Thriftimart

Last updated
View of one part of Valley Plaza, North Hollywood; At left: Owl Drugs' Big Owl market opened in 1951, and was sold and rebranded Thriftimart in 1954 Valley Plaza shopping center.jpg
View of one part of Valley Plaza, North Hollywood; At left: Owl Drugs' Big Owl market opened in 1951, and was sold and rebranded Thriftimart in 1954

Thriftimart was an American chain of supermarkets in Greater Los Angeles until 1984, founded by Roger M. Laverty. Many stores continue to operate as Smart & Final stores, now owned by Mexico City-based Chedraui.

Contents

History

Corporate history
YearCorporate nameChains operated
1930Fitzsimmons Stores, Ltd.Fitzsimmons
Thriftimart
194x Fitzsimmons
Thriftimart
Roberts
1955 Fitzsimmons (–1950s)
Thriftimart (–1984)
Roberts (–1960s)
Smart & Final Iris
1957Thriftimart, Inc.
1984 Smart & Final  Iris Co.
Part of Casino USA Inc.
Smart & Final Iris

As Fitzsimmons Markets, Ltd. (1930-1957)

Roger Montgomery Laverty was born in 1890 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. [1] In 1930, Laverty was vice president of the Central Division of the A&P, the largest U.S. grocery chain at the time. He and a group of colleagues bought Fitzsimmons Stores, Ltd., a small Los Angeles chain of markets. In 1939, Fitzsimmons acquired 9 Thriftimart stores, then in 1947, Laverty bought Thriftimart Inc. and the combined company kept the Fitzsimmons Stores, Ltd. name. [2] In 1948, sales at Fitzsimmons Stores Ltd. amounted to $19,931,475.

In 1949, Fitzsimmons Stores Ltd. acquired Fred Roberts & Co. which operated Roberts Markets, a 19-store Los Angeles-based chain, as well as 15 liquor stores. Roberts' 1948 sales were $18,889,948, just under Fitzsimmons' numbers for that year. [3] [2]

Geographic presence of Roberts Public Markets in 1949 [4]

Central L.A. (2)

  • 440 Atlantic Boulevard, East L.A.
  • 4030 Eagle Rock Boulevard, Glassell Park

San Fernando Valley (1)

  • 14532 Ventura Boulevard, Sherman Oaks

Southeast Los Angeles County (1)

  • 9609 Long Beach Boulevard, South Gate

Westside (10) Venice:

  • #1 1338 Washington Boulevard
  • #4 2570 Lincoln Boulevard
  • #23 325 Line (Lincoln) Boulevard (Clark's Ranch)

West L.A.

  • #5 10666 Pico Boulevard
  • #16 11526 Santa Monica Boulevard
  • #11 11841 Wilshire Boulevard
  • #28 12210 Santa Monica Boulevard
Westside (cont'd)

Santa Monica

  • #10 420 Broadway
  • #13 1505 Wilshire Boulevard

Culver City

  • #29 10113 Venice Boulevard

South Bay (4)

  • 3140 Imperial Highway, Inglewood
  • 468 Market Street, Inglewood
  • 49 Pier Avenue, Hermosa Beach
  • 310 Torrance Boulevard, Redondo beach

Long Beach (1)

  • 1830 Artesia Boulevard, North Long Beach
Geographic presence of Fitzsimmons Stores, Ltd. markets in 1952 [5]
T=Thriftimart, R=Roberts, F=Fitzsimmons, FL=Foodland RR=Roberts Ranch, CR=Clark's Ranch, B=Bill's

Central L.A. & adj. (5)

  • Baldwin Hills/Crenshaw 1T
  • Glassell Park 1R 1F
  • University Park 1T
  • East Los Angeles 1RR

Hollywood/Mid-Wilshire (6)

  • Hollywood 2T
  • West Hollywood 1T
  • Silverlake 1T
  • Leimert Park 1T
  • Echo Park 1T

Westside (14)

  • Venice 2R 1CR
  • West Los Angeles 1T 1R
  • Santa Monica 1T 1R
  • Beverly Hills 2T
  • Westdale 1T
  • Westchester 1T
  • Palms 1T
  • Ladera 1T
  • Brentwood 1T

San Fernando Valley (14)

  • Glendale 6T
  • Burbank 1T 1FL 1B
  • Van Nuys 2T
  • Valley Village 1T
  • Studio City 1T
  • North Hollywood 1F

South Bay (3)

  • Inglewood 1T
  • Hermosa Beach 1R
  • Compton 1T

Long Beach (4)

  • Los Altos South 1T
  • Lakewood Village 1T
  • Grant 1 RR
  • Franklin 1T

Southeast Los Angeles County (2)

  • South Gate 1R
  • Bellflower 1T

In 1954, Fitzsimmons acquired the large, 44,000 sq ft (4,100 m2) [6] Big Owl supermarket at Valley Plaza in North Hollywood, which was rebranded Thriftimart. [7] Big Owl had been a project of the Owl Drug Company, which stated that it had completed extensive research on shoppers' in-store behavior, the results of which it used to create a "revolutionary" store layout for Big Owl that would shorten the amount of walking required to complete a typical shopping trip. With the aim of providing the convenience of one-stop shopping, Big Owl also incorporated stores-in-store, which was uncommon at the time, including Van de Kamp's Bakeries, See's Candies, a "soda grill" for quick meals and snacks, a barber, cleaners, watch repair, and sales of china and gift items. It had 12 checkout lanes with electric cash registers, where shoppers could pay for good from all the departments (a relatively recent innovation in markets at the time), 9 entrances for the public, and its parking lot had space for 750 cars. Through a window, customers could watch meat be packed in cellophane, weighed, labeled and marked with a price, then watch a "tremendous, store-long" conveyor belt transport it to refrigerated cases in the store's meat sales area. Big Owl stated that its neon sign was the brightest in the U.S. west of Chicago. [6]

Fitzsimmons Stores, Ltd. bought the "Smart & Final Iris" company and its cash-and-carry (wholesale) stores in 1955. [8]

As Thriftimart, Inc. (1957–1984)

In 1957, Fitzsimmons Stores Ltd. had changed its name to Thriftimart, Inc., saying that Thriftimart had "come to mean leadership in the grocery field" and that it was for that reason most appropriate that the firm bear the Thriftimart name. At the time there were 43 Thriftimart-branded stores in addition to Fitzsimmons-branded stores.

As Greater Los Angeles grew, so did Thriftimart, Inc. There were 50 Thriftimart retail grocery stores in May 1960: 44 in Los Angeles County (including 1 in Lancaster), plus 1 in Riverside, 1 in San Bernardino County (Colton), 2 in Bakersfield and 2 in Las Vegas. [9] This grew to 56 (and 3,000 employees) by October 1960 [2] and 77 by 1971, [10] and 79 (plus 86 cash-and-carry and 5 warehouses) in 1976. [11]

In 1968, son Robert Edward Laverty became president and chairman of the board. [11]

Thriftimart opened its last new store in 1971. By 1983, the by then 43-store Thriftimart chain determined that it could not adapt to the trend towards larger supermarkets. Its stores measured on average 30,000 sq ft (2,800 m2) while others' averaged 45,000 sq ft (4,200 m2). Thriftimart stated that it had looked for a buyer, but of the major local chains — Boys, Hughes, Lucky, Ralphs, Safeway, and Vons — none was interested.

As Smart & Final Iris Co. (1984–)

In 1984, Thriftimart, Inc. changed its name to Smart & Final Iris Co. [12] In June of that year, Casino USA Inc. acquired the 8.3% stake in the Class A shares of Thriftimart Inc. owned by movie theater executives Michael Forman and James Cotter. [13]

On March 1, 1984, Thriftimart announced that it would sell 23 of its then 40 stores to Oakland-based Safeway Stores, Inc. which operated about 2,500 supermarkets but had relatively weak coverage in Los Angeles and Orange Counties, ranking #5 in 1983, trailing Ralphs, Vons, Lucky and Alpha Beta. 17 Thriftimart stores remained. [14]

In September of that year, Casino gained control of Smart & Final Iris (i.e. the former Thriftimart, Inc.) by acquiring the combined 87% of the company's Class B stock owned by the founder's children Roger Laverty II, Robert Laverty, and Nancy Harris for $75 million. [15] [16] Class B shareholders controlled 5 of the company's 9 board seats. [17]


Related Research Articles

Sobeys Inc. is a national supermarket chain in Canada with over 1,500 stores operating under a variety of banners. Headquartered in Stellarton, Nova Scotia, it operates stores in all ten provinces and accumulated sales of more than C$25.1 billion in the fiscal 2019 operating year. It is a wholly owned subsidiary of Empire Company Limited, a Canadian business conglomerate.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ralphs</span> American supermarket chain owned by Kroger

Ralphs is an American supermarket chain in Southern California. The largest subsidiary of Cincinnati-based Kroger, it is the oldest such chain west of the Mississippi River. Kroger also operates stores under the Food 4 Less and Foods Co. names in California.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">99 Ranch Market</span> Taiwanese-American supermarket chain

99 Ranch Market is an American supermarket chain owned by Tawa Supermarket Inc., which is based in Buena Park, California. 99 Ranch has 58 stores in the U.S., primarily in California, with other stores in Nevada, Oregon, Washington, New Jersey, Texas, Maryland, Massachusetts, Arizona, and Virginia. The company also started offering shopping via its website in 2014. In February 2021, the company also launched their mobile app for grocery delivery.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Safeway</span> American supermarket chain owned by Albertsons Companies, Inc

Safeway, Inc. is an American supermarket chain. The chain provides grocery items, food and general merchandise and a variety of specialty departments, such as bakery, delicatessen, floral and pharmacy, as well as Starbucks coffee shops and fuel centers. It is a subsidiary of Albertsons after being acquired by private equity investors led by Cerberus Capital Management in January 2015. Safeway's primary base of operations is in the Western United States with some stores located in the Mid-Atlantic region of the Eastern Seaboard. The subsidiary is headquartered in Pleasanton, California.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sylvan Goldman</span> American businessman and inventor

Sylvan Nathan Goldman was an American businessman and inventor of the shopping cart. His design had a pair of large wire baskets connected by tubular metal arms with four wheels.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Vons</span> American supermarket chain owned by Albertsons Companies, Inc

Vons is a supermarket chain owned by Albertsons, with most of its locations in Southern California and the Las Vegas Valley. It is headquartered in Fullerton, California, and operates stores under the Vons and Pavilions banners. It was owned by Safeway Inc. and headquartered in Arcadia, California, before that company was acquired by and folded into Albertsons along with all of their subsidiaries, including Vons.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tom Thumb (grocery store)</span> American supermarket chain in Texas owned by Albertsons Companies, Inc

Tom Thumb is a chain of supermarkets in the Dallas–Fort Worth metroplex. It operates under the name Tom Thumb for traditional grocery stores and Flagship Tom Thumb for higher end stores in affluent areas. It makes up part of the Southern division of Albertsons. When combined with sister chains Albertsons and Market Street, it is the number two supermarket group in the competitive Dallas/Fort Worth area behind Walmart. The chain's distribution center is in Roanoke, Texas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Supermarkets</span> Defunct American grocery store chain

National Supermarkets was a grocery chain in both the St. Louis, Missouri, and New Orleans, Louisiana, areas of the United States. Both firms were owned by Loblaw Companies of Canada, but in June 1995, they were sold by Loblaw to Schnucks Markets. Immediately after that, per the FTC, Schnucks sold the National New Orleans division to Schwegmann Brothers Giant Supermarkets of Metairie, Louisiana, which later sold them to Great A&P, which finally sold them to Rouse Markets in 2007. National itself had cemented the number two spot in St. Louis by acquiring several former Kroger locations and the Kroger distribution center in the market when the latter exited St. Louis in 1986. Kroger and National had been battling for the number two and three spots since the 1970s, swapping rankings several times over throughout the 1970s and 1980s.

The Skaggs Family, starting from a small frontier town in southern Idaho, came to have an important impact on merchandising across much of the United States. During most of the 20th century, the Skaggs name was prominent on hundreds of stores throughout the West and Midwest.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thrifty PayLess</span> Defunct American drugstore chain

Thrifty PayLess Holdings, Inc. was a pharmacy holding company that owned the Thrifty Drugs and PayLess Drug Stores chains in the western United States. The combined company was formed in April 1994 when Los Angeles–based TCH Corporation, the parent company of Thrifty Corporation and Thrifty Drug Stores, Inc., acquired the Kmart subsidiary PayLess Drug Stores Northwest, Inc. At the time of the merger, TCH Corporation was renamed Thrifty PayLess Holdings, Inc. and Thrifty operated 495 stores, PayLess operated 543 stores.

Dominick's was a Chicago-area grocery store chain and subsidiary of Safeway Inc. Dominick's distribution center was located in Northlake, Illinois, while its management offices were located in Oak Brook, Illinois.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Smart & Final</span> Chain of warehouse-style food and supply stores

Smart & Final is a chain of warehouse-style food and supply stores based in Commerce, California, which developed through a series of mergers and expansions. The oldest of the combined companies, Hellman-Haas Grocery, was founded in 1871 in Los Angeles. The company operates over 250 stores in the Western United States and 15 in northwestern Mexico.

Presto Foodmarkets was a chain of supermarkets and convenience stores in Great Britain, which first appeared in the early 1960s. While the fate of most of the chain's stores was conversion to Safeway, the final stores still trading as Presto were either closed or sold in 1998.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gelson's Markets</span> Southern California-based supermarket chain

Gelson's is a regional supermarket chain operating in Southern California. It operates service-oriented stores mostly in upscale neighborhoods.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Owl Drug</span> American drugstore retailer

The Owl Drug Company was an American drugstore retailer with its headquarters in San Francisco that operated the Owl Drug Stores chain. It was a subsidiary of Rexall stores at its peak in the 1920s through 1940s. The Owl Drug Stores sold medicines and pills, and later ventured into cosmetics, perfumes, and other goods.

SM Retail Inc. is a retail holding company based in Pasay, Philippines. It is a subsidiary of the conglomerate SM Investments Corporation. SM Retail has been a member of the International Association of Department Stores since 2009.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Valley Plaza</span> Shopping center in North Hollywood, Los Angeles

Valley Plaza was a shopping center in North Hollywood, Los Angeles, one of the first in the San Fernando Valley, opened in 1951. In the mid-1950s it was reported to be the largest shopping center on the West Coast of the United States and the third-largest in the country. It was located along Laurel Canyon Boulevard from Oxnard to Vanowen, and west along Victory Boulevard. Like its competitor Panorama City Shopping Center to the north, Valley Plaza started with one core development and grew over time to market, under the single name "Valley Plaza", a collection of adjacent retail developments with multiple developers, owners, and opening dates.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Boston Stores (California-based department store)</span> American department store chain

Boston Stores, originally and later still often called The Boston Store, was a chain of department stores based in Inglewood, California, just southwest of Central Los Angeles, that operated from 1934 through 1996.

Market Basket was the name used by two separate chains of supermarkets within Southern California. The first chain originated in Pasadena and operated from 1930 until 1982. The second chain operated from 1989 until 1994.

References

  1. "Montgomery Laverty 23 April 1890–13 June 1968 GF8Y-5KT". www.familysearch.org. Retrieved 31 March 2024.
  2. 1 2 3 "Thriftimart corporate history". The Colton Courier. 28 October 1960. p. 6. Retrieved 31 March 2024.
  3. "Fitzsimmons Buys Roberts Chain of 19 Supermarkets". The San Bernardino County Sun. 21 October 1949. p. 1. Retrieved 31 March 2024.
  4. "Advertisement for Swift's Premium Chicken". The Los Angeles Times. 24 June 1949. p. 41. Retrieved 2 April 2024.
  5. "Thrifitmart advertisement". The Los Angeles Times. 22 December 1952. p. 16. Retrieved 2 April 2024. (Hwd=Hollywood, SM=Santa Monica) Bill's Market, 14440 Burbank Bl, Burbank; Clark's Ranch, 325 Lincoln Bl, Venice; Fitzsimmons, 3075 San Fernando Rd (Glassell Park); 5207 Lankershim Bl, N Hwd; Foodlane, 7670 Hwd Way, Burbank; Roberts at 4030 Eagle Rock Bl (Glassell Park); 49 Pier Ave, Hermosa Beach; 9607 S Long Beach Bl, South Gate; 11526 SM Bl (West L.A.); 1505 Wilshire Bl SM; Venice: 2750 Lincoln Bl & 1338 Washington Bl; Roberts Ranch, 436 S Atlantic Bl, East L.A. and 1830 E Artesia Bl, Long Beach (Grant); Thriftimarts at 2600 S Vermont Ave (University Park); 1900 N Highland Ave, Hwd; 2430 Glendale Bl (Echo Park); 7980 Sunset Bl, Hwd; 4305 Degnan Bl (Leimert Park); 609 N Dillon St (Silverlake); 7985 SM Bl, W. Hwd.; Long Beach: 1945 E 4th St (Franklin); 4158 N Viking Way (Lakewood Village); 2164 Bellflower Bl (Los Altos S.); Burbank: 3708 Burbank Bl; Glendale: 1104 E Chevy Chase Dr, 310 & 826 N Glendale Ave, 915 and 1133 W Glenoaks Bl & 3606 N Verdugo Rd; N. Hwd: 12836 Ventura Bl (Studio City); 5145 Laurel Canyon Bl (Valley Village); in Van Nuys at 17625 Sherman Way and 15231 Ventura Bl; 1940 N Bullis Rd, Compton; 3140 W Imperial Bl, Inglewood; 5819 N Bellflower Bl, Bellflower; Beverly Hills: 9131 Olympic Bl & 9690 SM Bl; 3621 S La Brea Av (Crenshaw); 11630 Barrington Ct (Brentwood); 6480–6 La Tijera Bl (Ladera); 10113 Venice Bl (Palms); 12210 Santa Monica Bl (West L.A.); 8440 Lincoln Bl (Westchester); 11660 National Bl (Westdale); 420 Broadway SM
  6. 1 2 "Revolutionary Big Owl is the Market of Tomorrow". The Van Nuys News. 1 November 1951. p. 22. Retrieved 31 March 2024.
  7. "Big Owl Market Taken Over by Thriftimart". The Los Angeles Times. 6 August 1954. p. 48. Retrieved 31 March 2024.
  8. Groves, Martha (7 July 1987). "Smart & Final: Old-Line Chain Battles New Warehouse Rivals". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 30 March 2024.
  9. "Thriftimart is a thirty year old concern now operating fifty supermarkets". California Eagle. 5 May 1960. p. 15. Retrieved 30 March 2024.
  10. West's California Reporter. West Publishing Company. 1971. p. 298. Retrieved 30 March 2024. The retail division, Thriftimart, operates 77 retail grocery store
  11. 1 2 United States Federal Trade Commission (1976). Federal Trade Commission Decisions 1976. U.S. Government Printing Office. p. 74. Retrieved 30 March 2024.
  12. "Smart & Final Corporate / History; 140 Years of Superior Service, Growth and Success".
  13. "Thriftimart Shares". Reuters. 26 June 1984. p. D4. Retrieved 30 March 2024.
  14. "Thriftimart will sell 23 markets to Safeway". The Los Angeles Times. 2 March 1984. p. 55. Retrieved 31 March 2024.
  15. Yoshihara, Nancy (27 September 1984). "Casino USA to Buy Rest of Smart & Final Iris (p.1 of 2)". The Los Angeles Times. p. 101. Retrieved 31 March 2024.
  16. "Smart and Final Bid by Casino". The New York Times. 27 September 1984. p. 76. Retrieved 30 March 2024.
  17. Yoshihara, Nancy (27 September 1984). "Casino USA to Buy Rest of Smart & Final Iris (p.2 of 2)". The Los Angeles Times. p. 48. Retrieved 31 March 2024.