Le Jeune Case

Last updated
Le Jeune Case
Anne-Louis Girodet De Roucy-Trioson - Portrait of J. B. Belley, Deputy for Saint-Domingue - WGA09508.jpg
Haitian revolutionary and former slave Jean-Baptiste Belley, who lived in the area of Le Cap where the Le Jeune case was first heard. Portrait by Anne-Louis Girodet De Roucy-Trioson.
CourtLe Cap colonial court; Port-au-Prince superior court.
Decided1788
Case history
Appealed fromLe Cap colonial court
Appealed toPort-au-Prince superior court
Case opinions
Planter Le Jeune acquitted of having tortured and murdered his slaves.

The Le Jeune Case (or "Lejeune case") was a suit brought by 14 slaves against torture and murder by their master, Nicolas Le Jeune, in the French colony of Saint-Domingue in 1788. [1] Le Jeune was accused of torturing and murdering six slaves, who he said had planned to poison him. Despite overwhelming evidence of Le Jeune's guilt, courts ruled in favor of the planter, demonstrating the complicity of Saint-Domingue's legal system in the brutalization of slaves. [1] [2] The Haitian Revolution ending slavery in Saint-Domingue would begin only three years later.

Contents

Background

In 1685, France enacted the Code Noir, regulating the treatment of slaves in its colonies. [3] The code was brutal, and allowed both whipping and exploitation of slaves. Slaves who escaped as Maroons were to be branded, hamstrung or executed. [3] But the code also required that slaves be clothed and fed, and it ostensibly protected them against torture, murder and rape. [3] The codes were rarely enforced, [3] and beginning in 1767, French King Louis XV and his administration began amending the codes to reduce their protections of slaves, free blacks and mulattoes, and white colonists who might form personal relationships with them. [2] [3] In 1784 however, in response to abuses from slave-holding planters, France re-imposed more stringent regulations under the Code. [2]

Allegations of murder and torture

In March 1788, 14 slaves left the coffee plantation of Nicolas Le Jeune in Plaisance, Nord, southwest of Le Cap-Haïtien. [1] [3] They informed authorities in Le Cap that Le Jeune had murdered four of them, and was torturing two enslaved women at his plantation. [1] [3] Judges in Le Cap formed a commission to investigate the case, and its officers visited Le Jeune's plantation, where they found two women who were chained, and dying from wounds of torture. [1] [3] Le Jeune, who had burned off portions of their limbs, claimed that they were part of a slave plot to poison him. Investigators found no poison in the women's possessions. [1] [4] When both died, the Governor of Saint-Domingue demanded the arrest of Le Jeune, [3] who fled. [1]

Fear of poisoning by slaves was common in Saint-Domingue, and planters often extracted confessions of past or planned poisoning through torture. [3]

Map of Colonial-era Le Cap in 1728; slaves would bring their suit against Le Jeune to Le Cap courts in 1788. Cap Francais - Gravure ancienne - 1728.jpg
Map of Colonial-era Le Cap in 1728; slaves would bring their suit against Le Jeune to Le Cap courts in 1788.

In preliminary hearings, the 14 slaves reiterated their testimony against Le Jeune. [1] In response to the case, however, white planters in Saint-Domingue began a campaign in Le Jeune's defense, fearing that the "entire racial foundation" of slavery in the colony was imperiled. [3] Seven white witnesses testified to support Le Jeune, and hundreds of planters in influential colonial associations petitioned on his behalf. [1] Saint-Domingue's governor wrote to colonial administrators in France that "the safety of the colony depends on the acquittal of Le Jeune." [1] [2] Judges in Le Cap acquitted Le Jeune.

In response, the public prosecutor appealed before a superior legal council in Port-au-Prince, but fearing a hopeless case, he disappeared on the day of the hearing. [1] Le Jeune was again acquitted. [1] [3]

Legacy

The Le Jeune case demonstrated that colonial courts [2] and authorities [1] would defend the privileges of white colonists at all costs, and were willing to ignore laws passed in France that threatened their interests. White colonists in Saint-Domingue maintained that by protecting slavery, they were protecting property rights, and were thus acting in defense of individual liberties. [3]

Many French Enlightenment figures opposed slavery, and Denis Diderot's Encyclopedia article on the slave trade wrote, "let the colonies be destroyed rather than be the cause of so much evil." [1] But after his description of the Le Jeune case, historian C. L. R. James concludes that Enlightenment ideals were unable to effect change in the slave trade of France's colonies. [1]

Historian Laurent Dubois argues that colonial officials who prosecuted Le Jeune did so fearing Saint-Domingue's slaves would revolt unless Le Jeune was punished. [4] Historian Philippe Girard concludes that the Le Jeune case represented the "first steps of a revolutionary process that eventually culminated with the slave revolt," [3] referring to the Haitian Revolution that began in August 1791.

Related Research Articles

Toussaint Louverture Haitian general and revolutionary (1743–1803)

François-Dominique Toussaint Louverture was a Haitian general and the most prominent leader of the Haitian Revolution. During his life, Louverture first fought against the French, then for them, and then finally against France again for the cause of Haitian independence. As a revolutionary leader, Louverture displayed military and political acumen that helped transform the fledgling slave rebellion into a revolutionary movement. Louverture is now known as the "Father of Haiti."

Jean-Jacques Dessalines leader of Haitian Revolution and first ruler of independent Haiti (1758-1806)

Jean-Jacques Dessalines was a leader of the Haitian Revolution and the first ruler of an independent Haiti under the 1805 constitution. Under Dessalines, Haiti became the first country to permanently abolish slavery. Initially regarded as governor-general, Dessalines was later named Emperor of Haiti as Jacques I (1804–1806) by generals of the Haitian Revolution Army and ruled in that capacity until being assassinated in 1806. He is regarded as being one of the founding fathers of Haiti.

Saint-Domingue Former French colony on the isle of Hispaniola

Saint-Domingue was a French colony from 1659 to 1804 on the Caribbean island of Hispaniola; the island that now hosts two countries, the Dominican Republic and Haiti. The name was also used, at times, for the island of Hispaniola as a whole, all of it, nominally, being at times a French colony. The Spanish form of the name, Santo Domingo, also was used at times for the island as a whole. The border between the French-speaking Haiti and the Spanish-speaking Dominican Republic was not established until after the Dominican Republic's declaration of independence in 1844.

Free people of color Persons of partial African and European descent who were not enslaved

In the context of the history of slavery in the Americas, free people of color were people of mixed African, European, and sometimes Native American descent who were not enslaved. They were a distinct group of free people of color in the French colonies, including Louisiana and in settlements on Caribbean islands, such as Saint-Domingue (Haiti), St. Lucia, Dominica, Guadeloupe, and Martinique. In these territories and major cities, particularly New Orleans, and those cities held by the Spanish, a substantial third class of primarily mixed-race, free people developed. These colonial societies classified mixed-race people in a variety of ways, generally related to visible features and to the proportion of African ancestry. Racial classifications were numerous in Latin America.

Médéric Louis Élie Moreau de Saint-Méry French Creole colonist

Médéric Louis Élie Moreau de Saint-Méry, son of Bertrand-Médéric and Marie-Rose Moreau de Saint-Méry, was born in Fort-Royale, Martinique He was a lawyer and writer with a career in public office in France, Martinique, and Saint-Domingue. He is best known for his publications on Saint Domingue and Martinique. He married into a well-positioned family which allowed him to expand his connections among French people and in time, positioned himself as a member of the Parliament of France. Moreau was deeply involved in the founding of the Museum of Paris which he was later appointed president of in 1787

Haitian Revolution 1791–1804 slave revolt in the French colony of Saint-Domingue

The Haitian Revolution was a successful insurrection by self-liberated slaves against French colonial rule in Saint-Domingue, now the sovereign state of Haiti. The revolt began on 22 August 1791, and ended in 1804 with the former colony's independence. It involved black, biracial, French, Spanish, British, and Polish participants—with the ex-slave Toussaint Louverture emerging as Haiti's most charismatic hero. The revolution was the only slave uprising that led to the founding of a state which was both free from slavery, and ruled by non-whites and former captives. It is now widely seen as a defining moment in the history of the Atlantic World.

Affranchi is a former French legal term denoting a freedman or emancipated slave, but was a term used to refer pejoratively to mulattoes. It is used in the English language to describe the social class of freedmen in Saint-Domingue, and other slave-holding French territories, who held legal rights intermediate between those of free whites and enslaved Africans. In Saint-Domingue, roughly half of the affranchis were gens de couleur libres and the other half African slaves.

François Mackandal

François Mackandal was a Haitian Maroon leader in Haiti. He is sometimes described as a Haitian vodou priest, or houngan. For joining Maroons to kill slaves owners in Saint Domingue, he was captured and burned alive by French colonial authorities.

Léger-Félicité Sonthonax

Léger-Félicité Sonthonax was a French abolitionist and Jacobin before joining the Girondist party, which emerged in 1791. During the French Revolution, he controlled 7,000 French troops in Saint-Domingue during part of the Haitian Revolution. His official title was Civil Commissioner. From September 1792 to December 1795, he was the de facto ruler of Saint-Domingue's non-slave populace. Within a year of his appointment, his powers were considerably expanded by the Committee of Public Safety. He was recalled in 1795 largely due to the resurgence of conservative politics in France. Sonthonax believed that Saint-Domingue's whites were royalists or separatists, so he attacked the military power of the white settlers and by doing so alienated the colonial settlers from their government. Many gens de couleur asserted that they could form the military backbone of Saint-Domingue if they were given rights, but Sonthonax rejected this view as outdated in the wake of the August 1791 slave uprising. He believed that Saint-Domingue would need ex-slave soldiers among the ranks of the colonial army if it was to survive. On August 1793, he proclaimed freedom for all slaves in the north province. His critics allege that he was forced into ending slavery in order to maintain his own power.

Georges Biassou

Georges Biassou was an early leader of the 1791 slave rising in Saint-Domingue that began the Haitian Revolution. With Jean François and Jeannot, he was prophesied by the vodou priest, Dutty Boukman, to lead the revolution.

Julien Raimond (1744–1801) was an indigo planter in the French colony of Saint-Domingue, now the Republic of Haiti, who became a leader in its revolution and the formation of Haiti.

Vincent Ogé

Vincent Ogé was a French aristocrat of mixed descent who instigated a rebellion against white colonial authority in French Saint-Domingue that lasted from October to December 1790 in the area outside Cap-Français, the colony's main city. The Ogé revolt of 1790 foretold the massive slave uprising of August 1791 that eventually led to the Haitian Revolution.

Étienne Polverel (1740–1795) was a French lawyer, aristocrat, and revolutionary. He was a member of the Jacobin club. In 1792, he and Léger Félicité Sonthonax were sent to Saint-Domingue to suppress a slave revolt. Polverel was an abolitionist and after a few years he had emancipated the slaves of the colony and given them political equality.

The Haitian Revolution and the subsequent emancipation of Haiti as an independent state provoked mixed reactions in the United States. Among many white Americans this led to uneasiness, instilling fears of racial instability on its own soil and possible problems with foreign relations and trade between the two countries; among enslaved black Americans it fueled hope that the principles of the recent American Revolution might be realized in their own liberation.

The War of Knives, also known as the War of the South, was a civil war from June 1799 to July 1800 between the Haitian revolutionary Toussaint Louverture, a black ex-slave who controlled the north of Saint-Domingue, and his adversary André Rigaud, a mixed-race free person of color who controlled the south. Louverture and Rigaud fought over de facto control of the French colony of Saint-Domingue during the war. Their conflict followed the withdrawal of British forces from the colony during the early stages of the Haitian Revolution. The war resulted in Toussaint taking control of the entirety of Saint-Domingue, and Rigaud fleeing into exile.

1804 Haiti massacre Massacre of the French population in Haiti following the Haitian Revolution

The 1804 Haiti massacre was carried out against the French population and French Creoles remaining in Haiti following the Haitian Revolution, by soldiers, mostly former slaves, under orders from Jean-Jacques Dessalines. He had decreed that all suspected of conspiring in the acts of the expelled army should be put to death. From early January 1804 until 22 April 1804, squads of soldiers moved from house to house throughout Haiti, torturing and killing entire families. Between 3,000 to 5,000 people were killed.

Slavery in Haiti Slave labor as a legal institution extant 1492–1804

Slavery in Haiti started after the arrival of Christopher Columbus on the island in 1492 with the European colonists that followed from Portugal, Spain and France. The practice was devastating to the native population. Following the indigenous Tainos' near decimation from forced labor, disease and war, the Spanish, under advisement of the Catholic priest Bartolomé de las Casas and with the blessing of the Catholic church, began engaging in earnest in the 1600 kidnapped and forced labor of enslaved Africans. During the French colonial period beginning in 1625, the economy of Haiti was based on slavery, and the practice there was regarded as the most brutal in the world. The Haitian Revolution of 1804, the only successful slave revolt in human history, precipitated the end of slavery not only in Saint-Domingue, but in all French colonies. However, this revolt has only merited a marginal role in the histories of Portuguese and Spanish America. Moreover, it is to this rebellion in Haiti that the struggle for independence in Latin American can be traced to. However, several Haitian leaders following the revolution employed forced labor, believing a plantation-style economy was the only way for Haiti to succeed, and building fortifications to safeguard against attack by the French. During the U.S. occupation between 1915 and 1934, the U.S. military forced Haitians to work building roads for defense against Haitian resistance fighters.

Macaya, was a Kongolese-born Haitian revolutionary military leader. Macaya was one of the first black rebel leaders in Saint-Domingue to ally himself with the French Republican commissioners Sonthonax and Polverel. He helped to lead forces that recaptured Cap-Français on behalf of the French Republicans.

Planter class Socio-economic caste of Pan-American society

The planter class, known alternatively in the United States as the Southern aristocracy, was a socio-economic caste of Pan-American society that dominated 17th and 18th century agricultural markets through the slavery of African Americans. The Atlantic slave trade permitted planters access to inexpensive labor for the planting and harvesting of crops such as tobacco, cotton, indigo, coffee, tea, cocoa, sugar cane, sisal, oil seeds, oil palms, hemp, rubber trees, and fruits. Planters were considered part of the American gentry.

Alexandre de Vincent de Mazade was a French soldier who was twice acting governor of the French colony of Saint-Domingue between 1787 and 1789.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 James, CLR (1963). The Black Jacobins (Second Edition, Revised ed.). Vintage Books. pp. 22–24.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 Shen, Kona. "French Rule and Tensions in the Colony". History of Haiti. Brown University. Retrieved 22 December 2020.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Girard, Phlippe (2016). Toussaint Louverture. New York: Basic Books.
  4. 1 2 Laurent, Dubois (2004). Avengers of the New World. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.