Desmatophoca

Last updated

Desmatophoca
Temporal range: Early Miocene–Middle Miocene
Desmatophoca oregonensis 2.jpg
Desmatophoca oregonensis
Scientific classification Red Pencil Icon.png
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Class: Mammalia
Order: Carnivora
Clade: Pinnipedia
Family: Desmatophocidae
Genus: Desmatophoca
Condon, 1906
Species
  • D. brachycephala Barnes, 1987
  • D. oregonensis Condon, 1906 (type species)

Desmatophoca is an extinct genus of early pinniped that lived during the Miocene, and is named from the Greek "phoca", meaning seal. A taxon of the family Desmatophocidae, it shares some morphological similarities with modern true seals. [1] Two species are recognized: Desmatophoca oregonensis and Desmatophoca brachycephala [2] . Little information exists regarding Desmatophoca, due to the small number of fossil samples obtained and identified.

Contents

Unlike modern pinnipeds, Desmatophoca did not survive into the Holocene. [2] There is some scientific debate as to whether any Desmatophoca species may have been present in the Oligocene, but without fossil samples obtained from this era, this is based primarily on conjecture. [1] All samples of fossil Desmatophoca were found in marine deposits in Washington and Oregon, in the USA, which could indicate a geographic range of what is now the Pacific Northwest. [3]

Description

Despite sharing morphological similarities with extant true seals, Desmatophoca differ in unique and important ways. They had significantly shorter tails, and were likely much shorter overall than modern seals. [1] Despite their small size compared with the seals of today, they had heavier, and likely more powerful jaws. [3] Because of this, it is likely they had a stronger bite force than any seal alive today, making them formidable hunters of their time. [4] Like modern seals, they were carnivorous, and their large orbits indicate a sight-based hunting strategy. [2]

Skull and dentition

Desmatophoca skulls are characterized with large orbits, indicating the carnivorous pinnipeds were likely hunters reliant on sight. [5] Through comparisons with extant pinnipeds, Desmatophoca were determined to be either grip and tear feeders (biting prey and shaking it into smaller portions to consume) or pierce feeders (biting prey and using slight suction to draw it fully into the mouth). [2]

Desmatophoca mandibles are thick, and they possess wide coronoid processes; both of which provide jaw strength associated with grip and tear feeders. [4] The thickness of the mandible is especially important, as it provides both high bite force and increased surface area for muscular attachment between the jaws, which allows for stronger mastication. [6] The extremely thick mandibles also serve as a diagnostic characteristic of this genus. [4] Despite this evidence that indicates they may have been grip and tear feeders, Desmatophoca possess long tooth rows, which is characteristic of pierce feeders. [4] But, they likely lacked the diagnostic small mastication muscles that would be present on a true pierce feeder. [4] Because they have traits that would lend themselves to either strategy, it is still heavily debated which feeding strategy Desmatophoca utilized. Many agree it is likely the seals used some combination of pierce and rip and tear feeding, or potentially a new strategy not yet observed that served as a middle ground between the two. [2]

Desmatophoca have morphologically similar skulls to other predators of fish and squid, indicating this was the prominent makeup of their diet. [2] However, it has been proposed that D. oregonensis were actually filter feeders, though their lack of diagnostic features (such as complex tooth cuspation and simple dentition). [2] Further comparisons between Desmatophoca teeth with extant seals indicates they were a generalist species. [6]

A distinct diagnostic characteristic of Desmatophoca skulls is the unusually large and widely-spaced paraoccipital process, something not seen in modern carnivores. [3] They also have a rudimentary postorbital process compared with extant seals and other Desmatophocidae [3] .

Classification

Desmatophoca is the genus within the larger clade Desmatophocidae, which also contains the genus Allodesmus [2] .Allodesmus and Desmatophoca are both monophyletic, and are closely related sister groups. [7] The two genera both have large preoccipital processes, similar cranium shapes, and short rostrums. [2] Desmatophoca is thought to be the more primitive of the two, lacking the two-rooted postcanine teeth and prenarial shelf of Allodesmus [7] .Desmatophocidae have a close sister taxon as well, Phocidae , and both are found within the broad monophyly of Phocoidea. [8] All members of Phocoidea, including Desmatophoca, share large orbits, bulbous cheektooth crowns, and expanded contact between the squamosal and the jugal. [9]

Odobenidae

Phocoidea

Desmatophoca

Allodesmus

The genus Desmatophoca consists of two known species: D. oregonensis (named for Oregon, the state it was discovered in) and D. brachycephala [8] .

Discovery

The first Desmatophoca discovered was D. oregonensis, by Professor Thomas Condon in 1906, a year before his death. [1]

It was found in the middle Miocene layer of the Astoria Formation in Newport, Oregon. [8] It was described and classified based solely off of a skull and partial jaw, and at the time, it helped shed light on the relationship between modern pinnipeds and other terrestrial carnivores. [3] The use of D. oregonensis helped solidify the theory that modern seals evolved from terrestrial carnivores, and not the other way around. [3] By comparing morphologies of D. oregonensis with extant terrestrial carnivores, it was determined that Desmatophoca shares a most recent common ancestor with bears and mustelids. [3] This fossil sample also helped throw out the theory that seals share their most recent common ancestor with dogs and other canines, which was a popular thought at the time. [3]

The second species of Desmatophoca, D. brachycephala was discovered in 1987 by Barnes, in the late Miocene layer of the Astoria Formation that jetted into southwest Washington state. [8]

Limitations

Because fossil Desmatophoca have only appeared from the same site, the Astoria Foundation in the Pacific Northwest, there is a bias in the data that has been collected. [3] Additionally, few fossil Desmatophoca have been found and successfully categorized, meaning there is still much to be discovered about this species. In fact, of 388 instances of fossil pinniped species being identified successfully, only 5% of these samples belong to Desmatophocidae, comprising 11 species. [3]

Related Research Articles

Earless seal Family of mammals

The earless seals, phocids or true seals are one of the three main groups of mammals within the seal lineage, Pinnipedia. All true seals are members of the family Phocidae. They are sometimes called crawling seals to distinguish them from the fur seals and sea lions of the family Otariidae. Seals live in the oceans of both hemispheres and, with the exception of the more tropical monk seals, are mostly confined to polar, subpolar, and temperate climates. The Baikal seal is the only species of exclusively freshwater seal.

Odobenidae Seal family which includes the walrus

Odobenidae is a family of pinnipeds. The only living species is the walrus. In the past, however, the group was much more diverse, and includes more than a dozen fossil genera.

Pinniped Infraorder of mammals

Pinnipeds, commonly known as seals, are a widely distributed and diverse clade of carnivorous, fin-footed, semiaquatic, mostly marine mammals in the clade Pinnipedia. They comprise the extant families Odobenidae, Otariidae, and Phocidae. There are 34 extant species of pinnipeds, and more than 50 extinct species have been described from fossils. While seals were historically thought to have descended from two ancestral lines, molecular evidence supports them as a monophyletic lineage. Pinnipeds belong to the order Carnivora; their closest living relatives are musteloids, having diverged about 50 million years ago.

Caniformia Suborder of mammals

Caniformia is a suborder within the order Carnivora consisting of "dog-like" carnivorans. They include dogs, bears, raccoons, and mustelids. The Pinnipedia are also assigned to this group. The center of diversification for the Caniformia is North America and northern Eurasia. Caniformia stands in contrast to the other suborder of Carnivora, the Feliformia, the center of diversification of which was in Africa and southern Asia.

<i>Enaliarctos</i> Genus of pinniped

Enaliarctos is an extinct genus of pinniped, and may represent the ancestor to all pinnipeds. Prior to the discovery of Puijila, the five species in the genus Enaliarctos represented the oldest known pinniped fossils, having been recovered from late Oligocene and early Miocene strata of California and Oregon.

Douglas Ralph Emlong was an amateur fossil collector from the Oregon Coast in the northwestern United States. His collections contributed to the discovery and description of numerous extinct marine mammal species, many of which are ancestral to extant groups. Described as an 'indefatigable' fossil collector with 'Promethian prowess in discovery of unprecedented vertebrate fossils', he contributed substantially to the field from the age of fourteen. The ancestral pinniped Enaliarctos emlongi was named in his honor by Annalisa Berta in 1991.

<i>Kolponomos</i> Extinct genus of mammals

Kolponomos is an extinct genus of carnivoran mammal that existed in the Late Arikareean North American Land Mammal Age, early Miocene epoch, about 20 million years ago. It was likely a marine mammal. The genus was erected in 1960 by Ruben A. Stirton, a paleontologist at the University of California Museum of Paleontology, Berkeley, for the species K. clallamensis, on the basis of a partial skull and jaw found on the Olympic Peninsula. At the time, Stirton questionably assigned it to Procyonidae, its systematic position remained problematic until the discovery of more fossils including a nearly complete cranium from the original locality of K. clallamensis which helped identify it as part of the group from which pinnipeds evolved.

<i>Aetiocetus</i> Extinct genus of mammals

Aetiocetus is a genus of extinct basal mysticete, or baleen whale that lived 33.9 to 23.03 million years ago, in the Oligocene in the North Pacific ocean, around Japan, Mexico, and Oregon, U.S. It was first described by Douglas Emlong in 1966 and currently contains known four species, A. cotylalveus, A. polydentatus, A. tomitai, and A. weltoni. These whales are remarkable for their retention of teeth and presence of nutrient foramina, indicating that they possessed baleen. Thus, Aetiocetus represents the transition from teeth to baleen in Oligocene mysticetes. Baleen is a highly derived character, or synapomorphy, of mysticetes, and is a keratinous structure that grows from the palate, or roof of the mouth, of the whale. The presence of baleen is inferred from the fossil record in the skull of Aetiocetus. Aetiocetus is known from both sides of the Pacific Ocean: it was first documented in Oregon, United States, but it is also known from Japan and Mexico. The genus is currently constrained to the Northern hemisphere and has little value in biostratigraphic studies of the Oligocene due to its limited occurrences across the Pacific.

Phocinae Subfamily of carnivores

Phocinae is a subfamily of Phocidae whose distribution is found in the seas surrounding the Holarctic, with the Baikal seal being the world's only freshwater species of pinniped. What distinguishes them from other phocid seals is the presence of well-developed claws on their front and back flippers. The Phocinae is divided into three extant tribes: Erignathini, Cystophorini, and Phocini. Members of both Erignathini and Cystophorini have 34 chromosomes, while species in the tribe Phocini have 32 chromosomes.

<i>Allodesmus</i> Extinct genus of carnivores

Allodesmus is an extinct genus of pinniped from the middle to late Miocene of California and Japan that belongs to the extinct pinniped family Desmatophocidae.

<i>Pelagiarctos</i> Extinct genus of carnivores

Pelagiarctos was a genus of walrus that lived during the Mid Miocene, approx. 13-15 mya. Its remains have been found in the Sharktooth Hill Bonebed, in Kern County, California. It was originally described as an Otariidae, though it is now usually considered to be a basal Odobenidae.

<i>Puijila</i> Extinct genus of primitive pinnipeds

Puijila darwini is an extinct species of basal pinniped which lived during the Miocene epoch about 21 to 24 million years ago. Approximately a metre in length, the animal possessed only minimal physical adaptations for swimming. Unlike modern pinnipeds, it did not have flippers and its overall form was otter-like, albeit more specialized; its skull and teeth are the features that most clearly indicate that it is a seal.

<i>Pontolis</i> Extinct genus of carnivores

Pontolis is a large extinct genus of walrus. It contained three species, P. magnus, P. barroni, and P. kohnoi.

Semantoridae Extinct family of mammals

Semantoridae is an extinct family of stem-pinnipeds with fossils found in France, Kazakhstan, and Canada, dating back to various points in time in the Miocene epoch. Based on their overall anatomy semantorids were not marine specialists, as their elongated bodies, a long tail and robust limbs suggest they were freshwater animals not unlike otters. Indeed, at least some taxa such as Semantor and Potamotherium were initially classified as mustelids closely related to otters.

<i>Prototaria</i> Extinct genus of pinniped

Prototaria is an extinct genus of pinniped that lived approximately 15.97 to 13.65 mya during the Middle Miocene in what is now Japan. It belonged to the family Odobenidae, the only extant species of which is the walrus. Members of the genus Prototaria are believed to be the most basal imagotariine pinnipeds.

Proneotherium is an extinct genus of pinniped that lived approximately 20.43 to 15.97 mya during the Early Miocene in what is now Oregon, U.S.A. It belonged to the family Odobenidae, the only extant species of which is the walrus.

Monachinae Subfamily of carnivores

Monachinae is a subfamily of Phocidae whose distribution is found in the tropical, temperate and polar regions of the southern hemisphere, though in the distant past fossil representatives have been found on both sides of the North Atlantic Ocean. The difference between members of this group and members of Phocinae is in monachines the hindclaws are greatly reduced in size. Furthermore, all species have 34 chromosomes. There are three tribes recognized here: Monachini, Miroungini, and Lobodontini. While today represented by eight extant and one recently extinct species, Monachinae had an incredibly enriched fossil diversity that went into decline soon to be replaced by southern species of sea lions and fur seals.

<i>Osodobenus</i>

Osodobenus is an extinct genus of walrus from the Miocene to Pliocene of California. Osodobenus may have been the first tusked walrus and shows several adaptations that suggest it was a suction feeder, possibly even a benthic feeder like modern species. Three skulls are known showing pronounced sexual dimorphism, with the female lacking the same tusks as the male. Only a single species, Osodobenus eodon, is currently recognized.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Ray, C. (1976). Fossil Marine Mammals of Oregon. Systematic Zoology, 25(4), 420-436.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Berta, A. (1994). A New Species of Phocoid Pinniped Pinnarctidion from the Early Miocene of Oregon. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, 14(3), 405-413.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Wortman, J. T. (1906). A new fossil seal from the marine Miocene of the Oregon coast region. Science, 24(603), 89-92).
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 Kienle, S., & Berta, A. (2018). The evolution of feeding strategies in phocid seals (Pinnipedia, Phocidae). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, 38(6), Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, 02 November 2018, Vol.38(6).
  5. Valenzuela-Toro, A. & N. D. Pyenson. (2019). What do we know about the fossil record of pinnipeds? A historiographical investigation. Royal Society Open Science, 6(11), 191394.
  6. 1 2 Churchill, M., & M. Clementz. (2015). Functional Implications of Variation in Tooth Spacing and Crown Size in Pinnipedimorpha (Mammalia: Carnivora). The Anatomical Record, 298(5), 878-902.
  7. 1 2 Boessenecker, R. & Churchill M. (2018). The last of the desmatophocid seals: A new species of Allodesmus form the upper Miocene of Washington, USA, and a revision of the taxonomy of Desmatophocidae. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society, 184(1), 211-235.
  8. 1 2 3 4 Berta, A., & R. J. Emry. (2002). The Miocene pinniped Desmatophoca oregonensis Condon, 1906 (Mammalia, Carnivora), from the Astoria Formation, Oregon. Smithsonian Contributions to Paleobiology, 93, 113-147.
  9. Fulton, T. & C. Strobeck. (2010). Multiple fossil calibrations, nuclear loci and mitochondrial genomes provide new insight into biogeography and divergence timing for true seals (Phocidae, Pinnipedia). Journal of Biogeography, 37(5), 814-829.