Censorship in Israel

Censorship in Israel is officially carried out by the Israeli Military Censor, a unit in the Israeli government officially tasked with carrying out preventive censorship regarding the publication of information that might affect the security of Israel. The body is headed by the Israeli Chief Censor, a military official appointed by Israel's Minister of Defense, who bestows upon the Chief Censor the authority to suppress information he deems compromising from being made public in the media, ^{[1] [2]} such as Israel's nuclear weapons program and Israel's military operations outside its borders. On average, 2240 press articles in Israel are censored by the Israeli Military Censor each year, approximately 240 of which in full, and around 2000 partially. ^[3]

Articles concerning potentially controversial topics must be submitted to the Israeli Military Censor in advance; failing to do so may cause the reporter to lose his right to work as a journalist in Israel ^[4] and, in the case of foreign reporters, to be barred from the country. ^{[5] [6] [7]}

Censorship of press

Reporters Without Borders report on Israel states that "Under Israel’s military censorship, reporting on a variety of security issues requires prior approval by the authorities. In addition to the possibility of civil defamation suits, journalists can also be charged with criminal defamation and "insulting a public official". There is a freedom of information law but it is sometimes hard to implement. The confidentiality of sources is not protected by statutory law". ^[8]

Every journalist working within Israel is required to be accredited by the Israeli Government Press Office. The office is allowed to deny applications based on political or security considerations. ^[9]

Following the 2017 Qatar diplomatic crisis, Israel took steps to ban Qatar-based Al Jazeera by closing its Jerusalem office, revoking press cards, and asking cable and satellite broadcasters not to broadcast Al Jazeera. Defence minister Avigdor Lieberman had described some of Al Jazeera reports as "Nazi Germany–style" propaganda. It was not clear if the measures covered Al Jazeera English, considered less strident. ^[10]

As of 2020, Israel ranks 88th in the World Press Freedom Index. ^[11]

in 2024, Israel seized Associated Press equipment taking down their live shot in northern Gaza citing "new media law". ^[12]

In 2024, Israel raided and shut down the Al Jazeera Media Network bureau in Ramallah. This follows Israel’s previous shutdown of the Al Jazeera office in East Jerusalem which has been closed since May 2024. ^[13]

Censorship of Palestinian press

Before the Oslo Accords, Israeli police and government controlled the Palestinian territories, and with this, Israel censored the books and information Palestinians can read and output. By 1991, some 10,000 books had been banned, fax machines had been banned, and a number of phone lines had been cut. In addition, publications of anything with content considered "political significance" in the West Bank, Palestinian territory, had been prohibited, and Arab publications had been be "completely stopped"^{[ dubious – discuss ]}. ^{[14] [ better source needed ]}

Reporters Without Borders have raised serious concern regarding the treatment of journalists in Israel, particularly Palestinian journalists. Their current section on Israel states: "[…] journalists are exposed to open hostility from members of the government. Smear campaigns have been waged against media outlets and journalists by politicians with the help of their party and supporters, exposing the targets to harassment and anonymous messages and forcing them seek personal protection. […] The Israel Defence Forces often violate the rights of Palestinian journalists, especially when they are covering demonstrations or clashes in the West Bank or Gaza Strip" ^[11]

In their section on Palestine, they write that "the Israeli forces have continued to subject Palestinian journalists to arrest, interrogation, and administrative detention, often without any clear grounds. In recent years, the Israeli authorities have also closed several Palestinian media outlets for allegedly inciting violence." ^[15]

On 7 December 2021, Reporters Without Borders and the Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor called for an immediate end to the Israeli travel bans that prevent dozens of Palestinian journalists from leaving the West Bank and Gaza Strip. At that time, RSF was aware of at least 21 Palestinian journalists who were banned from travelling abroad. In many cases, the travel bans have remained in place for years. ^[16]

On 18 August 2022, Israeli forces issued military orders imposing the closure of seven prominent Palestinian human rights groups' offices after accusing them of operating as fronts for terrorist organizations. ^[17] The UN and other international organizations condemned Israel’s escalating attacks against Palestinian civil society. ^[18]

The killing of journalists

See also: Killing of journalists in the Israel–Hamas war and List of journalists killed in the Israel–Hamas war

In 2019, Christophe Deloire, director-general of Reporters Without Borders, accused Israel of war crimes after two journalists were shot and killed by the Israeli Defense Forces in Gaza while covering a protest. ^{[19] [20]} In an interview with the Jerusalem Post, Deloire said that "when Israel shot those journalists, it was intentional… The journalists could be clearly identified as journalists, with cameras and jackets and it could not be just by chance". ^[19]

A commission of inquiry mandated by the United Nations Human Rights Council came to the conclusion that the shooting with live ammunition by the Israeli Defense Forces, which ultimately resulted in 183 casualties, was a "serious human rights and humanitarian law violations" which "may constitute war crimes or crimes against humanity". The Commission found "reasonable grounds" to believe that Israeli snipers shot at journalists, while knowing they were clearly recognizable as such. ^[21]

According to the Committee to Protect Journalists, 18 Palestinian journalists were killed in Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories between 2001–2021. ^[22]

In 2021, Israel bombed and completely destroyed the building with the headquarters of the Associated Press and Al Jazeera in the Gaza Strip. ^[23]

In 2022, Palestinian-American journalist Shireen Abu Akleh was killed with a shot to her head while covering an operation of the Israel Defense Forces in the Palestinian city of Jenin. Upon doing its own investigation, American news channel CNN concluded that her death was the result of a targeted Israeli killing. ^[24] On 5 September, the IDF admitted a "high possibility" that the journalist was "accidentally hit" by army fire, but said that, despite US requests to do so, it would not undertake a criminal investigation into her death. ^[25]

Military censorship

The Israeli Military Censor has the power to prevent publication of certain news items. The censorship rules largely concern military issues such as not reporting if a missile hit or missed its target, troop movements, etc. but it is also empowered to control information about the oil industry and water supply. ^[9] Journalists who bypass the military censor or publish items that were censored may be subject to criminal prosecution and jail time; the censor also has the authority to close newspapers. However, these extreme measures have been rarely used. ^[26] One notable instance where a newspaper was closed temporarily was in the case of the Kav 300 affair where it was eventually discovered that the censor was used by the Shin Bet to cover up internal wrongdoings in the agency and led to one of the biggest public scandals in Israel during the 1980s. Following the incident the two main papers, HaAretz and Yediot Ahronot stopped participating in the Editors' Committee.

In 1996 a new agreement was reached and the Editors' Committee resumed operation. The new agreement allowed military censorship only of articles clearly harmful to national security and allowed the supreme court to override military decisions.

According to information provided by the military censor in response to a Freedom of Information request, in 2017 the censor banned the publication of 271 articles outright, and fully or partially redacted 21% of the articles submitted to it. ^[27]

In 2018, the censor prohibited the publication of 363 news articles, and partially or fully redacted 2,712 news items submitted to it for prior review. ^[28] This amounts to more than one news piece being censored and seven news items being redacted per day, on average.

One very commonly used way for Israeli media to circumvent censorship rules is to leak items to foreign news sources, which by virtue of being located outside of Israel are not subject to Israeli censorship. Once published, the Israeli media can simply quote the story. ^{[29] [30]}

Israeli laws outlaws hate speech and "expressing support for illegal or terrorist organizations". ^[9] Section 173 of the legal code makes it a crime to publish any "publication that is liable to crudely offend the religious faith or sentiment of others." ^[31]

In addition to media censorship, Israeli cinemas are subject to regulation regarding the exhibition of pornography and television stations face restrictions on early broadcasting of programs that are unsuitable for children.

Gag orders

This section is an excerpt from Gag order § Israel.[ edit ]

In late 2009, Israel issued a gag order against the Israeli media reporting on facts surrounding the Anat Kamm–Uri Blau affair. The gag order was ultimately subject to widespread criticism and publicity as the details of the case were reported overseas. The scandal centered around leaked documents from the Israeli Defense Force which suggested the military had engaged in extrajudicial killings. ^[32]

A gag order concerning the Prisoner X affair prevented Israeli coverage of the topic for more than two years. After numerous foreign media outlets revealed the prisoner's identity and other key facts in February 2013, a court partially lifted the gag order, allowing Israeli media to quote foreign press reports but offer no original reporting. ^[33]

On 13 November 2013 a gag order concerning a famous Israeli singer suspected of sex with girls below the age of consent was issued. While the traditional media did not advertise the name of the singer, social media platforms users like Facebook published the singer name and incriminating photos. On 20 November Eyal Golan released a press statement announcing he was the suspected singer. ^[34]

In 2014, a blanket gag order regarding the detainment of Avera Mengitsu was put into place. It lasted 10 months, until July 9, 2015. Discussions took place in social media forums and some reports were published on foreign websites. ^[35] Some clues about the affair were leaked to different Arabic media outlets, from which the story made its way to international media and was published to Tikun Olam by blogger Richard Silverstein. ^[36] The gag order was lifted following a request from Haaretz . ^[35] The Associated Press speculated that a statement made by Khaled Mashaal the previous day, in which he spoke of an Israeli request through a European intermediary for the release of "two soldiers and two bodies", may have "forced Israel's hand". ^[37]

In August 2017, Israeli court issued a month-old gag order on a state witness deal regarding the ongoing criminal investigations of the Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu.

Al Jazeera law

On 1 April 2024, the Knesset passed the "Al Jazeera law", which gives the Israeli government the power to close foreign news networks operating in the country and confiscate their equipment if they are deemed to be threats to national security. The law, passed in a 71 to 10 vote, was planned to be used against the Qatari news channel Al Jazeera according to Minister of Communications Shlomo Karhi. The law can be applied for an initial 45-day period but can be renewed. ^[38]

On 21 April 2024, the Communications Ministry shut down and seized the broadcasting equipment of an Associated Press livestream overlooking Northern Gaza, claiming that the wire service was providing information on the live stream to Al Jazeera, one of its clients, in violation of the law. The AP had refused an earlier verbal order the previous week to shut down the feed. According to the AP, it was in compliance with Israel's censorship rules prohibiting the coverage of details that could endanger Israeli lives such as troop movements and characterized the government's actions as "abusive". Later the same day, Karhi ordered the return of the equipment to the AP. ^{[39] [40]}

Notable incidents

• In 1960 two science fiction stories were published that circumvented censorship. The first was about Rudolf Teichmann and told the story of Eichmann's kidnapping. Uri Avnery's HaOlam HaZeh magazine published a story about the Lavon Affair.^{[ citation needed ]}
• Mordechai Vanunu who served 18 years in prison for treason and espionage was released in 2004, but is still under restrictions on speech and movement. ^[9] A BBC reporter was barred from the country after publishing an interview with him without handing it over to the censors first. ^[5]
• Israel has banned the use of the word Nakba in Israeli Arab schools and textbooks. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu justified the ban by saying that the term was "propaganda against Israel". ^[41]
• The death of Ben Zygier in 2010, an Australian-Israeli citizen who was allegedly recruited by Mossad, was censored until Australian news media broke the story in early 2013.^{[ citation needed ]}
• Early in 2016, the Military Censor wrote to at least 30 Israeli bloggers and Facebook page owners, demanding that any postings with military or security-related content be submitted for review before publication. ^[42] The request has the force of law. ^[42]
• In September 2024, the Israeli military besieged and forcibly shut down the offices of Al Jazeera Arabic in Ramallah, despite the city being designated Area A under the Oslo Accords.^{[ citation needed ]}

Banned films

Israel banned all films produced in Germany from 1956 until 1967. ^[43]

• 1957: The Girl in the Kremlin was banned because it may have harmed Israel's diplomatic relations with Moscow. ^[44]
• 1957: China Gate was banned in Israel for indulging in excessive cruelty. The Israeli film censorship board indicated the film depicted Chinese and Russian soldiers as "monsters". ^[45]
• 1965: Goldfinger played for six weeks before the Nazi past of Gert Fröbe, who played the title villain, was disclosed, despite him leaving the party in 1937. ^[46] However the ban was lifted once a Jewish family publicly thanked him for hiding two German Jews from the Gestapo during World War II.
• 1973: Hitler: The Last Ten Days was banned in a unanimous decision by the censorship board that Alec Guinness's Hitler was represented in too human a light. ^[47]
• 1988: Martin Scorsese's The Last Temptation of Christ was banned on the grounds that it could hurt the feelings of Christian believers in the Holy Land. ^[48] The Supreme Court of Israel later overturned the decision. ^[49]
• 2002: Jenin, Jenin was banned by the Israeli Film Ratings Board on the premise that it was libelous and might offend the public. The Supreme Court of Israel later overturned the decision. ^[50]

See also

• Freedom of information
• Freedom of speech in Israel
• Media of Israel
• Night letter
• Nakba denial

References

1. Aluf Benn (July–August 2001). "Israel: Censoring the past". Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, College of Behavioral and Social Sciences. University of Maryland. Archived from the original on June 19, 2009. Retrieved 31 December 2009.
2. P.R. Kumaraswamy (September 1998). "India and Israel: Evolving Strategic Partnership". Mideast Security and Policy Studies. Begin-Sadat Center for Strategic Studies. Retrieved 31 December 2009.
3. "נתונים חדשים חושפים טפח מאחורי הקלעים של יחסי הצנזורה הצבאית והעיתונות הישראלית". העין השביעית (in Hebrew). 16 June 2021. Retrieved 2022-11-11.
4. Times, Special to the New York (June 29, 1982). "Censorship by Israel: How It's Carried Out". The New York Times– via NYTimes.com.
5. "BBC says sorry to Israel". the Guardian. March 12, 2005.
6. Matar, Haggai (2020-03-09). "IDF censor redacted two thousand news items in 2019". +972 Magazine. Retrieved 2021-03-04.
7. "IDF Military Censor banned nearly 300 articles last year". The Jerusalem Post. 12 July 2018. Retrieved 2021-03-04.
8. "Israel | RSF". rsf.org. Retrieved 2022-11-11.
9. "Israel and the occupied territories – 2006". Country Reports on Human Rights Practices . US Department of State Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor. March 6, 2007. Retrieved November 5, 2014.
10. Chulov, Martin (6 August 2017). "Israeli government moves to impose ban on al-Jazeera news network". The Guardian. Retrieved 7 August 2017.
11. "Israel : Toxic environment | Reporters without borders". RSF. Retrieved 2021-03-04.
12. "Israeli officials seize AP equipment and take down live shot of northern Gaza, citing new media law". AP News. 2024-05-21. Retrieved 2024-05-21.
13. "Israeli soldiers raid, order closure of Al Jazeera office in Ramallah". Al Jazeera. 2024-09-22. Retrieved 2024-09-22.
14. D'Souza, Frances (1991). Information Freedom and Censorship: World Report 1991 . Chicago, Illinois: American Library Association. ISBN   0-8389-2156-6.
15. "Palestine : Harassed journalists | Reporters without borders". RSF. Retrieved 2021-03-04.
16. "RSF and Euro-Med condemn Israeli travel bans on Palestinian journalists". Euro-Med Monitor. Retrieved 7 December 2021.
17. "Israel shuts down 7 offices of orgs. in W. Bank designated 'terrorist'". The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com. 18 August 2022. Retrieved 2023-08-22.
18. "UN experts condemn Israeli suppression of Palestinian human rights organisations". OHCHR. Retrieved 24 August 2022.
19. "Reporters Without Borders: Israel committed war crimes against press". The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com. 21 May 2019. Retrieved 2021-03-04.
20. "UN commission: Israeli snipers 'intentionally shot' Palestinian journalists in 2018, killing 2". Committee to Protect Journalists. 2019-02-28. Retrieved 2021-03-04.
21. "OHCHR | No Justification for Israel to Shoot Protesters with Live Ammunition". www.ohchr.org. Retrieved 2021-03-04.
22. "Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territory Archives". Committee to Protect Journalists. Retrieved 2021-03-04.
23. Al Jazeera Staff. "'Give us 10 minutes': How Israel bombed a Gaza media tower". www.aljazeera.com. Retrieved 2022-11-11.
24. "Initial IDF probe of reporter's death proposes 2 scenarios for who fired fatal shot". Times of Israel.
25. Hadas Gold and Abeer Salman (September 5, 2022). "Israeli military admits Shireen Abu Akleh likely killed by Israeli fire, but won't charge soldiers". CNN.
26. "Editor & Publisher: AP Reveals Israeli Censorship, Says It Will Abide By Rules". Archived from the original on July 3, 2007.
27. Alyssa Fisher (July 4, 2018). "Israel Censored a News Story every 4 Hours Last Year". The Forward.
28. Matar, Haggai (2019-03-15). "A spike in censorship: Israel censored on average one news piece a day in 2018". +972 Magazine. Retrieved 2021-03-04.
29. Aluf Benn (July–August 2001). "Israel: Censoring the past". Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, College of Behavioral and Social Sciences. University of Maryland. Archived from the original on 19 June 2009. Retrieved 31 December 2009.
30. P.R. Kumaraswamy (September 1998). "India and Israel: Evolving Strategic Partnership". Mideast Security and Policy Studies. Begin-Sadat Center for Strategic Studies. Retrieved 31 December 2009.
31. "Make fun of God, but leave his believers alone", Haaretz , 27 August 2003
32. "Debate in Israel on Gag Order in Security Leak Case". The New York Times . 6 April 2010. Retrieved 8 September 2011.
33. Ravid, Barak (14 February 2013). "Ben Zygier affair: Israel partially lifts gag order on case of dual citizen's prison suicide". Haaretz. Retrieved 14 February 2013.
34. Hartman, Ben (20 November 2013). "Eyal Golan revealed to be mystery singer suspected of sex with underage girls". The Jerusalem Post. Jerusalem. Archived from the original on 5 September 2015. Retrieved 18 September 2015.
35. "Two Israelis missing after disappearing into Gaza, one being held by Hamas". Haaretz . July 9, 2015.
36. "Two Israelis are held in Gaza". Maariv . July 9, 2015.
37. "Amid Detente With Hamas, Israel Says 2 Citizens Held in Gaza". The New York Times . Associated Press. July 9, 2015. Archived from the original on July 12, 2015. Retrieved April 30, 2017.
38. Sokol, Sam; Sharon, Jeremy (1 April 2024). "Law allowing government to temporarily shut down Al Jazeera in Israel passed by Knesset". The Times of Israel.
39. Rasgon, Adam (21 May 2024). "Israel Seizes Camera From A.P., Citing Use of Its Images by Al Jazeera". The New York Times . ISSN   0362-4331 . Retrieved 21 May 2024.
40. "Israeli communications minister orders return of seized camera equipment to AP". AP News . 21 May 2024. Retrieved 21 May 2024.
41. "Israel bans "catastrophe" term from Arab schools". Reuters. 2009-07-22.
42. Gili Cohen (February 4, 2016). "Israel's Military Censor Takes on Dozens of Bloggers, Facebook Pages". Haaretz.
43. Israel lifts total ban on German films. Canadian Jewish Chronicle Review. 14 April 1967.
44. Israel Bans US Film. Archived 2016-08-01 at the Wayback Machine The Milwaukee Journal. 17 August 1957.
45. Israel Bans Film Depicting Reds as 'Monsters'. The Modesto Bee. 2 October 1957.
46. Israel Bans 'Goldfinger' for Nazi Past. St. Petersburg Times. 15 December 1965.
47. Israel Bans Hitler Film. Reading Eagle. 25 July 1973.
48. Israel Bans 'Last Temptation' The Lewiston Journal. 19 October 1988.
49. "Israel Lifts 'Last Temptation' Ban". Los Angeles Times . June 15, 1989. Retrieved September 12, 2012.
50. Israel court lifts Jenin film ban, BBC News, 11 November 2003.