Jobbers Canyon Historic District

Jobbers Canyon Historic District
Formerly listed on the  U.S. National Register of Historic Places
A view of the canyon
Location	Farnam Street on the north, South Eighth Street on the east, Jackson Street on the south, and South Tenth Street on the west, Downtown Omaha, Nebraska
Built	1920
Architect	John Latenser; Et al.
Architectural style	Renaissance, Romanesque, Richardsonian Romanesque
NRHP reference No.	86003408
Significant dates
Added to NRHP	1979 [1]
Removed from NRHP	March 26, 2002 [2]

Jobbers Canyon Historic District was a large industrial and warehouse area comprising 24 buildings located in downtown Omaha, Nebraska, US. It was roughly bound by Farnam Street on the north, South Eighth Street on the east, Jackson Street on the south, and South Tenth Street on the west. ^[3] In 1989, all 24 buildings in Jobbers Canyon were demolished, representing the largest National Register historic district loss to date. ^{[4] [5]}

About

The development of Jobber's Canyon mirrored Omaha's emergence as a central hub in the United States transportation system of the late 19th century and early 20th century. As the "Gateway to the West" serving several historic trails the Canyon housed several warehouses, grocers, and other dry goods outfitters for merchants throughout the Old West, particularly those along the Great Platte River Road. Railroad entrepreneurs, land speculators, and merchants built Jobbers Canyon from the 1870s onward. After George Francis Train landed the Union Pacific and Credit Foncier of America in Omaha, the city quickly turned into a transportation hub. ^[6] Fruit and vegetable wholesalers, meatpackers, and all sorts of supply people created a range of businesses, building almost 24 densely congested buildings in a seven-block by three-block area in downtown Omaha. At its peak, Jobbers Canyon had more than 1,700,000 square feet (160,000 m²) of office, warehouse, industrial and shipping space. ^[7]

Speaking in 1987 about Jobber's Canyon, J. Jackson Walter, president of the National Trust for Historic Preservation said, "The warehouse district, to the best of my knowledge, is certainly one of the Middle West's or the nation's finest collection of this sort of buildings." ^[8]

Individual properties

All of Omaha's largest and most notable wholesale and mercantile businesses built massive warehouse structures in the area by the early 20th century. Six- and seven-story red brick buildings filled with jobbing houses towered over red brick streets, creating a canyon-like feeling and leading to the area becoming called "Jobber's Canyon". The brick-surfaced South Ninth Street was an important streetscape in the city, with brick and cobblestone streets, railroad spur lines, loading docks, and dock canopies all contributing to the character of Jobbers Canyon. ^[9]

The area included the Kingman Implement Company building, also called the U.S. Tire building, located at 923 Farnam Street. It was built in 1900 as a six-story brick Renaissance Revival style structure. Kingman was a wholesale distributor of farm implements and vehicles. The Fairbanks, Morse and Company building at 923 Farnam Street was six stories tall. It was designed in 1907 by Omaha architects Fisher and Lawrie. In 1907 Fairbanks, Morse and Company was the largest manufacturer of gasoline, kerosene, and crude oil engines in the United States.^{[ citation needed ]}

In 1906, architect Charles Cleves designed a six-story building for the U.S. Supply Company, which distributed of wholesale steam, water and plumbing supplies. The Dempster Building was a five-story Renaissance Revival-style warehouse designed by Omaha architect John Latenser, Sr. in 1902. The Dempster Mill Manufacturing Company started as a small retail pump and windmill shop in 1880 and eventually grew to become a major manufacturer of windmills and farm implements. Architects Fisher & Lawrie designed another six-story red brick warehouse structure in 1900 for the Lee-Glass-Andreesen Hardware Company, which originated in 1880 as Lee, Fried & Co. They were wholesalers of hardware, cutlery and tinware.^{[ citation needed ]}

The eight-story Creighton Block was built for John A. Creighton to house the Byrne and Hammer Dry Goods Company. The most ornate building in Jobbers Canyon, this Renaissance Revival-style structure was designed by architect Charles Cleves. ^[9] Today the Greenhouse Apartments at 900 Farnam Street are the only building left from the original Jobbers Canyon.

The Nash Block at 902 Farnam Street was designed by Thomas R. Kimball and built in 1907.

Jobber's Canyon buildings	Address	Built	Demolished	Notes [10]
U.S. Supply Co.	901 Farnam Street	1906	1989
Kingman Implement Co.	923 Farnam Street	1900	1989
Harding Cream Co.	802-810 Harney Street	1904	1989
H.J. Lee warehouse	822 Harney Street	1900	1989
Fairbanks, Morse and Co.	902 Harney Street	1907	1989
Dempster	908 Harney Street	1902	1989
Crane Co. then Nogg Brothers Paper Co.	323 South Tenth Street	1905	1989	Bought by Nogg in 1966
Carpenter Paper Co.	815 Harney Street	1906	1989	Top floor remodeled in 1928
John Deere Plow Co.	402 South Ninth Street	1908	1989	Largest structure in the district
Creighton Block	824 Howard Street	1905	1989
Rector and Wilhelmy Co.	523 South Tenth Street	1889	1989
Richardson	902 Jackson Street	1891	1989
D. H. Food Co.	823 Howard Street	1901	1989
J.I. Case Plow Works	814 Jackson Street	1913	1989
Trimble Brothers	802 Jackson Street	1920	1989
American Radiator Co.	417 South Tenth Street	1905	1989
John Day Co.	401 South Tenth Street	c. 1892	1989	Remodeled 1932
Brunswick-Balke-Collender	407 South Tenth Street	c. 1888	1989
Nash Block	902 Farnam Street	1907	–	Only remaining building; divided into residential apartments
Omaha Cold Storage Co.	809 Farnam Street	1913	1989
Lee-Coit-Andreesen Hardware Co.	815 Farnam Street	1916	1989

Demolition

The M.E. Smith Building, designed by Frederick S. Stott, built in 1920 and formerly located at 201 South 10th Street. It was demolished in 1989.

Agriculture-related industries have always been important to Omaha's workforce. In addition to the meat industry, major employers have included the Kellogg Company and the Campbell Soup Company, which produces frozen Swanson and LeMenu products in Omaha. Exercising its influence, industry giant ConAgra transformed the skyline by demolishing Jobber's Canyon in 1989. Its world headquarters sat on 30 acres (120,000 m²) of the former historic district for the next 26 years. ^[11] At the time Charles M. Harper, chief executive of ConAgra, was asked about the district, and responded saying it was "some big, ugly red brick buildings". ^[8] ConAgra's campus created almost 300,000 square feet (30,000 m²) of office space. ^[7]

Critics charged that the city was being "held hostage" by ConAgra, ^[12] and that the city should not have to choose between its corporations and its historical legacies. ^[8]

At the time Omaha's then-planning director, Marty Shukert, said it was more important to keep the city's downtown core healthy than to keep the historic district. "This development may not be a large thing to a city with multiple corporate headquarters and a large development industry," he said. "In a relatively small community like this, the effects of a growing, national corporation echo throughout the economy." ^[8]

Trial

People for Responsible Omaha Urban Development (PROUD), with the National Trust for Historic Preservation as an intervening plaintiff, sued the Interstate Commerce Commission, the National Park Service and the Army Corps of Engineers in order to stop the demolition. The lawsuit alleged that the federal agencies failed to comply with the National Environmental Policy Act and the National Historic Preservation Act. The trial began in May 1988, and the district court immediately denied plaintiffs' request to stop demolition. The district court later ruled in favor of defendants on the merits, with a court of appeals affirming the district court decision in a brief opinion.

The court of appeal granted a partial stay of demolition during the appeals at a time when five buildings remained standing in the district. The injunction was later dissolved, and ultimately, all 24 buildings in the National Register-listed historic district were demolished, and the adjacent corporate campus was completed in 1992. ^[13]

Legacy

Two historic districts listed on the National Register currently border the former Jobbers Canyon site. They include the Old Market Historic District, which was listed in 1979; and the Omaha Rail and Commerce Historic District, which was listed in 1996. The Union Station, Burlington Train Station and Bemis Bag Company Building are all nearby buildings that have been included on the Register individually, reflecting the area's significance.

The National Park Service officially delisted the non-existent Jobbers Canyon Historic District in 2002. ^[2] In 2005 a restaurant called "Jobber's Canyon" opened in the Old Market, but later closed. ^[14] Some critics charge that Omaha's dual losses of Jobbers Canyon and the Union Stockyards represent a blatant disregard for the city's working-class history. ^[15]

In 2015, ConAgra moved its headquarters to Chicago and cut 1,500 of the 2,700 jobs at the Omaha offices. ^[16]

See also

• National Register of Historic Places listings in Douglas County, Nebraska
• Transportation in Omaha
• Omaha Rail and Commerce Historic District
• Old Market Historic District
• Warehouses in Omaha MPS

References

1. "National Register Information System". National Register of Historic Places . National Park Service. March 13, 2009.
2. (2002) National Park Service National Historic Register Listings April 2, 2002. National Park Service. Retrieved 7/8/07.
3. (nd) National Register of Historic Places - Nebraska, Douglas County. Retrieved 7/8/07.
4. Gratz, R.B. (1996) Living City: How America's Cities Are Being Revitalized by Thinking Small in a Big Way. John Wiley and Sons. p. V.
5. National Trust for Historic Preservation and Zagars, J. (1997) Preservation Yellow Pages: The Complete Information Source for Homeowners, Communities, and Professionals. John Wiley and Sons. p.80.
6. Larsen, L. and Cottrell, B. (1997) The Gate City: A History of Omaha. University of Nebraska Press. p. 26.
7. Gratz, R.B. (1996) Living City: How America's Cities Are Being Revitalized by Thinking Small in a Big Way. John Wiley and Sons. p. 6.
8. (1987) "Historic district at issue in Omaha," New York Times. 12/13/87. Retrieved 7/8/07.
9. (nd) "Jobbers Canyon". Archived 2006-11-13 at the Wayback Machine Mountain Lumber Company. Retrieved 7/8/07.
10. Spegel, Daniel D. (Summer 2012). "'Big, Ugly Red Brick Buildings': The Fight to Save Jobbers Canyon" (PDF). Nebraska History. pp. 54–83.^{[ permanent dead link ‍]}
11. Reeves, R. (nd) Omaha, Douglas County Archived 2011-07-20 at the Wayback Machine . University of Nebraska-Lincoln. Retrieved 7/8/07.
12. Schwab, J. (1989) "Omaha held hostage," Progressive. 53(5). p 36-39.
13. "People for Responsible Omaha Urban Development v. Interstate Commerce Commission". Defense Environmental Network and Information Exchange. Retrieved 7/8/07.
14. Keenan, J. (2005) Omaha World-Herald. 11/11/05. Retrieved 7/8/07.
15. Biga, L. A. (1998) "How the Mighty Did Fall: The Stockyards Nears the End of an Era." Archived October 9, 2007, at the Wayback Machine New Horizons. 9/21/98. Eastern Nebraska Office of Aging. Retrieved 6/22/07.
16. "ConAgra headquarters to leave Omaha for Chicago". Nebraska Public Media. Retrieved September 29, 2022.

Bibliography

• (2004) Omaha Since World War II: The Changing Face of the City (DVD). UNO Television.

External links

• Picture of downtown Omaha circa 1946, including the Jobbers Canyon in center.
• Slideshow of 3-dimensional model of Jobber's Canyon with present Greenhouse Apartments (former Nash Building) in detail. (This is a work in progress).

41°15′21″N95°55′38″W / 41.25583°N 95.92722°W / 41.25583; -95.92722