List of common misconceptions about the Middle Ages

Last updated

The Middle Ages is a traditional division of Western European history that roughly lasted from the 5th to the 15th centuries. After the collapse of the Western Roman Empire, civilization in different parts of Western Europe receded at different rates and at different times. Eventually, the Carolingian Empire was established in the 9th century and reunited much of Western Europe, but the entity itself collapsed and fractured into a number of states. State fragmentation and competition characterized much of the history of medieval Western Europe, [1] and that trend would remain true for a long period of history afterwards.

Contents

Even as the Middle Ages become increasingly well documented; historians increasingly focus on writing literature addressing some of the primary misconceptions about medieval history; [2] [3] and other historians take the alternative approach of highlighting many of the intellectual, scientific, and technological advances that took place during the period, [4] such ideas remain prominent in the public sphere and continue to dominate conceptions about the Middle Ages as a whole. A prominent misconception is related to the Dark Ages itself, a term that its traditionally used as a synonym for the Middle Ages to emphasize its barbarity, its intellectual ignorance or the supposed lack of sources by which the period is thought to be characterized although all of those characterizations have failed to withstand scholarly criticism. [5] [6]

Critical analysis of the Middle Ages has instead revealed it to have been a period of momentous change and, in many areas, tremendous progress. While people traditionally associate the Renaissance with post-medieval intellectual rebirth, the Renaissance is now seen to have initiated in different times in different places across Europe and to have itself begun during the Late Middle Ages. [7] Furthermore, a number of periods of intellectual rebirth took place throughout the medieval period, including the Carolingian Renaissance in the 9th century and, more importantly, the 12th-century Renaissance. Furthermore, despite some early debates, Christians quickly came to accept and adopt the cultural learning of the Greeks and the Romans, and they further decided that philosophy and science were handmaidens and precedents to acts of higher Christian learning.

Advances in many fields were made, and among the most critical developments were the rise of the university in the late 12th to the 13th centuries out of the prior cathedral schools, which had been established during the Carolingian renaissance, which itself was associated with the rise, for the first time in history, of a class of career scholars, who were engaged in the study of philosophy and learning. [8]

History of the "Dark Ages" misconception

Petrarch, who conceived the idea of a European "Dark Age." From Cycle of Famous Men and Women, Andrea di Bartolo di Bargilla, c. 1450 Petrarch by Bargilla.jpg
Petrarch, who conceived the idea of a European "Dark Age." From Cycle of Famous Men and Women, Andrea di Bartolo di Bargilla, c. 1450

The first author to describe the notion of a "Dark Ages" was Petrarch, a late medieval writer. From his perspective on the Italian Peninsula, Petrarch saw the Roman period and classical antiquity as an expression of greatness. [9] He spent much of his time traveling through Europe and rediscovering and republishing classic Latin and Greek texts. He wanted to restore Latin to its former purity. Petrarch wrote that history had two periods: the classic period of Greeks and Romans, followed by a time of darkness in which he saw himself as living. In around 1343, in the conclusion of his epic Africa , he wrote: "My fate is to live among varied and confusing storms. But for you perhaps, if as I hope and wish you will live long after me, there will follow a better age. This sleep of forgetfulness will not last forever. When the darkness has been dispersed, our descendants can come again in the former pure radiance." [10]

During the 16th- and 17th-century Reformation of the 16th and 17th centuries, Protestants generally had a similar view to Renaissance humanists such as Petrarch but added an anti-Catholic perspective. They saw classical antiquity as a golden age not only because of its Latin literature but also because it witnessed the beginnings of Christianity. They promoted the idea that the "Middle Age" was a time of darkness also because of corruption within the Catholic Church such as popes ruling as kings, the veneration of saints' relics, a licentious priesthood, and institutionalized moral hypocrisy. [11]

During the 17th- and 18th-century Age of Enlightenment, many critical thinkers saw religion as antithetical to reason. For them, the Middle Ages, or the "Age of Faith," was therefore the opposite of the Age of Reason. [12] Baruch Spinoza, Bernard Fontenelle, Immanuel Kant, David Hume, Thomas Jefferson, Thomas Paine, Denis Diderot, Voltaire, the Marquis De Sade and Jean-Jacques Rousseau were vocal in attacking the Middle Ages as a period of social regress dominated by religion, and Edward Gibbon in The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire expressed contempt for the "rubbish of the Dark Ages." [13] Yet just as Petrarch, seeing himself at the cusp of a "new age," was criticising the centuries before his own time, so too were Enlightenment writers.

The concept of the Dark Ages had been in use, but by the 18th century, it tended to be confined to the earlier part of the period. The earliest entry for a capitalized "Dark Ages" in the Oxford English Dictionary is a reference in Henry Thomas Buckle's History of Civilization in England in 1857. [14]

Medieval artistic illustration of the spherical Earth in a 14th-century copy of L'Image du monde (c. 1246) Gossuin de Metz - L'image du monde - BNF Fr. 574 fo42 - miniature.jpg
Medieval artistic illustration of the spherical Earth in a 14th-century copy of L'Image du monde (c. 1246)

The science historian David C. Lindberg criticised the public use of "dark ages" to describe the entire Middle Ages as "a time of ignorance, barbarism and superstition" for which "blame is most often laid at the feet of the Christian church, which is alleged to have placed religious authority over personal experience and rational activity." [15] The science historian Edward Grant wrote, "If revolutionary rational thoughts were expressed in the Age of Reason, they were made possible because of the long medieval tradition that established the use of reason as one of the most important of human activities." [16] Furthermore, Lindberg noted that contrary to common belief, "the late medieval scholar rarely experienced the coercive power of the church and would have regarded himself as free (particularly in the natural sciences) to follow reason and observation wherever they led." [17]

Misconceptions

Belief in a flat Earth

One of the most common errors surrounding the Middle Ages the period had people or the uneducated ones at the very least believed that the Earth was flat and that the belief was eventually reversed with the voyages of Christopher Columbus, which disproved common opinion on the sphericity of the Earth. However, that portrait of history only goes back to the early 19th century and was invented by Washington Irving in his book A History of the Life and Voyages of Christopher Columbus (1828). The idea further gained popularity in the late 19th and the early 20th centuries during the beginning of the debates over evolution. In his book Inventing the Flat Earth: Columbus and Modern Historians , the historian Jeffrey Burton Russell claims that "with extraordinary few exceptions no educated person in the history of Western Civilization from the third century B.C. onward believed that the Earth was flat." He ascribes the popularization of the flat Earth myth to the writings of John William Draper, Andrew Dickson White and Irving. [18]

To illustrate the point, all medieval references to the shape of the Earth, nearly without exception, have been noted to be spherical. For example, Johannes de Sacrobosco (1195–1256) wrote in his De sphaera mundi ("Treatise on the Sphere"):

That the earth, too, is round is shown thus. The signs and stars do not rise and set the same for all men everywhere but rise and set sooner for those in the east than for those in the west; and of this there is no other cause than the bulge of the earth. Moreover, celestial phenomena evidence that they rise sooner for Orientals than for westerners. For one and the same eclipse of the moon which appears to us in the first hour of the night appears to Orientals about the third hour of the night, which proves that they had night and sunset before we did, of which setting the bulge of the earth is the cause. (Ch. 1.9) [19]

Among many of the other medieval writers describing the sphericity of the Earth is Thomas Aquinas, who notes in his Summa Theologica that the sphericity of the Earth can be "demonstrated," [20] and John Mandeville, who in his The Travels of Sir John Mandeville also goes about demonstrating the sphericity of the Earth as an exercise. Some try to argue that an example of a medieval flat-earther included Isidore of Seville, who lived in the 6th and the 7th centuries, but he overtly teaches the sphericity of the Earth. [21]

How many angels can fit on the head of a pin?

It is frequently asserted that medieval scholastic philosophers engaged in drawn out debates and discussions on how many angels could fit on the head of a pin or a needle. This story is used to highlight the inefficient and fruitless nature of medieval intellectual pursuits when they did happen. Nevertheless, the debates did not take place. According to the historian Peter Harrison, "That scholastic philosophers engaged in speculations about how many angels could dance on the head of a pin has long been exposed as a myth invented in the seventeenth century." Harrison identifies William Chillingworth's The Religion of Protestants (1638) and William Sclater's An exposition with notes upon the first Epistle to the Thessalonians (1619) as the original sources of this myth. According to Harrison, the myth of the 'needles point' may have arisen from a pun claiming that the medieval scholastics argued about 'needless points'. [22]

However, the problem of cannibals' children in the Judgement Day [23] was addressed by several prominent theologians.[ citation needed ] Likewise, some medieval scholars themselves lamented the vast amount of time that had been used during the debate on the problem of universals.[ citation needed ]

Cat massacres and the subsequent plague

During the Middle Ages, cats were often kept as pets, and many were appreciated for their ability to manage household rodents. The Ancrene Wisse , a 13th-century medieval text, advises female hermits that "you shall not possess any beast, my dear sisters, except only a cat." [24] Nevertheless, the idea that a hatred developed against cats among Christians in the Middle Ages, followed by a subsequent massacre of cats enacted by the Catholic Church that would then promote the spread of the Black Plague because of the rodent populations that flourished in the absence of cats, goes back to and was popularized by a 2001 book by a historian of ancient Greece, Donald Engels, titled Classical Cats: The rise and fall of the sacred cat. The basis of this claim is a papal bull issued by Pope Gregory IX, Vox in Rama , which itself does not mention killing of cats or make any statements about cats being evil;

The following rites of this pestilence are carried out: when any novice is to be received among them and enters the sect of the damned for the first time, the shape of a certain frog appears to him, which some are accustomed to call a toad. Some kiss this creature on the hind-quarters and some on the mouth; they receive the tongue and the saliva of the beast inside their mouths; sometimes it appears unduly large, and sometimes equivalent to a goose or duck, and sometimes it even assumes the size of an oven. At length, when the novice has come forward, he is met by a man of marvelous pallor, who has very black eyes and is so emaciated and thin that, since his flesh has been wasted, seems to have remaining only skin drawn over the bone. The novice kisses him and feels cold, like ice, and after the kiss the memory of the catholic faith totally disappears from his heart. Afterwards they sit down to a meal and when they have arisen from it, from a certain statue, which is usual in a sect of this kind, a black cat about the size of an average dog, descends backwards, with its tail erect. First the novice, then the master, then each one of the order who are worthy and perfect, kiss the cat on its hindquarters; the imperfect, who do not estimate themselves worthy, receive grace from the master. Then each returns to his place and, speaking certain response, they incline their heads towards the cat. ‘Forgive us,’ says the master, and the one next to him repeats this, and a third responding and saying, ‘We know master’; a fourth says, ‘And we must obey.’ [25]

Though the source and no other refers to a massacre of cats, Engels claimed that based on it, as well as some artistic depictions where cats are shown as being killed, he could correctly make the "assumption" that cats were widely massacred in the medieval period. [26] Based on that and other comments by Engels in his book, including in his association with Augustine's theology with Nazism, some historians reviewing Engels's book have described him as a "fanatic" and accused him of using his imagination to fill in historical blanks. [27]

Furthermore, others pointed out that even had cat massacres been attempted, it would have played no role in the spread of Black Death for several reasons, including that cat extermination is extremely difficult to manage, fleas spreading the plague may not have spread from rats at all but person to person, and cats themselves are capable of catching the illness and then passing it onto humans. [28]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Flat Earth</span> Archaic conception of Earths shape

Flat Earth is an archaic and scientifically disproven conception of the Earth's shape as a plane or disk. Many ancient cultures subscribed to a flat-Earth cosmography, notably including ancient near eastern cosmology. The model has undergone a recent resurgence as a conspiracy theory.

In historiography, periodization is the process or study of categorizing the past into discrete, quantified, and named blocks of time for the purpose of study or analysis. This is usually done in order to understand current and historical processes, and the causality that might have linked those events.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Petrarch</span> 14th-century Italian scholar and poet

Francis Petrarch, born Francesco di Petracco, was a scholar from Arezzo and poet of the early Italian Renaissance and one of the earliest humanists.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Renaissance</span> European cultural period of the 14th to 17th centuries

The Renaissance is a period of history and a European cultural movement covering the 15th and 16th centuries. It marked the transition from the Middle Ages to modernity and was characterized by an effort to revive and surpass the ideas and achievements of classical antiquity. Associated with great social change in most fields and disciplines, including art, architecture, politics, literature, exploration and science, the Renaissance was first centered in the Republic of Florence, then spread to the rest of Italy and later throughout Europe. The term rinascita ("rebirth") first appeared in Lives of the Artists by Giorgio Vasari, while the corresponding French word renaissance was adopted into English as the term for this period during the 1830s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dark Ages (historiography)</span> Term for the Early Middle Ages

The Dark Ages is a term for the Early Middle Ages, or occasionally the entire Middle Ages, in Western Europe after the fall of the Western Roman Empire, which characterises it as marked by economic, intellectual, and cultural decline.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Renaissance humanism</span> Revival in the study of Classical antiquity

Renaissance humanism is a worldview centered on the nature and importance of humanity that emerged from the study of Classical antiquity.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Italian Renaissance</span> Italian cultural movement from the 14th to 17th century

The Italian Renaissance was a period in Italian history between the 14th and 16th centuries. The period is known for the initial development of the broader Renaissance culture that spread across Western Europe and marked the transition from the Middle Ages to modernity. Proponents of a "long Renaissance" argue that it started around the year 1300 and lasted until about 1600. In some fields, a Proto-Renaissance, beginning around 1250, is typically accepted. The French word renaissance means "rebirth", and defines the period as one of cultural revival and renewed interest in classical antiquity after the centuries during what Renaissance humanists labelled as the "Dark Ages". The Italian Renaissance historian Giorgio Vasari used the term rinascita ("rebirth") in his Lives of the Most Excellent Painters, Sculptors, and Architects in 1550, but the concept became widespread only in the 19th century, after the work of scholars such as Jules Michelet and Jacob Burckhardt.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Renaissance philosophy</span> Period of European thought (1355–1650)

The designation "Renaissance philosophy" is used by historians of philosophy to refer to the thought of the period running in Europe roughly between 1400 and 1600. It therefore overlaps both with late medieval philosophy, which in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries was influenced by notable figures such as Albert the Great, Thomas Aquinas, William of Ockham, and Marsilius of Padua, and early modern philosophy, which conventionally starts with René Descartes and his publication of the Discourse on Method in 1637.

Humanitas is a Latin noun meaning human nature, civilization, and kindness. It has uses in the Enlightenment, which are discussed below.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Renaissance of the 12th century</span> Period during the High Middle Ages of European history

The Renaissance of the 12th century was a period of many changes at the outset of the High Middle Ages. It included social, political and economic transformations, and an intellectual revitalization of Western Europe with strong philosophical and scientific roots. These changes paved the way for later achievements such as the literary and artistic movement of the Italian Renaissance in the 15th century and the scientific developments of the 17th century.

<i>Christian Topography</i> Geography work by Cosmas Indicopleustes (c. 550)

The Christian Topography is a 6th-century work, one of the earliest essays in scientific geography written by a Christian author. It originally consisted of five books written by Cosmas Indicopleustes and expanded to ten and eventually to twelve books at around 550 AD.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Continuity thesis</span> Hypothesis regarding European intellectual history

In the history of ideas, the continuity thesis is the hypothesis that there was no radical discontinuity between the intellectual development of the Middle Ages and the developments in the Renaissance and early modern period. Thus the idea of an intellectual or scientific revolution following the Renaissance is, according to the continuity thesis, a myth. Some continuity theorists point to earlier intellectual revolutions occurring in the Middle Ages, usually referring to the European Renaissance of the 12th century as a sign of continuity.

Hans Baron was a German-American historian of political thought and literature. His main contribution to the historiography of the period was to introduce in 1928 the term civic humanism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Myth of the flat Earth</span> Misconception that people in the Middle Ages believed Earth to be flat

The myth of the flat Earth, or the flat-Earth error, is a modern historical misconception that European scholars and educated people during the Middle Ages believed the Earth to be flat.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Medieval philosophy</span> Philosophy during the medieval period

Medieval philosophy is the philosophy that existed through the Middle Ages, the period roughly extending from the fall of the Western Roman Empire in the 5th century until after the Renaissance in the 13th and 14th centuries. Medieval philosophy, understood as a project of independent philosophical inquiry, began in Baghdad, in the middle of the 8th century, and in France and Germany, in the itinerant court of Charlemagne in Aachen, in the last quarter of the 8th century. It is defined partly by the process of rediscovering the ancient culture developed in Greece and Rome during the Classical period, and partly by the need to address theological problems and to integrate sacred doctrine with secular learning. This is one of the defining characteristics in this time period. Understanding God was the focal point of study of the philosophers at that time, Muslim and Christian alike.

<i>Gods Philosophers</i> 2009 book by James Hannam

God's Philosophers: How the Medieval World Laid the Foundations of Modern Science is a 2009 book written by British historian of science James Hannam.

Monastic schools were, along with cathedral schools, the most important institutions of higher learning in the Latin West from the early Middle Ages until the 12th century. Since Cassiodorus's educational program, the standard curriculum incorporated religious studies, the Trivium, and the Quadrivium. In some places monastic schools evolved into medieval universities which eventually largely superseded both institutions as centers of higher learning.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">European science in the Middle Ages</span> Period of history of science

European science in the Middle Ages comprised the study of nature, mathematics and natural philosophy in medieval Europe. Following the fall of the Western Roman Empire and the decline in knowledge of Greek, Christian Western Europe was cut off from an important source of ancient learning. Although a range of Christian clerics and scholars from Isidore and Bede to Jean Buridan and Nicole Oresme maintained the spirit of rational inquiry, Western Europe would see a period of scientific decline during the Early Middle Ages. However, by the time of the High Middle Ages, the region had rallied and was on its way to once more taking the lead in scientific discovery. Scholarship and scientific discoveries of the Late Middle Ages laid the groundwork for the Scientific Revolution of the Early Modern Period.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Christianity and science</span> Relationship between Christianity and science

Most scientific and technical innovations prior to the Scientific Revolution were achieved by societies organized by religious traditions. Ancient Christian scholars pioneered individual elements of the scientific method. Historically, Christianity has been and still is a patron of sciences. It has been prolific in the foundation of schools, universities and hospitals, and many Christian clergy have been active in the sciences and have made significant contributions to the development of science.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Classical education in the Western world</span>

Classical education in the Western world refers to a long-standing tradition of pedagogy that traces its roots back to ancient Greece and Rome, where the foundations of Western intellectual and cultural life were laid. At its core, classical education is centered on the study of the liberal arts, which historically comprised the trivium and the quadrivium. This educational model aimed to cultivate well-rounded individuals equipped with the knowledge and skills necessary to engage in public life, think critically, and pursue moral and intellectual virtues.

References

  1. ↑ Scheidel, Walter. Escape from Rome: The Failure of Empire and the Road to Prosperity. Princeton University Press, 2019.
  2. ↑ Harris, Stephen, and Bryon L. Grigsby, eds. Misconceptions about the Middle Ages. Routledge, 2010.
  3. ↑ Black, Winston. The Middle Ages: Facts and Fictions. ABC-CLIO, 2019.
  4. ↑ Seb Falk, The Light Ages: The Surprising Story of Medieval Science, Penguin, 2020.
  5. ↑ Fouracre, Paul (eds). The New Cambridge Medieval History: Volume 1 c.500–c.700. Cambridge University Press, 2005, 90. "In terms of the sources of information available, this is most certainly not a Dark Age.... Over the last century, the sources of evidence have increased dramatically, and the remit of the historian (broadly defined as a student of the past) has expanded correspondingly."
  6. ↑ Raico, Ralph. "The European Miracle" . Retrieved 14 August 2011. "The stereotype of the Middle Ages as 'the Dark Ages' fostered by Renaissance humanists and Enlightenment philosophes has, of course, long since been abandoned by scholars."
  7. ↑ Monfasani, John. Renaissance Humanism, from the Middle Ages to Modern Times. Routledge, 2016.
  8. ↑ Grant, Edward. The foundations of modern science in the Middle Ages: their religious, institutional and intellectual contexts. Cambridge University Press, 1996.
  9. ↑ Mommsen, Theodore E. "Petrarch's Conception of the'Dark Ages'." Speculum 17.2 (1942): 226–242.
  10. ↑ Petrarch (1343). Africa , IX, 451-7. This quotation comes from the English translation of Mommsen's article.
  11. ↑ F. Oakley, The medieval experience: foundations of Western cultural singularity (University of Toronto Press, 1988), pp. 1–4.
  12. ↑ Bartlett, Robert (2001). "Introduction: Perspectives on the Medieval World," in Medieval Panorama. ISBN   0-89236-642-7. "Disdain about the medieval past was especially forthright amongst the critical and rationalist thinkers of the Enlightenment. For them the Middle Ages epitomized the barbaric, priest-ridden world they were attempting to transform."
  13. ↑ Gibbon, Edward (1788). The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, Vol. 6, Ch. XXXVII, paragraph 619.
  14. ↑ Oxford English Dictionary (2 ed.). Oxford, England: Oxford University Press. 1989. a term sometimes applied to the period of the Middle Ages to mark the intellectual darkness characteristic of the time; often restricted to the early period of the Middle Ages, between the time of the fall of Rome and the appearance of vernacular written documents.
  15. ↑ David C. Lindberg, "The Medieval Church Encounters the Classical Tradition: Saint Augustine, Roger Bacon, and the Handmaiden Metaphor," in David C. Lindberg and Ronald L. Numbers, ed. When Science & Christianity Meet, (Chicago: University of Chicago Pr., 2003), p.8
  16. ↑ Edward Grant. God and Reason in the Middle Ages, Cambridge 2001, p. 9.
  17. ↑ Quoted in essay by Ted Peters, Science and Religion at Lindsay Jones (editor-in-chief). "Encyclopedia of Religion." Second Edition. Thomson Gale. 2005. p.8182.
  18. ↑ Jeffrey Russel. Inventing the Flat Earth. Praeger 1997.
  19. ↑ English translation of the De sphaera mundi here.
  20. ↑ "SUMMA THEOLOGIAE: The distinction of habits (Prima Secundae Partis, Q. 54)". www.newadvent.org.
  21. ↑ Stevens, Wesley M. "The Figure of the Earth in Isidore's" De natura rerum." Isis 71.2 (1980): 268–277.
  22. ↑ Harrison, Peter. "Angels on pinheads and needles’ points." Notes and Queries 63.1 (2016): 45–47.
  23. ↑ Material bodies of people were supposed to be set up together in the Judgement Day according to Catholic doctrine. Thus, a question rises what happens to children of cannibals whose bodies are made of material taken from other people.
  24. ↑ Amt, Emilie, and Katherine Allen Smith, eds. Medieval England, 500–1500: A Reader. Vol. 6. University of Toronto Press, 2018, 236.
  25. ↑ Kors, Alan, Alan Charles Kors, and Edward Peters, eds. Witchcraft in Europe, 400–1700: A documentary history. University of Pennsylvania Press, 2001, 115–6.
  26. ↑ Engels, Classical cats, 159.
  27. ↑ Thomas Harrison, "Classical Cats. The Rise and Fall of the Sacred Cat," Classics Ireland (2002): 88–91.
  28. ↑ Tucker, Abigail. The lion in the living room: How house cats tamed us and took over the world. Simon and Schuster, 2017, 50
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.