| "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" | |
|---|---|
| Northern Songs sheet music cover | |
| Song by the Beatles | |
| from the album Abbey Road | |
| Written | October 1968 |
| Released | 26 September 1969 |
| Recorded | 9–11 July 1969 |
| Studio | EMI, London |
| Genre | |
| Length | 3:27 |
| Label | Apple |
| Songwriters | Paul McCartney, credited to Lennon–McCartney |
| Producer | George Martin |
| Licensed audio | |
| "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" on YouTube | |
"Maxwell's Silver Hammer" is a song by the English rock band the Beatles from their 1969 album Abbey Road . Written and sung by Paul McCartney, the song tells the story of Maxwell Edison, a medicine student who murders people with a hammer; it has been described as a pop, pop rock, and music hall song.
McCartney wrote the song in October 1968 during the recording sessions for the Beatles' 1968 White Album . He described it as a symbolism for the downfalls of life, his "analogy for when something goes wrong out of the blue, as it so often does". The Beatles rehearsed "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" multiple times in January 1969 during sessions for Get Back , before they recorded it for Abbey Road in July. The band began recording the track on 9 July and completed it two days later. McCartney's bandmates all spoke negatively about the recording sessions for "Maxwell's Silver Hammer"; John Lennon recalled that McCartney "made us do it a hundred million times", and Ringo Starr declared it "the worst track we ever had to record". The song makes use of the anvil and Moog synthesizer – the first Beatles song to use the latter.
Apple Records released "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" on 26 September 1969, as part of Abbey Road. Lennon said that McCartney considered releasing the song as a single, but these plans were not addressed. An alternate take of the track appears on the Beatles' 1996 compilation Anthology 3 . Some critics have praised McCartney's songwriting, while others fault its pacing and silliness; it has consistently placed in the middle half of rankings of the Beatles' discography. "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" has been covered by several artists, such as George Fenton, Steve Martin, Frankie Laine, and the Bells. McCartney's original handwritten lyrics for the song were auctioned in 2022 for the starting price of $425,000.
Paul McCartney wrote "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" during the recording sessions for the Beatles' White Album in October 1968. [1] [2] It was his analogy for when something goes wrong. To portray this symbolically, he created a character named Maxwell armed with a silver hammer. [3] He described the track as "the kind of song I like to write" and said it was "a silly story about all these people I'd never met". [4] The band did not complete "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" in time to make the White Album, [1] [5] as most of its tracks had been recorded by October. [6]
McCartney's wife Linda recalled that he had grown interested in avant-garde theatre and immersed himself in the works of the French symbolist writer Alfred Jarry. [7] In 1965, he listened to the play Ubu Cocu on the radio and was intrigued. [8] This influence manifests itself in the song's storyline and tone and also explains how McCartney came across the word pataphysical, which is Jarry's coinage. [7] While McCartney wrote the song, it is credited to the Lennon–McCartney partnership. [1]
"Maxwell's Silver Hammer" is a pop, [9] [10] pop rock, [11] and music hall [12] song with a length of three minutes and twenty-seven seconds. [2] It is in the key of D major and follows common time. It comprises three verses, five refrains, three interludes, and an outro. [10] Its arrangement features guitars, bass, drums, piano, and a Moog synthesizer played by McCartney, the first time the latter featured on a Beatles track. [13] [2] Ringo Starr also provides an anvil part, although some writers have asserted that the band's road manager Mal Evans played the anvil. [14] [a] The engineer Geoff Emerick explains that Starr could not lift the bulky hammer and strike it onto the anvil in time, so Evans took over. [15]
The song's sections link together through markedly deliberate instrumentation or parts, like piano arpeggios into the third verse. The musicologist Tim Riley comments on the prominence of such stylistic garnishes and flourishes in "Maxwell's Silver Hammer": the change in pattern from one refrain to the next, the synthesizer countermelody, strikes of the anvil at a "bang, bang" lyric, and background vocals, for example. He feels that partly because of these, the track's light comedic nature "falls flat". "Such gimmickry is a sure sign of weak material: it doesn't generate its own setting, so one has to be designed to keep it propped up", he concludes. [16] Likewise, in the music critic Ian MacDonald's view, "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" is "[c]ompulsively fertile in melody and fascinated by music's formal beauties", and this reflects "[McCartney's] worst lapse of taste under the auspices of The Beatles". He feels the song is devoid of expression and meaning. [1] The music professor Dominic Pedler compared its stylistic structure to the Willie Nelson song "Crazy" (1954). [17] In their book Playing the Great Beatles Basslines (2006), Tony Bacon and Gareth Morgan write that McCartney's bassline is "open and effective". [18]
The verse spans up to twenty bars, opening with a square sixteen-bar section. The harmony opens up from I to V. [10] The refrain is made up of two variant phrases; the first one appears three times and has its harmonic shape fully closed, meanwhile the second one appears two times and is sung both times, having its harmonic shape open from I to V. [10] The musicologist Alan W. Pollack claimed the interlude "works just as nicely as a soft-shoe dancing kind of break between the middle sections." [10] It is four bars in length, and has its harmony shape closed, however its open chord progression "creates a momentary illusion of wide ranging movement." The bassline switches from D to G before changing back to D. The outro is a closing repeat of the interlude, and the beat of the anvil helps "seal the ending", as Pollack remarks. [10]
"Maxwell's Silver Hammer" follows Maxwell Edison, a medicine student who becomes a serial killer; [9] [11] the dark lyrics are hidden by an upbeat sound. [9] He uses the "silver hammer" to kill his girlfriend and his lecturer. [19] He goes to court for these killings, where Rose and Valerie, fans of Maxwell, push for him to be released. [12] As the judge makes the verdict, Maxwell murders him. [11] McCartney said the lyrics "epitomize the downfalls of life". [20] The author Hunter Davies thinks they orbit around a metaphor, stating: "The narrative is fairly ghastly – about someone called Maxwell who goes around killing people – but it is all a metaphor, about how just when things seem to be going well in life, down on your head comes a hammer – metaphorically, of course." [21]
According to Riley, Maxwell may have come across as a "spoof anti-hero" like the Paperback Writer ("Paperback Writer") and Bungalow Bill ("The Continuing Story of Bungalow Bill"), but his "elaborate musical character makes him sound like a contrived Looney Tune" instead. [22] Pollack notes that the "bang bang" sound is one of the very few instances of onomatopoeia in the band's catalogue. [10] Richie Unterberger of AllMusic contrasts McCartney's vocals against Maxwell's grisly acts. He states that when the chorus begins, it sounds like Maxwell is "celebrating a birthday [rather] than like he's announcing the death of victims by cruel and unusual means". [11]
"Maxwell's Silver Hammer" was one of the many new songs the Beatles rehearsed at Twickenham Film Studios in south-west London on 3 January 1969. [23] The band was working on the album Get Back, which would later become Let It Be . With Get Back, the Beatles sought to return to their musical roots after experimenting with more diverse music. [24] The project created part of the band's desire to return to live performance for the first time since their 1966 North American tour; [25] according to the Beatles historian Chris Ingham, McCartney planned for the band "to learn some songs, record them without frills, play them at a concert and film the whole thing". [26] The rehearsals were filmed by Michael Lindsay-Hogg, with the intention of making a documentary film that would accompany a televised Beatles concert. [27] [28]
McCartney presented "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" – "the corny one", as he described it – to the band on 3 January. [29] [30] They only performed it twice on the first day. [31] According to the biographers Doug Sulpy and Ray Schweighardt, they called these performances "very loose"; [32] the author Barry Miles also deemed the rehearsals of the song "poor". [33] The line-up was McCartney on lead vocals and bass guitar, John Lennon and George Harrison on guitar, and Starr on drums. [30] McCartney recommended adding a hammer and anvil part on the recording. [32] The Beatles returned to "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" on 7 January and [30] devoted extensive rehearsals to it. [34] Over the course of the rehearsals, Harrison decided to switch over to bass. [35] Sulpy and Schweighardt state that Harrison suggested having "a lot of people" sing in the chorus, but McCartney was "too busy singing to respond". [36] McCartney instructed Evans to hit an anvil with a hammer during the chorus. [30] The Beatles continued working on the song until 10 January, when work on it was put to a halt when Harrison walked out of the sessions, feeling weary of what he considered to be McCartney's overbearing attitude [37] and Lennon's lack of engagement with the project. [33] [38]
After the Twickenham rehearsals, the Beatles went into EMI's Studio Two (now part of Abbey Road Studios) on 9 July 1969 to record "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" for their eleventh studio album Abbey Road ; George Martin produced it, and Phil McDonald and John Kurlander engineered it. [39] Lennon arrived to work on the song after a grievous car crash kept him from attending the previous sessions, [40] [41] but he was still too ill to participate. [4] Yoko Ono, Lennon's wife, was more badly hurt and lay on a large double-bed in the studio. [39] Takes one through twenty-one of "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" were recorded during this session, but takes six to ten were not numbered. [39] According to Lennon, McCartney saw potential in releasing it as a single; these plans were never addressed. [1] [42]
The Beatles' relationship between each other soured during 1968's and 1969's recording sessions. [43] [44] McCartney said in a 1985 interview that the White Album marked a turning point and a source of friction between the group's members; he dubbed it "the tension album". [45] While working on Abbey Road, however, they did not know their time as a band was approaching an end. [46] [47] [b] [c] The recording of "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" reflected these tensions, drawing disapproval from Lennon, Harrison and Starr due to McCartney's desire to perfect it much as he had done with "Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da" (1968). [1]
I was very keen on it. It took a little bit long to record. I remember the guys getting p—ed [ sic ] with me. Occasionally, I, in particular, would take too long, 'cause I was trying to get what was in my head.
According to Emerick]], Lennon dismissed the song as "more of Paul's granny music". [55] He discussed it in a 1980 interview with David Sheff: [42]
That's Paul's. I hate it. 'Cuz [ sic ] all I remember is the track – he made us do it a hundred million times. He did everything to make it into a single and it never was and it never could've been, but he put guitar licks on it and he had somebody hitting iron pieces and we spent more money on that song then any of them in the whole album. I think.
Starr told Rolling Stone in 2008: "The worst session ever was "Maxwell's Silver Hammer." It was the worst track we ever had to record. It went on for fucking weeks. I thought it was mad." [56] [57] In a 1977 interview with Crawdaddy , Harrison recalled: "Sometimes Paul would make us do these really fruity songs. I mean, my god, 'Maxwell's Silver Hammer' was so fruity." [58] [59] It took the band four recording sessions to complete the song. [57] MacDonald stated that out of all the band's recordings, that of "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" best demonstrates why the Beatles split apart. [1]
The band recorded the basic track within the first recording session [39] and overdubbed new parts onto take twenty-one. [60] Throughout 10 and 11 July 1969, the Beatles continued to add overdubs to the song. [61] On 10 July, Martin added a Hammond organ to the transitions and introduction. Starr provided an anvil, McCartney doubled his vocals, and Harrison overdubbed various guitar parts. Thirteen stereo mixes were made by the end of the session. [2] [39] [60] On 11 July, Harrison added more overdubs to the chorus, and him and McCartney added additional vocals to the ending vocal ("Silver hammer man"). [62] During the session, the band took a break from "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" and decided to record Harrison's "Something". [63] Emerick stated that McCartney wanted the bass to "sound like a tuba", and he achieved that by "sliding into the notes instead of hitting them spot on". [64]
On 6 August, the Beatles returned to "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" to continue mixing and add overdubs. [65] McCartney recorded his Moog synthesizer onto several takes of the song, with take twenty-seven yielding the best results. [66] Ten stereo mixes were produced during the session, and more commenced on 12 August; [65] Two days later, the stereo mix for "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" was complete. [67] On 25 August, the master recording received its final edits; sound effects were created for the beginning of the song but went unused. [2] [68]
In 2019, the song received a new stereo remix for inclusion on the 50th anniversary deluxe edition of Abbey Road. Martin's son Giles produced the new mix alongside Sam Okell. [69] [70]
Abbey Road was released on 26 September 1969 in the United Kingdom through Apple Records. [71] [72] "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" appears as the third track on side one, between "Something" and "Oh! Darling". [71] The unused fifth take of "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" was released on Anthology 3 in 1996, [60] and the twelfth take featured on Abbey Road's 50th anniversary edition in 2019. [73] In 2022, McCartney's handwritten lyrics for the song were put up for auction with a starting price of $425,000 USD. [56]
In a contemporary review of the album, Alan Smith cites its story as "instantly-remembered", and says that "I'm a Loser" (1964) is Maxwell's "theme". [74] In contrast, Roger Chapman of Melody Maker called the song a "drag" and juxtaposed it unfavourably with "When I'm Sixty-Four" (1967). [75] Mike Jahn called it a "light singalong" akin to songs like "When I'm Sixty-Four" and "Yellow Submarine". [76] Rolling Stone's John Mendelsohn argues that McCartney and Ray Davies are the only songwriters who could have composed "Maxwell's Silver Hammer", a song he describes as a "jaunty vaudevillian music-hallish celebration". [77] Miles of Oz said that the song was "a complex little piece" and "a perfect example of Paul's combination of American rock with British brass band music". [78]
"Maxwell's Silver Hammer" is one of those songs which inspires partisan feelings among listeners; you either love it or you hate it.
According to the Beatles biographer Nicholas Schaffner, "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" is one of McCartney's "kinkiest songs", claiming that its story about Maxwell makes it sound "merry and gay". [79] On the other hand, the biographer Simon Leng considers it as "nauseating and bizarre". [80] MacDonald dismissed it as "sniggering nonsense" in his book Revolution in the Head (2007). [1] More positively, Unterberger writes that the plot of "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" is "amusing" for a pop rock song, [11] while Mark Hertsgaard, comparing it to "Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da", deems it "too sweet". [81]
Ranking every Beatles song from worst to best, Bill Wyman of Vulture placed it at number 182, referring to the song as "catchy as hell" and highlighting the anvil sound. [82] Michael Gallucci, writing for Ultimate Classic Rock , ranked it at number 157, [83] and Mark Beaumont of NME listed it at number 149; the latter remarked: "You've written some of the finest children's songs of the century, why the hell shouldn't you try to make a vaudevillian family singalong from the story of an insane, hammer wielding psychopath?" [84] Rolling Stone included "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" in its 2025 list of "50 Terrible Songs on Great Albums", calling its concept and storyline "crazy" and the time the Beatles spent to finish it "even crazier". [85]
The film composer George Fenton released a rendition of "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" as his debut single in 1969. [86] Produced by Mike Leander, [86] it peaked at number six on Sweden's Kvällstoppen charts and at number one on Tio i Topp in January 1970. [87] [88] In 1978, Steve Martin covered "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" for the soundtrack album Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band , [89] and the Canadian soft rock band the Bells released their version as a single in 1972. [90]
Frankie Laine recorded it for the 1976 musical documentary All This and World War II . [91] In 2015, the MonaLisa Twins released a cover of "Maxwell's Silver Hammer"; John Sinkevics of Local Spins names it one of the best covers of an Abbey Road track. [92] Brad Mehldau included a recording on his live album Your Mother Should Know: Brad Mehldau Plays The Beatles (2023). [93] The composer John Rutter covered "Maxwell's Silver Hammer" along with five other Beatles songs for his 1979 album The Beatles Concerto . [94]
According to Kevin Howlett, except where noted: [13]
The Beatles
Additional musician