North America from 1785 to 1795. [3] Carleton defied General George Washington and encouraged escaped slaves to emigrate with the Loyalists to Canada. [4] He also extended religious liberty to Roman Catholics and Jews under his officially Protestant regime. The editors explained in their first editorial in 2011 that the choice of "a bewigged British soldier, an ... unapologetic colonial governor from the pre-democratic era" is intended to underscore the magazine's belief that "history consists of more than a parade of secular modern progressives." [2] As David Frum summarized the Review's approach to history, "The important thing to understand about 19th century Canada is that it was not a failed revolutionary state. It was a successful conservative state. The great achievement of Canadian history was precisely the achievement of self-rule within the context of institutional continuity." [5]

The Review's editors wrote in the first issue's opening editorial:

We confess another potentially unpopular belief: that, at its core, Canada’s strength and advantage — that of a British liberal society with a strong French national enclave, resilient aboriginal communities, and a vital pluralism born of successive immigrant arrivals — would be void if polemically separated from its European, Judeo-Christian and Classical traditions, which is another answer to: why history. We are conscious and grateful heirs to an invaluable if variously pressured tradition of free expression and criticism that is found and defended with particular seriousness in the North Atlantic societies, and this we think should be recognized, protected, and always enhanced. [6]

Controversies

According to news reports, a 2019 Dorchester Review article by Champion entitled "Alberta’s Little History War," said that in Alberta classrooms, the "ongoing fad is that we need 'more' First Nations 'perspectives.'". [7] He said this was faddish because he himself had got a "repetitive" dose of "oolichan, cedar masks, and Trickster stories" in his own elementary school experience during the 1970s. He criticized as "deplorable agitprop" the classroom activity to teach from an alleged Indigenous perspective —the KAIROS Blanket exercise—"brainwashes children into thinking of themselves as ‘settlers’ stealing the land — the kind of 'truth and reconciliation' that is not evidence-based but relies on 'knowledge keepers’ to 'foster truth.'" [7] The blanket exercise has been widely used in Canada in response to the 2015 Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) call for inclusion of indigenous history in school curriculum as essential for improved relationships with non-indigenous people. [8] The TRC gathered approximately 7,000 testimonies from the survivors of residential schools over a six-year period—from 2008 to 2014, according to Justice Murray Sinclair. [9]

Themes

The history wars

According to a 2013 Toronto Review of Books article, "The History Wars in Canada", in 1998, then-York University history professor, Jack Granatstein "fired the opening shot of the History Wars"—a "fierce conflict about the meaning and purpose" of Canadian history. [10] In his 1998 book, Who Killed Canadian History? , Jack Granatstein said that, since the late 1960s, a new generation of social historians in history departments have waged an ideological war with historians like himself, who defend the traditional narrative history, with a focus on chronology and elite figures in political and military history. [11] :59 He said that in the writing and teaching of history in Canada, the teaching of "hard facts", has been replaced by distorted interpretations of the past that focus on "victimization and blame seeking". Among the reasons for these changes in historiography he included multiculturalism and the whole child approach to learning. [11]

In a 2013 article, Mark Sholdice argued that Champion was one of the "right-wing activists and scholars" leading the history wars in Canada, and moreover that he was "probably the most important Conservative historian in Canada" at that time. [10] Champion's 2010 book, The Strange Demise of British Canada: The Liberals and Canadian Nationalism, 1964-1968, written as his doctoral thesis, Nova Britannia Revisited, between 2004 and 2007, anticipated the Harper administration's views on the writing and teaching of Canadian history. [12] Sholdice added that in 2011, the history wars became a "tangible reality," with the Harper government favouring subjects such as the "military and the monarchy" for "historical attention", and "spending lavishly" on the "commemoration of the War of 1812." [10]

Media

National Post columnist Barbara Kay described the Dorchester Review as "politically incorrect and iconoclastic" writing which resists "the prevailing progressivist view that historians must choose between a right and wrong side of history," without catering to a specific ideology. David Frum greeted the Review's launch in 2011 as "one of the most exciting intellectual projects Canada has seen in a long while." [13] Jonathan Kay has described it as "the only high-level publication in Canada that examines our history and traditions without even a passing nod to academic fashions and identity politics." [14] Former Conservative Prime Minister Stephen Harper was observed reading the magazine in the House of Commons of Canada, contributing to its image as a right-wing publication. [14]

Writing in the Literary Review of Canada , professor of European Studies Jerry White cited The Dorchester Review among works that "might...prompt readers to rethink the way in which not all liberals are Liberals and not all conservatives sound like the Conservatives." [15]

The Review has been attacked by members of the alt-right tendency for being insufficiently alarmed by large-scale immigration. Ricardo Duchesne faulted Australian contributor Gregory Melleuish as an example of how "Conservatives self-deceive themselves into believing what they dislike because they are afraid of leftist repercussions." [16] The Review also published in its second issue an article highly critical of the treatment of Japanese Canadians during the Second World War. [17]

In 2017, Champion criticized right-wing counter-protestors for co-opting the Canadian Red Ensign, saying he was "disappointed when the self-described traditionalists of the Proud Boys were captured on video provoking Indigenous protesters with the flag." [18]

The journal's publication in 2022 of an article by Jacques Rouillard suggesting there was no concrete evidence of mass unmarked burials at Indian Residential Schools [19] received international attention from The Spectator, [20] among others. In follow-up, contributors Tom Flanagan and Brian Giesbrecht, [21] and anthropologist Hymie Rubenstein criticized [22] Canada's Crown-Indigenous Relations minister Marc Miller's rebuke of those that criticized "the nature and validity of these and other recovery efforts" following the announcement of the discovery of potentially unmarked grave at the St Joseph's Mission School. [23] [24]

Notable contributors

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert Borden</span> Prime minister of Canada from 1911 to 1920

Sir Robert Laird Borden was a Canadian lawyer and politician who was the eighth prime minister of Canada from 1911 to 1920. He is best known for his leadership of Canada during World War I.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">William Lyon Mackenzie King</span> 10th prime minister of Canada (1921–1926; 1926–1930; 1935–1948)

William Lyon Mackenzie King was a Canadian statesman and politician who was the tenth prime minister of Canada for three non-consecutive terms from 1921 to 1926, 1926 to 1930, and 1935 to 1948. A Liberal, he was the dominant politician in Canada from the early 1920s to the late 1940s. King is best known for his leadership of Canada throughout the Great Depression and the Second World War. He played a major role in laying the foundations of the Canadian welfare state and established Canada's international reputation as a middle power fully committed to world order. With a total of 21 years and 154 days in office, he remains the longest-serving prime minister in Canadian history.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">David Frum</span> Canadian-American political commentator (born 1960)

David Jeffrey Frum is a Canadian-American political commentator and a former speechwriter for President George W. Bush. He is currently a senior editor at The Atlantic as well as an MSNBC contributor. In 2003, Frum authored the first book about Bush's presidency written by a former member of the administration. He has taken credit for the famous phrase "axis of evil" in Bush's 2002 State of the Union address.

<i>National Post</i> Canadian national daily newspaper

The National Post is a Canadian English-language broadsheet newspaper available in several cities in central and western Canada. The paper is the flagship publication of Postmedia Network and is published Mondays through Saturdays, with Monday released as a digital e-edition only. The newspaper is distributed in the provinces of Ontario, Quebec, Alberta and British Columbia. Weekend editions of the newspaper are also distributed in Manitoba and Saskatchewan.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stephen Harper</span> Prime minister of Canada from 2006 to 2015

Stephen Joseph Harper is a Canadian politician who served as the 22nd prime minister of Canada from 2006 to 2015. Harper is the first and only prime minister to come from the modern-day Conservative Party of Canada, serving as the party's first leader from 2004 to 2015.

The Conservative Party of Canada, colloquially known as the Tories, is a federal political party in Canada. It was formed in 2003 by the merger of the two main right-leaning parties, the Progressive Conservative Party and the Canadian Alliance, the latter being the successor of the Western Canadian–based Reform Party. The party sits at the centre-right to the right of the Canadian political spectrum, with their federal rival, the Liberal Party of Canada, positioned to their left. The Conservatives are defined as a "big tent" party, practising "brokerage politics" and welcoming a broad variety of members, including "Red Tories" and "Blue Tories".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Canadian Indian residential school system</span> Schools to assimilate Indigenous children

The CanadianIndian residential school system was a network of boarding schools for Indigenous peoples. The network was funded by the Canadian government's Department of Indian Affairs and administered by Christian churches. The school system was created to isolate Indigenous children from the influence of their own culture and religion in order to assimilate them into the dominant Canadian culture. Over the course of the system's more than hundred-year existence, around 150,000 children were placed in residential schools nationally. By the 1930s, about 30 percent of Indigenous children were attending residential schools. The number of school-related deaths remains unknown due to incomplete records. Estimates range from 3,200 to over 30,000, mostly from disease.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pierre Poilievre</span> Canadian politician (born 1979)

Pierre Marcel Poilievre is a Canadian politician who has served as the leader of the Conservative Party of Canada and the leader of the Official Opposition since 2022. He has been a member of Parliament (MP) since 2004.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Truth commission</span> Commission tasked with discovering and revealing past wrongdoing

A truth commission, also known as a truth and reconciliation commission or truth and justice commission, is an official body tasked with discovering and revealing past wrongdoing by a government, in the hope of resolving conflict left over from the past. Truth commissions are, under various names, occasionally set up by states emerging from periods of internal unrest, civil war, or dictatorship marked by human rights abuses. In both their truth-seeking and reconciling functions, truth commissions have political implications: they "constantly make choices when they define such basic objectives as truth, reconciliation, justice, memory, reparation, and recognition, and decide how these objectives should be met and whose needs should be served".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Premiership of Stephen Harper</span>

The premiership of Stephen Harper began on February 6, 2006, when the first Cabinet headed by Stephen Harper was sworn in by Governor General Michaelle Jean. Harper was invited to form the 28th Canadian Ministry, becoming Prime Minister of Canada following the 2006 election, where Harper's Conservative Party won a plurality of seats in the House of Commons of Canada, defeating the Liberal Prime Minister Paul Martin's government. In the 2011 federal election, Harper won his first and only majority government.

Barbara Kay is a columnist for the Canadian newspaper National Post. She also writes a weekly column for The Post Millennial and a monthly column for Epoch Times.

Gregory Melleuish is an Australian associate professor of history and politics at the University of Wollongong. Subjects he teaches include Australian politics, political theory, world history and ancient history. Previously, he taught European history at the University of Melbourne and Australian Studies at the University of Queensland. He occasionally contributes opinion pieces for The Australian, The Conversation and On Line Opinion. He has been contributing editor of the Canada-based history journal, The Dorchester Review since 2011.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada</span> Investigated harm to indigenous students

The Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada was a truth and reconciliation commission active in Canada from 2008 to 2015, organized by the parties of the Indian Residential Schools Settlement Agreement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jonathan Kay</span> Canadian journalist

Jonathan Hillel Kay is a Canadian journalist. He was the editor-in-chief of The Walrus (2014–2017), and is a senior editor of Quillette. He was previously comment pages editor, columnist, and blogger for the Toronto-based Canadian daily newspaper National Post, and continues to contribute to the newspaper on a freelance basis. He is also a book author and editor, a public speaker, and a regular contributor to Commentary and the New York Post.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Day for Truth and Reconciliation</span> Canadian day of remembrance for victims of residential schools

The National Day for Truth and Reconciliation, originally and still colloquially known as Orange Shirt Day, is a Canadian holiday to recognize the legacy of the Canadian Indian residential school system.

<i>Who Killed Canadian History?</i> 1998 book by J. L. Granatstein

Who Killed Canadian History? is a 1998 book by Canadian historian J. L. Granatstein. The book argues that Canadians lack national unity because of their failure to teach their country's history. Granatstein contends that multiculturalism, social historians and weak history teaching standards are responsible for Canada's lack of a historical narrative. He advocates for a greater emphasis on the study of Canadian history in schools and university history departments, especially political and military history.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kuper Island Indian Residential School</span> Defunct Canadian residential school

The Kuper Island Indian Residential School, also known as Kuper Island Indian Industrial School, was a Canadian Indian residential school located on Kuper Island, near Chemainus, British Columbia, that operated from 1889 to 1975. The school was operated by the Roman Catholic Church, with funding from the Department of Indian Affairs.

The Canadian Indian residential school system were a network of boarding schools for Indigenous peoples. Directed and funded by the Department of Indian Affairs, and administered mainly by Christian churches, the residential school system removed and isolated Indigenous children from the influence of their own native culture and religion in order to forcefully assimilate them into the dominant Canadian culture. Given that most of them were established by Christian missionaries with the express purpose of converting Indigenous children to Christianity, schools often had nearby mission churches with community cemeteries. Students were often buried in these cemeteries rather than being sent back to their home communities, since the school was expected by the Department of Indian Affairs to keep costs as low as possible. Additionally, occasional outbreaks of disease led to the creation of mass graves when the school had insufficient staff to bury students individually.

The foreign policies of Canada and its predecessor colonies were under British control until the 20th century. This included wars with the United States in 1775-1783 and 1812–1815. Economic ties with the U.S. were always close. Political tensions arose in the 19th century from anti-British sentiment in the U.S. in the 1860s. Boundary issues caused diplomatic disputes resolved in the 1840s over the Maine boundary. and early 1900s, in the early 20th century over the Alaska boundary. There is ongoing discussion regarding the Arctic. Canada-US relations have been friendly in the 20th and 21st centuries.

References

  1. Masthead of Vol. 10, No. 1, Spring/Summer 2020 (print edition).
  2. 1 2 "The Dorchester Review — About". The Dorchester Review. Retrieved 3 December 2017.
  3. "Guy Carleton, 1st Baron Dorchester". Canadian Encyclopedia. Toronto: Historica Foundation. Retrieved February 1, 2018.
  4. "Sir Guy Carleton". Dictionary of Canadian Biography. Retrieved 21 October 2020.
  5. Frum, David (1 July 2011). "Setting Canadian History Right". National Post. Retrieved 26 October 2020.
  6. "From the Editors". The Dorchester Review. 1 (1): 2–3. Spring–Summer 2011.
  7. 1 2 Bruch, Timm (August 27, 2020). "Calls grow to remove Alberta curriculum advisor over 'racist' First Nation remarks". Calgary. Retrieved August 27, 2020.
  8. "Blanket exercise a 'reconciliation tool' that teaches indigenous history | CBC News". CBC. Archived from the original on 2019-05-02. Retrieved 2018-11-25.
  9. Justice Murray, Sinclair (2015). The Survivors Speak. Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada. ISBN   978-0-660-01985-7.
  10. 1 2 3 Sholdice, Mark (May 5, 2013). "The History Wars in Canada". Toronto Review of Books. Retrieved May 8, 2020.
  11. 1 2 Granatstein, Jack (1998). Who Killed Canadian History?. HarperCollins Publishers. p. 156. ISBN   0002557592.
  12. Champion, C.P. (2010). The Strange Demise of British Canada: The Liberals and Canadian Nationalism, 1964-1968. McGill-Queen's University Press. p. 347. ISBN   978-0-7735-3691-3.
  13. Frum, David (1 July 2011). "Setting Canadian History Right". National Post. Retrieved 26 October 2020.
  14. 1 2 "The Dorchester Review — the little magazine that can". National Post . May 24, 2016. Retrieved December 3, 2017.
  15. White, Jerry (June 2013). "Political Inheritance". Literary Review of Canada . Retrieved 17 December 2017.
  16. Duchesne, Ricardo (July 26, 2018). "Self-Deception Is Intrinsic To Conservative Support For Diversity". Council of European Canadians. Retrieved December 5, 2019.
  17. Reeve, Phyllis. "Shikataganai -- Never Again". The Dorchester Review. Retrieved 28 August 2020.
  18. Hamilton, Graeme (July 10, 2017). "Former Canadian flag, the Red Ensign, gets new, darker life as far-right symbol". National Post.
  19. "In Kamloops, Not One Body Has Been Found". The Dorchester Review. Retrieved 5 February 2022.
  20. "The mystery of Canada's indigenous mass graves | The Spectator". Spectator.co.uk. Retrieved 5 February 2022.
  21. "A Reply to Minister Marc Miller". The Dorchester Review. Retrieved 5 February 2022.
  22. "Is Indigenous knowledge infallible? Yes, says Marc Miller". The Dorchester Review. Retrieved 5 February 2022.
  23. "The same week as Williams Lake First Nation announced the discovery of 93 potential unmarked graves at the site of the St Joseph's Mission School, several articles began circulating questioning the nature and validity of these and other recovery efforts". Twitter.com. Retrieved 5 February 2022.
  24. Kirkup, Kristy (28 January 2022). "Crown-Indigenous Relations Minister Marc Miller concerned about 'concerted' efforts to deny experience of residential schools". Theglobeandmail.com. Retrieved 5 February 2022.