Craig v. Radford

Last updated
Craig et. al. v. Radford
Seal of the United States Supreme Court.svg
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided March 12, 1818
Full case nameCraig et. al. v. Radford
Citations16 U.S. 594 ( more )
3 Wheat. 594, 4 L. Ed. 467
Holding
Decree affirmed with costs
Court membership
Chief Justice
John Marshall
Associate Justices
Bushrod Washington  · William Johnson
H. Brockholst Livingston  · Thomas Todd
Gabriel Duvall  · Joseph Story
Case opinion
MajorityWashington, joined by unanimous

Craig et al. v. Radford, 16 U.S. (3 Wheat.) 594 (1818), is a United States Supreme Court decision delivered by Justice Bushrod Washington on March 12, 1818. The dispute arose from a suit in chancery to establish a clear title to land in Kentucky located on the south bank of the Ohio River, 30 miles downriver from the mouth of the Scioto River. A military land warrant for 1,000 acres had been issued by the Colony of Virginia on January 24, 1774, and duly patented by a French and Indian War veteran, William Sutherland. Subsequently, treasury warrants were purchased from the Commonwealth of Virginia in 1780 by Craig et al. which they duly patented over parts of the same property. [1] A suit in the United States Circuit Court for the District of Kentucky awarded unconditional title to the original Sutherland patent. [2] An appeal was argued before the Supreme Court during the 1817 term but the verdict upheld the lower court's decision. Non-citizen property rights established by this case have been cited and argued ever since. [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]

Contents

Early owners of the property included William Clark, Admiral William Radford and General Stephen W. Kearny. [11]

Origin of the Dispute

The Treaty of Paris in 1763 concluded the French and Indian War and distributed the lands of New France between Britain and Spain. King George then issued a royal proclamation. In it, he instructed his Royal Governors to issue military land warrants to war veterans, awarding acreage based upon military rank. Also, in recognition that the Cherokee from the south and the many Indian tribes north of the Ohio River hunted but did not reside in the area they called Kentucky, the king declared an Indian Reserve west of the Appalachian Divide by invalidating any land claims and ordering all settlers to vacate the reserve area.

The allure of uninhabited land, especially the Bluegrass Region, contributed to the colonist's disregard for the Indian Reserve. Settlers already in-place believed they had established "cabin rights". Newcomers, by building a cabin and farming the land, felt qualified under the homestead principle. As a result, the 1763 boundary line continually crept westward as British agents negotiated new treaties, such as the Treaty of Fort Stanwix, Treaty of Hard Labour and Treaty of Lochaber. Individuals also purchased land directly from tribes, such as for the Transylvania Colony. These transactions involved either the Cherokee or tribes from Pennsylvania, but they mostly ignored the western tribes north of the Ohio River, such as the Shawnee and Miami. The growing influx of settlers gave rise to deadly conflicts due to this oversight.

In 1772, the last Royal Governor for the Colony of Virginia, John Murray, 4th Earl of Dunmore (also known as Lord Dunmore) established Fincastle County, extending to the Mississippi River, the border with Spanish Louisiana. [12] : 3  He named William Preston as principal surveyor for the county. In 1773, Lord Dunmore issued the overdue military land warrants to French and Indian War veterans and their scope encompassed land south of the Ohio River, between the Scioto River and the Falls of the Ohio. In April 1774, teams departed to survey thousands of acres over the next months. On May 4, 1774, surveyor Hancock Taylor (along with chainmen Abraham Hemptonstrall, James Strother and Willis Lee) conducted a 1,000 acre survey for William Sutherland, who had served as an Ensign for the 95th Regiment of Foot. On July 27, 1774, close to present-day Carrollton, Indians attacked the survey party, killing Strother and wounding Taylor. During the party's retreat home, Taylor died near Richmond. [13] Hemptonstrall and Lee delivered Taylor's field notes to Preston's residence Smithfield. Preston recorded all of Taylor's surveys. [1]

The Virginia legislature abolished Fincastle County on December 31, 1774, due to its affiliation with loyalist Lord Dunmore. The Sutherland property then came under the jurisdiction of Kentucky County, Virginia. Upon the commencement of the American Revolutionary War, loyalist Sutherland permanently left Virginia for Orkney but still continued ownership of his Kentucky land.

John Craig, Lewis Craig and Simon Kenton purchased treasury warrants in 1780 and redeemed them for acreage which overlaid the Sutherland tract. Their claims were surveyed during 1785 and land patents were issued on or prior to May 26, 1788. The Commonwealth of Virginia did not patent the 1,000 acres to Sutherland until August 5, 1788. [1] : 595–96  Kentucky County was abolished on June 30, 1780, when it was divided into Fayette, Jefferson, and Lincoln Virginia counties. These three counties were retained when the Commonwealth of Kentucky was created in 1792. The disputed property came under jurisdiction of Fayette County, Kentucky.

Beginning August 19, 1796, William Sutherland began periodically advertising sale of his land, then under Mason County jurisdiction, through the Kentucky Court of Appeals. On February 13, 1799, Speculator William Radford (Admiral William Radford was his grandson) purchased Sutherland's 1,000 acre deed for $3,000. Radford, finding individuals who refused to relinquish their claims to his land, began a suit December 2, 1800 in chancery in United States District Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky. Following William Radford's death in 1803, his heir John Radford continued the suit. The court records announcing the final verdict are apparently lost; the last entry was dated November 24, 1806 while the case was still ongoing. In 1808, John, with his wife Harriet and infant son William, relocated from Fincastle, Virginia to the disputed property finally situated in Lewis County, Kentucky.

Objections

Most of the background was admitted as fact by both parties in the suit. Craig et al. disputed the following:

  1. Deputy surveyor Taylor did not hold the land warrant and so had no authority to execute his survey. [1] : 596 
  2. There was no physical proof of Taylor's survey and, even if so, Hemptonstrall testified the survey was begun but not completed. [1] : 596 
  3. Incomplete lines run by a deputy should not be sufficient for the principal surveyor to certify the plat and validate the grant. [1] : 596–97 
  4. Sutherland, as a Tory, was an enemy alien and forfeited his colonial land warrant when Virginia joined the United States. [1] : 599 

Resolution

The Supreme Court overruled all four objections. There was no dissenting opinion identified in the resolution.

  1. The principal surveyor's certificate referencing the land warrant is sufficient authority for the survey. [14] : 689 
  2. Incompetent or incomplete surveys do not invalidate the claim to the land. [15] : 40 
  3. A deputy has the whole power of the principal surveyor and Taylor's survey was accepted by the principal as completed. [16] : 215 
  4. No act of Virginia legislation had divested property from enemy alien owners before 1794 and the Jay Treaty ninth article protected defeasible estate from then on. [14] : 718 

Basis

Traditional English law allowed aliens to purchase land but the crown retained interest to that land. So, even though an alien could exercise dominion over his property as a tenant, he could not bequeath the land to heirs and had to surrender the title upon demand from the crown. [17] Upon declaration of war, enemy aliens automatically forfeited their title to the land. That presumption from long standing law became a pleading for this case. [18]

However, the Supreme Court held that land owned by British subjects, made aliens due to the Revolutionary War, was protected from confiscation per the Treaty of Paris. [19] To reclaim land possessed by British subjects, each state had to pass applicable legislation and then complete escheat proceedings for individual cases. [20] Virginia did not enact such law. As of 1794, under the protection afforded by the Jay Treaty, British subject Sutherland retained title to his 1,000 acres in question. [21]

John Radford died, gored by a boar in a hunting accident in 1817, before the Supreme Court decision was delivered the following year. [22] : 8–9  Widow Harriet Kennerly Radford moved with her three children to Saint Louis, Missouri to live near her two brothers, James and George Kennerly, and ailing first cousin, Julia Hancock Clark. Julia's husband was William Clark. Julia passed in 1820 and Harriet became Clark's second wife in 1821. [23] : 38 

William Preston wrote a letter May 27, 1774 to George Washington describing the escalated attacks his surveyors and residents in Kentucky were facing. These deadly attacks were a prelude to Lord Dunmore's War and then the subsequent Illinois Campaign and Northwest Indian War. [24]

There is argument that this case, by extending rights to non-citizen individuals per federal treaties, exceeded United States Constitutional authority. New York lawyer Franklin Pierce contended in 1908 that land titles were domestic law and state statutes were wrongly overridden, specifying this case as an example. [25] In 1984, Judge Robert Bork wrote a concurring opinion for the Tel-Oren v. Libyan Arab Republican case in the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit which argued the courts cannot apply treaty rights without explicit private right of action specified in the treaty. [26]

Related Research Articles

Transylvania Colony Short-lived extra-legal colony in frontier Kentucky

The Transylvania Colony, also referred to as the Transylvania Purchase, was a short-lived, extra-legal colony founded in early 1775 by North Carolina land speculator Richard Henderson, who formed and controlled the Transylvania Company. Henderson and his investors had reached an agreement to purchase a vast tract of Cherokee lands west of the southern and central Appalachian Mountains through the acceptance of the Treaty of Sycamore Shoals with most leading Cherokee chieftains then controlling these lands. In exchange for the land the tribes received goods worth, according to the estimates of some scholars, about 10,000 British pounds. To further complicate matters, this early American frontier land was also claimed by both the Virginia Colony and Province of North Carolina.

Virginia Military District

The Virginia Military District was an approximately 4.2 million acre (17,000 km²) area of land in what is now the state of Ohio that was reserved by Virginia to use as payment in lieu of cash for its veterans of the American Revolutionary War.

Lord Dunmores War Conflict between the Colony of Virginia and the Shawnee and Mingo American Indian nations

Lord Dunmore's War—or Dunmore's War—was a 1774 conflict between the Colony of Virginia and the Shawnee and Mingo American Indian nations.

Illinois-Wabash Company American colonial land company

The Illinois-Wabash Company, formally known as the United Illinois and Wabash Land Company, was a company formed in 1779 from the merger of the Illinois Company and the Wabash Company. The two companies had been established in order to purchase land from Native Americans in the Illinois Country, a region of North America acquired by Great Britain in 1763. The Illinois Company purchased two large tracts of land in 1773; the Wabash Company purchased two additional tracts in 1775.

William Radford

William Radford was a rear admiral of the United States Navy who served during the Mexican–American War and the American Civil War, in which he remained loyal to the Union, despite his Virginia birth. Radford commanded the Ironclad Division in the attacks on Fort Fisher to assert Union control of Cape Fear.

Ebenezer Zane

Ebenezer Zane was an American pioneer, soldier, politician, road builder and land speculator. Born in the Colony of Virginia, Zane established a settlement near Fort Henry which became Wheeling, on the Ohio River. He also blazed an early road through the Ohio Country to Limestone known as Zane's Trace.

Treaty of Fort Stanwix (1768) Treaty between Great Britain and the Iroquois people

The Treaty of Fort Stanwix was a treaty signed between representatives from the Iroquois and Great Britain in 1768 at Fort Stanwix. It was negotiated between Sir William Johnson, his deputy George Croghan, and representatives of the Iroquois.

Stephen Trigg was an American pioneer and soldier from Virginia. He was killed ten months after the surrender of Cornwallis at Yorktown in one of the last battles of the American Revolution while leading the Lincoln County militia at the Battle of Blue Licks, Kentucky.

William Christian was a military officer, planter and politician from the western part of the Colony of Virginia. He represented Fincastle County in the House of Burgesses and as relations with Britain soured, signed the Fincastle Resolutions. He later represented western Virginia in the Virginia Senate and founded Fort William, as well as helped negotiate the Treaty of Long Island of the Holston, which made peace between the Overmountain Men and Cherokees in 1777. He was killed in 1786 at the outset of the Northwest Indian War, leading an expedition against Native Americans near what is now Jeffersonville, Indiana.

Fincastle County, Virginia, was created by act of the Virginia General Assembly April 8, 1772 from Botetourt County. As colonial government considered Virginia's western extent to be the Mississippi River, that became Fincastle's western limit. Its eastern boundary was essentially the New River, thus dividing Botetourt County from north to south. The new county encompassed all of present day Kentucky, plus southwestern West Virginia and a slice of Virginia's western "tail". Although no county seat was designated by the act creating the county, the colonial governor ordered it to be placed at the "Lead Mines" of present day Wythe County; the community of Austinville later developed there.

The Fincastle Resolutions was a statement reportedly adopted on January 20, 1775, by fifteen elected representatives of Fincastle County, Virginia. Part of the political movement that became the American Revolution, the resolutions were addressed to Virginia's delegation at the First Continental Congress, and expressed support for Congress' resistance to the Intolerable Acts, issued in 1774 by the British Parliament.

John Floyd (pioneer)

James John Floyd (1750–1783) was an early settler of St. Matthews, Kentucky and helped lay out Louisville. In Kentucky he served as a Colonel of the Kentucky Militia in which he participated in raids with George Rogers Clark and later became one of the first judges of Kentucky.

Edward Worthington (1750-1754–1804) was an 18th-early 19th century American frontiersman, longhunter, surveyor, soldier, pioneer, and state militia officer who explored and later helped settle the Kentucky frontier. A veteran of the American Revolution and the Indian Wars, he also served as a paymaster under George Rogers Clark during the Illinois campaign. His grandson, William H. Worthington, was an officer with the 5th Iowa Volunteer Infantry Regiment during the American Civil War. Historian and author, Kathleen L. Lodwick is a direct descendant of Edward Worthington.

Wilson v. Mason, 5 U.S. 45 (1801), was a United States Supreme Court case. It resolved a dispute between George Wilson and Founding Father George Mason over 8,400 acres (34 km2) of land along the Green River in present-day Kentucky.

Harry Innes American judge

Harry Innes was a Virginia lawyer and patriot during the American Revolutionary War who became a local judge and prosecutor as well as helped establish the state of Kentucky, before he accepted appointment as United States District Judge of the United States District Court for the District of Kentucky and served until his death.

Thomas Todd United States federal judge (1765–1826)

Thomas Todd was an associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States from 1807 to 1826. Raised in the Colony of Virginia, he studied law and later participated in the founding of Kentucky, where he served as a clerk, judge, and justice. He was married twice and had a total of eight children. Todd joined the U.S. Supreme Court in 1807 and his handful of legal opinions there mostly concerned land claims.

William Preston (Virginia soldier) One of the signers of the Fincastle Resolutions

Colonel William Preston played a crucial role in surveying and developing the western colonies, exerted great influence in the colonial affairs of his time, enslaved many people on his plantation, and founded a dynasty whose progeny would supply leaders of the South for nearly a century. He served in the Virginia House of Burgesses and was a colonel in the militia during the American Revolutionary War. He was one of the fifteen signatories of the Fincastle Resolutions.

Angus McDonald (Virginia militiaman) Scottish American Military officer, frontiersman, sheriff, landowner

Angus McDonald was a prominent Scottish American military officer, frontiersman, sheriff and landowner in Virginia.

William Ward was the founder of Urbana, Ohio, and one of the original settlers in Kentucky's Mason County and Ohio's Mad River Valley.

David Glenn (pioneer)

David Glenn was of Irish descent and was born in 1753, likely in Pennsylvania but possibly in Virginia. He was one of the early settlers of Kentucky having accompanied James Harrod in founding Harrodstown in 1774, along with his older brother, Thomas. Today, Harrodsburg is considered the oldest permanent white settlement in Kentucky, being it was settled almost a full year before Boonesborough.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Wheaton, Henry (1818). Reports of Cases Argued and Adjudged in the Supreme Court of the United States, Vol. III. New York, New York: R. Donaldson. p. 595.
  2. ↑ Cook, Michael L.; Cook, Bettie Cummings. Kentucky Federal Court Records: District and 6th Circuit Order Books 1789-1804. Evansville, Indiana: Cook Publications. p. 168.
  3. ↑ Story, William W. (1856). A Treatise on the Law of Contracts, Vol. 1 (4th ed.). Boston, Massachusetts: Little, Brown and Company. pp. 92–93, 215–217.
  4. ↑ Pierce, Franklin (January 1908). Federal Usurpation (1st ed.). New York, New York: D. Appleton and Company. p. 255. Retrieved 14 April 2019.
  5. ↑ Hayden, Ralston (1917). "The States' Rights Doctrine and the Treaty-Making Power". The American Historical Review. 22 (3): 569–570. doi:10.2307/1842650. hdl: 2027/mdp.39015071601697 . ISSN   0002-8762. JSTOR   1842650.
  6. ↑ "Recent Cases: Alien Enemy". University of Pennsylvania Law Review and American Law Register. 69 (2): 176–191. January 1921. JSTOR   3314575.
  7. ↑ Buell, Raymond Leslie (1923). "Some Legal Aspects of the Japanese Question". The American Journal of International Law. 17 (1): 39–40. doi:10.2307/2187748. hdl: 2027/hvd.32044115649519 . JSTOR   2187748.
  8. ↑ "Conflict between Local and National Interests in Alien Landholding Restrictions". The University of Chicago Law Review. 16 (2): 315–323. 1949. doi:10.2307/1597954. ISSN   0041-9494. JSTOR   1597954.
  9. ↑ Kettner, James H. (1974). "The Development of American Citizenship in the Revolutionary Era: The Idea of Volitional Allegiance". The American Journal of Legal History. 18 (3): 237–238. doi:10.2307/845086. JSTOR   845086.
  10. ↑ Graeff, Kay; Sloss, David (2 March 2006). "Treaties in U.S. Courts: Judge Bork's Anti-Originalist Revolution". Bepress Legal Series (Working Paper 1031): 7–8, 24. Retrieved 14 April 2019.
  11. ↑ Lewis County Deeds Volume G. Lewis County Clerk Legal Records Department. pp. 101–104.
  12. ↑ Hammon, Neal O. (2013). John Floyd: The Life and Letters of a Frontier Surveyor. Louisville, Kentucky: Butler Books. ISBN   978-1-935497-69-1.
  13. ↑ Hammon, Neal O. "Early Kentucky Land Records, 1773-1780". Genealogy Trails History Group. Genealogy Trails. Retrieved 10 March 2019.
  14. 1 2 Coxe, Richard S. (1829). Digest of the Decisions in the Supreme Court, Circuit Courts and District Courts of the United States. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania: Philip H. Nicklin, Law Bookseller.
  15. ↑ Clark, Frank Emerson (1922). A Treatise on the Law of Surveying and Boundaries. Indianapolis, Indiana: The Bobbs-Merrill Company.
  16. ↑ Story, William W. (1856). A Treatise on the Law of Contracts, Vol. 1 (Fourth ed.). Boston, Massachusetts: Little, Brown and Company.
  17. ↑ "Alien Enemy – Acquisition of Property – Trading with the Enemy Act". University of Pennsylvania Law Review and American Law Register. 69 (2): 176. January 1921.
  18. ↑ Peters, Richard, ed. (1833). Condensed Reports of Cases in The Supreme Court of the United States, Volume IV. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania: DeSilver, Jun. and Thomas. p. 347.
  19. ↑ "Conflict Between Local and National Interests in Alien Landholding Restrictions". University of Chicago Law Review. 16 (2): 320. Winter 1949.
  20. ↑ Kettner, James H. (July 1974). "The Development of American Citizenship in the Revolutionary Era: The Idea of Volitional Allegiance". American Journal of Legal History. 18 (3): 237–8.
  21. ↑ Abbott, Benjamin Vaughn and Austin (1867). Digest of the Reports of the United States Courts and the Acts of Congress, Vol. I. New York, New York: Diossy & Cockcroft. p. 61.
  22. ↑ de Meissner, Sophie Radford (1920). Old Naval Days. New York: Henry Holt and Company.
  23. ↑ Kennerly, William Clark as told to Elizabeth Russell (1948). Persimmon Hill: A Narrative of Old St. Louis and the Far West. Norman, Oklahoma: University of Oklahoma Press.
  24. ↑ Hamilton, Stanislaus Murray, ed. (1902). Letters To Washington And Accompanying Papers (Volume V): 1774, 1775. Boston, Massachusetts and New York, New York: Houghton, Mifflin and Company. pp. 1–3.
  25. ↑ Pierce, Franklin (1908). Federal Usurpation. New York, New York: D. Appleton and Company.
  26. ↑ Graeff, Kay and Sloss, David. "Treaties in U.S. Courts: Judge Bork's Anti-Originalist Revolution". bepress Legal Series. Berkeley Electronic Press. Retrieved 10 August 2014.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.